Montana shooting, possibly within rights but brutal (Read 49439 times)

PeaShooter

Re: Montana shooting, possibly within rights but brutal
« Reply #80 on: May 11, 2014, 02:38:32 PM »
after the first couple thefts, the clear next step is to start closing your damn garage door, not wait up all night to see if someone goes into your garage again waiting to shoot him.

then, this guy probably wouldnt have had any more trouble with thefts, and the kid wouldnt be dead
After re-reading your posts in this thread, I think you have the facts of this case mixed up. All the linked articles say that the homeowner's home, not garage, had been broken into repeatedly in the preceding weeks. So even had the garage door been closed, this kid would probably have broken into the house next. For all we know, it's likely he was the thief who had been intruding into the house in the preceding weeks.

I also posed a common scenario in which the homeowner does not have a door on his garage, what then?
« Last Edit: May 11, 2014, 02:55:33 PM by PeaShooter »

Q

.
« Reply #81 on: May 12, 2014, 03:04:52 AM »
.
« Last Edit: December 14, 2016, 03:45:28 PM by Q »

Jl808

Re: Montana shooting, possibly within rights but brutal
« Reply #82 on: May 12, 2014, 04:23:20 AM »
Agreed!

When I visit anyone's home, I always make it a point to stay outside the first barrier (gate, front door, fence, etc) I come across. 

Even if the first barrier only has a latch that I can open for myself, I would always wait for the person I'm visiting to acknowledge me and (1) either come out and meet me or (2) respond and ask me to come in.
I think, therefore I am armed.
NRA Life Patron member, HRA Life member, HiFiCo Life Member, HDF member

The United States Constitution © 1791. All Rights Reserved.

xer 21

Re: Montana shooting, possibly within rights but brutal
« Reply #83 on: May 12, 2014, 10:40:09 PM »
After re-reading your posts in this thread, I think you have the facts of this case mixed up. All the linked articles say that the homeowner's home, not garage, had been broken into repeatedly in the preceding weeks. So even had the garage door been closed, this kid would probably have broken into the house next. For all we know, it's likely he was the thief who had been intruding into the house in the preceding weeks.

I also posed a common scenario in which the homeowner does not have a door on his garage, what then?

 the earlier articles mentioned that all previous thefts had occurred when they left their garage door open, and that he may have had pot stolen "from his garage".  i didnt get anything wrong.  if they changed their stements in more recent articles, fine.  but the articles from last week mentioned the garage, not the home.

but there's also this.  the guys who stole from him saying they stole the stuff from his garage or car.

 http://gazette.com/authorities-told-slain-student-looking-for-alcohol/article/feed/117786

and the scenario without a garage door is valid.  sure.  but that isnt this scenario.  if you have a door, you can close it.  if you don't you can't, and its a different story.  but when you have it, and don't, that's just flat out irresponsible. 

sure, it would be nice if you could trust people with an open garage, but you cant.  so you close the door.  either he set them up, or he was being totally irresponsible.  again, this isnt about whether i think he was within his rights.  im just saying, he could have done a hell of a lot more to both protect his property AND his family without jumping straight to the conclusion that he needs to go confront someone with lethal force.  that middle missing step of just closing the door probably would have stopped him from getting robbed in the first place, since he has the luxury of a garage door, and probably would have stopped someone from getting killed.

and whether or not he really did fear for his life (which im not buying yet, but if he did, its within his rights to shoot), you have to admit its not exactly fair for the kid to get shot and killed because some dude had his weed stolen.  yes, he made a really dumb choice and paid for it, but you cannot tell me he deserved to die over this. 

i've said it before and i'll say it again.  self defense with lethal force is supposed to be the last option.  you're not supposed to be actively looking to kill someone.  this guy clearly skipped over a totally valid option and went straight to lethal force, and could very well have been looking forward to it too.  im not saying this applies to anyone here, or to any more than a very few people out there, but just as there's idiots everywhere who make large groups look bad, there are gun owners who tarnish OUR reputation and fantasize about vigilante justice or who hope that they'll one day get to defend themselves (which in itself isnt really true, because they're not really looking to defend themselves, but to kill).  all im saying is that this reminds me a bit of that Minnesota case where they guy was waiting for someone to break in.    and that this guy just might be one of those guys.

and if you want to hate on me cause "i'm siding with anti gun people" (which is the vibe im already getting here), well, no.  cmon guys, this isnt even a large national story.  there's barely a side worth picking if that debate were in play because the only stories that matter in that debate are the ones large enough to make a national impact.  you only found it because you care about gun owners and the legal issues surrounding them as it pertains to us.  i get it.  its cases like these which can make or break gun rights for us sometimes.  if this guy got convicted, it would be a small (very small, considering where he lives, but still) black eye on those who wish to defend themselves, and those things still count.  but i just think some people are a little too quick to side with the shooter.  the shooter isnt always right.  i mean, cmon guys, we had people here supporting the minnesota shooting. 

xer 21

Re: Montana shooting, possibly within rights but brutal
« Reply #84 on: May 12, 2014, 10:43:23 PM »
Speaking for my own personal frame of mind, there is a fine line between deciding in advance you are going to shoot some unknown trespasser if you get the chance, and preparing yourself mentally to pull the trigger should you ever be in a situation that might require it.  What I've learned over time is, when facing a difficult challenge, you need to imagine yourself actually doing it.  The more you train, practice, and prepare yourself mentally, the less chance there is you'll hesitate.  It would be very easy for a prosecutor to twist preparation into premeditation. 

When it comes to reasonable doubt, however, I think it'll be difficult for the jury to split that hair without some concrete and damning evidence proving he intended to "shoot first and ask questions later."
of course it's a fine line, and that's the issue here.

but if he really told his hairdresser he was going to shoot some kids, i have a feeling that that's going to come back to haunt him.

just remember folks, the charges didnt come out of nowhere.  they are pretty unique charges; the cops already have SOME suspicion.  im not saying they can prove anything, but they probably feel like they have SOMETHING.

PeaShooter

Re: Montana shooting, possibly within rights but brutal
« Reply #85 on: May 13, 2014, 01:29:33 PM »
That new article has a lot of newer information than the old ones. Not surprisingly, both sides of the case are saying things that they think will help them in court. So as always it will be up to a jury in the end to decide whom to believe and what they think the facts are.

I don't really think it matters whether or not I think the teenager "deserved" to die, but for what it's worth, I do not think he deserved to die. Unless this teenager or his friends had also broken into this individual's house in the preceding weeks, in which case maybe he did deserve what he got.

We can also read between the lines of the latest article somewhat. How the heck did police suddenly find these two additional teens who claim to have burglarized the open garage and car in the preceding weeks? I'm just speculating, but probably they are the friends of the teenager who was shot. If so, that makes the claims of all the teenagers less credible in my eyes. As much as we find the behavior and claims of the homeowner to be odd in this case, the behavior and claims of the 4+ teenagers now involved in this case are odd as well.

Even if this guy did bait the teenagers in a minor sense, I can't say that I am completely against what he did. If I were robbed repeatedly and the police did not do anything about it, I might want to do the same. In an extreme case of baiting I would be worried, though. Like what if some maniac decided he wanted to kill people for fun in a legal manner by tricking innocent people onto his property, that would be scary.

Newb

Montana shooting, possibly within rights but brutal
« Reply #86 on: May 14, 2014, 05:01:18 AM »
Sorry but if I am so worried about people stealing from my garage, I would start by closing the door. Then security systems, cameras or whatever else he had. And then, maybe, deadly force. And that's a big maybe.

And if I'm not mistaken, since the door was open, and he technically hasn't stolen anything yet as he is still on the property, isn't he only trespassing at that point?

mauidog

Re: Montana shooting, possibly within rights but brutal
« Reply #87 on: May 14, 2014, 07:34:24 AM »
Sorry but if I am so worried about people stealing from my garage, I would start by closing the door. Then security systems, cameras or whatever else he had. And then, maybe, deadly force. And that's a big maybe.

And if I'm not mistaken, since the door was open, and he technically hasn't stolen anything yet as he is still on the property, isn't he only trespassing at that point?

See previous posts on definition of Burglary:

Burglary is a crime, the essence of which is illegal entry into a building for the purposes of committing an offense.

The burglar doesn't have to run outside holding a pillowcase with stolen property to prove intent.  The teen had no legitimate reason to be on that property, in that garage   He probably didn't even know the residents.

Based on that, his intent can be inferred to have been theft or some other crime.

Simply entering illegally is a burglary offense in and of itself.
An unarmed man can only flee from evil, and evil is not overcome by fleeing from it.   -- Jeff Cooper

HiCarry

Re: Montana shooting, possibly within rights but brutal
« Reply #88 on: May 14, 2014, 02:15:58 PM »
Mens rea - As an element of criminal responsibility, a guilty mind; a guilty or wrongful purpose; a criminal intent. Guilty knowledge and wilfulness.

http://legal-dictionary.thefreedictionary.com/mens+rea

xer 21

Re: Montana shooting, possibly within rights but brutal
« Reply #89 on: May 14, 2014, 02:53:37 PM »


Even if this guy did bait the teenagers in a minor sense, I can't say that I am completely against what he did. If I were robbed repeatedly and the police did not do anything about it, I might want to do the same. In an extreme case of baiting I would be worried, though. Like what if some maniac decided he wanted to kill people for fun in a legal manner by tricking innocent people onto his property, that would be scary.
im pretty sure most people, including you, would just not leave their doors open.

mauidog

Re: Montana shooting, possibly within rights but brutal
« Reply #90 on: May 14, 2014, 03:16:41 PM »
im pretty sure most people, including you, would just not leave their doors open.

You really need to find another point to discuss.

Not everyone REMEMBERS to close and lock all the doors.  I know I've left my garage door open more than once after working outside, only to discover it open just before bedtime.  Also, my daughter has left the house on at least two occasions thinking I was home and left the front door wide open.  That in no way invites anyone to come in for any reason.

People make mistakes and leave keys in door knobs, keys in ignitions, car doors unlocked, back doors open, windows open ... none of this is relevant.

 :wacko:
An unarmed man can only flee from evil, and evil is not overcome by fleeing from it.   -- Jeff Cooper

xer 21

Re: Montana shooting, possibly within rights but brutal
« Reply #91 on: May 14, 2014, 04:38:06 PM »
You really need to find another point to discuss.

Not everyone REMEMBERS to close and lock all the doors.  I know I've left my garage door open more than once after working outside, only to discover it open just before bedtime.  Also, my daughter has left the house on at least two occasions thinking I was home and left the front door wide open.  That in no way invites anyone to come in for any reason.

People make mistakes and leave keys in door knobs, keys in ignitions, car doors unlocked, back doors open, windows open ... none of this is relevant.

 :wacko:
its absolutely relevant.

mauidog

Re: Montana shooting, possibly within rights but brutal
« Reply #92 on: May 14, 2014, 05:04:12 PM »
An unarmed man can only flee from evil, and evil is not overcome by fleeing from it.   -- Jeff Cooper

macsak

mauidog

An unarmed man can only flee from evil, and evil is not overcome by fleeing from it.   -- Jeff Cooper

PeaShooter

Re: Montana shooting, possibly within rights but brutal
« Reply #95 on: December 18, 2014, 02:32:34 PM »
http://news.yahoo.com/deliberations-resume-exchange-student-killing-062400337.html

So it appears the guy has been convicted. I don't really like the decision but oh well. I don't know all the facts, but as I said earlier I would personally be fine with someone who had baited the kid in, as long as it was not an extreme case (the killing of an innocent). If the kid had been repeatedly burglarizing properties prior to his death, then that would justify the end result in my mind, but other people probably don't see it that way.

eyeeatingfish

Re: Montana shooting, possibly within rights but brutal
« Reply #96 on: December 21, 2014, 09:13:38 AM »
Crooks should realize that playing stupid games = winning stupid prizes.

I nominate this for comment of the year!

eyeeatingfish

Re: Montana shooting, possibly within rights but brutal
« Reply #97 on: December 21, 2014, 09:29:51 AM »
My assessment:
-The garage door being open is a non issue. Sure he could have closed it but he still has an expectation that no one would come inside. What if the man only had a carport and not a garage door, would this man be not allowed to defend his property? Or what if he left the door open so the thief would return and then he tackled the thief and detained him till police arrived? That would be a legal action as well.
-The comments he allegedly made about waiting to shoot someone doesn't prove ill intent but certainly doesn't help. Obviously he had reason to be concerned for the safety of his property but his comments could be used to suggest that he didn't give the intruder a chance to surrender.

-The thing that I think hurts him the most is that he testified that he couldn't see because it was pitch black.  This man has to be able to justify why he pulled the trigger with only the information available to him up until that point. From what I can gather from this article alone he knew someone (or something) was in the garage but he couldn't see who and he couldn't tell if the person had a weapon. That alone does not justify lethal force.

What if the individual was a police officer checking for a suspect? '
What if the individual was a neighbor looking for a dog?
What if the individual was an elderly person with dimentia?
What if the individual was a 6 year old kid who ran away from home?
This man had good reason to be concerned but I do not think he had good reason to shoot. It does not appear that he can articulate a real threat by the person, he can only articulate that he knew a person was there. Based on just this article I think a manslaughter cahrge would be most appropriate.

After further reading it appears he was convicted and I would have to say from what I do know this appears appropriate.
« Last Edit: December 21, 2014, 08:20:57 PM by eyeeatingfish »