Nitirde, melonite, sbn, etc. are on a chemical level.
Chf> standard. Keep in mind the common colt le6920 are standard barrels with chrome lining.. And they last a long time with abuse. From my understanding chf just last longer under heavy use/ constantly going from hi temp to ambient temp. Chrome is added to to both chf and standard barrels but there are barrels without chrome lining and i would stay away from them. I have a standard bcm barrel elw. i guess i couldve gotten a chf for 80 bucks more. But my spikes is a chf. I also have nitride barrels from faxon. To me, nitride is easier to take care of.
The avg shooter prob wont be able to tell the diff between chf and standard. Im one of them. But with covid goin on i think everyone is in the same boat unless you have your own private range.
Heres an article from bcm.
https://www.thefirearmsforum.com/threads/filthy-14-update.173677/Sorry not really an article, more like a forum talking bout it. But i do have the magazine in my trunk of my car. I guess they give you a copy if you buy an upper from bcm lol. Just google filthy14 and i think theres a pdf lurking somewhere. I remember people were on the lookout for this particular barrel at classes around the mainland. And people would post its round count. Iirc bout 5k rounds per class, he put on it.
Idk much bout 416 but as mr gunsngear explains, 416r trumps 416. Something bout cold weather will make lil cracks in plain old 416?? Its been a while since i watched it so i could be wrong.
Then you got ss410. Bcm seems to make alot of spr type of barrels. That must say something. Idk squat bout it tho.
As for carbon fiber barrels, all i know definitively is that they cost more than my glock19. Without researching imma guess that it dissipates heat better than steel (which is true for car hoods) and from an automotive standpoint, resin is used as a sealer. (still from an automotive pov) if resin exists on a barrel coupled with carbon fiber, then carbon fiber barrels are better than steel barrels, in the sense of weight to strength ratio. Blah idk just spit ballin why they cost so much. Never looked into it. Cause for 600$$+, ill just buy another gun or something else.
Thicker barrels are less prone to barrel whip. It still has but not as much. Which is why bcm and ballistic advantage makes their enhanced or hanson profiles. Thick closer to reciever and tapers off smaller towards the muzzle. Every company has their own version. Also thicker barrels take longer to heat up, which can cause accuracy shift on pencil barrels. But it has been proven thats not always the case. Maybe 100 rounds in a minute then yeah, i think a thicker barrel will have better accuracy.
Fwiw if i was to go to war id prob take my spikes chf middy 16 inch upper. Or the bcm elw middy.
Harmonics does play a good role in all of this like someone explained above. And the .223 mini14??? Is a prime example.
Iraqveteran does some meltdown vids with certain types of barrels to show comparisons.
Gunsngear did a comparison vid between nitride vs chrome lined meltdown vid as well.
A short summary: unless you have full auto, or able to pull that trigger faster than miculek, you prob wont be able to heat a barrel up enough to have an immense poa/poi shift. The gas tube will prob melt and your gun will be out of commission already before that happens.