Wadcutters, when tested on living targets, are really rather nasty. Rather than deviating around bones, like a round nose, or fragmenting, like expanding/frangible ammo, whey literally poke round holes through everything in a straight line. Not "let it squeeze closed after I pass like a fmj pointy bullet" holes but clean, neat, 0.357" holes. Through flesh, muscle, organs, and bone. Since you specified .38 special, velocities are in the 900f/s range, so they're not as powerful a punch as most defensive loads, but with bullet weights ranging between 110gr and 200gr, and 158gr being the standard, they're nothing to sneeze at. A standard load delivers about 310 ft/lbs at the muzzle, compared to .45 acp at 352 ft/lbs for ball ammo.
For punching paper, there's nothing better. They leave clean, well-defined holes, no tattered edges, no guessing. See the attached scan.
I've always liked the idea of wadcutters or semi-wadcutters as defensive rounds. There's no way I'll ever find myself in a courtroom with the prosecution arguing about my choice of ammo demonstrating some insatiable bloodlust if I'm using what are clearly marketed as target rounds. And, as I mentioned before, they are more efective than pointy bullets, such as the round nosed ones police used for decades.