Ok. So i read the iron pigs case. Biggest thing is that the State could not restrict where they could carry. The bar is not a place that they can restrict from Feds, even though the S.D. Prosecutor thought it should have been and that it was "sufficiently akin to the exceptions." He was wrong - it's not listed, that shit doesn't count. However, if the bar itself wanted to, it could restrict carry there, but not the government. The government could only restrict locations within their own domain (their buildings, parks, etc.). I see the judge stated that they were not under the influence, but I'm not sure the record really reflects that? The FLETC training says that the individuals involved were "socializing."
The USAG has stated that we must "meet the state standards, if any, regarding alcohol or drug use by law enforcement officers authorized to carry a firearm." That's in the AG memo 01312005. I'm not sure what Hawaii's standards are. I bet if I tried to UIPA the information they would give me a shit ton of grief.
The RI case will take some digging; however it was based off (People v. Togher (1970), 127 Ill.App.2d 141, 262 N.E.2d 88 from IL.
Because it's a federal statute, hawaii doesn't get to interpret it or fine tune the definitions. Either someone is covered under the law or they are not. Hawaii, nor any other state gets to define anything outside what is explicitly stated in the statute such as government property being off limits and the state establishing qualification standards.
Hawaii is just hostile to LEOSA, they claimed in the past that non residents must register even though there are cops that couldn't register even if they wanted to because they are prohibited under Hawaii law from possessing a firearm due to violent misdemeanor criminal convictions.
They also claimed that retiree's can only carry what you qualify with even though "types" of firearms are defined in 18 USC 921. If you qual with a handgun, all handguns are covered, if you qual with a shotgun, all shotguns are covered, if you qual with a short barreled shotgun, all short barreled shotguns are covered.
There is a murky area with intoxication; however, if someone is covered under LEOSA and are exempt... They are exempt from any law to the contrary. States just like to whine about preemption when they lose control over a situation.
At least Hawaii isn't as bad as the Mariana's islands who pretend that LEOSA doesn't exist at all.
This is why if you are ever jammed up for carrying under LEOSA, file a 1446 petition to move the case out of state court to federal court ASAP.
While there is no hard definition on intoxication for LEOSA, it is a federal standard that is not left to each state or territory to decide... Kind of like how these states that issue qual cards put "pistol" and "revolver" on the cards even though those words aren't defined in federal law, only "handgun".