1. So you want to pay an FFL a $20 or more fee for a private sale?
We don't do FFLs for private sales in Hawaii.
But I would pay that extra $25 to do the background check at the FFL, because its far more convenient than standing in line for 2 hours to apply for a permit, waiting 2 weeks, then standing in the same line again for another 30-60 minutes for a permit, picking up the firearm, then standing in line again for another 1-2 hours to register.
2. You don't think it hasn't already occurred to them that they could mail any documents, rather than having people have to make separate trips for each stage of the process? They know full well they could mail those without any security risk, they don't want to. Guess why.
I'm sure it has occurred to them, but its their mission to make it as hard as possible for us to obtain firearms, so as to discourage us from exercising our constitutional right.
The real question is: how many of the people on this forum have directly approached C&C officials to get this changed, or reached out to the media to make this an issue, or approached legislators? My assumption: less than a handful.
Make it a thorn in their side and eventually they will want to resolve it so we shut up.
3. You don't think it hasn't already occurred to them that they could have the FFL do all the registration paperwork, as they know full well is the case in 98% of the United States? They know full well they could have FFLs do that paperwork, they don't want to. Guess why.
I don't think that's the case. I think the FFLs just don't want to do the work, which is why they aren't pushing for doing the background checks. They could easily state that they would forward all the information to HPD firearms, which would actually make the firearms division's job easier because the FFL would be doing all the paperwork and background checks. All HPD would need to do is enter the info into their system, and send out the registration in the mail.
Just ask yourself: how many gun shops are leading the fight for 2a here in Hawaii? They sure love our business, but I didn't hear about any of the gunshops at any of the 2a rallies or testifying in opposition to the anti-firearm legislation.
4. That's why no amount of "common sense" "reasonable" "bargaining" and "compromise" (aka "willingly giving up our rights") will have any effect on the process as it exists. It's not amenable to reason. They know that. They know citizens have no leverage whatsoever (see ratios of testimony in recent committee hearings and the fact that the members then voted opposite the overwhelming citizen testimony position). They have no motive to change the process at all. It's just the way they like it (other than to make it even more difficult for a citizen to own any arm at all). Let's say if, and it's an enormously unlikely if, they tossed you a bone and allowed a permit to be mailed instead of picked up in person, you don't think that would be part of some calculated strategy? If they had any interest at all in reason or common sense being the basis of their policies they wouldn't have created the existing policies in the first place. Or do you really think they're just "stupid"?
The reason they keep doing what they do is because they know that most firearm owners in Hawaii don't have a spine to stand up to what is going on. They like to talk a big game on 2a about what they would do if confiscation was implemented, or what they would do if the Russians invade, yet when it comes time to fight for our 2a rights, they fade into the shadows with their endless excuses.
Now if the firearm community would just grow some balls and demonstrate how angry and serious we are, I'm sure it would have a profound effect on the way they do things. But take into account how many firearm owners there are in Hawaii, and how many of them are NOT apart of the HRA, NRA or any other national/state 2a organization.
The problem in Hawaii is that people don't give a shit, which is why we get walked over again and again.