2aHawaii
General Topics => General Discussion => Topic started by: Hunter1007 on January 01, 2013, 04:18:15 PM
-
What are your thoughts on this? Accept a "form" of AWB in return a national and "attainable" CCW permit? Before anyone gets all nuts, this is for disscusion purposes :) Obviously there would have to be concessions on both end but would you be willing to give up on some ground on semiauto rifles limitations for the ability to CCW (not just provisions for but permits granted to qualified citizens) in every state and in the workplace? Could this work out? I'm just looking how both sides could win. What do you guys think?
-
Nope. Would not support.
-
hell no. especially since we can win the CCW war without compromise. illinois's law got struck down, ours will too, some day.
national reciprocity is already in the works, we could theoretically just get an out of state permit somewhere else, and then legally be able to carry in hawaii, all while the police chief can go and deal with it.
-
hell no. especially since we can win the CCW war without compromise. illinois's law got struck down, ours will too, some day.
national reciprocity is already in the works, we could theoretically just get an out of state permit somewhere else, and then legally be able to carry in hawaii, all while the police chief can go and deal with it.
Absolutely agree :)
-
hell no. especially since we can win the CCW war without compromise. illinois's law got struck down, ours will too, some day.
national reciprocity is already in the works, we could theoretically just get an out of state permit somewhere else, and then legally be able to carry in hawaii, all while the police chief can go and deal with it.
That will never happen. The federal government will never tell the individual states to honor another state CCW. It's against the 10th amendment.
-
That will never happen. The federal government will never tell the individual states to honor another state CCW. It's against the 10th amendment.
and yet, it was being worked on by congress last year before all of this garbage.
whatever. either way, we have a far better chance of defeating draconian CCW laws on our own than we do of getting rid of a fucktarded AWB that passes.
-
No comprimise should be done. It is a right.
-
Yeah, I can see it go just like the fiscal cliff talks; AWB now then we'll do the national CCW later...
Its an interesting suggestion but not realistic. Liberals idea of compromise is doing exactly what they want and giving up your rights and hard earned money.
-
Oh hell no. Military style weapons are here for our freedom.
-
No comprimise should be done. It is a right.
CCW is not a right, it's a privilege. The sooner everyone accepts that fact the sooner it will become a reality.
-
CCW is not a right, it's a privilege. The sooner everyone accepts that fact the sooner it will become a reality.
Owning firearms IS a right.
Whether, semi auto or bolt action, lever action, single shot, rifles, shotguns, pistols, etc...
It is a constitutional right set in place to protect the people against a government that becomes oppressive, as it is becoming.
-
CCW is not a right, it's a privilege. The sooner everyone accepts that fact the sooner it will become a reality.
Some form of carry is a right. If open carry is allowed, then yes, CCW could be considered an additional privilege. However, if what you're saying is that carrying a firearm outside the home is a privilege, you couldn't be more wrong. There is no way to divorce 'keep' and 'bear' in the context of the Second Amendment. If the 2A protects an individual right to have firearms, then it also must protect a right to carry them. Even Sarah Brady knows that, which is why the anti-gunners are so enamored with the idea of interpreting 2A as protecting a general right of states to maintain militias, instead of protecting individuals' rights.
-
Simply put - no. We won't need to negotiate carry, we know that there is a right outside of the home, and the court cases are in line to prove so.
-
CCW is not a right, it's a privilege. The sooner everyone accepts that fact the sooner it will become a reality.
Factually incorrect. The right to bear arms is the right to carry a weapon for confrontation. The sooner we get rid of attitudes and thoughts like this, the more the reality will sink in.
-
Factually incorrect. The right to bear arms is the right to carry a weapon for confrontation.
So where is the factual proof? There is none, if it was fact, all states would allow CCW without restrictions, which they don't. So as of right now, no matter which way you try to argue against it, my statement is factually correct.
-
………………..,-~*’`¯lllllll`*~,
…………..,-~*`lllllllllllllllllllllllllll…
………,-~*lllllllllllllllllllllllllllllll…
……,-*lllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllll…
….;*`lllllllllllllllllllllllllll,-~*~-…
…..\lllllllllllllllllllllllllll/………\;;…
…...\lllllllllllllllllllll,-*………..`~-~…
…….\llllllllllll,-~*…………………)_-\..*`*;.…
……..\,-*`¯,*`)…………,-~*`~.………….../
……...|/.../…/~,…...-~*,-~*`;……………./.\
……../.../…/…/..,-,..*~,.`*~*…………….*...…
…….|.../…/…/.*`...\...……………………)….)¯`~,
…….|./…/…./…….)……,.)`*~-,……….../….|..)…
……/./.../…,*`-,…..`-,…*`….,---…...\…./…
…...(……….)`*~-,….`*`.,-~*.,-*……|…/.…/……
…….*-,…….`*-,...`~,..``.,,,-*……….|.,*.…
……….*,………`-,…)-,……… …..,-* `...,-*….(`-,...
-
No comprimise should be done. It is a right.
I agree. Why people would willingly give up their rights, or a portion thereof, is beyond me.
So where is the factual proof? There is none, if it was fact, all states would allow CCW without restrictions, which they don't. So as of right now, no matter which way you try to argue against it, my statement is factually correct.
Acceptance of the status quo is what you are seeing there, IMO. Laws or even implementations of laws or policies are being followed that impose restrictions on rights to carry a firearm, concealed or otherwise.
-
Nope. Would not support.
Same here. I see the need for an AR far more than CCW.
-
So where is the factual proof? There is none, if it was fact, all states would allow CCW without restrictions, which they don't. So as of right now, no matter which way you try to argue against it, my statement is factually correct.
This is so full of fail it's hilarious. If legislatures passed nothing but good, constitutional laws, why would we need a judiciary to act as a balance against their power? By your logic, the government can ship you to an internment camp any time they feel like it, because they did it before, and the state and federal governments never do anything to impinge on the rights of the citizenry.
-
CCW is not a right, it's a privilege. The sooner everyone accepts that fact the sooner it will become a reality.
That is the dumbest statement I heard in a long time of course concealed carry is a right as evident by the fifth Court of Appeals overturning Illinois bad on ccw I suspect we'll see the same thing with the California
then hawaii ....Its true however the opinion that open carry or concealed carry it doesn't have to be both
-
CCW is not a right, it's a privilege. The sooner everyone accepts that fact the sooner it will become a reality.
Never thought I'd hear this from someone on this forum.
-
Never thought I'd hear this from someone on this forum.
Successful troll is successful?
-
That is the dumbest statement I heard in a long time of course concealed carry is a right as evident by the fifth Court of Appeals overturning Illinois bad on ccw I suspect we'll see the same thing with the California
then hawaii ....Its true however the opinion that open carry or concealed carry it doesn't have to be both
5th circuit has nothing to do with us. We are in the 9th circuit. Still no proof.
-
5th circuit has nothing to do with us. We are in the 9th circuit. Still no proof.
Is it your considered opinion that anything Hawaii does must be constitutional?
-
Is it your considered opinion that anything Hawaii does must be constitutional?
No. But we belong to the 9 circuit which is the most restrictive circuit in the union. Also Hawaii in general will never allow CCW, we can't even register our guns at different places.
-
No. But we belong to the 9 circuit which is the most restrictive circuit in the union. Also Hawaii in general will never allow CCW, we can't even register our guns at different places.
Hawaii will be dragged into compliance with the Constitution, kicking and screaming, but in compliance nonetheless. Illinois just did, and they're worse than Hawaii.
-
Hawaii will be dragged into compliance with the Constitution, kicking and screaming, but in compliance nonetheless. Illinois just did, and they're worse than Hawaii.
Haha. Highly doubt that. Hawaii will make it so restrictive to obtain a CCW that it will be reserved for the select few. HPD just recently established a policy that their retired officers can now carry CCW. The retired officers have to fork out about $200 a year just to qualify and get certified by the AG office. These are seasoned officers that already have use of force training and are educated in state and constitutional law.
Everyone is saying that the system is broken and CCW is unconstitutional. No one is proposing solutions to the problem. CCW applicants will likely have to accomplish training like state law requirements, weapon qualification, medical review, psychological review, use of force in relation to state law, weapon retention, and handgun safety to name a few. All of this will be required at the applicants cost and may be required annually as CCW permits expire annually. Can you imagine what it will cost to obtain and maintain a CCW permit?
These are some of the things the legislature looks at. If there is not a viable process in place or a proposal to accomplish the process they will just shelf the bill for the next year.
Some say I'm just trolling, I say I'm just encouraging debate on the issue. A criminology professor many years ago said in order to find a solution to a problem you must debate the cons and turn them into pros so your opponents have nothing to argue.
-
negotiating is something you do when you feel like you're already losing. way too early.
-
negotiating is something you do when you feel like you're already losing. way too early.
If everyone adopts that ideal you will never get CCW! If its all or nothing be prepared to get nothing.
-
Haha. Highly doubt that. Hawaii will make it so restrictive to obtain a CCW that it will be reserved for the select few. HPD just recently established a policy that their retired officers can now carry CCW. The retired officers have to fork out about $200 a year just to qualify and get certified by the AG office. These are seasoned officers that already have use of force training and are educated in state and constitutional law.
Everyone is saying that the system is broken and CCW is unconstitutional. No one is proposing solutions to the problem. CCW applicants will likely have to accomplish training like state law requirements, weapon qualification, medical review, psychological review, use of force in relation to state law, weapon retention, and handgun safety to name a few. All of this will be required at the applicants cost and may be required annually as CCW permits expire annually. Can you imagine what it will cost to obtain and maintain a CCW permit?
These are some of the things the legislature looks at. If there is not a viable process in place or a proposal to accomplish the process they will just shelf the bill for the next year.
Some say I'm just trolling, I say I'm just encouraging debate on the issue. A criminology professor many years ago said in order to find a solution to a problem you must debate the cons and turn them into pros so your opponents have nothing to argue.
That's how it is now. It won't happen quickly, but the Supreme Court will soon rule that the Second Amendment protects a right to carry firearms outside the home. Once they do, say goodbye to may-issue and high fees. I'm not a constitutional law professor, but I'm pretty sure that governments are prohibited from charging exorbitant fees to engage in protected conduct. For example, although it costs money to obtain an ID, a government can force you to have one in order to vote because the cost is minimal. It would be unconstitutional outright if that government then charged hundreds of dollars for an ID as a means to discourage voting. The same will go for carry permits. The state will be forced to adopt a standard with only reasonable fees related to the issuance of the permit.
-
If everyone adopts that ideal you will never get CCW! If its all or nothing be prepared to get nothing.
This is not something that needs to be left to the voters of this state. It was decided when the Second Amendment was ratified, and we got everything. Now it's just a matter of rolling back unconstitutional infringements, and if the general public in Hawaii doesn't like it, they're welcome to secede.
-
Haha. Highly doubt that. Hawaii will make it so restrictive to obtain a CCW that it will be reserved for the select few. HPD just recently established a policy that their retired officers can now carry CCW. The retired officers have to fork out about $200 a year just to qualify and get certified by the AG office. These are seasoned officers that already have use of force training and are educated in state and constitutional law.
Everyone is saying that the system is broken and CCW is unconstitutional. No one is proposing solutions to the problem. CCW applicants will likely have to accomplish training like state law requirements, weapon qualification, medical review, psychological review, use of force in relation to state law, weapon retention, and handgun safety to name a few. All of this will be required at the applicants cost and may be required annually as CCW permits expire annually. Can you imagine what it will cost to obtain and maintain a CCW permit?
These are some of the things the legislature looks at. If there is not a viable process in place or a proposal to accomplish the process they will just shelf the bill for the next year.
Some say I'm just trolling, I say I'm just encouraging debate on the issue. A criminology professor many years ago said in order to find a solution to a problem you must debate the cons and turn them into pros so your opponents have nothing to argue.
would YOU mind bringing some proof? you're just ranting.
and lol, Hawaii already MADE it so restrictive. that's the whole basis of the lawsuit.
-
That's how it is now. It won't happen quickly, but the Supreme Court will soon rule that the Second Amendment protects a right to carry firearms outside the home. Once they do, say goodbye to may-issue and high fees. I'm not a constitutional law professor, but I'm pretty sure that governments are prohibited from charging exorbitant fees to engage in protected conduct. For example, although it costs money to obtain an ID, a government can force you to have one in order to vote because the cost is minimal. It would be unconstitutional outright if that government then charged hundreds of dollars for an ID as a means to discourage voting. The same will go for carry permits. The state will be forced to adopt a standard with only reasonable fees related to the issuance of the permit.
The kicker is that the government won't offer the classes. You have to get the classes accomplished on your own by a recognized company or foundation. It is the private company or foundation that will charge the crazy fees because they can. Look at the handgun safety classes. $200-$250 for a hand gun safety class. Now just imaging when you add the other mandated classes and medical reviews. I'm thinking at least $1000 before the AG qualification fees.
-
would YOU mind bringing some proof? you're just ranting.
and lol, Hawaii already MADE it so restrictive. that's the whole basis of the lawsuit.
Really. It that the best response you can come up with?
-
Really. It that the best response you can come up with?
its just as useful as any of yours.
-
Look at the handgun safety classes. $200-$250 for a hand gun safety class
its like 150 at OGC and free if you take the hunters course.
nice research.
-
The kicker is that the government won't offer the classes. You have to get the classes accomplished on your own by a recognized company or foundation. It is the private company or foundation that will charge the crazy fees because they can. Look at the handgun safety classes. $200-$250 for a hand gun safety class. Now just imaging when you add the other mandated classes and medical reviews. I'm thinking at least $1000 before the AG qualification fees.
Two questions: Who is chargin that much for a handgun safety class, and at that price, could I have a job? HDF's going rate last time I knew was just over a hundred bucks. The state already mandates mental health screenings as part of the permit to acquire. How much does that cost? $16.25 once? I'm having a hard time figuring out how you're getting to $1,000.
-
Two questions: Who is chargin that much for a handgun safety class, and at that price, could I have a job? HDF's going rate last time I knew was just over a hundred bucks. The state already mandates mental health screenings as part of the permit to acquire. How much does that cost? $16.25 once? I'm having a hard time figuring out how you're getting to $1,000.
I'm already succeeding in what I set out to do. Haha. You are doing the research in to it. That's the first step. Being educated.
its like 150 at OGC and free if you take the hunters course.
nice research.
If you do your research into my previous posts I have been telling everyone about the hunters Ed for months. I took it 15 years ago and that's how I bought my first handgun. Refer to my previous comment. LOL
-
I'm already succeeding in what I set out to do. Haha. You are doing the research in to it. That's the first step. Being educated.
If you do your research into my previous posts I have been telling everyone about the hunters Ed for months. I took it 15 years ago and that's how I bought my first handgun. Refer to my previous comment. LOL
So your goal this entire time has been to pull things out of your ass, then have them shot to pieces and pretend you're provoking deep thought? I haven't so much as googled, this is all off the top of my head, but I suppose it may be informational for some of our newer members.
-
I'm already succeeding in what I set out to do. Haha. You are doing the research in to it. That's the first step. Being educated.
If you do your research into my previous posts I have been telling everyone about the hunters Ed for months. I took it 15 years ago and that's how I bought my first handgun. Refer to my previous comment. LOL
no one's doing any research. everyone here pretty much already owns a firearm, we KNOW how much it costs. dont flatter yourself.
refer to your previous comment? ok, who's charging 200 or 250 for a class?
you're ranting.
-
So your goal this entire time has been to pull things out of your ass, then have them shot to pieces and pretend you're provoking deep thought? I haven't so much as googled, this is all off the top of my head, but I suppose it may be informational for some of our newer members.
of course, anyone who's done the permit process knows this already. and anyone who doesnt know didnt need this other guy ranting about how CCW is a privilege and will never happen, or will cost 1000 bucks to figure it out.
-
of course, anyone who's done the permit process knows this already. and anyone who doesnt know didnt need this other guy ranting about how CCW is a privilege and will never happen, or will cost 1000 bucks to figure it out.
Concur. I think he knows his original statement was asinine, and now he's trying to spin it as a devil's advocate thought experiment.
-
Concur. I think he knows his original statement was asinine, and now he's trying to spin it as a devil's advocate thought experiment.
->Yeah, next year, we're gonna have to pay 100 bucks to take a rifle safety course every year to get long gun permits!
->that's stupid
->See, i made you do research!
-
of course, anyone who's done the permit process knows this already. and anyone who doesnt know didnt need this other guy ranting about how CCW is a privilege and will never happen, or will cost 1000 bucks to figure it out.
What you don't realize is CCW is not going to be like applying for a permit to purchase. There will be other requirements added. That's where the cost will sky rocket. If you look at it from a different stand point. Owning a gun is also a privilege, go commit a crime and see if you can still own a gun. That "right" is now revoked. So is it really a "right"? Nope...
-
What you don't realize is CCW is not going to be like applying for a permit to purchase. There will be other requirements added. That's where the cost will sky rocket. If you look at it from a different stand point. Owning a gun is also a privilege, go commit a crime and see if you can still own a gun. That "right" is now revoked. So is it really a "right"? Nope...
got a source? of course not. because its you ranting.
Jesus, cmon, i'd even take some of Speedtek's tin foil hat links.
-
What you don't realize is CCW is not going to be like applying for a permit to purchase. There will be other requirements added. That's where the cost will sky rocket. If you look at it from a different stand point. Owning a gun is also a privilege, go commit a crime and see if you can still own a gun. That "right" is now revoked. So is it really a "right"? Nope...
Walking around a free man is a privilege, go commit a crime and see if you can still meet your friends at Starbucks. So is it really a "right"?
Voting is a privilege, go commit a crime and see if you can still vote. So is it really a "right"?
Breathing is a privilege, kill someone in Texas and see if you can go on living. So is it really a "right"?
-
I say no to an AWB ban in exchange for national CCW. Why must WE compromise with the intolerant, gun hating left? Why can't we have BOTH? I say push for a national CCW AND assault weapons ownership.
More guns equals less crime. Just read John Lott's study on the matter.
As for those saying we're going to be following Illinois, you do realize the 9th circuit court is the MOST liberal, right? The day they grant CCW to the western portion of the US is the day this state has two Republican Senators and Congressmen.
-
I say no to an AWB ban in exchange for national CCW. Why must WE compromise with the intolerant, gun hating left? Why can't we have BOTH? I say push for a national CCW AND assault weapons ownership.
More guns equals less crime. Just read John Lott's study on the matter.
As for those saying we're going to be following Illinois, you do realize the 9th circuit court is the MOST liberal, right? The day they grant CCW to the western portion of the US is the day this state has two Republican Senators and Congressmen.
If you're right, and you probably are, it will mean a circuit split, which dramatically improves the odds that SCOTUS will hear one of the carry cases currently working their way up. With the current composition of Justices, it seems pretty likely that they'll rule that the 2A protects an individual right to carry firearms for self defense. And then we're done.
-
SNIP
More guns equals less crime. Just read John Lott's study on the matter.
Off topic, but what happened to that dude's eyebrows? Looks like he has some scars up there. ???
-
With the current composition of Justices
That's the issue, isn't it? With Obama in another 4 years, it's highly likely that one or more Justices will be stepping down from the SCOTUS. If it's Scalia or Thomas, you can bet Obummer will nominate a radical progressive like himself. And do you actually think the GOP will show some balls and fight whomever he nominates? Look how that turned out with Sotomayor and Kagan! I mean, Jesus Christ, people! Sotomayor was RECORDED saying that laws are made from the bench! She admitted that she was/is an activist judge. Did that stop morons like Lindsey Graham from giving her the okay?
-
That's the issue, isn't it? With Obama in another 4 years, it's highly likely that one or more Justices will be stepping down from the SCOTUS. If it's Scalia or Thomas, you can bet Obummer will nominate a radical progressive like himself. And do you actually think the GOP will show some balls and fight whomever he nominates? Look how that turned out with Sotomayor and Kagan! I mean, Jesus Christ, people! Sotomayor was RECORDED saying that laws are made from the bench! She admitted that she was/is an activist judge. Did that stop morons like Lindsey Graham from giving her the okay?
Which is why it's important that we get a case in front of them before any of the conservative justices get a chance to retire or die. After Obama gets to nominate one of their replacements, all bets are off.