Show Posts

This section allows you to view all posts made by this member. Note that you can only see posts made in areas you currently have access to.

Messages - Jared

Pages: [1] 2 3 4
1
Legal and Activism / Re: Just watched Pureta en banc
« on: February 28, 2016, 04:47:09 AM »
I also wonder when they took the power away from the sheriff and only allowed the corporate police force to issue them.

When Hawaii became a state, they dissolved towns and county sheriff's. The sheriff is now a state agency and there are only county governments .


I also wonder when open carry was restricted.
2
Legal and Activism / Re: Just watched Pureta en banc
« on: February 27, 2016, 07:41:21 PM »
Entire
SECTION 7
Issues of licenses to carry. The judge of a court
of recotd or the sheriff of a county or city and county, shall, upon.
the application of any person having a bona fide residence or place
of business within the jurisdiction of said licensing authority, or of
any person having a bona fide residence or place of business with-.
in the United States, and a license to carry a pistol or revolver
concealed upon his person or to carry one elsewhere than in his home
or office, said license being issued by the authorities of any State or
political subdivision of the United States, issue a license to such person to carry a pistol or revolver within this territory elsewhere
than in his home or office, for not more than ‘one year from date of issue, if it appears that the applicant has good reason to ‘fear an injury’, to his person or property, or has any other proper reason for carrying a pistol or revolver, and that he is a suitable person to be so licensed. ‘The license shall, be in triplicate, in form to be prescribed by the treasurer of the territory, and ,shall bear the name, address, description and signature of the licensee and the reason ‘given for desiring a license. The original thereof shall be delivered to the licensee; the duplicate shall .within seven days, be ‘sent by registered mail, to the treasurer of the territory and the
triplicate shall be preserved for six years by the authority issuing said license.


Do you have a link to the entirety of Act 206? I'd like to read it. I looked online but I couldn't find it?

It appears Hawaii used to be shall issue and the license used to be valid statewide (territory wide).

I wonder when they went to May issue and I also wonder when they only allowed for the permits to be valid countywide instead of being valid statewide.
3
They won't come after you. Hawaii's registration system is so old that they don't even have a statewide database.

Many people left New York for Florida. It's safe to assume many of these people have sold or traded guns in Florida or even had some stolen,  they don't call New York to track you down. I don't see why Hawaii to Georgia would be any different.
4
Legal and Activism / Re: Hawaii has lowest gun death rates
« on: February 24, 2015, 10:20:53 PM »
Quite expected, but the VPC doesn't list what or where they got this information.  They say "new information" and all the VPC does is link to the CDC.  No reports.  No data. No information.


I mean let's be honest, Vermont is #34, and probably has some of the most lax gun laws... constitutional carry for a long ass time as well.

Just in Vermont last week visiting family. It's nice to sterile conceal carry (no ID no permission slip). Vermont doesn't even have a violent felon in posession ban. Only the Feds can prosecute under federal law.
5
But since we're asking questions, let me ask you this: Name a big governmental agency that you think does a good job at what it's supposed to be doing.

Definitely the post office. They are much better than the common carriers..... At least when it comes to delivering illegal drugs  :geekdanc:
6
If a natural-born US citizen has ancestry in a European nation, and is eligible for dual citizenship, are there any negative consequences from pursuing that?  I would think the answer is "No," but figure it can't hurt to ask.

It's for a friend of mine... ;)

No, the U.S. Ignores dual citizen ship. Just don't renounce your US citizenship on foreign soil.  You can renounce it on US soil if need be, but it won't mean anything to the US Gov.
7
Legal and Activism / Re: Unregistered firearm and actual court case
« on: August 19, 2014, 04:00:31 PM »
Jared,

Good question, I don't know myself. I know handguns have been registered since territorial days, somehow I scrubbed that out when I was writing my post. I just wish that this state would get with the 21st century, having to go to HPD for registration is asinine when the FFL has to verify all the information at point-of-sale and send the transfer information to HPD. If California can run its firearm registration system electronically, so can this state.

Granted I wish there was no registration or waiting period beyond the 5 mins for the NICS check (which HPD does when they run your permit application, plus the mental health check) but I am realistic. This is, and always will be, a Democrat progressive utopia, I don't see anything changing unless its via the Federal court system.

It can change and it slowly is. Hawaii is not as anti gun as it used to be. It was about a decade ago that they were considering license to possess firearms and ammo.

Firearms registration numbers have been on the rise. More people are owning guns and the more people you introduce to shooting and the idea of self defense, it contributes to the paradigm shift.

You gotta know that it frustrates to gun grabbers to no end that registration numbers have tripled since 2000.
8
Hawaiian law has no provision for unregistering a gun. This is nothing new. Michigan has no way to unregister a handgun either.

Hawaii's registration system is very antiquated and fortunately, it is not as efficient and standardize like it is in New York.

I have been thinking about moving to Hawaii when I retire many years down the road, or at least spend half of the year over there. So I have actually been thinking about registering all the guns I want to bring in one of the counties that I will not move to. That way when I move to one of the other counties, I have no legal obligation to register my guns there. And they will be harder to track because they would be tied to my out-of-state ID at an address that I no longer live at.

Or you could just register your guns in Kauai where of the old lady doesn't care if she gets your date of birth and social security number wrong… Which is no problem by my standards  :D
9
Legal and Activism / Re: Unregistered firearm and actual court case
« on: August 18, 2014, 02:54:17 PM »
Well registration wasn't required until 1992 or 1993 (can't remember which) so I am sure lots of people here in Hawaii have legally owned but unregistered firearms. I have not heard of any cases concerning prosecution over an unregistered firearm, nor any cases about someone prosecuted over possession of a high capacity magazine (at least where that was the primary issue,and not tacked onto other charges).

That is a neat tool!

While this is true for rifles and shotguns, handguns have been registered since Hawaii was a territory.  So the only way that could work for a handgun is if you're about 90 years old and you have a handgun that was made back in the 30s.

From my understanding, before Hawaii registered long arms, you needed an individual purchase permit for each long arm like you do for handguns. So wouldn't the rifle or shotgun have been registered on the individual permit to purchase form?
10
Legal and Activism / Re: Guam Passes "Shall Issue" CCW by 13-2 Vote
« on: May 24, 2014, 02:55:51 PM »
American Samoa is closer to Hawaii than Guam and their gun laws are terrible. You can only own .22 Rifle and Shotguns. All handguns are illegal AND if you bring legal firearms to own in the territory you pay 150% tax on the total cost of the firearm. Ammo also gets a 150% tax as well.

I will probably never move back home...ever.

I once sent the AS police an Email saying that they need to be versed in LEOSA because if I visit, I will be bringing 2 handguns and they can't do a thing about it.

AS does have terrible gun laws; however, the Marianas Islands is actually worse if you can believe it... Steps are being taken there, but it's slow going.
11
Well friends the fight for your rights goes well. However due to the unpaid nature of that fight I have to let Baker, Fisher and Young play out as all potentially have a lot of work involved in them.
Fisher gets heard for the last time on June 12th and 134-7 crime of violence provision will undoubtedly be struck down. I can assure you that opinion will be appealed.
Baker is going through the same en banc process as Peruta and there is a strong chance of  Supreme Court review. 
I doubt Young will be heard until after all the handgun carry issues are resolved in the Ninth.

That being said this is a great time to ask Hawaii's Second Amendment community to find a resident alien or U.S. national.  The reason for this is the Second Amendment Foundation has a standing policy of challenging such bans. The reason is these cases are guaranteed wins. There is no reason U.S. Nationals (born in America Samoa) should be denied firearm rights and the most important thing is for us to keep up the pressure do they think twice before passing a nonsensical law..

If you know anyone living here on a green card who has been in the country for at least a couple years see if they would consider being a plaintiff in this suit.  The first question they will ask is whether this could impact their green card. The answer to that is not unless they wish to face federal jail.  Any U.S. national would be great as well. 

Simply put its up to our community to find a person willing and able to be the plaintiff. PM me if you find someone.

I apologize if I am derailing this thread however you mentioned on one of the Calgon's threads that Hawaii conceded their ban on switchblades, butterfly knives, and carrying rifles and shotguns. was this during Baker's case? If so when do you think those statutes will be officially null and void.

While I do not know of any noncitizen residents of Hawaii, I have been involved in this issue for a few years now. I gave Alan At SAF a list of states that had citizen only discrimination laws and he has been working off of that list.

I am sure that you already know this however in case you do not I would reference the material that Comm2a used in Fletcher v Haas in the First Circuit.
12
Legal and Activism / Re: Win in Baker
« on: March 20, 2014, 05:20:31 PM »
We need to wait to see how Peruta is finally disposed off.  We should know more mid April.  That is my best guess at this point.

Chris,

If you win and Honolulu issues, will you apply to the other 3 counties? If not, will you ask the court to make the license statewide under the "undue burden" concept?

13
I can say with 100% honesty I cannot carry yet. So it's not an issue.  Even if it was, it's still recommended by all agencies to get carry permits to avoid things like GFSZ etc.

You won't have to worry about FGFSZA in HI, you are licensed to possess a firearm simply by registering it.

In fact, that's why I only registered one of my guns in HI, because the state did a background check and licenses me to possess a gun by issuing me a registration certificate.
14
There is no residency requirement.  The only thing HPD said is that people need to apply in person, because they are going to see you sign the paperwork and print you.  That's what was told to me a while ago.   Technically, when I applied I was a non resident military.

Right. I was assuming if the state is forced to go shall issue and they adopted the bill that Sam Slom has been pushing for years. That bill requires residency. I was just thinking 3 steps ahead :)

I just hope they don't bounce your case due to Your LEOSA coverage.
15
Great News !

Is it time to organize the Great Hawaii CCW application day ?

Class action anyone if Peruta stands and Hawaii fails to fall in line ?

If we can assert that HI doesn't grant anyone CCW permits on principal, and we don't have open carry, I would think we'd have a good chance to prevail.
We could also address the dissenting opinion at the same time, since they're saying the court should only be addressing CCW, not the right to bear.
( I didn't read the actuall opinions, just the links from Tom which seemed very informative. Thanks Tom. but it still means I'm ignorant. )

Keep up the good fight Chris, and thanks from all of us for the work you're doing !  :shaka:

If Peruta stands, you will have carry in Hawaii sooner rather than later.

Let's just hope they don't opt for shall issue open carry with the hope of ostracizing people and intimidating them from carrying. This could happen but it seems unlikely.

People OC in Guam and it's been accepted for the most part. You would think they would offer them a CCW permit in Guam but they haven't... But at least they have a mode of carry.... Soon HI will too :)
16
We still need to wait on the decision in Baker v. Kealoha then we'll see where it goes. For Chicago, the city had a set time period to get a new law on the books.

True, but keep in mind that Illinois had no carry system. They would have to had basically deputize people as peace officers to be able to carry. CA and HI are different in that they have laws already on the books for permits. While an intern period probably would be granted, it would most likely be shorter.
17
9th Circuit Court of Appeals rules that Carry is a right and that may issue licensing is unconstitutional.  Opinions for Richards v. San Diego and Baker v. Kealoha not published at this time.

http://cdn.ca9.uscourts.gov/datastore/opinions/2014/02/12/1056971.pdf



TLDR version:

1.) A right to carry firearms for self-defense exists outside the home.  Heller was not specific, but pointed squarely to this reasoning.
2.) History shows that bear meant to carry outside for self-defense.
3.) That right can be either/or, or both concealed or open, but one *must* be available to *ALL* common citizens.  May issue policies are wholly unconstitutional.

Today is an EXCITING day.

I predict that SCOTUS will grant cert to Drake (New Jersey) and Peruta will not be heard en banc.

Assuming Peruta stands, how will you go about attacking Hawaii.

134-9 is obviously not suitable to this decision. 134-9 deems that in an uncommon occurance that one may be issued an open carry license and in an exceptional case, a CCW license may be granted. This will have to be struck.

Second point, it seems they would be free to issue you either an OC  or CCW license, you wouldn't be able to demand one or the other, but at least one. HI would probably go with CCW.

Third point, the county restriction is an undue burden, if the state's limited public safety interested is satisfied by one chief issuing you a license, then it should be valid statewide.

Not to get ahead of myself, but if 134-9 is either replaced or an alternative to a newly created shall-issue statewide CCW law, PLEASE, do not forget about non-residents, if Hawaii doesn't want to recognize out of state licenses then perhaps they can have non-residents mail applications to the AG or the Department of Safety.

Just some thoughts.
18
Not to derail the thread, but if you get bored you can look into AS.  They have some *very* strange laws and stuff in the treaty.  Some stuff about the "spirit" or "essence" of the island and the tribe type stuff.  It would be considered crazy when compared to Western law.

Gray Peterson and I looked into AS.

It would seem that under the "fundamental rights" doctrine that RKBA would apply. AS is a bit complicated because they are not in the 9th circuit. It seems that they are in the Washington D.C. circuit.

AS has bad gun laws (they banned handguns in the late 1980's/or 1990). They are shotgun friendly but they only allow 22 cal rifles. CNMI is worse.
19
This isn't going to last long. It's already on like (3) different groups radars. Not just for LEOSA.  There are Heller style problems out there!

I think we can agree that the language has gaps in it that could cause some significant headache for anyone that got in trouble even though they may be 100% innocent?  I always think the best course of action is to not consume any alcohol when I'm carrying under that; my personal policy is not to, I never want anything in the way of being able to question my judgement.

I've been asking the CNMI AG for an opinion, he's ignoring me. The same for American Samoa. Guam on the other hand is 100 percent on board.


I'm well aware of the CNMI Heller issue... Thanks again for the donation. Let's just say, I'll miss my springfield XD :)
20
Ok. So i read the iron pigs case.  Biggest thing is that the State could not restrict where they could carry. The bar is not a place that they can restrict from Feds, even though the S.D. Prosecutor thought it should have been and that it was "sufficiently akin to the exceptions."  He was wrong - it's not listed, that shit doesn't count.   However, if the bar itself wanted to, it could restrict carry there, but not the government.  The government could only restrict locations within their own domain (their buildings, parks, etc.).  I see the judge stated that they were not under the influence, but I'm not sure the record really reflects that? The FLETC training says that the individuals involved were "socializing."

The USAG has stated that we must "meet the state standards, if any, regarding alcohol or drug use by law enforcement officers authorized to carry a firearm."  That's in the AG memo 01312005.   I'm not sure what Hawaii's standards are.  I bet if I tried to UIPA the information they would give me a shit ton of grief.

The RI case will take some digging; however it was based off (People v. Togher (1970), 127 Ill.App.2d 141, 262 N.E.2d 88  from IL.

Because it's a federal statute, hawaii doesn't get to interpret it or fine tune the definitions. Either someone is covered under the law or they are not. Hawaii, nor any other state gets to define anything outside what is explicitly stated in the statute such as government property being off limits and the state establishing qualification standards.

Hawaii is just hostile to LEOSA, they claimed in the past that non residents must register even though there are cops that couldn't register even if they wanted to because they are prohibited under Hawaii law from possessing a firearm due to violent misdemeanor criminal convictions.

They also claimed that retiree's  can only carry what you qualify with even though "types" of firearms are defined in 18 USC 921. If you qual with a handgun, all handguns are covered, if you qual with a shotgun, all shotguns are covered, if you qual with a short barreled shotgun, all short barreled shotguns are covered.

There is a murky area with intoxication; however, if someone is covered under LEOSA and are exempt... They are exempt from any law to the contrary.  States just like to whine about preemption when they lose control over a situation.

At least Hawaii isn't as bad as the Mariana's islands who pretend that LEOSA doesn't exist at all.

This is why if you are ever jammed up for carrying under LEOSA, file a 1446 petition to move the case out of state court to federal court ASAP. 

While there is no hard definition on intoxication for LEOSA, it is a federal standard that is not left to each state or territory to decide... Kind of like how these states that issue qual cards put "pistol" and "revolver" on the cards even though those words aren't defined in federal law, only "handgun".
Pages: [1] 2 3 4