There are already laws that can deal with these things right now, it's just the legislators, judges, and police don't want to do what has to be done. They can already arrest and commit people with current laws like terroristic threatening and MH1 for mental cases to stop violent acts from happening. If these people are such a threat to themselves or society then they should be kept out of society without bail or committed with a quick evaluation and court hearing to follow, then treatment/rehab until they are ready to go back into society. Political correctness, laziness, and lack of funding by government officials is the problem.
Need more police on the streets and investigators instead of putting them in admin positions like firearms section, need more jail space, funding for the courts to expedite cases, and funding for rehab/treatment.
The problem with red flag laws are they are giving a criminal punishment through a civil process. A 1 year protective order removing 2a rights is a criminal punishment given without a jury trial. At the very least, the burden of proof should be clear and convincing/probable cause for the 14 day order and proof beyond a reasonable doubt for the 1 year order. Preponderance of the evidence is only like 51% chance they're guilty versus not which is way to low to remove a civil right.
Preponderance of the evidence is the standard right below proof beyond a reasonable doubt if I understand correctly, and it is the standard for civil trials. I am not saying the level of proof shouldn't be higher but at the very least it should be preponderance of the evidence. Current proposals have it lower than that which is very problematic. I am not sure if there is any precedence for preponderance of the evidence being used to restrict any other constitutional rights though.
Police can take people for mental health evaluation but they cannot always take the person's firearms, unless the firearm is related to the mental health issue. So say you call because your friend is suicidal, cops come in, call their psychology, then take the person to the hospital for further evaluation and care. The cops can't take the guy's firearms.
I do think the MH-1 and other types of mental health orders (I think there is an MH-4, MH-3, etc) should/could be used as a framework. I think the red flag law serves as an avenue for regular people to start the review purchase. Now if a cop comes across a guy with mental issues or a psychologist comes across a guy then then can start the process to get this risky individual off the streets or get the firearms taken away, but does the average person know? Imagine you saw a bunch of warning signs in a family member of yours, do you know how to initiate a court proceeding to have that person have their guns taken away or committed? Heck, take guns out of the picture, do you know how to go about getting someone into the mental health system when there is need but they refuse? Honestly, I don't. The cops can start it if the person is an immediate danger to themselves but what if there is a serious mental health issue without an immediate danger?
Implemented properly a red flag law could be the process where regular people could report so called "red flags" which gets the ball rolling to take guns out of the hands of dangerous people and possibly get risky individuals placed in a care facility.