What about Bergdahl ? (Read 23265 times)

mauidog

Re: What about Bergdahl ?
« Reply #40 on: September 22, 2015, 01:31:28 AM »
When it comes to conviction yes, a crime is a crime, but when it comes to a punishment the details matter.

Would you say that all people convicted of murder should get the death penalty or would you want to know the details of the murder to make your decision? A premeditated violent murder might warrant a different punishment than say a father who murdered a man who just raped his daughter.  Would you execute both because murder is murder?

The details of his leaving his post are a little unclear, at least from what I have found in media reports, and those details matter.

Unless the homicide was justified (self defense, defense of another innocent, etc.), then the reason for the murder is not relevant.  The victim is dead.  The victims's family, friends and coworkers are without the victim. 

The taking of a life illegally is never justified.  Robbery?  Spousal abuse?  Sexual assault?  Jealousy?  Fear of prosecution for another crime?  In no situation can you say it's forgivable for murdering another person.

So, yes, I think all murderers should be sentenced to death.  Warehousing them for the remainder of their lives is fruitless.  What purpose can their lives serve behind bars until they die?  People serving life can be the most dangerous to corrections officers, infirmary workers, and inmates because they have nothing to lose. 

Details might help some try to understand why someone killed another, but that information should not be used to lessen the severity of the punishment.

Now, all of this is using another assumption --- that the prisoner is 100% guilty and there is no reasonable doubt as to that guilt.  A confession, video evidence, multiple eye witnesses, and unmistakeable forensics would be enough for me to convict. 

Eye for an eye.  If you kill another, your life is forfeit.  As for premeditated vs. homicides of passion -- where is justice when you are excused for murder and the next guy who kills is not?  Is there not a dead victim in both cases?  Should a lenient judge in one state hand out 25 to life sentences with possibility of parole, while one state over they get multiple life sentences or the death penalty for the same crime?  Justice requires we be consistent in punishing the guilty.  If you can't convict the prisoner of murder, then don't charge murder.  Obviously, there is doubt.  Like the Deedy case.  Was there intent to kill, or was it self defense?  If he gets convicted, which item on the menu should he receive?  I say, if he committed murder, he is a murderer and deserves a murderer's punishment.  If he did not commit murder, but defended himself, then he should never be charged with any degree of murder.

Everyone has empathy for the criminals.  What if that was me in the cell?  What would I want done?  That's not a good way to look at justice. You should empathize with the victim and the family of the victim.  How would I be feeling after the prisoner killed my wife/son/daughter/husband/mother/father/...?  Would I want the killer to be given the mercy he didn't show the victim? 

Taking a life is the ultimate act anyone can ever do.  It's one of the few things there can be no restitution for.  You can't give the person back their life, nor offer a substitute life in its place.  Perhaps in this declining morality we see in the US, we have to split hairs when it comes to murder.  A hate crime is worse than a premeditated murder, and a premeditated killing is worse than a spontaneous fit of road rage.  When the value of life is so cheap nowadays, it's easy to get drawn into trying to decide just how much a killer should pay for their crime.  Kill a gang member or hooker versus a soccer mom or doctor?  Kill a gay neighbor or Muslim coworker -- it's "hate".  Killing a spouse is love?  How about killing 20 kids in an elementary school versus chopping off a coworker's head?  Death is final.  Death has no measure of "how dead" you are.  Dead is dead.  If the death isn't justified, it's a crime, and the crime should exact an equal measure of punishment.
« Last Edit: September 22, 2015, 02:03:46 AM by mauidog »
An unarmed man can only flee from evil, and evil is not overcome by fleeing from it.   -- Jeff Cooper

mauidog

Re: What about Bergdahl ?
« Reply #41 on: September 22, 2015, 01:56:10 AM »
Most murder cases are 100% circumstantial.  The police only need means, motive, and opportunity to make someone a suspect.  The field is narrowed based on polygraphs, suspect interviews, forensics and a preponderance of the evidence -- which suspect is most likely the killer?

That leaves some doubt.  Without solid evidence or a confession, all you can do is use common sense and the evidence presented to decide guilt or innocence.  That leaves at least some room for the possibility the person is not guilty.  In that case, a death sentence would be wrong.

The death penalty should have a 100% threshold for certainty.  There should be one decision left for the prisoner:  injection, firing squad, or hanging.  No appeals on technicalities or rights violations.  "Guilty!  Death!  Sunrise, a week from tomorrow!"

In Bergdahl's case, the fact he left his post is undeniable.  There was no evidence offered so far to substantiate he was captured against his will.  There would have been evidence at his post.  At least he would have fired a round at the bad guys when he saw them -- unless he was sleeping!  I believe sleeping or leaving your post while on sentry duty is a bigger crime than just failure to show.  Total desertion, even bigger.

Unless he has a provable defense other than him or his lawyer mouthing words, he's guilty.  Substantiation and corroboration are needed if he is not guilty. 
An unarmed man can only flee from evil, and evil is not overcome by fleeing from it.   -- Jeff Cooper

eyeeatingfish

Re: What about Bergdahl ?
« Reply #42 on: September 22, 2015, 04:32:47 AM »
Unless the homicide was justified (self defense, defense of another innocent, etc.), then the reason for the murder is not relevant.  The victim is dead.  The victims's family, friends and coworkers are without the victim. 

The taking of a life illegally is never justified.  Robbery?  Spousal abuse?  Sexual assault?  Jealousy?  Fear of prosecution for another crime?  In no situation can you say it's forgivable for murdering another person.

So, yes, I think all murderers should be sentenced to death.  Warehousing them for the remainder of their lives is fruitless.  What purpose can their lives serve behind bars until they die?  People serving life can be the most dangerous to corrections officers, infirmary workers, and inmates because they have nothing to lose. 

WTF, my whole reply got deleted...

We may have to agree to disagree, I don't think this is a one size fits all type of situation. The punishment should fit the crime and that includes the circumstances of the crime, not just the outcome.

There are a couple issues with the death penalty as an automatic sentence. For starters, the justice system isn't perfect. People have been wrongly convicted both by mistake and through intentional actions. As you said, dead is dead, it is forever and that includes taking the life of the person convicted of the crime. You cannot give back the life to an individual who was wrongly convicted and executed. On top of that you would say no appeals process? No checks and balances? Just take someone's life on what might have been a sketchy conviction? Hope you never have to defend yourself with a firearm and get a liberal jury...

On top of that there are mental health issues. Sure if you are killed by a mentally handicapped person you are still dead but it brings into question whether someone is able to understand what they were doing. The same holds true for juveniles. BTW I am not referring to the Bergdahl case, just issues surrounding the death penalty.

As for the bergdahl case I am sure that if they are charging him with a crime then they have pretty good evidence. It would be interesting to see what kind of defense Bergdahl will come up with to explain his actions. The only explanation I can think of that would have any chance of working is some sort of mental health defense, some sort of episode related to PTSD or an illness perhaps. I doubt the abducted by aliens defense will work
« Last Edit: September 22, 2015, 04:49:08 AM by eyeeatingfish »

mauidog

Re: What about Bergdahl ?
« Reply #43 on: September 22, 2015, 08:49:20 AM »
WTF, my whole reply got deleted...

We may have to agree to disagree, I don't think this is a one size fits all type of situation. The punishment should fit the crime and that includes the circumstances of the crime, not just the outcome.

There are a couple issues with the death penalty as an automatic sentence. For starters, the justice system isn't perfect. People have been wrongly convicted both by mistake and through intentional actions. As you said, dead is dead, it is forever and that includes taking the life of the person convicted of the crime. You cannot give back the life to an individual who was wrongly convicted and executed. On top of that you would say no appeals process? No checks and balances? Just take someone's life on what might have been a sketchy conviction? Hope you never have to defend yourself with a firearm and get a liberal jury...

On top of that there are mental health issues. Sure if you are killed by a mentally handicapped person you are still dead but it brings into question whether someone is able to understand what they were doing. The same holds true for juveniles. BTW I am not referring to the Bergdahl case, just issues surrounding the death penalty.

As for the bergdahl case I am sure that if they are charging him with a crime then they have pretty good evidence. It would be interesting to see what kind of defense Bergdahl will come up with to explain his actions. The only explanation I can think of that would have any chance of working is some sort of mental health defense, some sort of episode related to PTSD or an illness perhaps. I doubt the abducted by aliens defense will work

Did you even read my comments?

Mental health issues can be faked.  People lie about hearing voices to avoid punishment.  There is no lab test that can verify someone is or isn't lying about their mental state.
An unarmed man can only flee from evil, and evil is not overcome by fleeing from it.   -- Jeff Cooper

eyeeatingfish

Re: What about Bergdahl ?
« Reply #44 on: September 23, 2015, 01:46:08 AM »
Did you even read my comments?

Mental health issues can be faked.  People lie about hearing voices to avoid punishment.  There is no lab test that can verify someone is or isn't lying about their mental state.

So you prefer to execute them anyway just in case they are lying? Actually there are ways to see if someone is lying about mental health using medical exams, questionnaires and interviews with psychologists. Remember that the government has to prove you are guilty, not make you prove that you are innocent.

You say there should be a 100% threshold for the death penalty, but such a thing rarely exists. It doesn't appear to exist in the bergdahl case. And I would fear anyone who wants to do away with checks and balances when it comes to taking a life.

mauidog

Re: What about Bergdahl ?
« Reply #45 on: September 23, 2015, 08:14:27 AM »
So you prefer to execute them anyway just in case they are lying? Actually there are ways to see if someone is lying about mental health using medical exams, questionnaires and interviews with psychologists. Remember that the government has to prove you are guilty, not make you prove that you are innocent.

You say there should be a 100% threshold for the death penalty, but such a thing rarely exists. It doesn't appear to exist in the bergdahl case. And I would fear anyone who wants to do away with checks and balances when it comes to taking a life.

Now you are definitely being obtuse.

I said, ONLY EXECUTE IN CASES WHERE THERE IS NO DOUBT OF GUILT.  The courts hold hearings to determine the mental status of the defendant.  If that shows he is not mentally ill, then YES!  One -way ticket to the promised land!

BTW, what school sold you your Psychology and Psychiatry degrees?

Once again you proved my point.  You are more concerned about arguing over the process of conviction.  You can't bring yourself to face the reality that a crime is a crime, and that the system has been rigged to give criminals excuses for their anti-social acts.
An unarmed man can only flee from evil, and evil is not overcome by fleeing from it.   -- Jeff Cooper

robtmc

Re: What about Bergdahl ?
« Reply #46 on: September 23, 2015, 06:09:19 PM »
You know nothing of my past experiences so your personal attack is uncalled for.
No one attacked you, merely an observation.

If nothing else, military service, combat service in particular, tends to clarify and focus.   You make decisions and take orders.

Some may return to shades of gray thinking later on, but not so much in my experience.

eyeeatingfish

Re: What about Bergdahl ?
« Reply #47 on: September 23, 2015, 08:30:29 PM »
Now you are definitely being obtuse.

I said, ONLY EXECUTE IN CASES WHERE THERE IS NO DOUBT OF GUILT.  The courts hold hearings to determine the mental status of the defendant.  If that shows he is not mentally ill, then YES!  One -way ticket to the promised land!

BTW, what school sold you your Psychology and Psychiatry degrees?

Once again you proved my point.  You are more concerned about arguing over the process of conviction.  You can't bring yourself to face the reality that a crime is a crime, and that the system has been rigged to give criminals excuses for their anti-social acts.

University of Hawaii.

There is room for doubt in the Bergdahl case and that is why I would not call for execution, simple as that. And even if there was no doubt, history has shown the importance of the appeals system.

Reality is not that a crime is a crime. If you sped in a car you have committed a crime, are you the same as a murderer? Of course not. The outcome is not the only thing that matters. In the case of manslaughter the outcome is the same as murder, someone died, but the circumstances are different. To maintain your logic then we should apply the death penalty to manslaughter, is that your position?

The system has been established so as to reduce abuses of power and to take as many steps to ensure innocent people are not convicted. Just curious,  do you believe in the phrase that it is better that 10 guilty men go free than one innocent man suffer?
« Last Edit: September 23, 2015, 08:38:19 PM by eyeeatingfish »

eyeeatingfish

Re: What about Bergdahl ?
« Reply #48 on: September 23, 2015, 08:37:27 PM »
No one attacked you, merely an observation.

If nothing else, military service, combat service in particular, tends to clarify and focus.   You make decisions and take orders.

Some may return to shades of gray thinking later on, but not so much in my experience.

Oh please, the subtlety of your insults and implications were not lost on me. I never spoke as if I had served, I never spoke as if I experienced military combat, I merely gave a differing opinion, gave my reasons why when asked. It wasn't even some opinion on the opposite extreme. Your reply suggests that no one of combat experience would have an opinion different than the death penalty and that my position is therefore ignorant of reality

mauidog

Re: What about Bergdahl ?
« Reply #49 on: September 23, 2015, 11:04:03 PM »
University of Hawaii.

There is room for doubt in the Bergdahl case and that is why I would not call for execution, simple as that. And even if there was no doubt, history has shown the importance of the appeals system.

Reality is not that a crime is a crime. If you sped in a car you have committed a crime, are you the same as a murderer? Of course not. The outcome is not the only thing that matters. In the case of manslaughter the outcome is the same as murder, someone died, but the circumstances are different. To maintain your logic then we should apply the death penalty to manslaughter, is that your position?

The system has been established so as to reduce abuses of power and to take as many steps to ensure innocent people are not convicted. Just curious,  do you believe in the phrase that it is better that 10 guilty men go free than one innocent man suffer?

You're on drugs!  That's the only explanation!

There hasn't been a trial.  How can you make that statement?  You won't be in the courtroom to hear all of the evidence and see the body language of the witnesses.  Again, how can you know there is doubt?

The only question I have is how you ever passed a firearm background check?
An unarmed man can only flee from evil, and evil is not overcome by fleeing from it.   -- Jeff Cooper

eyeeatingfish

Re: What about Bergdahl ?
« Reply #50 on: September 24, 2015, 07:12:11 AM »
You're on drugs!  That's the only explanation!

There hasn't been a trial.  How can you make that statement?  You won't be in the courtroom to hear all of the evidence and see the body language of the witnesses.  Again, how can you know there is doubt?

I have repeatedly said that based on the current knowledge I have on the case I would not apply the death penalty, but that I was open to changing my position if more evidence came to light. From the publicly known evidence there is room for doubt, doubt because there are unanswered questions about the circumstances.

Now if in trial Bergdahl goes martyr on us and says he left to support allah's fight on America then I would say execution is appropriate.

Quote
The only question I have is how you ever passed a firearm background check?

I passed it with flying colors.

mauidog

Re: What about Bergdahl ?
« Reply #52 on: September 24, 2015, 11:08:45 AM »
https://www.washingtonpost.com/world/national-security/disillusioned-and-self-deluded-bowe-bergdahl-vanished-into-a-brutal-captivity/2015/09/20/b15a8a8c-5f9b-11e5-b38e-06883aacba64_story.html

http://www.npr.org/sections/parallels/2015/09/24/443071030/the-very-strange-case-of-sgt-bowe-bergdahl

There's a giant, gaping hole in the "rationale" for him walking off the post.  His excuse is, he was going to the next camp to report problems to higher command, since he thought the unit was "in danger because of failed leadership." 

Well, since his unit was scheduled to rotate the next day, why leave?  Could he not take that opportunity to go talk to higher command while not performing normal duty? 

Or, was it more like, this was his last chance to slip away, while his unit was more focused on rotating the next day, and while he was still in a location that was close to the enemy he wanted to encounter?

If we want to talk about motives, then the one he offered for deserting his unit is bogus.  It makes little sense in the context of the unit rotating out.  His best chance of contacting higher command would have been during his unit's down time, not the day they are rotating.

Walking away caused weeks of grief for the unit.  Instead of rotating out, they were being interviewed, searching the local area, and basically redeployed the day they should have been relieved, enjoying some R&R.

Yeah, this guy is trying to make it sound like his intentions were golden.  Intentions don't count when you are guilty of desertion.  His decision to walk off, and his consequences to face.
An unarmed man can only flee from evil, and evil is not overcome by fleeing from it.   -- Jeff Cooper

robtmc

Re: What about Bergdahl ?
« Reply #53 on: September 24, 2015, 03:07:36 PM »
Yeah, this guy is trying to make it sound like his intentions were golden.  Intentions don't count when you are guilty of desertion.  His decision to walk off, and his consequences to face.
Well, the bastard is lawyered up, probably with the best shyster the Obunghole regime can find for him. 

Got to figure they have been working overtime to come up with a story that appeals to those foolish enough not to look too deep, IOW, MSM readers.  Those that have served can smell the BS, the civilian masses have no clue and will buy whatever seems emotionally plausible.

This is as much a PR event as a trial for desertion.

aieahound

Re: What about Bergdahl ?
« Reply #54 on: September 24, 2015, 03:25:31 PM »
Why would he walk off the night before his unit is rotating out to another base to get to another base ?

His story makes no sense.

Apparently they found a Mjr. General whose pretty sympathetic to investigate it. (After swapping 5 high level Taliban)

robtmc

Re: What about Bergdahl ?
« Reply #55 on: September 24, 2015, 06:38:03 PM »
Your reply suggests that no one of combat experience would have an opinion different than the death penalty and that my position is therefore ignorant of reality
Ah, a brief moment of clarity.  Do not know you, but have seen far too much of your postings, perhaps.

Very good, kid.  Here is how it is.  I do not waste my time debating kids and liberals online.  Those who have not been there and done that do not rate my attention. not that my opinion is worth spit. 

Access to a smartphone and Google are not substitutes for experience.  Ran into a couple of those years back, pissed me off when I realized I was arguing about 9/11 with some Australian girl that was maybe 15 at the time it happened.  That her experience ot it at the time it happened was zip did not matter, Google was all the she needed to argue with those that had lived through it.

Google does not equal experience, but the latest generation likes to use it as such. or as a substitute.  Not saying that is what you do, but much of why I am a curmudgeon.

Fellow veterans are the only ones on the left I will take the time to debate and argue with, they have earned my attention.  Other need to earn it.

eyeeatingfish

Re: What about Bergdahl ?
« Reply #56 on: September 24, 2015, 07:16:56 PM »
Yeah, that defense seems pretty bogus. Even if there were problems in his unit, this way of addressing them makes absolutely no sense.

I would have expected some sort of mental health defense.

DO you think Obama would ever allow the military execute him though?

mauidog

Re: What about Bergdahl ?
« Reply #57 on: September 24, 2015, 07:34:03 PM »
Yeah, that defense seems pretty bogus. Even if there were problems in his unit, this way of addressing them makes absolutely no sense.

I would have expected some sort of mental health defense.

DO you think Obama would ever allow the military execute him though?

After Obama:

went around Congress,
traded 5 top Taliban leaders for this deserter,
had a Rose Garden press conference with the Muslim mom and dad to announce to the world this man was returning to the US,
and joined Susan Rice in calling him a hero and POW who served with (GAG!)  "honor and distinction" ?   

Execution would be the icing on the cake!  Obama would sooner grant a pardon than have this deserter's execution staining his legacy.
An unarmed man can only flee from evil, and evil is not overcome by fleeing from it.   -- Jeff Cooper

eyeeatingfish

Re: What about Bergdahl ?
« Reply #58 on: September 24, 2015, 07:50:19 PM »
I do not waste my time debating kids and liberals online.

Well I am neither, so consider your time well spent! :shaka:

mauidog

Re: What about Bergdahl ?
« Reply #59 on: September 24, 2015, 07:57:34 PM »
Well I am neither, so consider your time well spent! :shaka:

The first step toward recovery is admitting you have a problem.

You have a ways to go!   :wacko:
An unarmed man can only flee from evil, and evil is not overcome by fleeing from it.   -- Jeff Cooper