If There Is No God, Murder Isn't Wrong (Read 49281 times)

Flapp_Jackson

Re: If There Is No God, Murder Isn't Wrong
« Reply #40 on: April 04, 2017, 01:30:12 PM »
http://blogforthelordjesuscurrentevents.com/2012/04/02/bart-ehrman-on-literacy-in-the-first-century/

Quote
If literacy rates were this low, we should have expected the initial movement of Jesus followers to have been largely an oral movement.  And, indeed, that’s just what the extant first-century Christian documents would lead us to believe.

There is a broad scholarly consensus – spanning the liberal-conservative spectrum – that we have seven letters of Paul that everyone can count on as genuinely his, and that they were written from 50 to 60 A.D.  When we read these documents today we recognize that they imply a great deal of information about Jesus that had already been exchanged orally, all around the eastern and northern Mediterranean Basin.

Think of it: 15-20 years of history without a written record.  Yet there is no hint of misunderstanding about the main points of the information about Jesus that had been exchanged.  See most notably 1 Corinthians 15:3-7.
The reasonable man adapts himself to the world;
the unreasonable one persists in trying to adapt the world to himself.
Therefore, all progress depends on the unreasonable man.
-- George Bernard Shaw

drck1000

Re: If There Is No God, Murder Isn't Wrong
« Reply #41 on: April 04, 2017, 01:33:30 PM »
Dude. . . where's the facepalm smiley. . .

Disclaimer here.  Another agnostic.  Raised Buddist, went to Jesuit Unversity.  Dunno how, but somehow that equals agnostic.  Anyways, that makes me no expert on religion, by any means.

I think I know what you're getting at.  And I believe it is books on religion DOCUMENT teachings of said religion.  They are NOT the basis of religion.  The basis of religion is MUCH more than the pages containing DOCUMENTATION of the religion.  Maybe you believe that is semantics, but perhaps something fundamental here that is causing some of the disconnect.  [benefit of doubt level = high]

Anyways, look up theories (some say conspiracies) about different versions of the bibles, gospels, etc.  I'd have to look up the opinions again (not using the word fact here), but if I recall correctly, many were second, third, etc hand documentation of spoken words that in many cases were passed on through many years.  Try the exercise where you have 10 people line up and send a verbal message down the chain and see how different the message is when it reaches the other end. . .

Inspector

Re: If There Is No God, Murder Isn't Wrong
« Reply #42 on: April 04, 2017, 02:50:59 PM »
Are you telling me everything written in the bible is false?  That people don't use that as a tool for worship or something to cite in their beliefs?  As i said previously,  religious books are the basis of most religions.  They are used as a baseline.  Picking and choosing cherry picked stuff that you like should be an insult on said religion.
SCIENCE THAT CAN’T BE QUESTIONED IS PROPAGANDA!!!

Inspector

Re: If There Is No God, Murder Isn't Wrong
« Reply #43 on: April 04, 2017, 02:57:30 PM »
Dude. . . where's the facepalm smiley. . .

SCIENCE THAT CAN’T BE QUESTIONED IS PROPAGANDA!!!

omnigun

Re: If There Is No God, Murder Isn't Wrong
« Reply #44 on: April 04, 2017, 04:17:18 PM »
http://blogforthelordjesuscurrentevents.com/2012/04/02/bart-ehrman-on-literacy-in-the-first-century/

I get some of your points, I may have not been too specific. I am focusing more on modern times. The difference is the book represents the religion currently.  In more modern times when literacy has been more developed people learned from either the book or a pastor or someone who could read teaching them from the book.  In modern times religion is ALOT less orally spread.  Even over time something that is oral its really hard to keep consistency.  Much like the game where you tell a phrase to someone and keep passing it on and comparing the starting and ending phrase.  For this argument I am using the book as the physical representative model.  As oral only words is something that is hard to quote.

read other reply for continuation and expansion.
« Last Edit: April 04, 2017, 04:24:12 PM by omnigun »

PeaShooter

Re: If There Is No God, Murder Isn't Wrong
« Reply #45 on: April 04, 2017, 04:21:49 PM »
I didn't read much of the bickering but I don't see why a non-religious person can't discuss the qualities of religion. In fact I might say the opposite is true: only a non-religious person can possibly engage in such discussion rationally and objectively. Because a religious person is someone who has chosen to steadfastly believe in certain things without any factual proof, thereby proving they are irrational at least in regard to certain topics.

omnigun

Re: If There Is No God, Murder Isn't Wrong
« Reply #46 on: April 04, 2017, 04:22:07 PM »
Dude. . . where's the facepalm smiley. . .

Disclaimer here.  Another agnostic.  Raised Buddist, went to Jesuit Unversity.  Dunno how, but somehow that equals agnostic.  Anyways, that makes me no expert on religion, by any means.

I think I know what you're getting at.  And I believe it is books on religion DOCUMENT teachings of said religion.  They are NOT the basis of religion.  The basis of religion is MUCH more than the pages containing DOCUMENTATION of the religion.  Maybe you believe that is semantics, but perhaps something fundamental here that is causing some of the disconnect.  [benefit of doubt level = high]

Anyways, look up theories (some say conspiracies) about different versions of the bibles, gospels, etc.  I'd have to look up the opinions again (not using the word fact here), but if I recall correctly, many were second, third, etc hand documentation of spoken words that in many cases were passed on through many years.  Try the exercise where you have 10 people line up and send a verbal message down the chain and see how different the message is when it reaches the other end. . .

In modern times AKA this century.  Christians and many other religions use the book as a BASIS of their religion.  If they don't agree with what it says they should change it.  But someone learning a religion this year this second their main source of information for that religion will be their religious book. There is not some 20 generation priest that his only knowledge is from oral communications.  In bible studies etc it all references the book.  Since it all references the book I equate that to that being the basis of the religion. Anyone on this forum has learned their religion mostly from a book.  That's a simple fact. Their BASIS of their current religious beliefs is a book. Their religion may not have started off like that but that is what the current religion is.

This brings to the cherry picking of stuff to teach but that's a little different argument.

Flapp_Jackson

Re: If There Is No God, Murder Isn't Wrong
« Reply #47 on: April 04, 2017, 04:24:33 PM »
I get some of your points, I may have not been too specific.  The difference is the book represents the religion.  In more modern times when literacy has been more developed people learned from either the book or a pastor or someone who could read teaching them from the book.  In modern times religion is ALOT less orally spread.  Even over time something that is oral its really hard to keep consistency.  Much like the game where you tell a phrase to someone and keep passing it on and comparing the starting and ending phrase.  For this argument I am using the book as the physical representative model.  As oral only words is something that is hard to quote.

That's not what you said.  You stated that religion is based on writings.  That means religion is founded on the writings, and that the writings must have existed before the religion.

Blather all you want, but if you say something that's demonstrably false, you will be called out on it.

And, please don't attempt to lecture me on the effects of literacy on religion, when it was I who had to educate you on that point. 

I am, after all, an academic at heart!
The reasonable man adapts himself to the world;
the unreasonable one persists in trying to adapt the world to himself.
Therefore, all progress depends on the unreasonable man.
-- George Bernard Shaw

omnigun

Re: If There Is No God, Murder Isn't Wrong
« Reply #48 on: April 04, 2017, 04:28:30 PM »
That's not what you said.  You stated that religion is based on writings.  That means religion is founded on the writings, and that the writings must have existed before the religion.

Blather all you want, but if you say something that's demonstrably false, you will be called out on it.

And, please don't attempt to lecture me on the effects of literacy on religion, when it was I who had to educate you on that point. 

I am, after all, an academic at heart!

You reply before I got to edit that I am talking about modern.  Other reply elaborates more on this topic.  Current religion is based on the book.  That's simple facts. How it started and how it evolved into writing is of little consequence. Its how it is right now, this second is what im citing. You are correct about calling me out when I didn't properly reference the time period that was my fault.  Other than that, nope...

omnigun

Re: If There Is No God, Murder Isn't Wrong
« Reply #49 on: April 04, 2017, 04:30:49 PM »
I didn't read much of the bickering but I don't see why a non-religious person can't discuss the qualities of religion. In fact I might say the opposite is true: only a non-religious person can possibly engage in such discussion rationally and objectively. Because a religious person is someone who has chosen to steadfastly believe in certain things without any factual proof, thereby proving they are irrational at least in regard to certain topics.

This  :thumbsup:

Inspector

Re: If There Is No God, Murder Isn't Wrong
« Reply #50 on: April 04, 2017, 04:47:31 PM »
Everything I learned about religion I learned from books, so must be that religion is based on books, right? 

As an aside, documentation of the "facts" is always at the discretion of the record keeper.  When I was consulting, when we had a meeting, my boss always said to the first to prepare and issue the minutes. That way, you have a level of control over what was said.  Same thing with documentation of spoken words. . .
Your boss sounds like the boss I had when I worked for Cisco Systems. Best boss I ever had.  :thumbsup: :thumbsup: :thumbsup:
SCIENCE THAT CAN’T BE QUESTIONED IS PROPAGANDA!!!

drck1000

Re: If There Is No God, Murder Isn't Wrong
« Reply #51 on: April 04, 2017, 04:57:48 PM »
In modern times AKA this century.  Christians and many other religions use the book as a BASIS of their religion.  If they don't agree with what it says they should change it.  But someone learning a religion this year this second their main source of information for that religion will be their religious book. There is not some 20 generation priest that his only knowledge is from oral communications.  In bible studies etc it all references the book.  Since it all references the book I equate that to that being the basis of the religion. Anyone on this forum has learned their religion mostly from a book.  That's a simple fact. Their BASIS of their current religious beliefs is a book. Their religion may not have started off like that but that is what the current religion is.

This brings to the cherry picking of stuff to teach but that's a little different argument.
So, but that line of thinking, current/modern religion is based on "the book". So then the basis of modern/current religion is different than from ancient religion? Since the current/modern version of the book didn't exist back then...

Again, the basis or foundation of a religion is very much more than any book. It's like saying you need to have a book to have beliefs. Yes, books are one very common form to teach religion, but you can very much have religion, even current modern religion, without any book. In fact, I would argue that any modern religion transcends any book about that religion.

Don't like religion, so they should change written word about it? Mmmmkay...


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

Inspector

Re: If There Is No God, Murder Isn't Wrong
« Reply #52 on: April 04, 2017, 05:13:59 PM »
Dude. . . where's the facepalm smiley. . .

Disclaimer here.  Another agnostic.  Raised Buddist, went to Jesuit Unversity.  Dunno how, but somehow that equals agnostic.  Anyways, that makes me no expert on religion, by any means.

I think I know what you're getting at.  And I believe it is books on religion DOCUMENT teachings of said religion.  They are NOT the basis of religion.  The basis of religion is MUCH more than the pages containing DOCUMENTATION of the religion.  Maybe you believe that is semantics, but perhaps something fundamental here that is causing some of the disconnect.  [benefit of doubt level = high]

Anyways, look up theories (some say conspiracies) about different versions of the bibles, gospels, etc.  I'd have to look up the opinions again (not using the word fact here), but if I recall correctly, many were second, third, etc hand documentation of spoken words that in many cases were passed on through many years.  Try the exercise where you have 10 people line up and send a verbal message down the chain and see how different the message is when it reaches the other end. . .
I was raised without any religion in the home. I was told that I am a particular religion but no religion was ever taught to me. My parents never took me to a place of worship of any type. When the religious holidays came around I was never taught the meaning of the religious aspect of the special day(s). Yet my parents used to try and control myself and my brothers using religion as the reason/excuse. Which in my particular case taught me to hate religion.

Both of my brothers ended up both being very religious even though they are different religions. I on the other hand have mellowed out in my old age and have come to realize that there is a place in our world/society for peaceful religions. I personally still despise religion for myself but I have learned to understand what real deep meaningful faith is all about from my family. Which just secures my belief that religion is not for me. I probably should be an angry Aetheist attacking every religious persons beliefs (Like the Onmipotent One) but I have decided that none of this is worth my getting worked up over.
SCIENCE THAT CAN’T BE QUESTIONED IS PROPAGANDA!!!

omnigun

Re: If There Is No God, Murder Isn't Wrong
« Reply #53 on: April 04, 2017, 10:43:51 PM »
So, but that line of thinking, current/modern religion is based on "the book". So then the basis of modern/current religion is different than from ancient religion? Since the current/modern version of the book didn't exist back then...

Again, the basis or foundation of a religion is very much more than any book. It's like saying you need to have a book to have beliefs. Yes, books are one very common form to teach religion, but you can very much have religion, even current modern religion, without any book. In fact, I would argue that any modern religion transcends any book about that religion.

Don't like religion, so they should change written word about it? Mmmmkay...


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

Yes in a sense with each generation religion changes.  Its never taught exactly the same every time.  But in the end the book is used as an basis.   I'm not saying its everything but its the foundation on which most religions are based on.  A written guide per say.  When you start "transcending" the book that brings up factions and cults and a bunch of other stuff that can spring off.  Look at Mormons as a recent example. Changing or editing the book is something that is done sometimes, think new testament.  In the end religion is just a tool used to control the masses and endow "morals" on people.  People fear the after life so it reassures them and sometimes gives them purpose.  But notice whenever a semi modern religion surfaces etc, they normally have a "book" that is the foundation of it.  Even Mormons who's religion is younger than the USA is of age if I remember correctly has a book.

Flapp_Jackson

Re: If There Is No God, Murder Isn't Wrong
« Reply #54 on: April 04, 2017, 11:14:08 PM »
Yes in a sense with each generation religion changes.  Its never taught exactly the same every time.  But in the end the book is used as an basis.   I'm not saying its everything but its the foundation on which most religions are based on.  A written guide per say.  When you start "transcending" the book that brings up factions and cults and a bunch of other stuff that can spring off.  Look at Mormons as a recent example. Changing or editing the book is something that is done sometimes, think new testament.  In the end religion is just a tool used to control the masses and endow "morals" on people.  People fear the after life so it reassures them and sometimes gives them purpose.  But notice whenever a semi modern religion surfaces etc, they normally have a "book" that is the foundation of it.  Even Mormons who's religion is younger than the USA is of age if I remember correctly has a book.

Are you also a Sociologist and Anthropologist at heart?  Some of the crap you're spewing here is not even close to the truth.  You should be embarrassed to be spending so much time BS-ing on a topic you should have ZERO interest in.

It always amazes me how atheists and agnostics use the phrase "Christians are trying to  shove their religion down everyone's throats," when it's the non-believers who become unhinged arguing against religion!

The only thing worse than a self-proclaimed agnostic discussing religion is a vegan at Ruby Tuesdays!!
The reasonable man adapts himself to the world;
the unreasonable one persists in trying to adapt the world to himself.
Therefore, all progress depends on the unreasonable man.
-- George Bernard Shaw

Flapp_Jackson

Re: If There Is No God, Murder Isn't Wrong
« Reply #55 on: April 05, 2017, 12:25:11 AM »
Yes in a sense with each generation religion changes.  Its never taught exactly the same every time. 
Please cite where you got this "fact".  It's amazing that the New Testament is just over 2,000 years old, and the Old Testament over 500 more years before Christ walked the Earth.  That a LOT of generations causing changes to "the religion".   I'm curious what changes can be tracked from generation to generation.  Surely you have a list.

But in the end the book is used as an basis.   I'm not saying its everything but its the foundation on which most religions are based on.  A written guide per say.  When you start "transcending" the book that brings up factions and cults and a bunch of other stuff that can spring off. 
You're basically arguing the chicken and the egg, but ignoring the fact we know the answer.  You've morphed your statement from "All religion is based on a book" to "the book is used now as a basis".  In reality, the book is a recording of the teachings of the religion.  The religion would exist without the book, just as it became a religion before the book existed and before most people could read.  That's why people attended church services -- to learn from the religious leaders.  Arguing  to try and make your original wrong statement correct is fruitless.  Religious text is not the religion.  The lessons taught in the words captured in them comprise the belief system.  The fact there is a book is incidental.   Whether oral, or written or put to music as song, as long as the lessons are taught, the medium is irrelevant to the existence of the religion.

Look at Mormons as a recent example. Changing or editing the book is something that is done sometimes, think new testament. 
If you look closely at your example, you'll notice they did not CHANGE the original writings.  The previous denominations/churches did not change.  The Mormons created a new religion borrowing the Old Testament from Catholic teachings.  Latter Day Saints was a movement, not an alteration of an existing denomination.  The "meat" of the LDS movement was original, not changed scripture.  Maybe you should research religion before providing analysis that's inaccurate.

In the end religion is just a tool used to control the masses and endow "morals" on people.
No, it is not JUST that!  It is a support system both physically and spiritually for people.  Churches have always been the cornerstone of charities.  It's a refuge for giving comfort and guidance.  It offers a feeling that life has meaning, and that the end of life is not the end.  It offers a belonging in a world that often makes us feel alone.  It provides a sense of peace and strength knowing your actions are right. 

It's not a universal truth that religion is used by governments to control the masses.  Some religions, like Christianity, are quashed by governments because they teach of a higher power than government, of freedom from worldly oppression, and of a reward in the afterlife.  It's very difficult to control someone who believes they are being tested by God and will one day be rewarded.  The Romans tried to kill Christians in fights with lions and gladiators.  Muslims tried/are trying to kill all Jews and Christians.  Hitler tried to exterminate the Jews.  None of that was an attempt to use religion as a control mechanism.  It's an attempt to remove those who care more about their immortal souls than anything the government can do.

People fear the after life so it reassures them and sometimes gives them purpose.  But notice whenever a semi modern religion surfaces etc, they normally have a "book" that is the foundation of it.  Even Mormons who's religion is younger than the USA is of age if I remember correctly has a book.
People fear many things.  What motivates some will not motivate others.  For some, giving over control of their lives to God takes the stress of living away,. at least when it comes to ethics, morals, and decisions related to them.

I've never heard of a "semi-modern religion."  Can you point me to the book that defines that academic term, Mr. Agnostic?
   

The reasonable man adapts himself to the world;
the unreasonable one persists in trying to adapt the world to himself.
Therefore, all progress depends on the unreasonable man.
-- George Bernard Shaw

Heavies

Re: If There Is No God, Murder Isn't Wrong
« Reply #56 on: April 05, 2017, 02:18:21 AM »
I was raised without any religion in the home. I was told that I am a particular religion but no religion was ever taught to me. My parents never took me to a place of worship of any type. When the religious holidays came around I was never taught the meaning of the religious aspect of the special day(s). Yet my parents used to try and control myself and my brothers using religion as the reason/excuse. Which in my particular case taught me to hate religion.

Both of my brothers ended up both being very religious even though they are different religions. I on the other hand have mellowed out in my old age and have come to realize that there is a place in our world/society for peaceful religions. I personally still despise religion for myself but I have learned to understand what real deep meaningful faith is all about from my family. Which just secures my belief that religion is not for me. I probably should be an angry Aetheist attacking every religious persons beliefs (Like the Onmipotent One) but I have decided that none of this is worth my getting worked up over.
Background:  I do not attend Church regularly, as I do not trust man's church.  I do believe in Jesus Christ as my savior and God as the creator, I try to live my life as such.

I am religious.  I went to a Christian school all my young life, and have been educated in that way.  However, I was brought up in a multi cultural and multi religion family.  I can respect and honor those with differing beliefs, and even those who do not hold religious beliefs. 

The basic point of the video is BASIC HUMAN MORALS AND DECENCY.   Judaeo-Christian system teaches this, to an extent, and so does many other religions, and so does those who may not hold to any religion.  The point is that many have faltered from those BASIC HUMAN MORALS AND DECENCY.  We live in an America that has no respect for life, no respect for private property, no respect for liberty. 

Unless that changes, where will we be?  One can argue the idiocies of the fine points, but we are still left with the brutal fact. 

Inspector

Re: If There Is No God, Murder Isn't Wrong
« Reply #57 on: April 05, 2017, 06:08:08 AM »
Background:  I do not attend Church regularly, as I do not trust man's church.  I do believe in Jesus Christ as my savior and God as the creator, I try to live my life as such.

I am religious.  I went to a Christian school all my young life, and have been educated in that way.  However, I was brought up in a multi cultural and multi religion family.  I can respect and honor those with differing beliefs, and even those who do not hold religious beliefs. 

The basic point of the video is BASIC HUMAN MORALS AND DECENCY.   Judaeo-Christian system teaches this, to an extent, and so does many other religions, and so does those who may not hold to any religion.  The point is that many have faltered from those BASIC HUMAN MORALS AND DECENCY.  We live in an America that has no respect for life, no respect for private property, no respect for liberty. 

Unless that changes, where will we be?  One can argue the idiocies of the fine points, but we are still left with the brutal fact.
Thanks for sharing that, B.

Two big things I took away from what you said here is about basic human morals and decency. And of course respect for those who do not believe the same as we do. Or even respect for those that believe the same as we do. Respect for life, private property and liberty. It's sad that I don't see much of that any more.
SCIENCE THAT CAN’T BE QUESTIONED IS PROPAGANDA!!!

omnigun

Re: If There Is No God, Murder Isn't Wrong
« Reply #58 on: April 05, 2017, 06:23:57 AM »
Background:  I do not attend Church regularly, as I do not trust man's church.  I do believe in Jesus Christ as my savior and God as the creator, I try to live my life as such.

I am religious.  I went to a Christian school all my young life, and have been educated in that way.  However, I was brought up in a multi cultural and multi religion family.  I can respect and honor those with differing beliefs, and even those who do not hold religious beliefs. 

The basic point of the video is BASIC HUMAN MORALS AND DECENCY.   Judaeo-Christian system teaches this, to an extent, and so does many other religions, and so does those who may not hold to any religion.  The point is that many have faltered from those BASIC HUMAN MORALS AND DECENCY.  We live in an America that has no respect for life, no respect for private property, no respect for liberty. 

Unless that changes, where will we be?  One can argue the idiocies of the fine points, but we are still left with the brutal fact.

America is about FREEDOM, this is the biggest thing we have.  I don't care what people believe in the end the point of this is discussion.  But I do have to disagree with "We live in an America that has no respect for life, no respect for private property, no respect for liberty. ".   I strongly believe in the right to choice.  Its your body you get to choose, its about freedom of decision if you want to get an abortion.  Just as much as its about your freedom to choose to believe in religion. 
« Last Edit: April 05, 2017, 06:38:15 AM by omnigun »

omnigun

Re: If There Is No God, Murder Isn't Wrong
« Reply #59 on: April 05, 2017, 06:31:21 AM »
Are you also a Sociologist and Anthropologist at heart?  Some of the crap you're spewing here is not even close to the truth.  You should be embarrassed to be spending so much time BS-ing on a topic you should have ZERO interest in.

It always amazes me how atheists and agnostics use the phrase "Christians are trying to  shove their religion down everyone's throats," when it's the non-believers who become unhinged arguing against religion!

The only thing worse than a self-proclaimed agnostic discussing religion is a vegan at Ruby Tuesdays!!

I don't believe I have ever said I had ZERO interest in religion.  I just said I'm agnostic.  The discussion interests me its why I'm here...

Funny you say that than heavies comment right after.  Its actually many Christians that are shoving their religion down many of Americas throats.  This is why I'm an independent and not fully republican.  The right to choice, the right to believe, these are all FREEDOM based.  You can do what you want to your body, its yours, abortion is fine.  If you are dieing and want to kill yourself its your life why is someone preventing that based on their religious beliefs?  If you want to smoke pot in the privacy of your home, do what you want.  If you want to own firearms, sure.  You want ISP's to not spy and sell your DATA, yes.  The whole point of this discussion is the effects of "religious morality"  on America.   That's the negatives of "religious morality" as some religions have different but similar sets of "morality".   America should be completely neutral to religion.  You can believe what you want, when you want.  But don't infringe on others rights.  That's the basics of freedom.
« Last Edit: April 05, 2017, 06:41:26 AM by omnigun »