2aHawaii
General Topics => Legal and Activism => Topic started by: MDS on May 05, 2013, 08:03:30 PM
-
Wish I could be there for this -
http://www.salon.com/2013/05/03/a_march_on_washington_with_loaded_rifles/ (http://www.salon.com/2013/05/03/a_march_on_washington_with_loaded_rifles/)
Edited to add the following link which was only available after the first page of comments were made based on the above link of an incomplete article on the matter.
The following link contains a video containing the organizers own words on the matter -
http://www.infowars.com/special-report-talk-show-host-calls-for-armed-march-on-d-c-plans-to-overthrow-government/ (http://www.infowars.com/special-report-talk-show-host-calls-for-armed-march-on-d-c-plans-to-overthrow-government/)
-
What a dumb idea. Like the secret service is actually going to let a 1000 people, with loaded rifles, walk past the White House.
-
trying to hold "the shot heard round the world 2.0"
What a dumb idea. Like the secret service is actually going to let a 1000 people, with loaded rifles, walk past the White House.
-
What a dumb idea. Like the secret service is actually going to let a 1000 people, with loaded rifles, walk past the White House.
"Should we meet physical resistance, we will peacefully turn back, having shown that free people are not welcome in Washington"
It helps to read the full article when commenting on something, liberal reading habits typically prove passé.
George Washington walked freely amongst an armed Militia - the difference in DC between yesterday’s men and today... scoundrels. :thumbsup:
-
"Should we meet physical resistance, we will peacefully turn back, having shown that free people are not welcome in Washington"
It helps to read the full article when commenting on something, liberal reading habits typically prove passé.
George Washington walked freely amongst an armed Militia - the difference in DC between yesterday’s men and today... scoundrels. :thumbsup:
its still a dumb idea that will vilify gun owners, imo.
-
its still a dumb idea that will vilify gun owners, imo.
Better to just hide our arms in closets, write to blind represenatives and petition a disjointed scrutiny judiciary? We’ve tried that the past 40+ years and as you can clearly see through recent events… it doesn't work well and it's only getting worse. The NRA and others are now adding to the approach to put our second amendment NATURAL rights back in place. There will be more action occurring now, get used to it. As the old saying goes, “Lead, follow or get the hell out of the way”. It doesn’t surprise me, it was the 3% that gave us our freedom and it will be the 3% that get it back. (III) :shaka:
-
They don't even let people stop to tie their shoe on The Hill right now.
Seriously. True story. From about 5 months ago.
Buddy of mine was in D.C. for work and walking around The Hill with a couple other people. They stopped as one needed to tie her shoe and before she had even started tying it a guard with an assault rifle (NOT an "assault weapon") told them to keep moving. No stopping. Keep moving. When she protested that she needed to tie her shoe the guy just apologized and repeated that she needed to keep moving.
Yep. Land of the free (to keep moving) and home of the brave (guards with automatic weapons.)
So... yeah. This is a ~really~ stupid idea. The concept is good but they shouldn't be doing it illegally and they shouldn't be doing it in D.C. No one other than the choir will have any sympathy when these armed folks get stopped by even more heavily armed folks and either arrested or told to leave. It is too likely that no good will come of it. This isn't strategic thinking, this is stupid publicity stunt.
-
I see this ending very badly for them. Think of the ramifications if just ONE of those guys decides that day is a great day to become that guy. Protests are not a bad thing, but this isn't they way to make your point. This guy was kicked out of the Marines for being to politically active regarding war (which makes one wonder why in the hell he joined the Marines if he is against war). He has a radio show that is funded by the Russians. He seems to be okay with taking on the government with violence...I just don't see this ending well for those folks. Not to mention, how bad that will make all of us 2A supporting, gun loving Americans look. We will all be labeled "crazy" or worse...
I am upset about the way my amazing country is being torn apart by the politicians in D.C., but there are better ways (and more stable folks to lead this movement) than a march with loaded "scary, black assault weapons" towards the white house...
But hey, that is just my two cents.
-
http://koehlerlaw.net/drug-offense/weapons/carrying-a-rifle-or-shotgun-in-d-c/ (http://koehlerlaw.net/drug-offense/weapons/carrying-a-rifle-or-shotgun-in-d-c/)
What they are proposing is a felony. Any bets they won't get 1000 potential felons to give up their gun rights?
"In order to secure a conviction for Carrying a Rifle or Shotgun as a misdemeanor in Washington, D.C., the government must prove beyond a reasonable doubt that: (1) the defendant carried a rifle or shotgun on or about his/her person, (2) the defendant did so voluntarily and on purpose, and not by mistake or accident; and (3) the defendant was not permitted by law to do so.
In order to prove this offense as a felony, the government must also prove that the defendant carried the rifle or shotgun in a place other than his/her home, place of business, or land/premises possessed and controlled by the defendant."
Sure is a good way to prove the point about how law abiding most gun owners are, don't you think?
-
The mother of bad ideas
-
Admittedly my first thought was, “why the hell in DC”? DC didn’t pass the proposed control crap, so the system (though clearly damaged) still managed to protect the 2nd on the most recent 2nd amendment assault. I also immediately thought what a potential cluster f of a mess. For me; there’s a part within that admires the proposed demonstration and another at the same moment that is damn concerned about it being a problem.
July 4th is pretty far off still and any number of things could redirect the event. He may never reach his goal participant wise then again - he may get double or triple+ his goal (this will be interesting to see). In the meanwhile, the concerns just expressed above in the thread could be shared with the organizer. Perhaps redirect his course in another direction/elsewhere, etc. I will add that we cannot stop moving forward on this issue. We can’t allow our concerns to wane because the DC bill was snuffed out this time. We all know damn good and well that if we move on, they will come back with the same proposals again and eventually they will get something though. We need to push back the already advanced legislation in States/etc, we need to make sure this doesn’t happen again within the next 30 or 40 years.
-
people are going to chicken out as the day nears
and more are going to chicken out on that day when they see how few people show up
that will leave a core group of nutjobs
who will say stupid stuff on the news
and then will resist when they are repelled or arrested
all it will take is one cop or protester losing their cool or even a backfire or firecracker and it's going to be a bloodbath
Admittedly my first thought was, “why the hell in DC”? DC didn’t pass the proposed control crap, so the system (though clearly damaged) still managed to protect the 2nd on the most recent 2nd amendment assault. I also immediately thought what a potential cluster f of a mess. For me; there’s a part within that admires the proposed demonstration and another at the same moment that is damn concerned about it being a problem.
July 4th is pretty far off still and any number of things could redirect the event. He may never reach his goal participant wise then again - he may get double or triple+ his goal (this will be interesting to see). In the meanwhile, the concerns just expressed above in the thread could be shared with the organizer. Perhaps redirect his course in another direction/elsewhere, etc. I will add that we cannot stop moving forward on this issue. We can’t allow our concerns to wane because the DC bill was snuffed out this time. We all know damn good and well that if we move on, they will come back with the same proposals again and eventually they will get something though. We need to push back the already advanced legislation in States/etc, we need to make sure this doesn’t happen again within the next 30 or 40 years.
-
people are going to chicken out as the day nears
and more are going to chicken out on that day when they see how few people show up
that will leave a core group of nutjobs
who will say stupid stuff on the news
and then will resist when they are repelled or arrested
all it will take is one cop or protester losing their cool or even a backfire or firecracker and it's going to be a bloodbath
They may arrest him long before the demonstration. My guess is, he'll be in jail before July 4th.
-
What if they marched with something more symbolic like muzzle loaders? Do they fall under the same category as shotguns and rifles? It would seem to me that if legal, it would send a stronger message.
-
If I had received an unsolicited email "invitation" to participate in this fiasco, I would have turned it in to the authorities. Since it's all over the internet, they know already. It's a terrible idea, and this guy (and these types of "ideas") make us normal folks look bad. At first, I thought this was some kind of comedy routine. I do hope "someone" doesn't let this come to pass. Why don't they just march with signs, after applying for a parade permit, or what ever kind of clearance a group must get to legally do something like this w/ these proposed numbers of people.
I'll read more, but at first reading, he's whako with a computer, radio show, and unfortunately, a gun. He sounds like the poster child for the "other side".
-
Unfortunately the pots begining to boil now. There's stuff going on all across the nation now on these matters and the above planed march is merely one of many liketype to come demonstrations across the nation. Check out Glenn Becks link preparing himself for what he see's coming now -
http://www.glennbeck.com/content/articles/article/198/39452/ (http://www.glennbeck.com/content/articles/article/198/39452/)
-
Unfortunately the pots begining to boil now. There's stuff going on all across the nation now on these matters and the above planed march is merely one of many liketype to come demonstrations across the nation. Check out Glenn Becks link preparing himself for what he see's coming now -
http://www.glennbeck.com/content/articles/article/198/39452/ (http://www.glennbeck.com/content/articles/article/198/39452/)
I don't always agree with glenn's social conservative points, but Ill be damned if he isn't an excellent speaker, smart, and articulate. He's a real conservative powerhouse.
-
From the mouth of the organizer of the March on Washington. He makes it pretty damn clear that if they aren't welcomed with police escort, that will be the end of it, less the fact they will have proven that Obama and local Police are "Oath Breakers" and not "Oath Keepers". The guy sounds fine to me with regard to his said plans. Let's see if it happens.
http://www.infowars.com/special-report-talk-show-host-calls-for-armed-march-on-d-c-plans-to-overthrow-government/ (http://www.infowars.com/special-report-talk-show-host-calls-for-armed-march-on-d-c-plans-to-overthrow-government/)
This is actually a chance for Obama to save a little face... put forth an official invitation to make the march and if Obama really wanted to save more face, he'd greet them in DC. But that won't happen, he's neither the balls or moral backbone to do such a thing.
-
I don't always agree with glenn's social conservative points, but Ill be damned if he isn't an excellent speaker, smart, and articulate. He's a real conservative powerhouse.
I don't always agree with him and or others either, but I do agree with enough of it to listen to them (mostly conservatives these days). I'm not pure conservative nor pure liberal but I damn well sure am a backer of the peoples natural rights and AGAINST any damn invasions thereof, I see such invasions as tyranny (there's been far too damn much of that lately).
-
From the mouth of the organizer of the March on Washington. He makes it pretty damn clear that if they aren't welcomed with police escort, that will be the end of it, less the fact they will have proven that Obama and local Police are "Oath Breakers" and not "Oath Keepers". The guy sounds fine to me with regard to his said plans. Let's see if it happens.
http://www.infowars.com/special-report-talk-show-host-calls-for-armed-march-on-d-c-plans-to-overthrow-government/ (http://www.infowars.com/special-report-talk-show-host-calls-for-armed-march-on-d-c-plans-to-overthrow-government/)
This is actually a chance for Obama to save a little face... put forth an official invitation to make the march and if Obama really wanted to save more face, he'd greet them in DC. But that won't happen, he's neither the balls or moral backbone to do such a thing.
Anyone care to weigh in on this plan and First Ammendment rights? Should these guys have the RIGHT to do this?
-
Anyone care to weigh in on this plan and First Ammendment rights? Should these guys have the RIGHT to do this?
I don't see any difference between a gun owner marching with loaded firearms in a peaceful protest and Martin Luther King, Jr. holding a sit-in protest where they are breaking laws by trespassing or going where Blacks were not permitted.
Civil disobedience is an American tradition. Walking with loaded firearms where (potentially unconstitutional) laws prohibit it does not equal violence. No difference in my mind.
-
people are going to chicken out as the day nears
and more are going to chicken out on that day when they see how few people show up
that will leave a core group of nutjobs
who will say stupid stuff on the news
and then will resist when they are repelled or arrested
all it will take is one cop or protester losing their cool or even a backfire or firecracker and it's going to be a bloodbath
^^^ this
all it takes is one.
-
According to the Constitution under the first and second amendments they already have the right to make the march. I would also agree that anyone who supposedly stands for these rights and considers the marchers effort to be foolish to be a person of (I’ll respectfully label it as) internal “incongruity”. IMO… they should have the RIGHT and already do have the RIGHT.
-
According to the Constitution under the first and second amendments they already have the right to make the march. I would also agree that anyone who supposedly stands for these rights and considers the marchers effort to be foolish to be a person of (I’ll respectfully label it as) internal “incongruity”. IMO… they should have the RIGHT and already do have the RIGHT.
Well, the laws and courts of the land would disagree with you on that but you are certainly welcome to your interpretation of the Constitution.
Just for the sake of it, nowhere does the Constitution specify that the rights stipulated in the Bill of Rights are "God Given" or "Inalienable." Those words came from other documents and writings of the Founding Fathers and have no relevance to the Constitution or to its interpretation. No matter how many people think so the courts have historically and consistently disagreed. The fact that we have a host of legal gun laws that greatly "infringe" on our "right" to keep and bear arms is ample evidence of this.
Those who think the Constitution is some kind of absolute that will protect them are ignoring 200+ years of legal precedents, laws and policies that prove otherwise.
That seems (to put it mildly) internally incongruent.
Anyone who participates in that march as it is currently planned will be guilty of knowingly committing a felony according to local law and any prosecutor will have no problem proving it in court. "But the Constitution says.....!" is a legal defense that hasn't worked in all but a handful of very specific cases.
While the concept of breaking unjust laws in order to highlight how unjust they are is well known and effective, it is only effective if the vast majority of people agree that it is unjust. That is not the case in the US right now concerning the right to bear arms. The best that can happen with this march is that they are politely asked by LEO's to not cross the bridge and they call it off. The worst is... quite a bit worse.
-
NM
-
Well, the laws and courts of the land would disagree with you on that but you are certainly welcome to your interpretation of the Constitution.
Just for the sake of it, nowhere does the Constitution specify that the rights stipulated in the Bill of Rights are "God Given" or "Inalienable." Those words came from other documents and writings of the Founding Fathers and have no relevance to the Constitution or to its interpretation. No matter how many people think so the courts have historically and consistently disagreed. The fact that we have a host of legal gun laws that greatly "infringe" on our "right" to keep and bear arms is ample evidence of this.
Those who think the Constitution is some kind of absolute that will protect them are ignoring 200+ years of legal precedents, laws and policies that prove otherwise.
That seems (to put it mildly) internally incongruent.
Anyone who participates in that march as it is currently planned will be guilty of knowingly committing a felony according to local law and any prosecutor will have no problem proving it in court. "But the Constitution says.....!" is a legal defense that hasn't worked in all but a handful of very specific cases.
While the concept of breaking unjust laws in order to highlight how unjust they are is well known and effective, it is only effective if the vast majority of people agree that it is unjust. That is not the case in the US right now concerning the right to bear arms. The best that can happen with this march is that they are politely asked by LEO's to not cross the bridge and they call it off. The worst is... quite a bit worse.
Do you think this may have been the case at some previous point in history? Like say around 1776 or so?
-
Well, the laws and courts of the land would disagree with you on that but you are certainly welcome to your interpretation of the Constitution.
Just for the sake of it, nowhere does the Constitution specify that the rights stipulated in the Bill of Rights are "God Given" or "Inalienable." Those words came from other documents and writings of the Founding Fathers and have no relevance to the Constitution or to its interpretation. No matter how many people think so the courts have historically and consistently disagreed. The fact that we have a host of legal gun laws that greatly "infringe" on our "right" to keep and bear arms is ample evidence of this.
Those who think the Constitution is some kind of absolute that will protect them are ignoring 200+ years of legal precedents, laws and policies that prove otherwise.
That seems (to put it mildly) internally incongruent.
Anyone who participates in that march as it is currently planned will be guilty of knowingly committing a felony according to local law and any prosecutor will have no problem proving it in court. "But the Constitution says.....!" is a legal defense that hasn't worked in all but a handful of very specific cases.
While the concept of breaking unjust laws in order to highlight how unjust they are is well known and effective, it is only effective if the vast majority of people agree that it is unjust. That is not the case in the US right now concerning the right to bear arms. The best that can happen with this march is that they are politely asked by LEO's to not cross the bridge and they call it off. The worst is... quite a bit worse.
Rights are, by definition, granted by nature (God, what have you), and are neither capable of being bestowed nor taken away from men and women by any government.
"Legal rights" are derived from the higher level rights bestowed by nature. For example, the right to life gives rise to the right to keep and bear arms. It is one's natural and unalienable right to protect one's own life, and therefore the right to use arms in the protection of one's life falls naturally under the same right.
To argue the categorization of the items listed the the Bill of Rights is counter-productive. They are RIGHTS. The wording in the Constitution, "the RIGHT to keep and bear arms shall not be infringed, " is indisputable. Whether you wish to argue the right is one endowed by our creator, or a legal right which stems from such a natural right is irrelevant.
We hold these truths to be self-evident, that all men are created equal, that they are endowed by their Creator with certain unalienable Rights, that among these are Life, Liberty and the pursuit of Happiness.
The key phrase here is "among these." The rights listed are not all inclusive. Therefore to argue that omission from the Constitution implies a right is NOT unalienable is unsupported.
-
Tell the Japanese Americans during WWII about their "God given rights..."
Until God comes down from the heavens and tells the Government what to do, your "rights" come from the government.
The Declaration is a legal document informing England that they would no longer be receiving taxes from us. Has ~nothing~ to do with the legal definition of rights. Applying the wording of the Declaration to the Constitution and the Bill of Rights is a classic fallacy that a lot of armchair Constitutional Scholars enjoy. Its still a fallacy.
Philosophers and historians talk about nature derived or God given rights. Meanwhile the legislature and courts deal with "legal rights" which are given and taken by the authorities.
Armed Watertown SWAT Team member: "You are being evacuated. There is a terrorist on the loose."
Resident: "Let me get my shoes..."
SWAT: "No, you are moving out now."
Resident: "But...."
SWAT: "Move! NOW!"
Notice the nuanced discussion of rights?
The 2nd amendment articulates the nature derived right to keep and bear arms. The NFA has articulated for quite some time a class of arms that you cannot keep and bear. The courts have held up time and time again that the 2nd amendment is not absolute and that regional governments have the authority to enact their own regulations. Thus... D.C's ban on open carry is both legal and Constitutional... according to today's interpretation of it.
Sure, things were quite different in 1776.
We had slaves, for example. Everything a women owned, including any money she made, was the property of her husband. Just a short while later it was legal to hunt Native Americans in California because they were animals, not people. Smokeless powder didn't exist. At that time they were still burning people alive here in Hawaii. After the revolution only land owning white males could vote in this great country. Each State printed its own currency. The Spanish Inquisition was still happening.
Laws have changed around a bit since then. Interpretations of laws that haven't changed have shifted around, too.
edit: I should say that I agree with the philosophers that "rights" are inalienable. My point is that the courts deal with laws much more than philosophy. The loaded rifle marchers are headed to jail if D.C. police chose to send them there.
-
Tell the Japanese Americans during WWII about their "God given rights..."
Until God comes down from the heavens and tells the Government what to do, your "rights" come from the government.
The Declaration is a legal document informing England that they would no longer be receiving taxes from us. Has ~nothing~ to do with the legal definition of rights. Applying the wording of the Declaration to the Constitution and the Bill of Rights is a classic fallacy that a lot of armchair Constitutional Scholars enjoy. Its still a fallacy.
Philosophers and historians talk about nature derived or God given rights. Meanwhile the legislature and courts deal with "legal rights" which are given and taken by the authorities.
Armed Watertown SWAT Team member: "You are being evacuated. There is a terrorist on the loose."
Resident: "Let me get my shoes..."
SWAT: "No, you are moving out now."
Resident: "But...."
SWAT: "Move! NOW!"
Notice the nuanced discussion of rights?
The 2nd amendment articulates the nature derived right to keep and bear arms. The NFA has articulated for quite some time a class of arms that you cannot keep and bear. The courts have held up time and time again that the 2nd amendment is not absolute and that regional governments have the authority to enact their own regulations. Thus... D.C's ban on open carry is both legal and Constitutional... according to today's interpretation of it.
Sure, things were quite different in 1776.
We had slaves, for example. Everything a women owned, including any money she made, was the property of her husband. Just a short while later it was legal to hunt Native Americans in California because they were animals, not people. Smokeless powder didn't exist. At that time they were still burning people alive here in Hawaii. After the revolution only land owning white males could vote in this great country. Each State printed its own currency. The Spanish Inquisition was still happening.
Laws have changed around a bit since then. Interpretations of laws that haven't changed have shifted around, too.
edit: I should say that I agree with the philosophers that "rights" are inalienable. My point is that the courts deal with laws much more than philosophy. The loaded rifle marchers are headed to jail if D.C. police chose to send them there.
Everything you are arguing is based on the norms of SOCIETY, not just the government. Society evolves (slavery, women's rights, minority rights, civil rights in general, etc.). As society evolves, so do the laws for that society -- for the most part.
You can cite as many examples of mistakes or societal injustices as you want. The fact remains: the American Constitutional system of government is the worst system in the world ...except for all the others!
-
Everything you are arguing is based on the norms of SOCIETY, not just the government. Society evolves (slavery, women's rights, minority rights, civil rights in general, etc.). As society evolves, so do the laws for that society -- for the most part.
You do realize this is ~exactly~ the argument many leftwingers make for increased gun regulation? :-/ Its also the rationale behind the NFA and why it doesn't (legally) infringe on the 2nd amendment.
You can cite as many examples of mistakes or societal injustices as you want. The fact remains: the American Constitutional system of government is the worst system in the world ...except for all the others!
Oh, no judgement from me on that. I didn't say it was bad, just that it was so. And the way it ~is~ differs substantially from the way many armchair Constitutional Scholars think it is.
-
You do realize this is ~exactly~ the argument many leftwingers make for increased gun regulation? :-/ Its also the rationale behind the NFA and why it doesn't (legally) infringe on the 2nd amendment.
That's the beauty of a government based on human rights and the rule of law. The fundamental basis of our system is applicable regardless of the issue or which side you are supporting. The reasoning that "left wingers" use to support their arguments do not give them an exclusive claim to those facts and suppositions. in fact, using the very same facts and suppositions to refute their misguided and erroneous conclusions helps bolster the pro-gun argument, in that the other side has just stipulated to the underlying principles.
More specifically, the evolution and enlightenment of a society does not support the disarming of the population. On the contrary, use of force to protect our enlightened population from those who have not reached that same pinnacle of tolerance and acceptance is a logical conclusion. Else, we risk having that advancement and enlightenment stripped from our society by choosing to have no means (or desire) to protect ourselves and our ideals. Hence, our advancement and enlightenment will have been wasted, and erased, because of our denial that such evolution was not universal.
I know I'm rambling, but it's been a rough month already ... and it's only the 6th!! :wacko:
-
Rationalization through disjointed perspectives is nothing new; and yes, it’s commonly found in “law”. And yes, those are the laws they are demonstrating against. Skewed laws which are to be constitutionally congruent can be readily identified by exposing the “perspective” used to derive the “rationalization” of the “law”. Any given perspective can derive any given evaluation. The pretense behind such skewed judiciary evaluation has become common place amongst the majority judiciary body today and it’s because of that last line of now compromised defense in which we now see our nation fallen to its knees. It’s clearly our judiciary branch, the last line that has failed – “We the people”. This has been accomplished through the internal compromise of those justices who have failed us all. My respect for law is limited to those laws that are clearly in line with common conscience and I find nothing but distain for those that are contrary to that conscience as they are a true aberration of their own undisciplined perspective. We all know what these skewed laws are like, coercion through “tax” (health care), building codes (not land use) applied to personal projects and not kept limited to the “business of”, administrative bypass of judicial due process (Fines, etc), (place your pet peeve here), etc.
So my opinion on the intent of the march on Washington remains unmoved. A nation that cannot allow such demonstration is a nation of bankrupt integrity and it’s clearly a nation that no longer represents the people. Therein lays the very intent of the March, a minority wants to peaceably assemble and demonstrate a grievance, simple as that and no diversity therein of applied perspective holds merit beyond its own devices.
-
If the Executive Office of the Nation (Obama) can come out on the national media and actually SUPPORT the illegal Occupy movement's actions (no permits, trespassing on private land, destruction of private and public property, impeding the flow of traffic, harassing pedestrians on public walkways, littering, noise, defecating and urinating in public, and so on), and applaude their spirit and determination, then Obama (and law enforcement) will be guilty of unequal application of the law should they interfere with this march.
Picking and choosing which causes you will support by allowing one group of protestors a free pass when breaking laws and not another group just smacks of a political agenda, not law enforcement.
-
Tell the Japanese Americans during WWII about their "God given rights..."
Until God comes down from the heavens and tells the Government what to do, your "rights" come from the government.
The Declaration is a legal document informing England that they would no longer be receiving taxes from us. Has ~nothing~ to do with the legal definition of rights. Applying the wording of the Declaration to the Constitution and the Bill of Rights is a classic fallacy that a lot of armchair Constitutional Scholars enjoy. Its still a fallacy.
Philosophers and historians talk about nature derived or God given rights. Meanwhile the legislature and courts deal with "legal rights" which are given and taken by the authorities.
Armed Watertown SWAT Team member: "You are being evacuated. There is a terrorist on the loose."
Resident: "Let me get my shoes..."
SWAT: "No, you are moving out now."
Resident: "But...."
SWAT: "Move! NOW!"
Notice the nuanced discussion of rights?
The 2nd amendment articulates the nature derived right to keep and bear arms. The NFA has articulated for quite some time a class of arms that you cannot keep and bear. The courts have held up time and time again that the 2nd amendment is not absolute and that regional governments have the authority to enact their own regulations. Thus... D.C's ban on open carry is both legal and Constitutional... according to today's interpretation of it.
Sure, things were quite different in 1776.
We had slaves, for example. Everything a women owned, including any money she made, was the property of her husband. Just a short while later it was legal to hunt Native Americans in California because they were animals, not people. Smokeless powder didn't exist. At that time they were still burning people alive here in Hawaii. After the revolution only land owning white males could vote in this great country. Each State printed its own currency. The Spanish Inquisition was still happening.
Laws have changed around a bit since then. Interpretations of laws that haven't changed have shifted around, too.
edit: I should say that I agree with the philosophers that "rights" are inalienable. My point is that the courts deal with laws much more than philosophy. The loaded rifle marchers are headed to jail if D.C. police chose to send them there.
So because laws are changed and re-interpeted over time our rights are changed? Whether endowed or granted? Seems like we have nothing to complain about then.
-
This is more than appropriate, this is needed. Many of you talk big about loving your rights and being willing to defend them and now you have the opportunity to do exactly that. Shall no be infringed doesn't mean compromise, it doesn't mean talk it over and come to something the politicians can agree on. And it sure as hell doesn't mean let the government dictate how, where, and when you can use your rights. The republic is no longer in control of the people and you can't win when they don't even have to play by the rules that they create.
You'll all grumble and groan about bans for this and bans for that. Maybe you send some emails and some money to a pro-gun organization. In the end you guys will just sit back and let it happen because there's already a long history of it. Here in Hawaii it was allowed for registration to pass, "assault pistols" became a legal definition, NFA items aren't allowed, and you can't even carry your gun around at all. This passive aggressive fight being put up out here is a whole bunch of bs and is never going to get anything fixed.
You only have rights when you are willing to defend them and the government knows this so it will ignore them first and answer for them later in their own courts. This state is right up there with NY and Cali where liberty is concerned.
-
This is more than appropriate, this is needed. Many of you talk big about loving your rights and being willing to defend them and now you have the opportunity to do exactly that. Shall no be infringed doesn't mean compromise, it doesn't mean talk it over and come to something the politicians can agree on. And it sure as hell doesn't mean let the government dictate how, where, and when you can use your rights. The republic is no longer in control of the people and you can't win when they don't even have to play by the rules that they create.
You'll all grumble and groan about bans for this and bans for that. Maybe you send some emails and some money to a pro-gun organization. In the end you guys will just sit back and let it happen because there's already a long history of it. Here in Hawaii it was allowed for registration to pass, "assault pistols" became a legal definition, NFA items aren't allowed, and you can't even carry your gun around at all. This passive aggressive fight being put up out here is a whole bunch of bs and is never going to get anything fixed.
You only have rights when you are willing to defend them and the government knows this so it will ignore them first and answer for them later in their own courts. This state is right up there with NY and Cali where liberty is concerned.
This was my point. Without anyone ever standing up for these rights, we might not have ever gotten them.
-
Needed?
As I've said before I agree with the demonstration in principle.
Doing it in D.C. is a huge mistake. Knowingly and publicly committing a felony is a huge mistake when most of us spout "law abiding gun owners" on a daily basis and that "criminals don't obey laws."
Sure, it would make a point but it is doing so in a way that is faaaaaar too easy for the opponents of the 2nd amendment to turn to their advantage. And doing so in a way that creates far more potential for damaging public moments than positive ones.
It is reactionary, incendiary hype building and not at all strategic thinking. You know why most demonstrations don't do much: utter lack of strategic thinking. Getting out there and expressing your opinion doesn't have any affect unless there is a larger movement afoot, legislation being considered, etc. That's why the Occupy "movement" hasn't accomplished much, why the hippies didn't get much actually changed in D.C. and why walking around with loaded rifles where it is a felony to do so is pointless.
When Gandhi broke the law and had lots of people making salt down by the sea and was arrested.... it was crystal clear that the British were being unreasonable in forbidding the making of salt. When (if) this march happens and some of them are thrown in jail before the rest abandon ship what crystal clear point will have been made to the larger public about gun owners and gun rights?
Sure, they are "standing up for our rights." But they are doing it in such a way that is more likely to damage those rights than to support them. That's stupid.
-
I agree that this is a bad idea. I think doing this at DC only gives the antis more ammo to fight us with.
All it takes is 1 in 1000 idiot to shoot someone and it becomes a horrible demonstration of gun rights. An al-quaeda terrorist or an anti-gun activist can easily just plant someone in there and make the whole gathering look like a bunch of dangerous and law breaking citizens.
-
Needed?
As I've said before I agree with the demonstration in principle.
Doing it in D.C. is a huge mistake. Knowingly and publicly committing a felony is a huge mistake when most of us spout "law abiding gun owners" on a daily basis and that "criminals don't obey laws."
Sure, it would make a point but it is doing so in a way that is faaaaaar too easy for the opponents of the 2nd amendment to turn to their advantage. And doing so in a way that creates far more potential for damaging public moments than positive ones.
It is reactionary, incendiary hype building and not at all strategic thinking. You know why most demonstrations don't do much: utter lack of strategic thinking. Getting out there and expressing your opinion doesn't have any affect unless there is a larger movement afoot, legislation being considered, etc. That's why the Occupy "movement" hasn't accomplished much, why the hippies didn't get much actually changed in D.C. and why walking around with loaded rifles where it is a felony to do so is pointless.
When Gandhi broke the law and had lots of people making salt down by the sea and was arrested.... it was crystal clear that the British were being unreasonable in forbidding the making of salt. When (if) this march happens and some of them are thrown in jail before the rest abandon ship what crystal clear point will have been made to the larger public about gun owners and gun rights?
Sure, they are "standing up for our rights." But they are doing it in such a way that is more likely to damage those rights than to support them. That's stupid.
the fear of losing your rights by using them is exactly why we have been losing them. Feelings do not trump rights and by allowing them to do so you further the destruction of all rights.
-
Needed?
As I've said before I agree with the demonstration in principle.
Doing it in D.C. is a huge mistake. Knowingly and publicly committing a felony is a huge mistake when most of us spout "law abiding gun owners" on a daily basis and that "criminals don't obey laws."
Sure, it would make a point but it is doing so in a way that is faaaaaar too easy for the opponents of the 2nd amendment to turn to their advantage. And doing so in a way that creates far more potential for damaging public moments than positive ones.
It is reactionary, incendiary hype building and not at all strategic thinking. You know why most demonstrations don't do much: utter lack of strategic thinking. Getting out there and expressing your opinion doesn't have any affect unless there is a larger movement afoot, legislation being considered, etc. That's why the Occupy "movement" hasn't accomplished much, why the hippies didn't get much actually changed in D.C. and why walking around with loaded rifles where it is a felony to do so is pointless.
When Gandhi broke the law and had lots of people making salt down by the sea and was arrested.... it was crystal clear that the British were being unreasonable in forbidding the making of salt. When (if) this march happens and some of them are thrown in jail before the rest abandon ship what crystal clear point will have been made to the larger public about gun owners and gun rights?
Sure, they are "standing up for our rights." But they are doing it in such a way that is more likely to damage those rights than to support them. That's stupid.
So when do we reach the tipping point on this issue? In other words, when do we reach that point where writing to our representatives is not enough? What makes us decide that being intellectual about it is just not enough? I would wonder which is more dangerous, action or inaction?
-
Good point Bud.
And for those spewing rhetoric and propaganda, who's buying a ticket to DC in July to carry their loaded rifle ?
If you feel that strongly, follow Chris Baker's and George Young's lead and take them to court to get our rights back.
1000 gunowners losing their 2A right by committing a felony as an act of symbolic martyrdom doesn't make any sense.
Especially in a year when all gun restriction bills have so far failed to pass.
-
The assumption appears to be that they will march across the bridge and through DC against law enforcement efforts. I didn't hear the organizer say that. I heard him say very much the opposite. So all this talk about a potential problem and committing a felony comes from where; assumption perhaps? Perhaps listening to what he said again might be a good idea. What they plan to do is not within the realm of the assumed from above.
The plan as presented by the organizer appears sound and that plan does not entail going forward against law-enforcement. He said they will comply with any law enforcement they encounter.
This puts the ball in DC’s hands. What will they do when (if) the marchers begin to cross the bridge?
We’ll then have an answer, either they allow them to demonstrate or they don’t. Everyone knows there is a law against being armed as proposed in DC and I’m certain DC is well aware of the proposed march by now. So… will DC police allow them to cross the bridge and then arrest them or will they stop them before attempting to cross the bridge and make no arrests or will they allow the full march without arrest?
There are three likely scenarios that might occur and each is differently telling of our current executive branch. Is there a point? There are three possible points, which will it be? DC won’t compromise and likewise will stop the demonstrators without arrest before crossing the bridge? DC will allow them to walk across the bridge and swoop in and make needless arrests that could have been avoided? DC will allow them to demonstrate without arrest. DC’s response will dictate the “point”.
And BTW 1000 armed men peaceably assembled would immediately subdue anyone within the ranks who tried to create problems. You can bet your butt there will be damn tight organizing as well as preaddressed responses to several possible issues that may arise. If there's a few bad people in the ranks... they'll be committing suicide that gets nowhere. In anycase, this maybe a very important moment in future history, if it happens. So to say its pointless etc, etc is somewhat premature. There are a few dynamics involved.\
This is very much a political issue and it need not be much of a "legal (beyond the poiont of the march)" issue unless DC makes it a legal issue. In any case, DC has 2 options to avoid making it a legal issue.
-
The assumption appears to be that they will march across the bridge and through DC against law enforcement efforts. I didn't hear the organizer say that. I heard him say very much the opposite. So all this talk about a potential problem and committing a felony comes from where; assumption perhaps? Perhaps listening to what he said again might be a good idea. What they plan to do is not within the realm of the assumed from above.
I don't have to assume its a felony to open carry a gun in DC. It's the law. If they are "allowed" to cross the bridge and make the entire march, returning to the other side in an "organized and peaceable manner", it's still a felony to open carry a loaded gun it DC. Bud's original question was "should they have the right to do this". I would say yes they should.
If the original question had be "do they have the right to do this" I would say "No, and we should continue to work at "fixing" this through legal channels".
I get the general idea of the event, I just don't believe its the best thing to do to help bolster 2a rights. Maybe if things "get worse" I would change my mind, but I'm not changing my mind on this one yet. It has the strong potential to hurt us. I'd rather give the money for an airline ticket to go to this event to the legal defense of Baker and Young. Now that would be a useful statement IMO.
-
...and if the entire event is called off and nothing happens, it's still a felony to open carry a loaded gun in DC. That's what needs to be changed, this march just isn't the way to do it...but I've been wrong before...
-
I don't have to assume its a felony to open carry a gun in DC. It's the law. If they are "allowed" to cross the bridge and make the entire march, returning to the other side in an "organized and peaceable manner", it's still a felony to open carry a loaded gun it DC. Bud's original question was "should they have the right to do this". I would say yes they should.
If the original question had be "do they have the right to do this" I would say "No, and we should continue to work at "fixing" this through legal channels".
I get the general idea of the event, I just don't believe its the best thing to do to help bolster 2a rights. Maybe if things "get worse" I would change my mind, but I'm not changing my mind on this one yet. It has the strong potential to hurt us. I'd rather give the money for an airline ticket to go to this event to the legal defense of Baker and Young. Now that would be a useful statement IMO.
what do you do when they make more laws? are you just going to stand by and say oh well it's the law if you don't them then you're a criminal and crazy because it's bad because it's illegal and it's illegal because it's bad. watching the situation develop left us with the GCA, NFA, and AWB.
-
I don't have to assume its a felony to open carry a gun in DC. It's the law. If they are "allowed" to cross the bridge and make the entire march, returning to the other side in an "organized and peaceable manner", it's still a felony to open carry a loaded gun it DC. Bud's original question was "should they have the right to do this". I would say yes they should.
If the original question had be "do they have the right to do this" I would say "No, and we should continue to work at "fixing" this through legal channels".
I get the general idea of the event, I just don't believe its the best thing to do to help bolster 2a rights. Maybe if things "get worse" I would change my mind, but I'm not changing my mind on this one yet. It has the strong potential to hurt us. I'd rather give the money for an airline ticket to go to this event to the legal defense of Baker and Young. Now that would be a useful statement IMO.
My point was – WILL DC ALLOW THEM TO COMMIT AND OR CHARGE THEM WITH A FELONY? Get it?
Did anyone propose it was the only thing that can currently be done? Sure there are all sorts of other things people can do; in fact people can do many things simultaneously. One could march, finance, write, file, vote, run for office, etc. It takes all of those things, not just one thing. Knocking another groups efforts because they don't settle well with you is just counter productive.
-
what do you do when they make more laws? are you just going to stand by and say oh well it's the law if you don't them then you're a criminal and crazy because it's bad because it's illegal and it's illegal because it's bad. watching the situation develop left us with the GCA, NFA, and AWB.
I don't think many American's are just standing by. Several are, but not all of us. I'm certainly not standing by, and I don't think any of us here at this site are. I just don't think it's time for this yet. We continue to go to hearings and provide testimony. Write letters and emails. Contact officials and give our opinions. I cite studies that I think are strong, and denounce those that I think are weak....and I continue to donate to HDF and HRA's PAC, and NRA, GOA and others who can get some bang for my bucks. I think most of us here do this... Don't know where the crazy part came from. I don't think the idea of the march is crazy, I just don't think it's an idea who's time has come yet. I don't think folks who would participate are crazy. But if one crazy did get in the ranks, it sure could backfire. We have other avenues with which to make a difference. Like I said, if it gets "that bad", I may do more...but first I'm gonna exhaust the legal avenues, which I think are currently working.....well to a degree :)
-
I admire the effort for the march, I do not have the time to attend it and I hope their efforts have a positive result as I hope all efforts to restore our second amendment rights are successful. It’s that simple and if that’s propaganda, foolish and hot air etc. well… you’ve my pity.
-
Considering that people get told to move on by armed guards if they so much as stop to tie their shoe on The Hill, I'm guessing that the D.C. law enforcement will not let a bunch of guys advertise that they are going to commit felonies and then commit them.
Given that the city grudgingly (and very slowly) allows its residents to even own pistols at all ONLY because the Supreme Court told them they had to, I doubt the department is all that sympathetic to an armed march.
That's pretty much the only reason I think this is a bad idea. If they stayed on the side of the river where it was legal it would be a great idea.
Reporter: "Why are you all carrying rifles?"
Articulate Spokesman: "We don't need a reason. It is perfectly legal for us to do so and we are exercising that right. As you can see, no one is getting hurt and there are no crimes being committed."
Reporter: "Why are you all here at this bridge?"
Articulate Spokesperson: "On this side of the bridge we are legally allowed to exercise our 2nd Amendment rights. On that side of the bridge exercising our 2nd Amendment rights would make us felons. What is perfectly safe and legal on this side of the river is a serious offense just over there. We don't think that makes any sense. A right is a right no matter where you are, isn't it?"
-
Well said Clshade
My question is why now ? Congress has made the statement that they wil not restrict gun rights at this time. I agree it's only at this time, but, in my opinion, this won't reflect well on responsible gun owners at this time.
Why kick a sleeping dog ?
And I hope all of us discussing this were in front of the State Capitol that Saturday in January. I know I was ( along with a crap load of 2A members). Now that was a glorious sight. and none of us were carrying firearms, much less loaded firearms....
Or have been attending legislative hearings, as Mr. Smith has.
The worst restrictions right now are in our own State.
-
And BTW 1000 armed men peaceably assembled would immediately subdue anyone within the ranks who tried to create problems. You can bet your butt there will be damn tight organizing as well as preaddressed responses to several possible issues that may arise. If there's a few bad people in the ranks... they'll be committing suicide that gets nowhere. In anycase, this maybe a very important moment in future history, if it happens. So to say its pointless etc, etc is somewhat premature. There are a few dynamics involved.\
Seriously? You think that a 1000 strangers get together to have this loaded rifle march and one person (another stranger to everyone else) will be able to keep everyone in check? One bad guy with bad intentions will always do bad stuff...
I LOVE this idea by clshade:
That's pretty much the only reason I think this is a bad idea. If they stayed on the side of the river where it was legal it would be a great idea.
Reporter: "Why are you all carrying rifles?"
Articulate Spokesman: "We don't need a reason. It is perfectly legal for us to do so and we are exercising that right. As you can see, no one is getting hurt and there are no crimes being committed."
Reporter: "Why are you all here at this bridge?"
Articulate Spokesperson: "On this side of the bridge we are legally allowed to exercise our 2nd Amendment rights. On that side of the bridge exercising our 2nd Amendment rights would make us felons. What is perfectly safe and legal on this side of the river is a serious offense just over there. We don't think that makes any sense. A right is a right no matter where you are, isn't it?"
This is the type of marches/protests or whatever that would be a good idea, minus the loaded weapons part. The only way I can see a loaded weapon march would be if everyone involved knew each other...you can't control other peoples actions, esp. if you do not know them. I would hate to give the gun grabbers any ammunition to use against us...
-
The best thing here is to use wisdom. If our petitions aren't heard......we try again. Then again. If this was a tea party type assembly......500,000 or more? Possible. But not probable. I don't disagree with the frustration. Its the method. Its not time yet. Soon, But not now. Use wisdom boys.......please. We have everything going for us. You guys have heart, courage, and the right. Lawlessness isn't going to help us. Stay calm, keep your ammo dry and your firearm clean.
-
The best thing here is to use wisdom. If our petitions aren't heard......we try again. Then again. If this was a tea party type assembly......500,000 or more? Possible. But not probable. I don't disagree with the frustration. Its the method. Its not time yet. Soon, But not now. Use wisdom boys.......please. We have everything going for us. You guys have heart, courage, and the right. Lawlessness isn't going to help us. Stay calm, keep your ammo dry and your firearm clean.
Definitely sound advice...still love clshades idea! Especially if you could choose a pro 2A reporter, it might make people think. Ultimately, we can do nothing that is criminal, be patient and let the NRA and those folks keep working!
-
Seriously? You think that a 1000 strangers get together to have this loaded rifle march and one person (another stranger to everyone else) will be able to keep everyone in check? One bad guy with bad intentions will always do bad stuff...
What sort of bent interpretation is that? It reminds me of a liberal fanatic’s interpretation of something said by the NRA. What was expressed is very much the opposite of what you’ve magically extrapolated. More like 997 men can stop a few idiots in the ranks... that is what was expressed. Nowhere did I state that one man can stop a few idiots within the ranks.
It's a magical thing, someone expresses something another doesn't agree with and all of a sudden they can’t even properly describe what was expressed, injecting whatever ridiculous thing that pops into mind. Good luck with those communication skills over there.
-
“still love clshades idea!” Did the simple fact that they are starting the march on the opposite side of the river of DC at the cemetery and the fact that the DC police have more than likely been alerted somehow escape notice? Did the most likely scenario of the DC police making them turn back at the bridge and cause them to march back to the cemetery somehow escape notice also? In other words, the most likely scenario if the march happens will be that they only march as clshades described. Do you think that the organizer hasn’t already determined that will most likely be the route they make? To this day, I am frigging amazed by wandering minds… oooh look up there in the sky, it must be a UFO! Please pay attention. Thanks. Again... I think the march is a damn good idea. By use of mental discipline, carefully think it through without involving UFO’s from the get go. You might learn something called "strategy". Kind of like when playing chess :thumbsup:
As I said before, there are several dynamics involved. Though not evident to many, it's clear that the organizer is far from being a fool, to the contrary. Consider the emotional disruption across the board and for what? What will more than likely add up to nothing more than an armed stroll from Arlington Cemetery in Virginia along the Potomac opposite DC to the bridge and back again (not illegal in Virginia)? Sort of like representatives of those who rest at Arlington Cemetery presenting arms towards DC, a friendly reminder of what was given to carry those arms.
-
Bent interpretation? Liberal fanatic? You mentioned that this group would have "damn tight organizing", I was disagreeing with you on that point. My "ridiculous injecting" was just pointing out that in my personal opinion, I don't see how one person can expect to have control over a thousand people who come from all over the country and gather for this event. ANYTHING that one idiot was able to do prior to being subdued by the 997 other dudes would be to late, it would completely ruin what your peaceful (though illegal) march was trying to achieve. I wasn't attacking your opinion, just giving you mine. Strange though, I have NEVER been called a liberal fanatic before....
Not to mention, I don't understand how committing a felony and losing your right to bear arms, helps the 2A movement...again, just my opinion.
-
Bent interpretation? Liberal fanatic? You mentioned that this group would have "damn tight organizing", I was disagreeing with you on that point. My "ridiculous injecting" was just pointing out that in my personal opinion, I don't see how one person can expect to have control over a thousand people who come from all over the country and gather for this event. ANYTHING that one idiot was able to do prior to being subdued by the 997 other dudes would be to late, it would completely ruin what your peaceful (though illegal) march was trying to achieve. I wasn't attacking your opinion, just giving you mine. Strange though, I have NEVER been called a liberal fanatic before....
Not to mention, I don't understand how committing a felony and losing your right to bear arms, helps the 2A movement...again, just my opinion.
It’s simply fascinating. You still don’t get it.
LOL and BTW you still haven't been called a liberal fanatic. LOL
-
The organizer isn't talking like he's planning to stop at the bridge.
He's purposefully challenging law enforcement to enforce laws that many feel are unconstitutional.
Many, many (might I stress... MANY) more people do not feel those laws are unconstitutional, or at the very least unreasonable.
To the average American what they hear is "Gun owners plan to break laws as part of pro gun demonstration."
That tends to turn people off. It IS an effective way to highlight unjust laws, of course, but I think planning to stop at the bridge is a better way to do it. If they plan to march into D.C.... then even if they are stopped the average American hears "Gun toting protesters plan to commit felonies but were stopped by police."
There are some other fallacies going on here, too. The assumption is that because it is D.C. that they are challenging the Federal Government. They are not: they are challenging the D.C. police department. If they actually get to the White House then they will be dealing with a whole different matter. For a number of very good reasons (and a number of very bad ones) you simply don't have your constitutional rights there and it has no bearing on the laws that do and don't allow carry in most of the country.
Civil disobedience is fine. Civil disobedience while armed is pretty high amperage and difficult to call civil disobedience. Armed civil disobedience in D.C. is setting yourself up for failure. The organizer knows that.
The mistake I think he is making is thinking that anyone who doesn't already agree with him will care. Those who already agree with him will just get mad if they are stopped by the police. If they are not stopped by the police... they have made no clear point, have they?
That would be the real coup do grace. If the D.C. cops and the Secret Service allowed the march to happen as planned. Think about that for a minute.
He may be thinking strategically but I don't think he has thought it through clearly enough. Either that or he's generating press for himself while being fairly sure it ain't gonna happen at all.
-
Below is his plan for the march, I have highlighted to phrase that is concerning...
On the morning of July 4, 2013, Independence Day, we will muster at the National Cemetery & at noon we will step off to march across the Memorial Bridge, down Independence Avenue, around the Capitol, the Supreme Court, & the White House, then peacefully return to Virginia across the Memorial Bridge. This is an act of civil disobedience, not a permitted event. We will march with rifles loaded & slung across our backs to put the government on notice that we will not be intimidated & cower in submission to tyranny. We are marching to mark the high water mark of government & to turn the tide. This will be a non-violent event, unless the government chooses to make it violent. Should we meet physical resistance, we will peacefully turn back, having shown that free people are not welcome in Washington, & returning with the resolve that the politicians, bureaucrats, & enforcers of the federal government will not be welcome in the land of the free.
Without knowing HIS actual motive for this march, I would caution being anywhere near that area. clshade said it perfectly, when he said, "Average American hears "Gun toting protesters plan to commit felonies but were stopped by police." And that is exactly how the media and politicians would run with this...
Whatever happens or doesn't happen regarding this march, I just hope it doesn't hurt the cause, you know...
-
clshade,
It's a very interesting strategy. How it all plays out, we won’t know till July 4th. I think perhaps researching his past demonstrations may shed some light on it… maybe (obviously he hasn’t committed any felonies thus far). The potential to commit a felony is there but will they be allowed to commit the felony wherever that line exists upon the bridge (it would be wrong for them allow the felony and then swoop in and arrest them)? Without the felony potential and high profile of DC, they would just be another like type demonstration. There may be more to it than what’s been divulged thus far. They may, if stopped, lay down arms and continue the march without arms. It’s hard to say what the whole plan is. It’s intriguing to me. The whole thing may change between now and then also.
michalebsdad,
"This will be a non-violent event, unless the government chooses to make it violent. Should we meet physical resistance, we will peacefully turn back, having shown that free people are not welcome in Washington, & returning with the resolve that the politicians, bureaucrats, & enforcers of the federal government will not be welcome in the land of the free."
In context he means just that, if the government makes it violent which I doubt they will. It's too high profile and there would be far too many witnesses with cell phone cameras considering the paranoia brewing on that front these days. Personally I don't think a whole heck of a lot will happen and I doubt they will even cross the bridge unless Obama steps in and allows it (he's the only one with the potential authority to do so, unless DC changes the law, etc).
I need to add the conspiracy slant here.... maybe he works for the Obama administration and it's all planned to allow the march through DC to boost Obama's agendas. :rofl:
-
Until God comes down from the heavens and tells the Government what to do, your "rights" come from the government.
clshade -- my understanding is that you have it backwards. I'm no expert in law but I don't think it is about the government giving us our "rights"... it is the people conferring "powers" to the government.
If the US was founded by a monarchy, then you'd be correct because the monarchy would be giving "rights" to the people. However, the people of the US overthrew the monarchy and created a government for the people by the people, and conferred limited powers to the government instead.
The government continues to gain more power though as the sheeple are scared into conferring more power to it.
I think the biggest mistake is when people start thinking of their elected officials as their government "leaders". Folks should be reminded that these politicians are called public "servants" and should be in service of the people they represent. The moment any of our public servants start acting like our king or masters is the time that they should be booted off by voting them out.
-
clshade -- my understanding is that you have it backwards. I'm no expert in law but I don't think it is about the government giving us our "rights"... it is the people conferring "powers" to the government.
If the US was founded by a monarchy, then you'd be correct because the monarchy would be giving "rights" to the people. However, the people of the US overthrew the monarchy and created a government for the people by the people, and conferred limited powers to the government instead.
The government continues to gain more power though as the sheeple are scared into conferring more power to it.
I think the biggest mistake is when people start thinking of their elected officials as their government "leaders". Folks should be reminded that these politicians are called public "servants" and should be in service of the people they represent. The moment any of our public servants start acting like our king or masters is the time that they should be booted off by voting them out.
x100
-
More philosophy, though I agree with you, Jl808.
My point is that "rights" are kind of an illusion. We talk about them as coming from God, Nature, or from the people... fine, but in practice you can only do what the authorities will let you do.
And sociologically about 60-70% of the population is wired to simply go along with whatever the rules are, whatever the "leaders" say. A number of them may question and be upset about things they don't agree with but they will still go along with it.
If there is a revolution it isn't just because enough of these types are rebelling against the established authority, it is because they are following a new authority.
Its not necessarily malicious on the part of the "leaders" - its just the way people are. What is malicious is that there are people who understand this and use it for their own purposes. The entire fields of Public Relations and Advertising are based on this. Sure, its a mistake to assume your rights and access to true information comes from the authorities but across cultures >60% of are are wired to make that assumption.
edit: To clarify: so, in practice, >60% of us create a government that we then follow more or less blindly. This is exactly why some of the founders thought revolution was a recurring necessity since there is almost no chance that such a government will NOT abuse its power at some point.
-
More philosophy, though I agree with you, Jl808.
My point is that "rights" are kind of an illusion. We talk about them as coming from God, Nature, or from the people... fine, but in practice you can only do what the authorities will let you do.
And sociologically about 60-70% of the population is wired to simply go along with whatever the rules are, whatever the "leaders" say. A number of them may question and be upset about things they don't agree with but they will still go along with it.
If there is a revolution it isn't just because enough of these types are rebelling against the established authority, it is because they are following a new authority.
Its not necessarily malicious on the part of the "leaders" - its just the way people are. What is malicious is that there are people who understand this and use it for their own purposes. The entire fields of Public Relations and Advertising are based on this. Sure, its a mistake to assume your rights and access to true information comes from the authorities but across cultures >60% of are are wired to make that assumption.
edit: To clarify: so, in practice, >60% of us create a government that we then follow more or less blindly. This is exactly why some of the founders thought revolution was a recurring necessity since there is almost no chance that such a government will NOT abuse its power at some point.
In the American Revolution, only about 3% of the American population actively supported rebellion.
Will you be part of that 3% if, or when, the time comes?
-
^^^^^
That hugely depends on who is leading it. Do you have any idea how easy it is end up replacing one problem with another?
-
That hugely depends on who is leading it. Do you have any idea how easy it is end up replacing one problem with another?
Why does it matter who the leader is? Either you know in your heart and your mind that what you are doing is right, or you stand with the other 60-70% (your figure) of low-information voters who choose to believe whatever the government and media tell them to.
If you require validation or consensus in order to trust your own moral and ethical compass, I would suggest you specifically are not leadership material.
The Only Thing Necessary for the Triumph of Evil is that Good Men Do Nothing
-
Because the leadership of that revolution will dictate the flavor of what comes next.
Look at past revolutions in other places and look at what happens immediately after in almost every case. A lot of good ideas have lead a lot of people to some very bad conditions.
If you think I require validation or consensus you are clearly not understanding my point. You're in good company: most revolutionaries have no clue how to build something new that works - they only know how to react against something they don't like.
Take Hawaii as an example and imagine that a revolution is underway to restore Sovereignty. If it is being lead by Hawaiian Blood purists who want to Kill Da Haoles, restore the Monarchy, start sacrificing people again and burning them alive it their shadow falls on them.... yeah, I might not want to have anything to do with it.
-
My point is that "rights" are kind of an illusion. We talk about them as coming from God, Nature, or from the people... fine, but in practice you can only do what the authorities will let you do.
Exactly. If a right were truly inalienable, then no act of government could deny it. Breathing, for example, is a right. If someone denies you your right to breath, you die. It quite literally cannot be taken from a living person. Belief is another. No one but you can decide what you believe.
Plus, as far as I'm concerned, the jury is still out on deities. Even if one or more exist (a point I do not concede), the whole making-their-will-known-to-mankind thing has a pretty sketchy history.
No, what "rights" are, in this context, are a set of privileges that society has agreed upon. This is why rights vary from country to country. This is why governments, societies, and circumstances can control whether or not a right applies. And this is why there is a very real threat of losing them.
Are these people exercising a right? Sure they are, the right to make a choice (yet another actual inalienable right.) They are choosing to violate laws as a form of protest.
-
Take Hawaii as an example and imagine that a revolution is underway to restore Sovereignty. If it is being lead by Hawaiian Blood purists who want to Kill Da Haoles, restore the Monarchy, start sacrificing people again and burning them alive it their shadow falls on them.... yeah, I might not want to have anything to do with it.
Off topic, but I have to ask you to site your source if your going to make such accusations. I actually know people that are part of this movement, although I do not share their beliefs your statement is not accurate. There are different hawaiian activist groups, problem is they are not united and tend to disagree on topics amongst themselves.
-
Apologies, ImKu - please note the "Imagine" and "if" in my quote. The situation I described is hypothetical not actual. As such it was not a statement or an accusation.
-
Apologies, ImKu - please note the "Imagine" and "if" in my quote. The situation I described is hypothetical not actual. As such it was not a statement or an accusation.
Mahalo Nui Loa :shaka:
-
Exactly. If a right were truly inalienable, then no act of government could deny it. Breathing, for example, is a right. If someone denies you your right to breath, you die. It quite literally cannot be taken from a living person. Belief is another. No one but you can decide what you believe.
Plus, as far as I'm concerned, the jury is still out on deities. Even if one or more exist (a point I do not concede), the whole making-their-will-known-to-mankind thing has a pretty sketchy history.
No, what "rights" are, in this context, are a set of privileges that society has agreed upon. This is why rights vary from country to country. This is why governments, societies, and circumstances can control whether or not a right applies. And this is why there is a very real threat of losing them.
Are these people exercising a right? Sure they are, the right to make a choice (yet another actual inalienable right.) They are choosing to violate laws as a form of protest.
From Eugene Volokh:
"Some recent conversations I’ve heard about “positive rights” and American legal traditions made me want to repeat something I’ve written before: While it’s true that the U.S. Constitution lacks some of the “positive rights” that people sometimes discuss under that label (e.g., a right to shelter, to medical care, to a subsistence income, and so on, it does secure other positive rights; and indeed, some positive rights are a longstanding feature of American legal traditions. I think such rights should remain limited, but I think one shouldn’t deny that they exist, and are in some measure secured by the U.S. Constitution (and state constitutions).
First, some definitions. The term “right” is a broad one, which encompasses many different kinds of entitlement."
See more here at the Volokh Conspiracy
http://www.volokh.com/2013/05/07/positive-rights-the-constitution-and-conservatives-and-moderate-libertarians/ (http://www.volokh.com/2013/05/07/positive-rights-the-constitution-and-conservatives-and-moderate-libertarians/)
Stanford also has this to say about rights:
"The connection between rights and struggle cannot be overstated — rights are not as much granted or endowed as they are fought for and claimed, and the essence of struggles past and ancient are encoded in the spirit of current concepts of rights and their modern formulations."
-
Hi clshade, I normally agree with you on some stuff but this is something I really disagree with you about.
It is not just a philosophical discussion but also a discussion about morality, justice and moral right. You mentioned the need for strategic thinking. One cannot just get people to accomplish a "what?" without people clearly understanding the "why?".
One cannot take God out of the constitution either. Philosophically, without a God, all our existence devolves into a base Darwinian world view of a might makes right existence, which is what you describe.
The only reason why Ghandi succeeded was because the world held a Christian perspective of morality. Ghandi's peaceful civil disobedience would have no chance in a Darwinian might makes right world view that you describe.
-
I've really enjoyed this discussion, by the way. :)
Jl808, we actually agree on that but I think we're focusing on a couple of different things.
What I'm describing is applied "rights", for lack of a better term. Its very darwinian and that is the sad part. Agencies and authorities break and misuse laws all the time, sometimes they suffer consequences for it. Those consequences come from our morality, no doubt about that. Usually the greater sense of morality prevents such things from happening in the first place. But not all the time.
Its like a cop stopping you for no good reason then demanding to search your car. They have no legal authority to do so... but they do it anyway. A more shocking example is the internment of the Japanese Americans during WWII. The Constitution specifically says they had the right to not be shuffled off to internment camps... but the President did it anyway.
At that level of reality it doesn't much matter where we think our rights come from since it is the "authorities" that are preventing us from exercising them. It is in the court of law, not the court of morality, that such issues are resolved. The philosophy and morality is what inspired the laws in the first place but after that we are in the Darwinian world of what is legal and what in not instead of what is moral and what is not. The best (and worst) lawyers thrive in the gap between what is moral and what is legal.
Philosophy and morality are hugely important in creating legal systems and in legal defense strategies. It is almost entirely irrelevant to what will happen for the armed marcher standing on the bridge to D.C. if he goes forward into a police line that is committed to enforcing D.C. no open carry law. The law says its a felony even if that is morally and philosophically at odds with the Constitution.
The only reason I raised this distinction in the first place is that it is the territory this armed march event is venturing into. On moral and philosophical grounds the organizer intends to prove whether or not "free people" are welcome in the country's capital. Meanwhile, the law of the land has already defined what they wish to do as a felony. For a large portion of the populace committing a felony is, by definition, immoral. I don't think enough people are yet concerned that the enforced infringements of the 2nd amendment (of which there are many) are also immoral. So in this case the unconstitutional law as it stands is supported by the majority's sense of morality - in some cases because those people are actually anti-gun but in most cases it is simply considered moral because it is the law.
Its absolutely true that morality leads to laws. Unfortunately, most people are wired to then assume that laws = moral and it takes a mighty stiff shove to shift them off that default position.
-
Hi clshade, I normally agree with you on some stuff but this is something I really disagree with you about.
It is not just a philosophical discussion but also a discussion about morality, justice and moral right. You mentioned the need for strategic thinking. One cannot just get people to accomplish a "what?" without people clearly understanding the "why?".
One cannot take God out of the constitution either. Philosophically, without a God, all our existence devolves into a base Darwinian world view of a might makes right existence, which is what you describe.
The only reason why Ghandi succeeded was because the world held a Christian perspective of morality. Ghandi's peaceful civil disobedience would have no chance in a Darwinian might makes right world view that you describe.
Is it a Jewish God, Christian God, Mormon God or Muslim God ? ( Sorry, totally inappropriate comment but couldn't resist )
There is a Taoist perspective that accepts a higher power without one supreme being. An ultimate interconnection of everything. Sort of like the Force in Star Wars.
and I vaguely remember a concept of Separation of Church and State. Religion shouldn't even be in this conversation in my opinion.
What rights have been taken away this year that we need to undertake an armed march on DC ?
So far we've won through the legal channels. Even when the political/social climate was as ripe as it gets. We've, the 2A community, have made a statement.
Will it be necessary someday, almost undoubtedly. But not today.
-
Hi aieahound.
Are you sure you really want me to answer your question? I will only if you're willing to be open to what I might say. ;)
Is it a Jewish God, Christian God, Mormon God or Muslim God ? ( Sorry, totally inappropriate comment but couldn't resist )
There is a Taoist perspective that accepts a higher power without one supreme being. An ultimate interconnection of everything. Sort of like the Force in Star Wars.
and I vaguely remember a concept of Separation of Church and State. Religion shouldn't even be in this conversation in my opinion.
What rights have been taken away this year that we need to undertake an armed march on DC ?
So far we've won through the legal channels. Even when the political/social climate was as ripe as it gets. We've, the 2A community, have made a statement.
Will it be necessary someday, almost undoubtedly. But not today.
The only thing I would say is about your comments regarding the separation of church and state...
Why can't religion be part of a conversation about constitutional rights? The constitution equally protects your and my religious beliefs just as it protects your and my right to bear arms.
Ok, back to topic... :)
jl808
-
In general, what was the "religion" of most of the "founding fathers" when the federalist letters, constitution, bill of rights etc...were drafted and adopted? Even with the concept of "separation of Church and State", the beliefs of those who authored these documents-the "founding Fathers"- is going to strongly influence their works/efforts.
I seriously doubt there were many Hindu, Muslims, Jews or Taoists among their numbers. So is it safe to say that all this work took place in a non-secular vacume, or was this period of our history influenced by the religious beliefs of the authors?
Edit below added:
I think by the direction this thread has gone, it's not inappropriate to discuss "religion" or beliefs. It's just a matter of who's religion and what beliefs.
http://www.archives.gov/nhprc/annotation/2002/2002-mar.pdf (http://www.archives.gov/nhprc/annotation/2002/2002-mar.pdf)
Some anti-gunners argue the interpretation of the constitution should be taken in the current context of the nation today vs in the early days. Its a very Willcentric world for Will Smith. IMO this is usually the case for others too. It's hard to divorce core beliefs from all things Will, but I try. ...and I fail or fall short. Or is this a failing? Perhaps not.
-
I've really enjoyed this discussion, by the way. :)
Jl808, we actually agree on that but I think we're focusing on a couple of different things.
What I'm describing is applied "rights", for lack of a better term. Its very darwinian and that is the sad part. Agencies and authorities break and misuse laws all the time, sometimes they suffer consequences for it. Those consequences come from our morality, no doubt about that. Usually the greater sense of morality prevents such things from happening in the first place. But not all the time.
Its like a cop stopping you for no good reason then demanding to search your car. They have no legal authority to do so... but they do it anyway. A more shocking example is the internment of the Japanese Americans during WWII. The Constitution specifically says they had the right to not be shuffled off to internment camps... but the President did it anyway.
At that level of reality it doesn't much matter where we think our rights come from since it is the "authorities" that are preventing us from exercising them. It is in the court of law, not the court of morality, that such issues are resolved. The philosophy and morality is what inspired the laws in the first place but after that we are in the Darwinian world of what is legal and what in not instead of what is moral and what is not. The best (and worst) lawyers thrive in the gap between what is moral and what is legal.
Philosophy and morality are hugely important in creating legal systems and in legal defense strategies. It is almost entirely irrelevant to what will happen for the armed marcher standing on the bridge to D.C. if he goes forward into a police line that is committed to enforcing D.C. no open carry law. The law says its a felony even if that is morally and philosophically at odds with the Constitution.
The only reason I raised this distinction in the first place is that it is the territory this armed march event is venturing into. On moral and philosophical grounds the organizer intends to prove whether or not "free people" are welcome in the country's capital. Meanwhile, the law of the land has already defined what they wish to do as a felony. For a large portion of the populace committing a felony is, by definition, immoral. I don't think enough people are yet concerned that the enforced infringements of the 2nd amendment (of which there are many) are also immoral. So in this case the unconstitutional law as it stands is supported by the majority's sense of morality - in some cases because those people are actually anti-gun but in most cases it is simply considered moral because it is the law.
Its absolutely true that morality leads to laws. Unfortunately, most people are wired to then assume that laws = moral and it takes a mighty stiff shove to shift them off that default position.
I'm enjoying these discussions too by the way. Thank you all for the articulation of your thoughts and for the civility in the discussion so far. :shaka:
clshade -- Yes, I think we are talking about the same thing but focusing on the different parts.
I like and agree with your point about morality leading to laws and how others get a law confused with morality. Something legal does not make it morally right. Something morally right may not be legal. Unfortunately, when people ask "can I do this?", some may only ask "is it legal?" without asking the other question "is it morally right?" When legal vs moral are no longer matching, then you get a situation where protesters intentionally do illegal but moral things to prove a moral point.
I think that is what this armed march is seriously trying to take a look at... it is asking whether what our country has declared legal / illegal still matches with the moral values used when the country was established. This battleground of philosophy and morality is the battleground of the mind that must first be fought and won before a more physical battle is fought.
-
In general, what was the "religion" of most of the "founding fathers" when the federalist letters, constitution, bill of rights etc...were drafted and adopted? Even with the concept of "separation of Church and State", the beliefs of those who authored these documents-the "founding Fathers"- is going to strongly influence their works/efforts.
I seriously doubt there were many Hindu, Muslims, Jews or Taoists among their numbers. So is it safe to say that all this work took place in a non-secular vacume, or was this period of our history influenced by the religious beliefs of the authors?
If I learned my history correctly, the founding fathers were wanting to get away from a predominantly Roman Catholic Europe ruled by monarchs and established a new country ruled by people that can practice their religious beliefs without a ruling monarch or government dictating to them what religion was legal or illegal. Most of the pilgrims were Protestant Christians and the founding fathers are assumed to also be Protestant Christians. There are some other theories about their religion on the internet though.
-
If I learned my history correctly, the founding fathers were wanting to get away from a predominantly Roman Catholic Europe ruled by monarchs and established a new country ruled by people that can practice their religious beliefs without a ruling monarch or government dictating to them what religion was legal or illegal. Most of the pilgrims were Protestant Christians and the founding fathers are assumed to also be Protestant Christians. There are some other theories about their religion on the internet though.
If I recall correctly - T Jefferson was listed as a Master Mason in US publications and Ben Franklin was no doubt a Freemason. In any case, there were clearly other influences aside from Christianity responsible for the form of our nation.
Look on the back of that 1 dollar bill closely at the Great Seal... annuit coeptis novus ordo seclorum
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Annuit_c%C5%93ptis (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Annuit_c%C5%93ptis)
-
If I recall correctly - T Jefferson was listed as a Master Mason in US publications and Ben Franklin was no doubt a Freemason. In any case, there were clearly other influences aside from Christianity responsible for the form of our nation.
Look on the back of that 1 dollar bill closely at the Great Seal... annuit coeptis novus ordo seclorum
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Annuit_c%C5%93ptis (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Annuit_c%C5%93ptis)
George Washington was a Master of a lodge; about 12 signers of the constitution were Freemasons.
Here in Hawaii, two Kamehameha's were freemasons, and most of your major streets are named after freemasons.
-
:thumbsup:
George Washington was a Master of a lodge; about 12 signers of the constitution were Freemasons.
Here in Hawaii, two Kamehameha's were freemasons, and most of your major streets are named after freemasons.
Where does one join these days I wonder.
-
:thumbsup:Where does one join these days I wonder.
In Hawaii, I believe it's the Free Mason's Union ... :rofl:
-
We're wandering far afield here, but...
The separation of Church and State doesn't, and wasn't intended to, separate religion from politics. That's impossible since people are religious. What it did was remove the Church from direct influence in political power. Meaning the Church itself has no direct say in policy.
-
.
-
We're wandering far afield here, but...
The separation of Church and State doesn't, and wasn't intended to, separate religion from politics. That's impossible since people are religious. What it did was remove the Church from direct influence in political power. Meaning the Church itself has no direct say in policy.
The church is a religious institution. The state is a governmental institution. People are human beings. When in government positions, people do no transform into non-religious beings because of some extreme interpretation of what "separation of church and state" really means.
In England, you had to be a member in good standing with the state-sanctioned church before you could hold public office. The decisions of the state were intermingled with the church's goals and wishes. By extension, you were punished for not belonging to the church by being excluded from public office.
That paradigm had to change if the freedom to worship (or not worship) as one chooses were to be realized.
If the founders had envisioned totally eradicating God from the government, do you think there would be "In God We Trust" on our currency", or "Under God" in our Pledge of Allegiance? Do you believe it's inappropriate for the President (EVERY SINGLE PRESIDENT) to mention at the end of speeches "God bless America?"
The extreme view of restricting anything associated in the slightest way to government from having the slightest hint of religious context was not the intent of the First Amendment:
Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof; or abridging the freedom of speech, or of the press; or the right of the people peaceably to assemble, and to petition the Government for a redress of grievances.[1]
-
I've had many extremely bad experiences with the masons while in the military. Maybe it was the particular lodge, but their morals and principles were extremely compromised, ranging from racism (black against white) to getting a fellow mason off the hook for sexual assault, and everything in between.
I know its not right to judge the entire mason community for such things, as many individuals of significant importance are consistent through US and Hawaii history. But my experience was pretty detrimental to my overall opinion on the free masons. I hope that one day someone can change my opinion.
Yeah, I've had some extremely bad experiences with people in the military, too. Let's give anecdotal evidence how that warped my opinion of the military in general, then give a caveat of how that might not be right to do.
That's a very lame way to smear a group then cover your butt.
-
Maybe it was the particular lodge, but their morals and principles were extremely compromised, ranging from racism (black against white) to getting a fellow mason off the hook for sexual assault, and everything in between.
That's what such networks are for. Every single one of the mentioned founding fathers was racist, though Franklin and Jefferson were less so than many at the time. Even so the country they founded based on "freedom" only allowed people of their own class to vote. It is not and never was about everyone's personal freedom. It was about the freedom of the upper class to conduct its business without the meddling (and excessive taxation) of Monarchs of varying temperament over time. The various States then became similar to small Kingdoms for the plutocratic families that owned and ran them. Those same families still hold the bulk of power in this country, and a few of them in Europe as well. The kings and queens may be gone but their families still hold most of the power.
Even the 2nd amendment, at the time, was not about the individual right to be armed. Are you kidding? At that time being armed was a basic necessity everywhere except in the cities: that wasn't even a question. Rifles (muskets, really) were how many people got their meat and there would still be conflicts with Native Americans for more than 100 years. The 2nd was about the right and responsibility of the States to maintain armed militias both for defense as part of the federal system and against the federal system. Militias which, as you might guess, were under the control of the white, male land owning class. It wasn't about the people's defense against tyranny, it was the ruling class's defense against tyranny. The federal government at the time was not allowed to maintain much of a standing army - a general policy that lasted right up until the Cold War and we were caught flatfooted for the last time with the Korean war. (The fed did wield huge power in the Navy, however.)
My how things have changed. The supreme court has ruled that (what's left of) the 2nd amendment IS about the person right to bear arms, the "Militia" is the federalized National Guard (by legal definition), States have almost no real power to stop the Federal government from doing what it wants, the ruling families now wield their power through multinational corporations and banks (which is why they no longer need powerful states) and the American Armed Forces are funded more than the next 10 countries combined... and act largely to further the economic interests of said multinational corporations and banks. (You have read "War is a Racket" (http://www.ratical.org/ratville/CAH/warisaracket.html), haven't you?)
You and I are taught that its about doing the right thing because it is imperative that the masses be mostly moral without having to be forced. The ruling class has no such limitation. To be fair, their definition of morality is different. The only "problem" is that after nearly 250 years of being told that we're free we all actually ~believe~ it.
-
If the founders had envisioned totally eradicating God from the government, do you think there would be "In God We Trust" on our currency", or "Under God" in our Pledge of Allegiance?
Neither the design of our currency ("In God We Trust" first appeared on coins in the late 1800s and wasn't adopted as our official motto until 1956), nor the Pledge of Allegiance (written 1892, adopted 1942, the words "under God" added1954) have anything to do with the Founders.
I'm not disagreeing that the Founders were religious men, just pointing out a fallacious argument.
-
Neither the design of our currency ("In God We Trust" first appeared on coins in the late 1800s and wasn't adopted as our official motto until 1956), nor the Pledge of Allegiance (written 1892, adopted 1942, the words "under God" added1954) have anything to do with the Founders.
I'm not disagreeing that the Founders were religious men, just pointing out a fallacious argument.
Tom: Notice I didn't ask why THEY (the founders) put those words there. I was asking, if the intent were to remove religion from all things related to government, then these things (currency, pledges, oaths of office) would have not included the word "God" no matter when they came to be.
-
Tom: Notice I didn't ask why THEY (the founders) put those words there. I was asking, if the intent were to remove religion from all things related to government, then these things (currency, pledges, oaths of office) would have not included the word "God" no matter when they came to be.
Ah. Well, dude, that's pretty obvious! Do you think the government today is in accord with the Founders' intentions? I bet, if we were to resurrect them, that after they'd taken a look around, they would collectively slap their heads and proclaim "how did you fuck this up so badly? It's only been 200 years!"
Now, whether their list of objections would include the use of the word "God" in official contexts, I don't know. I bet the list of transgressions more important would be so long that they would die a second time from old age before weighing in on that.
[EDIT to add an actual point]
If you are going to base things on the Founders' intentions, you really can't use examples that didn't occur until after the Founders weren't around to pass judgement on them.
-
Since you guys brought it up, I believe that freemasonry was probably instrumental in the American revolution and the formation of the US. If you look around, you'll find them and their "handwriting on the wall" all over the place.
As for what religious group Freemasonry belongs to, I think it has deep Egyptian religion roots.
-
Ah. Well, dude, that's pretty obvious! Do you think the government today is in accord with the Founders' intentions? I bet, if we were to resurrect them, that after they'd taken a look around, they would collectively slap their heads and proclaim "how did you fuck this up so badly? It's only been 200 years!"
Now, whether their list of objections would include the use of the word "God" in official contexts, I don't know. I bet the list of transgressions more important would be so long that they would die a second time from old age before weighing in on that.
[EDIT to add an actual point]
If you are going to base things on the Founders' intentions, you really can't use examples that didn't occur until after the Founders weren't around to pass judgement on them.
I think the founders who framed our government knew all too well that without acknowledging a higher power than humans, there can be no real human rights.
When in the Course of human events, it becomes necessary for one people to dissolve the political bands which have connected them with another, and to assume among the powers of the earth, the separate and equal station to which the Laws of Nature and of Nature's God entitle them, a decent respect to the opinions of mankind requires that they should declare the causes which impel them to the separation.
We hold these truths to be self-evident, that all men are created equal, that they are endowed by their Creator with certain unalienable Rights, that among these are Life, Liberty and the pursuit of Happiness.
I'm positive these words were carefully chosen, and the meaning is not up for dissection. Rights exist even in the absence of government. They must therefore derive from a different source ...
-
Good point Moosed.
But it's interesting the vagueness the Founders used:
Laws of Nature and Nature's God.
their Creator.
No reference to any particular religion. Just a natural higher power.
I don't don't doubt what the Founders religious beliefs were, but my belief is that Separation of Church and State was established by the Founders so that no one religion can dictate what our rights are.
Laws of Nature and Nature's God.
P.S.
I also enjoy this thread and it's intellectualism and civility. :thumbsup:
-
I think the founders who framed our government knew all too well that without acknowledging a higher power than humans, there can be no real human rights.
While I agree that the Founders probably held this belief, I most vehemently disagree with it. I think that the day we stand up and say
You know what? Let's make the world the way we WANT it to be. We, the people, think that everyone should have enough food, water, power, and liberty to become a self-actualized person. We, the people, are going to make this a place where it's safe to walk the streets at night. We, the people, agree that education is a good thing, and will make it available to all. We, the people, don't think that government has any business regulating X,Y, or Z, and shall shape our governments accordingly. Any gods, deities, higher powers or superior aliens who disagree, feel free to come down and try to convince us otherwise.
On that day, we will take a larger step forward than ever we have in our collective history. I think that secular humanism is the only shot we have at a truly benevolent and egalitarian society. I think it is not until we write superstition out of the equation that we have a shot ant anything remotely resembling world peace. From the dawn of man we've had religion, and while it has given us some nice things, it also has continually given us a world in pieces.
Which relates to marching on Washington, erm, well, it really doesn't. But just by using the words "marching" and "Washington" I stay on topic, right? :crazy:
-
While I agree that the Founders probably held this belief, I most vehemently disagree with it. I think that the day we stand up and say
On that day, we will take a larger step forward than ever we have in our collective history. I think that secular humanism is the only shot we have at a truly benevolent and egalitarian society. I think it is not until we write superstition out of the equation that we have a shot ant anything remotely resembling world peace. From the dawn of man we've had religion, and while it has given us some nice things, it also has continually given us a world in pieces.
Which relates to marching on Washington, erm, well, it really doesn't. But just by using the words "marching" and "Washington" I stay on topic, right? :crazy:
Any collective ideology, philosophy, or belief system can be used for either good or evil. I totally support the positive benefits that society and individuals receive from practicing religion or spiritual beliefs, be it Christianity, Islam, Buddhism, or Wicca!
Where I have to argue against this is when people are killed or hurt or demonized in order to unite the "followers" against a so-called destructive group (Jews, Americans, all Infidels, non-socialists, whoever). Then the religion/system becomes a perversion of conflicting and opposing messages. i.e. if Islam is the religion of peace, explain why so many terrorists in the world are Muslims and use their religion as the basis for their motivation.
If your beliefs give you guidance, comfort, strength, and a moral compass which defines right and wrong, then those can only be good things for the person and society in general. That assumes the definitions of good and evil are universally accepted. Even a child knows that lying is wrong, yet we give politicians a free pass because "they all do it, have always done it, and we just expect it!" :wacko:
As far as fixing the worlds problems, that will NEVER happen in our lifetime. As long as there are those who seek only power, notoriety, wealth, control, or attainment of their particular ideological agendas, how can we all agree on what's the best path for the world? There is also the principle of non-interference, What gives anyone the right to dictate how another is supposed to live? Think about "the homeless situation" in Hawaii. Until this state can fix our own problems, don't start singing "We are the world" just yet!
-
While I agree that the Founders probably held this belief, I most vehemently disagree with it. I think that the day we stand up and say
On that day, we will take a larger step forward than ever we have in our collective history. I think that secular humanism is the only shot we have at a truly benevolent and egalitarian society. I think it is not until we write superstition out of the equation that we have a shot ant anything remotely resembling world peace. From the dawn of man we've had religion, and while it has given us some nice things, it also has continually given us a world in pieces.
Which relates to marching on Washington, erm, well, it really doesn't. But just by using the words "marching" and "Washington" I stay on topic, right? :crazy:
LOL! Good save there, Tom_G. I'll have to put "marching" and "Washington" in my post too... Hey I just did!
Ok back to tangents, I truly admire people's intention of wanting to build a better and a more egalitarian society. I used to believe the same way as you do and took the song by the Beatles "Imagine" to heart.
It surely doesn't hurt to dream of a better world... however, one should stay grounded in reality as well.
"Religion" has not given us a world in pieces -- our world was always in pieces ever since the beginning of man's history. If you look at our human existence from a Christian perspective, it actually explains our human condition really well. Evil and violence has existed from our very beginning as seen in Cain murdering of his brother Abel.
The conclusion of an egalitarian and secular society that you describe is really no different from the conclusion and end-goal of a communist or socialist society where the masses are ruled by an enlightened and perfected few.
The biggest flaw of a secular point of view is that without a belief in an almighty God that created human beings, the view of a human being's nature becomes debased and humans become no more different from an animal. Some of the worst democides recorded in human history are done by godless dictatorial governments.
Communist Russia: 62 million killed
Communist China: 35 million killed
Nazi Germany: 21 million murdered
http://www.hawaii.edu/powerkills/NOTE1.HTM
How can you be sure that a belief in God is superstition? How can someone rule God out when one is not able to empirically prove it? How can one be so sure that something we are not able to see does not exist, just because we have not seen it?
Let me ask you.... What is harder to believe in?
1) That a perfect and righteous kingdom will be established by a perfect God upon Jesus Christ's return?
Or
2) That a utopian society can be created and ruled by perfected human beings?
If history is a good indicator, the second one is more unlikely, knowing the wicked and scheming nature of human beings and knowing that everything created by men entropy and decay over time. Remember, the adage: "today's tyrants were yesterday's heroes." If we have not learned anything, history will prove this time and time again.
Reading the bible, I am fascinated by how much the bible confirms and proves itself -- while we cannot see, God continues to prove that he is real through the history of the Jews. While most religions provide some nice teachings about how we are to live, no other religion has prophecied into the future and fulfilled it like the Bible has. The other exciting thing i find about the Bible, it is not yet done and says a lot about the present and the future.
Just my opinion... It is more realistic to believe in the coming justice of God and to wait in joyful anticipation of Christ's return. It is certainly more believable than that an imperfect and wicked people can create a perfect society.
Ok, sorry guys for the tangent. Back to the topic "marching" in "Washington"....
-
Let me ask you.... What is harder to believe in?
1) That a perfect and righteous kingdom will be established by a perfect God upon Jesus Christ's return?
Or
2) That a utopian society can be created and ruled by perfected human beings?
1 - Jesus Christ's return and a righteous kingdom established by a perfect God.
If history is a good indicator, the second one is more unlikely, knowing the wicked and scheming nature of human beings and knowing that everything created by men entropy and decay over time. Remember, the adage: "today's tyrants were yesterday's heroes." If we have not learned anything, history will prove this time and time again.
I don't remember history indicating the return of Jesus Christ and a righteous kingom established by a perfect God.
If we do not remember our history we are doomed to repeat it.
How many people died during the crusades ?
Thou Shalt not follow a false prophet.
What if Jesus is not the true prophet. Will God send you to hell ?
What if John the Baptist was the true prophet ?
Hypothetical:
John the Baptist came first. True prophet of God.
Satan saw people following him and sent Jesus. People then followed Jesus.
Now Satan secured millions (billions ? ) of minions by sending the false prophet.
Same way he deceived Adam with Eve and the apple. Satan's certainly capable.
Satan then sends Mohammed because he wants more minions. Billions more follow Mohammed.
I know I went way out of bounds but it is logical. If you're Satan, the best way to get more souls is to send more false prophets.
God didn't create men equal, Samuel Colt did.
Back to the topic "marching" in "Washington"....
-
Ok, now we are really off tangent. Just curious, aieahound. Are you really asking because you are asking these questions for real or are you asking to mock because you are offended? If I have unintentionally offended because of my beliefs, pls accept my apologies as it was not my intention to offend.
Otherwise, I will answer your questions civilly assuming that we are here to have a real discussion.
How many people died during the crusades ?
A lot of people died during the crusades. That's what happens when there is a war and bad people want to kill you because you wont convert to their religion. If the Christians did not fight the Muslims off, we will all be under the rule of Shariah law right now and would be living in a Muslim theocracy.
Thou Shalt not follow a false prophet.
What if Jesus is not the true prophet. Will God send you to hell ?
I'm not sure where you got that from. In Christian belief, Jesus is not a prophet but son of God the Father in the flesh.
What if John the Baptist was the true prophet ?
You're right. Jesus said that John was one of the greatest of prophets. But John himself testified about Jesus.
Matthew 3:13-17
13 Then Jesus came from Galilee to the Jordan to be baptized by John. 14 But John tried to deter him, saying, “I need to be baptized by you, and do you come to me?”
15 Jesus replied, “Let it be so now; it is proper for us to do this to fulfill all righteousness.” Then John consented.
16 As soon as Jesus was baptized, he went up out of the water. At that moment heaven was opened, and he saw the Spirit of God descending like a dove and alighting on him. 17 And a voice from heaven said, “This is my Son, whom I love; with him I am well pleased.”
Hypothetical:
John the Baptist came first. True prophet of God.
Satan saw people following him and sent Jesus. People then followed Jesus.
Now Satan secured millions (billions ? ) of minions by sending the false prophet.
Same way he deceived Adam with Eve and the apple. Satan's certainly capable.
Satan then sends Mohammed because he wants more minions. Billions more follow Mohammed.
I know I went way out of bounds but it is logical. If you're Satan, the best way to get more souls is to send more false prophets.
Yes, you're right that Satan will be sending false prophets after Christ. Jesus did warn against false teachers. There is even one mentioned in the bible that will claim (future tense) to be the Christ and will deceive many.
God didn't create men equal, Samuel Colt did.
Back to the topic "marching" in "Washington"....
I wholeheartedly agree with you on this! :Shaka:
-
Let me ask you.... What is harder to believe in?
1) That a perfect and righteous kingdom will be established by a perfect God upon Jesus Christ's return?
Or
2) That a utopian society can be created and ruled by perfected human beings?
Marching.
Washington.
;)
Honestly, for me #1 is impossible to believe in, while #2 is merely "nearly impossible."
Much like the pro- vs the anti- gunners, both sides can trot out instances of "religion done good" and "religion done evil." Meh. To me, that's completely irrelevant. The fact that such a dichotomy exists proves conclusively that religion isn't the problem, it's a symptom.
Where this discussion is headed must certainly include the nature of faith. So, I see two possibilities:
1. Some being, or beings, beyond my scope of comprehension decided to make this universe.
2. Weird shit, beyond my comprehension, just happened and resulted in this universe.
While #2 is absurd, #1 is complete fantasy. And to paraphrase a great fictional character, when you eliminate the complete fantasy, whatever remains, however absurd, must be reality.
Do I really need to say "my opinion" and other such disclaimers? Consider that all said! Oh, by the way, you guys are all in for a rude disappearance once I wake up!
-
Haha, thanks Tom_G. Your last comment made me laugh!
[edit] You mean to say an explosion in a printing press produced the US dictionary? (Sorry, couldn't resist!).
In all seriousness though, I find that the methodology you applied could be done in reverse in support of #1.
The only way I can believe that an explosion created the universe and all its wonders is if "someone" had full control of all the variables. I cannot imagine how mathematically possible it would be to create this world without an intelligent God controlling all the infinite variables during such an explosion.
I would never dream in a billion years how any random demolition work would magically create anything but a mess.
-
I just had an epiphany. And yes I would have deemed it not long ago a crazy nut rant and a commie idea but read the whole thing and consider it carefully recalling recent history to that of long ago history. Before one decides to go into an economics lesson, think it through very carefully while considering recent changes in technology.
All this banter on this thread that would ultimately solve nothing even if implemented as it should be constitutionally today. In other words, our grandchildren will lose their guns, you can bet on it if we don't make major changes today. So what’s the damn point if we don’t change our whole course now? This is what hit me while reading through this thread.
We once had a purpose and that purpose was to build a free society for anyone who wanted to join that purpose. We have since extended those basic freedoms to all races within our society and we’re currently struggling with extending it to accommodation of “minority lifestyles”. That’s in-line with advancing our constitution, sweeping up the “dust bunnies” now on that front and yes there are still classes and poor people etc. So there’s still more work to do that way but the main purpose has been met/completed.
What we’re now missing is our “societal” purpose. There is this society that has since been built and we forgot that our goal has been met. Our society has no purpose but to enrich it and only it because that is what was needed to build it. Therein lay the problems we face today, we’re missing purpose because our great goal was met. I’ve had everything I could want but I’m really not happy when I look around at our society, it’s broken and repetitive with no damn direction any longer, no new frontiers and no real dreams for our children to ponder.
We put our faith into a fiat currency with a central core… that is now our only purpose as a society. Like it or not, that’s what each of us has done, you can call it whatever, bottom line it only leads to self consumption/self destruction/and eventually all biological destruction. One can easily pretend that’s not true, but the fact is, it is true, look around you. We can argue God, Guns, and Rights till the cows come home and in that time we will only consume ourselves. Guns will inevitably be taken away in our current direction of societal purpose, it’s inevitable.
It’s now time to put our faith into a new purpose, a purpose that establishes a society of enlightenment in which we become very literally part of the heavens (space) and not isolated within them/it. Fiat currency is fine and dandy for now, but what we spend our currency/faith on as a nation is all wrong, our faith should be invested in enlightenment (bettering our environment, expanding our physical presence beyond this planet, establishing new frontiers in all facets of life and firstly helping those who are starving so they can reach our current efficiency level and onward). We don’t do this because there is no currency reward for possible pointless exploration or no currency rewards for helping others advance as well. But all that’s just a scheme, it’s just some scheme that was tossed together to establish some controls on a people who were struggling to very literally create a society. We’re now a society that has exceeded its needs through possible extreme productivity. That’s what we’re not seeing.
To be Frank… we have a society that can easily provide for everyone as it has become that efficient. We’re just not allowing it to produce what it has the ability to produce. Efficiency coupled with greed is why there are not enough jobs to go around and people are still starving in the world. Gun control is merely an issue today because we have not risen or adopted a new purpose and our current direction will only lead to self destruction/self consumption and gun rights will be long lost before that happens.
Seriously, who cares if the car companies are owned by the government, in fact why should they be owned at all by anyone? Why can’t we just go to work and make lots more cars with our government issued fiat currency? Communism? No, not communism - just do away with what’s essentially nothing more than fake profits.
It’s now fiat currency that works on faith alone and its backing is nothing but smoke and mirrors now. Why can’t everyone be put to work and paid in fiat currency? Why can’t we remove the greed factor by simply ignoring it and going to work and make Uncle Sam give us fiat currency for doing so? Ignore the greed, go to the store and get what you need with that faith based fiat currency as we do now. Think about efficiency… our possible efficiency if everyone works, far exceeds the world’s needs now.
Our problem is only the central Banking system trying to control everything. Abolish the Federal Reserve and seize our money presses. We can turn countless machines out of factories per day; we can harvest countless acres globally per day. We can responsibly build damns around the world and divert that water anywhere we need it. All we have to do is… do it. Only we are stopping us from advancing our freedoms and societal evolutions. Who would be in charge? ROTATE THEM ALL DAMN FREQUENTLY.
Very seriously I’m really seeing everything now as a damn bunch of BS and a damn waste of human existence. It’s time for us to move forward as a species and put away the useless systems that keep us held back as a species. They will all let us down just as we are seeing today, our system is broken and we all damn well know that. So what would be a responsible move for our grandkids? Heck… I would volunteer to haul the garbage in an enlightened society, but this isn’t such a society, it’s dog eat dog because we have allowed that to continue for no apparent reason except we’re simply not aware it could be different if we made it so. I’m nearly an old timer (50) and those near and above my age seriously think, just 20 years ago we weren’t able to do the amazing things we can do today… think about how far efficiency has advanced through our incredible machines, computers and robotics etc in just the past 20 years alone! We are on the threshold of what can be an incredibly enlightened society if we take the reins of power back, we the people and we may indeed need our guns to do just that! This maybe our last chance to turn our society around before it’s too late.
-
The problem with public education is it is too much about public (funding and social programs) and not enough about education. Too often, we feel we have had an original thought, when in fact we are sometimes centuries behind the curve! Imagine a world where we value knowledge of those who have gone before us and build upon it ... rather than reinvent the wheel!
The Age of Enlightenment
Jean-Jacques Rousseau
Jean-Jacques Rousseau in the mid 1700s attempted to persuade people that Locke and Hobbes had placed too much importance on the rights of individuals, leading to a pursuit for individual material gain in a laissez-faire economy at the expense of the pursuit of civic virtues associated with the common good. He felt that a growing division of labour exacerbated natural inequalities and culminated in the establishment of a powerful mercantile and propertied class that dominated the rest of society. To avoid the jeopardy of civil war, this class sought to appease the anger of the poor by instituting a new social order, a civil society that would provide equality and freedom for all. But this was just a trick, said Rousseau, that allowed the wealthy to maintain inequalities of power and privilege by postulating an equal freedom to acquire such advantages. And because of the consent given by the poor to such a form of governance, they were unlikely to rebel.
Rousseau devised the idea of the social contract as a means whereby citizens would make the common good their highest priority. This is accomplished by each person subjugating their right for the individual pursuit of happiness to that of their community’s right for collective well-being. The state is the arena for defining the nature of the common good, and civil liberty emerges when all people are willing to abide by the general will. Since common people are to be the law-makers, they will promulgate laws that result in moderating accumulation of individual wealth and thereby promote equality and trust.
It was the thinkers of the Scottish Enlightenment, notably David Hume, Adam Ferguson and Adam Smith, that laid the philosophical premises for capitalist mercantilism.
David Hume
David Hume, in his Treatise on Human Nature, argued that there was no unity between Reason and Morality, and that people set their goals on the basis of Morality, but use Reason in achieving them. His three fundamental rules of conduct - the stability of possessions, their transfer by consent, and the performance of promises - are human conventions, and not based in any ‘natural law’. The implications of this thought were profound, leading to the notion that people, in using their reason to follow their self-interests, eventually achieve the interests of society as a whole. People establish and follow the laws of the land, not so as to serve some universal good, but to maximize their self-interests in an enlightened manner.
Adam Ferguson and Adam Smith
Ferguson and Smith both held that the binding principle of civil society was a private morality predicated on public recognition by one’s peers, joined through bonds of moral sentiment. This philosophical stance did not preclude Adam Smith from asserting that, because an individual’s identity and power rested on their perceived value within an arena of exchange, the whole of society would be better off if marketplace exchanges were unconstrained by the state.
Immanuel Kant
Immanuel Kant’s main principle regarding civil society was that people should treat other people as ends in themselves rather than means to the ends of others. In other words, we must consider how others would benefit themselves from our actions, rather than how we might use them only for our own benefit, and we must ensure that whatever means we use to pursue our own self-interests does not interfere with others’ rights to pursue theirs. And while Kant echoed Hume in his relegation of ethics and morals to the private sphere, he advocated a public arena of rational, critical discourse concerning the ‘ends’ posed by the state. In this regard, he was the first to suggest that a functional civil society should be seen as distinct from the state.
-
The problem with public education is it is too much about public (funding and social programs) and not enough about education. Too often, we feel we have had an original thought, when in fact we are sometimes centuries behind the curve! Imagine a world where we value knowledge of those who have gone before us and build upon it ... rather than reinvent the wheel!
Oh no... I fully agree. I know the notion is nothing new about the currency etc, but in the past we didn't have the technological resources we have today. In the past 10 years alone we have made even greater steps forward technologically. But way back, there was struggle pure and simple just to get by and that was for everyone generally, if they didn’t just die from starvation. The elite could never hope to fully control a people 24/7 365 days a year everywhere all the time.
Here’s what I’m really getting at and this is the core of the present issue. This technology as currently abused will put full power in the hands of current elite like no power ever held by tyrants past. This is why I say, we are on the threshold now, not in 10 or 20 years, we are about to step over that threshold TODAY. I felt it but it hadn’t dawned on me how utterly historically different today is from any other moment of history. The power of today’s technology can either destroy the freedom of all people or if the power is reclaimed back by the people it can restore freedoms successful direction. It’s in these times today that we cannot, I repeat cannot allow the crime in government and corrupt financial system to continue forward. We have to crush it now before we can no longer assemble to do so later. If we don’t, we will lose everything and that isn’t BS and you all damn well know it.
So all this bantering here about 2a, rights etc… will all be for not later, it’s inevitable. Look at the corruption in DC and our military strategically positioned about the BRICS banking system nations by virtue of the fear from the current world banking system seeing it’s petro dollar about to be brought to its knees. They have passed bills to control the internet (our communications system), they are leveraging for full control.
Here’s the deal, call me crazy, but here’s the fact, it’s clear as day to anyone who can see the writing on the wall, this is our last chance.
-
Here’s the deal, call me crazy, but here’s the fact, it’s clear as day to anyone who can see the writing on the wall, this is our last chance.
Okay, you lost me. This is our last chance? What's this? The march on DC? Commandeer the Internet? Full blown rebellion? The French Revolution: American Style? ???
-
Okay, you lost me. This is our last chance? What's this? The march on DC? Commandeer the Internet? Full blown rebellion? The French Revolution: American Style? ???
It means we need to stop fooling ourselves and be prepared. I too have been fooling myself and ignoring the warning signs and considering the theatrics of folks like Alex Jones to be whacky (I still see many things he says as beyond fringe). But tonight it just dawned on me; I now see what’s been causing that uneasy tension in so many people. I couldn’t get my finger on it until just tonight.
So it just means we need to be prepared and even though it sounds really idiotic, hope when it happens there’s a large enough rebellion (not the march) to inspire enough people to join in and get our nation back into the proper hands of… “we the people. “ I’m thinking our military may play a role in starting and backing the rebellion. I can only hope that’s the case.
Rebellion or not, I see our future as screwed for some time to come. If the bible has its way… there will be no rebellion and we will step blindly as a people over the threshold we’re currently on and march right into revelations within 30 or more years. Either we face upheaval now for a while till things get back on track or we give away our nation completely and irretrievably to the corrupt elite and continue as their subjects under very uncomfortable conditions for many years to come.
When I was a younger man, I never thought our nation would become what it’s become, I would have slapped someone for saying so.
-
Well we seemed to have stepped WAY beyond this march topic...
-
I would never dream in a billion years how any random demolition work would magically create anything but a mess.
It did create a mess, but took 14 billion years to do so. Keep imagining!
-
Well we seemed to have stepped WAY beyond this march topic...
Yep, it demonstrates very well, basic human nature and the need for restraint though a "Constitution" of some temperament. Is it any wonder why ours has been used as T.P. by Congress, the Executive and Judiciary branches of our government?
So we inevitably see an open carry armed March scheduled on DC. Not a surprise at all. This is a very sensitive subject inducing a great deal of ideology to surface. Today we have the internet so such organized demonstrations can be arranged relatively easily by the common person. At the rate our basic liberties/rights/privileges are being crapped on by DC, Tomorrow we probably won’t have that privilege either.
Do any of the old timers recall when you could build a house without a permit, inspections and government scrutiny? How many like type liberties have been lost since those days? Sort of turns your stomach when thinking about it? It turns mine.
-
Thanks for the reply on my prior post MDS. And no, I am not offended, just enjoying the intellectual conversation and discussion.
One comment though, it must be true because the bible tells me so doesn't really fly. Depending on your faith of course.
:stopjack:
So if I read your last post right, the march on Washington is not just about 2A rights, but the entire state of affairs ?
-
MDS - I'm not sure I quite follow all that you've posted. I'll re-read it again and maybe you can explain at one of the pau hanas.
I think that you're trying to say that the US basically has no more vision / plan beyond economic wealth and prosperity and that folks are getting complacent because we have reached that goal.
Reminds me of an exhortation by a prophet in the bible "my people perish from a lack of knowledge."
Unfortunately, groups against our way of life have established clear visions for changing the US.
1. Communist infiltration goals published in 1963. This one is scary considering how much they have accomplished.
http://rense.com/general32/americ.htm
2. Islamic strategy for conquering Europe and the US:
http://www.islamreview.com/articles/islamicstrategy.shtml
-
Thanks for the reply on my prior post MDS. And no, I am not offended, just enjoying the intellectual conversation and discussion.
Thanks aieahound.
One comment though, it must be true because the bible tells me so doesn't really fly. Depending on your faith of course.
Understood. Like you said, the statement that "its in the bible so it must be true" is really more of an expression of faith that what got included in the Bible is what God had intended to be included in its final version. Hence the saying, "written by human hands but divinely inspired."
In one sense, the Bible is a compilation of written account by the Jews of mankind's origins, their genealogy, their history, their culture, their laws, eyewitness accounts and testimonies of Jesus, and letters written by the Apostles and first Christians. The various books in the Bible can be viewed as historical as they have been crossed reference with early historical records from other nations (Egyptian and Roman) indicating that those incidents did happen.
However, the interaction of the Jews with their "Jewish" God Yahweh is recorded so intertwined in this historical book, that the Bible gives witness and testimony to the divine God and his son Jesus. In effect, God has revealed Himself to the world, to and through his "chosen" people.
Did the Jews actually cross the Red Sea to escape their slavery in Egypt? I would think so. It is not scientific proof but I ask myself: "why would the Jewish people celebrate Passover so religiously if the journey out of Egypt did not really happen?" Not really sure how one would prove this but since i was not there when it happened, then it becomes a matter of faith.
Thank you for listening.
-
Shucks, My Bad Jl808. Referred to the wrong member. :oops: Thanks for the comments.
Enjoying this thoroughly. Amazing we here on 2A can talk intelligently and with civility through such a touchy topic. :thumbsup:
The Pau Hana should be awesome !
Still don't agree though. I'm more in line with Tom G.
Imagine all the people.....
-
A bit more further off topic, but who decided what books were to be included and not included in the bible? I have heard there are many other books that are not/have not been put into the bible.
-
A bit more further off topic, but who decided what books were to be included and not included in the bible? I have heard there are many other books that are not/have not been put into the bible.
Yes there were books that did not get included. I am not 100% sure of the details but from my limited understanding, the criteria used in what books to include was whether the books were divinely inspired by God or not.
The Old Testament was based on the Hebrew Torah. After Christ, the New Testament books were written as testimony about the fulfillment of the messianic promise of God in the Old Testament.
The Roman Catholic church first canonized the Bible in the 4th century. The Protestant reformation movement took off some books later because they believed those books were not divinely inspired.
You can find some details about what books were included or not in Wikipedia.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Books_of_the_Bible
-
Shucks, My Bad Jl808. Referred to the wrong member. :oops: Thanks for the comments.
Enjoying this thoroughly. Amazing we here on 2A can talk intelligently and with civility through such a touchy topic. :thumbsup:
The Pau Hana should be awesome !
Still don't agree though. I'm more in line with Tom G.
Imagine all the people.....
Fair enough -- You can put your faith in John Lennon while I'll put my faith in my God. (ducks for cover) :)
-
Yes there were books that did not get included. I am not 100% sure of the details but from my limited understanding, the criteria used in what books to include was whether the books were divinely inspired by God or not.
The Old Testament was based on the Hebrew Torah. After Christ, the New Testament books were written as testimony about the fulfillment of the messianic promise of God in the Old Testament.
The Roman Catholic church first canonized the Bible in the 4th century. The Protestant reformation movement took off some books later because they believed those books were not divinely inspired.
You can find some details about what books were included or not in Wikipedia.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Books_of_the_Bible (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Books_of_the_Bible)
I am not dispelling your statement, I just want to let you know that Wiki is the very unreliable. You can't quote Wiki as a source for any college paper. Just be careful of what you read on Wiki...it is not a reliable source of information.
-
I am not dispelling your statement, I just want to let you know that Wiki is the very unreliable. You can't quote Wiki as a source for any college paper. Just be careful of what you read on Wiki...it is not a reliable source of information.
As a rule of thumb, Wiki is an excellent starting point for research or for quick facts. But, it's a good idea to follow the links in a wiki article in the bibliography references. If the support links back-up the wiki information, it's probably okay.
YMMV
-
michaelbsdad and moosed -- good points both and point well taken. I didn't know where to find a good list and Wikipedia seemed like a good place to start.
-
michaelbsdad and moosed -- good points both and point well taken. I didn't know where to find a good list and Wikipedia seemed like a good place to start.
Moosed made a good point...just be careful. Some of the stuff on Wiki is spot on, some is not.
Found this...maybe this will help you! (sorry for the length...)
CBN.com (Christian Broadcast Network) Program Director Chris Carpenter recently sat down with Bock, a research professor at Dallas Theological Seminary, to discuss how the New Testament books were selected, the books that didn’t make it, and a Christian’s best argument to defend the validity of the Bible.
The early Christians worshipped Jesus Christ during His life and were guided by the Apostles after His death and resurrection. They had no texts to go by for direction. How then, do you explain the selection of books for the New Testament?
Well, it is a process that took time. What I am talking about is that in the First Century we don’t have the last of the Gospels written in all likelihood until the 90’s. So, you have a 60 year period in which you don’t have all the New Testament books nor have they been identified. And they are not functioning as a New Testament. So, the question then becomes how they taught theology in light of the development of those books particularly as those books began to circulate. It took time for certain books to reach certain regions. The way that happened is basically through three means: short doctrinal summaries that you see encased within some of the New Testament material, there is hymnic material which we also see encased in the New Testament material that tells us they were singing theology, and there are the various rights that symbolize theology like the baptism and the Lord’s Supper. So, these all re-affirm what the basic theology was.
When we hear about “missing gospels”, the name Nag Hammadi invariably is attached. What is the significance of Nag Hammadi? What was contained in these missing gospels? What makes them popular to people who question the authenticity of scripture?
We have 52 books that are not in our Bible from the second and third centuries that give evidence of a kind of Christianity that is an attempt to meld Greco-Roman philosophy and Christianity – and to make Christianity more palatable to a Greco-Roman world. That is really what those texts are about. We actually dug them up in 1945 (near Nag Hammadi, Egypt). So, they have been around for just over 60 years. We have known about them since the time of Irenaeus because he wrote about them in 180 A.D. The attention they have gotten is coupled with the cultural factor – that is that history is supposedly written by the winners and now we are hearing the voice of the losers. So, the thought is that we need to re-address the imbalance. Of course, the other half of the story is that sometimes the winners deserve to win. And that is part of the story I am trying to tell. I’m trying to explain why it is that this extra biblical material ended up not having an impact.
You mention Irenaeus. Who was he in the grand scheme of theological history?
He is a church father writing at the end of the Second Century. His first work was called “Against Heresies”. He was becoming alarmed by the rising up of various attempts to redefine Christianity. You have Marcion who is trying to remove anything Jewish. You have DeMontanus who is talking about access to a direct revelation. And then you have these Gnostics who are trying to find Greek philosophy in Christianity. So, he writes a work that is really against all of them but he spends the bulk of his time on the Gnostics.
For clarification, how would you define the Gnostic gospels?
Gnosticism comes from the Greek word for gnosis which means knowledge. It is a religion that claims to have secret knowledge above and beyond what most people have associated with religion. It includes ideas like what really counts is the spiritual. All matter is evil. God did not create creation, underling gods did. That creation was so flawed that matter will not be redeemed in you. This means that Jesus did not inhabit the flesh. There is no incarnation. It also means that there is no major discussion of sin and it also means that when the resurrection comes it will only involve your spirit going back to God. There is no resurrection of the body.
In theological circles I often hear people talk about canon. What is the canon?
Canon is s Greek word that means read or standard. So, it is a way of saying this is where we get the books that are the standard of our faith. That process of recognition of what was inspired took four centuries. The first person to list the 27 books that we have in our New Testament was a church father named Athanasius. He did it in 367 A.D. But the first portions of the New Testament to be recognized were the New Testament gospels, the Acts, and the epistles of Paul. That happened at the end of the Second Century, long before the process was completed. This is because these books were debated. Some of them were discussed as to whether they belonged in, like II Peter and II and III John. Books that didn’t make it in like I Clement Shepherd and Earnest. This is because they were on some lists but not on others originally. The factors that led to their selection included: did they go back to the Apostles or someone working very closely with the Apostles, were they theologically orthodox, and were they being used in a widespread way in the church geographically and through the passage of time. This was done to test their quality.
Why then, don’t you think some of these missing gospels were not included in the New Testament? I ask this based on the fact that in that era it was not nearly as easy to get the texts from one location to another. There was no technology to mail, email, or to broadcast in any way. They could have been just as valid.
The missing gospels were excluded from the New Testament mainly because they did not go back to the earliest generation. They didn’t have solid apostolic context or roots. Also, they had a very distinct theology, or competing theology. This is in regard to God in creation, with regard to the person of Jesus – which He could not have been incarnate, with regard to not dealing with sin. And so there were certain things that would have automatically excluded many of these works because of what they were teaching.
In relation to what you just said, here is an argument that has been popping up over the last several years mainly due to the Da Vinci Code. How do we know whether the New Testament as Christians know it is completely accurate? Man is frail and is prone to mistakes. Isn’t it possible that some of these early church fathers could have made errors?
There are really two questions and the first is how do we know the New Testament we have is an accurate reflection of what the New Testament was? First, before we can talk about what is accurate we have got to decide whether this really goes back. The answer to that question is that the amount of manuscript evidence that we have for the New Testament indicates to us that it has been transmitted with a good degree of care and what we have is very much a reflection of what existed at the start. Now, with regard to accuracy that is also a two level question. The issue of truth is a complex question. How do you prove truth? In some ways, when you are not dealing with science it is a very hard thing to do. So, what you are dealing with is that you want your hands on the best sources. You want your hands on those sources that the closest to what takes place. That is why the apostolic roots are so important. That is why the apostolic association of people is so important. Because if you look at our four gospels, most conservatives will say Matthew and John were written by the Apostles but Mark and Luke were not. Mark was an associate of Peter. Luke was close to Paul and had contact with many others. That is how you put that together. Then, the next thing is to ask yourself whether there is a coherence in what is going on in these texts. Do they make sense alongside one another? The answer to that question is yes. And the last thing is, does this explanation have more plausibility than other explanations for putting this together. Because you are dealing with the humanities and not the sciences you cannot come up with 100 percent proof. There is no experiment you can run that can replay the First Century. So, you are left in a situation where you are dealing with the plausibility of what is going on. The last factor, which is important theologically, but which most people don’t even think about is the role of spirit in opening up a person’s heart to what is going on in these texts. This is because of the claims that God is active in certain ways, even unusual ways. For some people this is a hurdle that they cannot get past.
For the average Christian, what is their best argument to defend the accuracy of the New Testament?
I actually think the best argument is to look at the behaviors of those who were closest to Jesus that we know about. Something changed them. The New Testament texts make it clear that something changed them. If I can say this, where they were wimps before the Cross, they were bold after the Cross. So, the very Peter who denied Jesus according to tradition was crucified for his faith afterward for standing up for Jesus. The very Paul who persecuted the Church and tried to remove Christians, put his life on the line and according to tradition he was also crucified as a result of defending his faith. If you knew you made it up … why would you die for it? That puts us into a plausibility position. What is more plausible to believe … that the early Church made this up and then died for it, or, this really happened and that explains the transformation?
Point blank, can these missing gospels do anything for us?
Historically, this stuff benefits us in understanding the debate that is going on between Christianity and these fringe groups. You get to hear from them directly. It is always helpful as a matter of history. But the bottom line question for most people is ‘does this stuff help us understand orthodox, real, authentic Christianity any better?’ The answer to that question is no. It doesn’t other than to provide a mirror against which we can see Christianity interacting with that which it views is not what Christianity is. To that extent it can be helpful.
-
Interesting. Another factor to consider is how many times the bible has been translated since its original writing and been through 2 already dead languages.
As I've learned translating Hawaiian, their is usually no direct translation that can say the same thing in both languages. You can get close, or paraphrase, but not say the exact same thing.
-
Interesting. Another factor to consider is how many times the bible has been translated since its original writing and been through 2 already dead languages.
As I've learned translating Hawaiian, their is usually no direct translation that can say the same thing in both languages. You can get close, or paraphrase, but not say the exact same thing.
Translations of the Bible were important because prior to them, only royalty, priestly and scholar classes were able to read the Bible. The masses had no access to learning how to read Hebrew, Aramaic, Greek or Latin, and had to depend on the priests to read and explain the Bible to them.
Protestant reformer Martin Luther's translation to German was significant because the Bible became accessible to the common folk.
King James' translation to old English is also a significant translation as the first English translation of the Bible.
There are lots of translations of the Bible now into many different languages around the world, not just English.
A good thing to know about the translation you are reading is the translation method used... 1) word for word translation?, 2) meaning for meaning translation?, or 3) some degree of combination between?
There are a bunch of revisionist translation that makes people suspect what agenda is behind the translation. Best to know something about the version you are reading. There is a degree of distrust for some of the newer revisionist translations that make people refer back to the King James Version often. King James was actually quite a scholar of the Bible himself and knew the Bible very well. The old English of KJV is kind of hard to understand though, so I prefer referencing New King James Version instead.
In case you didn't know, there is a Hawaiian Pidgin version of the New Testament actually, called Da Jesus Book.
https://www.youversion.com/bible/76/jhn.1.hwc
You may want to refer to NKJV if you are wondering what you're reading though. :)
https://www.youversion.com/bible/1/jhn.1.nkjv
-
Oh, dear.
Um. March. Washington.
:D
Generations of biblical scholars have hashed such issues out with no clear resolution. I doubt we'll reach any solid conclusions here and I'd take a moment to point out that in such topics the risk of stepping on toes is incredibly high. Wars actually have been started over it, not that I think it would get that heated here.
Talk about understanding the foundation of language that a society rests on and how shifting context shifts meaning and belief. I get the connection between this and the constitutional crux that this march in Washington is based on. I might suggest that the topic has wandered far enough afield that there is little chance it will shed any further light on the topic. These are now quite treacherous waters.
I've enjoyed reading it and participating as much as I did and its still going well... just figured I'd pop in a "be careful!" moment because... well, just because.
-
Thanks clshade. Yes the discussion has wandered off too far from the original post. And thanks for the word of caution.
Back to the original program.
-
Oh look in the sky...I think I see some MARCHING clouds...and something else, could it be? Yes, it looks like the WASHINGTON monument!
:shaka: :shaka:
-
.
-
Thanks for the reply on my prior post MDS. And no, I am not offended, just enjoying the intellectual conversation and discussion.
One comment though, it must be true because the bible tells me so doesn't really fly. Depending on your faith of course.
:stopjack:
So if I read your last post right, the march on Washington is not just about 2A rights, but the entire state of affairs ?
As per the Bible… I don’t subscribe to the notion of it predicting anything, just tossed that in there for all the folks who think Revelations pertains to the here and now and that would be an interpretation derived through a fixed perspective. I was raised Christian and went to Antioch and studied for the ministries years ago and while there found that religion was far too submerged in human interpretation, political agenda (for the bible King James and the Scottish Nobles), etc. That’s when I left the Church and realized spiritualism is a personal relationship course only. And before any believers pipe up on that matter, Jesus said that the truth would require more books than could fit on earth. So the notion we can live our lives through a bible inspired and formed by interest of the Scottish Nobel agenda to unify a at that time a divided empire and that somehow a bias man inspired collection of formerly cave bound scrolls prejudicially interpreted has the answers for everything is at best laughable. It’s time to think as a Man and to put your faith on that inner feeling of the truth that dwells within you. Today is filled with far more intricate issues that could have never hoped to be experienced by the many generations passed. “The Bible tells me so” is an opinion based on a narrow child like perspective perception. As like with most everyone, the internal questioning as to “why do I think that or feel that?” never comes to mind. Very rarely, if ever, do people question their own “beliefs” and “opinions” thus true understanding is never developed within them. That is an inarguable self evident truth and it’s precisely why the “church” is dying today. It’s dying because it has failed to grow though realizing and sharing more truth but rather it has opted to flounder in the stagnant past of a few previously expressed truths.
So yes, the March is about many things, not just 2A.
-
MDS - I'm not sure I quite follow all that you've posted. I'll re-read it again and maybe you can explain at one of the pau hanas.
I think that you're trying to say that the US basically has no more vision / plan beyond economic wealth and prosperity and that folks are getting complacent because we have reached that goal.
Reminds me of an exhortation by a prophet in the bible "my people perish from a lack of knowledge."
Unfortunately, groups against our way of life have established clear visions for changing the US.
1. Communist infiltration goals published in 1963. This one is scary considering how much they have accomplished.
http://rense.com/general32/americ.htm (http://rense.com/general32/americ.htm)
2. Islamic strategy for conquering Europe and the US:
http://www.islamreview.com/articles/islamicstrategy.shtml (http://www.islamreview.com/articles/islamicstrategy.shtml)
Oh yeah... they have indeed put those agendas into practice. In-fact we can look to the culprit for a reason as to how and why this is the case. How many families control the current world banking system? Who are they? Do they get together? If they do get together, where and when do they do this? How can they continue to hold control? What sources and ideologies can they introduce to keep that control?
During and before King James era we had a divided empire, it was the Scottish nobles who ultimately seized control and they did this through a series of events. That’s part of History that is better left for one to read about than to describe here. How did the Scottish nobles gain control and what was used in an attempt to unify the crumbling empire?
Today we have a world banking system that has ultimate control. The basic formula for control really hasn’t changed much and if one takes the time to read about historical controlling entities and what they did to obtain that control they will begin to get a better grasp on what we’re facing in the here and now.
We need to look at all groups and realize that most are simply being used as pawns. Again, we now have another chess game in play but in this case it’s on a grander scale (Global).
They are currently sewing chaos to create diversions, diversions to keep our attentions on everything but what they are truly focusing on at this time. At this time they’re positioning themselves to leverage the BRICS nations and they are killing many birds with a handful of stones. The artistry involved in the many occurring events is fascinatingly despicable.
The march on DC is benign comparatively to that of what should be going on today.
-
http://www.drsharonschuetz.com/the-factslegal-ramifications-and-consequences-of-the-armed-march-on-dc/ (http://www.drsharonschuetz.com/the-factslegal-ramifications-and-consequences-of-the-armed-march-on-dc/)
-
Man I hope these opportunists don't actually show up and march...btw, isn't his radio show funded by the Russians?
-
Man I hope these opportunists don't actually show up and march...btw, isn't his radio show funded by the Russians?
Our government is funded by Communist China. So, what's your point?
-
Or government is funded by Communist China. So, what's your point?
No, it was actually JUST a question...I thought I remembered reading that somewhere. I was just curious.
-
No, it was actually JUST a question...I thought I remembered reading that somewhere. I was just curious.
http://www.aim.org/aim-column/kgb-tv-to-air-show-hosted-by-anti-war-marine-vet/ (http://www.aim.org/aim-column/kgb-tv-to-air-show-hosted-by-anti-war-marine-vet/)
-
Here's the reality of our system...
Trampling of first ammendment rights and so on, if the IRS and the AP records scandal wasn't enough to expose the abuse here's another one. Adam is the one who organized the armed march on DC.
http://www.infowars.com/report-adam-kokesh-to-be-charged-with-assaulting-a-federal-officer/ (http://www.infowars.com/report-adam-kokesh-to-be-charged-with-assaulting-a-federal-officer/)
-
Adam was at a permitted demonstration in a park created for demonstrations while speaking about marijuana legalization. Police moved in to arrest him for what appears to be no legal reason. After arresting him they charged him with resisting arrest and assaulting a federal officer (in essence he was arrested for allegedly resisting arrest). They are currently holding him in a federal detention center, bail denied. This is obviously in reprisal for planning the march on DC.
As I said, it would be interesting to see how this pans out. Now we’re seeing how it’s panning out. This is clearly another example in how extensive abuse of power has gone. What’s most disturbing is how it occurs openly and not under obscure circumstances and there’s seemingly no hesitation on behalf of the abusers. Even the court has backed the abuse. Our complacency and tolerance as a people have reached detrimental levels. We hope the system still works and when it clearly fails we grumble, forget about it and move on as if it were simply an isolated fluke. Here’s a news flash, the system is clearly broken. It’s not about to break, it’s broken at all levels. We see it happening daily.
I wish it were still possible to say, these things will be corrected, just need to have some faith. Unless someone has buried their heads in the sand, there’s no legitimate argument to the contrary. It’s pretty damn clear the system is uncontrollably hell bent on putting our nation into a second American Revolution. I hope all of you are emotionally ready for what’s fairly self evident. These are very dismal times for our Nation.
http://www.infowars.com/adam-kokesh-calls-for-new-american-revolution/ (http://www.infowars.com/adam-kokesh-calls-for-new-american-revolution/)
-
For some reason out of the blue Adam was released from federal detention today even though he was being held without bail. Very strange situation...
http://www.infowars.com/adam-kokesh-released/ (http://www.infowars.com/adam-kokesh-released/)
Let's see what happens next.
-
Here's how this one ended...guys like him give gun owners a bad rap.
1) On the Fourth of July Libertarian activist Adam Kokesh posted a video of himself wielding and loading a pump action shotgun in Freedom Plaza in Washington, DC. Possession of an unregistered firearm and carrying of guns in public are both crimes in Washington, DC."
2) Police searched the Northern Virginia home of Adam Kokesh Tuesday evening and took him into custody on a felony charge of being in possession of hallucinogenic mushrooms while also having a gun (drugs, weapons).
http://www.usatoday.com/story/news/nation/2013/07/10/adam-kokesh-libertarian-gun-rights-virginia-shotgun/2504911/ (http://www.usatoday.com/story/news/nation/2013/07/10/adam-kokesh-libertarian-gun-rights-virginia-shotgun/2504911/)