Different barrel materials (Read 10058 times)

stangzilla

Different barrel materials
« on: October 01, 2020, 10:58:56 AM »
What are the pros/cons of different types if barrel materials?
Such as 416 stainless steel, cold hammer forged, carbon fiber, or any others you want to add
What's best accuracy, durability, most round count?
What's good for AR, bolt gun?

dv808

Re: Different barrel materials
« Reply #1 on: October 01, 2020, 11:54:22 AM »
Not too sure on the subtle differences in the materials but it's my understanding that normally the thicker the barrel, the more accurate it is. There's a whole bunch of different barrel profiles from pencil to bull.  The thicker the barrel is, the less deflection and it'll hold it's accuracy longer than thinner barrels especially as they heat up.  The trade off is weight.  Sure you could put bull barrels on all your rifles but they'll all be heavy.  Stainless is supposed to last longer.  Then there's different types of rifling.

Carbon fiber are carbon wrapped barrels that allow the manufacturer to use thinner barrels and then they are wrapped in carbon fiber to bull barrel or almost bull barrel profiles.  The resulting product is supposed to have the accuracy of the thicker barrels at greatly reduced weight.  They'll still be heavier than lighter profile barrels.

To me, an accurate barrel works on any rifle.  Doesn't matter whether it's a semi AR or bolt action.  The two rifles are normally shot differently though.  You don't tend to shoot a bolt as fast as an AR.

Most of my rifles have standard or lightweight profile barrels and they're used for hunting so I don't want to be lugging around a 12-15# rifle.  They may give up some accuracy but I'm probably not shooting more than a few shots at one time.  I have a carbon wrapped barrel for my 10-22.  Now that I have an accurate barrel for it, I have to find a factory load that it likes best.  It's the never-ending pursuit of accuracy.

Hope that helps a little.  It really comes down to $.  How much do you want to spend, what are you using the rifle for and where are you willing to sacrifice?  Also, being limited to only 100yds at Kokohead is a factor too.

Sent from my J8270 using Tapatalk

Flapp_Jackson

Re: Different barrel materials
« Reply #2 on: October 01, 2020, 12:18:32 PM »
You should also consider how the harmonic characteristics of barrels compare.  Length, thickness, temperature, free-floated vs. attached to hand guard, speed of bullet, rate of twist, etc. all combine to create a range of vibrational impulses which are transmitted to the barrel.

http://www.stocks-rifle.com/harmonics.htm

Changing any one of the harmonic factors can impact how well the barrel performs for a given application.
The reasonable man adapts himself to the world;
the unreasonable one persists in trying to adapt the world to himself.
Therefore, all progress depends on the unreasonable man.
-- George Bernard Shaw

drck1000

Re: Different barrel materials
« Reply #3 on: October 01, 2020, 12:20:10 PM »
What are the pros/cons of different types if barrel materials?
Such as 416 stainless steel, cold hammer forged, carbon fiber, or any others you want to add
What's best accuracy, durability, most round count?
What's good for AR, bolt gun?
I would say depends on intended use/purpose. 
Say AR & defensive use, longevity of "plain" or CHF barrel over uber accuracy potential. 
Say bolt action and paper shooting, more accuracy potential (nevermind any personal shooting technique deficiencies  :( ).  I am sure the performance of my basic Rem 700 barrel is limiting my shooting.  That said, no fault in trying to remove those mechanical or product deficiencies.   ;D

For "best accuracy", I would also consider manufacturing tolerance and quality along with the material. 

ren

Re: Different barrel materials
« Reply #4 on: October 01, 2020, 12:32:12 PM »
You should have the most accurate barrel you can afford. That's my opinion. Why waste money on guessing where a shot could be?
With that said, here's a brief overview from Krieger.
https://kriegerbarrels.com/about

or over 30 years this process has never stopped, and Krieger Barrels continues to test and perfect the steel composition and heat treatment regime. We do not offer multiple grades of steel. All of our steel must meet the same standards. We do offer most of our barrels in a choice of either stainless steel or chrome moly. Our stainless and chrome moly barrels are both held to the same standards from initial steel mill quality to final inspection of dimensions and finish.

I think single cut barrels offer the best balance between longevity and accuracy. The barrel isn't stressed into a form like a CHF one. I think that's the critical factor when the material is being heated up. There's mixed results from barrel treatments such as cryo'ing and salt baths. I've read that nitriding will make the barrel last longer with mixed results in accuracy.
In my limited experience with Shilen, Wilson Arms, and Krieger; Kriegers seem to last longer and maintain accuracy up to around 5000 rounds. I've rebarrelled Wilsons at about 3000. I'll try and get some pics later. Chrome lined isn't all that "cracked" up to be. I borescoped one CL barrel on a middie upper from DelTon and the finishing looked horrible but the barrel seems to shoot well for now. The DelTon barrel did have a lot of copper deposits which isn't a good sign of a well finished barrel.
Deeds Not Words

aaronc5362

Re: Different barrel materials
« Reply #5 on: October 01, 2020, 08:15:44 PM »


Nitirde, melonite, sbn, etc. are on a chemical level.

Chf> standard. Keep in mind the common colt le6920 are standard barrels with chrome lining.. And they last a long time with abuse. From my understanding chf just last longer under heavy use/ constantly going from hi temp to ambient temp. Chrome is added to to both chf and standard barrels but there are barrels without chrome lining and i would stay away from them. I have a standard bcm barrel elw.  i guess i couldve gotten a chf for 80 bucks more. But my spikes is a chf. I also have nitride barrels from faxon. To me, nitride is easier to take care of.

The avg shooter prob wont be able to tell the diff between chf and standard. Im one of them. But with covid goin on i think everyone is in the same boat unless you have your own private range.

Heres an article from bcm.

https://www.thefirearmsforum.com/threads/filthy-14-update.173677/

Sorry not really an article, more like a forum talking bout it. But i do have the magazine in my trunk of my car. I guess they give you a copy if you buy an upper from bcm lol. Just google filthy14 and i think theres a pdf lurking somewhere. I remember people were on the lookout for this particular barrel at classes around the mainland. And people would post its round count. Iirc bout 5k rounds per class, he put on it.

Idk much bout 416 but as mr gunsngear explains, 416r trumps 416. Something bout cold weather will make lil cracks in plain old 416?? Its been a while since i watched it so i could be wrong.

Then you got ss410. Bcm seems to make alot of spr type of barrels. That must say something. Idk squat bout it tho.

As for carbon fiber barrels,  all i know definitively is that they cost more than my glock19. Without researching imma guess that it dissipates heat better than steel (which is true for car hoods) and from an automotive standpoint,  resin is used as a sealer. (still from an automotive pov) if resin exists on a barrel coupled with carbon fiber, then carbon fiber barrels are better than steel barrels, in the sense of weight to strength ratio. Blah idk just spit ballin why they cost so much. Never looked into it. Cause for 600$$+, ill just buy another gun or something else.

Thicker barrels are less prone to barrel whip. It still has but not as much. Which is why bcm and ballistic advantage makes their enhanced or hanson profiles. Thick closer to reciever and tapers off smaller towards the muzzle. Every company has their own version. Also thicker barrels take longer to heat up, which can cause accuracy shift on pencil barrels. But it has been proven thats not always the case. Maybe 100 rounds in a minute then yeah, i think a thicker barrel will have better accuracy.

Fwiw if i was to go to war id prob take my spikes chf middy 16 inch upper. Or the bcm elw middy.

Harmonics does play a good role in all of this like someone explained above. And the .223 mini14??? Is a prime example.

Iraqveteran does some meltdown vids with certain types of barrels to show comparisons.

Gunsngear did a comparison vid between nitride vs chrome lined meltdown vid as well.

A short summary: unless you have full auto, or able to pull that trigger faster than miculek, you prob wont be able to heat a barrel up enough to have an immense poa/poi shift. The gas tube will prob melt and your gun will be out of commission already before that happens.
« Last Edit: October 01, 2020, 09:24:05 PM by aaronc5362 »

stangzilla

Re: Different barrel materials
« Reply #6 on: October 02, 2020, 12:23:45 PM »
thanks for all the great info

are there any types of barrels that are no good, to stay away from?

aaronc5362

Re: Different barrel materials
« Reply #7 on: October 02, 2020, 12:32:44 PM »
Id stay away from normal barrels that are not chrome lined/ or chemically enhanced. 1 or the other is fine by me.

As for stainless steel id prob go with 416r only. Oh ive had a faxon barrel that was 416r with nitride. I sold that upper tho. Best of both worlds. It was the flame fluted middy in x39 cal.

ren

Re: Different barrel materials
« Reply #8 on: October 02, 2020, 12:45:04 PM »
from what I've seen of Faxon - refer to borescope thread - I wouldnt buy one. Maybe they had a worn chamber reamer that they meant to change out?  I've also heard mixed results from Bear Creek Arsenal.

From my small sampling I'll stick with barrels from White Oak and CLE for ARs, and from barrel houses such as Krieger, Shilen and Wilson. The finish work such as chambering is just as important as how the barrel's bore is cut. If a barrel's chamber is not cut concentric with the bore or they used a worn reamer than bad things happen. At that point all the chrome lining and chem baths won't help it. Seen it first hand.
A lot of dealers tout and market the type of material but read what Krieger says about barrel material. They've been making barrels for competitive shooters for a long time. Bartlein is another barrel maker that has a good reputation.
Deeds Not Words

stangzilla

Re: Different barrel materials
« Reply #9 on: October 02, 2020, 12:45:46 PM »
Id stay away from normal barrels that are not chrome lined/ or chemically enhanced. 1 or the other is fine by me.

As for stainless steel id prob go with 416r only. Oh ive had a faxon barrel that was 416r with nitride. I sold that upper tho. Best of both worlds. It was the flame fluted middy in x39 cal.

I got 1 stainless barrel in 416R, the rest are chemically treated, 1 chrome lined

stangzilla

Re: Different barrel materials
« Reply #10 on: October 02, 2020, 01:11:22 PM »
from what I've seen of Faxon - refer to borescope thread - I wouldnt buy one. Maybe they had a worn chamber reamer that they meant to change out?  I've also heard mixed results from Bear Creek Arsenal.

From my small sampling I'll stick with barrels from White Oak and CLE for ARs, and from barrel houses such as Krieger, Shilen and Wilson. The finish work such as chambering is just as important as how the barrel's bore is cut. If a barrel's chamber is not cut concentric with the bore or they used a worn reamer than bad things happen. At that point all the chrome lining and chem baths won't help it. Seen it first hand.
A lot of dealers tout and market the type of material but read what Krieger says about barrel material. They've been making barrels for competitive shooters for a long time. Bartlein is another barrel maker that has a good reputation.

I don't have any high end barrels.  the best ones I have are from Ballistic Advantage that came with the assembled uppers that I bought, and a 416R barrel from a smaller company billed as "match barrel, subMOA" which seems to be pretty accurate
but I have heard good things about Krieger
I haven't really looked into match grade competition barrels...….yet 
thanks for the info  :shaka:

aaronc5362

Re: Different barrel materials
« Reply #11 on: October 03, 2020, 06:11:38 AM »
from what I've seen of Faxon - refer to borescope thread - I wouldnt buy one. Maybe they had a worn chamber reamer that they meant to change out?  I've also heard mixed results from Bear Creek Arsenal.

From my small sampling I'll stick with barrels from White Oak and CLE for ARs, and from barrel houses such as Krieger, Shilen and Wilson. The finish work such as chambering is just as important as how the barrel's bore is cut. If a barrel's chamber is not cut concentric with the bore or they used a worn reamer than bad things happen. At that point all the chrome lining and chem baths won't help it. Seen it first hand.
A lot of dealers tout and market the type of material but read what Krieger says about barrel material. They've been making barrels for competitive shooters for a long time. Bartlein is another barrel maker that has a good reputation.

Hmm ive had no problems with faxon. Couldve been a bad batch others have had. I still got 2 faxons in my safe. 16 inch mock dissy and 18in rifle gas. No problems yet *knock on wood* lol. But i know their customer service is awesome. They helped answer my questions with gas port diam (devulging supposed "classified" info. FU noveske lol jk..) before purchasing my x39 barrel. Noveske wouldnt gimme info on their barrels soooooo yeah. Haha. No douby noveske makes good shit tho.

I think every company will have lemons now and then but i agree with bca. Well in the beginning i know they were crap. But lately i been seeing good reviews on them. Maybe they are stepping up and doing better quality control?

I always hear bout shilen and krieger. And no doubt they are top tier for what they were designed to do. Match grade. I watch alot of vids on them lol.  But i dont plan on having a beautiful $ 400+ barrel that i will baby. Im clumsy and drop things and trip alot. Lol. I want something easy to maintain and when or if i scratch it im not gonna care. I mean i still take care of everything (mantra- take care of it and itll take care of you) but accidents happen and im prone to it lol.

aaronc5362

Re: Different barrel materials
« Reply #12 on: October 03, 2020, 06:14:46 AM »
I don't have any high end barrels.  the best ones I have are from Ballistic Advantage that came with the assembled uppers that I bought, and a 416R barrel from a smaller company billed as "match barrel, subMOA" which seems to be pretty accurate
but I have heard good things about Krieger
I haven't really looked into match grade competition barrels...….yet 
thanks for the info  :shaka:
[/q

BA is good too. My friends have them and they have no complaints either. The owner is very customer oriented. Which is what i like. I bought some other things from his company.

Plus i love watching their youtube vids. Not to see him but that girl is a cutie.  And they give some good info that helped me figure things out before. But still mainly to see her hahaha

drck1000

Re: Different barrel materials
« Reply #13 on: October 03, 2020, 01:45:17 PM »
thanks for all the great info

are there any types of barrels that are no good, to stay away from?
Nothing AR wise I would stay away from, at least that I can think of.  I have plain, nitride, melonite, CHF and non, etc.  For my use, which is say 5-50 yards "typical" with 50-200 yards "in consideration", can't say that I can tell a difference.  And I'm talking torso expectations, not uber, professional match shooting level. 

I want to test my LPVO upper eventually for more accuracy than my red dot uppers.  I have ammo lined up to test, but haven't been able to get out to the range.  That upper is a midlength CHF normal weight.  I do wish I had a lightweight upper to test side by side, but all of my lightweight barreled uppers are gone. 

I started out partial to midlength gas, but now most of my AR uppers are carbine.  They are a lot more "insensitive" to ammo, particularly the under gassed crappy ammo that I had bought quite a bit of.  It would choke with a couple of midlength uppers that I used to have, but those uppers also had heavier springs and buffers.  Probably could've gotten them to where the crappy ammo worked better, but never got around to it before I sold them. 

I guess I would stay away from any barrel material that is sensitive to corrosion.  That's about all I can think if.

stangzilla

Re: Different barrel materials
« Reply #14 on: October 03, 2020, 03:04:30 PM »

ren

Re: Different barrel materials
« Reply #15 on: October 03, 2020, 04:18:42 PM »


couple points that are not true.
Twist rate has an effect on accuracy. Try shooting a 77gr bullet out of a 1:12 twist barrel.
His thoughts on accuracy of stainless vs a "normal" barrel.
Most of the wear will be in the throat and "catastrophic" failure in sustained rate of fire will likely be in the gas tube.
He relates heat dispersion to color of the material - I suspect that is not what is happening. More surface area will help disperse heat - that's why there are fluted barrels. Some MG barrels have fins on them. For solar reflection - yes.
He tells us that we shouldn't be intimidated by people who claim to be a service member or a machinist - then he says he is a machinist that worked on farm equipment.
He also doesn't mention the chambering work and other barrel finishing processes such as lapping that contribute to the quality of the barrel.
Good barrels are affordable. White Oak sells in house chambered Wilson barrels. They can be had for less than $300. Douglas are great barrels too and are cheaper than Kriegers.
« Last Edit: October 03, 2020, 04:43:20 PM by ren »
Deeds Not Words

drck1000

Re: Different barrel materials
« Reply #16 on: October 03, 2020, 04:47:27 PM »
SNIP
Seems like a goober. I could follow the points he was making, but we he did a lot of over simplification or metallurgy and material properties as well as used wrong terminology. Reliability vs durability. Seems like he was conveying stuff others has told him and added is own “isms”.

One thing he mentioned that I agree with is that many won’t shoot out a barrel. I haven’t yet and got rid of a few uppers before I did. I have a couple current ARs that I envision shooting out the barrel. I think I’m over 1/2 way there on at least one. The recent shortage in ammo is gonna extend that period.  :(
« Last Edit: October 04, 2020, 08:13:47 AM by drck1000 »

stangzilla

Re: Different barrel materials
« Reply #17 on: October 04, 2020, 08:09:05 AM »
Seems like a goober.

Yup.  Goober  O0

stangzilla

Re: Different barrel materials
« Reply #18 on: October 04, 2020, 09:28:04 AM »
I have 2 assembled uppers with BA barrels 556 and 308. Did not know which kind of barrels they are, didnt research too much into it until now
They are both the Modern series barrel which is their basic barrel. Mine aren't Gucci builds, so it suits my purpose





stangzilla

Re: Different barrel materials
« Reply #19 on: October 05, 2020, 07:35:07 AM »





« Last Edit: October 05, 2020, 08:48:15 AM by stangzilla »