A march on Washington with loaded rifles (Read 61895 times)

Jl808

Re: A march on Washington with loaded rifles
« Reply #60 on: May 08, 2013, 07:52:29 AM »

Until God comes down from the heavens and tells the Government what to do, your "rights" come from the government.


clshade -- my understanding is that you have it backwards.  I'm no expert in law but I don't think it is about the government giving us our "rights"... it is the people conferring "powers" to the government. 

If the US was founded by a monarchy, then you'd be correct because the monarchy would be giving "rights" to the people.  However, the people of the US overthrew the monarchy and created a government for the people by the people, and conferred limited powers to the government instead.

The government continues to gain more power though as the sheeple are scared into conferring more power to it.

I think the biggest mistake is when people start thinking of their elected officials as their government "leaders".  Folks should be reminded that these politicians are called public "servants" and should be in service of the people they represent.   The moment any of our public servants start acting like our king or masters is the time that they should be booted off by voting them out.

« Last Edit: May 08, 2013, 07:59:36 AM by Jl808 »
I think, therefore I am armed.
NRA Life Patron member, HRA Life member, HiFiCo Life Member, HDF member

The United States Constitution © 1791. All Rights Reserved.

moosed

  • Trade Count: (+5)
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 867
  • Total likes: 0
  • Well, I'm all broken up over that man's rights!
  • Referrals: 2
    • View Profile
Re: A march on Washington with loaded rifles
« Reply #61 on: May 08, 2013, 08:58:23 AM »
clshade -- my understanding is that you have it backwards.  I'm no expert in law but I don't think it is about the government giving us our "rights"... it is the people conferring "powers" to the government.

If the US was founded by a monarchy, then you'd be correct because the monarchy would be giving "rights" to the people.  However, the people of the US overthrew the monarchy and created a government for the people by the people, and conferred limited powers to the government instead.

The government continues to gain more power though as the sheeple are scared into conferring more power to it.

I think the biggest mistake is when people start thinking of their elected officials as their government "leaders".  Folks should be reminded that these politicians are called public "servants" and should be in service of the people they represent.   The moment any of our public servants start acting like our king or masters is the time that they should be booted off by voting them out.

x100
When only cops have guns, it's called a "police state".

clshade

Re: A march on Washington with loaded rifles
« Reply #62 on: May 08, 2013, 09:42:14 AM »
More philosophy, though I agree with you, Jl808.

My point is that "rights" are kind of an illusion. We talk about them as coming from God, Nature, or from the people... fine, but in practice you can only do what the authorities will let you do.

And sociologically about 60-70% of the population is wired to simply go along with whatever the rules are, whatever the "leaders" say. A number of them may question and be upset about things they don't agree with but they will still go along with it.

If there is a revolution it isn't just because enough of these types are rebelling against the established authority, it is because they are following a new authority.

Its not necessarily malicious on the part of the "leaders" - its just the way people are. What is malicious is that there are people who understand this and use it for their own purposes. The entire fields of Public Relations and Advertising are based on this. Sure, its a mistake to assume your rights and access to true information comes from the authorities but across cultures >60% of are are wired to make that assumption.

edit: To clarify: so, in practice, >60% of us create a government that we then follow more or less blindly. This is exactly why some of the founders thought revolution was a recurring necessity since there is almost no chance that such a government will NOT abuse its power at some point.

moosed

  • Trade Count: (+5)
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 867
  • Total likes: 0
  • Well, I'm all broken up over that man's rights!
  • Referrals: 2
    • View Profile
Re: A march on Washington with loaded rifles
« Reply #63 on: May 08, 2013, 09:47:43 AM »
More philosophy, though I agree with you, Jl808.

My point is that "rights" are kind of an illusion. We talk about them as coming from God, Nature, or from the people... fine, but in practice you can only do what the authorities will let you do.

And sociologically about 60-70% of the population is wired to simply go along with whatever the rules are, whatever the "leaders" say. A number of them may question and be upset about things they don't agree with but they will still go along with it.

If there is a revolution it isn't just because enough of these types are rebelling against the established authority, it is because they are following a new authority.

Its not necessarily malicious on the part of the "leaders" - its just the way people are. What is malicious is that there are people who understand this and use it for their own purposes. The entire fields of Public Relations and Advertising are based on this. Sure, its a mistake to assume your rights and access to true information comes from the authorities but across cultures >60% of are are wired to make that assumption.

edit: To clarify: so, in practice, >60% of us create a government that we then follow more or less blindly. This is exactly why some of the founders thought revolution was a recurring necessity since there is almost no chance that such a government will NOT abuse its power at some point.

In the American Revolution, only about 3% of the American population actively supported rebellion.

Will you be part of that 3% if, or when, the time comes?
When only cops have guns, it's called a "police state".

clshade

Re: A march on Washington with loaded rifles
« Reply #64 on: May 08, 2013, 09:51:16 AM »
^^^^^

That hugely depends on who is leading it. Do you have any idea how easy it is end up replacing one problem with another?

moosed

  • Trade Count: (+5)
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 867
  • Total likes: 0
  • Well, I'm all broken up over that man's rights!
  • Referrals: 2
    • View Profile
Re: A march on Washington with loaded rifles
« Reply #65 on: May 08, 2013, 10:11:41 AM »
That hugely depends on who is leading it. Do you have any idea how easy it is end up replacing one problem with another?

Why does it matter who the leader is?  Either you know in your heart and your mind that what you are doing is right, or you stand with the other 60-70% (your figure) of low-information voters who choose to believe whatever the government and media tell them to.

If you require validation or consensus in order to trust your own moral and ethical compass, I would suggest you specifically are not leadership material.

The Only Thing Necessary for the Triumph of Evil is that Good Men Do Nothing
When only cops have guns, it's called a "police state".

clshade

Re: A march on Washington with loaded rifles
« Reply #66 on: May 08, 2013, 10:22:35 AM »
Because the leadership of that revolution will dictate the flavor of what comes next.

Look at past revolutions in other places and look at what happens immediately after in almost every case. A lot of good ideas have lead a lot of people to some very bad conditions.

If you think I require validation or consensus you are clearly not understanding my point. You're in good company: most revolutionaries have no clue how to build something new that works - they only know how to react against something they don't like.

Take Hawaii as an example and imagine that a revolution is underway to restore Sovereignty. If it is being lead by Hawaiian Blood purists who want to Kill Da Haoles, restore the Monarchy, start sacrificing people again and burning them alive it their shadow falls on them.... yeah, I might not want to have anything to do with it.

Tom_G

Re: A march on Washington with loaded rifles
« Reply #67 on: May 08, 2013, 10:26:54 AM »
My point is that "rights" are kind of an illusion. We talk about them as coming from God, Nature, or from the people... fine, but in practice you can only do what the authorities will let you do.

Exactly.  If a right were truly inalienable, then no act of government could deny it.  Breathing, for example, is a right.  If someone denies you your right to breath, you die.  It quite literally cannot be taken from a living person.  Belief is another.  No one but you can decide what you believe. 

Plus, as far as I'm concerned, the jury is still out on deities. Even if one or more exist (a point I do not concede), the whole making-their-will-known-to-mankind thing has a pretty sketchy history. 

No, what "rights" are, in this context, are a set of privileges that society has agreed upon.  This is why rights vary from country to country.  This is why governments, societies, and circumstances can control whether or not a right applies.  And this is why there is a very real threat of losing them.

Are these people exercising a right?  Sure they are, the right to make a choice (yet another actual inalienable right.)  They are choosing to violate laws as a form of protest. 
The difference between theory and reality is that, in theory, there is no difference between theory and reality.

ImKu

Re: A march on Washington with loaded rifles
« Reply #68 on: May 08, 2013, 10:34:29 AM »
Take Hawaii as an example and imagine that a revolution is underway to restore Sovereignty. If it is being lead by Hawaiian Blood purists who want to Kill Da Haoles, restore the Monarchy, start sacrificing people again and burning them alive it their shadow falls on them.... yeah, I might not want to have anything to do with it.

Off topic, but I have to ask you to site your source if your going to make such accusations.  I actually know people that are part of this movement, although I do not share their beliefs your statement is not accurate.  There are different hawaiian activist groups, problem is they are not united and tend to disagree on topics amongst themselves.
The mind acts like an enemy for those who do not control it.
- Bhagavad Gita

clshade

Re: A march on Washington with loaded rifles
« Reply #69 on: May 08, 2013, 10:39:56 AM »
Apologies, ImKu - please note the "Imagine" and "if" in my quote. The situation I described is hypothetical not actual. As such it was not a statement or an accusation.

ImKu

Re: A march on Washington with loaded rifles
« Reply #70 on: May 08, 2013, 10:45:16 AM »
Apologies, ImKu - please note the "Imagine" and "if" in my quote. The situation I described is hypothetical not actual. As such it was not a statement or an accusation.

Mahalo Nui Loa  :shaka:
The mind acts like an enemy for those who do not control it.
- Bhagavad Gita

Funtimes

Re: A march on Washington with loaded rifles
« Reply #71 on: May 08, 2013, 10:51:35 AM »
Exactly.  If a right were truly inalienable, then no act of government could deny it.  Breathing, for example, is a right.  If someone denies you your right to breath, you die.  It quite literally cannot be taken from a living person.  Belief is another.  No one but you can decide what you believe. 

Plus, as far as I'm concerned, the jury is still out on deities. Even if one or more exist (a point I do not concede), the whole making-their-will-known-to-mankind thing has a pretty sketchy history. 

No, what "rights" are, in this context, are a set of privileges that society has agreed upon.  This is why rights vary from country to country.  This is why governments, societies, and circumstances can control whether or not a right applies.  And this is why there is a very real threat of losing them.

Are these people exercising a right?  Sure they are, the right to make a choice (yet another actual inalienable right.)  They are choosing to violate laws as a form of protest.

From Eugene Volokh:

"Some recent conversations I’ve heard about “positive rights” and American legal traditions made me want to repeat something I’ve written before: While it’s true that the U.S. Constitution lacks some of the “positive rights” that people sometimes discuss under that label (e.g., a right to shelter, to medical care, to a subsistence income, and so on, it does secure other positive rights; and indeed, some positive rights are a longstanding feature of American legal traditions. I think such rights should remain limited, but I think one shouldn’t deny that they exist, and are in some measure secured by the U.S. Constitution (and state constitutions).

First, some definitions. The term “right” is a broad one, which encompasses many different kinds of entitlement."

See more here at the Volokh Conspiracy
http://www.volokh.com/2013/05/07/positive-rights-the-constitution-and-conservatives-and-moderate-libertarians/


Stanford also has this to say about rights:

"The connection between rights and struggle cannot be overstated — rights are not as much granted or endowed as they are fought for and claimed, and the essence of struggles past and ancient are encoded in the spirit of current concepts of rights and their modern formulations."
Check out the Hawaii Defense Foundation.
HDF on Facebook
Defender of the Accused in Arkansas Courts
Posts are not legal advice & are my own, unless said so.

Jl808

Re: A march on Washington with loaded rifles
« Reply #72 on: May 08, 2013, 11:38:56 AM »
Hi clshade, I normally agree with you on some stuff but this is something I really disagree with you about.

It is not just a philosophical discussion but also a discussion about morality, justice and moral right. You mentioned the need for strategic thinking. One cannot just get people to accomplish a "what?" without people clearly understanding the "why?".

One cannot take God out of the constitution either. Philosophically, without a God, all our existence devolves into a base Darwinian world view of a might makes right existence, which is what you describe.

The only reason why Ghandi succeeded was because the world held a Christian perspective of morality.  Ghandi's peaceful civil disobedience would have no chance in a Darwinian might makes right world view that you describe.
I think, therefore I am armed.
NRA Life Patron member, HRA Life member, HiFiCo Life Member, HDF member

The United States Constitution © 1791. All Rights Reserved.

clshade

Re: A march on Washington with loaded rifles
« Reply #73 on: May 08, 2013, 12:19:19 PM »
I've really enjoyed this discussion, by the way. :)

Jl808, we actually agree on that but I think we're focusing on a couple of different things.

What I'm describing is applied "rights", for lack of a better term. Its very darwinian and that is the sad part. Agencies and authorities break and misuse laws all the time, sometimes they suffer consequences for it. Those consequences come from our morality, no doubt about that. Usually the greater sense of morality prevents such things from happening in the first place. But not all the time.

Its like a cop stopping you for no good reason then demanding to search your car. They have no legal authority to do so... but they do it anyway. A more shocking example is the internment of the Japanese Americans during WWII. The Constitution specifically says they had the right to not be shuffled off to internment camps... but the President did it anyway.

At that level of reality it doesn't much matter where we think our rights come from since it is the "authorities" that are preventing us from exercising them. It is in the court of law, not the court of morality, that such issues are resolved. The philosophy and morality is what inspired the laws in the first place but after that we are in the Darwinian world of what is legal and what in not instead of what is moral and what is not. The best (and worst) lawyers thrive in the gap between what is moral and what is legal.

Philosophy and morality are hugely important in creating legal systems and in legal defense strategies. It is almost entirely irrelevant to what will happen for the armed marcher standing on the bridge to D.C. if he goes forward into a police line that is committed to enforcing D.C. no open carry law. The law says its a felony even if that is morally and philosophically at odds with the Constitution.

The only reason I raised this distinction in the first place is that it is the territory this armed march event is venturing into. On moral and philosophical grounds the organizer intends to prove whether or not "free people" are welcome in the country's capital. Meanwhile, the law of the land has already defined what they wish to do as a felony. For a large portion of the populace committing a felony is, by definition, immoral. I don't think enough people are yet concerned that the enforced infringements of the 2nd amendment (of which there are many) are also immoral. So in this case the unconstitutional law as it stands is supported by the majority's sense of morality - in some cases because those people are actually anti-gun but in most cases it is simply considered moral because it is the law.

Its absolutely true that morality leads to laws. Unfortunately, most people are wired to then assume that laws = moral and it takes a mighty stiff shove to shift them off that default position.
« Last Edit: May 08, 2013, 12:25:56 PM by clshade »

aieahound

Re: A march on Washington with loaded rifles
« Reply #74 on: May 08, 2013, 01:00:21 PM »
Hi clshade, I normally agree with you on some stuff but this is something I really disagree with you about.

It is not just a philosophical discussion but also a discussion about morality, justice and moral right. You mentioned the need for strategic thinking. One cannot just get people to accomplish a "what?" without people clearly understanding the "why?".

One cannot take God out of the constitution either. Philosophically, without a God, all our existence devolves into a base Darwinian world view of a might makes right existence, which is what you describe.

The only reason why Ghandi succeeded was because the world held a Christian perspective of morality.  Ghandi's peaceful civil disobedience would have no chance in a Darwinian might makes right world view that you describe.


Is it a Jewish God, Christian God, Mormon God or Muslim God ? ( Sorry, totally inappropriate comment but couldn't resist )

There is a Taoist perspective that accepts a higher power without one supreme being.  An ultimate interconnection of everything. Sort of like the Force in Star Wars.

and I vaguely remember a concept of Separation of Church and State. Religion shouldn't even be in this conversation in my opinion.

What rights have been taken away this year that we need to undertake an armed march on DC ?
So far we've won through the legal channels. Even when the political/social climate was as ripe as it gets.  We've, the 2A community, have made a statement. 
Will it be necessary someday, almost undoubtedly. But not today.

Jl808

Re: A march on Washington with loaded rifles
« Reply #75 on: May 08, 2013, 02:12:22 PM »
Hi aieahound.

Are you sure you really want me to answer your question?  I will only if you're willing to be open to what I might say.  ;)

Is it a Jewish God, Christian God, Mormon God or Muslim God ? ( Sorry, totally inappropriate comment but couldn't resist )

There is a Taoist perspective that accepts a higher power without one supreme being.  An ultimate interconnection of everything. Sort of like the Force in Star Wars.

and I vaguely remember a concept of Separation of Church and State. Religion shouldn't even be in this conversation in my opinion.

What rights have been taken away this year that we need to undertake an armed march on DC ?
So far we've won through the legal channels. Even when the political/social climate was as ripe as it gets.  We've, the 2A community, have made a statement. 
Will it be necessary someday, almost undoubtedly. But not today.

The only thing I would say is about your comments regarding the separation of church and state... 

Why can't religion be part of a conversation about constitutional rights?  The constitution equally protects your and my religious beliefs just as it protects your and my right to bear arms. 

Ok, back to topic... :)

jl808
« Last Edit: May 08, 2013, 04:14:03 PM by Jl808 »
I think, therefore I am armed.
NRA Life Patron member, HRA Life member, HiFiCo Life Member, HDF member

The United States Constitution © 1791. All Rights Reserved.

William Smith

Re: A march on Washington with loaded rifles
« Reply #76 on: May 08, 2013, 02:42:58 PM »
In general, what was the "religion" of most of the "founding fathers" when the federalist letters, constitution, bill of rights etc...were drafted and adopted?  Even with the concept of "separation of Church and State", the beliefs of those who authored these documents-the "founding Fathers"- is going to strongly influence their works/efforts. 
I seriously doubt there were many Hindu, Muslims, Jews or Taoists among their numbers.   So is it safe to say that all this work took place in a non-secular vacume, or was this period of our history influenced by the religious beliefs of the authors?

Edit below added:

I think by the direction this thread has gone, it's not inappropriate to discuss "religion" or beliefs. It's just a matter of who's religion and what beliefs. 
http://www.archives.gov/nhprc/annotation/2002/2002-mar.pdf

Some anti-gunners argue the interpretation of the constitution should be taken in the current context of the nation today vs in the early days.   Its a very Willcentric world for Will Smith.  IMO this is usually the case for others too.  It's hard to divorce core beliefs from all things Will, but I try.  ...and I fail or fall short.   Or is this a failing?  Perhaps not. 
« Last Edit: May 08, 2013, 03:08:10 PM by William Smith »

Jl808

Re: A march on Washington with loaded rifles
« Reply #77 on: May 08, 2013, 03:05:22 PM »
I've really enjoyed this discussion, by the way. :)

Jl808, we actually agree on that but I think we're focusing on a couple of different things.

What I'm describing is applied "rights", for lack of a better term. Its very darwinian and that is the sad part. Agencies and authorities break and misuse laws all the time, sometimes they suffer consequences for it. Those consequences come from our morality, no doubt about that. Usually the greater sense of morality prevents such things from happening in the first place. But not all the time.

Its like a cop stopping you for no good reason then demanding to search your car. They have no legal authority to do so... but they do it anyway. A more shocking example is the internment of the Japanese Americans during WWII. The Constitution specifically says they had the right to not be shuffled off to internment camps... but the President did it anyway.

At that level of reality it doesn't much matter where we think our rights come from since it is the "authorities" that are preventing us from exercising them. It is in the court of law, not the court of morality, that such issues are resolved. The philosophy and morality is what inspired the laws in the first place but after that we are in the Darwinian world of what is legal and what in not instead of what is moral and what is not. The best (and worst) lawyers thrive in the gap between what is moral and what is legal.

Philosophy and morality are hugely important in creating legal systems and in legal defense strategies. It is almost entirely irrelevant to what will happen for the armed marcher standing on the bridge to D.C. if he goes forward into a police line that is committed to enforcing D.C. no open carry law. The law says its a felony even if that is morally and philosophically at odds with the Constitution.

The only reason I raised this distinction in the first place is that it is the territory this armed march event is venturing into. On moral and philosophical grounds the organizer intends to prove whether or not "free people" are welcome in the country's capital. Meanwhile, the law of the land has already defined what they wish to do as a felony. For a large portion of the populace committing a felony is, by definition, immoral. I don't think enough people are yet concerned that the enforced infringements of the 2nd amendment (of which there are many) are also immoral. So in this case the unconstitutional law as it stands is supported by the majority's sense of morality - in some cases because those people are actually anti-gun but in most cases it is simply considered moral because it is the law.

Its absolutely true that morality leads to laws. Unfortunately, most people are wired to then assume that laws = moral and it takes a mighty stiff shove to shift them off that default position.

I'm enjoying these discussions too by the way.  Thank you all for the articulation of your thoughts and for the civility in the discussion so far.   :shaka:

clshade -- Yes, I think we are talking about the same thing but focusing on the different parts. 

I like and agree with your point about morality leading to laws and how others get a law confused with morality.   Something legal does not make it morally right.  Something morally right may not be legal.   Unfortunately, when people ask "can I do this?", some may only ask "is it legal?" without asking the other question "is it morally right?"  When legal vs moral are no longer matching, then you get a situation where protesters intentionally do illegal but moral things to prove a moral point. 

I think that is what this armed march is seriously trying to take a look at... it is asking whether what our country has declared legal / illegal still matches with the moral values used when the country was established.  This battleground of philosophy and morality is the battleground of the mind that must first be fought and won before a more physical battle is fought.

« Last Edit: May 08, 2013, 04:11:59 PM by Jl808 »
I think, therefore I am armed.
NRA Life Patron member, HRA Life member, HiFiCo Life Member, HDF member

The United States Constitution © 1791. All Rights Reserved.

Jl808

Re: A march on Washington with loaded rifles
« Reply #78 on: May 08, 2013, 03:39:20 PM »
In general, what was the "religion" of most of the "founding fathers" when the federalist letters, constitution, bill of rights etc...were drafted and adopted?  Even with the concept of "separation of Church and State", the beliefs of those who authored these documents-the "founding Fathers"- is going to strongly influence their works/efforts. 
I seriously doubt there were many Hindu, Muslims, Jews or Taoists among their numbers.   So is it safe to say that all this work took place in a non-secular vacume, or was this period of our history influenced by the religious beliefs of the authors?

If I learned my history correctly, the founding fathers were wanting to get away from a predominantly Roman Catholic Europe ruled by monarchs and established a new country ruled by people that can practice their religious beliefs without a ruling monarch or government dictating to them what religion was legal or illegal.   Most of the pilgrims were Protestant Christians and the founding fathers are assumed to also be Protestant Christians.  There are some other theories about their religion on the internet though.
I think, therefore I am armed.
NRA Life Patron member, HRA Life member, HiFiCo Life Member, HDF member

The United States Constitution © 1791. All Rights Reserved.

MDS

Re: A march on Washington with loaded rifles
« Reply #79 on: May 09, 2013, 08:22:26 AM »
If I learned my history correctly, the founding fathers were wanting to get away from a predominantly Roman Catholic Europe ruled by monarchs and established a new country ruled by people that can practice their religious beliefs without a ruling monarch or government dictating to them what religion was legal or illegal.   Most of the pilgrims were Protestant Christians and the founding fathers are assumed to also be Protestant Christians.  There are some other theories about their religion on the internet though.
If I recall correctly - T Jefferson was listed as a Master Mason in US publications and Ben Franklin was no doubt a Freemason. In any case, there were clearly other influences aside from Christianity responsible for the form of our nation.
Look on the back of that 1 dollar bill closely at the Great Seal... annuit coeptis novus ordo seclorum
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Annuit_c%C5%93ptis
« Last Edit: May 09, 2013, 08:28:06 AM by MDS »