Drone Policy... thoughts? (Read 11145 times)

new guy

Drone Policy... thoughts?
« on: February 07, 2013, 03:26:27 PM »
.
« Last Edit: August 25, 2016, 06:19:23 AM by new guy »
Your mindset is your primary weapon. - Jeff Cooper

Inspector

Re: Drone Policy... thoughts?
« Reply #1 on: February 07, 2013, 05:19:22 PM »
It's hypocritical. The Democrat Party says they are the party of the people and the little guy. And they are the ones to fight for citizen's rights. Yet they are fast to condemn American Citizens without a court trial. And them kill them with a drone strike. Also, it is the same people who are convicting them that are accusing them. That is something only true Socialist countries do without a blink of an eye. Now they are talking about turning these same drones on American Citizens on American Soil

Our government has turned into accuser, court, jury and executioner all in one. We live in very dangerous times right now.  :( :( :(
SCIENCE THAT CAN’T BE QUESTIONED IS PROPAGANDA!!!

Bunker

Re: Drone Policy... thoughts?
« Reply #2 on: February 07, 2013, 07:41:44 PM »
It's hypocritical. The Democrat Party says they are the party of the people and the little guy. And they are the ones to fight for citizen's rights. Yet they are fast to condemn American Citizens without a court trial. And them kill them with a drone strike. Also, it is the same people who are convicting them that are accusing them. That is something only true Socialist countries do without a blink of an eye. Now they are talking about turning these same drones on American Citizens on American Soil

Our government has turned into accuser, court, jury and executioner all in one. We live in very dangerous times right now.  :( :( :(

I didn't see anything about drone strikes on American soil, unless I missed that. My view is irregardless of nationality, if U.S. intel definitively concludes suspected terrorist leaders or senior members in a terrorist organization present an imminent threat to U.S. citizens, it's homeland or national interests, a drone strike is appropriate on foreign soil, not on U.S. soil, and this is irregardless of what party resides in the White House.

However, the article says “The condition that an operational leader present an ‘imminent’ threat of violent attack against the United States does not require the United States to have clear evidence that a specific attack on U.S. persons and interests will take place in the immediate future.” This is where I disagree with the policy...seems they can pull the trigger without conclusive evidence and this involves American lives in this scenario.

I believe once a citizen of any nationality becomes a terrorist, hell bent on destroying the U.S. and killing as many American's as possible, he now is classified as an enemy combatant and should be treated as such. Just because he is a U.S. citizen, shouldn't change the definition of an enemy combatant. JMHO 
« Last Edit: February 07, 2013, 07:51:08 PM by Bunker »

ren

Re: Drone Policy... thoughts?
« Reply #3 on: February 07, 2013, 10:31:47 PM »
The problem is that the 6th amendment is trumped by reports or evidence of questionable validity and reliability. If the American citizen had a day in court evidence against the accused would be examined. Of course the various orgs. have legal advisors but the principle of having a fair trial is not given. I think that what makes us a great country is the process given to its citizens and that our judicial system as well as our defense resources are examples of it.
I just hope the IC produces and examines credible evidence / reports to justify a lethal strike against a citizen-turned-terrorist.
Deeds Not Words

hvybarrels

Re: Drone Policy... thoughts?
« Reply #4 on: February 08, 2013, 07:01:49 AM »
I didn't see anything about drone strikes on American soil, unless I missed that.

wish there was an emoticon for a frog in a boiling pot of water
You don't need a parachute to go skydiving. You need a parachute to go skydiving twice.

new guy

Re: Drone Policy... thoughts?
« Reply #5 on: February 11, 2013, 01:40:14 PM »
.
« Last Edit: August 25, 2016, 06:19:42 AM by new guy »
Your mindset is your primary weapon. - Jeff Cooper

Bunker

Re: Drone Policy... thoughts?
« Reply #6 on: February 11, 2013, 04:24:00 PM »
Read an article that said they are using drones to look for the Christopher Dorner.... an American citizen on American soil.

I dunno if the drones here are equipped with Hellfires, but still something to think about!!

I believe unarmed drones with thermal imaging cameras have been used on U.S. soil in the past. I would hope that would be the case if they intend to use drones to locate this alleged fugitive (unarmed drones). He is entitled to a fair trail and does have the same rights as all Americans...innocent until proven guilty in a court of law. That's provided he doesn't get into a shootout and get killed in the process by his own choice. 

Heavies

Re: Drone Policy... thoughts?
« Reply #7 on: February 11, 2013, 06:04:57 PM »
Who gets to decide who is a terrorist??

Bunker

Re: Drone Policy... thoughts?
« Reply #8 on: February 11, 2013, 06:39:27 PM »
Who gets to decide who is a terrorist??

Info is dated but I believe [?] still valid and upheld up in all court cases to date. What has changed is the CIA is in the picture WRT drones. In my opinion, DoD should have COG. Someone please correct me if I misspoke.

Quote from: REF: General Counsel of the Department of Defense and Article 4 of the Third Geneva Convention
The determination of enemy combatant status has traditionally resided with the military commander who is authorized to engage the enemy with deadly force. In this regard, the task ultimately falls within the President’s constitutional responsibility as Commander in Chief to identify which forces and persons to engage or capture and detain during an armed conflict. There is no requirement that the President make such determinations personally, and in the vast majority of cases he does not do so. Rather, consistent with longstanding historical practice and applicable rules of engagement, the task is normally a function of the military command structure.

“Enemy combatant” is a general category that subsumes two sub-categories: lawful and unlawful combatants. Lawful combatants receive prisoner of war (POW) status and the protections of the Third Geneva Convention. Unlawful combatants do not receive POW status and do not receive the full protections of the Third Geneva Convention. The President has determined that Al Qaida members are unlawful combatants because (among other reasons) they are members of a non-state actor terrorist group that does not receive the protections of the Third Geneva Convention.

clshade

Re: Drone Policy... thoughts?
« Reply #9 on: February 11, 2013, 09:20:16 PM »
"Drones" - more accurately Unmanned Aerial Vehicles - are a great idea from any perspective except a myopic, technophobic point of view.

None of our soldiers are in harms way. With the sensor array on the military UAV's we have WAAAAAAY more information for making good decisions in the field than we ever have and the pilots have direct access to the chain of command in making tough calls. If this was WWII no one would even be asking this question - not even the bleeding hearts.

It is not WWII, however, and instead it is the "war" on terror and we have Americans that are also "enemy combatants" That's the problem, not that we use drones against them.

It is ~very~ murky, mucky legal territory. The US, since the Reign of King Bush II, has considered terrorists to be the same as enemy troops in the "war" on terror. This legal muck is what has brought us a law that is in direct conflict with habeas corpus - the rider on the NDAA. There something for everyone to be offended by there.

As for use of UAV's on home soil... I believe the ones being used in the search for the cop killer belong to law enforcement agencies instead of the military. I haven't looked into it but I would be ~very~ surprised if military drones were exempt from the prohibition against using the US military on our home soil except in the case of defense.

Drones are just machines, remote controlled helicopters on steroids. You can build them yourself and they've been used by journalists, activists, hobbyists, and law enforcement agencies along with the military. I think many people mistakenly assume that any drone is a military drone.

The drone strike policy is nothing more than saying something like "yes, we can hit Americans with artillery if they are in the terrorists training camp when we shell it."

Heavies

Re: Drone Policy... thoughts?
« Reply #10 on: February 12, 2013, 03:19:28 AM »
The policy itself is what I have issue with.  One should not allow administrative mandate to issue kill orders specifically on an American citizen just because someone somewhere says they are a terrorist.  If they happen to be in a known enemy camp, hanging out with the badguys, at the time the place gets blown the hell up, then I am fine with that, but if they are specifically targeting an American citizen, then that is where the problem starts.  That is a little too much like political assassination to me. This is what make folks jump into the tinfoil hat camp when a bunch of 2A supporters mysteriously start to meet untimely ends.  Like I said, who (really) gets to decide who is a terrorist? 

Cougar8045

Re: Drone Policy... thoughts?
« Reply #11 on: February 12, 2013, 07:45:23 AM »
I didn't see anything about drone strikes on American soil, unless I missed that. My view is irregardless of nationality, if U.S. intel definitively concludes suspected terrorist leaders or senior members in a terrorist organization present an imminent threat to U.S. citizens, it's homeland or national interests, a drone strike is appropriate on foreign soil, not on U.S. soil, and this is irregardless of what party resides in the White House.

However, the article says “The condition that an operational leader present an ‘imminent’ threat of violent attack against the United States does not require the United States to have clear evidence that a specific attack on U.S. persons and interests will take place in the immediate future.” This is where I disagree with the policy...seems they can pull the trigger without conclusive evidence and this involves American lives in this scenario.

I believe once a citizen of any nationality becomes a terrorist, hell bent on destroying the U.S. and killing as many American's as possible, he now is classified as an enemy combatant and should be treated as such. Just because he is a U.S. citizen, shouldn't change the definition of an enemy combatant. JMHO
With this policy in place, George Washington, Martha Washington, and their entire extended family would have been wiped out with a Hellfire missile during a wedding reception. 

There is no definition of "hell bent on destrying the US and killing as many Americans as possible".  Do you have an AR or AK?  You know the only reason for a private citizen to own one of those things is to kill as many Americans as possible, right?  That's what Grandpa Joe keeps saying.  Now you're frequenting a far right-wing anonymous message board with probable ties to various Hawaiian sovereignty groups, some of which advocate the violent overthrow of the US government.  You seem sort of hell-bent already.  Do you handload?  Holy shit, now we've a got an extreme right-wing activist with a cache of assault weapons and bomb making supplies.  Keep an eye on the sky, my friend, not that you'll ever see it coming. 
I'm just a fluffy white bunny rabbit who lost his way. 

"If a thief be found breaking in, and be smitten that he die, there shall no blood be shed for him. ..."  -Exodus 22:2

Cougar8045

Re: Drone Policy... thoughts?
« Reply #12 on: February 12, 2013, 07:52:12 AM »
The drone strike policy is nothing more than saying something like "yes, we can hit Americans with artillery if they are in the terrorists training camp when we shell it."
No, the drone strike policy says something more along the lines of, "If you are an American citizen we can use remote-controlled planes to hunt you down in a neutral country and assassinate you.  Even if you're not in a terrorist training camp.  Even if you've never been to one.  Even if you're just out for a drive with your wife and kids.  And once we've turned you and your extended family into charred chunks of meat and a smoking crater, we don't have to justify it to a single soul.  Feck you and your family.  'Merica!
I'm just a fluffy white bunny rabbit who lost his way. 

"If a thief be found breaking in, and be smitten that he die, there shall no blood be shed for him. ..."  -Exodus 22:2

clshade

Re: Drone Policy... thoughts?
« Reply #13 on: February 12, 2013, 08:28:33 AM »
^^^^

Yes, and we can, and do, that with any number of other technologies. Drones just make it easier. Which is my point: drones make it scary and visceral but are not the problem. The problem is the legal gray area that the drones are exposing about who an "enemy combatant" is and who makes that decision.

Drones are the "scary black guns" of overweening government power and intrusiveness. Its already overweening and intrusive - drones just make it more obvious.

new guy

Re: Drone Policy... thoughts?
« Reply #14 on: February 12, 2013, 08:43:26 AM »
.
« Last Edit: August 25, 2016, 06:21:30 AM by new guy »
Your mindset is your primary weapon. - Jeff Cooper

clshade

Re: Drone Policy... thoughts?
« Reply #15 on: February 12, 2013, 10:45:11 AM »
 :thumbsup:

Why is it that UAV's are different than other forms of military intelligence gathering and ordinance? Is there some other magical form of military ordinance that DOESN'T include human error? Why are UAV's held to a different standard?

Is it that UAV's make possible, even easy, things that we don't think our government should be doing?

Or, as is my point, is it just making OBVIOUS that our government can and does do things that we don't think they should be doing?

How is it more complex than a "simple" artillery strike? An artillery strike relies on intelligence to aim a strike at a target from a relatively safe, and ideally concealed, vantage point. That used to take a lot of different elements, from on the ground spotters to chain of command decision makers, communicating and coordinating in as close to real time as possible. UAV's facilitate that from an ideal vantage point and make the decisions almost real time. It isn't doing anything different than an artillery strike, its just making all those parts required for a strike MUCH easier and faster to coordinate. It doesn't eliminate the fog of war and mistakes happen but it isn't doing anything materially different than any other form of strike except making it easier, more covert, safer for the operators and quicker.

That's why I say they are only a bad idea from a myopic technophobic perspective. As pieces of hardware there is nothing intrinsically immoral about UAV's. 

As for the decisions about HOW and WHY that hardware is used.... that's a completely different issue. That is about the legal use of force and the Federal Government has been increasing shrugging off limitations on its use of force since the end of WWII and particularly after Vietnam.

I'm suggesting that discussions of "Drone Policy" potentially miss the root problem by focusing on "Drone" rather than "Policy."


new guy

Re: Drone Policy... thoughts?
« Reply #16 on: February 12, 2013, 11:25:26 AM »
.
« Last Edit: August 25, 2016, 06:22:20 AM by new guy »
Your mindset is your primary weapon. - Jeff Cooper

Bunker

Re: Drone Policy... thoughts?
« Reply #17 on: February 12, 2013, 11:26:59 AM »
With this policy in place, George Washington, Martha Washington, and their entire extended family would have been wiped out with a Hellfire missile during a wedding reception. 

There is no definition of "hell bent on destrying the US and killing as many Americans as possible".  Do you have an AR or AK?  You know the only reason for a private citizen to own one of those things is to kill as many Americans as possible, right?  That's what Grandpa Joe keeps saying.  Now you're frequenting a far right-wing anonymous message board with probable ties to various Hawaiian sovereignty groups, some of which advocate the violent overthrow of the US government.  You seem sort of hell-bent already.  Do you handload?  Holy shit, now we've a got an extreme right-wing activist with a cache of assault weapons and bomb making supplies.  Keep an eye on the sky, my friend, not that you'll ever see it coming.

Point taken. Ok, embellished (hell bent on destrying the US and killing as many Americans as possible) but my point/intent was the same as the "official" definition below and in the context of terrorists organizations..

“The President has determined that al Qaida members are unlawful combatants because (among other reasons) they are members of a non-state actor terrorist group that does not receive the protections of the Third Geneva Convention. Although the President’s determination on this issue is final, courts have concurred with his determination.”

Unlawful combatants are individuals who directly participate in hostilities without being authorized by governmental authority or under international law to do so. Unlawful combatants who engage in hostilities violate Law of Armed Conflict (LOAC) and become lawful targets. They may be killed or wounded and, if captured, may be tried as war criminals for their LOAC violations.

clshade

Re: Drone Policy... thoughts?
« Reply #18 on: February 12, 2013, 11:30:53 AM »
What about innocent bystanders?

Doesn't killing inordinate amounts of civilians make us war criminals? Is there a Geneva (or other) Convention for defining that somewhere?

Bunker

Re: Drone Policy... thoughts?
« Reply #19 on: February 12, 2013, 11:47:20 AM »
The policy itself is what I have issue with.  One should not allow administrative mandate to issue kill orders specifically on an American citizen just because someone somewhere says they are a terrorist.  If they happen to be in a known enemy camp, hanging out with the badguys, at the time the place gets blown the hell up, then I am fine with that, but if they are specifically targeting an American citizen, then that is where the problem starts.  That is a little too much like political assassination to me. This is what make folks jump into the tinfoil hat camp when a bunch of 2A supporters mysteriously start to meet untimely ends.  Like I said, who (really) gets to decide who is a terrorist?

Point taken and agree. Valid concern but I don’t think there is an unclassified answer and specific belly-buttons by name. The President as Commander and Chief has ultimate authority and can delegate that authority to engage the enemy with deadly force. I would think that any such delegation of authority would be limited to a very small group of military flag-level/senior officers and/or Senior Executive Service (SES) by position in the COG structure. Probably depending on threat priority would be a determining factor how far up the COC the decision resides.

I agree the policy is murky at best and I "disagree" with the new policy Obama is proposing (listed previously in this thread) but at some point we must have some level of confidence and faith in our military command structure and their ability to make sound, rational decisions based on "creditable intel." JMHO