Educate me about the 38 sp wadcutter. (Read 13460 times)

dogman

Educate me about the 38 sp wadcutter.
« on: December 09, 2014, 07:15:35 PM »
I've heard the term and seen videos of how they leave a clean hole on a paper target. I have never handled any. What's good and what's not so good about them?

Rocky

Re: Educate me about the 38 sp wadcutter.
« Reply #1 on: December 09, 2014, 08:03:57 PM »
 m   Bullets, just like  pellets projectiles, are specifically designed for a purpose.  :geekdanc:
Some are for hunting (magnum with heavier weight or pointed for penetration, hollow point for expansion).

     The Wad cutter is the same as the "basic" pellet with it's flat head designed to do exactly as you said, leave a clean hole on a paper target

Good = makes nice clean hole in paper (HP and RN tend to leave a ragged hole in paper)
Bad = not the best for other than what it was designed for. ( With it's lack of penetration or expansion, why use a paper cutter for SD ?)

 Let the argument's begin !
           
                                          :popcorn:
“I ask you to judge me by the enemies I have made.”
                                                           Franklin D. Roosevelt

Heavies

Re: Educate me about the 38 sp wadcutter.
« Reply #2 on: December 09, 2014, 08:11:13 PM »
I've heard the term and seen videos of how they leave a clean hole on a paper target. I have never handled any. What's good and what's not so good about them?

I use them (158grn LSWC) in my .357/.38 reloads with bullseye and trailboss. Never had any problems and pretty accurate, as far as I can shoot 'em.... (not a great pistol shot)  I don't load them hot, just target loads.  Tested out those new coated bullets and they seem to be just as good, if not better, because I got ZERO leading.  Nice clean round holes, easy to spot, even with my crappy binoculars.

Tom_G

Re: Educate me about the 38 sp wadcutter.
« Reply #3 on: December 09, 2014, 08:22:03 PM »
Wadcutters, when tested on living targets, are really rather nasty.  Rather than deviating around bones, like a round nose, or fragmenting, like expanding/frangible ammo, whey literally poke round holes through everything in a straight line.  Not "let it squeeze closed after I pass like a fmj pointy bullet" holes but clean, neat, 0.357" holes.  Through flesh, muscle, organs, and bone.  Since you specified .38 special, velocities are in the 900f/s range, so they're not as powerful a punch as most defensive loads, but with bullet weights ranging between 110gr and 200gr, and 158gr being the standard, they're nothing to sneeze at.  A standard load delivers about 310 ft/lbs at the muzzle, compared to .45 acp at 352 ft/lbs for ball ammo. 

For punching paper, there's nothing better.  They leave clean, well-defined holes, no tattered edges, no guessing.  See the attached scan.

I've always liked the idea of wadcutters or semi-wadcutters as defensive rounds.  There's no way I'll ever find myself in a courtroom with the prosecution arguing about my choice of ammo demonstrating some insatiable bloodlust if I'm using what are clearly marketed as target rounds.  And, as I mentioned before, they are more efective than pointy bullets, such as the round nosed ones police used for decades.
The difference between theory and reality is that, in theory, there is no difference between theory and reality.

dogman

Re: Educate me about the 38 sp wadcutter.
« Reply #4 on: December 09, 2014, 09:20:35 PM »
Hey guys, thanks for the informative replies (as always).  :shaka: The reason I specified 38 special was I saw some advertised on a LGS website. Until then, the thought of trying them never crossed my mind. I didn't know if it was going to be a waste of time and money. I will probably be picking up a box this week. Thanks again. :thumbsup: 

oldfart

Re: Educate me about the 38 sp wadcutter.
« Reply #5 on: December 09, 2014, 10:06:08 PM »
The cartridge on the left is a 38 wadcutter.
On the right is a 38 semiwadcutter.
A wadcutter is shaped like a 55 gallon drum. It is purported to be the most accurate bullet design.
But don't ask me why. My friend just won a fun match a couple months ago using 38 wadcutters from a custom 1911.
So I guess there is some truth to that.

A semiwadcutter aka swc, is more commonly encountered. Properly loaded, swc bullets will feed more reliably in in auto pistols and is usually an inexpensive alternative for general target practice.

Expanding on tom.g's post, the fbi used to issue agents 38 spec. Lead swc hollow points.
Apparently they worked pretty good. I think hpd used to issue federal nyclad swc hp's too.
So if you want to keep a revolver as an sd pistol, seek out some factory made lead swchp's.
It's legally defensible.

Back when revolvers were more fashionable, my friends and I played with hollow base wadcutters which is designed to be a strictly target bullet.
But boys will be boys and we loaded them backwards to expose an obscenely large hollow cavity.
We never did get around to doing any ballistic tests tho......
What, Me Worry?

Tom_G

Re: Educate me about the 38 sp wadcutter.
« Reply #6 on: December 09, 2014, 10:21:15 PM »
Back when revolvers were more fashionable, my friends and I played with hollow base wadcutters which is designed to be a strictly target bullet.
But boys will be boys and we loaded them backwards to expose an obscenely large hollow cavity.
We never did get around to doing any ballistic tests tho......

I've read about that practice.  Supposed to be NAST-EEE on soft targets!
The difference between theory and reality is that, in theory, there is no difference between theory and reality.

dogman

Re: Educate me about the 38 sp wadcutter.
« Reply #7 on: December 10, 2014, 05:17:46 AM »
Thanks O F  :shaka: and good points from you and Tom about being a legally defensible round, but what about over penetration? Would it be the same or less than FMJ?

oldfart

Re: Educate me about the 38 sp wadcutter.
« Reply #8 on: December 10, 2014, 07:47:00 AM »
Thanks O F  :shaka: and good points from you and Tom about being a legally defensible round, but what about over penetration?
Would it be the same or less than FMJ?
...
Over penetration was not a big problem in 38 spec with swchp ammo, which is usually 158 gr.
All things being equal, fmj would penetrate more with no expansion.
A 38 spec fmj load is not a great sd idea.
38 fmj is usually 130 gr. military ball ammo. Not much different from common 9mm ball practice ammo.
I don't think you want ball ammo in your sd pistol.

So...what are you trying to accomplish here?
What, Me Worry?

Heavies

Re: Educate me about the 38 sp wadcutter.
« Reply #9 on: December 10, 2014, 08:29:59 AM »
I agree with oldfart.
If you were going to use .38spl for SD/HD, I would use a modern HP in at least a +P Cartridge for a quality manufacturer (if you gun is rated). Leave wadcutters, SWC, and target loads for target practice.

Doing tons of research I was not impressed with the reported performance of .38spl, especially in a short barreled gun.  Notably, the round that I had chosen, standard Hornady Critical Defense, performed very very poorly in the shorter barrel pistols.   I sure DID NOT want to use .357 magnum in the confines of my house, if needed, and I was put off by the .38 spl performance,  so much so, I decided to go with 9mm for my SD round now (124 Gold Dot).

oldfart

Re: Educate me about the 38 sp wadcutter.
« Reply #10 on: December 10, 2014, 09:33:51 AM »
I've read about that practice.  Supposed to be NAST-EEE on soft targets!
....
I got some ballistic pumpkins. Need to find a venue.
What, Me Worry?

Tom_G

Re: Educate me about the 38 sp wadcutter.
« Reply #11 on: December 10, 2014, 10:49:17 AM »
what about over penetration? Would it be the same or less than FMJ?

I'd expect it to be seriously less.  WC/SWC are lead, unjacketed, so they will deform more than a FMJ round.  Plus, with the blunt leading edge, they transfer energy to the target more quickly than a round or pointy nosed bullet.  I'd be really surprised if you could get a standard load .38 special WC or SWC all the way through a person, even in a soft spot.

Now, I'm going to disagree with Heavies at this point.  Sure, there are more effective cartridges out there, but I really think most people underestimate the effectiveness of simply BEING SHOT.  Police used .38 special with round-nosed bullets for decades.  DECADES!  Why did they keep using such an "unimpressive" for decades?  I assure you, not because it didn't work!  And whatever it may lack in pure stopping power, it makes up for in ease of handling and quickness of follow-up shots.  I'm 100% sure that you could get 5 shots from a .38 snubbie on target with target loads in 70% the time you could do the same thing with +P SD loads. 

But I fear we are drifting off your question and into the everlasting debate about SD ammo selection.  Back to your original question:

What's good about them?
-cheap, both commercially and as reloads
-accurate
-Generally associated with moderate recoil loads

What's lacking about them?
-barrel scrubbing (WC/SWC tend to be unjacketed lead)
-hard to find in LGS (gun stores like stocking fancy SD loads)
-lots of exposed lead means extra care must be taken when eating musubi at the range.
The difference between theory and reality is that, in theory, there is no difference between theory and reality.

oldfart

Re: Educate me about the 38 sp wadcutter.
« Reply #12 on: December 10, 2014, 12:39:01 PM »
Just out of curiosity, I looked around to see if anybody had lead 38 wc or swchp bullets that could be loaded just for fun.
Both Hornady and Speer are still making the bullets and they are available online from midway.
According to the website, Speer changed to a modern lube coating. Back in the day they used some horrible waxy stuff that was unpleasant to load.
These could simulate the 158 swchp fbi ammo, which is not stylish any more and probably hard to find.

Babbling on===>
Here is something cool that I would not mind trying just for fun...see the pic
Berry's makes a soft-lead-swaged-plated 148 gr hollow base wadcutter that could be loaded backwards to expose that huge cavity.
I would not consider it for serious carry ammo. but it would be interesting to try on a ballistic pumpkin.
The copper plating eliminates bbl leading while offering no serious resistance to bullet deformation, aka expansion and fragmentation.
Nothing like this was made when I started loading back in the day.
What, Me Worry?

Heavies

Re: Educate me about the 38 sp wadcutter.
« Reply #13 on: December 10, 2014, 02:56:54 PM »
I'd expect it to be seriously less.  WC/SWC are lead, unjacketed, so they will deform more than a FMJ round.  Plus, with the blunt leading edge, they transfer energy to the target more quickly than a round or pointy nosed bullet.  I'd be really surprised if you could get a standard load .38 special WC or SWC all the way through a person, even in a soft spot.

Now, I'm going to disagree with Heavies at this point.  Sure, there are more effective cartridges out there, but I really think most people underestimate the effectiveness of simply BEING SHOT.  Police used .38 special with round-nosed bullets for decades.  DECADES!  Why did they keep using such an "unimpressive" for decades?  I assure you, not because it didn't work!  And whatever it may lack in pure stopping power, it makes up for in ease of handling and quickness of follow-up shots.  I'm 100% sure that you could get 5 shots from a .38 snubbie on target with target loads in 70% the time you could do the same thing with +P SD loads. 

But I fear we are drifting off your question and into the everlasting debate about SD ammo selection.  Back to your original question:

What's good about them?
-cheap, both commercially and as reloads
-accurate
-Generally associated with moderate recoil loads

What's lacking about them?
-barrel scrubbing (WC/SWC tend to be unjacketed lead)
-hard to find in LGS (gun stores like stocking fancy SD loads)
-lots of exposed lead means extra care must be taken when eating musubi at the range.


Ohoh.... Started the debate, Lol.   

Back in the day, when the "FBI load" was used, many bad guys where simarly armed with these .38 revolvers... even most autos where low capacity and hollow point expanding rounds where exotic.  It was a fesible and logical choice to use that round.

Nah, it is not that I thought the round to be uneffective, just that if you look at realities of the world we live in nowdays, you are more likely to encounter a bad guy weilding a stolen semi automatic pistol.  Now your .38 5 or 6 shot will put some hurt on the guy, but the guy would have double what you have....(assumiing the dude is following our asine mag limit laws)   I was in your camp Tom, I had a .357 4" under the bed, ready to go.  I thought about getting a 9mm for a "fun" gun so I didn't have to do so much reloading to go shoot.  Then I started researching the modern self defence rounds out there, and I came to the conclusion that in this day and age why put yourself at a disadvantage.   

Heavies

Re: Educate me about the 38 sp wadcutter.
« Reply #14 on: December 10, 2014, 02:58:00 PM »
Just out of curiosity, I looked around to see if anybody had lead 38 wc or swchp bullets that could be loaded just for fun.
Both Hornady and Speer are still making the bullets and they are available online from midway.
According to the website, Speer changed to a modern lube coating. Back in the day they used some horrible waxy stuff that was unpleasant to load.
These could simulate the 158 swchp fbi ammo, which is not stylish any more and probably hard to find.

Babbling on===>
Here is something cool that I would not mind trying just for fun...see the pic
Berry's makes a soft-lead-swaged-plated 148 gr hollow base wadcutter that could be loaded backwards to expose that huge cavity.
I would not consider it for serious carry ammo. but it would be interesting to try on a ballistic pumpkin.
The copper plating eliminates bbl leading while offering no serious resistance to bullet deformation, aka expansion and fragmentation.
Nothing like this was made when I started loading back in the day.

Those look interesting!  If you try those give us a review!   ;D

Tom_G

Re: Educate me about the 38 sp wadcutter.
« Reply #15 on: December 10, 2014, 03:10:05 PM »

Berry's makes a soft-lead-swaged-plated 148 gr hollow base wadcutter that could be loaded backwards to expose that huge cavity.
I would not consider it for serious carry ammo. but it would be interesting to try on a ballistic pumpkin.
The copper plating eliminates bbl leading while offering no serious resistance to bullet deformation, aka expansion and fragmentation.
Nothing like this was made when I started loading back in the day.


Call me when it's ballistic pumpkin day!
The difference between theory and reality is that, in theory, there is no difference between theory and reality.

Inspector

Re: Educate me about the 38 sp wadcutter.
« Reply #16 on: December 10, 2014, 06:41:30 PM »
I use LSWC for target shooting. But the best target load I have uses a Montana Gold JHP. The MG JHP's are not for SD due to the fact they are not designed to expand. They are designed strictly for target shooting and plinking. Being a hollow point they cut a much better hole than a FMJ. I am sure the X-Treme Bullets are the same.
SCIENCE THAT CAN’T BE QUESTIONED IS PROPAGANDA!!!

dogman

Re: Educate me about the 38 sp wadcutter.
« Reply #17 on: December 10, 2014, 09:47:33 PM »

So...what are you trying to accomplish here?

I was just wondering if these are something I should try. "Wadcutter" isn't a term you hear much, so when I saw some for sale it got my interest. I think I last heard the term on Adam 12 or Dragnet (current reruns}.

s197

Re: Educate me about the 38 sp wadcutter.
« Reply #18 on: December 11, 2014, 09:07:02 AM »
What's a ballistic pumpkin? Is it just a regular pumpkin or do you fill the cavity with ballistic gel?

aieahound

Re: Educate me about the 38 sp wadcutter.
« Reply #19 on: December 11, 2014, 10:38:04 AM »
Call me when it's ballistic pumpkin day!

+1

Can we do that at HDF range days ?

I'll bring the pumpkins, watermelons, gourds, squashes, apples...whatever you need. ( FYI potatoes suck because they don't explode )

We do that at a private north shore range and it's awesome.  ( no ballistic gel )