Why Do Cops Not Know How to Control an Investigation/Crime Scene? (Read 1151 times)

Flapp_Jackson

Why Do Cops Not Know How to Control an Investigation/Crime Scene?
« on: September 19, 2025, 01:00:41 PM »
Watching a bunch of body cam videos, I've realized the chaos is exacerbated by the Cops.

One Cop or pair of them responds to a call.  They spend 5-15+ minutes talking to the caller and others to figure out what happened.

If they need backup, another cop or 3 arrive -- often in separate cars -- and the cops wind up playing a frantic game of telephone.  The first cop may not even tell the second, third, ... what happened because they need to provide specific assistance -- detain someone, talk to security, etc.

Basically, each cop that arrives has to start at square one information-wise.  It should be the primary officer (first on scene or ranking officer) coordinating what everyone needs to do, and to brief them all together on what's going on.

It looks like a tax-paid cluster-f**k every time. 

Of course, the thing that bugs me most is when they are called for an obviously intoxicated person but spend 30 minutes trying to communicate to them through that alcohol and/or drug induced fog.  After repeating the same thing 3 times, it's time to stop treating them like a sober adult and just get them to a jail cell or hospital room.  It wastes everyone's time when the cops could be doing something more important than trying to help keep an impaired person out of trouble and out of jail.  you should get just a few chances to comply, answer questions, pass a sobriety test, or whatever, then game's over.

Somebody really needs to learn how to coordinate police, fire, and medical personnel so that everyone knows what happened up to that point, and who should be focused on what tasks.  Mostly, they stand around telling each other the few pieces they think they know while really not doing much to help.
The reasonable man adapts himself to the world;
the unreasonable one persists in trying to adapt the world to himself.
Therefore, all progress depends on the unreasonable man.
-- George Bernard Shaw

changemyoil66

Re: Why Do Cops Not Know How to Control an Investigation/Crime Scene?
« Reply #1 on: September 19, 2025, 01:49:19 PM »
With regard to your intoxicated person, this is like anything else. Cops should be able to just state a command like 3 times and if still no compliance, any injury the person gets is unable to sue and no disciplinary action.  But this would only work in a perfect world where cops don't abuse their power or violate peoples rights.

Example of justified: the machete shooting in Maui I think, the guy was told 20X to drop the machete and he refused, so MPD shot him.  He wasn't on his property holding a machete, he was in the road doing so. 

Example of unjustified: 1st amendment auditor in a public building recording. He was told to leave by the cops and he refused. He was arrested.  He later won a lawsuit in court.  So had the cops been able to do what ever they wanted, after 3 commands to leave the building, they could have used lethal force or more force that causes injuries for him not complying.

So it's a hard line to walk as cops have shown to be not good way to often.

Flapp_Jackson

Re: Why Do Cops Not Know How to Control an Investigation/Crime Scene?
« Reply #2 on: September 19, 2025, 02:30:30 PM »
With regard to your intoxicated person, this is like anything else. Cops should be able to just state a command like 3 times and if still no compliance, any injury the person gets is unable to sue and no disciplinary action.  But this would only work in a perfect world where cops don't abuse their power or violate peoples rights.

Example of justified: the machete shooting in Maui I think, the guy was told 20X to drop the machete and he refused, so MPD shot him.  He wasn't on his property holding a machete, he was in the road doing so. 

Example of unjustified: 1st amendment auditor in a public building recording. He was told to leave by the cops and he refused. He was arrested.  He later won a lawsuit in court.  So had the cops been able to do what ever they wanted, after 3 commands to leave the building, they could have used lethal force or more force that causes injuries for him not complying.

So it's a hard line to walk as cops have shown to be not good way to often.
I never said the cops can use lethal force to compel obedience.  Lethal is always the last resort when the officer's (or others') safety is threatened.

Also, there doesn't have to be force that causes injuries applied.  I'm just talking about the cops who show up and talk to someone forever who is obviously 3+ sheets into the wind.  It's like trying to convince a 2 year old they can't stay in the ball pit another hour because you need to leave.  do you negotiate for  30 minutes, or do you give them an ultimatum?  Once they've exhausted their chances to leave on their own, you physically extricate them and carry them to the car.

Cops that try to negotiate with someone who can't form a complete sentence or thought and needs the building to stop them from falling over is just wasting time and giving the drunk time to keep pushing the limits of the officer's patience.

Most cities had drunk tanks and laws against public intoxication -- driving or not.  if you're drunk in public, you were arrested and taken to detox.  Once you're sober, you can leave OOR unless you caused damage, got into a fight, or hit the cop.  Then you'll be arraigned for other charges besides a ticket for public intoxication.

Nowadays, with everything recorded, i think the cops are worried about Monday morning quarterbacking by their bosses.  People not there and not on duty responsible for possible more critical calls will pontificate on what should have been the cop's actions.  So, to be safe, they treat people who killed their active braincells for fun like reasonable adults when that's just not a wise decision.  Finally, when the cop has the drunk on the ground being injured trying to detain them for trespassing or disturbing the peace, the situation is able to be resolved.  The arrest should have been a long time before it go to that point.  Letting it drag on and on is usually why it gets that way. 

i'm not sure why your mind went immediately to lethal force, unless you're focuing on DEI hires who can't subdue a 110 lb 21 year old drunk.
The reasonable man adapts himself to the world;
the unreasonable one persists in trying to adapt the world to himself.
Therefore, all progress depends on the unreasonable man.
-- George Bernard Shaw

eyeeatingfish

Re: Why Do Cops Not Know How to Control an Investigation/Crime Scene?
« Reply #3 on: September 19, 2025, 10:52:12 PM »
Watching a bunch of body cam videos, I've realized the chaos is exacerbated by the Cops.

One Cop or pair of them responds to a call.  They spend 5-15+ minutes talking to the caller and others to figure out what happened.

If they need backup, another cop or 3 arrive -- often in separate cars -- and the cops wind up playing a frantic game of telephone.  The first cop may not even tell the second, third, ... what happened because they need to provide specific assistance -- detain someone, talk to security, etc.

Basically, each cop that arrives has to start at square one information-wise.  It should be the primary officer (first on scene or ranking officer) coordinating what everyone needs to do, and to brief them all together on what's going on.

It looks like a tax-paid cluster-f**k every time. 

Of course, the thing that bugs me most is when they are called for an obviously intoxicated person but spend 30 minutes trying to communicate to them through that alcohol and/or drug induced fog.  After repeating the same thing 3 times, it's time to stop treating them like a sober adult and just get them to a jail cell or hospital room.  It wastes everyone's time when the cops could be doing something more important than trying to help keep an impaired person out of trouble and out of jail.  you should get just a few chances to comply, answer questions, pass a sobriety test, or whatever, then game's over.

Somebody really needs to learn how to coordinate police, fire, and medical personnel so that everyone knows what happened up to that point, and who should be focused on what tasks.  Mostly, they stand around telling each other the few pieces they think they know while really not doing much to help.

That practice of explaining things as additional officers arrive does have some benefits though. Officers could talk over the case to make sure they are clear on the offense, they could discuss how to handle the situation, get information about the individual from someone who knows them better. At the very least the officer hearing the victim is going to need to explain to the arresting officer the facts of the case so the arrest can be justified.

But if the additional officers are just being curious then ideally they should be given a task where they don't need to know the whole background. No need to repeat it for the 5th officer, just tell them go direct traffic.

Flapp_Jackson

Re: Why Do Cops Not Know How to Control an Investigation/Crime Scene?
« Reply #4 on: September 19, 2025, 11:36:37 PM »
That practice of explaining things as additional officers arrive does have some benefits though. Officers could talk over the case to make sure they are clear on the offense, they could discuss how to handle the situation, get information about the individual from someone who knows them better. At the very least the officer hearing the victim is going to need to explain to the arresting officer the facts of the case so the arrest can be justified.

But if the additional officers are just being curious then ideally they should be given a task where they don't need to know the whole background. No need to repeat it for the 5th officer, just tell them go direct traffic.

Go direct traffic?  For a routine traffic stop?  That never happens.  Cops park their cruisers half in the roadway behind the vehicle they stopped and expect traffic to flow around them.  If the driver being stopped is smart, they will try to pull into a parking lot or side road to keep from blocking traffic.  Unless there's an accident, nobody seems to care about directing traffic.  They turn on their cop-car lights and dare anyone to hit them.

I never said there's no benefit to explaining things to cops who arrived as backup.  I'm simply saying there's no procedure for briefing them so everyone is on the same page.  With sirens blaring, traffic zooming nearby, upset people yelling and screaming, and cops yelling commands, it's worse than a elementary school lunchroom at noon!  Cop A is first to arrive. Cop B arrives 10 minutes later and gets a brief update from A while A is still gathering facts.  C and D get there after 20 minutes, and B tries to brief them with as much info as A gave them -- but often that info is spotty and lacking detail, b/c B only got the big picture from A.  Then C and D, who are NOT interviewing people but instead checking iDs and getting witness statements, won't get any new or additional info that A & B obtained in their interviews with the primary parties.  It's a report-writing exercise that gathers a bunch of info from various people while trying to render aid, control medical, fire and traffic, all while attempting to decide if anyone should be detained, arrested and charged -- and for what.

Mostly what i see is an overlap of effort, which may accidentally discover inconsistencies in someones story that points to deception, but that usually happens because shock and adrenaline can alter perceptions, and asking the same questions of the same people repeatedly can give their mind time to fill in the gaps of their statement with details they either just remembered or felt like the gap needed to be filled and they added what they might surmise happened.

Rule of thumb: if 3 people ask you the exact same questions, and your answers vary from person to person, that's expected as you remember details or analyze whether what you answered was what actually happened or you thought it was what happened.  Someone who gives the same details in the same order with little or no variation between recitations is usually showing deception.  They've created a story, and they are sticking to it.  No memory of the incident is involved, just recalling a memorized set of answers.
The reasonable man adapts himself to the world;
the unreasonable one persists in trying to adapt the world to himself.
Therefore, all progress depends on the unreasonable man.
-- George Bernard Shaw

eyeeatingfish

Re: Why Do Cops Not Know How to Control an Investigation/Crime Scene?
« Reply #5 on: September 19, 2025, 11:51:59 PM »
Go direct traffic?  For a routine traffic stop?  That never happens.  Cops park their cruisers half in the roadway behind the vehicle they stopped and expect traffic to flow around them.  If the driver being stopped is smart, they will try to pull into a parking lot or side road to keep from blocking traffic.  Unless there's an accident, nobody seems to care about directing traffic.  They turn on their cop-car lights and dare anyone to hit them.

I never said there's no benefit to explaining things to cops who arrived as backup.  I'm simply saying there's no procedure for briefing them so everyone is on the same page.  With sirens blaring, traffic zooming nearby, upset people yelling and screaming, and cops yelling commands, it's worse than a elementary school lunchroom at noon!  Cop A is first to arrive. Cop B arrives 10 minutes later and gets a brief update from A while A is still gathering facts.  C and D get there after 20 minutes, and B tries to brief them with as much info as A gave them -- but often that info is spotty and lacking detail, b/c B only got the big picture from A.  Then C and D, who are NOT interviewing people but instead checking iDs and getting witness statements, won't get any new or additional info that A & B obtained in their interviews with the primary parties.  It's a report-writing exercise that gathers a bunch of info from various people while trying to render aid, control medical, fire and traffic, all while attempting to decide if anyone should be detained, arrested and charged -- and for what.

Mostly what i see is an overlap of effort, which may accidentally discover inconsistencies in someones story that points to deception, but that usually happens because shock and adrenaline can alter perceptions, and asking the same questions of the same people repeatedly can give their mind time to fill in the gaps of their statement with details they either just remembered or felt like the gap needed to be filled and they added what they might surmise happened.

Rule of thumb: if 3 people ask you the exact same questions, and your answers vary from person to person, that's expected as you remember details or analyze whether what you answered was what actually happened or you thought it was what happened.  Someone who gives the same details in the same order with little or no variation between recitations is usually showing deception.  They've created a story, and they are sticking to it.  No memory of the incident is involved, just recalling a memorized set of answers.

I just gave direct traffic as an example of something to do. Of course not all situations require traffic control.

I do see what you are referring to on video sometimes time is wasted by duplicating work or a failure of someone to delegate specific tasks to the various officers. I think that there is value in it often times though, it may not always be obvious when we watch it but sometimes it does serve a purpose.

I would disagree about your saying a lack of variation shows deception, it is the other way around. If 3 officers each talk to a person and they get three different versions that suggests deception. It is hard to tell a lie repeatedly the same way each time. If someone is telling the truth the story will remain the same because they aren't having to remember what their last lie was or make it up again, they just say what they remember.

The ones that bother me are when additional officer arrive and make things worse, the ones that rile up a person who the first officer calmed down. Some officers are better at talking than others and can get more than the first officer.