When it comes to conviction yes, a crime is a crime, but when it comes to a punishment the details matter.
Would you say that all people convicted of murder should get the death penalty or would you want to know the details of the murder to make your decision? A premeditated violent murder might warrant a different punishment than say a father who murdered a man who just raped his daughter. Would you execute both because murder is murder?
The details of his leaving his post are a little unclear, at least from what I have found in media reports, and those details matter.
Unless the homicide was justified (self defense, defense of another innocent, etc.), then the reason for the murder is not relevant. The victim is dead. The victims's family, friends and coworkers are without the victim.
The taking of a life illegally is never justified. Robbery? Spousal abuse? Sexual assault? Jealousy? Fear of prosecution for another crime? In no situation can you say it's forgivable for murdering another person.
So, yes, I think all murderers should be sentenced to death. Warehousing them for the remainder of their lives is fruitless. What purpose can their lives serve behind bars until they die? People serving life can be the most dangerous to corrections officers, infirmary workers, and inmates because they have nothing to lose.
Details might help some try to understand why someone killed another, but that information should not be used to lessen the severity of the punishment.
Now, all of this is using another assumption --- that the prisoner is 100% guilty and there is no reasonable doubt as to that guilt. A confession, video evidence, multiple eye witnesses, and unmistakeable forensics would be enough for me to convict.
Eye for an eye. If you kill another, your life is forfeit. As for premeditated vs. homicides of passion -- where is justice when you are excused for murder and the next guy who kills is not? Is there not a dead victim in both cases? Should a lenient judge in one state hand out 25 to life sentences with possibility of parole, while one state over they get multiple life sentences or the death penalty for the same crime? Justice requires we be consistent in punishing the guilty. If you can't convict the prisoner of murder, then don't charge murder. Obviously, there is doubt. Like the Deedy case. Was there intent to kill, or was it self defense? If he gets convicted, which item on the menu should he receive? I say, if he committed murder, he is a murderer and deserves a murderer's punishment. If he did not commit murder, but defended himself, then he should never be charged with any degree of murder.
Everyone has empathy for the criminals. What if that was me in the cell? What would I want done? That's not a good way to look at justice. You should empathize with the victim and the family of the victim. How would I be feeling after the prisoner killed my wife/son/daughter/husband/mother/father/...? Would I want the killer to be given the mercy he didn't show the victim?
Taking a life is the ultimate act anyone can ever do. It's one of the few things there can be no restitution for. You can't give the person back their life, nor offer a substitute life in its place. Perhaps in this declining morality we see in the US, we have to split hairs when it comes to murder. A hate crime is worse than a premeditated murder, and a premeditated killing is worse than a spontaneous fit of road rage. When the value of life is so cheap nowadays, it's easy to get drawn into trying to decide just how much a killer should pay for their crime. Kill a gang member or hooker versus a soccer mom or doctor? Kill a gay neighbor or Muslim coworker -- it's "hate". Killing a spouse is love? How about killing 20 kids in an elementary school versus chopping off a coworker's head? Death is final. Death has no measure of "how dead" you are. Dead is dead. If the death isn't justified, it's a crime, and the crime should exact an equal measure of punishment.