What about Bergdahl ? (Read 23266 times)

mauidog

Re: What about Bergdahl ?
« Reply #20 on: September 20, 2015, 09:41:51 AM »
Just because the death penaty can be a punishment does not mean it has to be the imposed punishment.

So why do you think the death penalty should be imposed?

He's a Muslim sympathizer (Did you not see the video of Obama and the traitor's parents in the Rose Garden?)

His father was posting pro-Muslim, anti-US tweets before and during his son's desertion.

He abandoned his post, leaving his other team members vulnerable to attack without warning.

He probably gave his captors as much information as he knew about operations, troop strengths, and plans.

He was used in trade for 5 top Taliban leaders.   :wtf:   We have yet to trade ANYONE for the captives in Iran, but this guy is worth 5 top generals of the enemy??

Obama bypassed Congress to make the trade.  He knew they would not approve, so he did this ILLEGALLY.

More military died looking for him. 

There has been no accounting for why or how he was taken prisoner.  Had he remained at his post, he'd have never been captured.

The Army has investigated for a long time now, and they see cause for charging him with these offenses,  They don't do that with only circumstantial evidence.

Roll all of that up into a total package, and what we have is a deserter who not only put our military and their objectives at risk, but was REWARDED for  it.  The punishment must be harsh enough to let the next enemy sympathizer think 3 times before deciding desertion is worth it.

Is that making an example of him?  YOU BET!!  It's one of the best things about punishment.  It hopefully deters others from making the same choices. 

In the military, unlike the civilian world, the seriousness of one's actions in a war zone can have dire consequences.  That's the reason for the Code of Conduct.  He swore an oath to give his life if necessary.  Instead, he switched sides and was used to cause even more damage to our security.
An unarmed man can only flee from evil, and evil is not overcome by fleeing from it.   -- Jeff Cooper

eyeeatingfish

Re: What about Bergdahl ?
« Reply #21 on: September 20, 2015, 03:04:40 PM »
Because he's a fucking traitor to his brothers in arms and to the United States of America.

 I see no reason to pay to keep this walking pile of shit alive. We waste enough tax dollars as it is.

Fuck him.

Ironically it would cost more to have him executed than to keep him alive in jails.

mauidog

Re: What about Bergdahl ?
« Reply #22 on: September 20, 2015, 03:18:27 PM »
Ironically it would cost more to have him executed than to keep him alive in jails.

Why do you keep bringing up cost?  That's irrelevant. 

We don't care what it costs for a rail project that won't fix the traffic problems. 

We don't care what it costs for Obama  and his wife to take separate jets to the same destination in California a couple of hours apart. 

We don't care how much we are sending to Middle Eastern countries (including Iran now) to buy their cooperation.

We don't care how much it costs to maintain the roads, bridges, sewer and water lines until we find out the money wasn't used for that.

So, tell me.  If the punishment is what the people want, then why do you believe it should instead be decided based on cost?
An unarmed man can only flee from evil, and evil is not overcome by fleeing from it.   -- Jeff Cooper

kekoa

Re: What about Bergdahl ?
« Reply #23 on: September 20, 2015, 05:01:45 PM »
Ironically it would cost more to have him executed than to keep him alive in jails.


Really???? Break down that math formula for please.

dustoff003

What about Bergdahl ?
« Reply #24 on: September 20, 2015, 08:14:41 PM »
Just because the death penaty can be a punishment does not mean it has to be the imposed punishment.

So why do you think the death penalty should be imposed?

I don't think that is necessary.

i had a reply but accidentally closed the window and it was lost, if I am up to it later I will attempt to recreate it.

okay here we go let me try this again.

eef have you served? If yes to prior were you deployed? If yes to previous combat or non combat? If you answered no to the previous three ?'s I don't care what you think about the death penalty being necessary or think you can be able to fully understand the severity of what Bergdahl did. In my mind desertion is equal to treason.

Bergdahl needs to be shot or hung from the neck until dead :thumbsup: I hope that the Taliban ass raped him frequently. It's surprising they didn't kill him he probably claimed Pashtunwali.

As Q stated this guy (Bergdahl) should have handled his business like a man or just offed himself. When you Enlist or are Commissioned you swear and oath, there is currently no draft he volunteered to serve no one forced him. When you are deployed all you have are the Soldiers to your left and right and they likewise. You trust that they will be there for you and they trust you will be there for them, if neither party or one side doesn't hold up their end bad things happen and people die. The POS left in the night how cowardly he was lucky that whomever was on the perimeter didn't shoot him. If he did that shit and left while being outside the wire his peers very well could/should have unloaded on him.

If he was responsible for other deaths of service members because of his desertion he should die. If I was responsible for the death of one of my Soldiers or one of my aircrews I would find that hard to reckon with and it would be hard to live with myself. I would accept whatever punishment administered to me if I were negligent in my duties.

The last time a person was executed for desertion was WW II,  https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Eddie_Slovik prior to that was the Civil War I think were due for another. My grandfather served in the same regiment as Slovik and the story of his desertion and execution were two of the few he shared with me about his European combat experience. I think the moral of him telling me the story is that I know the severity of desertion and so I knew not to be a fuck stick.

I had some more written this morning and then I may have written it differently now but I thing my intent was the same.

I am surprised that no one has mentioned about his father going full Taliban?
« Last Edit: September 20, 2015, 08:44:56 PM by dustoff003 »

robtmc

Re: What about Bergdahl ?
« Reply #25 on: September 20, 2015, 08:21:06 PM »
If he was responsible for other deaths of service members because of his desertion he should die.
+1

That the one you reply to has such a mushy take on it says it all, 

eyeeatingfish

Re: What about Bergdahl ?
« Reply #26 on: September 21, 2015, 12:19:10 AM »

Really???? Break down that math formula for please.

I don't know the math breakdown involved but it actually cost taxpayers more money to execute someone than to put them in prison for life. I know some of the costs include the lengthy court hearings involved as well as an increased cost associated with keeping a prisoner on death row since they are housed differently.

eyeeatingfish

Re: What about Bergdahl ?
« Reply #27 on: September 21, 2015, 12:42:18 AM »
okay here we go let me try this again.

eef have you served? If yes to prior were you deployed? If yes to previous combat or non combat? If you answered no to the previous three ?'s I don't care what you think about the death penalty being necessary or think you can be able to fully understand the severity of what Bergdahl did. In my mind desertion is equal to treason.

Bergdahl needs to be shot or hung from the neck until dead :thumbsup: I hope that the Taliban ass raped him frequently. It's surprising they didn't kill him he probably claimed Pashtunwali.

As Q stated this guy (Bergdahl) should have handled his business like a man or just offed himself. When you Enlist or are Commissioned you swear and oath, there is currently no draft he volunteered to serve no one forced him. When you are deployed all you have are the Soldiers to your left and right and they likewise. You trust that they will be there for you and they trust you will be there for them, if neither party or one side doesn't hold up their end bad things happen and people die. The POS left in the night how cowardly he was lucky that whomever was on the perimeter didn't shoot him. If he did that shit and left while being outside the wire his peers very well could/should have unloaded on him.

If he was responsible for other deaths of service members because of his desertion he should die. If I was responsible for the death of one of my Soldiers or one of my aircrews I would find that hard to reckon with and it would be hard to live with myself. I would accept whatever punishment administered to me if I were negligent in my duties.

The last time a person was executed for desertion was WW II,  https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Eddie_Slovik prior to that was the Civil War I think were due for another. My grandfather served in the same regiment as Slovik and the story of his desertion and execution were two of the few he shared with me about his European combat experience. I think the moral of him telling me the story is that I know the severity of desertion and so I knew not to be a fuck stick.

I had some more written this morning and then I may have written it differently now but I thing my intent was the same.

I am surprised that no one has mentioned about his father going full Taliban?

I did not serve, I was in line to (2 years college ROTC) but things didn't work out. To be clear I am not saying that your opinion is wrong, I just gave my opinion on the question of whether he should be executed based on what I know now which is not that in depth. I know the synopses but I don't know the details or circumstances of why he left. I am not going to condemn someone to die without more information. I think this whole discussion is a little premature since we don't know the results of the military's full investigation. (Unless that has been released and I wasn't aware)

I agree desertion in combat is a very serious charge and should be punished seriously. Treason is also very serious however it is a different crime and would need to have certain evidence to support that charge. I don't believe that deserting your post meets the criteria for treason. Has it been shown the Bergdahl aided the enemy? I am not saying he hasn't but I just haven't seen that proven yet.

I think the only real strong argument for his execution would be that other service members died in the search for him. Whether his father is pro muslim/anti American and the fact Obama traded 5 terrorists for him doesn't matter. He absolutely needs to be held responsible for the lives that were lost as the result of his actions, I just wouldn't say it needs to be the death penalty at this point. When more information comes out I might change my mind. I think my two biggest questions about this case is why Bergdahl left his post and what was his mental state of mind when he did so?

On a side note, Obama should be held responsible for making such a stupid trade and for not doing it properly as well.

aieahound

Re: What about Bergdahl ?
« Reply #28 on: September 21, 2015, 08:16:47 AM »
EEF,

I think you're approaching this like it's a civilian trial and matter.

I never served but I can only imagine the feelings of the men on the field of battle if someone in your unit walks off their post (pre-meditated as he sent all his stuff home prior) in the middle of the night.

Then gets his dumb ass captured, men possibly die searching for him, then 5 enemy generals get released in trade (although that is an Obama issue.

As Edster so eloquently put it : Fuck Him

We never shoulda went looking for him the first place. Then we shoulda told the Taliban what they could do with him.
But that's just my civilian opinion.

I was very curious to hear from our service members and veterans.

mauidog

Re: What about Bergdahl ?
« Reply #29 on: September 21, 2015, 09:06:37 AM »
In the past (but not now, I'm sure), commanding officers and NCOs would shoot soldiers who tried to run away in the face of enemy fire.  That's how serious it is.

No trial, no "does it rise to this level of a capital offense?", and no "what was his state of mind?"  We should all be judged based on our actions.  Our state of mind is not going to excuse leaving the others to fight without you.

Logically, if the soldier is fleeing, leaving the troops one man short, making an example of him won't worsen the situation and will probably keep more from fleeing.
An unarmed man can only flee from evil, and evil is not overcome by fleeing from it.   -- Jeff Cooper

Q

.
« Reply #30 on: September 21, 2015, 09:30:45 AM »
.
« Last Edit: May 19, 2025, 05:43:51 AM by Q »

robtmc

Re: What about Bergdahl ?
« Reply #31 on: September 21, 2015, 09:32:00 AM »
I did not serve
Now, there is a shocker!  I would never have guessed.
 /S

mauidog

Re: What about Bergdahl ?
« Reply #32 on: September 21, 2015, 09:46:13 AM »
There's a valid reason why the military has a civilian supervisory chain of command.  From the Secretaries of the services to the Commander in Chief, including other civilian members of the National Command Authority (NCA), we rest the power to deploy national forces with civilians to further political objectives.

There is also a valid reason why these civilians need to trust their military commanders to execute those orders.  There are realities on the front lines with which the civilians have no direct experience unless they also served.

The invention of TV and the placement of TV reporters with front line troops changed forever the dynamics of the NCA.  Now, families sitting in their living rooms can see images and hear reports directly from the war zones.  If a report implies anything at all the public disagrees with, it upsets the political apple cart, causing our representatives to call on the NCA to make changes.

Transparency is one thing.  Micromanagement is something else entirely.  Ever since Korea, we've had civilians in war rooms with satellite images and direct video feeds micromanaging the war fighters without the benefit of understanding the challenges they face.

And those are the civilians actually involved in the planning and execution of the operations.  Civilians going to  work everyday in Hawaii with no ties to the military have only the news to base their opinions on. 

And we all know how "pro military" the Liberal mainstream media is.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/National_Command_Authority

Opinions based on the Liberal Mainstream Media is suspect at best.  Better to rethink your beliefs and opinions with the firsthand inputs you receive elsewhere.

Quote
It's easier to fool someone than convince them they've been fooled.

It ain't what you don't know that gets you into trouble. It's what you know for sure that just ain't so.
-- Mark Twain
« Last Edit: September 21, 2015, 09:57:43 AM by mauidog »
An unarmed man can only flee from evil, and evil is not overcome by fleeing from it.   -- Jeff Cooper

eyeeatingfish

Re: What about Bergdahl ?
« Reply #33 on: September 21, 2015, 05:16:18 PM »
Now, there is a shocker!  I would never have guessed.
 /S

You know nothing of my past experiences so your personal attack is uncalled for.

eyeeatingfish

Re: What about Bergdahl ?
« Reply #34 on: September 21, 2015, 05:34:33 PM »
If this had happened on the battlefield and his CO shot him for deserting then so be it, the CO would explain his actions and it would be done with. But that isn't the case. Now he is back in America and he can go through a proper military court. Why would you not want to go through the military court trial? I trust the military court system to hear the case and administer appropriate punishment.

Q,
I have seen some of the video interviews and I understand their anger, but that is only part of the picture. There are other parts of the picture that are not yet being made public and I reserve my use of the death penalty until I know more. Like I said, things that come out in the trial might change my mind to where I would support the death penalty. But the last thing I want to do is a knee jerk reaction and condemnation without knowing enough information. Just like when an officer or armed civilian is accused of shooting and killing a suspect I am not going to rush to condemn them without a better picture of what happened. I try to base my opinions in such matters on the objective hearings of a court proceedings over the fickle nature of social media.

And please don't imply I am a terrorist sympathizer because I point out that treason and desertion are not the same thing. If we are going to discuss the matter then we should do it accurately. I never suggested Bergdahl should get a slap on the wrist and I never implied there was anything ok about what he did.
« Last Edit: September 21, 2015, 05:51:13 PM by eyeeatingfish »

mauidog

Re: What about Bergdahl ?
« Reply #35 on: September 21, 2015, 06:46:27 PM »
 :popcorn: :popcorn: :popcorn: :popcorn:

You know nothing of my past experiences so your personal attack is uncalled for.
An unarmed man can only flee from evil, and evil is not overcome by fleeing from it.   -- Jeff Cooper

mauidog

Re: What about Bergdahl ?
« Reply #36 on: September 21, 2015, 06:53:51 PM »
If this had happened on the battlefield and his CO shot him for deserting then so be it, the CO would explain his actions and it would be done with. But that isn't the case. Now he is back in America and he can go through a proper military court. Why would you not want to go through the military court trial? I trust the military court system to hear the case and administer appropriate punishment.

Q,
I have seen some of the video interviews and I understand their anger, but that is only part of the picture. There are other parts of the picture that are not yet being made public and I reserve my use of the death penalty until I know more. Like I said, things that come out in the trial might change my mind to where I would support the death penalty. But the last thing I want to do is a knee jerk reaction and condemnation without knowing enough information. Just like when an officer or armed civilian is accused of shooting and killing a suspect I am not going to rush to condemn them without a better picture of what happened. I try to base my opinions in such matters on the objective hearings of a court proceedings over the fickle nature of social media.

And please don't imply I am a terrorist sympathizer because I point out that treason and desertion are not the same thing. If we are going to discuss the matter then we should do it accurately. I never suggested Bergdahl should get a slap on the wrist and I never implied there was anything ok about what he did.

YOUR use of the death penalty?  So tell us what it would take for you to summarily and without delay impose the death penalty on someone?  Rape?  Homicide?  Bullying on the Internet?
An unarmed man can only flee from evil, and evil is not overcome by fleeing from it.   -- Jeff Cooper

eyeeatingfish

Re: What about Bergdahl ?
« Reply #37 on: September 21, 2015, 07:56:59 PM »
YOUR use of the death penalty?  So tell us what it would take for you to summarily and without delay impose the death penalty on someone?  Rape?  Homicide?  Bullying on the Internet?

Meaning that I would not call for the death penalty in this case without further information. You on the other hand would call for the use of the death penalty. You gave your answer on what should be done, I gave mine, why is that such a big deal? I in no way defended Bergdahl, i just called for a punishment that wasn't as severe as the punishment you would like to see.

As for the second half of your comment I support the use of the death penalty for cases of murder under certain circumstances. I don't know what you mean by "summarily and without delay impose the death penalty on someone." Upon seeing such a crime, upon someone claiming such crime, or upon conviction of such a crime?  I am trying to understand what sort of scenario you are getting at with that question. If I were a CO in a combat situation and one of my soldiers told me that he was leaving to go join the enemy and I was unable to restrain him from doing so then yes I would use lethal force to stop him. I wouldn't find it an easy thing to do, but necessary if for no other reason than the fact he posses knowledge which could put the safety of other troops in jeopardy.

The supreme court has ruled that the death penalty cannot be an automatic sentence upon conviction though I don't know how that applies to military court, how much constitutional law applies to military law seems a little bit hazy, but that is another subject.

mauidog

Re: What about Bergdahl ?
« Reply #38 on: September 21, 2015, 10:11:52 PM »
Meaning that I would not call for the death penalty in this case without further information. You on the other hand would call for the use of the death penalty. You gave your answer on what should be done, I gave mine, why is that such a big deal? I in no way defended Bergdahl, i just called for a punishment that wasn't as severe as the punishment you would like to see.

As for the second half of your comment I support the use of the death penalty for cases of murder under certain circumstances. I don't know what you mean by "summarily and without delay impose the death penalty on someone." Upon seeing such a crime, upon someone claiming such crime, or upon conviction of such a crime?  I am trying to understand what sort of scenario you are getting at with that question. If I were a CO in a combat situation and one of my soldiers told me that he was leaving to go join the enemy and I was unable to restrain him from doing so then yes I would use lethal force to stop him. I wouldn't find it an easy thing to do, but necessary if for no other reason than the fact he posses knowledge which could put the safety of other troops in jeopardy.

The supreme court has ruled that the death penalty cannot be an automatic sentence upon conviction though I don't know how that applies to military court, how much constitutional law applies to military law seems a little bit hazy, but that is another subject.

We are giving our opinion on the ASSUMPTION that he is guilty, 

We all will wait for the facts to either support our assumption or not.  Either way, you have to be able to ask yourself "what if the guy did what the Army is charging him with?"

Saying "I'll have to wait for all the facts" is no answer.  Refusing to answer tells us everything we need to know about your answer.  You believe there is no such thing as a crime unless all elements of the crime can be proven.  In a battle environment, that's rarely going to be the case.  Evidence gets destroyed and witnesses are few (or dead).  The military doesn't adhere to the civilian rules of evidence.  It's extremely rare for a court martial to excuse criminal behavior based on a technicality or personal reason.  Duty is duty.  Failure is failure.  Desertion is desertion.  Unless he was really captured against his will, he's guilty based on the result.  Period.
An unarmed man can only flee from evil, and evil is not overcome by fleeing from it.   -- Jeff Cooper

eyeeatingfish

Re: What about Bergdahl ?
« Reply #39 on: September 22, 2015, 12:18:02 AM »
We are giving our opinion on the ASSUMPTION that he is guilty, 

We all will wait for the facts to either support our assumption or not.  Either way, you have to be able to ask yourself "what if the guy did what the Army is charging him with?"

Saying "I'll have to wait for all the facts" is no answer.  Refusing to answer tells us everything we need to know about your answer.  You believe there is no such thing as a crime unless all elements of the crime can be proven.  In a battle environment, that's rarely going to be the case.  Evidence gets destroyed and witnesses are few (or dead).  The military doesn't adhere to the civilian rules of evidence.  It's extremely rare for a court martial to excuse criminal behavior based on a technicality or personal reason.  Duty is duty.  Failure is failure.  Desertion is desertion.  Unless he was really captured against his will, he's guilty based on the result.  Period.

When it comes to conviction yes, a crime is a crime, but when it comes to a punishment the details matter.

Would you say that all people convicted of murder should get the death penalty or would you want to know the details of the murder to make your decision? A premeditated violent murder might warrant a different punishment than say a father who murdered a man who just raped his daughter.  Would you execute both because murder is murder?

The details of his leaving his post are a little unclear, at least from what I have found in media reports, and those details matter.