Montana shooting, possibly within rights but brutal (Read 49439 times)

bubba808

ImKu

Re: Montana shooting, possibly within rights but brutal
« Reply #1 on: April 29, 2014, 08:09:09 PM »
I don't know the laws of that state, but to answer your question, no I do not think it is justified.  If in fact he was baiting with the intent of killing someone, that goes without saying IMO.
« Last Edit: April 29, 2014, 08:26:10 PM by ImKu »
The mind acts like an enemy for those who do not control it.
- Bhagavad Gita

dogman

Re: Montana shooting, possibly within rights but brutal
« Reply #2 on: April 29, 2014, 08:18:38 PM »
If you get repeatedly burglarized because you leave your garage door partially open, you should close your garage door.>:( :(

Q

.
« Reply #3 on: April 29, 2014, 08:22:43 PM »
.
« Last Edit: December 14, 2016, 03:37:47 PM by Q »

HiCarry

Re: Montana shooting, possibly within rights but brutal
« Reply #4 on: April 29, 2014, 08:57:00 PM »
We don't know all the facts, so it is difficult to draw any conclusions, yet.

IF the facts show that the homeowner had legitimate concerns for his life or safety, it leans toward a justifiable shooting.

IF the facts show the homeowner "baited" the kid into committing a crime, it leans toward an unjustifiable shooting.

Remember, the media, especially in self defense shootings are notoriously biased and not beyond "doctoring" the facts to achieve their goals....NBC's altering of the 911 tape in the Travon Martin reporting is a shining example.

Jl808

Montana shooting, possibly within rights but brutal
« Reply #5 on: April 29, 2014, 09:03:48 PM »
Crooks should realize that playing stupid games = winning stupid prizes.
I think, therefore I am armed.
NRA Life Patron member, HRA Life member, HiFiCo Life Member, HDF member

The United States Constitution © 1791. All Rights Reserved.

Walena

Re: Montana shooting, possibly within rights but brutal
« Reply #6 on: April 29, 2014, 09:22:36 PM »
We all know how the media can twist around a story just to make it interesting news.

Just my initial opinion, as I don't know all the details, and how much of was reported is true, and the exact laws there. I'm not even an attorney, so I could be way off on this.

If they baited the garage to lure the thieves in and shoot them, then no.

If he armed himself and went outside to his garage to confront the person in the garage, then no.

He never I.D'd his target before he began shooting, then no.

Was there mention of any call to 911 before him going outside to the garage, because more than likely the operator would have advised him to stay inside.

dogman

Re: Montana shooting, possibly within rights but brutal
« Reply #7 on: April 29, 2014, 09:32:43 PM »
I don't get why people say 'he should have closed the door', when it is already against the law for people to enter and individual's home or property uninvited. That is called trespassing, whether the door is open or not, so that kid had no reason to be in his garage for whatever reason.
If someone kept breaking the lock on my front door and burglarizing my home, I would get a better lock. There's nothing wrong with preventative maintenance. Unfortunately there are people who do things even though it's against the law. If the kid was stealing from the guy, maybe he got what he deserves, maybe not.

Q

.
« Reply #8 on: April 29, 2014, 09:40:39 PM »
.
« Last Edit: December 14, 2016, 03:38:11 PM by Q »

Pizzo

Re: Montana shooting, possibly within rights but brutal
« Reply #9 on: April 30, 2014, 06:33:38 AM »
I can't speak on wether this was a "justifiable" shooting or not, there is still a lot of missing, and possibly misleading, information.

However, being born and raised in Montana (Libby, Flathead lake area and Kalispell) I can tell you that you DO NOT go onto private property or land without being invited. And you sure as hell DO NOT go into someones house, garage, barn or any other structure on said private property without being invited or without an extremely good reason!!

Doing so will, and can, result in being shot. This is just how it was and how it is up there. It's old country with unwriten rules and old laws, it's a wild place with wild people. As a child we were always taught to protect yourself and your family at any cost and to NEVER go on property we had no place being on!

With that being said Montana also has a terrible and rampid meth and prescription drug abuse problem right now and home break ins, car break ins, vandalisms and robberies are at an all time high. This has caused many of it's residents to live on edge and to expect the worse when it comes to hearing bumps in the night.

Of course none of what I wrote validates any persons actions in shooting another human being. It does however shed some light on the history and current crimes that may affect a persons (homeowners) mental state and judgements leading to a shooting.

The real question of course is WHAT THE HELL IS AN EXCHANGE STUDENT DOING IN A STRANGERS GARAGE IN THE MIDDLE OF THE NIGHT?!  :wtf:

punaperson

Re: Montana shooting, possibly within rights but brutal
« Reply #10 on: April 30, 2014, 06:49:21 AM »
The real question of course is WHAT THE HELL IS AN EXCHANGE STUDENT DOING IN A STRANGERS GARAGE IN THE MIDDLE OF THE NIGHT?!  :wtf:
This tragedy could have been avoided were it not for the insular ignorance of Americans re the cultural practices of other nations and peoples. It is well known that outside America, and especially in Germany where this student was from, entering a stranger's property and taking things from that property in the middle of the night is an accepted activity, and even encouraged as "fun". What is wrong with Americans? Papiere bitte. [/sarcasm]

mauidog

Re: Montana shooting, possibly within rights but brutal
« Reply #11 on: April 30, 2014, 08:04:37 AM »
It's tough to form an educated opinion when all the facts are not reported or known.  There are, however, two undeniable facts:

1.  Diren Dede will never do anything wrong ever again, and

2.  *Kaarma's a bitch!

(Note for those too lazy to read the article:  the home owner's name is Markus Kaarma.   :thumbsup:)
An unarmed man can only flee from evil, and evil is not overcome by fleeing from it.   -- Jeff Cooper

kumaWRX

Re: Montana shooting, possibly within rights but brutal
« Reply #12 on: April 30, 2014, 08:32:30 AM »
I can't speak on wether this was a "justifiable" shooting or not, there is still a lot of missing, and possibly misleading, information.

However, being born and raised in Montana (Libby, Flathead lake area and Kalispell) I can tell you that you DO NOT go onto private property or land without being invited. And you sure as hell DO NOT go into someones house, garage, barn or any other structure on said private property without being invited or without an extremely good reason!!

Doing so will, and can, result in being shot. This is just how it was and how it is up there. It's old country with unwriten rules and old laws, it's a wild place with wild people. As a child we were always taught to protect yourself and your family at any cost and to NEVER go on property we had no place being on!

With that being said Montana also has a terrible and rampid meth and prescription drug abuse problem right now and home break ins, car break ins, vandalisms and robberies are at an all time high. This has caused many of it's residents to live on edge and to expect the worse when it comes to hearing bumps in the night.

Very good info  :thumbsup:   That reminds me, I recently saw a documentary on drugs in Montana and how a lot of drug dealers and runners are moving into Big Sky country.  They're coming here because drugs sell for a lot more than most other places in this country because it's distance from Mexico and South America and because there's a lot less competition to fight with.  Also, Montana has some of highest amount of addicts per capita because a lot of them are trying to escape the boredom of the vast open spaces.  I believe I saw this on Nat Geo, very interesting.

causa mortis

Re: Montana shooting, possibly within rights but brutal
« Reply #13 on: April 30, 2014, 01:01:43 PM »
It's real simple: if you don't want to risk bodily harm, then don't sneak onto private property and into someone's garage in the middle of the night. It's obvious this German kid wasn't out making door-to-door bible sales.

aieahound

Re: Montana shooting, possibly within rights but brutal
« Reply #14 on: April 30, 2014, 02:14:40 PM »
Based on the facts in the article ( and I'm not saying those are the real facts or complete ) Looks kinda messed up.
Legal in Texas though.  :D

Appears the homeowner went around and entered through the open garage door, effectively trapping the kid.
Then fired off four shots into the darkness, which was reportedly pitch black.

It's real simple: if you don't want to risk bodily harm, then don't sneak onto private property and into someone's garage in the middle of the night. It's obvious this German kid wasn't out making door-to-door bible sales.

+1. I agree with that.
But this seems a little Wonky.

German kid was probably talked into it by the other no-good kid that ran.

HiCarry

Re: Montana shooting, possibly within rights but brutal
« Reply #15 on: April 30, 2014, 09:43:37 PM »
If baiting someone to commit a crime is wrong, shouldn't that make officers pretending to be prostitues wrong? What about cops baiting people to hire them when they portray themselves as hitmen? Better still, when they bail pedophiles as underage girls/boys?

This kid, for whatever reason, was illegally in his house. The shooters true motives might be revealed, but in the end it boils down to  the fact that had this kid respected this mans property and privacy, this never would have happened.

I'm pretty sure they didn't have a 'free cookies, come on in!' Sign on their garage, so it doesn't matter if the garage was partially closed or all the way open; kid shouldn't have been there, and he paid the price, whether if it was excessive or not.

Hey, for what it's worth, I agree with you. If you don't want to get shot, don't go onto others folks property or try to steal their stuff. That being said, in many places it just isn't that black or white and shooting at someone ONLY because he's in your home (i.e. without a fear for your life or safety) could well land you in deep legal doo doo....

I suspect Montana has some pretty strong Castle Doctrine laws, maybe even a presumption of deadly intent if inside a residence uninvited. 

mauidog

Re: Montana shooting, possibly within rights but brutal
« Reply #16 on: April 30, 2014, 09:54:41 PM »
Hey, for what it's worth, I agree with you. If you don't want to get shot, don't go onto others folks property or try to steal their stuff. That being said, in many places it just isn't that black or white and shooting at someone ONLY because he's in your home (i.e. without a fear for your life or safety) could well land you in deep legal doo doo....

I suspect Montana has some pretty strong Castle Doctrine laws, maybe even a presumption of deadly intent if inside a residence uninvited.

My opinion about someone breaking into a home is basically ... if they are there when the house is empty, it's a simple breaking and entering/burglary issue.  BUT, if there is someone home, then it's a home invasion. 

If someone is brazen enough to enter a home while it's occupied, they must also be prepared to do whatever is necessary to force the residents to submit.  That makes them a serious threat which justifies use of deadly force.
An unarmed man can only flee from evil, and evil is not overcome by fleeing from it.   -- Jeff Cooper

HiCarry

Re: Montana shooting, possibly within rights but brutal
« Reply #17 on: April 30, 2014, 11:29:25 PM »
My opinion about someone breaking into a home is basically ... if they are there when the house is empty, it's a simple breaking and entering/burglary issue.  BUT, if there is someone home, then it's a home invasion. 

If someone is brazen enough to enter a home while it's occupied, they must also be prepared to do whatever is necessary to force the residents to submit.  That makes them a serious threat which justifies use of deadly force.

I don't disagree with your logic but again, it depends on where you are and the laws of that state. In New Jersey you must retreat from your own home, or at least attempt to. In other states, the mere presence of someone in your house uninvited presumes they are there with deadly intent so as to justify deadly force without further articulated fear for your life or safety.

You shoot someone in your house in NJ with out additional justification, you're going to jail for a long time. Same situation in a less restrictive (or, as I prefer to call them, "more enlightened") state, and you probably won't even go "downtown" for the evening.

SOLEsource684

Re: Montana shooting, possibly within rights but brutal
« Reply #18 on: May 01, 2014, 12:16:09 AM »
I don't disagree with your logic but again, it depends on where you are and the laws of that state. In New Jersey you must retreat from your own home, or at least attempt to. In other states, the mere presence of someone in your house uninvited presumes they are there with deadly intent so as to justify deadly force without further articulated fear for your life or safety.

You shoot someone in your house in NJ with out additional justification, you're going to jail for a long time. Same situation in a less restrictive (or, as I prefer to call them, "more enlightened") state, and you probably won't even go "downtown" for the evening.

It still baffles me why the victim should have to retreat from their own home when some SOB criminal decides to break in. That is a total :wtf: moment.

punaperson

Re: Montana shooting, possibly within rights but brutal
« Reply #19 on: May 01, 2014, 06:45:43 AM »
It still baffles me why the victim should have to retreat from their own home when some SOB criminal decides to break in. That is a total :wtf: moment.
Yeah, it's a mystery alright. Somewhere, in whatever reasoning there might be, is some form of an assumption about criminals not acting out of choice, but the idea that "they can't help it" because they are merely the automaton product/result of a "difficult upbringing", and therefore, like the adjudicated insane, can't really be held responsible for their actions, therefore you may not legally harm them no matter what they are doing.

1. Of course there are likely hundreds if not thousands of people who grew up in identical or nearly identical conditions that do not commit criminal acts, and
2. A lot of these criminals are recidivists with extremely lengthy histories of repeating criminal acts over and over and over again, and yet the "criminal justice system" deems them worthy of being returned to society again and again and again so they may harm innocent people.

So yeah, you gotta retreat. And if you don't retreat, you gotta be really nice to them. Because they can't help it.

Remember though, if you respond to this criminal threat in a way that harms the criminal, regardless of your upbringing and the circumstances at hand, you will (in many jurisdictions including Hawaii) be treated as a criminal who clearly acted out of choice. Go figure.