Laws i would like to see changed/fixed (Read 11625 times)

London808

Laws i would like to see changed/fixed
« on: March 06, 2016, 08:28:27 AM »
Changes I would like to see in Hawaiis gun laws, Although I believe most firearms laws are unconstitutional it is by now obvious to most that they are not going to go away, So here is a list of changes I would like to see that will not only keep people safe/happy but will take burden of gun owners

Permits,
Both rifle and pistol permits treated the same. 1 permit good for 1 year.
Permits issued from ANY police station.
Permits Must be issued unless legal reason is found not to (At the time the law says they MAY issue).
Permits Must be issued to all legal residents of the united states upon completion of a background check.
Permits issued in a timely manor, after completion of medical/background checks permits should be made available as soon as possible. ( Especially with reissue of permits)
Permits will be issued 7 days a week during business/station hours

Registration
Purchases from an FFL,  Registration done by the FFL at time of purchase, A form filled out by the FFL stating the same as what is required by the current law, along with a photocopy of the ID pretested and a finger or thumb print.
Private sales either done via an FFL or Completed with Police as per the current system.
Registration at Police station to be available 7 days a week during station hours.
Registration of guns bough in from out of state within 30 days, Penalty for non registration in a timely manor a fine (unless criminal intent is found)

Possession
A firearm (and ammo)may be possed at any time in any location for legal reason, Must be transported unloaded in an enclosed container or original packing.
Concealed carry MUST be issued after completion of a training course.

Selling And Manufacturer of firearms,
 Licensee required only  for those in the business of selling and/or manufacturing firearms.

I will update as i think of anything else or other stuff is bought to my attention, What do you guys think ?
"Mr. Roberts is a bit of a fanatic, he has previously sued HPD about gun registration issues." : Major Richard Robinson 2016

oldfart

Re: Laws i would like to see changed/fixed
« Reply #1 on: March 06, 2016, 08:38:29 AM »
There is a section I thought interesting.
Different mandatory sentencing depending on whether you commit a crime with a revolver or a semi-auto pistol.
Anachronistic I suspect.
What, Me Worry?

Jl808

Re: Laws i would like to see changed/fixed
« Reply #2 on: March 06, 2016, 09:01:14 AM »
Nice thread, London808.   :thumbsup:
I think, therefore I am armed.
NRA Life Patron member, HRA Life member, HiFiCo Life Member, HDF member

The United States Constitution © 1791. All Rights Reserved.

London808

Re: Laws i would like to see changed/fixed
« Reply #3 on: March 06, 2016, 09:25:37 AM »
There is a section I thought interesting.
Different mandatory sentencing depending on whether you commit a crime with a revolver or a semi-auto pistol.
Anachronistic I suspect.


IMO there should be no such thing as mandatory sentencing, All crimes are different and as such all facts should be taken into account with intent and willingness to break a law.
"Mr. Roberts is a bit of a fanatic, he has previously sued HPD about gun registration issues." : Major Richard Robinson 2016

Tom_G

Re: Laws i would like to see changed/fixed
« Reply #4 on: March 06, 2016, 10:26:43 AM »
My list:

HRS 134
The difference between theory and reality is that, in theory, there is no difference between theory and reality.

punaperson

Re: Laws i would like to see changed/fixed
« Reply #5 on: March 06, 2016, 10:32:48 AM »
Changes I would like to see in Hawaiis gun laws, Although I believe most firearms laws are unconstitutional it is by now obvious to most that they are not going to go away, So here is a list of changes I would like to see that will not only keep people safe/happy but will take burden of gun owners.
Once you acknowledge that the laws as they exist are unconstitutional and are "not going to go away", why argue to incrementally make them a "little less unconstitutional"? That's exactly the strategy they want us to adopt: beg for a crumb. The whole underlying aim of the laws is not the oft-touted "public safety", but rather merely to harass, encumber and intimidate (would-be) weapons owners to the point where at least some people just give up, and the rest of the law-abiding ones are strictly monitored as if they were criminals on a pedophile registry. The "changes" you suggest are merely the minor alteration of "inconveniences" that do not address in any way the ultimate tyranny of the state dictating infringements on natural civil rights that are constitutionally-guaranteed against government interference. That's not close to being granted even "house slave" status.

How are you going to get such changes made legislatively? The authorities won't even consider mailing me my permit, but instead make me drive 40 minutes each way for a THIRD time to pick up a piece of paper without even asking me for identification. Their justifying reasoning for adhering to such a procedure (in spite of various government and private entities mailing passports, drivers licenses, social security cards, credit cards, etc.) is: "We've always done it that way". You think these people are amenable to "reason"? I know I've seen the past two legislative sessions that clearly they are not.

How about this as the starting point? No government involvement in any way with the acquisition/transfer and ownership and bearing of firearms (and their accessories, e.g. suppressors, magazines, barrel length, etc.) or any other weapons (electric "stun" guns, knives, expandable batons, etc., etc., etc.) at the state level (given federally-mandated NICS checks for FFL purchases).

But I'd probably help in some way if I could...  :geekdanc:  :shaka:

London808

Re: Laws i would like to see changed/fixed
« Reply #6 on: March 06, 2016, 11:37:35 AM »
Once you acknowledge that the laws as they exist are unconstitutional and are "not going to go away", why argue to incrementally make them a "little less unconstitutional"?
Although i belive the laws to be unconstitutional the supreme court has ruled that they are, Untill such time that is changed i have no choice but to accept that, Thats how the legal system works
That's exactly the strategy they want us to adopt: beg for a crumb. The whole underlying aim of the laws is not the oft-touted "public safety", but rather merely to harass, encumber and intimidate (would-be) weapons ( I believe you mean Firearm or Arms, Untill its used as such it it is not a Weapon. very important difference especially when talking about laws )owners to the point where at least some people just give up, and the rest of the law-abiding ones are strictly monitored as if they were criminals on a pedophile registry. The "changes" you suggest are merely the minor alteration of "inconveniences" that do not address in any way the ultimate tyranny of the state dictating infringements on natural civil rights that are constitutionally-guaranteed against government interference. That's not close to being granted even "house slave" status.
By jumping through there hoops no matter how big and small to exercise my rights I and many others are showing that no matter what they do we will continue to do so, Yes some peopel give up in the process or cant be bothered with the humbug it causes, But as Gun owners and enthusiasts its our job to educate the public and to explain how important it is to exersices thire rights and to bring new people into the fold. If we give up hope then they will never have it. 

How are you going to get such changes made legislatively? The authorities won't even consider mailing me my permit, but instead make me drive 40 minutes each way for a THIRD time to pick up a piece of paper without even asking me for identification. Their justifying reasoning for adhering to such a procedure (in spite of various government and private entities mailing passports, drivers licenses, social security cards, credit cards, etc.) is: "We've always done it that way". You think these people are amenable to "reason"? I know I've seen the past two legislative sessions that clearly they are not.
The first step to getting any changes is talking about it, If you just shutup because you dont think things will change then you have already lost, The last few years have seen more and more gun wonders in America and Gun owners belive in theire rights and war willing to vote to protect them. A lot of people have no clue what bills are being made/passed and as some one who is a firearms enutsist who wants to protect our rights its our job to make sure as many epople as possible know. We have some great people on this website that have put together lists and calls to action to oppose them.
Secondly we need to start contacting those that are voting in support even tho a HUGE majority of the testimonials submitted  oppose them. If they keep voting against the people and getting away with it they will.


How about this as the starting point? No government involvement in any way with the acquisition/transfer and ownership and bearing of firearms (and their accessories, e.g. suppressors, magazines, barrel length, etc.) or any other weapons (electric "stun" guns, knives, expandable batons, etc., etc., etc.) at the state level (given federally-mandated NICS checks for FFL purchases).
I think you have this the wrong way round their should be NO Federal restrictions on firearms only state. Those state laws should be inline with the constitution.
But I'd probably help in some way if I could...  :geekdanc:  :shaka:
You are helping, By talking about it, You could do more As i stated above speaking to your representatives and law makers is a great way.

Also with regards to your permit. What island are you on ?

"Mr. Roberts is a bit of a fanatic, he has previously sued HPD about gun registration issues." : Major Richard Robinson 2016

Q

Re: Laws i would like to see changed/fixed
« Reply #7 on: March 06, 2016, 06:29:43 PM »
Expanding on permits from any station, I think it should be improved for the registration process with the following:

- Go to any station with firearm

- fill out paperwork and have firearm verified by that station's firearm sub-division officers

- That HPD station mails in the paperwork to the main firearms division

- They mail you a copy of your registration, just like how the C&C mails you a copy of your vehicle registration.




The list London provided are good talking points for us to reach out to C&C officials and legislators. People can talk about completely doing away with 134 or getting rid of registration or permits, but thats never going to happen any time soon.

It's better to change the current system in our favor while we work on longer term goals, like the removal of 134 all together.

London808

Re: Laws i would like to see changed/fixed
« Reply #8 on: March 06, 2016, 08:37:36 PM »
Expanding on permits from any station, I think it should be improved for the registration process with the following:.......................................

Even better all transfers have to be via an FFL (if HPD opens up registration at other stations they are going to tack on a fee as they can per HRS 134) So instead of going to any police station FFL fills out a registration transfer form that they send into HPD, Registration comes in the mail. Same thing for new sales. If an FFL can be trusted to sell firearms in a legal manor they should be trusted to verify a serial number,
The list London provided are good talking points for us to reach out to C&C officials and legislators. People can talk about completely doing away with 134 or getting rid of registration or permits, but thats never going to happen any time soon.
It's better to change the current system in our favor while we work on longer term goals, like the removal of 134 all together.
Thats my point instead of trying to fight a fight taht were not going to win lets try and make them see common sense and at least make the process Easier, Faster and bearable for everyone. Instead of going in or making contact with an all or nothing list, Lets show them that were being resanable and willing to compromises to find something that works for every one. Can you imagen the money the city cold save by moving to an FFL based registration system,  Instead of useing police officers for registration they can use clerks at half the cost and get twice the amount of work done,
"Mr. Roberts is a bit of a fanatic, he has previously sued HPD about gun registration issues." : Major Richard Robinson 2016

punaperson

Re: Laws i would like to see changed/fixed
« Reply #9 on: March 06, 2016, 09:58:43 PM »
Even better all transfers have to be via an FFL (if HPD opens up registration at other stations they are going to tack on a fee as they can per HRS 134) So instead of going to any police station FFL fills out a registration transfer form that they send into HPD, Registration comes in the mail. Same thing for new sales. If an FFL can be trusted to sell firearms in a legal manor they should be trusted to verify a serial number,
1. So you want to pay an FFL a $20 or more fee for a private sale?
2. You don't think it hasn't already occurred to them that they could mail any documents, rather than having people have to make separate trips for each stage of the process? They know full well they could mail those without any security risk, they don't want to. Guess why.
3. You don't think it hasn't already occurred to them that they could have the FFL do all the registration paperwork, as they know full well is the case in 98% of the United States? They know full well they could have FFLs do that paperwork, they don't want to. Guess why.
4. That's why no amount of "common sense" "reasonable" "bargaining" and "compromise" (aka "willingly giving up our rights") will have any effect on the process as it exists. It's not amenable to reason. They know that. They know citizens have no leverage whatsoever (see ratios of testimony in recent committee hearings and the fact that the members then voted opposite the overwhelming citizen testimony position). They have no motive to change the process at all. It's just the way they like it (other than to make it even more difficult for a citizen to own any arm at all). Let's say if, and it's an enormously unlikely if, they tossed you a bone and allowed a permit to be mailed instead of picked up in person, you don't think that would be part of some calculated strategy? If they had any interest at all in reason or common sense being the basis of their policies they wouldn't have created the existing policies in the first place. Or do you really think they're just "stupid"?

Thats my point instead of trying to fight a fight taht were not going to win lets try and make them see common sense and at least make the process Easier, Faster and bearable for everyone. Instead of going in or making contact with an all or nothing list, Lets show them that were being resanable and willing to compromises to find something that works for every one. Can you imagen the money the city cold save by moving to an FFL based registration system,  Instead of useing police officers for registration they can use clerks at half the cost and get twice the amount of work done,
1. Imagine the money they could save by not registering or permitting any firearms transactions at all, you know, like in 98% of the rest of the United States. If you think this is about them "saving money", I have a bridge in Brooklyn for sale, cheap. You really think the chief wants to propose to a budget committee that because his department came to a common sense policy that their work load has decreased so they will be needing less money in their next budget allocation?
2. Re "common sense" "reasonable" "compromise" etc., see point 4 above.

eyeeatingfish

Re: Laws i would like to see changed/fixed
« Reply #10 on: March 06, 2016, 10:49:39 PM »
I would like a system where you get your permit to purchase and all you have to do is call the police station to confirm the permit is valid and the firearm may be transferred. Registration to be mailed in like a car registration. Or heck, just allow transfer at any police station and can be witnessed by the officer. Easy enough.

Q

Re: Laws i would like to see changed/fixed
« Reply #11 on: March 07, 2016, 12:09:16 AM »
1. So you want to pay an FFL a $20 or more fee for a private sale?

We don't do FFLs for private sales in Hawaii.

But I would pay that extra $25 to do the background check at the FFL, because its far more convenient than standing in line for 2 hours to apply for a permit, waiting 2 weeks, then standing in the same line again for another 30-60 minutes for a permit, picking up the firearm, then standing in line again for another 1-2 hours to register.

2. You don't think it hasn't already occurred to them that they could mail any documents, rather than having people have to make separate trips for each stage of the process? They know full well they could mail those without any security risk, they don't want to. Guess why.

I'm sure it has occurred to them, but its their mission to make it as hard as possible for us to obtain firearms, so as to discourage us from exercising our constitutional right.

The real question is: how many of the people on this forum have directly approached C&C officials to get this changed, or reached out to the media to make this an issue, or approached legislators? My assumption: less than a handful.

Make it a thorn in their side and eventually they will want to resolve it so we shut up.


3. You don't think it hasn't already occurred to them that they could have the FFL do all the registration paperwork, as they know full well is the case in 98% of the United States? They know full well they could have FFLs do that paperwork, they don't want to. Guess why.

I don't think that's the case. I think the FFLs just don't want to do the work, which is why they aren't pushing for doing the background checks. They could easily state that they would forward all the information to HPD firearms, which would actually make the firearms division's job easier because the FFL would be doing all the paperwork and background checks. All HPD would need to do is enter the info into their system, and send out the registration in the mail.

Just ask yourself: how many gun shops are leading the fight for 2a here in Hawaii? They sure love our business, but I didn't hear about any of the gunshops at any of the 2a rallies or testifying in opposition to the anti-firearm legislation.



4. That's why no amount of "common sense" "reasonable" "bargaining" and "compromise" (aka "willingly giving up our rights") will have any effect on the process as it exists. It's not amenable to reason. They know that. They know citizens have no leverage whatsoever (see ratios of testimony in recent committee hearings and the fact that the members then voted opposite the overwhelming citizen testimony position). They have no motive to change the process at all. It's just the way they like it (other than to make it even more difficult for a citizen to own any arm at all). Let's say if, and it's an enormously unlikely if, they tossed you a bone and allowed a permit to be mailed instead of picked up in person, you don't think that would be part of some calculated strategy? If they had any interest at all in reason or common sense being the basis of their policies they wouldn't have created the existing policies in the first place. Or do you really think they're just "stupid"?

The reason they keep doing what they do is because they know that most firearm owners in Hawaii don't have a spine to stand up to what is going on. They like to talk a big game on 2a about what they would do if confiscation was implemented, or what they would do if the Russians invade, yet when it comes time to fight for our 2a rights, they fade into the shadows with their endless excuses.

Now if the firearm community would just grow some balls and demonstrate how angry and serious we are, I'm sure it would have a profound effect on the way they do things. But take into account how many firearm owners there are in Hawaii, and how many of them are NOT apart of the HRA, NRA or any other national/state 2a organization.

The problem in Hawaii is that people don't give a shit, which is why we get walked over again and again.

London808

Re: Laws i would like to see changed/fixed
« Reply #12 on: March 07, 2016, 07:10:50 AM »
1. So you want to pay an FFL a $20 or more fee for a private sale?
2. You don't think it hasn't already occurred to them that they could mail any documents, rather than having people have to make separate trips for each stage of the process? They know full well they could mail those without any security risk, they don't want to. Guess why.
3. You don't think it hasn't already occurred to them that they could have the FFL do all the registration paperwork, as they know full well is the case in 98% of the United States? They know full well they could have FFLs do that paperwork, they don't want to. Guess why.
4. That's why no amount of "common sense" "reasonable" "bargaining" and "compromise" (aka "willingly giving up our rights") will have any effect on the process as it exists. It's not amenable to reason. They know that. They know citizens have no leverage whatsoever (see ratios of testimony in recent committee hearings and the fact that the members then voted opposite the overwhelming citizen testimony position). They have no motive to change the process at all. It's just the way they like it (other than to make it even more difficult for a citizen to own any arm at all). Let's say if, and it's an enormously unlikely if, they tossed you a bone and allowed a permit to be mailed instead of picked up in person, you don't think that would be part of some calculated strategy? If they had any interest at all in reason or common sense being the basis of their policies they wouldn't have created the existing policies in the first place. Or do you really think they're just "stupid"?
1. Imagine the money they could save by not registering or permitting any firearms transactions at all, you know, like in 98% of the rest of the United States. If you think this is about them "saving money", I have a bridge in Brooklyn for sale, cheap. You really think the chief wants to propose to a budget committee that because his department came to a common sense policy that their work load has decreased so they will be needing less money in their next budget allocation?
2. Re "common sense" "reasonable" "compromise" etc., see point 4 above.

Q has covered most of what im about to say but im going to say it anyway
1, If it saves me a trip to the police station YES, Heres why, Most gun shops are open longer hours and on weekends, Police stations are not, If i can get my registration/transfer done at a time thats convenient for me im willing to pay a little for that. Not to mention it will be done faster and more strealine saving me time waiting at the police staion. My time is worth money to me.
2 They are doing it to be inconvenient, you keep bringing up your permit not be mailed to you. Guess what they can do it. HPD does it. (They are choosing not to. I will go back over this latter on )
3 Actually 98% of the rest of the US does no do this, Most states with a registration requirement require a trip to the police station with the firearm to register it. (98% would mean only Hawaii requires it)
4 Compromise is not giving up your rights, Compromises is where BOTH SIDES give something to get something. You want no gun restrictions, no Registration ect........ They dont want us to have ANY guns. Lets meet in the middle, Your attitude of they have all the power so why fight it sucks, If thats what you truly believe then you should turn in any guns you own Because they have the power and thats what they want. Again you bring up mailing a permit. The law does not prohbit them from doing it, HPD does it (and again i will get back to it )

The reason they have the power is because WE GRANT IT TO THEM. They are not a ruling class they dont get power because its theirs, They get it from the people. Filling  out testimony is nice and as you have seen recently does little, But did you follow up with a phone call and e-mail a letter saying Hey i submitted testimony did you read it, What is your stance on it. What are you going to do for me, The person who votes for you ? If every person whos a member on this bored filled at tesstimony and then called there Rep to ask if they took the time to read it things could change, But people are lazy and expect others to do the work.
"Mr. Roberts is a bit of a fanatic, he has previously sued HPD about gun registration issues." : Major Richard Robinson 2016

punaperson

Re: Laws i would like to see changed/fixed
« Reply #13 on: March 07, 2016, 07:12:12 AM »
We don't do FFLs for private sales in Hawaii.
I know that. The original poster's suggestions included that private sales go through FFLs as one of his goals.

The real question is: how many of the people on this forum have directly approached C&C officials to get this changed, or reached out to the media to make this an issue, or approached legislators? My assumption: less than a handful.
I decided over a year ago to test the waters by attempting to get a response to suggesting changing an innocuous part of the unconstitutional Hawaii Second Amendment infringing laws by asking that the final stage of registration, picking up the finalized registration document, be accomplished via mailing rather than a personal trip to the police station (one of my arguments was the enlarged carbon footprint when you included all the trips by all the gun registrants, since I know they love that anthropogenic global warming b*llsh*t...) . What could be more "common sense" and "reasonable" than that? I wrote (and in some cases also called for follow-up) police chief Kubojiri, the (criminal) mayor Mr. Kenoi, the District Attorney, Mitch Roth, all the County Council members, my state senator Ruderman, and my state representative Onishi. As I've mentioned elsewhere, the chief's response was (after several more emails asking for an answer) "We've always done it that way". The only other response I got was from one council person's staff member asking for a more detailed clarification of the issue, and then I never heard from them again. I'm sure the authorities of the City and County of Honolulu are far more amenable to reason and common sense than here on the Big Island. Keep us informed as to how it goes.

Make it a thorn in their side and eventually they will want to resolve it so we shut up.
I seriously doubt it. You don't think they smirk or snicker or shake their head or laugh out loud when they see another email or letter or phone call or petition or testimony that challenges their unchallengeable authority to impose irrational restrictions on people's rights? The only motive they have to change, other than a direct unambiguous court order, is due to political pressure, and we all know exactly how the politics here line up (and no likelihood of that ever changing in the foreseeable future). Don't take my word for it. Read the state briefs in Baker, and the state and county briefs in Young, and amicus briefs filed by the state in other Ninth Circuit cases and it's clear that they have no intention of making anything "reasonable" or "common sense" for firearms owners (e.g. EVERYWHERE outside the home is a "sensitive area" (per Heller allowable restrictions), thus via intermediate scrutiny no one ought be allowed to possess a firearm outside the home because "public safety").
« Last Edit: March 07, 2016, 07:17:36 AM by punaperson »

London808

Re: Laws i would like to see changed/fixed
« Reply #14 on: March 07, 2016, 07:44:28 AM »
Heres what you should of done, (was typing this as you responded)

Went in to apply for permit, Whgen you give them the forms Tell them you want them to mail it to you.
They will say we cant. You hand them your pre paid, self-addressed pre-paid envelope, certified restricted-delivery return receipt required (already paid and attached), You tell them yes you can mail it with this.
They tell you we cant. We dont do that.
You ask to speak to a Sargent/Captain ect..., you polity explain your applying for a permit that you would like mailed to you. They will most likely tell you we dont do that. You then explain that The Honolulu police department does it as long as You provide the mailing envelope with certification, the information can be found on there website (information below)
"As an option, applicants may have their processed permits mailed to them. Applicants need to provide a self-addressed pre-paid envelope, certified restricted-delivery return receipt required(available at the U.S. Post Office) at time of application for permit. Long-gun (rifles/shotguns) permits are valid for one (1) year from the date of issue. Be advised that a handgun (pistols/revolvers) permit is valid for only ten (10) days from the date of issue."
( This is how i know for a fact that they can mail it to you, even if they choose not to.)
Chances are they will go OK hold on, make a call and come back and say OK.
Now if they dont you can then explain that State law requires all applications to be uniform and that if HPD does it that way they should to, Again they might say OK they might not.
If they dont you have a few options, Call/e-mail the chiefs office asking for there input, Call the state AG ask for there input, Call your local and state reps asking for their input.

Make sure to document every one you spoke (name/badge number) the date, time and location,  along with what there response was, After completing all thee steps, They decide that they wont mail it then you can say you did everything you could and then you can bitch about it.
"Mr. Roberts is a bit of a fanatic, he has previously sued HPD about gun registration issues." : Major Richard Robinson 2016

punaperson

Re: Laws i would like to see changed/fixed
« Reply #15 on: March 07, 2016, 08:10:35 AM »
Q has covered most of what im about to say but im going to say it anyway
1, If it saves me a trip to the police station YES, Heres why, Most gun shops are open longer hours and on weekends, Police stations are not, If i can get my registration/transfer done at a time thats convenient for me im willing to pay a little for that. Not to mention it will be done faster and more strealine saving me time waiting at the police staion. My time is worth money to me.
2 They are doing it to be inconvenient, you keep bringing up your permit not be mailed to you. Guess what they can do it. HPD does it. (They are choosing not to. I will go back over this latter on )
Of course they CAN. They are not proscribed by any legal authority from mailing a registration document. So what? The question is: DO they mail them? No, they don't, and won't. When they do be sure to tell us. You know what else they CAN do? Issue concealed carry licenses. DO they. NO, they don't. What's the point of talking about what they CAN do? All that matters is what they actually DO. I only mention the mailing of the document versus having to pick it up in person because it is one of the examples of an obvious harassment where there is absolutely no rational argument re "public safety" or "security" of any kind that withstands the slightest scrutiny.

3 Actually 98% of the rest of the US does no do this, Most states with a registration requirement require a trip to the police station with the firearm to register it. (98% would mean only Hawaii requires it)
Really? Could you please list those jurisdictions for me? Only Hawaii and the District of Columbia require registration of all firearms. Which jurisdictions, (other than Hawaii and the District of Columbia) requiring registration require that the owners bring the firearms to the police station? Please be specific. And please reference your source. I'm sure we all saw the long lines of hundreds of people in Connecticut to register their "assault weapons" (even though it's estimated that no more the 20% of owners registered). I'm sure we all noticed also that not one single person in those lines possessed an "assault weapon" while in line.

4 Compromise is not giving up your rights, Compromises is where BOTH SIDES give something to get something. You want no gun restrictions, no Registration ect........ They dont want us to have ANY guns. Lets meet in the middle, Your attitude of they have all the power so why fight it sucks, If thats what you truly believe then you should turn in any guns you own Because they have the power and thats what they want. Again you bring up mailing a permit. The law does not prohbit them from doing it, HPD does it (and again i will get back to it )
That's the lamest most absurd argument concerning "rights" as legally defined in the United States I've ever heard (well, other than "you have no rights"). You mean like Rosa Parks should have been satisfied with being able to sit at the back ot bus because at least they COMPROMISED and let her on the bus at all? You mean like gay people shouldn't have argued for the right to legally "marry" when they had been granted the COMPROMISE of legal "domestic partnerships"? You mean like women ought not to have advocated for the right to vote because the COMPROMISE had been granted that they could own some kinds of property? You have no even vaguely correct concept of what rights are. The list is endless, just go through the Bill of Rights and COMPROMISE everything away. The fact that you are willing to "compromise" your rights says everything about your views and strategy. No thanks.

The reason they have the power is because WE GRANT IT TO THEM. They are not a ruling class they dont get power because its theirs, They get it from the people. Filling  out testimony is nice and as you have seen recently does little, But did you follow up with a phone call and e-mail a letter saying Hey i submitted testimony did you read it, What is your stance on it. What are you going to do for me, The person who votes for you ? If every person whos a member on this bored filled at tesstimony and then called there Rep to ask if they took the time to read it things could change, But people are lazy and expect others to do the work.
I wouldn't be surprised if I've sent 10 times the emails and phone calls and letters and faxes that you have in past year. I could well be wrong. Maybe you've sent 10 times what I have. Some people are lazy, and perhaps that's one reason more people aren't "politically active". But one major reason is because their "activism" (at least from perspective of attempting to acquire our Second Amendment right in Hawaii) bears no fruit. Unless you count "they didn't pass that idiotic obviously unconstitutional psych evaluation every time you buy a gun bill this year" as being a "success". Most people have better things to do than waste their time engaging in activity that bears the same fruit as banging their head against a wall. If people saw that when they call and write and submit testimony in overwhelming numbers and then politicians actually respond to the public input by honoring the public's wishes... they might be motivated, but when what they see is overwhelming testimony that is ignored by the politicians, they are reasonable to conclude "What's the point? It doesn't make any difference". Who can blame them, it's a perfectly reasonable response. So you can rant all you want about "the people" having the power etc., but the reality is the system is rigged by those in power, and "the people" know it, shrug, and walk away. Well, except for some of the obstinate and obnoxious types.  :wave:

London808

Re: Laws i would like to see changed/fixed
« Reply #16 on: March 07, 2016, 08:10:47 AM »
I know that. The original poster's suggestions included that private sales go through FFLs as one of his goals.
I decided over a year ago to test the waters by attempting to get a response to suggesting changing an innocuous part of the unconstitutional Hawaii Second Amendment infringing laws by asking that the final stage of registration, picking up the finalized registration document,
Registration has been declared constitutional by SCOTUS, As such under law it is constitutional.  Withb regards to registration, You currently need to register the firearm, As you can only do that at the police station you need to go their becasue the registration need your signiture, There will never be a register by mail option, (The only compromise i can see would be register Via an FFL who verify identity)  With regards to mailing your permit, As it stand its a police department choice. If it was challenged constitutionally it wall would flat on its face. They will claim public safety, they are verifying the person picking up is the person whos permit it is.
If you believe differently let us know when you file your lawsuit


(one of my arguments was the enlarged carbon footprint when you included all the trips by all the gun registrants, since I know they love that anthropogenic global warming b*llsh*t...)
Stuff like this does little to help, Its not a vlaid argument and makes it look like your grasping at straws

 . What could be more "common sense" and "reasonable" than that? I wrote (and in some cases also called for follow-up) police chief Kubojiri, the (criminal) mayor Mr. Kenoi, the District Attorney, Mitch Roth, all the County Council members, my state senator Ruderman, and my state representative Onishi. As I've mentioned elsewhere, the chief's response was (after several more emails asking for an answer) "We've always done it that way". The only other response I got was from one council person's staff member asking for a more detailed clarification of the issue, and then I never heard from them again. I'm sure the authorities of the City and County of Honolulu are far more amenable to reason and common sense than here on the Big Island. Keep us informed as to how it goes.
Would love to see the letters/e-mails you sent and got back, Would give a better insite into what your dealing with and how to work with/around them.

I seriously doubt it. You don't think they smirk or snicker or shake their head or laugh out loud when they see another email or letter or phone call or petition or testimony that challenges their unchallengeable authority to impose irrational restrictions on people's rights? The only motive they have to change, other than a direct unambiguous court order, is due to political pressure, and we all know exactly how the politics here line up (and no likelihood of that ever changing in the foreseeable future).
So what your saying here is, We cant make changes so why try. If I had of listened to advice like that i would not be able to own a firearm right now, HPD had a bullshit policy that stooped me owning a gun, It even led them to seize my lalready legally owned firarm. So instead of sitting back and going oh well the system is corrupt is sued them in federal court and they ended up giving me everything i wanted and changing thire policy so they can never do the same thing to any one else. 


We have the power to make change as long as we get up of our hands and work together to do it, The changes to the law i have suggested (most of them) are very minor changes that have no effect on  public safety and are mostly just a procedural change. Am i expecting the laws to change tomorrow ? NO. But not talking about it will never achieve anything
"Mr. Roberts is a bit of a fanatic, he has previously sued HPD about gun registration issues." : Major Richard Robinson 2016

punaperson

Re: Laws i would like to see changed/fixed
« Reply #17 on: March 07, 2016, 08:18:33 AM »
We have the power to make change as long as we get up of our hands and work together to do it, The changes to the law i have suggested (most of them) are very minor changes that have no effect on  public safety and are mostly just a procedural change. Am i expecting the laws to change tomorrow ? NO. But not talking about it will never achieve anything
Keep me informed on how things change on all the issues you are working on.

Jl808

Re: Laws i would like to see changed/fixed
« Reply #18 on: March 07, 2016, 08:34:00 AM »
Keep up the good work London808, Q and punaperson.  I know you guys are doing what you can and we can all try to make things better.

I really like this thread.  Please keep the thread on-topic.  London808, let me know if you need help cleaning up the posts (without losing the discussion) so this thread will be easier to read.
I think, therefore I am armed.
NRA Life Patron member, HRA Life member, HiFiCo Life Member, HDF member

The United States Constitution © 1791. All Rights Reserved.

London808

Re: Laws i would like to see changed/fixed
« Reply #19 on: March 07, 2016, 08:37:58 AM »
Keep up the good work London808, Q and punaperson.  I know you guys are doing what you can and we can all try to make things better.

I really like this thread.  Please keep the thread on-topic.  London808, let me know if you need help cleaning up the posts (without losing the discussion) so this thread will be easier to read.

Its hard to respond sometimes without making the reply look like a personal attack, its never my intention and im sure its not the intention of others. But sometimes to have a conversation about something feelings will get hurt and we just need to get past it an move on.

Thanks for the offer of cleanup will let you know if needed,.
"Mr. Roberts is a bit of a fanatic, he has previously sued HPD about gun registration issues." : Major Richard Robinson 2016