I've really enjoyed this discussion, by the way.

Jl808, we actually agree on that but I think we're focusing on a couple of different things.
What I'm describing is applied "rights", for lack of a better term. Its very darwinian and that is the sad part. Agencies and authorities break and misuse laws all the time, sometimes they suffer consequences for it. Those consequences come from our morality, no doubt about that. Usually the greater sense of morality prevents such things from happening in the first place. But not all the time.
Its like a cop stopping you for no good reason then demanding to search your car. They have no legal authority to do so... but they do it anyway. A more shocking example is the internment of the Japanese Americans during WWII. The Constitution specifically says they had the right to not be shuffled off to internment camps... but the President did it anyway.
At that level of reality it doesn't much matter where we think our rights come from since it is the "authorities" that are preventing us from exercising them. It is in the court of law, not the court of morality, that such issues are resolved. The philosophy and morality is what inspired the laws in the first place but after that we are in the Darwinian world of what is legal and what in not instead of what is moral and what is not. The best (and worst) lawyers thrive in the gap between what is moral and what is legal.
Philosophy and morality are hugely important in creating legal systems and in legal defense strategies. It is almost entirely irrelevant to what will happen for the armed marcher standing on the bridge to D.C. if he goes forward into a police line that is committed to enforcing D.C. no open carry law. The law says its a felony even if that is morally and philosophically at odds with the Constitution.
The only reason I raised this distinction in the first place is that it is the territory this armed march event is venturing into. On moral and philosophical grounds the organizer intends to prove whether or not "free people" are welcome in the country's capital. Meanwhile, the law of the land has already defined what they wish to do as a felony. For a large portion of the populace committing a felony is, by definition, immoral. I don't think enough people are yet concerned that the enforced infringements of the 2nd amendment (of which there are many) are also immoral. So in this case the unconstitutional law as it stands is supported by the majority's sense of morality - in some cases because those people are actually anti-gun but in most cases it is simply considered moral because it is the law.
Its absolutely true that morality leads to laws. Unfortunately, most people are wired to then assume that laws = moral and it takes a mighty stiff shove to shift them off that default position.