Montana shooting, possibly within rights but brutal (Read 49444 times)

Kingkeoni

Re: Montana shooting, possibly within rights but brutal
« Reply #20 on: May 01, 2014, 07:48:42 AM »
German kid was probably talked into it by the other no-good kid that ran.

Allow me to be the first one to call bullshit on this.

Presuming that this kid from Germany was some saint, skipping home with a picnic basket is foolish.

We don't know his true intentions right now, and the only side of the story we have is the home owners.

Germany has its own fair share of crime as well.

While gun violence is significantly less, their burglaries and robberies are up with the highest per capita in the world.

http://www.nationmaster.com/country-info/compare/Germany/United-States/Crime
Your number one Option for Personal Security is a lifelong commitment to avoidance, deterrence, and de-escalation.

Someday someone may kill you with your own gun, but they should have to beat you to death with it because it is empty.

aieahound

Re: Montana shooting, possibly within rights but brutal
« Reply #21 on: May 01, 2014, 09:24:13 AM »
I'm not saying the German kid was a saint. He was certainly up to no-good.

But it's interesting that the local kid runs like a bat out of hell (presumably) when the homeowner comes out and the German kid takes 2 shotgun blasts in the back of the pitch black garage.

German exchange student could have been the mastermind. Possible but not likely.

Still sounds like the homeowner trapped him by entering the garage from outside the garage door. ( unless it's a detached garage, but then there'd be no castle doctrine ) 

Jl808

Re: Montana shooting, possibly within rights but brutal
« Reply #22 on: May 01, 2014, 11:11:33 AM »
German kid would still be alive if he decided not to break into someone's house.
I think, therefore I am armed.
NRA Life Patron member, HRA Life member, HiFiCo Life Member, HDF member

The United States Constitution © 1791. All Rights Reserved.

aieahound

Re: Montana shooting, possibly within rights but brutal
« Reply #23 on: May 01, 2014, 02:42:16 PM »
I'm not defending the kid but this was no home invasion. Wasn't even a B&E.

Homeowner sounds like a Joe Biden gone awry. If you hear a noise, just run outside and fire 4 blasts into your pitch black garage.

And I understand we don't have all the facts.

But how do we know the local kid wasn't telling the German kid, "Don't worry just run in there and grab whatever the hell he was after. We do it all the time. I'll stand watch. "
German kid. "Yeah I want to fit in. Cool."

Homeowner comes out and local kid runs like hell, leaving German kid hung out to dry. 
Never thinking that homeowner would just start blowing off multiple shotgun rounds into the garage without ID'ing anything, much less the suspect. 

mauidog

Re: Montana shooting, possibly within rights but brutal
« Reply #24 on: May 01, 2014, 03:03:35 PM »
I'm not defending the kid but this was no home invasion. Wasn't even a B&E.

Homeowner sounds like a Joe Biden gone awry. If you hear a noise, just run outside and fire 4 blasts into your pitch black garage.

And I understand we don't have all the facts.

But how do we know the local kid wasn't telling the German kid, "Don't worry just run in there and grab whatever the hell he was after. We do it all the time. I'll stand watch. "
German kid. "Yeah I want to fit in. Cool."

Homeowner comes out and local kid runs like hell, leaving German kid hung out to dry. 
Never thinking that homeowner would just start blowing off multiple shotgun rounds into the garage without ID'ing anything, much less the suspect.

The German "kid" was 17.  Same age as Trayvon Martin.

At 17, you can legally drive, join the military with parental consent, legally watch "R" rated movies, and on and on.  This kid was old enough to know right from wrong, and unless you know something you aren't telling us, he was just as likely to be the instigator.  Not sure if you've met many foreign exchange students, but the ones I remember were more willing to break a few rules to have fun because they had the "I'm not from here" excuse to use and get away with it.

The homeowner, Kaarma (still chuckle at that name's irony!  :D ) had been burglarized several times.  For all we know, this was the same burglar coming back for more goodies thinking it'll be just as easy as last time.

How do I know all that?  The same way you know what you're posting...

IMAGINATION!!

An unarmed man can only flee from evil, and evil is not overcome by fleeing from it.   -- Jeff Cooper

punaperson

Re: Montana shooting, possibly within rights but brutal
« Reply #25 on: May 01, 2014, 03:16:14 PM »
I'm not defending the kid but this was no home invasion. Wasn't even a B&E.

Homeowner sounds like a Joe Biden gone awry. If you hear a noise, just run outside and fire 4 blasts into your pitch black garage.

And I understand we don't have all the facts.

But how do we know the local kid wasn't telling the German kid, "Don't worry just run in there and grab whatever the hell he was after. We do it all the time. I'll stand watch. "
German kid. "Yeah I want to fit in. Cool."

Homeowner comes out and local kid runs like hell, leaving German kid hung out to dry. 
Never thinking that homeowner would just start blowing off multiple shotgun rounds into the garage without ID'ing anything, much less the suspect.
Whatever the facts turn out to be about who may have induced or encouraged whom to do what for whatever reasons, the fact that does apparently remain is that someone went onto and into another person's private property, likely with the intent to take something that didn't belong to them. I suppose it is possible that they were sightseeing, but the previous two similar events in the same location were thefts... could have been a coincidence, right? Theft and trespassing are clearly a choice. Yes, I said it. A person freely chose to engage in criminal activity. Unless in the extremely unusual circumstance of acting solely out of the duress of lethal threats unless he would do as ordered (aka "Patty Hearst Syndrome"), this person chose to act as he did. Whether the actions that subsequently took place were moral or legal is another question entirely, but those questions would never have arisen had not the German student chosen to do what he did, commit a crime, initiating a chain of events.

Or, more succinctly, as JI808 put it:
German kid would still be alive if he decided not to break into someone's house.
« Last Edit: May 01, 2014, 04:09:25 PM by punaperson »

aieahound

Re: Montana shooting, possibly within rights but brutal
« Reply #26 on: May 01, 2014, 03:35:52 PM »
I agree I'm throwing crap in there that don't exist and a 17 year old is not a kid. Probably a comment that didn't need to be made and sidetracked the thread.
 :stopjack:

This was no home invasion. Wasn't even a B&E.

Homeowner still sounds like a Joe Biden gone awry. If you hear a noise, just run outside and fire 4 blasts into your pitch black garage.

Would you run outside, enter your garage from the outside and fire 4 blasts blind on a trapped thief you think might still be there ?
( Only if you live in Texas where it's legal.  At least I think it's legal in TX. I personally thought it would be legal in Montana also.  )

What happened?
Thought the guy was rustlin' my fishin' gear again, so I shot him dead.
Did you see him?
No, I didn't see him, but I feared for my life.
Why did you fear for your life ?
Cause I ran outside and had him trapped in my garage and couldn't see him cause I had no lights or flashlight.
Why didn't you take a flashlight ?
Cause I had a shotgun.
Did you call the police ?
Who needs the police, I had a shotgun. And he's not gonna be stealing from anyone else anymore.

Meanwhile, the guy is dead. Dead.

That's a serious thing we all need to think about.
What is worth killing someone over ?
Repeatedly ripping off your crap from your open garage ?

That's a whole 'nother conversation.
( and this is NOT a thou shalt not kill rant. There are definitely situations, IMO where we would all be justified. )

German kid would still be alive if he decided not to break into someone's house.
And I agree.

Walena

Re: Montana shooting, possibly within rights but brutal
« Reply #27 on: May 01, 2014, 06:08:52 PM »
German kid would still be alive if he decided not to break into someone's house.

The German kid AND his partner know now that it's better to be alive.   ;D

aieahound

Re: Montana shooting, possibly within rights but brutal
« Reply #28 on: May 01, 2014, 06:48:03 PM »
The German kid AND his partner know now that it's better to be alive.   ;D

No offense to anyone, but this a little bit nuts.
And there's a few comments on this thread that mirror this sentiment.

Folks would be willing to kill a 17 year old ( or 20 year old or 22 year old or 40 year old or whatever ) to send a message to the neighborhood youth/young men/whatever you want to call them not to take your crap out of your open garage ? ( If it was legal. )

Personally, I'm not getting it.

The one kid doesn't know any better because he's dead.  Dead.

You play stupid games you get stupid prizes. I get that.
But there's a responsibility that comes with owning a firearm. ( Like not firing 4 shotgun rounds blindly into your garage. )
We have the ability to deal in Death. That's a huge responsibility which, I'm sure, most of us take seriously.

They come in my house where I'm with my wife and kids. Different story. No problem with it.
They do something life threatening outside my house to someone else and I have access to my firearm, no problem with it. ( wish we could conceal carry and our laws condoned it. Would probably (hopefully) take action regardless. )

Newb

Re: Montana shooting, possibly within rights but brutal
« Reply #29 on: May 01, 2014, 07:07:15 PM »
I have watched this forum for quite some time as I am military and hope to eventually attain a concealed carry permit to protect myself and family. I do not post as I prefer to quietly observe and not get drawn into the internet arguments that almost always ensue.

With that being said, I honestly feel that many of the comments I read in this forum and especially in these types of threads are just giving the PD and lawmakers ammo against the cause we all stand for. Take a moment and read through some of the comments posted here. Do any of you honestly believe that based on the info presented, a person of any age should be dead? For the contents of a garage that the owner left open after being robbed twice already, he has killed another human being.

Do you really thing lawmakers and PD are in a hurry to allow that type of street justice to occur in their state? They watch these type forums and get the opinion that we are all waiting for a CCW so we can kill everyone who wrongs us in any way. And some of the comments here say just that.

I am not trying to point fingers. I am merely saying let's think about the impact of the statements we make. 

bubba808

Re: Montana shooting, possibly within rights but brutal
« Reply #30 on: May 01, 2014, 07:55:29 PM »
No offense to anyone, but this a little bit nuts.
And there's a few comments on this thread that mirror this sentiment.

Folks would be willing to kill a 17 year old ( or 20 year old or 22 year old or 40 year old or whatever ) to send a message to the neighborhood youth/young men/whatever you want to call them not to take your crap out of your open garage ? ( If it was legal. )

Personally, I'm not getting it.

The one kid doesn't know any better because he's dead.  Dead.

You play stupid games you get stupid prizes. I get that.
But there's a responsibility that comes with owning a firearm. ( Like not firing 4 shotgun rounds blindly into your garage. )
We have the ability to deal in Death. That's a huge responsibility which, I'm sure, most of us take seriously.

They come in my house where I'm with my wife and kids. Different story. No problem with it.
They do something life threatening outside my house to someone else and I have access to my firearm, no problem with it. ( wish we could conceal carry and our laws condoned it. Would probably (hopefully) take action regardless. )
:thumbsup:
I have watched this forum for quite some time as I am military and hope to eventually attain a concealed carry permit to protect myself and family. I do not post as I prefer to quietly observe and not get drawn into the internet arguments that almost always ensue.

With that being said, I honestly feel that many of the comments I read in this forum and especially in these types of threads are just giving the PD and lawmakers ammo against the cause we all stand for. Take a moment and read through some of the comments posted here. Do any of you honestly believe that based on the info presented, a person of any age should be dead? For the contents of a garage that the owner left open after being robbed twice already, he has killed another human being.

Do you really thing lawmakers and PD are in a hurry to allow that type of street justice to occur in their state? They watch these type forums and get the opinion that we are all waiting for a CCW so we can kill everyone who wrongs us in any way. And some of the comments here say just that.

I am not trying to point fingers. I am merely saying let's think about the impact of the statements we make. 
:thumbsup:

Jl808

Montana shooting, possibly within rights but brutal
« Reply #31 on: May 02, 2014, 06:18:40 AM »
Here is another one in Minnesota.

The homeowner was convicted in court of premeditated murder.

The two teens had broken into another person's home just a day prior. They have also broken into the homeowner's house before. But the judge excluded the evidence as irrelevant.

The homeowner house's had been broken into before where weapons were stolen.  A neighbor testified that the homeowner appeared frightened after the first incident.

The homeowner is a retired US State Department employee that worked on "technical security issues" for US embassies.

http://www.foxnews.com/us/2014/04/29/minn-homeowner-convicted-premeditated-murder/?intcmp=latestnews
« Last Edit: May 02, 2014, 06:36:18 AM by Jl808 »
I think, therefore I am armed.
NRA Life Patron member, HRA Life member, HiFiCo Life Member, HDF member

The United States Constitution © 1791. All Rights Reserved.

Jl808

Montana shooting, possibly within rights but brutal
« Reply #32 on: May 02, 2014, 08:17:15 AM »
For the record, I do not condone vigilante justice.  But I also do not condone burglars and thieves no matter what their age.

Everyone has a right to be secure in their own person / property and protected from illegal seizure. An open garage door is not an invitation to take someone's stuff.  Back then, folks don't need to lock the front doors of their homes.  When did people forget this???

But capital punishment for theft is kinda extreme. Unless they were threatening the lives of the occupants, the burglars should have been apprehended, and tried for their actions by a just jury and the law. The same goes for the 2 homeowners involved in the shooting.

I realize that hindsight and armchair quarterbacking is 20-20, what should these homeowners have done?
« Last Edit: May 02, 2014, 08:26:13 AM by Jl808 »
I think, therefore I am armed.
NRA Life Patron member, HRA Life member, HiFiCo Life Member, HDF member

The United States Constitution © 1791. All Rights Reserved.

kia_killer

  • Trade Count: (+16)
  • Full Member
  • ***
  • Posts: 225
  • Total likes: 8
  • Now you can have it.
  • Referrals: 0
    • View Profile
Re: Montana shooting, possibly within rights but brutal
« Reply #33 on: May 02, 2014, 08:48:46 AM »
I have watched this forum for quite some time as I am military and hope to eventually attain a concealed carry permit to protect myself and family. I do not post as I prefer to quietly observe and not get drawn into the internet arguments that almost always ensue.

With that being said, I honestly feel that many of the comments I read in this forum and especially in these types of threads are just giving the PD and lawmakers ammo against the cause we all stand for. Take a moment and read through some of the comments posted here. Do any of you honestly believe that based on the info presented, a person of any age should be dead? For the contents of a garage that the owner left open after being robbed twice already, he has killed another human being.

Do you really thing lawmakers and PD are in a hurry to allow that type of street justice to occur in their state? They watch these type forums and get the opinion that we are all waiting for a CCW so we can kill everyone who wrongs us in any way. And some of the comments here say just that.

I am not trying to point fingers. I am merely saying let's think about the impact of the statements we make.

I don't see any posts validating killing the guy. I may have missed it. Given the limited and probably exaggerated details from the article, I wouldn't call this justified. My stance may or may not change when more accurate and comprehensive info is available. Without identifying the intruder, he couldn't of known for sure whether it was a threat or not. IF the article turns out to be accurate, then IMO Kaarma isn't a person I would want in my neighborhood. That being said, I like many members here, have little sympathy for criminals. The fact is, had he not committed the crime this would be a non issue. I don't think anyone here would say he needed to die though.

macsak

Re: Montana shooting, possibly within rights but brutal
« Reply #34 on: May 02, 2014, 08:52:38 AM »
For the record, I do not condone vigilante justice.  But I also do not condone burglars and thieves no matter what their age.

Everyone has a right to be secure in their own person / property and protected from illegal seizure. An open garage door is not an invitation to take someone's stuff.  Back then, folks don't need to lock the front doors of their homes.  When did people forget this???

But capital punishment for theft is kinda extreme. Unless they were threatening the lives of the occupants, the burglars should have been apprehended, and tried for their actions by a just jury and the law. The same goes for the 2 homeowners involved in the shooting.

I realize that hindsight and armchair quarterbacking is 20-20, what should these homeowners have done?

the one point that people are missing so far is that if he did indeed circle around from the outside and fire into the garage, he was firing towards the house where his partner and child were
so not only did he not identify the threat, he also ignored what was beyond his target
 :grrr:

one2boost

Re: Montana shooting, possibly within rights but brutal
« Reply #35 on: May 02, 2014, 09:26:34 AM »
All I have to say is, bummers someone had to die, life is not like GTA or whatever video game one could respawn and start that level over when one makes a wrong choice.

Another thing, the only positive lining I see, is I bet no one will ever break into this family's home ever again.

punaperson

Re: Montana shooting, possibly within rights but brutal
« Reply #36 on: May 02, 2014, 09:37:14 AM »
the one point that people are missing so far is that if he did indeed circle around from the outside and fire into the garage, he was firing towards the house where his partner and child were
so not only did he not identify the threat, he also ignored what was beyond his target
 :grrr:
Do you have some information that lead you to believe that that was actually the direction of fire? I didn't see anything at all about that. But if he really hadn't identified his target it could have been his neighbor trying to get back his chainsaw the guy never returned after borrowing, or something. I'm pretty sure we could speculate approximately forever until all the facts come out in court after the prosecution and defense present all their evidence.

On the other hand:

http://www.foxcarolina.com/story/25373283/spartanburg-waffle-house-shooting-video-released-sparks-new-debate

CCW holder kills gun-toting masked robber in Waffle House. Dante (now deceased) and Jawan (now convicted of armed robbery and sentenced to 30 years) are defended by Tamika (Dante's cousin) who, of course, says he was a good kid, never did anything wrong, never got in any trouble, liked to dance, etc. etc. etc., and that people should have to have more training before getting a CCW and that he didn't have to shoot. The trainer (former county deputy) who trained the shooter for his CCW says it was all legal and clearly self-defense. It's all on surveillance video. No charges filed against shooter.

punaperson

Re: Montana shooting, possibly within rights but brutal
« Reply #37 on: May 02, 2014, 09:39:40 AM »
All I have to say is, bummers someone had to die, life is not like GTA or whatever video game one could respawn and start that level over when one makes a wrong choice.

Another thing, the only positive lining I see, is I bet no one will ever break into this family's home ever again.
I wouldn't be surprised if Mr. Kaarma is not in jail, and/or at the very least all firearms have likely been removed from the home. Criminals aren't as afraid of baseball bats... especially if the only person in the home is female with a child.

aieahound

Re: Montana shooting, possibly within rights but brutal
« Reply #38 on: May 02, 2014, 09:47:58 AM »
All I have to say is, bummers someone had to die, life is not like GTA or whatever video game one could respawn and start that level over when one makes a wrong choice.

Another thing, the only positive lining I see, is I bet no one will ever break into this family's home ever again.
Actually they might if the husband/partner is locked up for 20 years. ( What Puna said, he beat me to the reply )

Do you have some information that lead you to believe that that was actually the direction of fire? I didn't see anything at all about that. But if he really hadn't identified his target it could have been his neighbor trying to get back his chainsaw the guy never returned after borrowing, or something. I'm pretty sure we could speculate approximately forever until all the facts come out in court after the prosecution and defense present all their evidence.

From article ( and I'm not saying the article is accurate but it's the info we have )

"Kaarma allegedly grabbed a shotgun and exited the front door to confront the intruder. He then entered the garage through the open door and fired his shotgun four times into the darkness."

"Pflager ( Kaarma's common law wife) allegedly told police that Kaarma said “hey, hey” before he loaded a shell into the gun’s chamber. She said Dede yelled “hey” or “wait” before the shotgun fired. The boy was dead on arrival at St. Patrick Hospital.

Kaarma told police after the incident he was afraid the intruder had a knife or a tool from the garage, but couldn’t be certain because it was pitch-black inside.

“He stated he thought he was going to die and that the guy would try to get out of the garage and described thinking he could act like a caged animal,” the affidavit stated."

Footnote: http://missoulian.com/news/local/suspect-in-big-sky-student-s-shooting-gets-death-threats/article_fdaccb9c-d005-11e3-a429-0019bb2963f4.html

On the other hand:

http://www.foxcarolina.com/story/25373283/spartanburg-waffle-house-shooting-video-released-sparks-new-debate

CCW holder kills gun-toting masked robber in Waffle House. Dante (now deceased) and Jawan (now convicted of armed robbery and sentenced to 30 years) are defended by Tamika (Dante's cousin) who, of course, says he was a good kid, never did anything wrong, never got in any trouble, liked to dance, etc. etc. etc., and that people should have to have more training before getting a CCW and that he didn't have to shoot. The trainer (former county deputy) who trained the shooter for his CCW says it was all legal and clearly self-defense. It's all on surveillance video. No charges filed against shooter.

No one here ( well maybe couple guys, or one guy ) is against CCW and the good it can do. It's this particular incident we're talking about.

punaperson

Re: Montana shooting, possibly within rights but brutal
« Reply #39 on: May 02, 2014, 10:28:50 AM »
No one here ( well maybe couple guys, or one guy ) is against CCW and the good it can do. It's this particular incident we're talking about.
I was just pointing out that even if law enforcement, the prosecutor's office, the certified CCW trainer, etc. all agree that it was justifiable homicide, SOMEONE (in this case cousin Tamika) is going to say it was wrong and no matter what a masked gun-wielding criminal was doing that the requirements for CCW ought to be raised to a higher threshold, or a de facto impossible threshold, such as we have here in Hawaii.