2aHawaii

General Topics => Political Discussion => Topic started by: Jl808 on October 10, 2023, 03:18:16 PM

Title: Trump handed a victory in fraud trial
Post by: Jl808 on October 10, 2023, 03:18:16 PM
Appeals court has put a stay on the sham trial

https://youtu.be/--uxxB_My28?feature=shared
Title: Re: Trump handed a victory in fraud trial
Post by: Flapp_Jackson on October 10, 2023, 05:30:08 PM
How is it a sham?  His property is not worth over a billion dollars.   I can't apply for loans and say my current property is worth 100mil.... that's fraud.   If not I would have hundreds of properties.

Show me any bank or other lending institution that will take a borrower's word alone for the value of a multi-million-dollar property.

The insurance companies as well.

None of the banks or insurance companies loaning Trump money on the properties or covering it for losses has complained that the property is over-valued.  They have had professionals appraise the values, and were satisfied it could be sold to cover the loans and would not allow inflated claims were there to be a loss.

You are just as delusional as the judge.
Title: Re: Trump handed a victory in fraud trial
Post by: macsak on October 10, 2023, 06:39:52 PM
banks issued the loans under their assessors and parameters
loans WERE PAID OFF
where's the crime? who was harmed???

How is it a sham?  His property is not worth over a billion dollars.   I can't apply for loans and say my current property is worth 100mil.... that's fraud.   If not I would have hundreds of properties.
Title: Re: Trump handed a victory in fraud trial
Post by: changemyoil66 on October 10, 2023, 07:03:51 PM
Federal banks overloaned money causing a resession.

No one went to jail or trial. In fact, the banks got paid.

At most its underwriters not doing their job.

But orangeman bad.

Sent from my SM-G991U using Tapatalk

Title: Re: Trump handed a victory in fraud trial
Post by: ren on October 10, 2023, 07:15:06 PM
I declare my parents' basement  worth $1Googolplex...so why am I still living here?
Title: Re: Trump handed a victory in fraud trial
Post by: changemyoil66 on October 10, 2023, 07:28:44 PM
I declare my parents' basement  worth $1Googolplex...so why am I still living here?
I get scam offers to buy my condo. I tell them $1,000,000 cash. No offers after that.

Hope I dont get indicted.

Sent from my SM-G991U using Tapatalk

Title: Re: Trump handed a victory in fraud trial
Post by: Flapp_Jackson on October 10, 2023, 07:50:37 PM
I get scam offers to buy my condo. I tell them $1,000,000 cash. No offers after that.

Hope I dont get indicted.

I get calls weekly to sell my house.  I try to get the name of the business, and most just hang up.  The ones i could research were not incorporated anywhere i could find, were not licensed realtors in Hawaii, and their websites looked like they were created on the fly by a novice high schooler.

One guy had to let his "partner" call me to talk about checking the property out.  Sounds like an "I hook 'em, he reels 'em in" thing happening.
Title: Re: Trump handed a victory in fraud trial
Post by: macsak on October 10, 2023, 08:22:55 PM
I get calls weekly to sell my house.  I try to get the name of the business, and most just hang up.  The ones i could research were not incorporated anywhere i could find, were not licensed realtors in Hawaii, and their websites looked like they were created on the fly by a novice high schooler.

One guy had to let his "partner" call me to talk about checking the property out.  Sounds like an "I hook 'em, he reels 'em in" thing happening.

they are called "wholesalers"
they are not real estate agents
when you see those "we buy houses" signs up, this is what they are
they con people into wanting to sell their houses, and make thousands on the sale...
Title: Re: Trump handed a victory in fraud trial
Post by: Flapp_Jackson on October 10, 2023, 09:41:57 PM
they are called "wholesalers"
they are not real estate agents
when you see those "we buy houses" signs up, this is what they are
they con people into wanting to sell their houses, and make thousands on the sale...

I figured it was as scam at some level.

I asked one if he was a licensed realtor, and he told me no, but his "partner" is.

These cold calls asking "are you thinking about selling" gets an immediate hang-up now.
Title: Re: Trump handed a victory in fraud trial
Post by: ren on October 11, 2023, 11:03:04 AM
so much hate blinds people...
I wish I could self evaluate properties when I got my mortgage and when the City does their evaluations for taxes
Title: Re: Trump handed a victory in fraud trial
Post by: Flapp_Jackson on October 11, 2023, 11:38:00 AM

Yeah,  everyone would do this.   Trump said his property was worth over a billion for the sake of getting loans, but when it came to taxes it was valued alot less,  I think 18million? 🤔

Everyone knows tax assessments are not based on actual market value.

if it is, then I'm a criminal, too.

You still don't have an answer for why the banks blindly took Trump's valuation -- or did they get an independent assessment themselves?

Why won't you answer that?
Title: Re: Trump handed a victory in fraud trial
Post by: Flapp_Jackson on October 11, 2023, 11:43:59 AM
Fraud is fraud.  If I got 100 properties with fraudulent over evaluations, sold them all and paid all my loans, are you saying I didn't commit a crime?

Unless the people lending the money got stuck with a defaulted loan and a property that can't be sold for the loan balance, there is no fraud.

No different than one car dealer asking for $2000 more than other dealers ask.  Something is worth what others will be willing to pay.  There is no concrete number that remains stagnant.  Markets fluctuate, values change, and assessments vary.  Choosing the highest assessment isn't fraud.  It's just an opinion.
Title: Re: Trump handed a victory in fraud trial
Post by: changemyoil66 on October 11, 2023, 11:53:43 AM
Unless the people lending the money got stuck with a defaulted loan and a property that can't be sold for the loan balance, there is no fraud.

No different than one car dealer asking for $2000 more than other dealers ask.  Something is worth what others will be willing to pay.  There is no concrete number that remains stagnant.  Markets fluctuate, values change, and assessments vary.  Choosing the highest assessment isn't fraud.  It's just an opinion.

This sums it up.  It's also very common for people to pay more than what a property is appraised (valued) at. Like someone never heard of bidding war.
Title: Re: Trump handed a victory in fraud trial
Post by: Flapp_Jackson on October 11, 2023, 11:59:22 AM
Fraud is fraud.  If I got 100 properties with fraudulent over evaluations, sold them all and paid all my loans, are you saying I didn't commit a crime?

It's not fraud if the amount borrowed is less than the actual market value of the property.  He can say it's worth a gazillion, but if he only borrows half the market value of 18 million, then there's no fraud.  The loan would have to exceed the market value of all the collateral involved, not just one property.

if Trump defaulted, and a property brings less than what's owed at auction or public sale, then the lender can still get a judgement against the Trump Corp and get paid. 

If you have a house worth $1M, and you owe $400K, when you default on your mortgage the bank will sell the property.  If the property sells for $300K, you will still owe the bank $100K after the sell.  They don't write it off as their loss that quickly.

But, since all loans were paid off, there's no dispute.  Other factors go into approving a loan, such as assets, income and credit history.  The Trump Corp declared bankruptcy in the past, too.  Is it fraud for them to now claim they are a good credit risk?  If so, that would also apply to all the auto makers in the US.  Arrest  them all!!
Title: Re: Trump handed a victory in fraud trial
Post by: changemyoil66 on October 11, 2023, 12:18:43 PM
It's not fraud if the amount borrowed is less than the actual market value of the property.  He can say it's worth a gazillion, but if he only borrows half the market value of 18 million, then there's no fraud.  The loan would have to exceed the market value of all the collateral involved, not just one property.

if Trump defaulted, and a property brings less than what's owed at auction or public sale, then the lender can still get a judgement against the Trump Corp and get paid. 

If you have a house worth $1M, and you owe $400K, when you default on your mortgage the bank will sell the property.  If the property sells for $300K, you will still owe the bank $100K after the sell.  They don't write it off as their loss that quickly.

But, since all loans were paid off, there's no dispute.  Other factors go into approving a loan, such as assets, income and credit history.  The Trump Corp declared bankruptcy in the past, too.  Is it fraud for them to now claim they are a good credit risk?  If so, that would also apply to all the auto makers in the US.  Arrest  them all!!

You left out how especially for loans this size, banks just believe what the borrower tells them.  No need verify for themselves. TDS is laughable for this one.

BRB applying to get a loan to buy 20 Lamborgini's.

Excuse me Mr. Bank, my income is $400,000,000 a month.  Loan me money based on this.

Bank says : OK sure.
Title: Re: Trump handed a victory in fraud trial
Post by: Sodie on October 11, 2023, 01:14:49 PM
I think the situation is a bit more complicated than it’s being painted here.  I don’t think it’s a case of overvaluing property used as direct collateral for a loan (which would still be wrong, but not necessarily as big a deal).

After reading just a little bit of the civil complaint, it looks like that in at least one case, there is an actual loss to one or more banks, like this:

- Mr. Trump wants a loan to buy a property.
- Bank says the proposition involves some risk, based on the nature of the property (one bank executive called a property a “tough asset” and said the bank’s initial reaction to the application for a loan was “not enthusiastic”), which they consider in setting loan terms (interest rate, etc.).
- The proposal is to do a “recourse loan,” in which the lender may go after borrower’s assets other than the property being purchased in the event of default.
- The terms of the recourse loan depend heavily on the borrower’s net worth, as represented by annual Statements of Financial Condition; higher net worth means easier recourse for the lender, which means less risk, which means better terms (lower interest rate, etc.)
- I don’t know for sure, but I would expect the lender to get an independent opinion on the value of the property to be purchased; I don’t know that the lender would have the capability to completely assess the net worth of every borrower, and so may rely on Statements of Financial Condition and guaranties from the borrower.
- IF the borrower fraudulently represents their net worth to be higher than it truly is, the lender then provides the loan at a lower interest rate than they otherwise would, resulting in direct financial loss to the lender.

I didn’t read the whole complaint (it’s 222 pages), but that seems to be the issue in at least one part of it.
Title: Re: Trump handed a victory in fraud trial
Post by: Flapp_Jackson on October 11, 2023, 01:46:49 PM
I think the situation is a bit more complicated than it’s being painted here.  I don’t think it’s a case of overvaluing property used as direct collateral for a loan (which would still be wrong, but not necessarily as big a deal).

After reading just a little bit of the civil complaint, it looks like that in at least one case, there is an actual loss to one or more banks, like this:

- Mr. Trump wants a loan to buy a property.
- Bank says the proposition involves some risk, based on the nature of the property (one bank executive called a property a “tough asset” and said the bank’s initial reaction to the application for a loan was “not enthusiastic”), which they consider in setting loan terms (interest rate, etc.).
- The proposal is to do a “recourse loan,” in which the lender may go after borrower’s assets other than the property being purchased in the event of default.
- The terms of the recourse loan depend heavily on the borrower’s net worth, as represented by annual Statements of Financial Condition; higher net worth means easier recourse for the lender, which means less risk, which means better terms (lower interest rate, etc.)
- I don’t know for sure, but I would expect the lender to get an independent opinion on the value of the property to be purchased; I don’t know that the lender would have the capability to completely assess the net worth of every borrower, and so may rely on Statements of Financial Condition and guaranties from the borrower.
- IF the borrower fraudulently represents their net worth to be higher than it truly is, the lender then provides the loan at a lower interest rate than they otherwise would, resulting in direct financial loss to the lender.

I didn’t read the whole complaint (it’s 222 pages), but that seems to be the issue in at least one part of it.

If a banker is lending millions based on guarantees of the borrower, that's not fraud -- it's stupidity.  They shouldn't be allowed to manage their own money, much less the assets of a large financial business.
Title: Re: Trump handed a victory in fraud trial
Post by: changemyoil66 on October 11, 2023, 02:23:11 PM
If a banker is lending millions based on guarantees of the borrower, that's not fraud -- it's stupidity.  They shouldn't be allowed to manage their own money, much less the assets of a large financial business.

Like I said, banks gave out loans to people who couldnt pay them. Enter recession and banks being bailed out.  Was any borrower or underwriter (bank) charged for a crime for this?  I remember reading 1 article that stated banks weren't verifying income, but taking what ever was written on the applicaiton so they can meet their sales goals.
Title: Re: Trump handed a victory in fraud trial
Post by: Flapp_Jackson on October 11, 2023, 02:33:18 PM
Like I said, banks gave out loans to people who couldnt pay them. Enter recession and banks being bailed out.  Was any borrower or underwriter (bank) charged for a crime for this?  I remember reading 1 article that stated banks weren't verifying income, but taking what ever was written on the applicaiton so they can meet their sales goals.

Congress (Freddie and Fannie Mac) lowered the qualification standards, because the Dems believed owning a home is a "right."  So, the industry started doing all kinds of creative financing -- no principle/interest only payments, low payments for 3 years then massive balloon payments, variable interest rate loans, etc.

Then, when they got the bright idea of selling these toxic loans bundled as investments, the bottom fell out when the truth was publicized.  Homes lost all that inflated value caused by increased demand for loans they never would qualify for before.  The bubble burst, and that's when the banks that played ball with Obama were bailed out.  Bears Stearns was the first to fail.  The bail outs started the next week.  They were sold to JPMorgan.

All that borrowing going on because Congress wanted to have everyone owning homes -- whether they could afford it or not.  And the banks playing "Hot potato" with the loans they were certain would be foreclosed on let them reduce their risk.  BtW, the banks downplayed the risk for those bundled loans to get them sold.  Anyone go to jail for fraud?
Title: Re: Trump handed a victory in fraud trial
Post by: Sodie on October 11, 2023, 03:46:20 PM
If a banker is lending millions based on guarantees of the borrower, that's not fraud -- it's stupidity.  They shouldn't be allowed to manage their own money, much less the assets of a large financial business.

This is based on your years of experience in investment banking…?

Maybe that’s why we have laws that say you can’t misrepresent material information when you apply for a loan?

I’m not saying Trump did or didn’t misrepresent information in this case, but if he did, seems like pretty clear fraud to me…
Title: Re: Trump handed a victory in fraud trial
Post by: astroboy on October 11, 2023, 06:29:15 PM
Congress (Freddie and Fannie Mac) lowered the qualification standards, because the Dems believed owning a home is a "right."  So, the industry started doing all kinds of creative financing -- no principle/interest only payments, low payments for 3 years then massive balloon payments, variable interest rate loans, etc.

Then, when they got the bright idea of selling these toxic loans bundled as investments, the bottom fell out when the truth was publicized.  Homes lost all that inflated value caused by increased demand for loans they never would qualify for before.  The bubble burst, and that's when the banks that played ball with Obama were bailed out.  Bears Stearns was the first to fail.  The bail outs started the next week.  They were sold to JPMorgan.

All that borrowing going on because Congress wanted to have everyone owning homes -- whether they could afford it or not.  And the banks playing "Hot potato" with the loans they were certain would be foreclosed on let them reduce their risk.  BtW, the banks downplayed the risk for those bundled loans to get them sold.  Anyone go to jail for fraud?



Absolutely Right. Many of the toxic mortgages were indeed bundled together and sold as "A" paper investments.
Institutions like pension funds bought these investments. Banks gave zero down mortgages to people with bad
credit and who were also on welfare. This was done in the name of social justice.The Clintons were proponents
of this insanity. As if this wasn't bad enough, no one I know of went to jail for this fraud.   
Title: Re: Trump handed a victory in fraud trial
Post by: Flapp_Jackson on October 11, 2023, 06:50:40 PM
This is based on your years of experience in investment banking…?

Maybe that’s why we have laws that say you can’t misrepresent material information when you apply for a loan?

I’m not saying Trump did or didn’t misrepresent information in this case, but if he did, seems like pretty clear fraud to me…

Rather than insult me, show what you believe I said that's wrong and give some sort of proof -- other than detailing your vast experience in the financial and legal sectors.

Quote
Material misrepresentation is the act of intentional hiding or
fabrication of a material fact which, if known to the other party, could
have terminated, or significantly altered the basis of, a contract, deal,
or transaction. It is a misrepresentation that would be likely to induce
a reasonable person to manifest his assent, or that the maker knows
would be likely to induce the recipient to do so.

So far, not a single lender has come forward to say they would have withdrawn a loan offer or offered significantly less favorable terms had the valuations been less than reported.

And so far, nobody hating on Trump seems to get the important and basic fact that every single lender pays for property value assessments independent of the borrower's "guarantees".

Every house I've closed on -- buyer or seller -- the lender required an independent survey of property values that recently sold in my area and an inspection to make sure the property is in an appropriate condition.  Without that appraisal, the loan doesn't get approved.

I wonder if any of the anti-Trumper's here think Trump bribed the appraisers to get those "fraudulent" valuations?  Now THAT would be actual fraud.

I asked my Virginia realtor and property manager to do a quick appraisal of my rental home there for an estimate of where I might price my home should i sell.  At the same time, i went online and did my own survey using tax information, property sales, and anything else publicly available, and I came up with what I would price it at.

My realtor called back about 4 days later, and the range they came up with put the price I estimated exactly in the middle.

It's not that hard to come up with a property value if you do the work.  If the bank were buying the property, that's one thing.  They'd want to know at what price they can be guaranteed of realizing a profit.  All they needed for the loan was whether the property covered the amount borrowed and how much profit that represented in interest.
Title: Re: Trump handed a victory in fraud trial
Post by: Sodie on October 11, 2023, 07:47:06 PM
Rather than insult me, show what you believe I said that's wrong and give some sort of proof -- other than detailing your vast experience in the financial and legal sectors.

Because you’re the heart of civility in this forum?  Irony, thy name is Flapp.


So far, not a single lender has come forward to say they would have withdrawn a loan offer or offered significantly less favorable terms had the valuations been less than reported.

And so far, nobody hating on Trump seems to get the important and basic fact that every single lender pays for property value assessments independent of the borrower's "guarantees".

Every house I've closed on -- buyer or seller -- the lender required an independent survey of property values that recently sold in my area and an inspection to make sure the property is in an appropriate condition.  Without that appraisal, the loan doesn't get approved.

I wonder if any of the anti-Trumper's here think Trump bribed the appraisers to get those "fraudulent" valuations?  Now THAT would be actual fraud.

I asked my Virginia realtor and property manager to do a quick appraisal of my rental home there for an estimate of where I might price my home should i sell.  At the same time, i went online and did my own survey using tax information, property sales, and anything else publicly available, and I came up with what I would price it at.

My realtor called back about 4 days later, and the range they came up with put the price I estimated exactly in the middle.

It's not that hard to come up with a property value if you do the work.  If the bank were buying the property, that's one thing.  They'd want to know at what price they can be guaranteed of realizing a profit.  All they needed for the loan was whether the property covered the amount borrowed and how much profit that represented in interest.

Maybe because it goes without saying that if he had misrepresented his net worth, and they knew the accurate number, that they would’ve given less favorable terms?

There is information in the complaint that indicates the only way to get the deal he wanted was to provide a personal guaranty, in the particular case I was looking at.

Also, I think what you’re saying isn’t quite the same as what I’m saying.  Yes, I know lenders get appraisals of property used as collateral. In a recourse loan, they also retain the option of going after other assets the borrower has.  Example: let’s say I own a house, and I want to buy another one.  When I apply for a mortgage for the second house, the lender gets an appraisal of that property… but since it’s most likely a recourse loan, they can go after my first house, and my car, and whatnot, if I default.  Do they order appraisals for all of that property, to verify my net worth?  Doubtful.  For somebody like Donald Trump? I expect they would rely on the Statements of Financial Condition that he has attested to.

Like I said, I’m not saying he did anything wrong, or didn’t do anything wrong.  I’m saying that if he did misrepresent his net worth in order to get more favorable terms in financial dealings with banks and/or insurance companies, that seems to me like it would be fraud, whether or not any banks have explicitly said “we wouldn’t have written the same loan if we knew his net worth was different than what he said.”
Title: Re: Trump handed a victory in fraud trial
Post by: macsak on October 11, 2023, 08:03:03 PM
Because you’re the heart of civility in this forum?  Irony, thy name is Flapp.


Maybe because it goes without saying that if he had misrepresented his net worth, and they knew the accurate number, that they would’ve given less favorable terms?

There is information in the complaint that indicates the only way to get the deal he wanted was to provide a personal guaranty, in the particular case I was looking at.

Also, I think what you’re saying isn’t quite the same as what I’m saying.  Yes, I know lenders get appraisals of property used as collateral. In a recourse loan, they also retain the option of going after other assets the borrower has.  Example: let’s say I own a house, and I want to buy another one.  When I apply for a mortgage for the second house, the lender gets an appraisal of that property… but since it’s most likely a recourse loan, they can go after my first house, and my car, and whatnot, if I default.  Do they order appraisals for all of that property, to verify my net worth?  Doubtful.  For somebody like Donald Trump? I expect they would rely on the Statements of Financial Condition that he has attested to.

Like I said, I’m not saying he did anything wrong, or didn’t do anything wrong.  I’m saying that if he did misrepresent his net worth in order to get more favorable terms in financial dealings with banks and/or insurance companies, that seems to me like it would be fraud, whether or not any banks have explicitly said “we wouldn’t have written the same loan if we knew his net worth was different than what he said.”

earlier you said, "seems like pretty clear fraud to me…"
and now you are saying, "seems to me like it would be fraud"
goalposts moved...
Title: Re: Trump handed a victory in fraud trial
Post by: Sodie on October 11, 2023, 08:15:05 PM
earlier you said, "seems like pretty clear fraud to me…"
and now you are saying, "seems to me like it would be fraud"
goalposts moved...

Because I left out the words “pretty clear”?  Yep, you’re right.  Totally reversed my position by saying “would be fraud” instead of “pretty clear fraud.”  ::)
Title: Re: Trump handed a victory in fraud trial
Post by: macsak on October 11, 2023, 08:27:16 PM
Because I left out the words “pretty clear”?  Yep, you’re right.  Totally reversed my position by saying “would be fraud” instead of “pretty clear fraud.”  ::)

you didn't say, "would be fraud"
you said, "like it would be fraud"

there's a difference between "pretty clear" and "like it would"...
Title: Re: Trump handed a victory in fraud trial
Post by: Sodie on October 11, 2023, 08:39:46 PM
you didn't say, "would be fraud"
you said, "like it would be fraud"

there's a difference between "pretty clear" and "like it would"...

I didn’t categorically say it would be fraud because I haven’t read the New York law that applies to see what the elements of the offense are, but it seems to me that if one were to intentionally misrepresent their Statement of Financial Conditions in order to get better loan terms, that would likely be fraud. 

That’s seriously the nit you’re going to pick?
Title: Re: Trump handed a victory in fraud trial
Post by: hvybarrels on October 11, 2023, 09:39:15 PM
If they hate him so much to go after him like this then he must be doing something right
Title: Re: Trump handed a victory in fraud trial
Post by: macsak on October 12, 2023, 05:58:52 AM
I didn’t categorically say it would be fraud because I haven’t read the New York law that applies to see what the elements of the offense are, but it seems to me that if one were to intentionally misrepresent their Statement of Financial Conditions in order to get better loan terms, that would likely be fraud. 

That’s seriously the nit you’re going to pick?

so you admit you didn't read the law, yet you said it was "pretty clear"?
got it...
Title: Re: Trump handed a victory in fraud trial
Post by: QUIETShooter on October 12, 2023, 06:32:08 AM
If they hate him so much to go after him like this then he must be doing something right

They hate him so much they're not thinking straight.  Making themselves look like fools.
Title: Re: Trump handed a victory in fraud trial
Post by: ren on October 12, 2023, 06:49:17 AM
funny how there's so much financial talk on a 2a site but less firearms talk
Title: Re: Trump handed a victory in fraud trial
Post by: Flapp_Jackson on October 12, 2023, 07:13:46 AM
funny how there's so much financial talk on a 2a site but less firearms talk


I'll take "Political Discussions" for $1000 ....

 :geekdanc: :popcorn:
Title: Re: Trump handed a victory in fraud trial
Post by: Sodie on October 12, 2023, 08:03:37 AM
so you admit you didn't read the law, yet you said it was "pretty clear"?
got it...

I was considering the general definition and elements of fraud, which I had heard a while ago.  Under that definition, the plaintiff(s) would need to have suffered harm, which is what it seems to me that several posts in this thread have focused on.

I’ve now read the applicable section of NY law, and it’s even more broad than what I was thinking; it covers way more than the traditional general definition, and allows the AG of NY to bring suit (doesn’t have to be a harmed party, like a bank in this case).  Under the law cited in the complaint, former President Trump’s alleged conduct would absolutely constitute fraud.

Now we’ll see if the State of New York can prove it by “clear and convincing” evidence.

Sounds like Mr. Trump may also be considering challenging the law on constitutional grounds, which will be interesting to watch.
Title: Re: Trump handed a victory in fraud trial
Post by: changemyoil66 on October 12, 2023, 08:11:47 AM

I'll take "Political Discussions" for $1000 ....

 :geekdanc: :popcorn:


BBUUURRRRNNNNNNNNN
Title: Re: Trump handed a victory in fraud trial
Post by: changemyoil66 on October 12, 2023, 08:14:02 AM
They hate him so much they're not thinking straight.  Making themselves look like fools.

They only look like fools to people who don't have TDS or know how to use logic and recognize another witch hunt.

Title: Re: Trump handed a victory in fraud trial
Post by: changemyoil66 on October 12, 2023, 08:14:31 AM
funny how there's so much financial talk on a 2a site but less firearms talk

I get all my finance advice from 2ahi. Well here and Russell Peters ($0.50)
Title: Re: Trump handed a victory in fraud trial
Post by: ren on October 12, 2023, 10:39:25 AM
you guys can argue about all the details etc. but when you step back and think about what really is going on - the purposeful targeting of a former President who is running for re election. This undermines everything no matter what party you belong to - in our supposedly free country. Weak men create hard times. And most of you that argue here don't shoot / train - just collect ...and argue
Title: Re: Trump handed a victory in fraud trial
Post by: changemyoil66 on October 12, 2023, 11:30:06 AM
you guys can argue about all the details etc. but when you step back and think about what really is going on - the purposeful targeting of a former President who is running for re election. This undermines everything no matter what party you belong to - in our supposedly free country. Weak men create hard times. And most of you that argue here don't shoot / train - just collect ...and argue

Most here are aware of this, which is why all the post are a bigger deal than they sound. Those who support these fraudulent indictments are the unaware ones.  At this point, even if a legitimate crime was commited, it took so many false claims that I would most likely overlook said crime.
Title: Re: Trump handed a victory in fraud trial
Post by: Flapp_Jackson on October 12, 2023, 11:44:34 AM
you guys can argue about all the details etc. but when you step back and think about what really is going on - the purposeful targeting of a former President who is running for re election. This undermines everything no matter what party you belong to - in our supposedly free country. Weak men create hard times. And most of you that argue here don't shoot / train - just collect ...and argue

It makes no sense to cast aspersions on people who have the same values as yourself.

Everybody has a different set of circumstances.  We can't all spend $$$$ and hours going to the range, cleaning guns, reloading/finding ammo, etc.

Also, how difficult has the C&C made it to even go to the range?  Closed for how long?  Reopened for fewer days per week, reservation system, etc.

No skeet, no MPPL, no action bay events at all.

So, yeah. It's our fault if we "don't shoot / train - just collect".

  :crazy:
Title: Re: Trump handed a victory in fraud trial
Post by: changemyoil66 on October 12, 2023, 11:49:15 AM
It makes no sense to cast aspersions on people who have the same values as yourself.

Everybody has a different set of circumstances.  We can't all spend $$$$ and hours going to the range, cleaning guns, reloading/finding ammo, etc.

Also, how difficult has the C&C made it to even go to the range?  Closed for how long?  Reopened for fewer days per week, reservation system, etc.

No skeet, no MPPL, no action bay events at all.

So, yeah. It's our fault if we "don't shoot / train - just collect".

  :crazy:

I never really thought about this until now. Since I haven't shot since November 2022. does this mean I don't shoot?  Its not by choice, but bays closed and I'm not about to waste $ at the bench side or at an indoor range.  Nov was to do my CCW test. Shot 50rds. Prior to that, shot in Vegas to zero the red dots. Total 50rds in the same month. Then last time I really shot was in Sept 2022 just before the range closed.
Title: Re: Trump handed a victory in fraud trial
Post by: hvybarrels on October 12, 2023, 04:07:10 PM
And most of you that argue here don't shoot / train - just collect ...and argue

I resemble that remark
Title: Re: Trump handed a victory in fraud trial
Post by: QUIETShooter on October 12, 2023, 05:37:14 PM
Range too far. 

And then only 3 relays?  LOL!
Title: Re: Trump handed a victory in fraud trial
Post by: eyeeatingfish on October 15, 2023, 08:06:42 PM
Show me any bank or other lending institution that will take a borrower's word alone for the value of a multi-million-dollar property.

The insurance companies as well.

None of the banks or insurance companies loaning Trump money on the properties or covering it for losses has complained that the property is over-valued. 

So your argument is that fraud is only illegal if the banks and insurance companies complain?

And even if the government doesn't prosecute because the banks didn't complain, what does that say about Trump? Do you see the irony of this defense? It basically admits he is a liar and corrupt but says it is ok since no one complained. And this is the man you want to lead this country?
Title: Re: Trump handed a victory in fraud trial
Post by: changemyoil66 on October 16, 2023, 09:01:38 AM
So your argument is that fraud is only illegal if the banks and insurance companies complain?

And even if the government doesn't prosecute because the banks didn't complain, what does that say about Trump? Do you see the irony of this defense? It basically admits he is a liar and corrupt but says it is ok since no one complained. And this is the man you want to lead this country?


SWWWOOOOOSSSHHHHHHH

*covers 1 eye
"I guess you didn't see it did you"

Street Fighter the Movie reference.
Title: Re: Trump handed a victory in fraud trial
Post by: ren on October 16, 2023, 09:27:38 AM
victory is an X / A zone shot. ...but you guys here wouldn't know....
Title: Re: Trump handed a victory in fraud trial
Post by: eyeeatingfish on October 16, 2023, 08:34:25 PM

SWWWOOOOOSSSHHHHHHH

*covers 1 eye
"I guess you didn't see it did you"

Street Fighter the Movie reference.

I swoosh your swoosh.

Even if having no one complaining and thus you don't have the elements of a crime, you still have Trump admitting to behavior undesierable in a president.
Title: Re: Trump handed a victory in fraud trial
Post by: macsak on October 16, 2023, 09:01:55 PM
goalposts moved...

I swoosh your swoosh.

Even if having no one complaining and thus you don't have the elements of a crime, you still have Trump admitting to behavior undesierable in a president.
Title: Re: Trump handed a victory in fraud trial
Post by: changemyoil66 on October 17, 2023, 08:14:17 AM
goalposts moved...

F22's on back order currently, even though I'm making the $ due to my goal post moving business.
Title: Re: Trump handed a victory in fraud trial
Post by: changemyoil66 on October 17, 2023, 08:15:14 AM
I swoosh your swoosh.

Even if having no one complaining and thus you don't have the elements of a crime, you still have Trump admitting to behavior undesierable in a president.

#doesntunderstnadswoosh like how someone doesn't understand when called Jean or referenced Jeanism.
Title: Re: Trump handed a victory in fraud trial
Post by: ren on October 17, 2023, 08:36:49 AM
you guys should do a shoot off. 100 yards offhand A zone hits . iton sights
Title: Re: Trump handed a victory in fraud trial
Post by: changemyoil66 on October 17, 2023, 08:46:43 AM
you guys should do a shoot off. 100 yards offhand A zone hits . iton sights

Rather do boto measuring contest. But since I'm Asian, I get to add 4 inches.
Title: Re: Trump handed a victory in fraud trial
Post by: eyeeatingfish on October 17, 2023, 10:32:21 AM
#doesntunderstnadswoosh like how someone doesn't understand when called Jean or referenced Jeanism.

#doesnotunderstandwhataboutism so I guess I am in good company then.

You are sidestepping the fact that this defense illustrates how Trump is a slimy liar. I don't care if he is guilty of this or not, what it says about his character is enough. Ignore it and support him anyway if you like, you get to vote the way you like.
Title: Re: Trump handed a victory in fraud trial
Post by: eyeeatingfish on October 17, 2023, 10:33:27 AM
Rather do boto measuring contest. But since I'm Asian, I get to add 4 inches.

That escalated quickly.... can we do something less gay?
Title: Re: Trump handed a victory in fraud trial
Post by: ren on October 17, 2023, 10:36:52 AM
That escalated quickly.... can we do something less gay?

range this weekend. SR1 target at 100 yards.  Off hand . Iron sights
Title: Re: Trump handed a victory in fraud trial
Post by: eyeeatingfish on October 17, 2023, 10:46:03 AM
range this weekend. SR1 target at 100 yards.  Off hand . Iron sights

Tempting.

Or we could do video games. Halo, Smash Brothers, Call of Duty?
Title: Re: Trump handed a victory in fraud trial
Post by: ren on October 17, 2023, 11:15:40 AM
Tempting.

Or we could do video games. Halo, Smash Brothers, Call of Duty?

silly
Title: Re: Trump handed a victory in fraud trial
Post by: changemyoil66 on October 17, 2023, 11:27:12 AM
#doesnotunderstandwhataboutism so I guess I am in good company then.

You are sidestepping the fact that this defense illustrates how Trump is a slimy liar. I don't care if he is guilty of this or not, what it says about his character is enough. Ignore it and support him anyway if you like, you get to vote the way you like.

Have you ever  stated the value of something and it wasn't for market value? Does this make you a liar?  Trump isn't an appraiser or a professional who knows the exact value of properties.  He does know more than the regular person though.    Re-read what flapp posted. It's the job of the bank to verify what is stated by a person is accurate or not. 
Title: Re: Trump handed a victory in fraud trial
Post by: eyeeatingfish on October 17, 2023, 12:05:49 PM
Have you ever  stated the value of something and it wasn't for market value? Does this make you a liar?  Trump isn't an appraiser or a professional who knows the exact value of properties.  He does know more than the regular person though.    Re-read what flapp posted. It's the job of the bank to verify what is stated by a person is accurate or not.

Square footage is not a subjective matter like value is.

Here in Hawaii we have a law that makes it illegal to lie about the authenticity of an item for sale. Basically if I tell you I have an autographed original of something but I lied about its authenticity then I have committed a crime. The law does not put the burden on the buyer to double check the authenticity first. Now if I sell you something fake and you don't care then the criminal case really wouldn't go anywhere. Now this might be a good example of why this is a politically biased prosecution but valuing a property for a loan is a bit more complicated with more repercussions so it may not be a fair comparison in evaluating legal defenses.

Having said that, there are two facets to this.  The above is the legal facet, whether criminal fraud or civil fraud was committed. The other facet, that you are ignoring and that I am concentrating on, is that the behavior still makes Trump a bad person. If I am playing sports and I cheat to get an extra point but the extra point has no bearing on the outcome of the game I am still a cheater.
Title: Re: Trump handed a victory in fraud trial
Post by: changemyoil66 on October 17, 2023, 12:22:51 PM
Square footage is not a subjective matter like value is.

Here in Hawaii we have a law that makes it illegal to lie about the authenticity of an item for sale. Basically if I tell you I have an autographed original of something but I lied about its authenticity then I have committed a crime. The law does not put the burden on the buyer to double check the authenticity first. Now if I sell you something fake and you don't care then the criminal case really wouldn't go anywhere. Now this might be a good example of why this is a politically biased prosecution but valuing a property for a loan is a bit more complicated with more repercussions so it may not be a fair comparison in evaluating legal defenses.

Having said that, there are two facets to this.  The above is the legal facet, whether criminal fraud or civil fraud was committed. The other facet, that you are ignoring and that I am concentrating on, is that the behavior still makes Trump a bad person. If I am playing sports and I cheat to get an extra point but the extra point has no bearing on the outcome of the game I am still a cheater.

That example doesn't work.  What you would have had to say is that HI has a law for selling something for more than it's market value, which we don't have. But thanks for playing.

Trump isn't a professional, even with sqft.  The lender would have to verify it if it's that important by sending out a professional to verify the sqft and correct as needed. 1 cannot just rely on blue prints either as whats on paper can also be wrong. I mean are you expecting Trump to go and measure the property and not even be 1ft off?  Cause whether he's 1 ft or 1,000,000 ft off, it's still not correct and you would think he's a fraud. Same goes with getting an expired meter ticket, 1 minute or 10 mins after the meter expires is still a ticket. Or 14ft away from a corner instead of 15ft. Or if cops were to enforce mag limits. 15rd mag pistol mag or 30rd pistol mag, are both the same level of illegal.

Trump isn't a saint.  I dont' expect any billionaire to be one either.  I would even call him an asshole at times, but he's the asshole we need that got stuff done. But this is just based off of his TV show and public appearances.  I have never met him, so maybe this is his persona he's portraying.  But from people who have been interviewed that have met him (regular folk), they all said the same thing "he's a lot nicer in person than what they thought".  And of course the fake news never aired this interview again. 1 was for the VEgas shooting when he visited the hospital, another was when he visited the veterans hospital, another when he was ordering burgers in Boston (IIRC).  Or would you rather have a nice guy who shits on this country?




Title: Re: Trump handed a victory in fraud trial
Post by: Flapp_Jackson on October 17, 2023, 02:15:01 PM
That example doesn't work.  What you would have had to say is that HI has a law for selling something for more than it's market value, which we don't have. But thanks for playing.

Trump isn't a professional, even with sqft.  The lender would have to verify it if it's that important by sending out a professional to verify the sqft and correct as needed. 1 cannot just rely on blue prints either as whats on paper can also be wrong. I mean are you expecting Trump to go and measure the property and not even be 1ft off?  Cause whether he's 1 ft or 1,000,000 ft off, it's still not correct and you would think he's a fraud. Same goes with getting an expired meter ticket, 1 minute or 10 mins after the meter expires is still a ticket. Or 14ft away from a corner instead of 15ft. Or if cops were to enforce mag limits. 15rd mag pistol mag or 30rd pistol mag, are both the same level of illegal.

Trump isn't a saint.  I dont' expect any billionaire to be one either.  I would even call him an asshole at times, but he's the asshole we need that got stuff done. But this is just based off of his TV show and public appearances.  I have never met him, so maybe this is his persona he's portraying.  But from people who have been interviewed that have met him (regular folk), they all said the same thing "he's a lot nicer in person than what they thought".  And of course the fake news never aired this interview again. 1 was for the VEgas shooting when he visited the hospital, another was when he visited the veterans hospital, another when he was ordering burgers in Boston (IIRC).  Or would you rather have a nice guy who shits on this country?

There is no actual formula for assessing the value of any propoerty.

For most properties, you have to factor in "location, location, location." 

A property would have to be compared to other properties with a similar size, age and amenities, all within the same general area.

How easy do you think it is to find another property that's comparable to Trump's properties (known for their lavish luxury), in the same general area, WHICH HAVE RECENTLY SOLD??

Good luck with that assessment! 

If someone thinks square feet is the end-all, be-all of this issue, they need to try doing a market survey themselves.  It's really not that difficult or time consuming ... for residential properties or areas where business properties change hands relatively frequently.
Title: Re: Trump handed a victory in fraud trial
Post by: changemyoil66 on October 17, 2023, 04:25:49 PM
There is no actual formula for assessing the value of any propoerty.

For most properties, you have to factor in "location, location, location." 

A property would have to be compared to other properties with a similar size, age and amenities, all within the same general area.

How easy do you think it is to find another property that's comparable to Trump's properties (known for their lavish luxury), in the same general area, WHICH HAVE RECENTLY SOLD??

Good luck with that assessment! 

If someone thinks square feet is the end-all, be-all of this issue, they need to try doing a market survey themselves.  It's really not that difficult or time consuming ... for residential properties or areas where business properties change hands relatively frequently.

This is also true,but according to EEF, Trump is an expert because he held him to the standard of "lying" about the property.  And ignored the lenders and their underwriters and SOP for high value loans.

What if , I get a text from someone who wants to buy my property. What if I reply with $1,000,000 cash and meet me in front the building tomorrow.  Would this mean that I'm over valuing my property and subject to fraud?

I have a general idea what my property is worth, but I'm not a realtor, appraiser, etc...
Title: Re: Trump handed a victory in fraud trial
Post by: Flapp_Jackson on October 17, 2023, 04:40:37 PM
This is also true,but according to EEF, Trump is an expert because he held him to the standard of "lying" about the property.  And ignored the lenders and their underwriters and SOP for high value loans.

What if , I get a text from someone who wants to buy my property. What if I reply with $1,000,000 cash and meet me in front the building tomorrow.  Would this mean that I'm over valuing my property and subject to fraud?

I have a general idea what my property is worth, but I'm not a realtor, appraiser, etc...

The realtor who sold us this house told us about the Japanese "Invasion" in the late 1980s.  The stock market in Japan had been on fire, to the point where it was getting tough to find any more stocks there that weren't already max'ed out in future growth potential.

So, the Japanese with all that money came to Hawaii.  As the realtor told it, a friend of his had been in the same house for 20 years.  One Sunday afternoon, there came a knock on the door.  It was a realtor.  After introductions, the realtor asked, "So, how much would you take for your house?"

The owner said, "If you're a realtor, then you already know this property isn't listed for sale."

"I know, but I have a client from Japan in my car (pointing to the man in his back seat).  We've been looking at properties and open houses, but as we drove by here, he said he really likes your house.  Seriously -- no joke.  If you had to name a number, what would it take to get you to sell?"

After a few seconds, he gave the guy a number that was what he paid plus a healthy return on investment.  They signed the papers on the spot, and the visitor paid in cash.

At that specific time, before house prices began increasing in part due to these investors, everyone in that man's neighborhood was upside down on their mortgages (owed more than they could sell it for).  However, after that man sold for such a huge amount, much more than the assessments had been, suddenly everyone in the neighborhood was able to refinance or sell for way more than their mortgage.

I guess those people should have been arrested for fraud, since the only reason their property values increased was because one man was able to sell to a randon buyer for much, much more than market value.

Such crooks and liars!!
Title: Re: Trump handed a victory in fraud trial
Post by: eyeeatingfish on October 17, 2023, 10:30:52 PM
That example doesn't work.  What you would have had to say is that HI has a law for selling something for more than it's market value, which we don't have. But thanks for playing.

Trump isn't a professional, even with sqft.  The lender would have to verify it if it's that important by sending out a professional to verify the sqft and correct as needed. 1 cannot just rely on blue prints either as whats on paper can also be wrong. I mean are you expecting Trump to go and measure the property and not even be 1ft off?  Cause whether he's 1 ft or 1,000,000 ft off, it's still not correct and you would think he's a fraud. Same goes with getting an expired meter ticket, 1 minute or 10 mins after the meter expires is still a ticket. Or 14ft away from a corner instead of 15ft. Or if cops were to enforce mag limits. 15rd mag pistol mag or 30rd pistol mag, are both the same level of illegal.

Trump isn't a saint.  I dont' expect any billionaire to be one either.  I would even call him an asshole at times, but he's the asshole we need that got stuff done. But this is just based off of his TV show and public appearances.  I have never met him, so maybe this is his persona he's portraying.  But from people who have been interviewed that have met him (regular folk), they all said the same thing "he's a lot nicer in person than what they thought".  And of course the fake news never aired this interview again. 1 was for the VEgas shooting when he visited the hospital, another was when he visited the veterans hospital, another when he was ordering burgers in Boston (IIRC).  Or would you rather have a nice guy who shits on this country?

Look at the facts, Trump wasn't off by a couple hundred square feet, the square footage listed was 3 times the actual size.
You are misrepresenting it by trying to paint it as subjective market value when the issue isn't value, it is square footage.

Comparing what he did to getting the square footage wrong by a couple feet is so ridiculous. You might as well drive 100 mph in a school zone and tell the cop your speedometer is broken and you aren't an expert in determining speeds. This is almost a worse defense than the previous one. So now Trump wasn't a liar, he is just so dumb he cannot tell the difference between a foot and a yard stick? I mean come on, if I were going to defend Trump I would at least pick a better argument that doesn't paint him as corrupt or incompetent. At the very least concoct an argument to the effect of saying that an employee filled out the form and he didn't know the employee put the wrong number.

I have heard from a number of sources that Trump was very reasonable in person. Also I agree that he made a number of good calls when leading this country. Having said that, I think he has demonstrated enough personal characteristics that, to me, disqualifies him from holding the office of president. A corrupt cop could pull me from a burning vehicle but I wouldn't then excuse his corruption.
Title: Re: Trump handed a victory in fraud trial
Post by: eyeeatingfish on October 17, 2023, 10:32:00 PM
silly

Thought you might say that. I think CMO and I are similar in age so I wager we likely played some of the same games growing up.
Title: Re: Trump handed a victory in fraud trial
Post by: Flapp_Jackson on October 19, 2023, 01:35:40 PM
In response  to those that said the loan was repaid so nobody got hurt. Where is the crime?

Lying of a loan application is a felony. If you speed and don't kill anyone or damage property it is still a crime.

Prove he lied.

So far, you haven't shown anything close to that.

Once again, property value assessments are as much subjective as objective.  Go read my other posts about real estate valuation factors.  You obviously failed to read them, ignored them, and/or failed to understand them.
Title: Re: Trump handed a victory in fraud trial
Post by: macsak on October 19, 2023, 04:19:51 PM
wow, he was convicted already?

The court already determined that Trump lied.. now we are just determining what the penalty will be.
Title: Re: Trump handed a victory in fraud trial
Post by: macsak on October 19, 2023, 04:20:29 PM
and is that "we" like when you are a Duke Basketball fan?

The court already determined that Trump lied.. now we are just determining what the penalty will be.
Title: Re: Trump handed a victory in fraud trial
Post by: Flapp_Jackson on October 19, 2023, 04:58:59 PM
The court already determined that Trump lied.. now we are just determining what the penalty will be.

You're a moron.

The judge that ruled Trump committed fraud and lied was presiding in CIVIL COURT, not criminal court.

There are no "penalties" in civil trials unless there is a statutory allowance for things like pain & suffering, punitive damages, etc.  Purely financial in nature, not like he's being found guilty of a crime.

Which Liberal Democratic Socialist Progressive website did you get your law degree from?

BTW, civil judgements are not grounds for barring Trump from running for office again.  Just so you know.

And on that note, maybe you missed the good news out of the Supreme Court?

Supreme Court declines to consider longshot bid
to disqualify Trump from running for president

Quote
The Supreme Court said Monday that it will not take up a longshot challenge to
Donald Trump’s eligibility to run for president because of his alleged role in the
January 6, 2021, attack on the US Capitol.

The case was brought by John Anthony Castro, a little-known candidate for the
Republican presidential nomination, who sued Trump earlier this year in an effort
to disqualify him from running for president and holding the office “given his
alleged provision of aid or comfort to the convicted criminals and insurrectionist
that violently attacked our United States Capitol on January 6, 2021.”

The case was denied without any comment or recorded vote.
https://www.cnn.com/2023/10/02/politics/donald-trump-fourteenth-amendment-ballot-case-supreme-court/index.html
Title: Re: Trump handed a victory in fraud trial
Post by: ren on October 19, 2023, 05:09:57 PM
You're a moron.

anything new? You can tell who's alter ego that is...
Title: Re: Trump handed a victory in fraud trial
Post by: macsak on October 19, 2023, 07:18:43 PM
so where's your name on the order, since "we" are determining the penalty...

The court order identifies Trump and other members of the Trump organization violated NY State executive law.

The certificates of incorporation were cancelled, a receiver will be appointed and Trump organization will be dissolved. The plaintiff one on the major charges.

There's always the possibility of criminal charges to follow. It's already been determined that they lied and committed fraud.

Read it yourself at https://www.documentcloud.org/documents/23991850-nyag-v-trump-summary-judgement-sanctions-decision-20230926
Title: Re: Trump handed a victory in fraud trial
Post by: Flapp_Jackson on October 19, 2023, 07:54:55 PM
The court order identifies Trump and other members of the Trump organization violated NY State executive law.

The certificates of incorporation were cancelled, a receiver will be appointed and Trump organization will be dissolved. The plaintiff one on the major charges.

There's always the possibility of criminal charges to follow. It's already been determined that they lied and committed fraud.

Read it yourself at https://www.documentcloud.org/documents/23991850-nyag-v-trump-summary-judgement-sanctions-decision-20230926

You have that backwards, genius.

If you lose in civil court, the judgement has no bearing on subsequent criminal prosecution.  However, if found guilty in a criminal trial, the evidence from that case goes a long way toward getting a civil judgement afterward.

hmmm.  Curious they went the civil route first ,,,

The standards of evidence are much higher for criminal court (guilt proven beyond a reasonable doubt) versus civil court (what's more likely based on a preponderance of the evidence -- 51% tips the balance either way).

So, you keep lecturing us on what's coming next, Perry Mason.  I'll wait for the movie.
Title: Re: Trump handed a victory in fraud trial
Post by: changemyoil66 on October 20, 2023, 08:27:28 AM
Look at the facts, Trump wasn't off by a couple hundred square feet, the square footage listed was 3 times the actual size.
You are misrepresenting it by trying to paint it as subjective market value when the issue isn't value, it is square footage.

Comparing what he did to getting the square footage wrong by a couple feet is so ridiculous. You might as well drive 100 mph in a school zone and tell the cop your speedometer is broken and you aren't an expert in determining speeds. This is almost a worse defense than the previous one. So now Trump wasn't a liar, he is just so dumb he cannot tell the difference between a foot and a yard stick? I mean come on, if I were going to defend Trump I would at least pick a better argument that doesn't paint him as corrupt or incompetent. At the very least concoct an argument to the effect of saying that an employee filled out the form and he didn't know the employee put the wrong number.

I have heard from a number of sources that Trump was very reasonable in person. Also I agree that he made a number of good calls when leading this country. Having said that, I think he has demonstrated enough personal characteristics that, to me, disqualifies him from holding the office of president. A corrupt cop could pull me from a burning vehicle but I wouldn't then excuse his corruption.

Is Trump an expert on square footage? 

So here's a good example. If a someone is going 1mph over the speed limit vs 10mph over the speed limit, are both still breaking the law?  And remember, 10mph over is 10X faster than 1mph over.

Thanks for falling for the fake news agenda again.
Title: Re: Trump handed a victory in fraud trial
Post by: changemyoil66 on October 20, 2023, 08:27:58 AM
In response  to those that said the loan was repaid so nobody got hurt. Where is the crime?

Lying of a loan application is a felony. If you speed and don't kill anyone or damage property it is still a crime.


Jean is back. Time for some popcorn.
Title: Re: Trump handed a victory in fraud trial
Post by: macsak on October 23, 2023, 11:54:29 AM
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4nhpb9jhirY
Title: Re: Trump handed a victory in fraud trial
Post by: eyeeatingfish on October 26, 2023, 10:20:50 PM
wow, he was convicted already?

I think what he is referring to is the judge's summary judgement that the evidence shows he lied, thereby committing fraud, so a trial was not necessary for that part.
Title: Re: Trump handed a victory in fraud trial
Post by: eyeeatingfish on October 26, 2023, 10:31:48 PM
Is Trump an expert on square footage? 

So here's a good example. If a someone is going 1mph over the speed limit vs 10mph over the speed limit, are both still breaking the law?  And remember, 10mph over is 10X faster than 1mph over.

Thanks for falling for the fake news agenda again.


Why are you doing such gymnastics to excuse Trump's fraud? Do you really believe Trump is that dumb to not know how to calculate basic geometry? Is he so bad at real estate that he thought he bought a 15,000 square foot property when it was 5,000 when he originally bought it?

Just admit it, this is who Trump is. How many times has he played these little games in the real estate market. Just like when he tricked people into thinking they had a higher up apartment than he had. Trump does not have any plausible deniability here.

Do you think every person caught with drugs simply claims they can't tell weights? "Judge, I didn't know I had 5 ounces, I thought I only had 3 grams..." That is not going to fly.
Title: Re: Trump handed a victory in fraud trial
Post by: changemyoil66 on October 27, 2023, 08:10:05 AM

Why are you doing such gymnastics to excuse Trump's fraud? Do you really believe Trump is that dumb to not know how to calculate basic geometry? Is he so bad at real estate that he thought he bought a 15,000 square foot property when it was 5,000 when he originally bought it?

Just admit it, this is who Trump is. How many times has he played these little games in the real estate market. Just like when he tricked people into thinking they had a higher up apartment than he had. Trump does not have any plausible deniability here.

Do you think every person caught with drugs simply claims they can't tell weights? "Judge, I didn't know I had 5 ounces, I thought I only had 3 grams..." That is not going to fly.

Thanks for playing with your poor example. You're missing how it would be 1 oz or 1.9999999999 oz of a schedule 1 narcotic is still illegal. 

I'm not playing gymnastics, but instead trying to show you how to think for yourself.  Re-read what I posted. Do cops know how much horsepower an HPD cruiser is?  So you give the manuals HP answer and then it's dyno'd and you're incorrect.  Should the officer be charged with fraud?  How about how fast a cop was going prior to a deadly car accident?  Science proves it was faster which caused the death.  Is this fraud? 

I cannot show you anymore how being wrong about sqft is nothing but the DOJ reaching for something or how loan underwriting works.  Are any underwriters going to get charged with fraud cause they approved the loan at said sqft?  Now IF he got the official sq footage document and whited out what a professional filled in, then it could be something.
Title: Re: Trump handed a victory in fraud trial
Post by: Flapp_Jackson on October 27, 2023, 08:38:42 AM
Thanks for playing with your poor example. You're missing how it would be 1 oz or 1.9999999999 oz of a schedule 1 narcotic is still illegal. 

I'm not playing gymnastics, but instead trying to show you how to think for yourself.  Re-read what I posted. Do cops know how much horsepower an HPD cruiser is?  So you give the manuals HP answer and then it's dyno'd and you're incorrect.  Should the officer be charged with fraud?  How about how fast a cop was going prior to a deadly car accident?  Science proves it was faster which caused the death.  Is this fraud? 

I cannot show you anymore how being wrong about sqft is nothing but the DOJ reaching for something or how loan underwriting works.  Are any underwriters going to get charged with fraud cause they approved the loan at said sqft?  Now IF he got the official sq footage document and whited out what a professional filled in, then it could be something.

I bought a 1500 sqft home in Virginia for $70K.

I also bought a 1500 sqft home in Hawaii for $400K.

Obviously there's no difference between two houses of the same square footage.  A lifelong real estate billionaire is obviously guilty of fraud for using a higher per sqft value than a more knowledgable judge.
Title: Re: Trump handed a victory in fraud trial
Post by: changemyoil66 on October 27, 2023, 12:52:50 PM
I bought a 1500 sqft home in Virginia for $70K.

I also bought a 1500 sqft home in Hawaii for $400K.

Obviously there's no difference between two houses of the same square footage.  A lifelong real estate billionaire is obviously guilty of fraud for using a higher per sqft value than a more knowledgable judge.

Are you sure the realtor and inspector got the sqft correct?  They may face federal charge for fraud if they were off by any amount.
Title: Re: Trump handed a victory in fraud trial
Post by: eyeeatingfish on October 29, 2023, 09:10:38 PM
Thanks for playing with your poor example. You're missing how it would be 1 oz or 1.9999999999 oz of a schedule 1 narcotic is still illegal. 

I'm not playing gymnastics, but instead trying to show you how to think for yourself.  Re-read what I posted. Do cops know how much horsepower an HPD cruiser is?  So you give the manuals HP answer and then it's dyno'd and you're incorrect.  Should the officer be charged with fraud?  How about how fast a cop was going prior to a deadly car accident?  Science proves it was faster which caused the death.  Is this fraud? 

I cannot show you anymore how being wrong about sqft is nothing but the DOJ reaching for something or how loan underwriting works.  Are any underwriters going to get charged with fraud cause they approved the loan at said sqft?  Now IF he got the official sq footage document and whited out what a professional filled in, then it could be something.

If my son got the size of our house wrong by a factor of 3 I would say he can claim ignorance. If someone who prides themselves on a real estate mogul got the size of the house wrong by a factor of 3 I call BS. That is not a level of ignorance I think he gets to claim.

So you are comparing horsepower on an engine to the area of a rectangle? Talk about poor examples.

Like I said, if he simply came out and said an aid filled out the form wrong and Trump missed it then at least that is believable, but the "I don't know how to measure, I am not trained to use a tape measure" type excuse just insults our intelligence. I mean even if you like Trump that is an objectively bad defense.
Title: Re: Trump handed a victory in fraud trial
Post by: changemyoil66 on October 30, 2023, 08:53:01 AM
If my son got the size of our house wrong by a factor of 3 I would say he can claim ignorance. If someone who prides themselves on a real estate mogul got the size of the house wrong by a factor of 3 I call BS. That is not a level of ignorance I think he gets to claim.

So you are comparing horsepower on an engine to the area of a rectangle? Talk about poor examples.

Like I said, if he simply came out and said an aid filled out the form wrong and Trump missed it then at least that is believable, but the "I don't know how to measure, I am not trained to use a tape measure" type excuse just insults our intelligence. I mean even if you like Trump that is an objectively bad defense.

Again, swooosh. You missed the point.  What I'm getting at isn't an aide filled out the form wrong, is that unless Trump himself measured the property, then he could be off and would be charged for another witch hunt.  Then the fact that the underwriters for the loan didn't question it or go measure themselves. And yet they're certifying that the info is accurate and yet no "fraud" charge for any underwriter/lender.

What my HP example is that you are not seeing is on paper, something can say X, but in reality until physically measured, it will be something else.    And many times, things aren't acutally physically measured by said person.

And again, this is another witch hunt now focusing on dotting "i's" and crossing "t's".

Thanks for playing.
Title: Re: Trump handed a victory in fraud trial
Post by: ren on October 30, 2023, 08:55:17 AM
speaking of properties, a sea wall is OK'd for Obama's property in Waimanalo but North Shore residents get daily fines just trying to save their property
Title: Re: Trump handed a victory in fraud trial
Post by: hvybarrels on October 30, 2023, 09:05:54 AM
speaking of properties, a sea wall is OK'd for Obama's property in Waimanalo but North Shore residents get daily fines just trying to save their property

Seawall = waves bounce off and carry away the sand
Imagine paying that much money for beachfront just so you can stumble down slippery stairs and bang your toe on coral heads
https://www.propublica.org/article/oceanfront-property-tied-to-obama-granted-exemption-from-hawaiis-environmental-laws

(https://i.dailymail.co.uk/1s/2022/02/06/00/53825919-10481075-image-a-16_1644109381178.jpg)
Title: Re: Trump handed a victory in fraud trial
Post by: macsak on October 30, 2023, 11:48:44 AM
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Jyj3AK6fIJU
Title: Re: Trump handed a victory in fraud trial
Post by: eyeeatingfish on October 30, 2023, 01:59:26 PM
Again, swooosh. You missed the point.  What I'm getting at isn't an aide filled out the form wrong, is that unless Trump himself measured the property, then he could be off and would be charged for another witch hunt.  Then the fact that the underwriters for the loan didn't question it or go measure themselves. And yet they're certifying that the info is accurate and yet no "fraud" charge for any underwriter/lender.

What my HP example is that you are not seeing is on paper, something can say X, but in reality until physically measured, it will be something else.    And many times, things aren't actually physically measured by said person.

And again, this is another witch hunt now focusing on dotting "i's" and crossing "t's".

Thanks for playing.

So bascially anyone can just claim whatever square footage they want and later claim ignorance because they didn't measure themselves they would be immune to prosecution? No one would ever be convicted if such a defense worked.

If an underwriter failed to do due diligence in measuring the property that doesn't release Trump from all criminal liability. If you sold me a fraudulent art piece and I failed to get it inspected by an expert that doesn't mean you didn't commit a crime. Maybe in a civil trial asking for damages but not in a criminal trial.

Now if I said my house was 1525 square feet and it was 1515 square feet then sure, that is a reasonable mistake and prosecuting such would be an egregious use of the justice system. But if I said it was 15,000 square feet when it was 5,000 that is not such a reasonable mistake.
Title: Re: Trump handed a victory in fraud trial
Post by: changemyoil66 on October 30, 2023, 05:18:32 PM
So bascially anyone can just claim whatever square footage they want and later claim ignorance because they didn't measure themselves they would be immune to prosecution? No one would ever be convicted if such a defense worked.

If an underwriter failed to do due diligence in measuring the property that doesn't release Trump from all criminal liability. If you sold me a fraudulent art piece and I failed to get it inspected by an expert that doesn't mean you didn't commit a crime. Maybe in a civil trial asking for damages but not in a criminal trial.

Now if I said my house was 1525 square feet and it was 1515 square feet then sure, that is a reasonable mistake and prosecuting such would be an egregious use of the justice system. But if I said it was 15,000 square feet when it was 5,000 that is not such a reasonable mistake.
So ur saying theres a "grace" number given. What is this official number that you think there is? Once u provide this number, we will apply it to how much Trump was off and then determine if fraud was committed.

Then apply this same judgment to everyone who approved the loan cause they too agreed to the figures used.

Cause others agreed to it as well.


ENTIRE POST IS SARCASTIC.

Sent from my SM-G991U using Tapatalk

Title: Re: Trump handed a victory in fraud trial
Post by: Sodie on October 30, 2023, 05:33:52 PM
Again, swooosh. You missed the point.  What I'm getting at isn't an aide filled out the form wrong, is that unless Trump himself measured the property, then he could be off and would be charged for another witch hunt.  Then the fact that the underwriters for the loan didn't question it or go measure themselves. And yet they're certifying that the info is accurate and yet no "fraud" charge for any underwriter/lender.

What my HP example is that you are not seeing is on paper, something can say X, but in reality until physically measured, it will be something else.    And many times, things aren't acutally physically measured by said person.

And again, this is another witch hunt now focusing on dotting "i's" and crossing "t's".

Thanks for playing.

Curious why you think the underwriter/lender would have committed fraud?  What would they have to gain by overvaluing a property that a borrower is using as collateral?
Title: Re: Trump handed a victory in fraud trial
Post by: Flapp_Jackson on October 30, 2023, 06:52:40 PM
Curious why you think the underwriter/lender would have committed fraud?  What would they have to gain by overvaluing a property that a borrower is using as collateral?

Lenders benefit by approving very large loans.  Bank makes more money as do the employees who bring in the big clients.

As long as the borrower doesn't default and pays as agreed, the bank is happy and prosperous.

As for underwriters, the more a property is worth, the higher the coverage needed to insure it.  Insurance is a requirement for borrowing against the property.

The higher the value of the property, the higher the premiums for the insurance company and bonuses for the salesman.

Title: Re: Trump handed a victory in fraud trial
Post by: eyeeatingfish on November 03, 2023, 10:49:19 PM
So ur saying theres a "grace" number given. What is this official number that you think there is? Once u provide this number, we will apply it to how much Trump was off and then determine if fraud was committed.

Then apply this same judgment to everyone who approved the loan cause they too agreed to the figures used.

Cause others agreed to it as well.

ENTIRE POST IS SARCASTIC.

Sent from my SM-G991U using Tapatalk

Grace? No, I am applying a reasonableness standard.
Title: Re: Trump handed a victory in fraud trial
Post by: changemyoil66 on November 04, 2023, 08:40:48 AM
Grace? No, I am applying a reasonableness standard.
Swooooossshhhhhhhh

Sent from my SM-G991U using Tapatalk

Title: Re: Trump handed a victory in fraud trial
Post by: eyeeatingfish on November 04, 2023, 09:57:56 PM
Swooooossshhhhhhhh

Sent from my SM-G991U using Tapatalk

You are swooshing yourself but you don't realize it... does that make it a double swoosh or swoosh squared?
Title: Re: Trump handed a victory in fraud trial
Post by: changemyoil66 on November 05, 2023, 07:55:51 PM
You are swooshing yourself but you don't realize it... does that make it a double swoosh or swoosh squared?
Hahhhhha swooooosshhhh again.

Sent from my SM-G991U using Tapatalk

Title: Re: Trump handed a victory in fraud trial
Post by: changemyoil66 on November 07, 2023, 04:13:18 PM
So someone here didn't answer what's the "grace number" for being off on square footage.  Because the example of going over the speed limit whether 1mph over or 10mph over, both are still illegal.  Today during the Rahimi SCOTUS hearing, the DOJ argued that anyone who breaks the law (in general) is no longer law abiding citizen and should lose their 2a right as they are no longer part of "the people" in the Bill of Rights.  They were then asked what about someone who goes 30mph in a 25mph zone.  Would they also lose their 2A right under the DOJ's agreement?

Another point in the trial, Bidens pick (Jackson) asked the DOJ if there was any laws back then about domestic violence as she thought those law didn't exist.  Well, guess she didn't bother to read the amicus briefs that specifically addressed this, that there were laws.  Guess this is what happens when someone gets the job due to the color of their skin and gender.
Title: Re: Trump handed a victory in fraud trial
Post by: QUIETShooter on November 07, 2023, 06:31:26 PM
No qualifications needed under the biden administration.

Being black helps.
Title: Re: Trump handed a victory in fraud trial
Post by: eyeeatingfish on November 07, 2023, 07:06:19 PM
So someone here didn't answer what's the "grace number" for being off on square footage.

There is no grace number. I already pointed you to the reasonableness standard to address questions like this.

Someone asking for a grace number sounds like someone trying to get out of trouble for something they know they did wrong.
Title: Re: Trump handed a victory in fraud trial
Post by: changemyoil66 on November 07, 2023, 09:07:05 PM
There is no grace number. I already pointed you to the reasonableness standard to address questions like this.

Someone asking for a grace number sounds like someone trying to get out of trouble for something they know they did wrong.
So what # is it reasonable to be off by?

This is whats refered to as a grace number im asking for. As any # not the  correct sqft would be wrong.



Sent from my SM-G991U using Tapatalk

Title: Re: Trump handed a victory in fraud trial
Post by: hvybarrels on November 08, 2023, 08:53:48 AM
The judge and prosecutor were way off on their estimate, which is what makes this trial an obvious political hit job
Title: Re: Trump handed a victory in fraud trial
Post by: changemyoil66 on November 08, 2023, 09:29:55 AM
Reasonable is pretty obvious.   If you are off by a zero or two that's not reasonable.   100mil property vs 1bil. 2ksqft house vs 20k. Etc.

So is off being by up to 9 reasonable?  As being off by 10 adds a zero.
Title: Re: Trump handed a victory in fraud trial
Post by: macsak on November 08, 2023, 10:06:51 AM
let's see if those people who posted how trump was lying and committing fraud will admit that the judge and prosecutor were wr-wr-wr-wrong...

The judge and prosecutor were way off on their estimate, which is what makes this trial an obvious political hit job
Title: Re: Trump handed a victory in fraud trial
Post by: eyeeatingfish on November 09, 2023, 11:13:47 PM
So what # is it reasonable to be off by?

This is whats refered to as a grace number im asking for. As any # not the  correct sqft would be wrong.

Sent from my SM-G991U using Tapatalk

I don't think you can set a specific number and draw the line. It is a case by case basis looking at the totality of the circumstances.

How many rounds can you shoot at someone in self defense before it turns to murder?

I think exaggerating the size or a property by a factor of 3 is way beyond reasonable. If you think that is reasonable then we disagree.
Title: Re: Trump handed a victory in fraud trial
Post by: changemyoil66 on November 10, 2023, 06:22:19 PM
I don't think you can set a specific number and draw the line. It is a case by case basis looking at the totality of the circumstances.

How many rounds can you shoot at someone in self defense before it turns to murder?

I think exaggerating the size or a property by a factor of 3 is way beyond reasonable. If you think that is reasonable then we disagree.
So 2.999999 is acceptable then right?



Sent from my SM-G991U using Tapatalk

Title: Re: Trump handed a victory in fraud trial
Post by: eyeeatingfish on November 10, 2023, 10:52:19 PM
So 2.999999 is acceptable then right?



Sent from my SM-G991U using Tapatalk

You want a line where none can reasonably be drawn without creating a massive bureaucracy.

I suppose though you could make a sliding fine scale. $100 for every % you understate  the size of your property. (for example)
Title: Re: Trump handed a victory in fraud trial
Post by: changemyoil66 on November 11, 2023, 07:24:11 PM
You want a line where none can reasonably be drawn without creating a massive bureaucracy.

I suppose though you could make a sliding fine scale. $100 for every % you understate  the size of your property. (for example)
So ur claim cannot be proved. Got it.

Sent from my SM-G991U using Tapatalk

Title: Re: Trump handed a victory in fraud trial
Post by: eyeeatingfish on November 11, 2023, 08:04:05 PM
So ur claim cannot be proved. Got it.

Sent from my SM-G991U using Tapatalk

I didn't make any claim needing to be proven. I explained that reasonableness should be used as the guide.

I even gave you a way of making a punishment that was proportional to the offense, like a speeding ticket.

Your argument isn't even a serious one. If you had a broken speedometer in your car it would be fair for a judge to give you a break for doing 30 in a 25 school zone, but if you were doing 75 in a school zone then a judge should give you the same break?
Title: Re: Trump handed a victory in fraud trial
Post by: changemyoil66 on December 01, 2023, 08:06:18 PM
I didn't make any claim needing to be proven. I explained that reasonableness should be used as the guide.

I even gave you a way of making a punishment that was proportional to the offense, like a speeding ticket.

Your argument isn't even a serious one. If you had a broken speedometer in your car it would be fair for a judge to give you a break for doing 30 in a 25 school zone, but if you were doing 75 in a school zone then a judge should give you the same break?
Nice goal post moving. I said what does the law say? 1 mph or 70mph is still a law being broken.

Now u talking about getting breaks.

Sent from my SM-G991U using Tapatalk

Title: Re: Trump handed a victory in fraud trial
Post by: changemyoil66 on December 01, 2023, 08:10:25 PM
Deutch bank exec says trump has the strongest personal balance sheet hes ever seen. Hes a good opportunity.

Guess he never verified and just believes everything he sees on paper. Brb looking for my handwritten receipt that says i have $200,000,000,000,000 in 1 of their checking accounts. No need verify right?

Sent from my SM-G991U using Tapatalk

Title: Re: Trump handed a victory in fraud trial
Post by: eyeeatingfish on December 01, 2023, 09:27:20 PM
Nice goal post moving. I said what does the law say? 1 mph or 70mph is still a law being broken.

Now u talking about getting breaks.

Sent from my SM-G991U using Tapatalk

Nuance just swooshed you
Title: Re: Trump handed a victory in fraud trial
Post by: changemyoil66 on December 02, 2023, 07:12:15 PM
Nuance just swooshed you
Still goal post moving. Hahahhaha

Sent from my SM-G991U using Tapatalk

Title: Re: Trump handed a victory in fraud trial
Post by: changemyoil66 on December 02, 2023, 07:12:48 PM
Oops Deutch bank also said they lowered trumps worth by 50% when factoring in the loan.

Sent from my SM-G991U using Tapatalk

Title: Re: Trump handed a victory in fraud trial
Post by: Flapp_Jackson on December 02, 2023, 07:20:39 PM
Oops Deutch bank also said they lowered trumps worth by 50% when factoring in the loan.

They also offered to loan Trump even more money than he requested. 

They testified Trump always paid his loans either according to the terms of sometimes ahead of time.

Title: Re: Trump handed a victory in fraud trial
Post by: groveler on December 02, 2023, 07:37:45 PM
Nice goal post moving. I said what does the law say? 1 mph or 70mph is still a law being broken.

Now u talking about getting breaks.

Sent from my SM-G991U using Tapatalk
one thing most laws don't take into account is intent.
Legally 1 mph over posted limit ( posted limits are arbitrary, decided by engineers like me that ALWAYS take the safe side) is illegal
however did you intend to hurt someone? Probably not.
Laws are supposed to be guidelines not absolute.
Cops that make them absolute are assholes.
That is why nobody likes or trusts them anymore.
We need more Mayberry Sheriffs and fewer Barney Fifes.
 :thumbsup:



Title: Re: Trump handed a victory in fraud trial
Post by: Flapp_Jackson on December 02, 2023, 09:44:53 PM
one thing most laws don't take into account is intent.
Legally 1 mph over posted limit ( posted limits are arbitrary, decided by engineers like me that ALWAYS take the safe side) is illegal
however did you intend to hurt someone? Probably not.
Laws are supposed to be guidelines not absolute.
Cops that make them absolute are assholes.
That is why nobody likes or trusts them anymore.
We need more Mayberry Sheriffs and fewer Barney Fifes.
 :thumbsup:

Traffic laws are a different breed from almost all criminal laws.  Most are treated as civil infractions.  Even insurance companies are less concerned with the lawlessness and only focus on the amount of money you cost them already and whether they can risk you costing them more later.

Most insurance companies used to track you by the points the state issues against your license, with certain increases in premiums wih so many points in a given period. 

in fact, traffic laws have various categories, too.  Speeding or recklessness is serious, but an equipment infraction (no safety inspection, dark window tint, headlight out, tires too wide, etc.) are often treated as a much less serious ticket.

Since we know traffic laws have evolved from being about safety to simply revenue generation for the jurisdiction, It's best to have all your registration, inspection, insurance, tags, stickers and license in order to avoid giving any Cop that stops you cause to see you as anything other than law-abiding.  It amazes me how many people with warrants get caught because of expired tags.

So, as far as intent is concerned, it's a non-issue in traffic court.  However, that doesn't mean you can't present a "guilty with a reason" defense.  A friend convinced the judge that he was just trying to move right into an exit lane, but a huge line of traffic refused to let him in.  He saw a sizable gap ahead, so he sped up to get in line.  That's when the cops lasered him.  The judge bought it and dismissed the ticket.  The cop who was in the courtroom was pissed!  And to piss him off more, my friend asked the judge where he could make a donation to the policeman's assistance fund in the amount of his fine!  LOL!!

So, while the Cops may not care about intent or justifications, you do have the option to try and get a judge to hear it -- away from the tension and stress of a traffic stop next to a busy roadway.


Title: Re: Trump handed a victory in fraud trial
Post by: macsak on December 03, 2023, 01:14:21 PM
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-tG0_baR514
Title: Re: Trump handed a victory in fraud trial
Post by: changemyoil66 on December 03, 2023, 07:33:02 PM
Traffic laws are a different breed from almost all criminal laws.  Most are treated as civil infractions.  Even insurance companies are less concerned with the lawlessness and only focus on the amount of money you cost them already and whether they can risk you costing them more later.

Most insurance companies used to track you by the points the state issues against your license, with certain increases in premiums wih so many points in a given period. 

in fact, traffic laws have various categories, too.  Speeding or recklessness is serious, but an equipment infraction (no safety inspection, dark window tint, headlight out, tires too wide, etc.) are often treated as a much less serious ticket.

Since we know traffic laws have evolved from being about safety to simply revenue generation for the jurisdiction, It's best to have all your registration, inspection, insurance, tags, stickers and license in order to avoid giving any Cop that stops you cause to see you as anything other than law-abiding.  It amazes me how many people with warrants get caught because of expired tags.

So, as far as intent is concerned, it's a non-issue in traffic court.  However, that doesn't mean you can't present a "guilty with a reason" defense.  A friend convinced the judge that he was just trying to move right into an exit lane, but a huge line of traffic refused to let him in.  He saw a sizable gap ahead, so he sped up to get in line.  That's when the cops lasered him.  The judge bought it and dismissed the ticket.  The cop who was in the courtroom was pissed!  And to piss him off more, my friend asked the judge where he could make a donation to the policeman's assistance fund in the amount of his fine!  LOL!!

So, while the Cops may not care about intent or justifications, you do have the option to try and get a judge to hear it -- away from the tension and stress of a traffic stop next to a busy roadway.
So either radaring cops wake up wanting to issue speeding tickets or they are ordered to find people to issue said tickets too.

Not like HI has a traffic problem where people should drive faster. Lame ass HI speed limits of 45-60mph.

Too bad cops cant ticket someone for driving too slow. Like 18 on kapiolani blvd thats 35mph with no cars in front of them.

Sent from my SM-G991U using Tapatalk

Title: Re: Trump handed a victory in fraud trial
Post by: eyeeatingfish on December 03, 2023, 09:49:26 PM
one thing most laws don't take into account is intent.
Legally 1 mph over posted limit ( posted limits are arbitrary, decided by engineers like me that ALWAYS take the safe side) is illegal
however did you intend to hurt someone? Probably not.
Laws are supposed to be guidelines not absolute.
Cops that make them absolute are assholes.
That is why nobody likes or trusts them anymore.
We need more Mayberry Sheriffs and fewer Barney Fifes.
 :thumbsup:

Most, if not all criminal laws, (and I believe traffic laws as well but would have to double check) list a state of mind and "intentionally" is one of the states of mind.

I agree with the second half though, discretion is a very important tool for police to use, try to tailor the action to the offense and the situation. I have seen many times where an officer could have chosen a less punitive action and not doing so, in the end, makes their job harder because they are, in part, creating their own opponents.
Title: Re: Trump handed a victory in fraud trial
Post by: changemyoil66 on December 04, 2023, 08:47:55 AM
Most, if not all criminal laws, (and I believe traffic laws as well but would have to double check) list a state of mind and "intentionally" is one of the states of mind.

I agree with the second half though, discretion is a very important tool for police to use, try to tailor the action to the offense and the situation. I have seen many times where an officer could have chosen a less punitive action and not doing so, in the end, makes their job harder because they are, in part, creating their own opponents.

 HRS134
Title: Re: Trump handed a victory in fraud trial
Post by: Flapp_Jackson on December 04, 2023, 11:13:14 AM
HRS134

Every law that I know of either explicitly states "intent" as an element of the crime within the statute (knowingly, willfully, intentionally, etc.), or it excludes intent by default as not applicable to the charges.

Case in point: the axiom "ignorance of the law is no excuse."  Meaning, you can't use as a defense, "I didn't mean to break the law, because i didn't know it was illegal."

So, no, it's the opposite of what the "expert" here says.  Unless stated, intent is NOT an element of the crime -- ESPECIALLY traffic infractions. 

Does anyone really believe, "I didn't mean to go 15 over the limit," is a viable defense?
Title: Re: Trump handed a victory in fraud trial
Post by: changemyoil66 on December 04, 2023, 11:35:43 AM
Every law that I know of either explicitly states "intent" as an element of the crime within the statute (knowingly, willfully, intentionally, etc.), or it excludes intent by default as not applicable to the charges.

Case in point: the axiom "ignorance of the law is no excuse."  Meaning, you can't use as a defense, "I didn't mean to break the law, because i didn't know it was illegal."

So, no, it's the opposite of what the "expert" here says.  Unless stated, intent is NOT an element of the crime -- ESPECIALLY traffic infractions. 

Does anyone really believe, "I didn't mean to go 15 over the limit," is a viable defense?

Lets see how he weasels his way out of this one. "Most, if not all laws..." was his words. Had he left out "if not all laws" part, then he covered his tracks.  But then gain HRS134 is only 1 section, but it's a lot of subsections. He would then say see, it's only 1 of thousands of laws.
Title: Re: Trump handed a victory in fraud trial
Post by: eyeeatingfish on December 04, 2023, 03:28:08 PM
Every law that I know of either explicitly states "intent" as an element of the crime within the statute (knowingly, willfully, intentionally, etc.), or it excludes intent by default as not applicable to the charges.

Case in point: the axiom "ignorance of the law is no excuse."  Meaning, you can't use as a defense, "I didn't mean to break the law, because i didn't know it was illegal."

So, no, it's the opposite of what the "expert" here says.  Unless stated, intent is NOT an element of the crime -- ESPECIALLY traffic infractions. 

Does anyone really believe, "I didn't mean to go 15 over the limit," is a viable defense?

What part of "I have to double check" don't you understand?

You are really going to try and get gotcha points on a statement I made where I said I wasn't sure about one aspect and would have to check? Surely you can find better things to mentally masturbate over.

Title: Re: Trump handed a victory in fraud trial
Post by: changemyoil66 on December 04, 2023, 04:46:01 PM
What part of "I have to double check" don't you understand?

You are really going to try and get gotcha points on a statement I made where I said I wasn't sure about one aspect and would have to check? Surely you can find better things to mentally masturbate over.


AANNNNDDDD HERE IT IS!!!!!!!!!! Hi Newsom.
Title: Re: Trump handed a victory in fraud trial
Post by: Flapp_Jackson on December 04, 2023, 05:44:47 PM
What part of "I have to double check" don't you understand?

You are really going to try and get gotcha points on a statement I made where I said I wasn't sure about one aspect and would have to check? Surely you can find better things to mentally masturbate over.

Was I talking to you?

#Narcissist
Title: Re: Trump handed a victory in fraud trial
Post by: eyeeatingfish on December 04, 2023, 08:44:53 PM
Was I talking to you?

#Narcissist

Backpedaling I see...
Title: Re: Trump handed a victory in fraud trial
Post by: changemyoil66 on December 05, 2023, 08:41:53 AM
Backpedaling I see...

Says the professional goal post mover.
Title: Re: Trump handed a victory in fraud trial
Post by: Flapp_Jackson on December 05, 2023, 09:58:52 AM
Backpedaling I see...

You can' even post the truthful answer to a simple question.

You know I wasn't.  Yet, here you are -- trying to fill the topic with more back and forth.

I thought you said you weren't going to do anymore of that?
Title: Re: Trump handed a victory in fraud trial
Post by: eyeeatingfish on December 05, 2023, 08:54:44 PM
You can' even post the truthful answer to a simple question.


What question?
I don't lie and you can't prove I do, you just want to pick internet fights, like a troll.
Title: Re: Trump handed a victory in fraud trial
Post by: Flapp_Jackson on December 05, 2023, 08:57:21 PM
What question?
I don't lie and you can't prove I do, you just want to pick internet fights, like a troll.

#Back
#Forth
#Rinse
#Repeat
Title: Re: Trump handed a victory in fraud trial
Post by: ren on December 05, 2023, 08:58:02 PM
MRO!
Title: Re: Trump handed a victory in fraud trial
Post by: Flapp_Jackson on December 05, 2023, 09:01:00 PM
MRO!

Is that a disability?  Are we making fun of that now?

#Classy

 :rofl:
Title: Re: Trump handed a victory in fraud trial
Post by: ren on December 05, 2023, 09:07:26 PM
Is that a disability?  Are we making fun of that now?

#Classy

 :rofl:

ok how about ACOG!
Title: Re: Trump handed a victory in fraud trial
Post by: Flapp_Jackson on December 05, 2023, 09:11:54 PM
ok how about ACOG!

ACOG is singular.  Hence the article "A" at the beginning.

Why buy ACOG when you can buy SOMECOGS?
Title: Re: Trump handed a victory in fraud trial
Post by: ren on December 05, 2023, 09:14:08 PM
ACOG is singular.  Hence the article "A" at the beginning.

Why buy ACOG when you can buy SOMECOGS?

too buku! too buku!