A march on Washington with loaded rifles (Read 61889 times)

Jl808

Re: A march on Washington with loaded rifles
« Reply #100 on: May 09, 2013, 04:48:59 PM »
Haha, thanks Tom_G. Your last comment made me laugh!

[edit] You mean to say an explosion in a printing press produced the US dictionary?  (Sorry, couldn't resist!).

In all seriousness though, I find that the methodology you applied could be done in reverse in support of #1. 

The only way I can believe that an explosion created the universe and all its wonders is if "someone" had full control of all the variables.  I cannot imagine how mathematically possible it would be to create this world without an intelligent God controlling all the infinite variables during such an explosion.

I would never dream in a billion years how any random demolition work would magically create anything but a mess.
« Last Edit: May 09, 2013, 06:13:45 PM by Jl808 »
I think, therefore I am armed.
NRA Life Patron member, HRA Life member, HiFiCo Life Member, HDF member

The United States Constitution © 1791. All Rights Reserved.

MDS

Re: A march on Washington with loaded rifles
« Reply #101 on: May 09, 2013, 06:51:33 PM »
I just had an epiphany. And yes I would have deemed it not long ago a crazy nut rant and a commie idea but read the whole thing and consider it carefully recalling recent history to that of long ago history. Before one decides to go into an economics lesson, think it through very carefully while considering recent changes in technology.

 All this banter on this thread that would ultimately solve nothing even if implemented as it should be constitutionally today. In other words, our grandchildren will lose their guns, you can bet on it if we don't make major changes today. So what’s the damn point if we don’t change our whole course now? This is what hit me while reading through this thread.

     We once had a purpose and that purpose was to build a free society for anyone who wanted to join that purpose.  We have since extended those basic freedoms to all races within our society and we’re currently struggling with extending it to accommodation of “minority lifestyles”.  That’s in-line with advancing our constitution, sweeping up the “dust bunnies” now on that front and yes there are still classes and poor people etc. So there’s still more work to do that way but the main purpose has been met/completed.
What we’re now missing is our “societal” purpose. There is this society that has since been built and we forgot that our goal has been met. Our society has no purpose but to enrich it and only it because that is what was needed to build it. Therein lay the problems we face today, we’re missing purpose because our great goal was met. I’ve had everything I could want but I’m really not happy when I look around at our society, it’s broken and repetitive with no damn direction any longer, no new frontiers and no real dreams for our children to ponder.
We put our faith into a fiat currency with a central core… that is now our only purpose as a society. Like it or not, that’s what each of us has done, you can call it whatever, bottom line it only leads to self consumption/self destruction/and eventually all biological destruction. One can easily pretend that’s not true, but the fact is, it is true, look around you. We can argue God, Guns, and Rights till the cows come home and in that time we will only consume ourselves. Guns will inevitably be taken away in our current direction of societal purpose, it’s inevitable.
It’s now time to put our faith into a new purpose, a purpose that establishes a society of enlightenment in which we become very literally part of the heavens (space) and not isolated within them/it.  Fiat currency is fine and dandy for now, but what we spend our currency/faith on as a nation is all wrong, our faith should be invested in enlightenment (bettering our environment, expanding our physical presence beyond this planet, establishing new frontiers in all facets of life and firstly helping those who are starving so they can reach our current efficiency level and onward). We don’t do this because there is no currency reward for possible pointless exploration or no currency rewards for helping others advance as well. But all that’s just a scheme, it’s just some scheme that was tossed together to establish some controls on a people who were struggling to very literally create a society. We’re now a society that has exceeded its needs through possible extreme productivity. That’s what we’re not seeing.
To be Frank… we have a society that can easily provide for everyone as it has become that efficient.  We’re just not allowing it to produce what it has the ability to produce. Efficiency coupled with greed is why there are not enough jobs to go around and people are still starving in the world. Gun control is merely an issue today because we have not risen or adopted a new purpose and our current direction will only lead to self destruction/self consumption and gun rights will be long lost before that happens.
Seriously, who cares if the car companies are owned by the government, in fact why should they be owned at all by anyone? Why can’t we just go to work and make lots more cars with our government issued fiat currency? Communism? No, not communism - just do away with what’s essentially nothing more than fake profits.
It’s now fiat currency that works on faith alone and its backing is nothing but smoke and mirrors now. Why can’t everyone be put to work and paid in fiat currency? Why can’t we remove the greed factor by simply ignoring it and going to work and make Uncle Sam give us fiat currency for doing so? Ignore the greed, go to the store and get what you need with that faith based fiat currency as we do now. Think about efficiency… our possible efficiency if everyone works, far exceeds the world’s needs now.
Our problem is only the central Banking system trying to control everything. Abolish the Federal Reserve and seize our money presses.  We can turn countless machines out of factories per day; we can harvest countless acres globally per day. We can responsibly build damns around the world and divert that water anywhere we need it. All we have to do is… do it. Only we are stopping us from advancing our freedoms and societal evolutions. Who would be in charge? ROTATE THEM ALL DAMN FREQUENTLY.

Very seriously I’m really seeing everything now as a damn bunch of BS and a damn waste of human existence. It’s time for us to move forward as a species and put away the useless systems that keep us held back as a species. They will all let us down just as we are seeing today, our system is broken and we all damn well know that. So what would be a responsible move for our grandkids? Heck… I would volunteer to haul the garbage in an enlightened society, but this isn’t such a society, it’s dog eat dog because we have allowed that to continue for no apparent reason except we’re simply not aware it could be different if we made it so. I’m nearly an old timer (50) and those near and above my age seriously think,  just 20 years ago we weren’t able to do the amazing things we can do today… think about how far efficiency has advanced through our incredible machines, computers and robotics etc in just the past 20 years alone! We are on the threshold of what can be an incredibly enlightened society if we take the reins of power back, we the people and we may indeed need our guns to do just that! This maybe our last chance to turn our society around before it’s too late.

moosed

  • Trade Count: (+5)
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 867
  • Total likes: 0
  • Well, I'm all broken up over that man's rights!
  • Referrals: 2
    • View Profile
Re: A march on Washington with loaded rifles
« Reply #102 on: May 09, 2013, 07:06:46 PM »
The problem with public education is it is  too much about public (funding and social programs) and not enough about education.  Too often, we feel we have had an original thought, when in fact we are sometimes centuries behind the curve!  Imagine a world where we value knowledge of those who have gone before us and build upon it ... rather than reinvent the wheel!

Quote
The Age of Enlightenment

Jean-Jacques Rousseau

Jean-Jacques Rousseau in the mid 1700s attempted to persuade people that Locke and Hobbes had placed too much importance on the rights of individuals, leading to a pursuit for individual material gain in a laissez-faire economy at the expense of the pursuit of civic virtues associated with the common good. He felt that a growing division of labour exacerbated natural inequalities and culminated in the establishment of a powerful mercantile and propertied class that dominated the rest of society. To avoid the jeopardy of civil war, this class sought to appease the anger of the poor by instituting a new social order, a civil society that would provide equality and freedom for all. But this was just a trick, said Rousseau, that allowed the wealthy to maintain inequalities of power and privilege by postulating an equal freedom to acquire such advantages. And because of the consent given by the poor to such a form of governance, they were unlikely to rebel.

Rousseau devised the idea of the social contract as a means whereby citizens would make the common good their highest priority. This is accomplished by each person subjugating their right for the individual pursuit of happiness to that of their community’s right for collective well-being. The state is the arena for defining the nature of the common good, and civil liberty emerges when all people are willing to abide by the general will. Since common people are to be the law-makers, they will promulgate laws that result in moderating accumulation of individual wealth and thereby promote equality and trust.

It was the thinkers of the Scottish Enlightenment, notably David Hume, Adam Ferguson and Adam Smith, that laid the philosophical premises for capitalist mercantilism.

David Hume

David Hume, in his Treatise on Human Nature, argued that there was no unity between Reason and Morality, and that people set their goals on the basis of Morality, but use Reason in achieving them. His three fundamental rules of conduct - the stability of possessions, their transfer by consent, and the performance of promises - are human conventions, and not based in any ‘natural law’. The implications of this thought were profound, leading to the notion that people, in using their reason to follow their self-interests, eventually achieve the interests of society as a whole. People establish and follow the laws of the land, not so as to serve some universal good, but to maximize their self-interests in an enlightened manner.

Adam Ferguson and Adam Smith

Ferguson and Smith both held that the binding principle of civil society was a private morality predicated on public recognition by one’s peers, joined through bonds of moral sentiment. This philosophical stance did not preclude Adam Smith from asserting that, because an individual’s identity and power rested on their perceived value within an arena of exchange, the whole of society would be better off if marketplace exchanges were unconstrained by the state.

Immanuel Kant

Immanuel Kant’s main principle regarding civil society was that people should treat other people as ends in themselves rather than means to the ends of others. In other words, we must consider how others would benefit themselves from our actions, rather than how we might use them only for our own benefit, and we must ensure that whatever means we use to pursue our own self-interests does not interfere with others’ rights to pursue theirs. And while Kant echoed Hume in his relegation of ethics and morals to the private sphere, he advocated a public arena of rational, critical discourse concerning the ‘ends’ posed by the state. In this regard, he was the first to suggest that a functional civil society should be seen as distinct from the state.
When only cops have guns, it's called a "police state".

MDS

Re: A march on Washington with loaded rifles
« Reply #103 on: May 09, 2013, 07:46:35 PM »
The problem with public education is it is  too much about public (funding and social programs) and not enough about education.  Too often, we feel we have had an original thought, when in fact we are sometimes centuries behind the curve!  Imagine a world where we value knowledge of those who have gone before us and build upon it ... rather than reinvent the wheel!
Oh no... I fully agree. I know the notion is nothing new about the currency etc, but in the past we didn't have the technological resources we have today. In the past 10 years alone we have made even greater steps forward technologically. But way back, there was struggle pure and simple just to get by and that was for everyone generally, if they didn’t just die from starvation. The elite could never hope to fully control a people 24/7 365 days a year everywhere all the time.

Here’s what I’m really getting at and this is the core of the present issue.  This technology as currently abused will put full power in the hands of current elite like no power ever held by tyrants past.  This is why I say, we are on the threshold now, not in 10 or 20 years, we are about to step over that threshold TODAY. I felt it but it hadn’t dawned on me how utterly historically different today is from any other moment of history. The power of today’s technology can either destroy the freedom of all people or if the power is reclaimed back by the people it can restore freedoms successful direction. It’s in these times today that we cannot, I repeat cannot allow the crime in government and corrupt financial system to continue forward. We have to crush it now before we can no longer assemble to do so later. If we don’t, we will lose everything and that isn’t BS and you all damn well know it.
So all this bantering here about 2a, rights etc… will all be for not later, it’s inevitable. Look at the corruption in DC and our military strategically positioned about the BRICS banking system nations by virtue of the fear from the current world banking system seeing it’s petro dollar about to be brought to its knees. They have passed bills to control the internet (our communications system), they are leveraging for full control.
Here’s the deal, call me crazy, but here’s the fact, it’s clear as day to anyone who can see the writing on the wall, this is our last chance.

moosed

  • Trade Count: (+5)
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 867
  • Total likes: 0
  • Well, I'm all broken up over that man's rights!
  • Referrals: 2
    • View Profile
Re: A march on Washington with loaded rifles
« Reply #104 on: May 09, 2013, 07:58:39 PM »
Here’s the deal, call me crazy, but here’s the fact, it’s clear as day to anyone who can see the writing on the wall, this is our last chance.

Okay, you lost me.  This is our last chance?  What's this?  The march on DC?  Commandeer the Internet?  Full blown rebellion?  The French Revolution: American Style?     ???
When only cops have guns, it's called a "police state".

MDS

Re: A march on Washington with loaded rifles
« Reply #105 on: May 09, 2013, 08:40:28 PM »
Okay, you lost me.  This is our last chance?  What's this?  The march on DC?  Commandeer the Internet?  Full blown rebellion?  The French Revolution: American Style?     ???
It means we need to stop fooling ourselves and be prepared. I too have been fooling myself and ignoring the warning signs and considering the theatrics of folks like Alex Jones to be whacky (I still see many things he says as beyond fringe). But tonight it just dawned on me; I now see what’s been causing that uneasy tension in so many people. I couldn’t get my finger on it until just tonight.
So it just means we need to be prepared and even though it sounds really idiotic, hope when it happens there’s a large enough rebellion (not the march) to inspire enough people to join in and get our nation back into the proper hands of… “we the people. “ I’m thinking our military may play a role in starting and backing the rebellion. I can only hope that’s the case.
Rebellion or not, I see our future as screwed for some time to come. If the bible has its way… there will be no rebellion and we will step blindly as a people over the threshold we’re currently on and march right into revelations within 30 or more years. Either we face upheaval now for a while till things get back on track or we give away our nation completely and irretrievably to the corrupt elite and continue as their subjects under very uncomfortable conditions for many years to come.
When I was a younger man, I never thought our nation would become what it’s become, I would have slapped someone for saying so.

michalebsdad

Re: A march on Washington with loaded rifles
« Reply #106 on: May 09, 2013, 08:58:38 PM »
Well we seemed to have stepped WAY beyond this march topic...

Tom_G

Re: A march on Washington with loaded rifles
« Reply #107 on: May 09, 2013, 09:39:27 PM »

I would never dream in a billion years how any random demolition work would magically create anything but a mess.

It did create a mess, but took 14 billion years to do so.  Keep imagining!
The difference between theory and reality is that, in theory, there is no difference between theory and reality.

MDS

Re: A march on Washington with loaded rifles
« Reply #108 on: May 09, 2013, 10:11:46 PM »
Well we seemed to have stepped WAY beyond this march topic...

Yep, it demonstrates very well, basic human nature and the need for restraint though a "Constitution" of some temperament. Is it any wonder why ours has been used as T.P. by Congress, the Executive and Judiciary branches of our government?
So we inevitably see an open carry armed March scheduled on DC. Not a surprise at all. This is a very sensitive subject inducing a great deal of ideology to surface. Today we have the internet so such organized demonstrations can be arranged relatively easily by the common person.  At the rate our basic liberties/rights/privileges are being crapped on by DC, Tomorrow we probably won’t have that privilege either.
Do any of the old timers recall when you could build a house without a permit, inspections and government scrutiny? How many like type liberties have been lost since those days? Sort of turns your stomach when thinking about it? It turns mine.

aieahound

Re: A march on Washington with loaded rifles
« Reply #109 on: May 10, 2013, 09:36:11 AM »
Thanks for the reply on my prior post MDS. And no, I am not offended, just enjoying the intellectual conversation and discussion.
One comment though, it must be true because the bible tells me so doesn't really fly. Depending on your faith of course.

 :stopjack:

So if I read your last post right, the march on Washington is not just about 2A rights, but the entire state of affairs ?

Jl808

Re: A march on Washington with loaded rifles
« Reply #110 on: May 10, 2013, 12:42:04 PM »
MDS - I'm not sure I quite follow all that you've posted. I'll re-read it again and maybe you can explain at one of the pau hanas.

I think that you're trying to say that the US basically has no more vision / plan beyond economic wealth and prosperity and that folks are getting complacent because we have reached that goal.

Reminds me of an exhortation by a prophet in the bible "my people perish from a lack of knowledge."

Unfortunately, groups against our way of life have established clear visions for changing the US.

1. Communist infiltration goals published in 1963.  This one is scary considering how much they have accomplished.
http://rense.com/general32/americ.htm

2. Islamic strategy for conquering Europe and the US:
http://www.islamreview.com/articles/islamicstrategy.shtml

I think, therefore I am armed.
NRA Life Patron member, HRA Life member, HiFiCo Life Member, HDF member

The United States Constitution © 1791. All Rights Reserved.

Jl808

Re: A march on Washington with loaded rifles
« Reply #111 on: May 10, 2013, 01:13:26 PM »
Thanks for the reply on my prior post MDS. And no, I am not offended, just enjoying the intellectual conversation and discussion.

Thanks aieahound.


One comment though, it must be true because the bible tells me so doesn't really fly. Depending on your faith of course.


Understood. Like you said, the statement that "its in the bible so it must be true" is really more of an expression of faith that what got included in the Bible is what God had intended to be included in its final version. Hence the saying, "written by human hands but divinely inspired."

In one sense, the Bible is a compilation of written account by the Jews of mankind's origins, their genealogy, their history, their culture, their laws, eyewitness accounts and testimonies of Jesus, and letters written by the Apostles and first Christians. The various books in the Bible can be viewed as historical as they have been crossed reference with early historical records from other nations (Egyptian and Roman) indicating that those incidents did happen.

However, the interaction of the Jews with their "Jewish" God Yahweh is recorded so intertwined in this historical book, that the Bible gives witness and testimony to the divine God and his son Jesus.  In effect, God has revealed Himself to the world, to and through his "chosen" people.

Did the Jews actually cross the Red Sea to escape their slavery in Egypt?  I would think so.  It is not scientific proof but I ask myself: "why would the Jewish people celebrate Passover so religiously if the journey out of Egypt did not really happen?"  Not really sure how one would prove this but since i was not there when it happened, then it becomes a matter of faith.

Thank you for listening. 
I think, therefore I am armed.
NRA Life Patron member, HRA Life member, HiFiCo Life Member, HDF member

The United States Constitution © 1791. All Rights Reserved.

aieahound

Re: A march on Washington with loaded rifles
« Reply #112 on: May 10, 2013, 01:38:33 PM »
Shucks, My Bad Jl808.  Referred to the wrong member.  :oops:    Thanks for the comments.

Enjoying this thoroughly. Amazing we here on 2A can talk intelligently and with civility through such a touchy topic.  :thumbsup:

The Pau Hana should be awesome !

Still don't agree though. I'm more in line with Tom G.

Imagine all the people.....

bass monkey

Re: A march on Washington with loaded rifles
« Reply #113 on: May 10, 2013, 02:04:58 PM »
A bit more further off topic, but who decided what books were to be included and not included in the bible?  I have heard there are many other books that are not/have not been put into the bible.

Jl808

Re: A march on Washington with loaded rifles
« Reply #114 on: May 10, 2013, 03:18:51 PM »
A bit more further off topic, but who decided what books were to be included and not included in the bible?  I have heard there are many other books that are not/have not been put into the bible.

Yes there were books that did not get included. I am not 100% sure of the details but from my limited understanding, the criteria used in what books to include was whether the books were divinely inspired by God or not.

The Old Testament was based on the Hebrew Torah.  After Christ, the New Testament books were written as testimony about the fulfillment of the messianic promise of God in the Old Testament.

The Roman Catholic church first canonized the Bible in the 4th century. The Protestant reformation movement took off some books later because they believed those books were not divinely inspired.

You can find some details about what books were included or not in Wikipedia.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Books_of_the_Bible
I think, therefore I am armed.
NRA Life Patron member, HRA Life member, HiFiCo Life Member, HDF member

The United States Constitution © 1791. All Rights Reserved.

Jl808

Re: A march on Washington with loaded rifles
« Reply #115 on: May 10, 2013, 03:23:58 PM »
Shucks, My Bad Jl808.  Referred to the wrong member.  :oops:    Thanks for the comments.

Enjoying this thoroughly. Amazing we here on 2A can talk intelligently and with civility through such a touchy topic.  :thumbsup:

The Pau Hana should be awesome !

Still don't agree though. I'm more in line with Tom G.

Imagine all the people.....

Fair enough -- You can put your faith in John Lennon while I'll put my faith in my God. (ducks for cover) :)
« Last Edit: May 10, 2013, 03:46:04 PM by Jl808 »
I think, therefore I am armed.
NRA Life Patron member, HRA Life member, HiFiCo Life Member, HDF member

The United States Constitution © 1791. All Rights Reserved.

michalebsdad

Re: A march on Washington with loaded rifles
« Reply #116 on: May 10, 2013, 03:26:01 PM »
Yes there were books that did not get included. I am not 100% sure of the details but from my limited understanding, the criteria used in what books to include was whether the books were divinely inspired by God or not.

The Old Testament was based on the Hebrew Torah.  After Christ, the New Testament books were written as testimony about the fulfillment of the messianic promise of God in the Old Testament.

The Roman Catholic church first canonized the Bible in the 4th century. The Protestant reformation movement took off some books later because they believed those books were not divinely inspired.

You can find some details about what books were included or not in Wikipedia.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Books_of_the_Bible

I am not dispelling your statement, I just want to let you know that Wiki is the very unreliable. You can't quote Wiki as a source for any college paper. Just be careful of what you read on Wiki...it is not a reliable source of information.

moosed

  • Trade Count: (+5)
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 867
  • Total likes: 0
  • Well, I'm all broken up over that man's rights!
  • Referrals: 2
    • View Profile
Re: A march on Washington with loaded rifles
« Reply #117 on: May 10, 2013, 03:32:00 PM »
I am not dispelling your statement, I just want to let you know that Wiki is the very unreliable. You can't quote Wiki as a source for any college paper. Just be careful of what you read on Wiki...it is not a reliable source of information.

As a rule of thumb, Wiki is an excellent starting point for research or for quick facts.  But, it's a good idea to follow the links in a wiki article in the bibliography references.  If the support links back-up the wiki information, it's probably okay.

YMMV
When only cops have guns, it's called a "police state".

Jl808

Re: A march on Washington with loaded rifles
« Reply #118 on: May 10, 2013, 03:45:46 PM »
michaelbsdad and moosed -- good points both and point well taken. I didn't know where to find a good list and Wikipedia seemed like a good place to start.
I think, therefore I am armed.
NRA Life Patron member, HRA Life member, HiFiCo Life Member, HDF member

The United States Constitution © 1791. All Rights Reserved.

michalebsdad

Re: A march on Washington with loaded rifles
« Reply #119 on: May 10, 2013, 03:54:18 PM »
michaelbsdad and moosed -- good points both and point well taken. I didn't know where to find a good list and Wikipedia seemed like a good place to start.

Moosed  made a good point...just be careful. Some of the stuff on Wiki is spot on, some is not.

Found this...maybe this will help you! (sorry for the length...)

CBN.com (Christian Broadcast Network) Program Director Chris Carpenter recently sat down with Bock, a research professor at Dallas Theological Seminary, to discuss how the New Testament books were selected, the books that didn’t make it, and a Christian’s best argument to defend the validity of the Bible.

The early Christians worshipped Jesus Christ during His life and were guided by the Apostles after His death and resurrection. They had no texts to go by for direction. How then, do you explain the selection of books for the New Testament?

Well, it is a process that took time. What I am talking about is that in the First Century we don’t have the last of the Gospels written in all likelihood until the 90’s. So, you have a 60 year period in which you don’t have all the New Testament books nor have they been identified. And they are not functioning as a New Testament. So, the question then becomes how they taught theology in light of the development of those books particularly as those books began to circulate. It took time for certain books to reach certain regions. The way that happened is basically through three means: short doctrinal summaries that you see encased within some of the New Testament material, there is hymnic material which we also see encased in the New Testament material that tells us they were singing theology, and there are the various rights that symbolize theology like the baptism and the Lord’s Supper. So, these all re-affirm what the basic theology was.

When we hear about “missing gospels”, the name Nag Hammadi invariably is attached. What is the significance of Nag Hammadi? What was contained in these missing gospels? What makes them popular to people who question the authenticity of scripture?

We have 52 books that are not in our Bible from the second and third centuries that give evidence of a kind of Christianity that is an attempt to meld Greco-Roman philosophy and Christianity – and to make Christianity more palatable to a Greco-Roman world. That is really what those texts are about. We actually dug them up in 1945 (near Nag Hammadi, Egypt). So, they have been around for just over 60 years. We have known about them since the time of Irenaeus because he wrote about them in 180 A.D. The attention they have gotten is coupled with the cultural factor – that is that history is supposedly written by the winners and now we are hearing the voice of the losers. So, the thought is that we need to re-address the imbalance. Of course, the other half of the story is that sometimes the winners deserve to win. And that is part of the story I am trying to tell. I’m trying to explain why it is that this extra biblical material ended up not having an impact.

You mention Irenaeus. Who was he in the grand scheme of theological history?

He is a church father writing at the end of the Second Century. His first work was called “Against Heresies”. He was becoming alarmed by the rising up of various attempts to redefine Christianity. You have Marcion who is trying to remove anything Jewish. You have DeMontanus who is talking about access to a direct revelation. And then you have these Gnostics who are trying to find Greek philosophy in Christianity. So, he writes a work that is really against all of them but he spends the bulk of his time on the Gnostics.

For clarification, how would you define the Gnostic gospels?

Gnosticism comes from the Greek word for gnosis which means knowledge. It is a religion that claims to have secret knowledge above and beyond what most people have associated with religion. It includes ideas like what really counts is the spiritual. All matter is evil. God did not create creation, underling gods did. That creation was so flawed that matter will not be redeemed in you. This means that Jesus did not inhabit the flesh. There is no incarnation. It also means that there is no major discussion of sin and it also means that when the resurrection comes it will only involve your spirit going back to God. There is no resurrection of the body.

In theological circles I often hear people talk about canon. What is the canon?

Canon is s Greek word that means read or standard. So, it is a way of saying this is where we get the books that are the standard of our faith. That process of recognition of what was inspired took four centuries. The first person to list the 27 books that we have in our New Testament was a church father named Athanasius. He did it in 367 A.D. But the first portions of the New Testament to be recognized were the New Testament gospels, the Acts, and the epistles of Paul. That happened at the end of the Second Century, long before the process was completed. This is because these books were debated. Some of them were discussed as to whether they belonged in, like II Peter and II and III John. Books that didn’t make it in like I Clement Shepherd and Earnest. This is because they were on some lists but not on others originally. The factors that led to their selection included: did they go back to the Apostles or someone working very closely with the Apostles, were they theologically orthodox, and were they being used in a widespread way in the church geographically and through the passage of time. This was done to test their quality.

Why then, don’t you think some of these missing gospels were not included in the New Testament? I ask this based on the fact that in that era it was not nearly as easy to get the texts from one location to another. There was no technology to mail, email, or to broadcast in any way. They could have been just as valid.

The missing gospels were excluded from the New Testament mainly because they did not go back to the earliest generation. They didn’t have solid apostolic context or roots. Also, they had a very distinct theology, or competing theology. This is in regard to God in creation, with regard to the person of Jesus – which He could not have been incarnate, with regard to not dealing with sin. And so there were certain things that would have automatically excluded many of these works because of what they were teaching.

In relation to what you just said, here is an argument that has been popping up over the last several years mainly due to the Da Vinci Code. How do we know whether the New Testament as Christians know it is completely accurate? Man is frail and is prone to mistakes. Isn’t it possible that some of these early church fathers could have made errors?

There are really two questions and the first is how do we know the New Testament we have is an accurate reflection of what the New Testament was? First, before we can talk about what is accurate we have got to decide whether this really goes back. The answer to that question is that the amount of manuscript evidence that we have for the New Testament indicates to us that it has been transmitted with a good degree of care and what we have is very much a reflection of what existed at the start. Now, with regard to accuracy that is also a two level question. The issue of truth is a complex question. How do you prove truth? In some ways, when you are not dealing with science it is a very hard thing to do. So, what you are dealing with is that you want your hands on the best sources. You want your hands on those sources that the closest to what takes place. That is why the apostolic roots are so important. That is why the apostolic association of people is so important. Because if you look at our four gospels, most conservatives will say Matthew and John were written by the Apostles but Mark and Luke were not. Mark was an associate of Peter. Luke was close to Paul and had contact with many others. That is how you put that together. Then, the next thing is to ask yourself whether there is a coherence in what is going on in these texts. Do they make sense alongside one another? The answer to that question is yes. And the last thing is, does this explanation have more plausibility than other explanations for putting this together. Because you are dealing with the humanities and not the sciences you cannot come up with 100 percent proof. There is no experiment you can run that can replay the First Century. So, you are left in a situation where you are dealing with the plausibility of what is going on. The last factor, which is important theologically, but which most people don’t even think about is the role of spirit in opening up a person’s heart to what is going on in these texts. This is because of the claims that God is active in certain ways, even unusual ways. For some people this is a hurdle that they cannot get past.

For the average Christian, what is their best argument to defend the accuracy of the New Testament?

I actually think the best argument is to look at the behaviors of those who were closest to Jesus that we know about. Something changed them. The New Testament texts make it clear that something changed them. If I can say this, where they were wimps before the Cross, they were bold after the Cross. So, the very Peter who denied Jesus according to tradition was crucified for his faith afterward for standing up for Jesus. The very Paul who persecuted the Church and tried to remove Christians, put his life on the line and according to tradition he was also crucified as a result of defending his faith. If you knew you made it up … why would you die for it? That puts us into a plausibility position. What is more plausible to believe … that the early Church made this up and then died for it, or, this really happened and that explains the transformation?

Point blank, can these missing gospels do anything for us?

Historically, this stuff benefits us in understanding the debate that is going on between Christianity and these fringe groups. You get to hear from them directly. It is always helpful as a matter of history. But the bottom line question for most people is ‘does this stuff help us understand orthodox, real, authentic Christianity any better?’ The answer to that question is no. It doesn’t other than to provide a mirror against which we can see Christianity interacting with that which it views is not what Christianity is. To that extent it can be helpful.