Weapons for Airline Travel (Read 23431 times)

zippz

Re: Weapons for Airline Travel
« Reply #20 on: May 21, 2017, 05:13:38 PM »
Get a big dog and declare it as a service animal or carry a letter of recommendation from HPD. Authorized Carry Dog. ACD.

Seems like you can bring any animal aboard nowadays. 

ren

Re: Weapons for Airline Travel
« Reply #21 on: May 21, 2017, 06:00:15 PM »
Seems like you can bring any animal aboard nowadays.
Yeah imagine the poor passenger next to the person with a pig. Where would it use the bathroom?
None of those animals would help in a hijacking.

However...

Deeds Not Words

Colt808

Re: Weapons for Airline Travel
« Reply #22 on: May 22, 2017, 05:24:46 AM »
I just timed how long it would take to reach in my carry on bag, pull out a sock and drop the coin purse in my pocket into it.  9 seconds.  If questioned, you could say you saw this guy acting weird so you copied MacGyver and made your improvised weapon just in case.  A tactical flashlight with a crenellated bezel also has a legitimate use so they cannot say anything there.
That is not what you said in your post. Nevertheless, an improvised weapon is still a weapon and illegal. Carrying a fanny pack or man purse would keep you on the right side of the law and if it's something with a quick release buckle way faster than 9 seconds.

Quote
when you say stick, are you referring to a cane?  I agree with you that a sap or cane is not a real good extremely close quarter weapon, but a kubotan certainly is and so is a tactical flashlight or the CS Pocket Shark or my modified Sharpie.  A hit in the temple from one of these could easily be lethal and a strike in the throat or eye will end the fight.  A kubotan type weapon can easily break a jaw or hand or get you out of a RNC pretty easily.
Again...A stick/kubotan or modified sharpie would be legally questionable. Anything improvised or modified can raise questions.

I think a lot of some people's concerns about the legality of these items are unfounded.  Whether anyone decides to carry something or not is purely a personal choice, but being of Medicare age, I like to try and even up the odds a bit if I ever get into a physical confrontation with someone who will most likely be a lot younger and stronger
The concerns are not unfounded at all. The legality (or illegality in this case) of bringing a weapon aboard an aircraft is clear. If you're caught, you get the cuffs and that's all there is to it. People can argue over intent and types weapons, etc....But none of that matters when you're cooling your heels in some hoosegow waiting for your day in court. This is free legal advice because I wouldn't want you spending time dealing with that at your age.


I fly 5 or 6 times a month and I always have my stainless steel Parker classic pen, a flashlight (crenellated bezel), and keys on me...no weapons.


Reason obeys itself; and ignorance submits to whatever is dictated to it. ~Thomas Paine


And I still see stupid people.

changemyoil66

Re: Weapons for Airline Travel
« Reply #23 on: May 22, 2017, 08:54:55 AM »
I had the convo with my wife that if anyone goes aloha snackbar on the plane to help me fight.  Because the bystander affect would probably take place ( no one acts because they think someone else will).  I told her that I will be the human shield and if she can, kick some ass while I'm being stabbed, hit, or what ever. 

The plane is going down anyways so why not fight.

drck1000

Re: Weapons for Airline Travel
« Reply #24 on: May 22, 2017, 09:26:33 AM »
I flew to California with a knife without realizing it, went through X-ray and everything. only found out about it on the way back when they did catch it.
I've had that happen to me at least once.  Didn't realize that it was in my carry on until return trip.  Found it at one of the checkpoints after bags were already checked in and gone.  Had to mail the utility tool/knife back to myself.  Come to think of it, I haven't seen one of those mailing bins in a while. 

London808

Re: Weapons for Airline Travel
« Reply #25 on: May 22, 2017, 09:52:12 AM »
I've had that happen to me at least once.  Didn't realize that it was in my carry on until return trip.  Found it at one of the checkpoints after bags were already checked in and gone.  Had to mail the utility tool/knife back to myself.  Come to think of it, I haven't seen one of those mailing bins in a while.

And you wont, The airports make to much money selling the knifes in bulk
"Mr. Roberts is a bit of a fanatic, he has previously sued HPD about gun registration issues." : Major Richard Robinson 2016

drck1000

Re: Weapons for Airline Travel
« Reply #26 on: May 22, 2017, 09:57:30 AM »
And you wont, The airports make to much money selling the knifes in bulk
They got rid of those bins?  I think this was when I was on my way back home from SF or Seattle.  I thought I saw those self mailing bins somewhere recently, maybe it was DFW.  But not sure. 

RSN172

Re: Weapons for Airline Travel
« Reply #27 on: May 22, 2017, 11:27:26 AM »
That is not what you said in your post. Nevertheless, an improvised weapon is still a weapon and illegal. Carrying a fanny pack or man purse would keep you on the right side of the law and if it's something with a quick release buckle way faster than 9 seconds.
Again...A stick/kubotan or modified sharpie would be legally questionable. Anything improvised or modified can raise questions.
The concerns are not unfounded at all. The legality (or illegality in this case) of bringing a weapon aboard an aircraft is clear. If you're caught, you get the cuffs and that's all there is to it. People can argue over intent and types weapons, etc....But none of that matters when you're cooling your heels in some hoosegow waiting for your day in court. This is free legal advice because I wouldn't want you spending time dealing with that at your age.


I fly 5 or 6 times a month and I always have my stainless steel Parker classic pen, a flashlight (crenellated bezel), and keys on me...no weapons.
I timed how long it would take when you referred to assembling a weapon, like I was having to spend several minutes or using a tool to put something together.  As far as the fanny pack goes, what are you going to put in it for weight? Not your cell phone.  If you only have a lot of coins, the same reasonng you are using for a coin purse in a sock would also apply.  Would you consider a CS Pocket Shark illegal since it is modified and marketed as a defense weapon?  In a later post I also showed the Surefire flashlight I will be carrying to replace the one I was using previously since it is designed for striking with tbe back end as well as the front.  Did you ever see how strong your Parker pen is?  It might break in half and stab you in the hand.  I wouldn't count on that.  I have that same pen.  I fly quite often, not as much as you, but enough to be a Pualani Gold member on Hawaiian, (30 flights or more a year)

I genuinely appreciate all the concerns that not only you, but everyone may have had.  I may just carry my Surefire and an unmodified Sharpie Pro in the future.  My only concern would be the cap coming off if not glued on.
Happily living in Puna

macsak

Re: Weapons for Airline Travel
« Reply #28 on: May 22, 2017, 11:36:16 AM »
I timed how long it would take when you referred to assembling a weapon, like I was having to spend several minutes or using a tool to put something together.  As far as the fanny pack goes, what are you going to put in it for weight? Not your cell phone.  If you only have a lot of coins, the same reasonng you are using for a coin purse in a sock would also apply.  Would you consider a CS Pocket Shark illegal since it is modified and marketed as a defense weapon?  In a later post I also showed the Surefire flashlight I will be carrying to replace the one I was using previously since it is designed for striking with tbe back end as well as the front.  Did you ever see how strong your Parker pen is?  It might break in half and stab you in the hand.  I wouldn't count on that.  I have that same pen.  I fly quite often, not as much as you, but enough to be a Pualani Gold member on Hawaiian, (30 flights or more a year)

I genuinely appreciate all the concerns that not only you, but everyone may have had.  I may just carry my Surefire and an unmodified Sharpie Pro in the future.  My only concern would be the cap coming off if not glued on.

good plan, the flashlight will serve you well
your modified sharpie pro is no longer a pen, you stated it was out of ink, and you added jb weld for weight and stated that the cap is now unable to be removed
what purpose does it serve other than a weapon?
pocket decoration, i guess

Colt808

Re: Weapons for Airline Travel
« Reply #29 on: May 22, 2017, 11:43:47 PM »
I timed how long it would take when you referred to assembling a weapon, like I was having to spend several minutes or using a tool to put something together.  As far as the fanny pack goes, what are you going to put in it for weight? Not your cell phone.  If you only have a lot of coins, the same reasonng you are using for a coin purse in a sock would also apply.  Would you consider a CS Pocket Shark illegal since it is modified and marketed as a defense weapon?  In a later post I also showed the Surefire flashlight I will be carrying to replace the one I was using previously since it is designed for striking with tbe back end as well as the front.  Did you ever see how strong your Parker pen is?  It might break in half and stab you in the hand.  I wouldn't count on that.  I have that same pen.  I fly quite often, not as much as you, but enough to be a Pualani Gold member on Hawaiian, (30 flights or more a year)

I genuinely appreciate all the concerns that not only you, but everyone may have had.  I may just carry my Surefire and an unmodified Sharpie Pro in the future.  My only concern would be the cap coming off if not glued on.
The time it takes was not the issue being pointed out. It's more about items being assembled/fashioned/combined to create a weapon.

As for the fanny pack? Put your coin pouch in it or 2 rolls of quarters (which is about 16oz). It really doesn't matter the point being made was, unlike a sock full of coins, storing things is a legitimate purpose of fanny pack.

The CS Pocket Shark is not modified. It's designed as a rugged marker.

I've rarely been without my Parker classic for almost 30 years. And because I always have it, I've used it for some stupid things like to turn a the chuck key for my drill, disassemble my Mini-14 and punch a pilot hole in sheet rock.  It's scuffed up and has had the pocket clip replaced/re-soldered 4 or 5 times but the barrel is straight and true. So I know it's pretty tough.


Whether one carries a flashlight, bag/purse full of coins, or a quality writing instrument....avoid modified items and the term "weapon" so you'll remain unquestionably legal.
Reason obeys itself; and ignorance submits to whatever is dictated to it. ~Thomas Paine


And I still see stupid people.

RSN172

Re: Weapons for Airline Travel
« Reply #30 on: May 23, 2017, 06:01:26 AM »
Regardless of what each person's choice would or will be, my main point is carry something that you can use to defend yourself with effectively even when flying.  My first choice is the tactical flashlight because of its usefulness everyday and in an emergency.
Happily living in Puna

davgdavg

Re: Weapons for Airline Travel
« Reply #31 on: May 23, 2017, 11:01:02 AM »
I respectively disagree with the basic prowess of this. This is a defensive situation, and should be thought of as such.
Lets think about this realistically. Most likely scenario is a knife/razor/etc.

Swinging a flashlight or sack of coins for a knockout blow requires more room than any plane I've ever been on allows for, even if you get the chance. I guess you could go over the top and hit them on the top of the head, but this isn't the movies and that kind of strike isn't as good as one to the face, jaw, or temple. You're also probably going to give up the element of surprise. The priority is neutralize the weapon first if possible, not the person. Once that's done you have a huge advantage in numbers. Incapacitating someone who is willing to die to kill others with a pen is also not very likely.

Really, the only realistic course of action is to restrain, get rid of their weapon, and choke out and/or having other people jump in. Maybe you can grab their hair and knee to the head which will incapacitate most people, but that's still relying on good luck.

Chances are, you're going to be grappling and for sure playing dirty. This isn't even mma, this is life vs death anything goes. I'd rather bite a mf on the jugular and gouge their eyes out than try for a perfect stab with a stupid pen.

Therefore, what you want to have is as much thick leather on as possible. Leather gloves for sure. Gloves and a jacket with the collar popped with some sort of hat if possible. You're most likely not going to get away unscathed, sorry. In a scuffle with someone with a knife on a crowded plane, somebody is probably gonna get cut. So its about minimizing the chance that that cut disables you. You need to disable the guy(s) long enough to take advantage of your advantage: numbers. If you can grab their knife or hands, fights over.

Anyhow, my .02 :shaka:

« Last Edit: May 23, 2017, 11:14:12 AM by davgdavg »

RSN172

Re: Weapons for Airline Travel
« Reply #32 on: May 23, 2017, 06:08:56 PM »
I am pretty sure I can take someone out with a strike from tactical flashlight.  You don't swing it, you either thrust with it like you would with a knife, or hammer fist.  A good hit in the temple, just below the ear, eye, nose, jaw or throat and the fight is over.  It can eadily break bones in a hand or a collar bone and may be even a rib.  I do agree that any pen, unless it is a tactical.pen, is not strong enough to use in a fight, unless you got nothing else..  Regarding tbe amount of space needed, if I hit someone anywhere in the head from even one foot away with a tac light, they will be shaken enough for me to deliver a follow up blow because they will not recover from that first hit in a quarter of a second.
Happily living in Puna

drck1000

Re: Weapons for Airline Travel
« Reply #33 on: May 24, 2017, 08:14:07 AM »
I am pretty sure I can take someone out with a strike from tactical flashlight.  You don't swing it, you either thrust with it like you would with a knife, or hammer fist.  A good hit in the temple, just below the ear, eye, nose, jaw or throat and the fight is over.  It can eadily break bones in a hand or a collar bone and may be even a rib.  I do agree that any pen, unless it is a tactical.pen, is not strong enough to use in a fight, unless you got nothing else..  Regarding tbe amount of space needed, if I hit someone anywhere in the head from even one foot away with a tac light, they will be shaken enough for me to deliver a follow up blow because they will not recover from that first hit in a quarter of a second.
Just curious, but what kind of scenario are you envisioning here?  As in someone attacking you? 

Understand that you're trying to be prepared to defend yourself in any case, as in trying to be prepared for whatever may happen.  But what I envision in your post above is say 1) you will have the awareness that this guy is a threat and 2) the wherewithal to have whatever defensive implement that you will have ready to go. 

Things happen quickly and while I wouldn't discount anyone's desire to be prepared to defend themselves, I would envision likely scenarios somewhat like mentioned above with having to restrain the person first.  You are just going to have to try to fend off that person as best you can hand-to-hand.  That is assuming they are attacking you.  I am not saying hope for help to come, but that is what I envision happening.

What you mention above sounds move offensive than defensive, as in you get to choose the start of the engagement.  Have the improvised item ready and striking when you have opportunity.  Many times in a defensive situation, you're just going to find yourself in the middle of it and at that point, you're already engaged with the person.  Yeah, if I had a solid item like a light or other item in my hand, that would help with the effectiveness of the blow, but I don't see that as realistic. 

If you're thinking of a scenario like 9/11, Flight 93 where passengers are fighting back against a person or group of people.  Like that flight recently where the guy has to be duct taped to his seat.  I can see what you mentioned above as likely. 

I have been jabbed with that tactical pen thingy as well as training blades and they are effective for sure.  A jab with one of those things to the ribs definitely gets my attention. 

RSN172

Re: Weapons for Airline Travel
« Reply #34 on: May 24, 2017, 05:53:05 PM »

What you mention above sounds move offensive than defensive, as in you get to choose the start of the engagement.  Have the improvised item ready and striking when you have opportunity.  Many times in a defensive situation, you're just going to find yourself in the middle of it and at that point, you're already engaged with the person.  Yeah, if I had a solid item like a light or other item in my hand, that would help with the effectiveness of the blow, but I don't see that as realistic. 


You may think I'm paranoid but I am in condition yellow when in public.  I look at everybody to see what they are carrying, if they have a folder in their pocket etc.  If in an elevator and someone else comes in, my hand is on the handle of the fixed blade I carry in the tip up position on my belt.  Same thing if walking in a parking lot and I am passing someone and I look back as soon as we pass.  Don't want someone playing the knock out game with me.

If you perceive a threat from someone you need to strike first.  Wait for them to hit first and you will lose 80% of the time.  So yeah, I generally will have a weapon in my hand ready to go and that is not unrealistic with me.
Happily living in Puna

drck1000

Re: Weapons for Airline Travel
« Reply #35 on: May 24, 2017, 06:10:28 PM »
You may think I'm paranoid but I am in condition yellow when in public.  I look at everybody to see what they are carrying, if they have a folder in their pocket etc.  If in an elevator and someone else comes in, my hand is on the handle of the fixed blade I carry in the tip up position on my belt.  Same thing if walking in a parking lot and I am passing someone and I look back as soon as we pass.  Don't want someone playing the knock out game with me.

If you perceive a threat from someone you need to strike first.  Wait for them to hit first and you will lose 80% of the time.  So yeah, I generally will have a weapon in my hand ready to go and that is not unrealistic with me.
Nah. I don't think you're paranoid. Situational awareness. Was just trying to think of a realistic scenario on an airplane. 


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

davgdavg

Re: Weapons for Airline Travel
« Reply #36 on: May 25, 2017, 01:13:44 PM »
You may think I'm paranoid but I am in condition yellow when in public.  I look at everybody to see what they are carrying, if they have a folder in their pocket etc.  If in an elevator and someone else comes in, my hand is on the handle of the fixed blade I carry in the tip up position on my belt.  Same thing if walking in a parking lot and I am passing someone and I look back as soon as we pass.  Don't want someone playing the knock out game with me.

If you perceive a threat from someone you need to strike first.  Wait for them to hit first and you will lose 80% of the time.  So yeah, I generally will have a weapon in my hand ready to go and that is not unrealistic with me.

You live in Hawaii right? Situational awareness is one thing, but preparing yourself to use a blade on every stranger you come across sounds like a horrible way to live. Then again, maybe your're an Immortal. There can be only one, lol.

RSN172

Re: Weapons for Airline Travel
« Reply #37 on: May 25, 2017, 06:48:58 PM »
You live in Hawaii right? Situational awareness is one thing, but preparing yourself to use a blade on every stranger you come across sounds like a horrible way to live. Then again, maybe your're an Immortal. There can be only one, lol.

You think Hawaii is safe and a paradise?  If you chose to be in condition white, that is your choice, I don't.  If someone is going to randomly attack you, they are not going to say ,"Excuse me sir, I am going to attack you now."  Remember the school teacher sitting on the bench when a nut case just came up and started stabbing her to death.  There have been several others that I have read about.  You never know what someone is thinking.  Some of the worse serial killers in history looked like an ordinary nice guy.  Hope that you never have to face a serious physical confrontation, but may be you are that 6'8" physical specimen, strong as a gorilla and have no fear of anyone.
Happily living in Puna

ren

Re: Weapons for Airline Travel
« Reply #38 on: May 25, 2017, 11:52:33 PM »
Deeds Not Words

changemyoil66

Re: Weapons for Airline Travel
« Reply #39 on: May 26, 2017, 01:02:11 PM »
Warrior Poet on youtube talked about the color codes.  The main thing I learned was don't be in orange/yellow when near a 80 year old grandma.  You can't treat everyone like a threat.  If you do, then you will be burned out and miss the legit orange/red.  So profile even though not PC.