A march on Washington with loaded rifles (Read 61908 times)

aieahound

Re: A march on Washington with loaded rifles
« Reply #40 on: May 07, 2013, 01:02:20 PM »
Good point Bud.

And for those spewing rhetoric and propaganda, who's buying a ticket to DC in July to carry their loaded rifle ?

If you feel that strongly, follow Chris Baker's and George Young's lead and take them to court to get our rights back.

1000 gunowners losing their 2A right by committing a felony as an act of symbolic martyrdom doesn't make any sense.
Especially in a year when all gun restriction bills have so far failed to pass.

MDS

Re: A march on Washington with loaded rifles
« Reply #41 on: May 07, 2013, 01:17:45 PM »
The assumption appears to be that they will march across the bridge and through DC against law enforcement efforts. I didn't hear the organizer say that. I heard him say very much the opposite. So all this talk about a potential problem and committing a felony comes from where; assumption perhaps? Perhaps listening to what he said again might be a good idea. What they plan to do is not within the realm of the assumed from above.

The plan as presented by the organizer appears sound and that plan does not entail going forward against law-enforcement. He said they will comply with any law enforcement they encounter.
This puts the ball in DC’s hands. What will they do when (if) the marchers begin to cross the bridge?

We’ll then have an answer, either they allow them to demonstrate or they don’t. Everyone knows there is a law against being armed as proposed in DC and I’m certain DC is well aware of the proposed march by now.  So… will DC police allow them to cross the bridge and then arrest them or will they stop them before attempting to cross the bridge and make no arrests or will they allow the full march without arrest?

There are three likely scenarios that might occur and each is differently telling of our current executive branch. Is there a point? There are three possible points, which will it be? DC won’t compromise and likewise will stop the demonstrators without arrest before crossing the bridge? DC will allow them to walk across the bridge and swoop in and make needless arrests that could have been avoided? DC will allow them to demonstrate without arrest. DC’s response will dictate the “point”.

And BTW 1000 armed men peaceably assembled would immediately subdue anyone within the ranks who tried to create problems. You can bet your butt there will be damn tight organizing as well as preaddressed responses to several possible issues that may arise. If there's a few bad people in the ranks... they'll be committing suicide that gets nowhere. In anycase, this maybe a very important moment in future history, if it happens. So to say its pointless etc, etc is somewhat premature. There are a few dynamics involved.\

This is very much a political issue and it need not be much of a "legal (beyond the poiont of the march)" issue unless DC makes it a legal issue. In any case, DC has 2 options to avoid making it a legal issue.

« Last Edit: May 07, 2013, 01:31:21 PM by MDS »

William Smith

Re: A march on Washington with loaded rifles
« Reply #42 on: May 07, 2013, 01:40:09 PM »
The assumption appears to be that they will march across the bridge and through DC against law enforcement efforts. I didn't hear the organizer say that. I heard him say very much the opposite. So all this talk about a potential problem and committing a felony comes from where; assumption perhaps? Perhaps listening to what he said again might be a good idea. What they plan to do is not within the realm of the assumed from above.


I don't have to assume its a felony to open carry a gun in DC.  It's the law.  If they are "allowed" to cross the bridge and make the entire march, returning to the other side in an "organized and peaceable manner",  it's still a felony to open carry a loaded gun it DC.  Bud's original question was "should they have the right to do this".  I would say yes they should. 
If the original question had be "do they have the right to do this" I would say "No, and we should continue to work at "fixing" this through legal channels". 

I get the general idea of the event, I just don't believe its the best thing to do to help bolster 2a rights.  Maybe if things "get worse" I would change my mind, but I'm not changing my mind on this one yet.  It has the strong potential to hurt us.  I'd rather give the money for an airline ticket to go to this event to the legal defense of Baker and Young.  Now that would be a useful statement IMO.

William Smith

Re: A march on Washington with loaded rifles
« Reply #43 on: May 07, 2013, 01:47:23 PM »
...and if the entire event is called off and nothing happens, it's still a felony to open carry a loaded gun in DC.  That's what needs to be changed, this march just isn't the way to do it...but I've been wrong before...

Aegis808

Re: A march on Washington with loaded rifles
« Reply #44 on: May 07, 2013, 01:54:49 PM »
I don't have to assume its a felony to open carry a gun in DC.  It's the law.  If they are "allowed" to cross the bridge and make the entire march, returning to the other side in an "organized and peaceable manner",  it's still a felony to open carry a loaded gun it DC.  Bud's original question was "should they have the right to do this".  I would say yes they should. 
If the original question had be "do they have the right to do this" I would say "No, and we should continue to work at "fixing" this through legal channels". 

I get the general idea of the event, I just don't believe its the best thing to do to help bolster 2a rights.  Maybe if things "get worse" I would change my mind, but I'm not changing my mind on this one yet.  It has the strong potential to hurt us.  I'd rather give the money for an airline ticket to go to this event to the legal defense of Baker and Young.  Now that would be a useful statement IMO.

what do you do when they make more laws? are you just going to stand by and say oh well it's the law if you don't them then you're a criminal and crazy because it's bad because it's illegal and it's illegal because it's bad. watching the situation develop left us with the GCA, NFA, and AWB.

MDS

Re: A march on Washington with loaded rifles
« Reply #45 on: May 07, 2013, 02:05:51 PM »
I don't have to assume its a felony to open carry a gun in DC.  It's the law.  If they are "allowed" to cross the bridge and make the entire march, returning to the other side in an "organized and peaceable manner",  it's still a felony to open carry a loaded gun it DC.  Bud's original question was "should they have the right to do this".  I would say yes they should. 
If the original question had be "do they have the right to do this" I would say "No, and we should continue to work at "fixing" this through legal channels". 

I get the general idea of the event, I just don't believe its the best thing to do to help bolster 2a rights.  Maybe if things "get worse" I would change my mind, but I'm not changing my mind on this one yet.  It has the strong potential to hurt us.  I'd rather give the money for an airline ticket to go to this event to the legal defense of Baker and Young.  Now that would be a useful statement IMO.


My point was – WILL DC ALLOW THEM TO COMMIT AND OR CHARGE THEM WITH A FELONY? Get it?
Did anyone propose it was the only thing that can currently be done?  Sure there are all sorts of other things people can do; in fact people can do many things simultaneously.  One could march, finance, write, file, vote, run for office, etc. It takes all of those things, not just one thing. Knocking another groups efforts because they don't settle well with you is just counter productive.

William Smith

Re: A march on Washington with loaded rifles
« Reply #46 on: May 07, 2013, 02:08:27 PM »
what do you do when they make more laws? are you just going to stand by and say oh well it's the law if you don't them then you're a criminal and crazy because it's bad because it's illegal and it's illegal because it's bad. watching the situation develop left us with the GCA, NFA, and AWB.
I don't think many American's are just standing by.  Several are, but not all of us. I'm certainly not standing by, and I don't think any of us here at this site are.  I just don't think it's time for this yet.  We continue to go to hearings and provide testimony.  Write letters and emails.  Contact officials and give our opinions.  I cite studies that I think are strong, and denounce those that I think are weak....and I continue to donate to HDF and HRA's PAC, and NRA, GOA and others who can get some bang for my bucks.  I think most of us here do this...  Don't know where the crazy part came from.  I don't think the idea of the march is crazy, I just don't think it's an idea who's time has come yet. I don't think folks who would participate are crazy.  But if one crazy did get in the ranks, it sure could backfire. We have other avenues with which to make a difference.  Like I said, if it gets "that bad", I may do more...but first I'm gonna exhaust the legal avenues, which I think are currently working.....well to a degree :)

MDS

Re: A march on Washington with loaded rifles
« Reply #47 on: May 07, 2013, 02:18:10 PM »
I admire the effort for the march, I do not have the time to attend it and I hope their efforts have a positive result as I hope all efforts to restore our second amendment rights are successful.  It’s that simple and if that’s propaganda, foolish and hot air etc. well… you’ve my pity.

clshade

Re: A march on Washington with loaded rifles
« Reply #48 on: May 07, 2013, 02:28:30 PM »
Considering that people get told to move on by armed guards if they so much as stop to tie their shoe on The Hill, I'm guessing that the D.C. law enforcement will not let a bunch of guys advertise that they are going to commit felonies and then commit them.

Given that the city grudgingly (and very slowly) allows its residents to even own pistols at all ONLY because the Supreme Court told them they had to, I doubt the department is all that sympathetic to an armed march.

That's pretty much the only reason I think this is a bad idea. If they stayed on the side of the river where it was legal it would be a great idea.

Reporter: "Why are you all carrying rifles?"
Articulate Spokesman: "We don't need a reason. It is perfectly legal for us to do so and we are exercising that right. As you can see, no one is getting hurt and there are no crimes being committed."
Reporter: "Why are you all here at this bridge?"
Articulate Spokesperson: "On this side of the bridge we are legally allowed to exercise our 2nd Amendment rights. On that side of the bridge exercising our 2nd Amendment rights would make us felons. What is perfectly safe and legal on this side of the river is a serious offense just over there. We don't think that makes any sense. A right is a right no matter where you are, isn't it?"

aieahound

Re: A march on Washington with loaded rifles
« Reply #49 on: May 07, 2013, 02:40:39 PM »
Well said Clshade

My question is why now ?  Congress has made the statement that they wil not restrict gun rights at this time. I agree it's only at this time, but, in my opinion, this won't reflect well on responsible gun owners at this time.

Why kick a sleeping dog ?

And I hope all of us discussing this were in front of the State Capitol that Saturday in January. I know I was ( along with a crap load of 2A members). Now that was a glorious sight. and none of us were carrying firearms, much less loaded firearms....
Or have been attending legislative hearings, as Mr. Smith has.   

The worst restrictions right now are in our own State.
 

michalebsdad

Re: A march on Washington with loaded rifles
« Reply #50 on: May 07, 2013, 06:19:40 PM »


And BTW 1000 armed men peaceably assembled would immediately subdue anyone within the ranks who tried to create problems. You can bet your butt there will be damn tight organizing as well as preaddressed responses to several possible issues that may arise. If there's a few bad people in the ranks... they'll be committing suicide that gets nowhere. In anycase, this maybe a very important moment in future history, if it happens. So to say its pointless etc, etc is somewhat premature. There are a few dynamics involved.\

Seriously? You think that a 1000 strangers get together to have this loaded rifle march and one person (another stranger to everyone else) will be able to keep everyone in check? One bad guy with bad intentions will always do bad stuff...

I LOVE this idea by clshade:

That's pretty much the only reason I think this is a bad idea. If they stayed on the side of the river where it was legal it would be a great idea.

Reporter: "Why are you all carrying rifles?"
Articulate Spokesman: "We don't need a reason. It is perfectly legal for us to do so and we are exercising that right. As you can see, no one is getting hurt and there are no crimes being committed."
Reporter: "Why are you all here at this bridge?"
Articulate Spokesperson: "On this side of the bridge we are legally allowed to exercise our 2nd Amendment rights. On that side of the bridge exercising our 2nd Amendment rights would make us felons. What is perfectly safe and legal on this side of the river is a serious offense just over there. We don't think that makes any sense. A right is a right no matter where you are, isn't it?"

This is the type of marches/protests or whatever that would be a good idea, minus the loaded weapons part. The only way I can see a loaded weapon march would be if everyone involved knew each other...you can't control other peoples actions, esp. if you do not know them. I would hate to give the gun grabbers any ammunition to use against us...

pastordennis

  • Trade Count: (0)
  • Sr. Member
  • ****
  • Posts: 349
  • Total likes: 0
  • Isaiah 55:11
  • Referrals: 1
    • View Profile
Re: A march on Washington with loaded rifles
« Reply #51 on: May 07, 2013, 06:21:46 PM »
The best thing here is to use wisdom. If our petitions aren't heard......we try again. Then again. If this was a tea party type assembly......500,000 or more? Possible. But not probable. I don't disagree with the frustration. Its the method. Its not time yet. Soon, But not now. Use wisdom boys.......please. We have everything going for us. You guys have heart, courage, and the right. Lawlessness isn't going to help us. Stay calm, keep your ammo dry and your firearm clean.

michalebsdad

Re: A march on Washington with loaded rifles
« Reply #52 on: May 07, 2013, 06:27:23 PM »
The best thing here is to use wisdom. If our petitions aren't heard......we try again. Then again. If this was a tea party type assembly......500,000 or more? Possible. But not probable. I don't disagree with the frustration. Its the method. Its not time yet. Soon, But not now. Use wisdom boys.......please. We have everything going for us. You guys have heart, courage, and the right. Lawlessness isn't going to help us. Stay calm, keep your ammo dry and your firearm clean.

Definitely sound advice...still love clshades idea! Especially if you could choose a pro 2A reporter, it might make people think. Ultimately, we can do nothing that is criminal, be patient and let the NRA and those folks keep working!

MDS

Re: A march on Washington with loaded rifles
« Reply #53 on: May 07, 2013, 10:56:44 PM »
Seriously? You think that a 1000 strangers get together to have this loaded rifle march and one person (another stranger to everyone else) will be able to keep everyone in check? One bad guy with bad intentions will always do bad stuff...
What sort of bent interpretation is that? It reminds me of a liberal fanatic’s interpretation of something said by the NRA.  What was expressed is very much the opposite of what you’ve magically extrapolated. More like 997 men can stop a few idiots in the ranks... that is what was expressed. Nowhere did I state that one man can stop a few idiots within the ranks.
It's a magical thing, someone expresses something another doesn't agree with and all of a sudden they can’t even properly describe what was expressed, injecting whatever ridiculous thing that pops into mind. Good luck with those communication skills over there.

MDS

Re: A march on Washington with loaded rifles
« Reply #54 on: May 07, 2013, 11:27:39 PM »
“still love clshades idea!” Did the simple fact that they are starting the march on the opposite side of the river of DC at the cemetery and the fact that the DC police have more than likely been alerted somehow escape notice? Did the most likely scenario of the DC police making them turn back at the bridge and cause them to march back to the cemetery somehow escape notice also? In other words, the most likely scenario if the march happens will be that they only march as clshades described. Do you think that the organizer hasn’t already determined that will most likely be the route they make? To this day, I am frigging amazed by wandering minds… oooh look up there in the sky, it must be a UFO! Please pay attention. Thanks. Again... I think the march is a damn good idea. By use of mental discipline, carefully think it through without involving UFO’s from the get go. You might learn something called "strategy". Kind of like when playing chess :thumbsup:

As I said before, there are several dynamics involved. Though not evident to many, it's clear that the organizer is far from being a fool, to the contrary. Consider the emotional disruption across the board and for what? What will more than likely add up to nothing more than an armed stroll from Arlington Cemetery in Virginia along the Potomac opposite DC to the bridge and back again (not illegal in Virginia)? Sort of like representatives of those who rest at Arlington Cemetery presenting arms towards DC, a friendly reminder of what was given to carry those arms.
« Last Edit: May 08, 2013, 12:12:28 AM by MDS »

michalebsdad

Re: A march on Washington with loaded rifles
« Reply #55 on: May 07, 2013, 11:51:52 PM »
Bent interpretation? Liberal fanatic? You mentioned that this group would have "damn tight organizing", I was disagreeing with you on that point. My "ridiculous injecting" was just pointing out that in my personal opinion, I don't see how one person can expect to have control over a thousand people who come from all over the country and gather for this event. ANYTHING that one idiot was able to do prior to being subdued by the 997 other dudes would be to late, it would completely ruin what your peaceful (though illegal) march was trying to achieve. I wasn't attacking your opinion, just giving you mine. Strange though, I have NEVER been called a liberal fanatic before....

Not to mention, I don't understand how committing a felony and losing your right to bear arms, helps the 2A movement...again, just my opinion.

MDS

Re: A march on Washington with loaded rifles
« Reply #56 on: May 08, 2013, 12:06:27 AM »
Bent interpretation? Liberal fanatic? You mentioned that this group would have "damn tight organizing", I was disagreeing with you on that point. My "ridiculous injecting" was just pointing out that in my personal opinion, I don't see how one person can expect to have control over a thousand people who come from all over the country and gather for this event. ANYTHING that one idiot was able to do prior to being subdued by the 997 other dudes would be to late, it would completely ruin what your peaceful (though illegal) march was trying to achieve. I wasn't attacking your opinion, just giving you mine. Strange though, I have NEVER been called a liberal fanatic before....

Not to mention, I don't understand how committing a felony and losing your right to bear arms, helps the 2A movement...again, just my opinion.

It’s simply fascinating. You still don’t get it.

LOL and BTW you still haven't been called a liberal fanatic. LOL
« Last Edit: May 08, 2013, 12:20:18 AM by MDS »

clshade

Re: A march on Washington with loaded rifles
« Reply #57 on: May 08, 2013, 12:25:50 AM »
The organizer isn't talking like he's planning to stop at the bridge.

He's purposefully challenging law enforcement to enforce laws that many feel are unconstitutional.

Many, many (might I stress... MANY) more people do not feel those laws are unconstitutional, or at the very least unreasonable.

To the average American what they hear is "Gun owners plan to break laws as part of pro gun demonstration."

That tends to turn people off. It IS an effective way to highlight unjust laws, of course, but I think planning to stop at the bridge is a better way to do it. If they plan to march into D.C.... then even if they are stopped the average American hears "Gun toting protesters plan to commit felonies but were stopped by police."

There are some other fallacies going on here, too. The assumption is that because it is D.C. that they are challenging the Federal Government. They are not: they are challenging the D.C. police department. If they actually get to the White House then they will be dealing with a whole different matter. For a number of very good reasons (and a number of very bad ones) you simply don't have your constitutional rights there and it has no bearing on the laws that do and don't allow carry in most of the country.

Civil disobedience is fine. Civil disobedience while armed is pretty high amperage and difficult to call civil disobedience. Armed civil disobedience in D.C. is setting yourself up for failure. The organizer knows that.

The mistake I think he is making is thinking that anyone who doesn't already agree with him will care. Those who already agree with him will just get mad if they are stopped by the police. If they are not stopped by the police... they have made no clear point, have they?

That would be the real coup do grace. If the D.C. cops and the Secret Service allowed the march to happen as planned. Think about that for a minute.

He may be thinking strategically but I don't think he has thought it through clearly enough. Either that or he's generating press for himself while being fairly sure it ain't gonna happen at all.

michalebsdad

Re: A march on Washington with loaded rifles
« Reply #58 on: May 08, 2013, 12:40:10 AM »
Below is his plan for the march, I have highlighted to phrase that is concerning...

On the morning of July 4, 2013, Independence Day, we will muster at the National Cemetery & at noon we will step off to march across the Memorial Bridge, down Independence Avenue, around the Capitol, the Supreme Court, & the White House, then peacefully return to Virginia across the Memorial Bridge. This is an act of civil disobedience, not a permitted event. We will march with rifles loaded & slung across our backs to put the government on notice that we will not be intimidated & cower in submission to tyranny. We are marching to mark the high water mark of government & to turn the tide. This will be a non-violent event, unless the government chooses to make it violent. Should we meet physical resistance, we will peacefully turn back, having shown that free people are not welcome in Washington, & returning with the resolve that the politicians, bureaucrats, & enforcers of the federal government will not be welcome in the land of the free.

Without knowing HIS actual motive for this march, I would caution being anywhere near that area. clshade said it perfectly, when he said, "Average American hears "Gun toting protesters plan to commit felonies but were stopped by police." And that is exactly how the media and politicians would run with this...

Whatever happens or doesn't happen regarding this march, I just hope it doesn't hurt the cause, you know...

MDS

Re: A march on Washington with loaded rifles
« Reply #59 on: May 08, 2013, 01:09:57 AM »
clshade,
    It's a very interesting strategy. How it all plays out, we won’t know till July 4th. I think perhaps researching his past demonstrations may shed some light on it… maybe (obviously he hasn’t committed any felonies thus far). The potential to commit a felony is there but will they be allowed to commit the felony wherever that line exists upon the bridge (it would be wrong for them allow the felony and then swoop in and arrest them)?  Without the felony potential and high profile of DC, they would just be another like type demonstration. There may be more to it than what’s been divulged thus far. They may, if stopped, lay down arms and continue the march without arms. It’s hard to say what the whole plan is. It’s intriguing to me. The whole thing may change between now and then also.

michalebsdad,
     "This will be a non-violent event, unless the government chooses to make it violent. Should we meet physical resistance, we will peacefully turn back, having shown that free people are not welcome in Washington, & returning with the resolve that the politicians, bureaucrats, & enforcers of the federal government will not be welcome in the land of the free."
      In context he means just that, if the government makes it violent which I doubt they will. It's too high profile and there would be far too many witnesses with cell phone cameras considering the paranoia brewing on that front these days. Personally I don't think a whole heck of a lot will happen and I doubt they will even cross the bridge unless Obama steps in and allows it (he's the only one with the potential authority to do so, unless DC changes the law, etc).


I need to add the conspiracy slant here.... maybe he works for the Obama administration and it's all planned to allow the march through DC to boost Obama's agendas.  :rofl:
« Last Edit: May 08, 2013, 01:15:59 AM by MDS »