Breakdown of Rahimi SCOTUS gun case hearing (Read 37120 times)

Flapp_Jackson

Re: Breakdown of Rahimi SCOTUS gun case hearing
« Reply #120 on: December 02, 2023, 08:19:01 AM »
Its goal post moving. Thats all he has for his wrong arguments.

And his whataboutism game is weak (what about CRIMINALS being arrested before trial?  Was their due process right violated?).

#FruitSalad
#Apples&Oranges
The reasonable man adapts himself to the world;
the unreasonable one persists in trying to adapt the world to himself.
Therefore, all progress depends on the unreasonable man.
-- George Bernard Shaw

Brystont1

Re: Breakdown of Rahimi SCOTUS gun case hearing
« Reply #121 on: December 02, 2023, 09:07:22 AM »
Imagine being arrested for a crime you didn’t commit and didn’t get accused of. Then you get a hearing where you have to prove that you are not going to commit a crime which again you are not accused of committing.   :crazy: :crazy: :crazy:

Flapp_Jackson

Re: Breakdown of Rahimi SCOTUS gun case hearing
« Reply #122 on: December 02, 2023, 09:50:00 AM »
Imagine being arrested for a crime you didn’t commit and didn’t get accused of. Then you get a hearing where you have to prove that you are not going to commit a crime which again you are not accused of committing.   :crazy: :crazy: :crazy:

But, it's Constitutional as long as they give you a hearing ... a week or two later.

 :crazy: :crazy: :crazy:
The reasonable man adapts himself to the world;
the unreasonable one persists in trying to adapt the world to himself.
Therefore, all progress depends on the unreasonable man.
-- George Bernard Shaw

eyeeatingfish

Re: Breakdown of Rahimi SCOTUS gun case hearing
« Reply #123 on: December 02, 2023, 10:02:36 PM »
Imagine being arrested for a crime you didn’t commit and didn’t get accused of. Then you get a hearing where you have to prove that you are not going to commit a crime which again you are not accused of committing.   :crazy: :crazy: :crazy:

Not really the best comparison because this isn't a criminal issue, this is a civil issue. Sometimes a crime is involved (like domestic violence) but the process is a civil one. You can have your rights taken away from you in mental health cases prior to having a hearing.
Also, someone actually does make allegations against you for this type of order to take place.

eyeeatingfish

Re: Breakdown of Rahimi SCOTUS gun case hearing
« Reply #124 on: December 02, 2023, 10:07:34 PM »
Speaking of flawed reasoning...

If he's such a danger that his guns need to be taken without a hearing first, WHY IS HE NOT BEING ARRESTED???

I'll tell you why: because #1 he has not committed a crime, #2 he's not being accused of a crime, and #3, there is no criminal complaint to arrest him under.  Red flag laws are a CIVIL procedure.

Your comparison between a criminal case and a civil case is wrong ... and dumb.

I already agreed with you that if the judge thinks someone is that dangerous then they should bring him in for a mental health examination.

As for your pointing out he hasn't been accused of committing any crime I already pointed out to you that people are taken into medical custody for mental health evaluations without committing a crime.

The point I was making to you is that having a hearing for the accused to be present doesn't have to occur before they lose their rights, whether in criminal or civil procedures.

eyeeatingfish

Re: Breakdown of Rahimi SCOTUS gun case hearing
« Reply #125 on: December 02, 2023, 10:10:47 PM »
Please show me where i said "arrested".

Nice goal post moving.

Sent from my SM-G991U using Tapatalk

I didn't say you said arrested, focus. I was giving you an example where someone's rights are taken away before a hearing.

Flapp_Jackson

Re: Breakdown of Rahimi SCOTUS gun case hearing
« Reply #126 on: December 02, 2023, 10:38:28 PM »
I already agreed with you that if the judge thinks someone is that dangerous then they should bring him in for a mental health examination.

As for your pointing out he hasn't been accused of committing any crime I already pointed out to you that people are taken into medical custody for mental health evaluations without committing a crime.

The point I was making to you is that having a hearing for the accused to be present doesn't have to occur before they lose their rights, whether in criminal or civil procedures.

Here you are again, still arguing apples vs. oranges.

Taking away someone's firearms -- a protected constitutional right -- is COMPLETELY different than holding someone for a mental eval.

Normally someone being held for such an eval HAS DONE SOMETHING that demonstrates they are a danger to themselves or others.  No such standard is being applied to red flag laws, or else instead of just taking the guns, they would hold the gun owner for a mental eval.

All I can do is explain it, but I can't understand it for you.
The reasonable man adapts himself to the world;
the unreasonable one persists in trying to adapt the world to himself.
Therefore, all progress depends on the unreasonable man.
-- George Bernard Shaw

changemyoil66

Re: Breakdown of Rahimi SCOTUS gun case hearing
« Reply #127 on: December 03, 2023, 07:04:52 AM »
I didn't say you said arrested, focus. I was giving you an example where someone's rights are taken away before a hearing.
Thanks for admitting goal post moving.

Sent from my SM-G991U using Tapatalk

changemyoil66

Re: Breakdown of Rahimi SCOTUS gun case hearing
« Reply #128 on: December 03, 2023, 07:09:33 AM »
Here you are again, still arguing apples vs. oranges.

Taking away someone's firearms -- a protected constitutional right -- is COMPLETELY different than holding someone for a mental eval.

Normally someone being held for such an eval HAS DONE SOMETHING that demonstrates they are a danger to themselves or others.  No such standard is being applied to red flag laws, or else instead of just taking the guns, they would hold the gun owner for a mental eval.

All I can do is explain it, but I can't understand it for you.
He has no logic to his answer. Like when Charlie Kirk debates someone. Fact vs. feelings. And in this case ego.

He keeps repeating things that arent true, in hopes no one calls him out on it, thus making what he said is true.

Then there is only so many ways to show hes wrong, but he requires even more evidence. So its simpler to stop explaining after a certain point. Like talking to a retarded person, sometimes u can only explain so much.

Someone else does on TV this often, which is where he gets his new nickname from.

Red flag laws dont even have enough to even arrest the person.

Sent from my SM-G991U using Tapatalk

eyeeatingfish

Re: Breakdown of Rahimi SCOTUS gun case hearing
« Reply #129 on: December 03, 2023, 09:23:49 PM »
Here you are again, still arguing apples vs. oranges.

Taking away someone's firearms -- a protected constitutional right -- is COMPLETELY different than holding someone for a mental eval.

Normally someone being held for such an eval HAS DONE SOMETHING that demonstrates they are a danger to themselves or others.  No such standard is being applied to red flag laws, or else instead of just taking the guns, they would hold the gun owner for a mental eval.

All I can do is explain it, but I can't understand it for you.

What do you mean no such standard exists for red flag laws? If you think someone simply says "I don't like Flapp having guns" that is not enough for the judge to go take your guns.

https://www.capitol.hawaii.gov/hrscurrent/Vol03_Ch0121-0200D/HRS0134/HRS_0134-0064.htm
According to the HRS
(d)  In determining whether sufficient grounds for an ex parte gun violence protective order exist, the court shall consider all relevant evidence presented by the petitioner, and may also consider other relevant evidence, including evidence of facts relating to the respondent's:

     (1)  Unlawful, reckless, or negligent use, display, storage, possession, or brandishing of a firearm;
     (2)  Act or threat of violence against the respondent's self or another person, regardless of whether the violence involves a firearm;
     (3)  Violation of a protective order or restraining order issued pursuant to chapter 586 or section 604-10.5, or a similar law in another state;
     (4)  Abuse of controlled substances or alcohol or commission of any criminal offense that involves controlled substances or alcohol; and
     (5)  Recent acquisition of any firearms, ammunition, or other deadly weapons.

Look at 1-5, those are "SOMETHING that demonstrates they are a danger to themselves or others" as you put it.

And the HRS even sets a standard of proof
(f)  If the court finds probable cause to believe that the respondent poses an imminent danger of causing bodily injury to the respondent's self or another person by owning, purchasing, possessing, receiving, or having in the respondent's custody or control any firearm or ammunition, the court shall issue an ex parte gun violence protective order.

Then in the next section, look a standard!
https://www.capitol.hawaii.gov/hrscurrent/Vol03_Ch0121-0200D/HRS0134/HRS_0134-0065.htm
(c)  If the court finds by a preponderance of the evidence at the hearing that the respondent poses a significant danger of causing bodily injury to the respondent's self or another person by owning, purchasing, possessing, receiving, or having in the respondent's custody or control any firearm or ammunition, the court shall issue a one-year gun violence protective order.

Holding someone for a mental eval is still restricting your constitutional rights, and as I pointed out to you, it is a greater restriction than restricting firearm ownership. If you are in a mental facility for an evaluation your freedom to do many things is restricted.

All I can do is explain it, but I can't understand it for you.
« Last Edit: December 03, 2023, 09:29:33 PM by eyeeatingfish »

eyeeatingfish

Re: Breakdown of Rahimi SCOTUS gun case hearing
« Reply #130 on: December 03, 2023, 09:26:12 PM »
Thanks for admitting goal post moving.

Sent from my SM-G991U using Tapatalk

Restraining orders have restricted people's access to firearms for decades now. Since you claim it is so unconstitutional, perhaps you can point to a SCOTUS case that supports your claim.

BTW, imagine lawmakers modified the law to take into account your claims of lack of due process. Imagine they had the hearing first and then took the firearms after. Would you then say the law is constitutional?
« Last Edit: December 03, 2023, 09:31:41 PM by eyeeatingfish »

Flapp_Jackson

Re: Breakdown of Rahimi SCOTUS gun case hearing
« Reply #131 on: December 03, 2023, 09:33:28 PM »
Restraining orders have restricted people's access to firearms for decades now. Since you claim it is so unconstitutional, perhaps you can point to a SCOTUS case that supports your claim.

BTW, imagine lawmakers modified the law to take into account your claims of lack of due process. Imagine they had the hearing first and then took the firearms after. Would you then say the law is constitutional?

You are so dumb:
Quote
United States v. Rahimi is a pending United States Supreme Court case
regarding the Second Amendment to the United States Constitution and
whether it confers the government's ability to prohibit firearm possession
by a person with a domestic violence restraining order.
The reasonable man adapts himself to the world;
the unreasonable one persists in trying to adapt the world to himself.
Therefore, all progress depends on the unreasonable man.
-- George Bernard Shaw

eyeeatingfish

Re: Breakdown of Rahimi SCOTUS gun case hearing
« Reply #132 on: December 03, 2023, 09:41:15 PM »
You are so dumb:


Someone clearly doesn't understand this case

Rahimi AGREED to the stipulation that he not have firearms. That is why this case is different than a challenge to a normal restraining order.

How does your foot taste?

Flapp_Jackson

Re: Breakdown of Rahimi SCOTUS gun case hearing
« Reply #133 on: December 03, 2023, 10:03:44 PM »

Someone clearly doesn't understand this case

Rahimi AGREED to the stipulation that he not have firearms. That is why this case is different than a challenge to a normal restraining order.

How does your foot taste?

Obviously you STILL haven't bothered to watch the videos on the first page of this thread.

The reasonable man adapts himself to the world;
the unreasonable one persists in trying to adapt the world to himself.
Therefore, all progress depends on the unreasonable man.
-- George Bernard Shaw

changemyoil66

Re: Breakdown of Rahimi SCOTUS gun case hearing
« Reply #134 on: December 04, 2023, 08:26:43 AM »
Restraining orders have restricted people's access to firearms for decades now. Since you claim it is so unconstitutional, perhaps you can point to a SCOTUS case that supports your claim.

BTW, imagine lawmakers modified the law to take into account your claims of lack of due process. Imagine they had the hearing first and then took the firearms after. Would you then say the law is constitutional?

So you're arguments is that unless SCOTUS takes it up, it's not unconstitutional?  Guess HI chief of police denying people their CCW all these decades is constitutional cause until Bruen and Young vs. Hawaii, it was OK cause the courts didn't decide it.  Same with HI's mag limit and SBR restrictions.  Please tell me how many lawsuits HI won in the past 8 years about 2A stuff...the answer is ZERO. Which means they were on the books and violating peoples right until someone had the $ to challenge it.  So to answer your question, there is no SCOTUS case yet.  Are you now trying to make yourself sound right about something since you've been wrong a lot. Why not ask me what 1+1 equals.

I don't have to imagine law makers modifying or making laws that lack due process, they already have done so, most recent with Red Flag law. We discussed this already.

Now you're asking if other than red flag restraing orders are constitutional, I reply with a no as they too lack due process.  I know a guy who used to work in a judges chamber and he saw all the time how TRO's are abused for custody battles.  Long story short, the 1st person to file one wins.

But lets keep the focus on red flag law and how you have yet to post a constitutional one. Are you having trouble finding it?

Heres one of the 1st that you cannot use since it's unconstitutional. WA, a man was inside his home and had his firearm holstered. Thru his window, he was "looking at his neighbors funny". So he got his guns taken away. When asked about any prior interaction, the neighbors said they never interacted with him, but he looked at them funny. He got his guns taken away. IDK what the outcome later was, but his 2A right was taken away without due process first. Cops showed up at his door and consfiscsated his guns. Court later.

changemyoil66

Re: Breakdown of Rahimi SCOTUS gun case hearing
« Reply #135 on: December 04, 2023, 08:28:10 AM »
Obviously you STILL haven't bothered to watch the videos on the first page of this thread.

Or maybe he did, but doesn't understand it. There is no one near him to explain stuff with a chalkboard.

Tism awareness month.

eyeeatingfish

Re: Breakdown of Rahimi SCOTUS gun case hearing
« Reply #136 on: December 04, 2023, 02:28:06 PM »
Obviously you STILL haven't bothered to watch the videos on the first page of this thread.

Obviously you STILL haven't bothered to listen to the podcast.

Hypocrite much?

You didn't even address where you claimed there was no standard but I pointed it out to you in the law.
« Last Edit: December 04, 2023, 02:55:45 PM by eyeeatingfish »

eyeeatingfish

Re: Breakdown of Rahimi SCOTUS gun case hearing
« Reply #137 on: December 04, 2023, 02:54:25 PM »
So you're arguments is that unless SCOTUS takes it up, it's not unconstitutional?  Guess HI chief of police denying people their CCW all these decades is constitutional cause until Bruen and Young vs. Hawaii, it was OK cause the courts didn't decide it.  Same with HI's mag limit and SBR restrictions.  Please tell me how many lawsuits HI won in the past 8 years about 2A stuff...the answer is ZERO. Which means they were on the books and violating peoples right until someone had the $ to challenge it.  So to answer your question, there is no SCOTUS case yet.  Are you now trying to make yourself sound right about something since you've been wrong a lot. Why not ask me what 1+1 equals.

I don't have to imagine law makers modifying or making laws that lack due process, they already have done so, most recent with Red Flag law. We discussed this already.

Now you're asking if other than red flag restraing orders are constitutional, I reply with a no as they too lack due process.  I know a guy who used to work in a judges chamber and he saw all the time how TRO's are abused for custody battles.  Long story short, the 1st person to file one wins.

But lets keep the focus on red flag law and how you have yet to post a constitutional one. Are you having trouble finding it?

Heres one of the 1st that you cannot use since it's unconstitutional. WA, a man was inside his home and had his firearm holstered. Thru his window, he was "looking at his neighbors funny". So he got his guns taken away. When asked about any prior interaction, the neighbors said they never interacted with him, but he looked at them funny. He got his guns taken away. IDK what the outcome later was, but his 2A right was taken away without due process first. Cops showed up at his door and consfiscsated his guns. Court later.


Strawman. My argument is not saying that something is constitutional until the SCOTUS says otherwise. What I did was challenge you to find a SCOTUS case in which they did say, or even suggest in some minor way that this issue is unconstitutional. You know, I am asking you if you can support your claim with some sort of case law. You can make an ideological argument of course but in reality the final determination of whether something is "constitutional" is theirs until another SCOTUS changes it or the constitution is amended.

Now you can, and did, say there was no SCOTUS case on it, which is fine, and honest of you, but what you have to recognize is that means this issue is in dispute. Now you and I and every other joe blow on the internet can argue to we are blue in the face about whether some particular thing is constitutional but that is hardly a decisive answer on the topic. We can take it up a step and cite videos from youtube lawyers that we agree, and that gives us a better understanding of the issues, but we are still left with no decisive answer to the question because you can get 5 experts who say one thing and 5 experts who say another. If I gave you 5 experts who say red flag laws are constitutional are you actually going to change your mind? Ideas of constitutional rights evolve, it took 200+ years for us to arrive at our current understanding of freedom of speech. Someone can claim that the 1st amendment is as clear as day from the text but they would be fundamentally wrong given how it ebbed and flowed over time. All of this is to say that the constitutionality of this question is not a clear obvious one. You can say "i think it is unconstitutional because...." and I can said "I think it is constitutional because..." but we are both just stating our opinions and feelings on the matter. For either to act as if we speak with some divine truth is unwarranted. Because of this I would never insult someone if they thought there wasn't due process when I think there is, I would only make the case for due process being present without climbing on some high horse.

I have seen TROs abused but that is not the fault of the law rather the people making false claims. If I lied and told a cop you hit me you would get arrested the same. Doesn't make assault a bad law, it is just a fact of life that people will take advantage of laws and abuse them sometimes. In fact, I would argue that a TRO taking away firearm gets closer to the line of unconstitutionality than do red flag laws since red flag laws try to target a specific area of danger instead of just saying "my ex harassed me so take away his guns as well". But that is another topic.

The example you gave of WA, if as simple as you say, would be unconstitutional, in my opinion. Not for a lack of a pre-seizure hearing but for lack of any evidence to conclude he is dangerous. However this is where judges and petitioners need to be held accountable. If a law, like ours, says that you must have a certain level of proof but a judge grants the order without sufficient proof then that is the fault of the judge, just like any other case where a judge makes a bad decision.



So, if you can answer my other question, if the system were changed so that a hearing with the respondent being present was required before any seizure, would you then feel this would be a constitutional revocation or at least sufficient due process?

changemyoil66

Re: Breakdown of Rahimi SCOTUS gun case hearing
« Reply #138 on: December 04, 2023, 04:22:46 PM »

Strawman. My argument is not saying that something is constitutional until the SCOTUS says otherwise. What I did was challenge you to find a SCOTUS case in which they did say, or even suggest in some minor way that this issue is unconstitutional. You know, I am asking you if you can support your claim with some sort of case law. You can make an ideological argument of course but in reality the final determination of whether something is "constitutional" is theirs until another SCOTUS changes it or the constitution is amended.

Now you can, and did, say there was no SCOTUS case on it, which is fine, and honest of you, but what you have to recognize is that means this issue is in dispute. Now you and I and every other joe blow on the internet can argue to we are blue in the face about whether some particular thing is constitutional but that is hardly a decisive answer on the topic. We can take it up a step and cite videos from youtube lawyers that we agree, and that gives us a better understanding of the issues, but we are still left with no decisive answer to the question because you can get 5 experts who say one thing and 5 experts who say another. If I gave you 5 experts who say red flag laws are constitutional are you actually going to change your mind? Ideas of constitutional rights evolve, it took 200+ years for us to arrive at our current understanding of freedom of speech. Someone can claim that the 1st amendment is as clear as day from the text but they would be fundamentally wrong given how it ebbed and flowed over time. All of this is to say that the constitutionality of this question is not a clear obvious one. You can say "i think it is unconstitutional because...." and I can said "I think it is constitutional because..." but we are both just stating our opinions and feelings on the matter. For either to act as if we speak with some divine truth is unwarranted. Because of this I would never insult someone if they thought there wasn't due process when I think there is, I would only make the case for due process being present without climbing on some high horse.

I have seen TROs abused but that is not the fault of the law rather the people making false claims. If I lied and told a cop you hit me you would get arrested the same. Doesn't make assault a bad law, it is just a fact of life that people will take advantage of laws and abuse them sometimes. In fact, I would argue that a TRO taking away firearm gets closer to the line of unconstitutionality than do red flag laws since red flag laws try to target a specific area of danger instead of just saying "my ex harassed me so take away his guns as well". But that is another topic.

The example you gave of WA, if as simple as you say, would be unconstitutional, in my opinion. Not for a lack of a pre-seizure hearing but for lack of any evidence to conclude he is dangerous. However this is where judges and petitioners need to be held accountable. If a law, like ours, says that you must have a certain level of proof but a judge grants the order without sufficient proof then that is the fault of the judge, just like any other case where a judge makes a bad decision.



So, if you can answer my other question, if the system were changed so that a hearing with the respondent being present was required before any seizure, would you then feel this would be a constitutional revocation or at least sufficient due process?

So much Newsom in this post.  Re-read what I posted already to your post

"My argument is not saying that something is constitutional until the SCOTUS says otherwise. What I did was challenge you to find a SCOTUS case in which they did say, or even suggest in some minor way that this issue is unconstitutional. You know, I am asking you if you can support your claim with some sort of case law. You can make an ideological argument of course but in reality the final determination of whether something is "constitutional" is theirs until another SCOTUS changes it or the constitution is amended. "

This is exactly what your argument is saying. Do you even remember what you post?

Since there is no ruling that a 10rd mag ban is not unconstitutional by SCOTUS, then it must be constitutional right?  Same almost all of HI's HRS134, exlcuding Tasers which was just amened recently only cause someone sued HI.

Newson-Tism. Thanks for playing. Will get to the other stuff later that is probaby wrong too. But I'm busy right now.

Wchiro

Re: Breakdown of Rahimi SCOTUS gun case hearing
« Reply #139 on: December 04, 2023, 04:40:40 PM »
 :popcorn:  ::) :popcorn: