
Why is it that UAV's are different than other forms of military intelligence gathering and ordinance? Is there some other magical form of military ordinance that DOESN'T include human error? Why are UAV's held to a different standard?
Is it that UAV's make possible, even easy, things that we don't think our government should be doing?
Or, as is my point, is it just making OBVIOUS that our government can and does do things that we don't think they should be doing?
How is it more complex than a "simple" artillery strike? An artillery strike relies on intelligence to aim a strike at a target from a relatively safe, and ideally concealed, vantage point. That used to take a lot of different elements, from on the ground spotters to chain of command decision makers, communicating and coordinating in as close to real time as possible. UAV's facilitate that from an ideal vantage point and make the decisions almost real time. It isn't doing anything different than an artillery strike, its just making all those parts required for a strike MUCH easier and faster to coordinate. It doesn't eliminate the fog of war and mistakes happen but it isn't doing anything materially different than any other form of strike except making it easier, more covert, safer for the operators and quicker.
That's why I say they are only a bad idea from a myopic technophobic perspective. As pieces of hardware there is nothing intrinsically immoral about UAV's.
As for the decisions about HOW and WHY that hardware is used.... that's a completely different issue. That is about the legal use of force and the Federal Government has been increasing shrugging off limitations on its use of force since the end of WWII and particularly after Vietnam.
I'm suggesting that discussions of "Drone Policy" potentially miss the root problem by focusing on "Drone" rather than "Policy."