Montana shooting, possibly within rights but brutal (Read 49444 times)

mauidog

Re: Montana shooting, possibly within rights but brutal
« Reply #60 on: May 08, 2014, 10:00:38 PM »
Just curious,
did the kid steal something?  How did you establish that he was a burglar?  What law are you referring to?

I guess you need some help, huh?

Let me Google that for you ...

http://lmgtfy.com/?q=burglary
An unarmed man can only flee from evil, and evil is not overcome by fleeing from it.   -- Jeff Cooper

Q

.
« Reply #61 on: May 08, 2014, 10:41:57 PM »
.
« Last Edit: December 14, 2016, 03:35:07 PM by Q »

bubba808

Re: Montana shooting, possibly within rights but brutal
« Reply #62 on: May 08, 2014, 10:55:49 PM »
I guess you need some help, huh?

Let me Google that for you ...

http://lmgtfy.com/?q=burglary

Burglary is a crime, the essence of which is illegal entry into a building for the purposes of committing an offence. Usually that offence will be theft
exactly.. now read.... he entered, but what offence did he commit? Is there any proof that he stole or entered to steal?

Kingkeoni

Re: Montana shooting, possibly within rights but brutal
« Reply #63 on: May 08, 2014, 11:02:50 PM »
Burglary is a crime, the essence of which is illegal entry into a building for the purposes of committing an offence. Usually that offence will be theft
exactly.. now read.... he entered, but what offence did he commit? Is there any proof that he stole or entered to steal?

Simply entering illegally is an offense in and of itself.
Your number one Option for Personal Security is a lifelong commitment to avoidance, deterrence, and de-escalation.

Someday someone may kill you with your own gun, but they should have to beat you to death with it because it is empty.

mauidog

Re: Montana shooting, possibly within rights but brutal
« Reply #64 on: May 08, 2014, 11:10:18 PM »
Burglary is a crime, the essence of which is illegal entry into a building for the purposes of committing an offence. Usually that offence will be theft
exactly.. now read.... he entered, but what offence did he commit? Is there any proof that he stole or entered to steal?

I'm positive he wasn't there to witness for his Lord and Savior.  At least those people have the decency to knock on the front door before walking around the house looking for you!
An unarmed man can only flee from evil, and evil is not overcome by fleeing from it.   -- Jeff Cooper

bubba808

Re: Montana shooting, possibly within rights but brutal
« Reply #65 on: May 08, 2014, 11:31:30 PM »
Simply entering illegally is an offense in and of itself.
I agree, but simply entering does NOT constitute burglary like mauidog stated.

Q

.
« Reply #66 on: May 08, 2014, 11:37:11 PM »
.
« Last Edit: December 14, 2016, 03:35:13 PM by Q »

bubba808

Re: Montana shooting, possibly within rights but brutal
« Reply #67 on: May 08, 2014, 11:39:31 PM »
I'm positive he wasn't there to witness for his Lord and Savior.  At least those people have the decency to knock on the front door before walking around the house looking for you!

Oh Wat, now you know the layout of the house and assume the kid walked around the house to the garage in the back?

Just relax and let the truth come out before you call da shooter a victim and start claiming the kid was burglarizing the home.  Trespassing may have been a better term.

Jl808

Montana shooting, possibly within rights but brutal
« Reply #68 on: May 08, 2014, 11:42:26 PM »
:rofl:  You guys all crack me up.   :shaka:  Good night!  :sleeping:
I think, therefore I am armed.
NRA Life Patron member, HRA Life member, HiFiCo Life Member, HDF member

The United States Constitution © 1791. All Rights Reserved.

mauidog

Re: Montana shooting, possibly within rights but brutal
« Reply #69 on: May 08, 2014, 11:49:48 PM »
Oh Wat, now you know the layout of the house and assume the kid walked around the house to the garage in the back?

Just relax and let the truth come out before you call da shooter a victim and start claiming the kid was burglarizing the home.  Trespassing may have been a better term.

Who said he went around to the back?  You really need to practice reading comprehension.  Just because you THINK you know what I was thinking doesn't mean you're right!

You really have a tough time taking in new information, don't you? 

Or is it more like you refuse to be proven wrong?
An unarmed man can only flee from evil, and evil is not overcome by fleeing from it.   -- Jeff Cooper

bubba808

Re: Montana shooting, possibly within rights but brutal
« Reply #70 on: May 08, 2014, 11:58:28 PM »
Who said he went around to the back?  You really need to practice reading comprehension.  Just because you THINK you know what I was thinking doesn't mean you're right!

You really have a tough time taking in new information, don't you? 

Or is it more like you refuse to be proven wrong?

U said it.  We are talkin about this kid in the garage that got shot.  Then u said, at least religious people knock at the front before walking around the house looking for you". 
I'm positive he wasn't there to witness for his Lord and Savior.  At least those people have the decency to knock on the front doorbefore walking around the house looking for you!
I tired talk to you, LoL SMH.

mauidog

Re: Montana shooting, possibly within rights but brutal
« Reply #71 on: May 09, 2014, 12:00:49 AM »
U said it.  We are talkin about this kid in the garage that got shot.  Then u said, at least religious people knock at the front before walking around the house looking for you".  I tired talk to you, LoL SMH.

You like to argue.  Just admit you have no point.  You're a troll, and this is what you do!   :crazy:
An unarmed man can only flee from evil, and evil is not overcome by fleeing from it.   -- Jeff Cooper

HiCarry

Re: Montana shooting, possibly within rights but brutal
« Reply #72 on: May 09, 2014, 01:22:44 AM »
Burglary is a crime, the essence of which is illegal entry into a building for the purposes of committing an offence. Usually that offence will be theft
exactly.. now read.... he entered, but what offence did he commit? Is there any proof that he stole or entered to steal?

Montana's "Castle Doctrine" appears to have a "presumption" element that allows the use of force, up to deadly force, to prevent someone from illegally entering your home. I suspect that will come into play during any proceedings.

Here's the relevant Montana statue:

45-3-103. Use of force in defense of occupied structure. (1) A person is justified in the use of force or threat to use force against another when and to the extent that the person reasonably believes that the use of force is necessary to prevent or terminate the other person's unlawful entry into or attack upon an occupied structure.

     (2) A person justified in the use of force pursuant to subsection (1) is justified in the use of force likely to cause death or serious bodily harm only if:

     (a) the entry is made or attempted and the person reasonably believes that the force is necessary to prevent an assault upon the person or another then in the occupied structure; or

     (b) the person reasonably believes that the force is necessary to prevent the commission of a forcible felony in the occupied structure.

punaperson

Re: Montana shooting, possibly within rights but brutal
« Reply #73 on: May 09, 2014, 06:04:28 AM »
Montana's "Castle Doctrine" appears to have a "presumption" element that allows the use of force, up to deadly force, to prevent someone from illegally entering your home. I suspect that will come into play during any proceedings.

Here's the relevant Montana statue:

45-3-103. Use of force in defense of occupied structure. (1) A person is justified in the use of force or threat to use force against another when and to the extent that the person reasonably believes that the use of force is necessary to prevent or terminate the other person's unlawful entry into or attack upon an occupied structure.

     (2) A person justified in the use of force pursuant to subsection (1) is justified in the use of force likely to cause death or serious bodily harm only if:

     (a) the entry is made or attempted and the person reasonably believes that the force is necessary to prevent an assault upon the person or another then in the occupied structure; or

     (b) the person reasonably believes that the force is necessary to prevent the commission of a forcible felony in the occupied structure.
Damn, HiCarry, what is it with you and quoting facts? You are operating under the mistaken assumption that the person you are addressing 1. is capable of understanding facts, and/or 2. is not a troll. I operate under the same delusion, because i don't want to believe that anyone is really that REMAINDER OF COMMENT DELETED.

As for the law and this case, I'm guessing the lawyers will be discussing 1. whether or not the garage (attached or not attached to house?) constituted an "occupied structure" if the owners were in the house proper, and 2. what constitutes a "reasonable belief". Do I have a "reasonable belief" that the person you are addressing is not amenable to reason?

HiCarry

Re: Montana shooting, possibly within rights but brutal
« Reply #74 on: May 09, 2014, 02:10:13 PM »
Damn, HiCarry, what is it with you and quoting facts? You are operating under the mistaken assumption that the person you are addressing 1. is capable of understanding facts, and/or 2. is not a troll. I operate under the same delusion, because i don't want to believe that anyone is really that REMAINDER OF COMMENT DELETED.

As for the law and this case, I'm guessing the lawyers will be discussing 1. whether or not the garage (attached or not attached to house?) constituted an "occupied structure" if the owners were in the house proper, and 2. what constitutes a "reasonable belief". Do I have a "reasonable belief" that the person you are addressing is not amenable to reason?
Dude, I can't help myself...it's like a disease or something....

PeaShooter

Re: Montana shooting, possibly within rights but brutal
« Reply #75 on: May 09, 2014, 05:20:04 PM »
http://www.nytimes.com/2014/05/08/us/missoula-montana-homeowner-shoots-teenager-in-garage.html?_r=0

I learned of this case through that article; it paints the teenager in a slightly less favorable light than some of the other articles, saying that he was indeed there to steal and cause trouble. Anyway, here are some other ideas I had on the matter.

Suppose that the evidence eventually bears out that this teenager was the person who had been repeatedly robbing this home over the previous two weeks, would that change the minds of any of the people here advocating for the teenager?

What if we were talking about a different case in which the homeowner's garage has no door? I know plenty of people without doors on their garages. I also know the frustration of law enforcement not doing anything when your yard is repeatedly trespassed onto and robbed weekly.

Isn't it reasonable to assume malice if a forced entry occurs at night? The surveillance camera video image of the teenager looks threatening enough to me. On the other hand, if the homeowner was able to see the intruder on surveillance, it may have been wiser to call the police instead of going out to confront him. That would be a good argument for the prosecution against the homeowner.

xer 21

Re: Montana shooting, possibly within rights but brutal
« Reply #76 on: May 10, 2014, 02:24:33 PM »
http://www.nytimes.com/2014/05/08/us/missoula-montana-homeowner-shoots-teenager-in-garage.html?_r=0

I learned of this case through that article; it paints the teenager in a slightly less favorable light than some of the other articles, saying that he was indeed there to steal and cause trouble. Anyway, here are some other ideas I had on the matter.

Suppose that the evidence eventually bears out that this teenager was the person who had been repeatedly robbing this home over the previous two weeks, would that change the minds of any of the people here advocating for the teenager?

What if we were talking about a different case in which the homeowner's garage has no door? I know plenty of people without doors on their garages. I also know the frustration of law enforcement not doing anything when your yard is repeatedly trespassed onto and robbed weekly.

Isn't it reasonable to assume malice if a forced entry occurs at night? The surveillance camera video image of the teenager looks threatening enough to me. On the other hand, if the homeowner was able to see the intruder on surveillance, it may have been wiser to call the police instead of going out to confront him. That would be a good argument for the prosecution against the homeowner.
the only thing that really matters here in my mind is he did indeed plan this out as a trap.  at that point, he's already decided he's going to shoot. and that might override castle doctrine, especially since that would clearly be premeditated, and (although this probably doesnt hold in court this way), actually WANTED someone to enter his property.  especially since the better solution would have been to just prevent your shit from getting stolen by simply keeping your damn garage door closed instead of attemtping to escalate it.

if anything paints this guy in a poor light, its his hair dresser or whatever saying the guy was waiting up all night to shoot someone, if that is true information.

and i really dont care what anyone else says.  after the first couple thefts, the clear next step is to start closing your damn garage door, not wait up all night to see if someone goes into your garage again waiting to shoot him.  lethal violence is the last step, not the first.  then, this guy probably wouldnt have had any more trouble with thefts, and the kid wouldnt be dead, and he wouldnt be in court.

mauidog

Re: Montana shooting, possibly within rights but brutal
« Reply #77 on: May 10, 2014, 08:16:49 PM »
the only thing that really matters here in my mind is he did indeed plan this out as a trap.  at that point, he's already decided he's going to shoot. and that might override castle doctrine, especially since that would clearly be premeditated, and (although this probably doesnt hold in court this way), actually WANTED someone to enter his property.  especially since the better solution would have been to just prevent your shit from getting stolen by simply keeping your damn garage door closed instead of attemtping to escalate it.

if anything paints this guy in a poor light, its his hair dresser or whatever saying the guy was waiting up all night to shoot someone, if that is true information.

and i really dont care what anyone else says.  after the first couple thefts, the clear next step is to start closing your damn garage door, not wait up all night to see if someone goes into your garage again waiting to shoot him.  lethal violence is the last step, not the first.  then, this guy probably wouldnt have had any more trouble with thefts, and the kid wouldnt be dead, and he wouldnt be in court.

Speaking for my own personal frame of mind, there is a fine line between deciding in advance you are going to shoot some unknown trespasser if you get the chance, and preparing yourself mentally to pull the trigger should you ever be in a situation that might require it.  What I've learned over time is, when facing a difficult challenge, you need to imagine yourself actually doing it.  The more you train, practice, and prepare yourself mentally, the less chance there is you'll hesitate.  It would be very easy for a prosecutor to twist preparation into premeditation. 

When it comes to reasonable doubt, however, I think it'll be difficult for the jury to split that hair without some concrete and damning evidence proving he intended to "shoot first and ask questions later."
An unarmed man can only flee from evil, and evil is not overcome by fleeing from it.   -- Jeff Cooper

aieahound

Re: Montana shooting, possibly within rights but brutal
« Reply #78 on: May 11, 2014, 11:15:57 AM »

The concept of "don't shoot to wound" is not the same as "shoot to kill 'em." And one should be careful as to what one posts in regards to shooting someone to kill them. God forbid that you ever are forced into using your gun to defend yourself and do end up killing someone, your self defense claim could be in real jeopardy. Some over zealous prosecutor will comb these, and other boards, looking for just these types of statements to substantiate that you didn't really shoot to "stop the threat" but rather that you carried out your previously stated plan to kill the guy because that's what you said on some internet forum.

I value your opinions and advice HiCarry.

However, in my opinion on this one, if you're not justified in using deadly force, you better not pull out a gun.
Stop the threat. Of course we all hope the perp lives, it's a horrible thing to live with killing a person. But you're using deadly force to stop him.
And it better be justifiably deadly. Whether he dies or not.
Upon further questioning, hard to explain how you shot him center mass without acknowledging the chance of death was likely.
It's not shoot to kill, it's knowing the chance of death is likely when you fire that gun.

There's no premeditated plan in lawful self-defense shootings as far as I know. Only preparation.

 :stopjack:

I was only putting it in that context in my prior post because the young man was killed, not just shot.

mauidog

Re: Montana shooting, possibly within rights but brutal
« Reply #79 on: May 11, 2014, 12:27:13 PM »
I value your opinions and advice HiCarry.

However, in my opinion on this one, if you're not justified in using deadly force, you better not pull out a gun.
Stop the threat. Of course we all hope the perp lives, it's a horrible thing to live with killing a person. But you're using deadly force to stop him.
And it better be justifiably deadly. Whether he dies or not.
Upon further questioning, hard to explain how you shot him center mass without acknowledging the chance of death was likely.
It's not shoot to kill, it's knowing the chance of death is likely when you fire that gun.

There's no premeditated plan in lawful self-defense shootings as far as I know. Only preparation.

 :stopjack:

I was only putting it in that context in my prior post because the young man was killed, not just shot.

It's up to everyone to know the laws and act in a way they understand is justified legally.  They must also reconcile with their own moral beliefs, which has been beaten to death on this forum a few times.

However, the law allows for the shooter the justification based on what they believed, not based on the stated or demonstrated intentions of the threat.

If a COP sees someone with a replica gun, his belief that the replica is a real gun justifies discharging his weapon. 

Reality being what it is, people like to second guess anyone's thought process when they kill another person.  The laws, however, give the benefit of the doubt to the shooter, what he believed at the time, and how high he deemed the threat being presented.

Debating whether shooting to kill is different than shooting to wound is irrelevant to what most people experience.  If you are in a situation that involves violence, and you are afraid you'll be severely injured or killed, you won't be Googling the HRS or calling an attorney to find out if pulling the trigger is justified. 

You'll do WHATEVER YOU HAVE TO DO to survive.  Either that, or you'll be unable to kill someone who intends to kill you, but at least it will be YOUR decision to make.  The gun control/anti-gun politicians and followers would rather make that decision for you in favor of the criminals.
An unarmed man can only flee from evil, and evil is not overcome by fleeing from it.   -- Jeff Cooper