A guy I know and his friend were assaulted by this guy. 1 was riding his jetski and cut this guys fishing line with it. He became upset and the jet ski rider apologized while standing next to the guy I know.
The guy I know has money and offered to buy a new line. Then the guy said that he owes him a new reel. The guy I know has a criminal background and didn't want trouble, so he said Ok, I have to go to the ATM as I don't have the hundreds of dollars that he wanted.
He said he wants it now on the spot or something like that and began attacking the jet ski rider. The jet ski rider ended up landing badly and injured his spine/neck. He has over 6 figures in hospital bills. The guy I know ended up with a minor buss up face. The attacker then left.
Neither wanted to fight, and the guy above seemed to be looking for a fight.
No charges were brought, even though a police report was filed. IDK the reason why.
The facts of the case are unusual. Two people damage a fishing line. One offers hundreds of dollars for the damage. The 3 get into a fight, but only the pair are injured badly. Only then do they decide to get the police involved.
Very messy and difficult to prove anything against any of them without independent witnesses or video.
If you were the AG, what charges would you think are appropriate?
To me, it's more of a civil case. We know there are medical bills, and we know how the injuries happened. We also know a fishing line was damaged. The "new reel" part is unable to be proven unless the fisherman admits to it.
The big question would be whether or not this was mutual combat where both sides were willingly engaged in the fighting. Or was it one-sided, which could be supported by 2 parties receiving severe injuries and the fisherman receiving minor injuries if any at all. Unless he sought treatment, there's no way to be sure -- so have to assume he was uninjured to any significant degree.
i bet if the Jet Skiier had died from his spinal injuries or been permanently disabled, the outcome would have been different. The AG would have no choice but to arrest and let the facts be heard in court.
Just because your friend tells you his side of the story doesn't mean it's not embellished or altered to make his side look like the victims. I would start by asking, "They really stopped to talk to an angry guy over a cut line that was accidental?" Most people would not confront someone acting up over such a small problem. Just keep going and don't look back.