I had a moron friend on FB post about someone else's loans. Loan balance was for $25K. They made their monthly payment and in a few years, the balance was $24K. Which makes no sense to me unless they're just paying $10 a month or the interest rate is 20% (which it's not). So she was basically posting BS stories. I looked at it like a car payment. $25K in loan dept is manageable. Pay a few hundred a month and in 5-6 years (like a car loan) it's done. Now bigger loans like $100K are the ones that even a low interest rate will hurt you.
But this comes down to actions have consequences. Spend $500K to go to Harvard and get a rubbish degree that doesn't pay well, then you will be screwed.
A Simple Interest Loan follows the "rule of seven-eighths." When you first start making payments, 7/8 of the payment goes toward interest, and 1/8 goes toward principle. Doesn't take a math wiz to see that the balance is going to shrink super-slowly at that rate.
Then, when you reach the halfway point of the loan's term, you're pay about 50/50 for principle/interest. When you near the end of the term, you will be paying 7/8 toward principle and 1/8 toward interest.
The purpose for this is to ensure the lender gets their interest payments front-loaded. They're making their "profit" for lending you the money long before you pay the balance down to a much smaller sum.
Now look at student loans. First thing is the term. I believe the standard term is 10 years. You can also opt for the extended plan, which lengthens the term of the loan to 25 years for a $25K loan balance. On top of that, you can take deferrals, like when the student is still in school or joins the military. No payments are required, but the interest continues to accrue.
Then there's the interest rate. Loans taken out in the 7/06-6/08 timeframe have an interest rate of over 8%. Loans taken out in the last decade range from 3.4%-5.05% depending on when they originated. The rates are fixed rates as of 2006, meaning they remain the same through the life of the loan. Before 2006, they were variable rates.
So, paying double the rate for a loan compared to what you could have gotten on a home equity loan is one factor. Another is extending the loan term to 25, or even 30, years. Those 2 factors could easily mean the person with a 25K balance is seeing a very tiny reduction of the principle in the first year. Depending on the size of the debt, you can change the term. If you owe over $60K, you can go out to 30 years in the extended plan.
As you also mentioned, the size of the regular payment also plays into how much you owe over time. If you pay the standard payment on $25K, you'll make monthly payments of around $236 for 10 years. Every time you skip a payment or defer payments for military service, hardships, etc., the interest will be calculated on the current outstanding balance each month and piled on top of the loan balance. Each day after the first month you skipped, you'll owe interest on the interest accrued. By the time you get around to making payments, the additional interest will have compounded daily.
They take the average daily interest rate for a year (basically %5 / 365, if 5% is the APR), and multiply the daily balance by that daily rate. It really causes the outstanding balance to go up when no payments are made.
There are many free amortization tools on the web. Find one that does student loans. The ones offered by the lenders are not as detailed or transparent as they should be.