2aHawaii

General Topics => Legal and Activism => Topic started by: bubba808 on February 24, 2014, 06:42:36 PM

Title: yet another reason to not escalate straight to deadly force if ccw were allowed
Post by: bubba808 on February 24, 2014, 06:42:36 PM
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mMQD2vNO_Jw&feature=youtube_gdata_player (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mMQD2vNO_Jw&feature=youtube_gdata_player)
I believe the situation is bigger 25yo argues with 44yo and 44 year old defends his wife/family, 25yo takes a swing, 44yo KOs 25yo.
Title: Re: yet another reason to not escalate straight to deadly force if ccw were allowed
Post by: suka on February 24, 2014, 07:07:37 PM
like
Title: Re: yet another reason to not escalate straight to deadly force if ccw were allowed
Post by: Lifer on February 24, 2014, 07:12:35 PM
Love it.

Punk was out for awhile... Ha :thumbsup:
Title: Re: yet another reason to not escalate straight to deadly force if ccw were allowed
Post by: Haoleb on February 24, 2014, 07:43:49 PM
In that situation if the older guy drew a weapon and fired he would almost certainly be prosecuted. He did not try to leave the situation. For anyone who keeps a firearm in their home or plans to carry if legal carry comes to Hawaii I would highly suggest reading "In the gravest extreme" by Massad Ayoob. It is not a terribly long read but a very matter-of-fact presentation of what it means to possess that kind of responsibility. I recently bought it and read it myself and it is a good start to carrying.
Title: Re: yet another reason to not escalate straight to deadly force if ccw were allowed
Post by: Scar16 on February 24, 2014, 08:03:26 PM
Ya got knocked the fk out by an old guy mr. 25 yr old lol  :thumbsup: :rofl:
Title: Re: yet another reason to not escalate straight to deadly force if ccw were allowed
Post by: pastordennis on February 24, 2014, 08:35:22 PM
LIKE
Title: Re: yet another reason to not escalate straight to deadly force if ccw were allowed
Post by: ren on February 24, 2014, 08:47:18 PM
http://www.staradvertiser.com/s?action=login&f=y&id=246845141 (http://www.staradvertiser.com/s?action=login&f=y&id=246845141)
another scenario.
Even in the case of Roosevelt High there is still public sentiment about shooting a mentally challenged teenager; despite him having a knife.
Imagine if you and your family of four were encountered by a mentally (not crazy anymore) teen armed with a knife.
Now parents of these mentally challenged teens are pushing for more sympathy (read imposing responsibility on the govt.) from the public.
Title: Re: yet another reason to not escalate straight to deadly force if ccw were allowed
Post by: edster48 on February 24, 2014, 09:11:51 PM
http://www.staradvertiser.com/s?action=login&f=y&id=246845141 (http://www.staradvertiser.com/s?action=login&f=y&id=246845141)
another scenario.
Even in the case of Roosevelt High there is still public sentiment about shooting a mentally challenged teenager; despite him having a knife.
Imagine if you and your family of four were encountered by a mentally (not crazy anymore) teen armed with a knife.
Now parents of these mentally challenged teens are pushing for more sympathy (read imposing responsibility on the govt.) from the public.


Yeah, I read this in the paper this morning. How "cruel and unfeeling" it is for the public to actually expect to be protected from 6' tall 250 lb mentally unstable, violent individuals.
Especially when it "only" costs us 200k per bed at the youth correctional facility, per year.
My heart truly bleeds, in fact, I'm feeling a tear coming to my eye right now........... :'(
Title: Re: yet another reason to not escalate straight to deadly force if ccw were allowed
Post by: ImKu on February 24, 2014, 10:14:02 PM
http://www.staradvertiser.com/s?action=login&f=y&id=246845141 (http://www.staradvertiser.com/s?action=login&f=y&id=246845141)
another scenario.
Even in the case of Roosevelt High there is still public sentiment about shooting a mentally challenged teenager; despite him having a knife.
Imagine if you and your family of four were encountered by a mentally (not crazy anymore) teen armed with a knife.
Now parents of these mentally challenged teens are pushing for more sympathy (read imposing responsibility on the govt.) from the public.


Little off topic... but for this,  you need to understand both sides.  I am totally for defending yourself and your loved ones, especially if a weapon is involved,  and given the situation that was reported I agree with the actions of the officers.  With that said, the number of "mentally challenged"  is quite high (i want to say 1 in 20 or so), and if you ever worked with them and been around them for years to include their family, you would understand where the sympathy comes from.  Unfortunately,  not all these "mentally challenged" people come from loving families... Not an excuse, but some of these individuals are just angry all the time.  Not to say this is the case in this particular incident.
Here's one for thought, imagine having a child that never showed affection, only aggressiveness and anger.  I've seen it, and it's hard on the parents.   I count my own blessings as I don't know if I could handle that.  Just my .02 as to why there may be people sympathetic.
Title: Re: yet another reason to not escalate straight to deadly force if ccw were allowed
Post by: kong on February 25, 2014, 07:38:27 AM
Hindsight is 20-20.  Hence the reasonable officer/person standard knowing what a reasonable person/officer knows at the time of the incident without having hindsight.  Now deconfliction as well as doing a tactical retreat, though LEO's have no duty to retreat.
Title: Re: yet another reason to not escalate straight to deadly force if ccw were allowed
Post by: HiCarry on February 25, 2014, 08:25:23 AM
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mMQD2vNO_Jw&feature=youtube_gdata_player (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mMQD2vNO_Jw&feature=youtube_gdata_player)
I believe the situation is bigger 25yo argues with 44yo and 44 year old defends his wife/family, 25yo takes a swing, 44yo KOs 25yo.
I don't think anyone was advocating that one's first move in the event you are involved in a confrontation was to use deadly force, but rather that having that option in reserve would be "nice." It was fortunate that the "older" gentleman had the skills necessary (and the physical capabilities) to handle the situation without having to resort to deadly force. But what if that wasn't the case, or that the others on the younger guy's side appeared to be more "involved" in the confrontation creating a disparity of force? What if the older guy had a heart condition that precluded him from engaging in strenuous physical activity?

The bottom line is that it is difficult to know all the circumstances of this situation, or other self defense situations and therefore difficult to discern with any certainty whether the actions the older guy took were reasonable. One of the reasons I favor "Stand your ground" laws is that in 20-20 hindsight it is pretty easy to say "you should have retreated" rather than escalated to deadly force. In the heat of the confrontation, the door or hallway behind you offered may not be seen, the demeanor of the aggressor may seem more menacing, or the mental condition may not be obvious. Therefore it seems prudent to allow the law abiding person to act to defend himself without the possibility of someone after the fact saying "..you should have..."

With all that being said, I think it is important to discuss these types of situations, both with your peers and with yourself and your family. Those discusisons, IMHO, should be open and honest, accepting of differing opinions, but without the "I know better because of my super secret, high speed training that I can't tell you about but you should believe otherwise you're just an idiot and will go to jail" type of attitudes. Personally, I am happy to learn from those with more experience, I just want to know what that experience is....

Just my opinion.....
Title: Re: yet another reason to not escalate straight to deadly force if ccw were allowed
Post by: aieahound on February 25, 2014, 10:21:45 AM
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mMQD2vNO_Jw&feature=youtube_gdata_player (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mMQD2vNO_Jw&feature=youtube_gdata_player)
I believe the situation is bigger 25yo argues with 44yo and 44 year old defends his wife/family, 25yo takes a swing, 44yo KOs 25yo.

I saw the exact same thing happen when I was in High School camping at Bellows.

2 old guys, at least 50, sitting on a picnic table when a young 20-something guy came up and started going off on one of them.
Old guy not being berated stands up and young guy calls him out.
Young guy starts doing the monkey dance while old guy just circles him.
BAM ! one punch from old guy and young guy was nappy nappy.
It was awesome.

Personally though, I think if you're carrying, you have a higher duty/responsibility to try to de-escalate.
It looks like the old guy was trying to de-escalate this situation when Junior swung at thim.

Interesting question though, Could this situation have justified use of deadly force ?
Much larger and younger individual, took an unprovoked swing.

What about brandishing ?
Title: Re: yet another reason to not escalate straight to deadly force if ccw were allowed
Post by: kia_killer on February 25, 2014, 10:36:15 AM
I don't think anyone was advocating that one's first move in the event you are involved in a confrontation was to use deadly force, but rather that having that option in reserve would be "nice." It was fortunate that the "older" gentleman had the skills necessary (and the physical capabilities) to handle the situation without having to resort to deadly force. But what if that wasn't the case, or that the others on the younger guy's side appeared to be more "involved" in the confrontation creating a disparity of force? What if the older guy had a heart condition that precluded him from engaging in strenuous physical activity?

The bottom line is that it is difficult to know all the circumstances of this situation, or other self defense situations and therefore difficult to discern with any certainty whether the actions the older guy took were reasonable. One of the reasons I favor "Stand your ground" laws is that in 20-20 hindsight it is pretty easy to say "you should have retreated" rather than escalated to deadly force. In the heat of the confrontation, the door or hallway behind you offered may not be seen, the demeanor of the aggressor may seem more menacing, or the mental condition may not be obvious. Therefore it seems prudent to allow the law abiding person to act to defend himself without the possibility of someone after the fact saying "..you should have..."

With all that being said, I think it is important to discuss these types of situations, both with your peers and with yourself and your family. Those discusisons, IMHO, should be open and honest, accepting of differing opinions, but without the "I know better because of my super secret, high speed training that I can't tell you about but you should believe otherwise you're just an idiot and will go to jail" type of attitudes. Personally, I am happy to learn from those with more experience, I just want to know what that experience is....

Just my opinion.....

Bingo.
Title: Re: yet another reason to not escalate straight to deadly force if ccw were allowed
Post by: HiCarry on February 25, 2014, 02:09:01 PM

Personally though, I think if you're carrying, you have a higher duty/responsibility to try to de-escalate.
It looks like the old guy was trying to de-escalate this situation when Junior swung at thim.

Interesting question though, Could this situation have justified use of deadly force ?
Much larger and younger individual, took an unprovoked swing.

What about brandishing ?

I agree. If you are carrying a gun and it appears (via witness statements or video..) that you did not try to deescalate the situation, you would likely find it more difficult (not impossible) to successfully use a self defense claim in this type of situation. On the other hand, it did seem like the older guy was trying to deescalate the situation.

So, as a thought exercise, what would you (not "you" specifically, but as an open question to the forum participants) have done, supposing you did not have the ability to physically fight back? What steps would you have taken to deescalate the situation and where would your "line in the sand" be if you had a legal firearm? Would you do anything different if you didn't have a firearm in the same situation?

As for brandishing, most jurisdictions don't consider pulling a firearm out in preparation to use it brandishing, but catching that charge is still a possibility.

And, how about we keep this civil and on-target without the "you're stupid and will go to jail if you don't do as I say" type of comments....
Title: Re: yet another reason to not escalate straight to deadly force if ccw were allowed
Post by: pastordennis on February 25, 2014, 08:15:16 PM
    **
    Posts: 81
    Referrals: 0
        View Profile
        Email
        Personal Message (Offline)

Re: yet another reason to not escalate straight to deadly force if ccw were allowed
« Reply #9 on: Today at 07:38:27 AM »

    Quote

Hindsight is 20-20.  Hence the reasonable officer/person standard knowing what a reasonable person/officer knows at the time of the incident without having hindsight.  Now deconfliction as well as doing a tactical retreat, though LEO's have no duty to retreat.


Leo's have no duty to retreat and neither should law abiding citizens. That is B.S. for the GOV. to even think this.
Title: Re: yet another reason to not escalate straight to deadly force if ccw were allowed
Post by: bubba808 on February 25, 2014, 09:34:44 PM
I don't think anyone was advocating that one's first move in the event you are involved in a confrontation was to use deadly force, but rather that having that option in reserve would be "nice." 

I agree, its wasnt the first move, but some of the moves discussed were straight towards it...I think it was along the lines of....
"say stop, yell stop, present force, use force if persisted. "
and
"Intent, opportunity, capability are met, ... use of force is justified"
and
"....Imagine drawing and holding your firearm, which you drew because you feared the guy would actually do what he just told you he would do to you, and then the aggressor tackles you and takes your gun from you. 
I'd shoot him first.  Anyone stupid enough to tackle someone holding a gun on them is also stupid enough to try and kill you over a stupid argument...
It's simple math:  he terrorizes you verbally + you have a gun + he continues to attack
Gun drawn = reasonable fear of serious injury/death = upper hand
Attacker seeing he is outgunned continues = high/stupid/angry enough to kill..."


But what if that wasn't the case, or that the others on the younger guy's side appeared to be more "involved" in the confrontation creating a disparity of force?Lets start with leaving the scene... just get your gear and family and go...shake your head, call police, whatever. 
What if the older guy had a heart condition that precluded him from engaging in strenuous physical activity? Slowly walk away gripping your chest...
the problem I have with the what if scenarios you keep presenting is I think if you only bring up and discuss the extremes of possibilities on the side justifying force instead of a series of scenarios with multiple outcomes.  If only the extreme on the side of use is discussed and the "when not to's" are ignored, then it almost seems as though the norm is justification and use of that force. 

I agree with certain parts of your statements however, i think an individuals behavior will be based on personal morals and values.  Id just like to say that IMHO, because you can justifying use of deadly force,  doesnt necessitate it.. Although it differs from my personal beliefs, i can understand use of a firearm as a LAST RESORT, but why deadly? Why not to wound to allow your escape?   


The bottom line is that it is difficult to know all the circumstances of this situation, or other self defense situations and therefore difficult to discern with any certainty whether the actions the older guy took were reasonable. One of the reasons I favor "Stand your ground" laws is that in 20-20 hindsight it is pretty easy to say "you should have retreated" rather than escalated to deadly force.I think there is a stand your ground law, and it doesnt involve a gun.  If you want to stand your ground, stand it, and you should have the same weapons at your disposal as your attacker.  (I think this comes from watching too much kung fu movies when i was a kid, lol) The alternative choice for you would be walk away. 
In the heat of the confrontation, the door or hallway behind you offered may not be seen, the demeanor of the aggressor may seem more menacing, or the mental condition may not be obvious. Therefore it seems prudent to allow the law abiding person to act to defend himself without the possibility of someone after the fact saying "..you should have..."
again with scenarios, I caution you in your use as seeming menacing or having a mental condition should not imo justify defending with presentation or use of deadly force.  Its interesting how different people percieve things differently, which is really what I think we are talking about here with these videos... I think its important to discuss as I think some of the views expressed are based on perceptions that individuals have, but differ from the the norm of society here in Hawaii.  In Hawaii people act a little different than what some may be used to, but if youre not familiar with how people act here ... and how they understand you, your perception of a threat may be incorrect, therefore your actions not justified.  I brought up in another thread a "what if "about a haka... if you see it, it might be menacing to you, but normal to the people of the island, so you yell stop da haka, show your gun, den if haka continues, bang, bang? Not good.

With all that being said, I think it is important to discuss these types of situations, both with your peers and with yourself and your family. Those discusisons, IMHO, should be open and honest, accepting of differing opinions...
HiCarry,   I especially like this part about open talking with family and friends and having a discussion and i hope a plan for these situations if/when they arise

Just my opinion.....
Title: Re: yet another reason to not escalate straight to deadly force if ccw were allowed
Post by: bubba808 on February 25, 2014, 10:53:33 PM
I saw the exact same thing happen when I was in High School camping at Bellows.

2 old guys, at least 50, sitting on a picnic table when a young 20-something guy came up and started going off on one of them.
Old guy not being berated stands up and young guy calls him out.
Young guy starts doing the monkey dance while old guy just circles him.
BAM ! one punch from old guy and young guy was nappy nappy.
It was awesome.
it sounds awesome
Personally though, I think if you're carrying, you have a higher duty/responsibility to try to de-escalate.
It looks like the old guy was trying to de-escalate this situation when Junior swung at thim.

Interesting question though, Could this situation have justified use of deadly force ?
some would argue yes, justified, but I would say uncle did a great job just like that, so in my opinion, not necessary
Much larger and younger individual, took an unprovoked swing.
yup, despite this, still did great.
What about brandishing ?
brandishing?, who is she? She sounds exquisite.  LoL.  Seriously,  its the risk you take if you engage and try to "stand your ground".  Me personally, I woulda walked... if da guy like chase, den im gonna use whatever means i have at my disposal to defend myself without killing da guy.
Title: Re: yet another reason to not escalate straight to deadly force if ccw were allowed
Post by: Q on February 26, 2014, 12:28:40 AM
This topic is constantly being resurrected because one group of individuals feel that people should fight with their fists before deadly force is presented/applied in a self-defense situation. Lets examine the facts:

Proponents of the above video claim that this is an ideal situation as to how a situation can be handled via hand-to-hand combat. What these individuals are failing to mention is that the individual who knocked the punk ass idiot out actually is in the advantageous position in this instance, due to the following:

a) The defender is bigger than the aggressor. Because of his height advantage, and the fact that his arms are either the same size or slightly longer than the aggressor, he now has a mechanical / physiological advantage in that he can generate far more force in a a far more efficient manner, all while maintaining adequate distance to make the aggressors attacks ineffective. Let's assume the aggressor in this video is 5'8, and the defender is 5'10. What would have happened if the defender was 5'6? What would have happened if it was one of the females instead of this male? This changes the dynamic of the whole situation, and in fact changes the perception of threat to the individual, should the roles have been different, and the defender been a smaller, weaker individual compared to the aggressor.

b) The aggressor is not only drunk, but his motor skills are severely impaired. Look at how he staggers around the beach, his speech is sporadic, and how physically impaired he was to throw the punch and respond the the counter-attack of the defender. Alcohol is a depressant, meaning that it suppresses many of the physiological and neurological functions of the body/brain, thus 'impairing' them. Its easy to beat a guy up who is drunk off his ass and falling all over the place, but what would have happened if the individual had instead been using some type of stimulant like an amphetamine? People on stimulants normally aren't staggering all over the place, as these drugs actually promote the production of adrenaline and dopamine in the system, resulting in a higher threshold for pain, better command of motor skills (in terms of attack), and the ability to sustain a prolonged attack than a drunk person due to the decreased response of fatigue.

Self-defense is defined as the ability to neutralize a threat effectively and efficiently, all while reducing the possibility of bodily injury or harm to oneself or other individuals. If someone has the ability to say, 'stop or you will be shot' vs having to risk potential bodily harm by getting into a fist fight, which is more effective and efficient and reducing the risk of bodily injury to the defender, all while neutralizing the threat? And unarmed combat is only necessary because of the following: either the laws of the area do not allow one to defend themselves with weapons, or unarmed combat is taught as an alternative form of self-defense in the event that the weapon is unavailable to be used at the precise moment. In the latter case, either the threat is neutralized because the individual will not have a chance to obtain his/her weapon at all, or it allows the individual to gain the advantageous position in which to obtain his/her weapon and further neutralize the threat without further unnecessary risk to his/herself.

I will agree with bubba808 on the fact of walking away. But if there is no ability to walk away, then I am neutralizing the threat in the most effective means possible.
Title: Re: yet another reason to not escalate straight to deadly force if ccw were allowed
Post by: HiCarry on February 26, 2014, 09:00:53 AM

I agree, its wasnt the first move, but some of the moves discussed were straight towards it...I think it was along the lines of....
"say stop, yell stop, present force, use force if persisted. "
and
"Intent, opportunity, capability are met, ... use of force is justified"

And here is where perception and your personal capabilities come into play. If individuals feel they can go hand to hand and be successful, then by all means, do so. Unfortunately, many of those who advocate this method may have little actual experience with trying to physically control a drunk or drugged individual. I generally feel pretty comfortable going "hands on" but in a true life or death situation, my experience tells me controlling such a person, especially alone, is fraught with the possibility that you will be over powered. I have been involved in many, many, many "take downs" of violent individuals over the course of my career. And I can tell you that even with several well trained and capable individuals, physically subduing someone isn't always as easy as it is in the movies. Someone who knows the reality of this situation isn't likely to put himself into a situation where the "bad guy" has a good change of overpowering him before going to his gun. That would place the "good guy" at a severe tactical advantage, including then being unable to access and utilize his gun.

and
"....Imagine drawing and holding your firearm, which you drew because you feared the guy would actually do what he just told you he would do to you, and then the aggressor tackles you and takes your gun from you. 
I'd shoot him first.  Anyone stupid enough to tackle someone holding a gun on them is also stupid enough to try and kill you over a stupid argument...
It's simple math:  he terrorizes you verbally + you have a gun + he continues to attack
Gun drawn = reasonable fear of serious injury/death = upper hand
Attacker seeing he is outgunned continues = high/stupid/angry enough to kill..."

I think there are a couple of points to examine here. First, as mentioned above, many with experience in dealing with violent individuals realize that going "one on one" with a nutjob isn't necessarily a great idea (Think ICE or PCP.....) and may advocate going to the gun early. I can't say I disagree, and that in some instances, such as those with physical disabilities or kids/spouses to care for that make it impractical to leave expediently, it may be the only choice. Again, it is a personal choice, one that you may have to justify at trial and that will be judged as to "reasonableness," but a personal choice nonetheless. And there is a lot of truth in assuming that any individual that would charge you while holding a gun is also dumb/crazy/drugged/drunk enough to try and hurt or kill you over a stupid argument. It is a fallacy to think that you can reason with, or deal logically with someone so deranged.

But what if that wasn't the case, or that the others on the younger guy's side appeared to be more "involved" in the confrontation creating a disparity of force?Lets start with leaving the scene... just get your gear and family and go...shake your head, call police, whatever.

I agree. Leave the scene if you can. But what if that's not practical? What if you have family, friends, high value items that you cannot gather up without letting down your guard and placing yourself in a tactically disadvantageous position? Hard to defend yourself if you're carrying your igloo back to the car.....I do think that he should have called 911, or directed someone else to do so. Getting the police there should be a priority, but not necessarily THE priority.
 
What if the older guy had a heart condition that precluded him from engaging in strenuous physical activity? Slowly walk away gripping your chest...

I suspect that was an attempt to inject some levity, so I'll do the same, adding that you should also be gripping the butt of your firearm....

the problem I have with the what if scenarios you keep presenting is I think if you only bring up and discuss the extremes of possibilities on the side justifying force instead of a series of scenarios with multiple outcomes.  If only the extreme on the side of use is discussed and the "when not to's" are ignored, then it almost seems as though the norm is justification and use of that force. 

There are lot's of folks that may think going to the gun early is the answer. That may, or may not, be "correct" which is why I think rationally discussing these types of situations is the best way to look at many different possibilities and solutions. It is always best to have options, including avoiding the situation if possible, but also the option to use a firearm if the situation dictates. Discussing options also helps ferret out the internet warriors who's only options are to go to the gun. Stating unequivocally that you just need to walk away or to always go immediately go to the gun dismisses the great many viable options that may be available, and is an indicator that you are not open to a reasoned, rational discussion on the matter.

I agree with certain parts of your statements however, i think an individuals behavior will be based on personal morals and values.  Id just like to say that IMHO, because you can justifying use of deadly force,  doesnt necessitate it.. Although it differs from my personal beliefs, i can understand use of a firearm as a LAST RESORT, but why deadly? Why not to wound to allow your escape?   

I think your statement suggests that you are not very familiar with the realities of self defense with a firearm. If you have moral objections to using deadly force, that is your prerogative. But don't expect others to agree. I suggest that anyone considering buying a gun for protection have a very frank discussion with themselves about whether or not you are capable of using it and taking a human life. If you are not fully committed to using that firearm and willing to take a life to protect you or your family, you shouldn't have a gun for that purpose. That being said, once you make the decision to get a gun, you should endeavor to learn as much as possible about it and the subject of self defense. If you had done that, you would have realized how, and I say this without trying to insult you, ignorant you are on the subject. You do not, and I will repeat this, you do not shoot to wound!! You shoot to stop the threat, which means getting rounds into the largest area of the bad guy that will likely stop his progress. That means center mass. I'll say it again....you NEVER, NEVER, NEVER, shoot to wound.

The bottom line is that it is difficult to know all the circumstances of this situation, or other self defense situations and therefore difficult to discern with any certainty whether the actions the older guy took were reasonable. One of the reasons I favor "Stand your ground" laws is that in 20-20 hindsight it is pretty easy to say "you should have retreated" rather than escalated to deadly force.I think there is a stand your ground law, and it doesnt involve a gun.  If you want to stand your ground, stand it, and you should have the same weapons at your disposal as your attacker.  (I think this comes from watching too much kung fu movies when i was a kid, lol) The alternative choice for you would be walk away. 

Stand Your Ground (SYG) laws are just that. It simply says that if you are lawfully in a place you are not mandated to retreat. It does not automatically justify a claim of self defense, nor does it somehow allow you to "shoot first and ask questions later. You can "stand your ground" with or without a firearm, but to suggest that you should then only have the same weapon as the aggressor is naive and, as you suggest, probably comes from fantasy rather than reality. And again, avoid the situation is always the better choice, IMHO, but that does not mean that circumstances may preclude that option.

In the heat of the confrontation, the door or hallway behind you offered may not be seen, the demeanor of the aggressor may seem more menacing, or the mental condition may not be obvious. Therefore it seems prudent to allow the law abiding person to act to defend himself without the possibility of someone after the fact saying "..you should have..."
again with scenarios, I caution you in your use as seeming menacing or having a mental condition should not imo justify defending with presentation or use of deadly force.  Its interesting how different people percieve things differently, which is really what I think we are talking about here with these videos... I think its important to discuss as I think some of the views expressed are based on perceptions that individuals have, but differ from the the norm of society here in Hawaii.  In Hawaii people act a little different than what some may be used to, but if youre not familiar with how people act here ... and how they understand you, your perception of a threat may be incorrect, therefore your actions not justified.  I brought up in another thread a "what if "about a haka... if you see it, it might be menacing to you, but normal to the people of the island, so you yell stop da haka, show your gun, den if haka continues, bang, bang? Not good.

But we should not burden the otherwise lawabiding citizen with the requirement that they integrate into their thought process, during the heat of a potential self defense situation, the possibility that the loud, threatening, posturing individual is "just acting up" rather than presenting a credible threat. That's like saying you should have to determine that the gun pointed at you is real and loaded before using deadly force. It simply isn't practical nor possible and to think such a requirement should be imposed is, again, IMHO, a very bad idea. As for other's not "understanding" the "local way." Again, I'm sorry. If you go to the mainland and wander into gang territory, would you suggest that you not be able to use your firearm when one of the gang members was threatening you because in reality, in that area, such threats were merely the "local way" to treat outsiders? I doubt it.

With all that being said, I think it is important to discuss these types of situations, both with your peers and with yourself and your family. Those discusisons, IMHO, should be open and honest, accepting of differing opinions...
HiCarry,   I especially like this part about open talking with family and friends and having a discussion and i hope a plan for these situations if/when they arise

A plan is always good. Discuss with your family what you expect them to do in these situations. They should call the police, stay out of the way, take shelter, or, if trained and equipped, participate in a coordinated effort to provide the family self defense.

Title: Re: yet another reason to not escalate straight to deadly force if ccw were allowed
Post by: Funtimes on February 26, 2014, 10:42:59 PM
Re: Shooting to "Wound"

This is basically how it is:  If you could have "wounded" the guy, then he wasn't enough of a threat to utilize deadly force (otherwise, you would have used it).  The basic thought is that if you aren't willing to stop the threat, then you haven't reached the threshold where you should be pulling the trigger anyways.  Therefore, you just shot someone to shoot them basically!
Title: Re: yet another reason to not escalate straight to deadly force if ccw were allowed
Post by: bubba808 on February 26, 2014, 11:39:11 PM
And here is where perception and your personal capabilities come into play. If individuals feel they can go hand to hand and be successful, then by all means, do so. Unfortunately, many of those who advocate this method may have little actual experience with trying to physically control a drunk or drugged individual. I generally feel pretty comfortable going "hands on" but in atrue life or death situation, my experience tells me controlling such a person, especially alone, is fraught with the possibility that you will be over powered. I have been involved in many, many, many "take downs" of violent individuals over the course of my career. And I can tell you that even with several well trained and capable individuals, physically subduing someone isn't always as easy as it is in the movies. Someone who knows the reality of this situation isn't likely to put himself into a situation where the "bad guy" has a good change of overpowering him before going to his gun. That would place the "good guy" at a severe tactical advantage, including then being unable to access and utilize his gun. 

mahalo for bearing with me as i try to understand your reasoning.  If one has little experience dealing with situations, why not recommend getting training in this area instead of escalating to shooting?
were either this video, the video of the local shouting racial slurs or the thread about the teenage boy getting shot at Roosevelt, where advocating for ccw realy life or death? 


I think there are a couple of points to examine here. First, as mentioned above, many with experience in dealing with violent individuals realize that going "one on one" with a nutjob isn't necessarily a great idea (Think ICE or PCP.....) and may advocate going to the gun early. I can't say I disagree, and that in some instances, such as those with physical disabilities or kids/spouses to care for that make it impractical to leave expediently, it may be the only choice. Again, it is a personal choice, one that you may have to justify at trial and that will be judged as to "reasonableness," but a personal choice nonetheless. And there is a lot of truth in assuming that any individual that would charge you while holding a gun is also dumb/crazy/drugged/drunk enough to try and hurt or kill you over a stupid argument. It is a fallacy to think that you can reason with, or deal logically with someone so deranged.

the "many" you refer actually skews the data as these are people who "deal" with violence on a regular basis.  How many people in Hawaii are actually victims of the crime scenarios you mention? Do you have real crime statistical numbers from Hawaii recently that can prove the threats you percieve as (dumb/crazy/drugged/drunk/deranged) are real and in the quanity to justify ccw?  I mean compared to the mainland, I feel Hawaii is relatively safe and per capita crime is much lower here.   Why is it that in most of your "what if" scenarios, the guy with the gun is either physically weak or is challenging some drunk, drugged crazed fiend? What about if ccw does become common that the drunk, drug crazed fiends will now be packing heat too, so now we gotta worry about the masses being smart enough to use good practices and judgement when using a firearm.  That scares me more than the highly unlikey event of being in a life or death situation here, what do you think? 


I agree. Leave the scene if you can. But what if that's not practical? What if you have family, friends, high value items that you cannot gather up without letting down your guard and placing yourself in a tactically disadvantageous position? Hard to defend yourself if you're carrying your igloo back to the car.....I do think that he should have called 911, or directed someone else to do so. Getting the police there should be a priority, but not necessarily THE priority. 

if its life or death... I say screw practicality, you can run, or try your best to defend yourself.  High value items... maybe not so smart to bring these all over.   Family and friends should join you in your resistance/defense.  Bottom line, pick your battles wisely. 

I suspect that was an attempt to inject some levity,so I'll do the same, adding that you should also be gripping the butt of your firearm....

hey, look at me I learned a new word. LoL,  seriously gripping the butt sounds great, keep it holstered

There are lot's of folks that may think going to the gun early is the answer. That may, or may not, be "correct" which is why I think rationally discussing these types of situations is the best way to look at many different possibilities and solutions. It is always best to have options, including avoiding the situation if possible, but also the option to use a firearm if the situation dictates. Discussing options also helps ferret out the internet warriors who's only options are to go to the gun. Stating unequivocally that you just need to walk away or to always go immediately go to the gun dismisses the great many viable options that may be available, and is an indicator that you are not open to a reasoned, rational discussion on the matter. 

who are these "lots of folks", surely they are in the minority of the population here.  I think when i sat in hunters ed with my wife they shared some statistics like less tahn 3% of Hawaii population legally own guns. i also think that even among firearm owners here in Hawaii I dont think the majority would choose to "go to the gun early" as you say

I think your statement suggests that you are not very familiar with the realities of self defense with a firearm. If you have moral objections to using deadly force, that is your prerogative. But don't expect others to agree. I suggest that anyone considering buying a gun for protection have a very frank discussion with themselves about whether or not you are capable of using it and taking a human life. If you are not fully committed to using that firearm and willing to take a life to protect you or your family, you shouldn't have a gun for that purpose. That being said, once you make the decision to get a gun, you should endeavor to learn as much as possible about it and the subject of self defense. If you had done that, you would have realized how, and [0I say this without trying to insult you, ignorant you are on the subject. You do not, and I will repeat this, you do not shoot to wound!! You shoot to stop the threat, which means getting rounds into the largest area of the bad guy that will likely stop his progress. That means center mass. I'll say it again....you NEVER, NEVER, NEVER, shoot to wound. 

you are correct, please forgive my ignorance of firearm defense.  I do not expect anyone to agree with my personal choices and I think I have made that clear that these are my choices only.  With that said, i dont agree that you need to be fully committed to taking a life,  i do agree with committed to using it.  I appreciate you not insulting my admitted ignorance to your reasoning.  Please, if you dont mind take the time to explain why not shoot to wound.. doesnt shooting to wound, neutralize the threat? Why never never?

Stand Your Ground (SYG) laws are just that. It simply says that if you are lawfully in a place you are not mandated to retreat. It does not automatically justify a claim of self defense, nor does it somehow allow you to "shoot first and ask questions later. You can "stand your ground" with or without a firearm, but to suggest that you should then only have the same weapon as the aggressor is naive and, as you suggest, probably comes from fantasy rather than reality. And again, avoid the situation is always the better choice, IMHO, but that does not mean that circumstances may preclude that option. 

You mean kung fu isnt real? LoL

But we should not burden the otherwise lawabiding citizen with the requirement that they integrate into their thought process, during the heat of a potential self defense situation, the possibility that the loud, threatening, posturing individual is "just acting up" rather than presenting a credible threat. That's like saying you should have to determine that the gun pointed at you is real and loaded before using deadly force. It simply isn't practical nor possible and to think such a requirement should be imposed is, again, IMHO, a very bad idea. As for other's not "understanding" the "local way." Again, I'm sorry. If you go to the mainland and wander into gang territory, would you suggest that you not be able to use your firearm when one of the gang members was threatening you because in reality, in that area, such threats were merely the "local way" to treat outsiders? I doubt it. 

I still think that one should understand or familiarize with "local ways" if youre in the islands.  I think it is the traveller responsibilty.  Same goes for outside of the country ... tread lightly.  And also different regions within this country. I mean ive been to the four corners and throughout and have been met with racism and disrespect in certain places cuz ignorant whites or blacks thinks locals from Hawaii are mexicans or cant tell the difference between a Japanese, Korean, or Chinese...but its ok, I didnt want to shoot and killem because they were ignorant. I just shook my head and kept walkin...the correlation to local ways which are cultural differences that may not be fully understood versus criminal gang activity as a local way is a terrible comparison imho.  Im not saying locals dont attack and use of force is not justified if they do, im justcsaying a little familiraization goes a long way, as does a open mind.

A plan is always good. Discuss with your family what you expect them to do in these situations. They should call the police, stay out of the way, take shelter, or, if trained and equipped, participate in a coordinated effort to provide the family self defense. 

I totally agree with this, and I appreciate you taking the time to discuss this to help gain a better understanding of what is the correct thing to do and also what the law provides for.






Title: Re: yet another reason to not escalate straight to deadly force if ccw were allowed
Post by: bubba808 on February 26, 2014, 11:48:00 PM
Re: Shooting to "Wound"

This is basically how it is:  If you could have "wounded" the guy, then he wasn't enough of a threat to utilize deadly force (otherwise, you would have used it).  The basic thought is that if you aren't willing to stop the threat, then you haven't reached the threshold where you should be pulling the trigger anyways.  Therefore, you just shot someone to shoot them basically!
I see, so where is this threshold defined exactly, I hope something as serious as taking another persons life isnt arbitrarily left up to the individual who is perceiving the threat.  Otherwise I had better be practicing my "quick draw" like you so as even if I am in the wrong but I see you drawing on me, I can justify my defense quicker, better, faster, just like the old westerns..etc.  smh
Title: Re: yet another reason to not escalate straight to deadly force if ccw were allowed
Post by: Q on February 27, 2014, 01:36:17 AM
I see, so where is this threshold defined exactly, I hope something as serious as taking another persons life isnt arbitrarily left up to the individual who is perceiving the threat.  Otherwise I had better be practicing my "quick draw" like you so as even if I am in the wrong but I see you drawing on me, I can justify my defense quicker, better, faster, just like the old westerns..etc.  smh


Lets just keep it simple: if you want to fist fight someone, go ahead and fist fight them; that's fine.

But smart people will use things that reduce the need for physical confrontation and/or give them the upper hand in the situation so that they can neutralize the threat without risking increased probability of bodily harm and/or death.

And there is no need to disrespect Funtimes; he is just stating the obvious and the knowledge he acquired through legitimate training and experience. If you don't like the fact that some people don't need to puff up their chest and risk the possibility off getting their ass beat, and would rather instead choose the path of least resistance, then take it out on a paper with some crayons or something, because there are many people with legitimate experience who really don't have the time or the luxury to put themselves in a greater risk of injury or death simply because they are butthurt and want to cater to their ego.
Title: Re: yet another reason to not escalate straight to deadly force if ccw were allowed
Post by: Funtimes on February 27, 2014, 09:04:59 AM
I see, so where is this threshold defined exactly, I hope something as serious as taking another persons life isnt arbitrarily left up to the individual who is perceiving the threat.  Otherwise I had better be practicing my "quick draw" like you so as even if I am in the wrong but I see you drawing on me, I can justify my defense quicker, better, faster, just like the old westerns..etc.  smh

Sir - Deadly force is left to the person who perceives that they have a potential threat of serious bodily harm or death.   You can talk all the crap about drawing that you want, after three years of teaching over 1,000 students in Hawaii and practice my times continue to come down and the motions become more fluid.  That's just a fact of training.

The fact still remains that if you had the opportunity to "wound" the individual instead of shoot to stop the threat then you probably had opportunities to perform some other action that did not equal deadly force.   This is the same principle that people get hemmed up on warnings shots.
Title: Re: yet another reason to not escalate straight to deadly force if ccw were allowed
Post by: HiCarry on February 27, 2014, 06:53:11 PM
Quote
mahalo for bearing with me as i try to understand your reasoning.  If one has little experience dealing with situations, why not recommend getting training in this area instead of escalating to shooting?
were either this video, the video of the local shouting racial slurs or the thread about the teenage boy getting shot at Roosevelt, where advocating for ccw realy life or death?

Training is always good, but it is unreasonable to expect all law abiding individuals to devote the time necessary to get ALL the training one would need to be prficient in ALL areas that might be pertinent or relevent to any particular self defense situation. Therefore I would advocate a 60 year old person with heart disease and a hip replacement get a CCW without having to train for hand to hand combat. Would I suggest that he get all the training he could? Of course. Would I mandate that he attend twice weekly martial arts training, along with verbal judo classes, weapons retention class, baton class, etc., etc., etc.? Absolutely not. As for whether or not any of the situations you mention were "life and death" I think you miss the point. The determination of what is "life or death" is the prerogative of the individual involved in that situation. Hopefully that person has thought out these types of situations and has tried to defuse or extricate himself from that situation, but ultimately it is that persons perception of what the risks are. It will be up to the trier of fact to determine if the reasoning aligns with the law and what others similarly situated would have done.

Quote
the "many" you refer actually skews the data as these are people who "deal" with violence on a regular basis.  How many people in Hawaii are actually victims of the crime scenarios you mention? Do you have real crime statistical numbers from Hawaii recently that can prove the threats you percieve as (dumb/crazy/drugged/drunk/deranged) are real and in the quanity to justify ccw?  I mean compared to the mainland, I feel Hawaii is relatively safe and per capita crime is much lower here.   Why is it that in most of your "what if" scenarios, the guy with the gun is either physically weak or is challenging some drunk, drugged crazed fiend? What about if ccw does become common that the drunk, drug crazed fiends will now be packing heat too, so now we gotta worry about the masses being smart enough to use good practices and judgement when using a firearm.  That scares me more than the highly unlikey event of being in a life or death situation here, what do you think? 

First I don't know what you are trying to say about skewing the data. Second, I don't care what the statistics about crime are, either here or elsewhere in regards to advocating for concealed carry. I don't think you need to "justify" your need to exercise your rights. Just as we should not have to show "good cause" (or per Hawaii statutory language, "in exceptional cases...") neither do I think I need to justify why I want to carry concealed. It doesn't matter how frequently violent crime occurs, only that it can and that our right to defend ourselves with the most effective tools, as determined by the individual, should not be infringed. And, considering that the police have no legal duty to protect us, why should we have to justify any decision about how we choose to defend ourselves?

The reason I tend to use the "physically weak" or drunk/drugged scenarios, is because to often people who are ignorant of the issues surrounding this topic are way too quick to suggest that using a gun was "wrong" because they could have: a) run away; b) physically engaged the subject; c) just called the police and waited; or, d) deescalated the situation. Those individuals have the benefit of hindsight and were immunized to the realities of the situation in real time. The same reason I do not advocate for retreat first laws and do advocate for Stand Your Ground laws. It removes the ability of some over zealous anti self defense prosecutor challenging an otherwise "good shoot" because after the fact, and in the completely safe and secure comfort of their office, their 20/20 hindsight thought there was ample opportunities to leave.

And I do not believe for a moment that when we get CCW here, that drunks and drugged bad guys will suddenly start carrying firearms more than these lawbreaking criminals already do. The statistics from other states have been pretty convincing that the anti's doomsday scenarios of blood running in the streets and shootouts over parking stalls are wholly unfounded.

Quote
if its life or death... I say screw practicality, you can run, or try your best to defend yourself.  High value items... maybe not so smart to bring these all over.   Family and friends should join you in your resistance/defense.  Bottom line, pick your battles wisely.

My opinion may differ from others, but I am not totally convinced that deadly force shouldn't be allowable to stop someone from taking your stuff. Now, would I shoot someone trying to steal my TV? Probably not. But what if he's trying to steal my car? And, my car is the only way I can get to work and provide for my family. If I don't have my car my family doesn't eat, my mortgage doesn't get paid, and ultimately my family is forced to live on the streets. Or what if I were handicapped and the vehicle that was being stolen was specially equipped for me and that I could not afford to replace it? Knowing that, would you be so quick to say using lethal force to protect your stuff wasn't "justified?" And unless my 5'1'' girlfriend is armed, do you really think I am going to encourage her to get involved in a physical altercation? Hell no!! She is to leave the area and get help, call the police etc. She is not to stay so some drugged crazed nutjob can do what he wants to her if I can't physically subdue him. No one is arguing that you shouldn't pick your battles wisely, but you seem to suggest that in wisely picking your battles a firearm would rarely, if ever be needed.....

Quote
hey, look at me I learned a new word. LoL,  seriously gripping the butt sounds great, keep it holstered

Keep it holstered if possible, but if you have to draw ans present, having your hand on the grip shortens the time needed to get the gun in the fight if needed.

Quote
who are these "lots of folks", surely they are in the minority of the population here.  I think when i sat in hunters ed with my wife they shared some statistics like less tahn 3% of Hawaii population legally own guns. i also think that even among firearm owners here in Hawaii I dont think the majority would choose to "go to the gun early" as you say

I was speaking to those on these types of forums that seem to rely first on going to the gun rather than some of the other options that may be available to them....I'd like to know the orgins of that statistic. Even the AG's yearly report doesn't attempt to state the percentage of Hawaii's residents that own guns. I personally think the number is a little higher.

Quote
you are correct, please forgive my ignorance of firearm defense.  I do not expect anyone to agree with my personal choices and I think I have made that clear that these are my choices only.  With that said, i dont agree that you need to be fully committed to taking a life,  i do agree with committed to using it.  I appreciate you not insulting my admitted ignorance to your reasoning.  Please, if you dont mind take the time to explain why not shoot to wound.. doesnt shooting to wound, neutralize the threat? Why never never?

As Funtimes tried to explain, in the eyes of the courts, you trying to explain that you "shot to wound" would likely undermine your attempted self defense claim. To use deadly force one must have a reasonable fear of death or great bodily injury (or fear kidnapping, rape or forcible sodomy, in Hawaii). Any competent prosecutor will turn your "shoot to wound" into a lack of the fear for your life or great bodily injury. Something along the lines of: "So, Mr. Bubba, you say you shot to wound him" Yes, you reply. "So, you had the opportunity to think about what was happening and you took the time to steady your hand, get a good sight picture on his hand (or arm, leg...)  and take a shot." the prosecutor says. "And how long have you been shooting a handgun Mr. Bubba?" Not long, as a matter of fact I am pretty new to this. "So, as a new shooter, you felt you had enough time to take a very difficult shot, at a small, moving target, with minimal training and experience, and you want this court to believe that you were actually in fear of your life at the time you took that shot??"

To be clear, this is not the movies. I tell all my students up front that I am going to ruin TV and movies for them because if all they know about guns and self defense comes from movies or TV, they're wrong! You sound like you have bought into that same thought process. Furthermore, an extremity wound may not stop the attacker, heck he may not even know he's been shot. He may still be able to continue advancing on you and now you have one less round to use should you need it. And there there is the whole issue about actually being able to hit the hand, arm, leg, or whatever...I don't know about you, but I consider myself a pretty decent shot and I would never think that in the heat of a confrontation, with my adrenalin pumping and the resulting loss of fine motor skills, that I would be able to hit such a small target and I'm betting you wouldn't be able to either. There are plenty of good references out there on this subject and you should study up on them. In the mean time, just take for granted that you DO NOT shoot to wound. Period. End of discussion.

I still think that one should understand or familiarize with "local ways" if youre in the islands.  I think it is the traveller responsibilty.  Same goes for outside of the country ... tread lightly.  And also different regions within this country. I mean ive been to the four corners and throughout and have been met with racism and disrespect in certain places cuz ignorant whites or blacks thinks locals from Hawaii are mexicans or cant tell the difference between a Japanese, Korean, or Chinese...but its ok, I didnt want to shoot and killem because they were ignorant. I just shook my head and kept walkin...the correlation to local ways which are cultural differences that may not be fully understood versus criminal gang activity as a local way is a terrible comparison imho.  Im not saying locals dont attack and use of force is not justified if they do, im justcsaying a little familiraization goes a long way, as does a open mind.

I agree that you should become familiar with the local customs. But if you are suggesting that one should defer taking the appropriate actions in regards to maintaining their safety or defending themselves because some locals are more bark than bite, I disagree. If I'm walking down the street in LA and someone in a blue bandana stops me and makes comments and takes actions that I perceive to be threatening, but others might not because they are more familiar with this type of behaviors from the locals, that's too bad for him. I don't go looking for fights, as a matter of fact I go to great lengths to avoid them, but a threat, made either in jest or earnest, is going to be taken seriously my me. It's like expecting someone to know the difference between an unloaded and a loaded gun when it's shoved in your ribs during a robbery. I don't care. I will respond as if the threat is real because the life of my family or myself is something I am not going to risk on being wrong.

Quote
I see, so where is this threshold defined exactly, I hope something as serious as taking another persons life isnt arbitrarily left up to the individual who is perceiving the threat.  Otherwise I had better be practicing my "quick draw" like you so as even if I am in the wrong but I see you drawing on me, I can justify my defense quicker, better, faster, just like the old westerns..etc.  smh

I have assumed you are genuine in your attempts to seek knowledge on this matter, but this last response of yours makes me wonder if I have wasted my time and energy. Funtimes is very knowledgeable on these matters, and I would suggest that you try to absorb what he is trying to tell you rather than make a smart ass comment that does nothing but show how ignorant you are on this subject. So, how about you actually open your mind, as you suggested "travelers" do earlier, so that you can learn rather than using tired and worn memes better suited to the anti gun crowd? If you are truly interested in learning, you shouldn't diss those that have expertise in the matter. So, to reiterate what Funtimes was trying to explain: A self defense claim will be judged on what you perceived at the time, knowing only what you knew at the time the event happened. How well you articulate how you felt (including feeling afraid for your life), what you saw, and what actions the other actor took will all factor into whether your actions were reasonable and what another similarly situated individual would have done in those circumstances. If you want to call that process "arbitrary" so be it. But that's the reality of the situation and like it or not, that's what you will have to deal with.
Title: Re: yet another reason to not escalate straight to deadly force if ccw were allowed
Post by: ImKu on February 27, 2014, 07:44:13 PM
I have assumed you are genuine in your attempts to seek knowledge on this matter, but this last response of yours makes me wonder if I have wasted my time and energy. Funtimes is very knowledgeable on these matters, and I would suggest that you try to absorb what he is trying to tell you rather than make a smart ass comment that does nothing but show how ignorant you are on this subject. So, how about you actually open your mind, as you suggested "travelers" do earlier, so that you can learn rather than using tired and worn memes better suited to the anti gun crowd? If you are truly interested in learning, you shouldn't diss those that have expertise in the matter. So, to reiterate what Funtimes was trying to explain: A self defense claim will be judged on what you perceived at the time, knowing only what you knew at the time the event happened. How well you articulate how you felt (including feeling afraid for your life), what you saw, and what actions the other actor took will all factor into whether your actions were reasonable and what another similarly situated individual would have done in those circumstances. If you want to call that process "arbitrary" so be it. But that's the reality of the situation and like it or not, that's what you will have to deal with.

You are not wasting your time as I and I would guess others enjoy learning from you and Funtimes.  Thank you for your contribution to this thread as your explaination of topics of interest are on point IMO.  :shaka:
Title: Re: yet another reason to not escalate straight to deadly force if ccw were allowed
Post by: bubba808 on February 27, 2014, 08:02:45 PM

Lets just keep it simple: if you want to fist fight someone, go ahead and fist fight them; that's fine.

But smart people will use things that reduce the nschizophreniaphysical confrontation and/or give them the upper hand in the situation so that they can neutralize the threat without risking increased probability of bodily harm and/or death.

And there is no need to disrespect Funtimes; he is just stating the obvious and the knowledge he acquired through legitimate training and experience. If you don't like the fact that some people don't need to puff up their chest and risk the possibility off getting their ass beat, and would rather instead choose the path of least resistance, then take it out on a paper with some crayons or something, because there are many people with legitimate experience who really don't have the time or the luxury to put themselves in a greater risk of injury or death simply because they are butthurt and want to cater to their ego.
first off, smart the way you use it can be interpreted as lazy, or possibly not giving a shit about anothers life, man. the reason i say arbitrary is its so subjective, "how someone feels",  what if individual with undiagnosed schizophrenia,  or just unstable like an Uesugi, or just overly sensitive... then they feel scared and threated and whipping out guns everwhere.

now I never meant any disrespect, im not sure how you interpreted what I wrote but I thought it was almost a complement on his draw speed from the youtub ed video.  Hey, im just trying to understand if there is a definition of the threshold funtimes described.  As I stated, I sincerely hoped it wasnt arbitrary, but as he pointed out, it is.  So be it.    As far as your insults.... youre the very one who said that ccw would cause everbody to start acting a whole lot nicer.. my opinion...you need to work on your etiquette.   
Title: Re: yet another reason to not escalate straight to deadly force if ccw were allowed
Post by: bubba808 on February 27, 2014, 08:08:46 PM
Sir - Deadly force is left to the person who perceives that they have a potential threat of serious bodily harm or death.   
Damn, that sucks imho.

You can talk all the crap about drawing that you want, after three years of teaching over 1,000 students in Hawaii and practice my times continue to come down and the motions become more fluid.  That's just a fact of training.
I still didnt get where I talked crap, I thought it was a compliment on your speed, and my point was that there would be a need for quicker draw if the reality was ccw.  If it was offensive, pleaee dont shoot, it was not intentional.

The fact still remains that if you had the opportunity to "wound" the individual instead of shoot to stop the threat then you probably had opportunities to perform some other action that did not equal deadly force.   This is the same principle that people get hemmed up on warnings shots.
well at least I can understand the logic you use with the "wounding" which is all I wanted to know.
Title: Re: yet another reason to not escalate straight to deadly force if ccw were allowed
Post by: bubba808 on February 27, 2014, 08:29:48 PM
Ok, i have read your responses and i agree with some, and disagree with some of what you wrote, but i respect your opinion, and although i have a different opinion than yours, im content with the non-explaination also..  I was just curious about why you feel the need for ccw, and to understand where you were coming from better.  My mind is open, thats why i am posting and attempting to understand you, but it appears you are agitated due to being asked for explanations so im comfortable ending the discussion here.  Thanks for your time.
Title: Re: yet another reason to not escalate straight to deadly force if ccw were allowed
Post by: Q on February 27, 2014, 08:46:05 PM
first off, smart the way you use it can be interpreted as lazy, or possibly not giving a shit about anothers life, man. the reason i say arbitrary is its so subjective, "how someone feels",  what if individual with undiagnosed schizophrenia,  or just unstable like an Uesugi, or just overly sensitive... then they feel scared and threated and whipping out guns everwhere.

now I never meant any disrespect, im not sure how you interpreted what I wrote but I thought it was almost a complement on his draw speed from the youtub ed video.  Hey, im just trying to understand if there is a definition of the threshold funtimes described.  As I stated, I sincerely hoped it wasnt arbitrary, but as he pointed out, it is.  So be it.    As far as your insults.... youre the very one who said that ccw would cause everbody to start acting a whole lot nicer.. my opinion...you need to work on your etiquette.

So basically you are comparing the training that individuals like Funtimes and myself received to undiagnosed schizophrenia? The way you try to validate your point just continues to reveal that either 1) you have absolutely no training in CCW, or 2) that you think using a firearm to defend yourself is somehow cheating or not honorable, which is an ego problem.

And why do you keep thinking that someone who is CCW trained automatically wants to kill someone for minor egotistical infractions? You have it in your head that if someone insults us or hurts our feelings, that we are just going to shoot them. If that is your stance on the issue, then I suggest you actually look at your own perceptions, because in the psychology field what is happening with this discussion is called projection. Projection is the instance in which someone assumes another individual will do something, based upon what they would do in a similar situation. So it actually might be that you think YOU might shoot someone in this type of situation, and therefore you assume/hope that people will do the same. Sorry, but the guys I know on this forum are not of that sort, so please don't try and say what someone might or might not do in a situation that does and/or does not demand presentation/application of lethal force.

And I did say that, because an armed society is a polite society, given the fact that if you try to mess with someone who is armed, chances are they do have, in their choice of options, the ability to shoot you.

Once again, if you don't like the fact that people will take the path of least resistance to avoid bodily harm or or death while trying to neutralize a threat, don't CCW if/when Hawaii allows it.
Title: Re: yet another reason to not escalate straight to deadly force if ccw were allowed
Post by: bubba808 on February 27, 2014, 09:49:15 PM
So basically you are comparing the training that individuals like Funtimes and myself received to undiagnosed schizophrenia?
im not comparing that, you are, im saying that if ccw is allowed others who apply could be granted the priveledge with the condition.

The way you try to validate your point just continues to reveal that either 1) you have absolutely no training in CCW, or 2) that you think using a firearm to defend yourself is somehow cheating or not honorable, which is an ego problem.
at least I try to validate my points.  I have already established the fact that I am not trained in ccw.
1.  That said, what special training are you referrring to that is/will be required for ccw? Hunters ed, a shooters course?, and now, if a peruta type law passes, no good cause for requesting and being granted ccw.  Its not necessarily, you, definately not funtimes, and hicarry that im really worried about.  Its the bulk of the dheep in society that m a y apply and have the power of ccw, but without the training or sense to use it responsibly.   What if they aim for center mass and miss, and wound, continue shooting? What if they miss and hit innocent bystanders? It seems the risk of opening ccw up will almost be a pandoras box of sorts, and its definately NOT the Hawaii I want in the future.  I think at this point, with the lack of crime statistics that warrant ccw, ccw is unnecessary here in Hawaii.
2  i do think it could be dishonorable to defend yourself with a firearm, depending on circumstances.  I also think people could abuse this privilege, if granted, by using deadly force when NOT absolutely necessary.   And that is my problem.


And why do you keep thinking that someone who is CCW trained automatically wants to kill someone for minor egotistical infractions?
I do not think that.You have it in your head that if someone insults us or hurts our feelings, that we are just going to shoot them.
do you have mental telepathy?  I dont think this either, but as a proponent of ccw, how do you know someone else who is granted ccw, wont do what you describe?

. Sorry, but the guys I know on this forum are not of that sort, so please don't try and say what someone might or might not do in a situation that does and/or does not demand presentation/application of lethal force.
you say this yet you, hicarry, paint elaborate, "what if" scenarios about what someone weak, physically ill, getting attacked by drunken drug crazed gang bangers..might or might not do and justfy application of lethal force.  Your double standard is silly, its seems like you are doing a great job of pushing people genuinely interested in understanding ccw and 2a away with your cocky and abrasive comments and attitude.  Seriously...you want to gain support or teach people about what you know, i suggest you learn to be polite. 
And I did say that, because an armed society is a polite society, given the fact that if you try to mess with someone who is armed, chances are they do have, in their choice of options, the ability to shoot you.
arent we already an armed society? Why aren't you polite yet? So, now if ccw is granted youre gonna start treating others respectfully and be polite?  If so, that may be the strongest arguement yet to grant ccw
Once again, if you don't like the fact that people will take the path of least resistance to avoid bodily harm or or death while trying to neutralize a threat, don't CCW if/when Hawaii allows it.
I may, I may not choose to exercise ccw, im trying to learn more about it so as to make my own decision on wether to support or not.  When the time to decide comes... I will.
Title: Re: yet another reason to not escalate straight to deadly force if ccw were allowed
Post by: ImKu on February 27, 2014, 10:09:22 PM
Not to bash on you, but your arguments are very similar to the mindset of gun grabbers.  Why do you need this, why do gou need that (i.e. ar15 or 30rd mags).  To some it is a right that should not be infringed upon.
Title: Re: yet another reason to not escalate straight to deadly force if ccw were allowed
Post by: Funtimes on February 27, 2014, 10:36:15 PM
@Bubba808

To clarify just a little more for you:

Our subjectiveness goes off of this 'mystical' reasonable person standard.   That type of stuff is generally left up to the jury, who is the 'reasonable person' (all together).  But, normally, in most of the country - trying to hurt someone with a weapon, or actually hurting someone (with anything) could get you laid down on a metal slab for life.  Some places even allow you to defend property with lethal force.  I would hate to say that the standard is not high, but it really doesn't take much to be able to seriously hurt or injure someone.   Where someone might see punching as no problem, to another that could be the most traumatic experience of their life. 

I would like to say that for the most part, people generally know when they are terrified.  People tend to avoid conflicts as best as possible, and most will leave or try to get away if they can. I think the lone rangers that you may be concerned with are few and far between.  When I first was carrying firearms in FL / GA, I realized that after a while it kind of changed and molded my behaviors.  The places that I was worried about needing a gun, I ended up not going to as often after I had a gun.  Other behavior changes were present to, such as walking in different and less populated entrances of the mall; all the punk ass kids were hanging out of the movies, so we would go adjacent though a sears or borders.

re - special training:
I do not think that Hawaii will buy or accept the basic training.  It's possible, and our courses that we instructed do meet the requirements for some states.  Other than saying I would like to see constitutional carry, what I would want is the tiered permit system like Arizona.  To carry generally, no permit is required... to carry in specific dense places you need proof of training.  Training for this stuff is generally like 20/25 rounds on target out to 25 yards.  It could be anything similar, but expect a scoring requirement.  professionally, I think any class without a scoring requirement is kind of just a fake class now. 

Re citizen shot and wounded:  What happens is the citizen can sue.  If the person dies, then it's possible he could be tried for some sort of manslaughter charge or reckless xxx.  But honestly, if it was a legit shot - this is probably going to be hard to pin criminally - and very easy civilly.

re hawaii crime:  Crime in hawaii is not non-existent.  In fact, back for 2009 - Hawaii was ranked 35th in the Country for violent crime.  While they were not the worse, there are far better; Vermont who had constitutional carry was the safest and ranked #1.  Also, the property crime rates in Hawaii are some of the most horrible in the country.  We were the 5th worst place in existence.  People rob and steal from people all the time in Hawaii.  Not to be a conspiracy theorist, but I have good word that crimes are under-reported by the media in Hawaii to preserve the tourism industry.  After teaching classes, I've had people come to learn who have been held hostage in their homes, been drug out at gun point by criminals, who have been raped, attacked, carjacked, and had all their personal possessions stolen.  Hawaii just isn't as safe as people think it is.   We do well in murder, but that's mostly due to the inactivity of gangs when you compare it to many other places.   
Title: Re: yet another reason to not escalate straight to deadly force if ccw were allowed
Post by: kia_killer on February 27, 2014, 10:54:40 PM

The problem is operating in hypotheticals. Are the situations you present possible? Yes. Is it likely? Not very, especially when you consider all the other states that issue ccw. These hypotheticals don't seem have any real basis. You say ccw will open up Pandora's box. There are around 30 states that issue ccw, but they don't seem to be having a lot of issues with these extreme scenarios you are presenting. Might I suggest some bedtime reading? http://hawaiiccw.com/gun-myths/concealed-carry-myths/people-permits-commit-crimes/ (http://hawaiiccw.com/gun-myths/concealed-carry-myths/people-permits-commit-crimes/) Research the topic from a different angle, you might be surprised.
Title: Re: yet another reason to not escalate straight to deadly force if ccw were allowed
Post by: bubba808 on February 27, 2014, 11:14:46 PM
Not to bash on you, but your arguments are very similar to the mindset of gun grabbers.  Why do you need this, why do gou need that (i.e. ar15 or 30rd mags).  To some it is a right that should not be infringed upon.
Its pretty insulting, but I forgive your ignorance.   im simply struggling to understand other CCW proponents perspective so im asking questions? Its called getting educated and informed.  I have enjoyed firearms for hunting and target practice since I was a kid, and I still do enjoy it.    I have no problem with using firearms for these endeavors.  I struggle with the concept of everday citizens packing and possibly killing people, I am content with military/LEO possessing this power.  Forgive me for challenging, questioning, and validating others opinion.  Maybe you should ask more questions as your understanding is limited. The topic is CCW, which isnt a right or privilege as it is currently restricted here, therefore, currently nothing is being infringed upon.  This is not Arizona, Vermont, Alaska, Utah, or Kentucky.... this is Hawaii... I am comfortable with gun ownership w/o CCW here.  If there were stronger arguments for CCW, I may choose to support it, but at this time... imho, its unnecessary. 
Title: Re: yet another reason to not escalate straight to deadly force if ccw were allowed
Post by: bubba808 on February 27, 2014, 11:29:22 PM
The problem is operating in hypotheticals. Are the situations you present possible? Yes. Is it likely? Not very, especially when you consider all the other states that issue ccw. These hypotheticals don't seem have any real basis. You say ccw will open up Pandora's box. There are around 30 states that issue ccw, but they don't seem to be having a lot of issues with these extreme scenarios you are presenting. Might I suggest some bedtime reading? http://hawaiiccw.com/gun-myths/concealed-carry-myths/people-permits-commit-crimes/ (http://hawaiiccw.com/gun-myths/concealed-carry-myths/people-permits-commit-crimes/) Research the topic from a different angle, you might be surprised.
ridiculous... are you blind to the mostly one sided hypotheticals that have been shared by others?  Of course im trying to illustrate the other side of the coin, if the rebutt had merit, then the hypotheticals would be centered around the " average person" instead of the weak, frail, ill, elderly, with the heart condition, being attacked by drunk, drug crazed, gangsters. 

I will read up... thanks.  Im going off my experience and travels to states/countries that had relaxed gun laws, I swear every other day as I watched the nightly news, there was a shooting on the highway from road rage, or a shooting in a parking lot or, something involving a gun.   It was also very uncomfortable being around people who were carrying and I was not.
Title: Re: yet another reason to not escalate straight to deadly force if ccw were allowed
Post by: bubba808 on February 27, 2014, 11:56:40 PM
@Bubba808

To clarify just a little more for you:

Our subjectiveness goes off of this 'mystical' reasonable person standard.   That type of stuff is generally left up to the jury, who is the 'reasonable person' (all together).  But, normally, in most of the country - trying to hurt someone with a weapon, or actually hurting someone (with anything) could get you laid down on a metal slab for life.  Some places even allow you to defend property with lethal force.  I would hate to say that the standard is not high, but it really doesn't take much to be able to seriously hurt or injure someone.  Where someone might see punching as no problem, to another that could be the most traumatic experience of their life. 

I would like to say that for the most part, people generally know when they are terrified.  People tend to avoid conflicts as best as possible, and most will leave or try to get away if they can. I think the lone rangers that you may be concerned with are few and far between.  When I first was carrying firearms in FL / GA, I realized that after a while it kind of changed and molded my behaviors.  The places that I was worried about needing a gun, I ended up not going to as often after I had a gun.  Other behavior changes were present to, such as walking in different and less populated entrances of the mall; all the punk ass kids were hanging out of the movies, so we would go adjacent though a sears or borders.

re - special training:
I do not think that Hawaii will buy or accept the basic training.  It's possible, and our courses that we instructed do meet the requirements for some states.  Other than saying I would like to see constitutional carry, what I would want is the tiered permit system like Arizona.  To carry generally, no permit is required... to carry in specific dense places you need proof of training.  Training for this stuff is generally like 20/25 rounds on target out to 25 yards.  It could be anything similar, but expect a scoring requirement.  professionally, I think any class without a scoring requirement is kind of just a fake class now. 

Re citizen shot and wounded:  What happens is the citizen can sue.  If the person dies, then it's possible he could be tried for some sort of manslaughter charge or reckless xxx.  But honestly, if it was a legit shot - this is probably going to be hard to pin criminally - and very easy civilly.

re hawaii crime:  Crime in hawaii is not non-existent.  In fact, back for 2009 - Hawaii was ranked 35th in the Country for violent crime.  While they were not the worse, there are far better; Vermont who had constitutional carry was the safest and ranked #1.  Also, the property crime rates in Hawaii are some of the most horrible in the country.  We were the 5th worst place in existence.  People rob and steal from people all the time in Hawaii.  Not to be a conspiracy theorist, but I have good word that crimes are under-reported by the media in Hawaii to preserve the tourism industry.  After teaching classes, I've had people come to learn who have been held hostage in their homes, been drug out at gun point by criminals, who have been raped, attacked, carjacked, and had all their personal possessions stolen.  Hawaii just isn't as safe as people think it is.   We do well in murder, but that's mostly due to the inactivity of gangs when you compare it to many other places.

Thanks for the clarifications.

I agree that if more/specialized training is required that would make it easier to accept ccw.

being able to sue if an innocent bystander is shot is not comfortable.  Its almost like getting hit by an uninsured motorist.  They are poor and cant afford insurance to thet drive without, they hit you, you can sue, but for what? Your health and well being, the very thing youre trying to protect with CCW may be taken.  If you sue, They may have nothing of value to take.

property crime rates may be high, but its almost irrelevant as you couldnt use deadly force against a thief,  or does getting robbed make a case for feeling threatened/terrified and using deadly force? If ccw were allowed, could you draw your weapon to stop/control a thief without getting in trouble?  What if thief is leaving (heading away from you) with your jewelry, and you draw and yell stop, he doesnt see and continues to head away; could you do anything?

I realize there is crime in Hawaii, but im curious about the actual statistics of quantities of those crimes that CCW/deadly force could be used to prevent (sodomy, rape, serious injury, etc)?
Title: Re: yet another reason to not escalate straight to deadly force if ccw were allowed
Post by: ImKu on February 28, 2014, 12:13:26 AM
Its pretty insulting, but I forgive your ignorance.   im simply struggling to understand other CCW proponents perspective so im asking questions? Its called getting educated and informed.  I have enjoyed firearms for hunting and target practice since I was a kid, and I still do enjoy it.    I have no problem with using firearms for these endeavors.  I struggle with the concept of everday citizens packing and possibly killing people, I am content with military/LEO possessing this power.  Forgive me for challenging, questioning, and validating others opinion.  Maybe you should ask more questions as your understanding is limited. The topic is CCW, which isnt a right or privilege as it is currently restricted here, therefore, currently nothing is being infringed upon.  This is not Arizona, Vermont, Alaska, Utah, or Kentucky.... this is Hawaii... I am comfortable with gun ownership w/o CCW here.  If there were stronger arguments for CCW, I may choose to support it, but at this time... imho, its unnecessary.

Don't know why you feel the need to call me ignorant, but whatever.  What I was trying to do was let you know how I and maybe others perceive some of your statements.  Your uneasiness with CCW is similar to that of people that I have talked to about gun laws.  They are not comfortable with people possessing "assault weapons" and they think that people don't "need" them.  Same concept with CCW.  Just because YOU think that there is a requirement or a "stronger argument" needed is justify CCW, you don't want to support it.  Do you not see the correlation?  What about my understanding is limited?   Or is that just another attempt to insult me?  Come on man, I am trying to keep this civil... if anything it seems that your understanding is limited.  You fail to understand what basic requirements MUST be met prior to the use deadly force as you still need someone to tell you when it is justified.

My belief is that CCW is a right, a right that is not acknowledged here.  So it has been infringe upon since the beginning.  No privilege necessary.  This is how I feel.  Others may disagree, and that's fine.  What kills me is that you state that you would be "content with military/LEO possessing this power" (of CCW).  Do you know how many military is on this island bro?  BTW, no shit this is Hawaii.  I'm kanaka moali so you can cut that crap out.


*I wish Funtimes was here, as his classes/training that he provided would have helped you understand deadly force.
http://legal-dictionary.thefreedictionary.com/Deadly+Force (http://legal-dictionary.thefreedictionary.com/Deadly+Force)
Title: Re: yet another reason to not escalate straight to deadly force if ccw were allowed
Post by: Q on February 28, 2014, 02:38:09 AM
I struggle with the concept of everday citizens packing and possibly killing people, I am content with military/LEO possessing this power.

 ??? ??? ???

So you get butthurt when ImKu says you have the same ideology as gun-grabbers, yet you preach the same thing that gun-grabbers preach?

Of course im trying to illustrate the other side of the coin, if the rebutt had merit, then the hypotheticals would be centered around the " average person" instead of the weak, frail, ill, elderly, with the heart condition, being attacked by drunk, drug crazed, gangsters. 

So you assume the average American is what, a 5'10 male who is in decent physical shape and has some level of hand-to-hand combat training? The more you keep talking, the more it shows that you really don't know about the subject. Predators, in both figurative and literal senses, go after the weak. Why would someone looking for some easy cash or to commit a crime go after someone who looks physically capable of defending against an attack? I suggest you start off with some discovery channel to watch what predators do in the wild, then actually do some research about how and what human predators do before you try to demean the advice of people who have not only received training on the subject, but actually dealt with predators in their profession.

Im going off my experience and travels to states/countries that had relaxed gun laws, I swear every other day as I watched the nightly news, there was a shooting on the highway from road rage, or a shooting in a parking lot or, something involving a gun.   It was also very uncomfortable being around people who were carrying and I was not.

So in case you didn't know, there is a guy who lurks on this forum who claims that bullets were flying past his head while he was hiking on an unsanctioned trail because his brother was in vietnam, and he told him what bullets sound like, so he KNOWS it was a bullet that flew by his head.


You have it in your head that if someone insults us or hurts our feelings, that we are just going to shoot them.
do you have mental telepathy?  I dont think this either, but as a proponent of ccw, how do you know someone else who is granted ccw, wont do what you describe?

I guess I must, because I am right, am I not?

And how do I know this? I don't. Do you?

BTW, if you are going to cut and paste my quotes, at least try and cut and paste the whole thing to validate the point. That specific section that you quoted also addressed the fact that you are projecting your fears about gun control.


By your statements, it is becoming evident that you seem to be affiliated with those who are anti-gun. Thus far, you have openly stated that you do not feel safe with people carrying firearms, that you feel only the police and military should do so, and you keep bringing up irrelevant and in fallible evidence about situations in which you were not directly involve, all of which are driving you to project your obvious fears and prejudices into what you assume the rest of the firearm community will do.

Once again, if you don't want to carry a firearm, don't carry a firearm. And if you don't like firearms, why hang out around a firearm forum?
Title: Re: yet another reason to not escalate straight to deadly force if ccw were allowed
Post by: 2aHawaii on February 28, 2014, 04:13:40 AM
Q, let's try and keep this civil. I think this is a great learning opportunity for people who are on the fence about CCW.
Title: Re: yet another reason to not escalate straight to deadly force if ccw were allowed
Post by: kia_killer on February 28, 2014, 09:22:21 AM
ridiculous... are you blind to the mostly one sided hypotheticals that have been shared by others?  Of course im trying to illustrate the other side of the coin, if the rebutt had merit, then the hypotheticals would be centered around the " average person" instead of the weak, frail, ill, elderly, with the heart condition, being attacked by drunk, drug crazed, gangsters. 

I will read up... thanks.  Im going off my experience and travels to states/countries that had relaxed gun laws, I swear every other day as I watched the nightly news, there was a shooting on the highway from road rage, or a shooting in a parking lot or, something involving a gun.   It was also very uncomfortable being around people who were carrying and I was not.
Nope not blinded, but I let statistics weigh in on my decisions more than fear.  "It was also very uncomfortable being around people who were carrying and I was not." I didnt feel uncomfortable in my travels to other carry friendly states, maybe you did, but that doesnt mean your feelings were justified. The problem is jumping to these extreme scenarios without providing any real evidence that these scenarios will become common place when ccw is allowed here. A good place to look is at other states with ccw that have had it in place for sometime. This provides the most accurate guess at how another state will fair with ccw. Your quote above also hits another note about other people carrying when you cant. Criminals carry regardless of laws, and should be feared way more than your average ccw holder. Since criminals do carry, I would like to carry especially since they are not operating in the confines of the law. Its funny that you say you watched the nightly news and there were regular shootings when you were in other states. My response to that would be. I swear it seems like there are always stories of people getting stabbed here in Hawaii.  You also failed to mention if these "shootings" were involving ccw holders, criminals, police, or accidental. Shootings do happen fairly regularly, but not by ccw holders. Mostly its gang related. Which other states do have a bigger problem with than Hawaii.
Title: Re: yet another reason to not escalate straight to deadly force if ccw were allowed
Post by: Funtimes on February 28, 2014, 09:27:34 AM
The topic is CCW, which isnt a right or privilege as it is currently restricted here, therefore, currently nothing is being infringed upon.  This is not Arizona, Vermont, Alaska, Utah, or Kentucky.... this is Hawaii...

On this note, I think that you may have a fundamental misunderstanding of what the right to self-defense has consisted of in this country from our founding.  People have always been able to carry arms (guns) for self-defense and defense of others.  If you care to read the Peruta decision, I think it's probably the best written opinion covering history on the 2nd Amendment that I have seen.  They cover almost all of the State cases that are routinely mis-attributed.  The only time "conceal" carry has been really authorized to be banned, was when open carry of arms was available. To this point, carrying concealed was considered a cowards way of carrying a gun; in today's standards, we would reverse this as too many people are butt hurt when they see a firearm.  My bias aside, the opinions holding against really skim the surface looking for quotes they can toss in for a citation, but completely do not get the message from the courts they cite.  They are really being disingenuous and it's kind of repulsive.

 In earlier periods, minority races were suppressed by democrats and had gun rights restricted in order to keep African Americans unarmed.  This is essentially where 'gun control,' as we know it, began.   This continued and incidents like the Black Panthers march on the California State capitol lead to more gun crime laws and regulations. Politicians have used gun crime to further their attempts to look hard and tough and crime and gangs.  Then during prohibition, Federal agents were getting their tails handed to them by thugs and common citizens, so they started to ban the full auto firearms and other devices under the NFA etc.

The problem with saying that this is not arizona, vermont, alaka etc. is kind of a farce.  Hawaii is part of the United States; regardless of how it got there, or who thinks that it shouldn't be - it is. That means the state has to play ball under the Constitution.  The philosophy espoused by some of the Hawaii Court justices in that "Western law has no place on our islands" is garbage and makes those individuals a disgrace to the judicial system.  Justices do not get options on whether or not they want to uphold the constitution based on what state they live in.

To another point: The Kingdom of Hawaii also allowed the bearing of arms for self-defense.
Title: Re: yet another reason to not escalate straight to deadly force if ccw were allowed
Post by: kia_killer on February 28, 2014, 09:30:33 AM
Its pretty insulting, but I forgive your ignorance.   im simply struggling to understand other CCW proponents perspective so im asking questions? Its called getting educated and informed.  I have enjoyed firearms for hunting and target practice since I was a kid, and I still do enjoy it.    I have no problem with using firearms for these endeavors.  I struggle with the concept of everday citizens packing and possibly killing people, I am content with military/LEO possessing this power.  Forgive me for challenging, questioning, and validating others opinion.  Maybe you should ask more questions as your understanding is limited. The topic is CCW, which isnt a right or privilege as it is currently restricted here, therefore, currently nothing is being infringed upon.  This is not Arizona, Vermont, Alaska, Utah, or Kentucky.... this is Hawaii... I am comfortable with gun ownership w/o CCW here.  If there were stronger arguments for CCW, I may choose to support it, but at this time... imho, its unnecessary.

Your feelings might change if ever confronted by someone intent on doing harm to you or your family, but by that time it will be too late.
Title: Re: yet another reason to not escalate straight to deadly force if ccw were allowed
Post by: HiCarry on February 28, 2014, 10:07:27 AM
Q, let's try and keep this civil. I think this is a great learning opportunity for people who are on the fence about CCW.
I agree. I must admit that some of the questions posed have made me question the true intent of poster, but subsequent replies lead me to believe his questions are genuine, even if, IMHO, a bit ill-informed. So, let's help a brother out...and do so knowing we may be sharing a range, or a frosty adult beverage with him sometime down the road...
Title: yet another reason to not escalate straight to deadly force if ccw were allowed
Post by: Jl808 on February 28, 2014, 01:27:49 PM
This is a good discussion. I had contemplated this from the OP's point of view especially with the Deedy trial, trying to see it with a local understanding of local culture and here are some of my thoughts...

1. Hard numbers about CCW has shown a very high correlation of CCW and a decrease in crime rates. So, how is Hawaii so different that it would not be the same here?

2. If Hawaii permits CCW and then some punk ass now has to worry "is this guy armed" before trying to pick a fight, why is that a bad thing?  Wouldn't it be better if troublemakers now have to think twice before trying to make trouble or try to rob someone?  It has been shown many many times that criminals want gun control and want their intended victims to be unarmed so that they will be safer on their criminal jobs.

If some punk want to monkey dance and show off to their friends at the expense of an innocent bystander, we should not be trying to protect that instigator and allow the intended victims to protect themselves instead.

3. If you decide to CCW, you will know that you will want to absolutely be sure before having to use your firearm in self defense at the risk of getting sued, imprisoned, and living with that decision for the rest of your life. 

You'll want to educate yourself as much as possible at the risk of losing your permit to carry or even purchase a firearm if you are convicted of wrongdoing.

I would think that CCW applicants will be more careful than police or soldiers as they don't have that "immunity" that LEOs seem to have. That means no stupid monkey dances. If one wants to show off their MMA skills, do it in the confines of your own backyard, a gym or MMA school.

4. Besides, statistics also show that private CCW holders consistently show much lower rates of shooting the wrong person than LEOs responding to a call.

I can pull the statistics for #1 or #4 if you like. It's in this forum somewhere.
Title: Re: yet another reason to not escalate straight to deadly force if ccw were allowed
Post by: bubba808 on February 28, 2014, 02:03:18 PM
I agree. I must admit that some of the questions posed have made me question the true intent of poster, but subsequent replies lead me to believe his questions are genuine, even if, IMHO, a bit ill-informed. So, let's help a brother out...and do so knowing we may be sharing a range, or a frosty adult beverage with him sometime down the road...
the help bringing me up to speed is much appreciated. I dont think I have ever claimed to be well informed, I haveonly been stating my opinions and trying to understand others.  Damn, you know how much damn typing this is... its sure is time consuming... leading me to question if the investment is even worth the effort to reach an understanding.
Title: Re: yet another reason to not escalate straight to deadly force if ccw were allowed
Post by: bubba808 on February 28, 2014, 03:01:22 PM
Don't know why you feel the need to call me ignorant, but whatever.  What I was trying to do was let you know how I and maybe others perceive some of your statements.  Your uneasiness with CCW is similar to that of people that I have talked to about gun laws.  They are not comfortable with people possessing "assault weapons" and they think that people don't "need" them.  Same concept with CCW.  Just because YOU think that there is a requirement or a "stronger argument" needed is justify CCW, you don't want to support it.  Do you not see the correlation?  What about my understanding is limited?   Or is that just another attempt to insult me?  Come on man, I am trying to keep this civil... if anything it seems that your understanding is limited.  You fail to understand what basic requirements MUST be met prior to the use deadly force as you still need someone to tell you when it is justified.

My belief is that CCW is a right, a right that is not acknowledged here.  So it has been infringe upon since the beginning.  No privilege necessary.  This is how I feel.  Others may disagree, and that's fine.  What kills me is that you state that you would be "content with military/LEO possessing this power" (of CCW).  Do you know how many military is on this island bro?  BTW, no shit this is Hawaii.  I'm kanaka moali so you can cut that crap out.


*I wish Funtimes was here, as his classes/training that he provided would have helped you understand deadly force.
http://legal-dictionary.thefreedictionary.com/Deadly+Force (http://legal-dictionary.thefreedictionary.com/Deadly+Force)
You say you no mean to bash then you bash.  As stated, your post was insulting.  Interesting how you correlate assult weapon ownership with CCW.  Im fine with owning firearm, and I own many myself, including assult rifles, I think its great and i do wish there was more freedom of movement as I feel the HRSs are overly restrictive, but to me CCW is totally different, its  unencumbered, and hidden, and anybody could be packing.  Of course, I can have an opinion... you dont like it? IDGAF!   Im not saying you have to agree, im just expressing a difference of opinion and looking for some objective evidence that would cause me to change my mind.

 I did not fail to understand that athe basic requirements Must be met.  as stated, I personally dont agree with how arbitrary or basic the requirement is as the threshold is left up to feelings of individual. You realize some people are more "sensitive" than others right? So if the same "sensitive" people can and probably will get CCW if it is granted, and the start "feeling" threatened, and start whipping out guns and maybe shooting someone... i think that will suck more than the pleasure of carrying.  Also as Funtimes stated, it is unsure what amount of additional training, if any, will be needed to obtain CCW, and now.. possibly without "good cause", more of the "sensitives" might be packing in the future.  Thats what I dont like.  Again, these are my opinions.

The military/LEO is an oversight on my part, what I intended to convey was military leo/non military leo... just so there is NO mistaking, let me say I do NOT agree that every member of the military should have CCW, only those military members in a LEO capacity.  Sorry for not being clear enough.

WRT this being Hawaii, if you raed my other posts, i stated that have experienced CCW/open carry and it doesnt feel as comfortable, , I felt uneasy, tense, on edge, as I had an added worry that I might bump into somebody and get shot, or my family might get shot, and every other day on the news, something gun related.... here I feel relaxed, at ease, I no need be as worried, the news get gun related violence... rarely tho.  So please, no get excited bu.. and as far you being Hawaiian, what does race/ethnicity have to do with any of this? Are you saying that only your views are representative of local style cuz youre Hawaiian?   Im saying that per the video where da other hawaiian was goin racial on da haoles, he was wrong, but it wasnt threatening enough to meet the basic requirements to warrant CCW and the accompanying ability to use deadly force.  I am starting to understand HiCarry and Funtimes points about if the situation were to have escalated that it could become to the level where thay may choose to use and be justified under the law.  And like they said, if I dont like the law, tough.  Me personally, I am choosing to hold myself to a higher standard than the laws of man, I am following the laws of GOD, by choosing not to kill another man.  Again this is my CHOICE, im not telling them to do the same, im telling them my opinion.

furthermore, you can believe whatever you like about CCW being a right.  But Is it really a right if its not acknowledged? I dont think so...otherwise id ask you to execise your right.   If you feel like your rights are being infringed upon, go confront or  sue whoever is taking your rights.  Dont get mad at me cuz I get a difference of opinion.
Title: Re: yet another reason to not escalate straight to deadly force if ccw were allowed
Post by: 2aHawaii on February 28, 2014, 03:22:17 PM
Hey bubba808,

Here living in Hawaii where we haven't every really had a recognized right for concealed (or open) carry except for a couple politically chosen people in the past, this change can be scary in our minds. But think about this, many other states have gone through the exact same changes in recognizing the right to carry and they haven't experienced the "horrible catastrophes" that the Brady Campaign always promises.

One point, you say that you are worried about unstable people escalating situations and just start shooting, but do you also normally walk down these streets with the same concerns? Are you aware there are criminals that walk around every day carrying guns illegally? You may not think about it because it's "out of sight, out of mind." Sometimes the things that can scare us the most are our own ideas of what can happen.

If you feel like your rights are being infringed upon, go confront or  sue whoever is taking your rights.

Since you mentioned the above, I assume that you don't know that there is a lawsuit out right now being considered in the 9th circuit court for Hawaii (Baker v. Kealoha). That is also why we start having these discussions. As was the opinion of the three judge panel in Peruta v. San Diego, they hold that the right to carry outside the home is a historically recognized right. This is important because the government will often try and gradually take away rights, slowly but surely, and this is something we are gaining back.

If you don't know, it is legal to carry today in Hawaii with an issued concealed carry permit. Historically, however, Hawaii has created a de facto ban on carry by not issuing any permits at all. A few police chiefs in the past have issued these permits (more than 10 years ago) but only has issued them to politically connected citizens.
Title: Re: yet another reason to not escalate straight to deadly force if ccw were allowed
Post by: bubba808 on February 28, 2014, 03:52:43 PM
Nope not blinded, but I let statistics weigh in on my decisions more than fear.  "It was also very uncomfortable being around people who were carrying and I was not." I didnt feel uncomfortable in my travels to other carry friendly states, maybe you did, but that doesnt mean your feelings were justified. The problem is jumping to these extreme scenarios without providing any real evidence that these scenarios will become common place when ccw is allowed here. A good place to look is at other states with ccw that have had it in place for sometime. This provides the most accurate guess at how another state will fair with ccw. Your quote above also hits another note about other people carrying when you cant. Criminals carry regardless of laws, and should be feared way more than your average ccw holder. Since criminals do carry, I would like to carry especially since they are not operating in the confines of the law. Its funny that you say you watched the nightly news and there were regular shootings when you were in other states. My response to that would be. I swear it seems like there are always stories of people getting stabbed here in Hawaii.  You also failed to mention if these "shootings" were involving ccw holders, criminals, police, or accidental. Shootings do happen fairly regularly, but not by ccw holders. Mostly its gang related. Which other states do have a bigger problem with than Hawaii.
Me too, I let statistic weigh in on my decisions also.  When I asked for statistics, none were provided.  Are you seriously questioning if my feelings are justified? My uncomfortable feeling is a result of my own perceptions, how can you tell if my feeling are justified, as they are my feelings.  Just like the feelings of being threatened are based on the individuals perceptions may or may not be justified to you, but to me they are justified. Imam agreeing with you about the problem with extreme scenarios, but that goes for both sides of the issue, which is what I was trying to illustrate.   
My question WRT CCW, is not wether crime is low, was crime high before and now that ccw was is allowed, did it go down?  I.e. did ccw actually decrease crime?   I understand what youre saying about criminals, however criminals are the extreme, if you read my posts, I have stated that my concern would be more about the increased number of firearms in public and the careless use of these firearms.  I think I mentioned that the shooting were reported to be due to apparent road rage and altercation in a parking lot etc.  These were non accidental from citizens, not LEO, if citizen was a criminal it was not or could not be determined via news report.
WRT gang related crime, youre saying gangs cause higher crime rates and other states have a bigger problem with gang crime than Hawaii, so arent you providing statistics that say Hawaii has less crime? So do we then need ccw to reduce crime when we already have less crime?
Title: Re: yet another reason to not escalate straight to deadly force if ccw were allowed
Post by: 2aHawaii on February 28, 2014, 04:03:40 PM
Check out this carry map
Title: Re: yet another reason to not escalate straight to deadly force if ccw were allowed
Post by: HiCarry on February 28, 2014, 04:09:39 PM
Ok, i have read your responses and i agree with some, and disagree with some of what you wrote, but i respect your opinion, and although i have a different opinion than yours, im content with the non-explaination also..  I was just curious about why you feel the need for ccw, and to understand where you were coming from better.  My mind is open, thats why i am posting and attempting to understand you, but it appears you are agitated due to being asked for explanations so im comfortable ending the discussion here.  Thanks for your time.


I am not agitated that you are asking for explanations, rather that you seem to dismiss valid and learned opinions. I am also bothered slightly by what I perceive as the incorrect assumption that owning, using, and carrying a firearm, including outside your home is a "privilege" rather than a right. You made a comment to the effect that if it were a right, then you (the person you were responding to...) should carry regardless of the law. Tell me, sir, is voting a right or a privilege? I ask because at one time newly freed slaves were denied the right to vote. So, when they were denied a chance to vote, that would, by your logic, mean that at that time voting was a privilege and not a right. Whereas now, because African Americans can vote, it's a right. Just because our RIGHTS are currently suppressed, doesn't mean they aren't rights. For years Washington DC made it illegal to have a handgun at home. During that time, was owning a firearm a privilege or a right?

As far as the non-explanation, I'm not sure what you're referring to. I tried to address all your questions/concerns, but if I missed any, I am happy to try to answer them. Just let me know. As I stated earlier, I am committed to trying to help "newbies" and those with legitimate questions and a willingness to learn. All I ask is that you actually take to heart what is said and the effort required (and not just by myself) to respond. I think I speak for most when I say we all want to help the new guys. We were all in the same boat at one time. 
Title: Re: yet another reason to not escalate straight to deadly force if ccw were allowed
Post by: HiCarry on February 28, 2014, 04:12:48 PM
the help bringing me up to speed is much appreciated. I dont think I have ever claimed to be well informed, I haveonly been stating my opinions and trying to understand others.  Damn, you know how much damn typing this is... its sure is time consuming... leading me to question if the investment is even worth the effort to reach an understanding.
Of course the effort is worth it....if you are considering concealed carry, or even just trying to wrap your head around the issues, information is key.
Title: Re: yet another reason to not escalate straight to deadly force if ccw were allowed
Post by: 338KID on February 28, 2014, 04:19:44 PM



But smart people will use things that reduce the need for physical confrontation and/or give them the upper hand in the situation so that they can neutralize the threat without risking increased probability of bodily harm and/or death.
Very true 
If it came down to a fist fight I would of gotten hurt . If it came down to the quicker draw I would of gotten shot . The only way I would win is to be the smarter man and walk .
Title: Re: yet another reason to not escalate straight to deadly force if ccw were allowed
Post by: bubba808 on February 28, 2014, 04:27:39 PM
On this note, I think that you may have a fundamental misunderstanding of what the right to self-defense has consisted of in this country from our founding.  People have always been able to carry arms (guns) for self-defense and defense of others.  If you care to read the Peruta decision, I think it's probably the best written opinion covering history on the 2nd Amendment that I have seen.  They cover almost all of the State cases that are routinely mis-attributed.  The only time "conceal" carry has been really authorized to be banned, was when open carry of arms was available. To this point, carrying concealed was considered a cowards way of carrying a gun; in today's standards, we would reverse this as too many people are butt hurt when they see a firearm.  My bias aside, the opinions holding against really skim the surface looking for quotes they can toss in for a citation, but completely do not get the message from the courts they cite.  They are really being disingenuous and it's kind of repulsive.

 In earlier periods, minority races were suppressed by democrats and had gun rights restricted in order to keep African Americans unarmed.  This is essentially where 'gun control,' as we know it, began.   This continued and incidents like the Black Panthers march on the California State capitol lead to more gun crime laws and regulations. Politicians have used gun crime to further their attempts to look hard and tough and crime and gangs.  Then during prohibition, Federal agents were getting their tails handed to them by thugs and common citizens, so they started to ban the full auto firearms and other devices under the NFA etc.

The problem with saying that this is not arizona, vermont, alaka etc. is kind of a farce.  Hawaii is part of the United States; regardless of how it got there, or who thinks that it shouldn't be - it is. That means the state has to play ball under the Constitution.  The philosophy espoused by some of the Hawaii Court justices in that "Western law has no place on our islands" is garbage and makes those individuals a disgrace to the judicial system.  Justices do not get options on whether or not they want to uphold the constitution based on what state they live in.

To another point: The Kingdom of Hawaii also allowed the bearing of arms for self-defense.
i will take your advice and read the peruta decision as I find it very interesting.  I found you history lesson educational.  When you say kingdom of hawaii allowed bearing of arms for self defense, in what capacity? Open, concealed, or at home?  If im not mistaken, i can bear my arms for self defense in my own home... not sure about during sojourn or at other times.  I am aware of the constitution but as you well know, each state has its own subset of laws, and that is why there is such a great disparity when it comes to gun rights in our country. Regardless of how you feel about Hawaii justices decisions, the burden is theirs to uphold, and not ours.  My point about Hawaii is simply, we are not as restrictive as other states, and not as open as others, and with my current understanding (or lack of understanding) am okay to some extent with Hawaiis current 2A laws wrt ccw. 
Title: Re: yet another reason to not escalate straight to deadly force if ccw were allowed
Post by: bubba808 on February 28, 2014, 04:39:27 PM
Hey bubba808,

Here living in Hawaii where we haven't every really had a recognized right for concealed (or open) carry except for a couple politically chosen people in the past, this change can be scary in our minds. But think about this, many other states have gone through the exact same changes in recognizing the right to carry and they haven't experienced the "horrible catastrophes" that the Brady Campaign always promises.

One point, you say that you are worried about unstable people escalating situations and just start shooting, but do you also normally walk down these streets with the same concerns? Are you aware there are criminals that walk around every day carrying guns illegally? You may not think about it because it's "out of sight, out of mind." Sometimes the things that can scare us the most are our own ideas of what can happen.
I do think about this when walking around, I am weary but not as worried about being hit with a hand, fist, or knife than I am about a bullet, given a bullets range and destructive capacity. 
Since you mentioned the above, I assume that you don't know that there is a lawsuit out right now being considered in the 9th circuit court for Hawaii (Baker v. Kealoha). That is also why we start having these discussions. I was aware of the hdf but not this specific caseAs was the opinion of the three judge panel in Peruta v. San Diego, they hold that the right to carry outside the home is a historically recognized right. This is important because the government will often try and gradually take away rights, slowly but surely, and this is something we are gaining back.

If you don't know, it is legal to carry today in Hawaii with an issued concealed carry permit. Historically, however, Hawaii has created a de facto ban on carry by not issuing any permits at all. A few police chiefs in the past have issued these permits (more than 10 years ago) but only has issued them to politically connected citizens.this I was definately aware of, thats why when I discuss ccw, I usually stated that it isnt granted... that being by the chief of police.
Title: Re: yet another reason to not escalate straight to deadly force if ccw were allowed
Post by: bubba808 on February 28, 2014, 04:40:26 PM
 :thumbsup:
Very true 
If it came down to a fist fight I would of gotten hurt . If it came down to the quicker draw I would of gotten shot . The only way I would win is to be the smarter man and walk .
Title: Re: yet another reason to not escalate straight to deadly force if ccw were allowed
Post by: HiCarry on February 28, 2014, 04:51:12 PM
You say you no mean to bash then you bash.  As stated, your post was insulting.  Interesting how you correlate assult weapon ownership with CCW.  Im fine with owning firearm, and I own many myself, including assult rifles, I think its great and i do wish there was more freedom of movement as I feel the HRSs are overly restrictive, but to me CCW is totally different, its  unencumbered, and hidden, and anybody could be packing.  Of course, I can have an opinion... you dont like it? IDGAF!   Im not saying you have to agree, im just expressing a difference of opinion and looking for some objective evidence that would cause me to change my mind.

First, let's all take a deep breath and assume that no one is bashing anyone. Remember, here on the interweb it is sometimes difficult to convey the nuances of actual conversation, so let's try to play nice in the sandbox. Second, I doubt you own an "assault rifle" as that denotes a select fire weapon. You most likely own what the press and anti's like to call an "assault weapon" which is made up term, conceived to promote confusion and fear over any military looking rifle. But, that being said, the analogy to an "assault weapon" and concealed carry isn't that far off. Believe it or not, some people would make it illegal for you to own that semi-automatic rifle just because "they" call it an "assault weapon." You, from what I can deduce from your multiple statements, don't think folks should be able to concealed carry, or that you believe the practice should be restricted to a small class of people you believe are better trained. (on a side note, you know what the yearly round count to re-qualify at HPD is? Take a wild guess.....) However, the data (and this is true, hard data, not the "..I feel..." or "I think"...type of emotional argument that is so frequently used by anti's...) does not support the wild west shootouts or gunfights over minor issues as you seem to suggest will happen. Florida is a prime example. As one of the leaders in the "shall issue" concealed carry movement, they originally created, funded and maintained a database just to keep track of crimes committed by all these newly permitted residents. They maintained that database for something like 10 years and finally shut it down. You know why? Because, in general, those individuals that are willing to go thru the necessary process to get a CCW are extremely law abiding. The legislature finally determined that so few crimes, of any kind, not just firearms related, were committed by CCW holders that it was no cost effective to keep the registry open. Data from other states mirrors those findings and currently, across the nation, those that hold CCWs are less likely than the population in general to commit ANY crime, let alone a firearms related one. And it is interesting that many of the folks who were initially opposed to CCW based on the same fears and concerns you raise, such as LE, have subsequently come out and said they were wrong and that all the bad things they tthought would happen never did. And finally, I think it says a lot that not one state that has made it easier to get a CCW has repealed its law, or subsequently made it more difficult to get one.

 I did not fail to understand that athe basic requirements Must be met.  as stated, I personally dont agree with how arbitrary or basic the requirement is as the threshold is left up to feelings of individual. You realize some people are more "sensitive" than others right? So if the same "sensitive" people can and probably will get CCW if it is granted, and the start "feeling" threatened, and start whipping out guns and maybe shooting someone... i think that will suck more than the pleasure of carrying.  Also as Funtimes stated, it is unsure what amount of additional training, if any, will be needed to obtain CCW, and now.. possibly without "good cause", more of the "sensitives" might be packing in the future.  Thats what I dont like.  Again, these are my opinions.

And while you are entitled to your opinions, you are not entitled to your own facts. As stated above, your concern that WHEN we get CCW folks will be shooting each other over parking stalls and other perceived slights, just isn't going to happen. It hasn't happened anywhere else in the US that has liberal CCW laws, why do you suspect it will happen here? Are the people of Hawaii dumber than their counterparts on the mainland? Are they in general, more prone to unprovoked outbursts than those on the mainland? What personality flaws make you think individuals in Hawaii aren't going to be as safe, responsible, and restrained as those on the mainland? You do realize that most of the shooting we have had here have been with illegal, non-registered guns, right? With the exception of Uyesugi and Deedy, the notable firearms related shootings have all been with non-registered guns. So, don't be too concerned about those legal, law abiding citizens with guns, be concerned with the criminals that will carry and use firearms regardless of what any law says.

The military/LEO is an oversight on my part, what I intended to convey was military leo/non military leo... just so there is NO mistaking, let me say I do NOT agree that every member of the military should have CCW, only those military members in a LEO capacity.  Sorry for not being clear enough.

WRT this being Hawaii, if you raed my other posts, i stated that have experienced CCW/open carry and it doesnt feel as comfortable, , I felt uneasy, tense, on edge, as I had an added worry that I might bump into somebody and get shot, or my family might get shot, and every other day on the news, something gun related.... here I feel relaxed, at ease, I no need be as worried, the news get gun related violence... rarely tho.  So please, no get excited bu.. and as far you being Hawaiian, what does race/ethnicity have to do with any of this? Are you saying that only your views are representative of local style cuz youre Hawaiian?   Im saying that per the video where da other hawaiian was goin racial on da haoles, he was wrong, but it wasnt threatening enough to meet the basic requirements to warrant CCW and the accompanying ability to use deadly force.  I am starting to understand HiCarry and Funtimes points about if the situation were to have escalated that it could become to the level where thay may choose to use and be justified under the law.  And like they said, if I dont like the law, tough.  Me personally, I am choosing to hold myself to a higher standard than the laws of man, I am following the laws of GOD, by choosing not to kill another man.  Again this is my CHOICE, im not telling them to do the same, im telling them my opinion.

And I would bet that all those news stories, or at least the vast majority, were about people using illegal guns, not lawful concealed carriers. I also hate to break it to you, but a lot of the crimes, including violent and firearms related, are not reported in the news. If you personally know any cops, ask them haw frequently these crimes are actually committed versus reported. You will be surprised. And God did not say you not kill, he said you should not murder. Killing in defense of yourself, your family, or the church was never thought to be a sin.

furthermore, you can believe whatever you like about CCW being a right.  But Is it really a right if its not acknowledged? I dont think so...otherwise id ask you to execise your right.   If you feel like your rights are being infringed upon, go confront or  sue whoever is taking your rights.  Dont get mad at me cuz I get a difference of opinion.

Please see my other response about a right versus a privilege. Was it a right to own a handgun in Washington DC before the Heller decision? Of course it was, that's why it went to court. Just because you can't exercise a right doesn't make it not a right and suggesting otherwise again shows a certain amount of ignorance about the topic one would otherwise think one would have at this point in time. And, just to be clear, I use ignorance/ignorant not as a pejorative, but rather to convey that you just don't know...

Title: Re: yet another reason to not escalate straight to deadly force if ccw were allowed
Post by: bubba808 on February 28, 2014, 04:54:36 PM
Of course the effort is worth it....if you are considering concealed carry, or even just trying to wrap your head around the issues, information is key.
I agree, that is why i am making the effort, thanks to patient mature people.  It is pretty sad that just because I question something, or i have difference of opinion, or debate an issue, some on this forum, perceive it as a threat, or challenge to their own personal opinion and reply with such hostility and disrespect, and brand me as a gun grabber or lump me in with the likes of a knudsen. SMH
Title: Re: yet another reason to not escalate straight to deadly force if ccw were allowed
Post by: HiCarry on February 28, 2014, 05:29:18 PM
Me too, I let statistic weigh in on my decisions also.  When I asked for statistics, none were provided.

Remind me what statistics you were asking for. The most recent study, started after after Obama's EO that allowed the CDC to use funding to fuel gun research, stated that self defense shootings were at least as common as the criminal use of guns.

http://news.investors.com/ibd-editorials/082113-668335-cdc-gun-violence-study-goes-against-media-narrative.htm (http://news.investors.com/ibd-editorials/082113-668335-cdc-gun-violence-study-goes-against-media-narrative.htm) and http://www.gunsandammo.com/2013/08/27/cdc-gun-research-backfires-on-obama/ (http://www.gunsandammo.com/2013/08/27/cdc-gun-research-backfires-on-obama/)

And a link to the study itself: http://www.nap.edu/openbook.php?record_id=18319&page= (http://www.nap.edu/openbook.php?record_id=18319&page=)

And here's a good general information resource that debunks many of the gun myths you seem to buy into: http://www.gunfacts.info/ (http://www.gunfacts.info/)

People with concealed carry permits are:
• 5.7 times less likely to be arrested for violent offenses than the general public
• 13.5 times less likely to be arrested for non-violent offenses than the general public
An Analysis of the Arrest Rate of Texas Concealed Carry Handgun License Holders as Compared to the Arrest Rate of the Entire Texas Population, William E. Sturdevant, PE, September 11, 1999

In Texas, citizens with concealed carry permits are 14 times less likely to commit a crime. They are also five times less likely to commit a violent crime.
Texas Department of Public Safety and the U.S. Census Bureau, reported in San Antonio Express-News, September, 2000

Even gun control organizations agree it is a non-problem, as in Texas – “because there haven't been Wild West shootouts in the streets” - Nina Butts, Texans Against Gun Violence, Dallas Morning News, August 10, 2000

Of 14,000 CCW licensees in Oregon, only 4 (0.03%) were convicted of the criminal (not necessarily violent) use or possession of a firearm.

“I'm detecting that I'm eating a lot of crow on this issue ... I think that says something, that we've gotten to this point in the year and in the third largest city in America there has not been a single charge against anyone that had anything to do with a concealed handgun.”
John Holmes, Harris County [Houston, TX] District Attorney, In Session: Handgun Law's First Year Belies Fears of 'Blood in the Streets,” Texas Lawyer, December 9, 1996

In Florida, a state that has allowed concealed carry since late 1987, you are twice as likely to be attacked by an alligator as by a person with a concealed carry permit.
Concealed Weapons/Firearms License Statistical Report, Florida Department of State, 1998 – Florida Game and Fresh Water Fish Commission, December 1998

Compared to the entire population, Texas CCW holders are about 7.6 times less likely to be arrested for a violent crime.
Texas Department of Corrections data, 1996-2000, compiled by the Texas State Rifle Association, www.tsra.com/arrests.htm (http://www.tsra.com/arrests.htm)

A different study concludes that the four year violent crime arrest rate for CCW holders is 128 per 100,000. For the general population, it is 710 per 100,000. In other words, CCW holders are 5.5 times less likely to commit a violent crime.
An Analysis Of The Arrest Rate Of Texas Concealed Handgun License Holders As Compared To The Arrest Rate Of The Entire Texas Population, William E. Sturdevant, PE, September 11, 1999

“I lobbied against the law in 1993 and 1995 because I thought it would lead to wholesale armed conflict. That hasn't happened. All the horror stories I thought would come to pass didn't happen. No bogeyman. I think it's worked out well, and that says good things about the citizens who have permits. I'm a convert."
Glenn White, President of the Dallas Police Association, Dallas Morning News, December 23, 1997

“It has impressed me how remarkably responsible the permit holders have been.”
Colonel James Wilson, Director Texas Department of Public Safety, Dallas Morning News, Jun 11, 1996

Multiple victim public shootings drop in states that pass shall-issue CCW legislation.
Multiple Victim Public Shootings, Bombings, and Right-to-Carry Concealed Handgun Laws: Contrasting Private and Public Law Enforcement, Lott John R., Landes William M.; University of Chicago – covers years 1977 to 1995


Are you seriously questioning if my feelings are justified? My uncomfortable feeling is a result of my own perceptions, how can you tell if my feeling are justified, as they are my feelings.  Just like the feelings of being threatened are based on the individuals perceptions may or may not be justified to you, but to me they are justified.

While you are entitled to your feelings, it isn't improper to have someone note, especially if they can provide a factual basis for it, to say your fears are unfounded. If you fear that a lawful CCW holder is going to shoot you while you are visiting the mainland, your fears are unfounded based on the statistics. Which is why so many of "us" are quick to call you (and anyone else) on your use of "feelings" over logic and factual information. You can be afraid to fly, but statistically you are safer flying than driving in a car. That's a fact, and if you wanted to advertise to the world that you were afraid of flying, I suspect many would be all too willing to correctly state that your "feelings" were unfounded.

 Imam agreeing with you about the problem with extreme scenarios, but that goes for both sides of the issue, which is what I was trying to illustrate.   
My question WRT CCW, is not wether crime is low, was crime high before and now that ccw was is allowed, did it go down?  I.e. did ccw actually decrease crime?   I understand what youre saying about criminals, however criminals are the extreme, if you read my posts, I have stated that my concern would be more about the increased number of firearms in public and the careless use of these firearms.  I think I mentioned that the shooting were reported to be due to apparent road rage and altercation in a parking lot etc.  These were non accidental from citizens, not LEO, if citizen was a criminal it was not or could not be determined via news report.
WRT gang related crime, youre saying gangs cause higher crime rates and other states have a bigger problem with gang crime than Hawaii, so arent you providing statistics that say Hawaii has less crime? So do we then need ccw to reduce crime when we already have less crime?

See some of the facts I noted above. The bottom line is: good law abiding folks are not going to suddenly become careless and whip out their gun at the slightest provocation. That crime generally goes down after CCW is passed, along with mass shootings. That all the blood in the streets, gun fights over trivial matters aren't going to happen....unless that is, you somehow think the good citizens of Hawaii are fundamentally different and less capable of restraint and good judgement than those who live on the mainland.
Title: Re: yet another reason to not escalate straight to deadly force if ccw were allowed
Post by: ImKu on February 28, 2014, 05:56:46 PM
property crime rates may be high, but its almost irrelevant as you couldnt use deadly force against a thief,  or does getting robbed make a case for feeling threatened/terrified and using deadly force? If ccw were allowed, could you draw your weapon to stop/control a thief without getting in trouble?  What if thief is leaving (heading away from you) with your jewelry, and you draw and yell stop, he doesnt see and continues to head away; could you do anything?

THIS is why I state that you do not understand the requirements that must be met prior to using Deadly Force, as YOU are the one asking the questions here in bold.  Here's one.  Never point you weapon at someone unless you intend to shoot.  BASIC firearms safety.  Maybe I was taught differently, but safe firearms handling and the rules and regulations of Deadly Force and when it is justified to use is ingrained from training.  You stay you understand the requirements, then you should be able to answer your questions yourself then.


You say you no mean to bash then you bash.  As stated, your post was insulting.  Interesting how you correlate assult weapon ownership with CCW.  Im fine with owning firearm, and I own many myself, including assult rifles, I think its great and i do wish there was more freedom of movement as I feel the HRSs are overly restrictive, but to me CCW is totally different, its  unencumbered, and hidden, and anybody could be packing.  Of course, I can have an opinion... you dont like it? IDGAF!   Im not saying you have to agree, im just expressing a difference of opinion and looking for some objective evidence that would cause me to change my mind.

 I did not fail to understand that athe basic requirements Must be met.  as stated, I personally dont agree with how arbitrary or basic the requirement is as the threshold is left up to feelings of individual. You realize some people are more "sensitive" than others right? So if the same "sensitive" people can and probably will get CCW if it is granted, and the start "feeling" threatened, and start whipping out guns and maybe shooting someone... i think that will suck more than the pleasure of carrying.  Also as Funtimes stated, it is unsure what amount of additional training, if any, will be needed to obtain CCW, and now.. possibly without "good cause", more of the "sensitives" might be packing in the future.  Thats what I dont like.  Again, these are my opinions.

The military/LEO is an oversight on my part, what I intended to convey was military leo/non military leo... just so there is NO mistaking, let me say I do NOT agree that every member of the military should have CCW, only those military members in a LEO capacity.  Sorry for not being clear enough.

WRT this being Hawaii, if you raed my other posts, i stated that have experienced CCW/open carry and it doesnt feel as comfortable, , I felt uneasy, tense, on edge, as I had an added worry that I might bump into somebody and get shot, or my family might get shot, and every other day on the news, something gun related.... here I feel relaxed, at ease, I no need be as worried, the news get gun related violence... rarely tho.  So please, no get excited bu.. and as far you being Hawaiian, what does race/ethnicity have to do with any of this? Are you saying that only your views are representative of local style cuz youre Hawaiian?   Im saying that per the video where da other hawaiian was goin racial on da haoles, he was wrong, but it wasnt threatening enough to meet the basic requirements to warrant CCW and the accompanying ability to use deadly force.  I am starting to understand HiCarry and Funtimes points about if the situation were to have escalated that it could become to the level where thay may choose to use and be justified under the law.  And like they said, if I dont like the law, tough.  Me personally, I am choosing to hold myself to a higher standard than the laws of man, I am following the laws of GOD, by choosing not to kill another man.  Again this is my CHOICE, im not telling them to do the same, im telling them my opinion.

furthermore, you can believe whatever you like about CCW being a right.  But Is it really a right if its not acknowledged? I dont think so...otherwise id ask you to execise your right.   If you feel like your rights are being infringed upon, go confront or  sue whoever is taking your rights.  Dont get mad at me cuz I get a difference of opinion.

OMG man, you keep missing my point.  You are basically stating that because you worry about "sensitive" people with the ability of obtaining CCW will go and shoot people for no reason, that CCW is not a good idea for Hawaii.  Am I right?  PLEASE explain how that is any different than someone that is worried that an "assault weapon" (as the liberal media would say) in the hands of a crazy person is the reason they should be banned.   :popcorn: 

I was not bashing (don't know how many different ways I can put that), but it was supposed to be informative for you to see another perspective of what others may gather from your posts.  If you still do not see the correlation then I have nothing more to add (and will stop trying).

For the military, I will speak for myself.  Part of our basic job entails LEO type of duty (armed sentries).  So, I guess your talking specifically base police (to make the group smaller). 

As far as the race thing, that is a different tangent that you decided to go off on your own.  Not me.  YOU are the one that quoted me and then stated "this is Hawaii".  Hence my response.  STOP trying to insinuate that I am saying anything if I didn't state it myself.  To answer your question, no I am not stating that because I am Hawaiian that only my views represent "local style".  Your assumptions have been way off the mark man, so if you need clarification it's better you ask than assume.
Title: Re: yet another reason to not escalate straight to deadly force if ccw were allowed
Post by: bubba808 on February 28, 2014, 05:59:37 PM


, I doubt you own an "assault rifle" as that denotes a select fire weapon. You most likely own..l an "assault weapon" you are correct, forgive my mistake.  I can only dream about owning a full auto AR or AK.

You, from what I can deduce from your multiple statements, don't think folks should be able to concealed carry, or that you believe the practice should be restricted to a small class of people you believe are better trained. (on a side note, you know what the yearly round count to re-qualify at HPD is? Take a wild guess.....) However, the data (and this is true, hard data, not the "..I feel..." or "I think"...type of emotional argument that is so frequently used by anti's...) does not support the wild west shootouts or gunfights over minor issues as you seem to suggest will happen. Florida is a prime example. As one of the leaders in the "shall issue" concealed carry movement, they originally created, funded and maintained a database just to keep track of crimes committed by all these newly permitted residents. They maintained that database for something like 10 years and finally shut it down. You know why? Because, in general, those individuals that are willing to go thru the necessary process to get a CCW are extremely law abiding. The legislature finally determined that so few crimes, of any kind, not just firearms related, were committed by CCW holders that it was no cost effective to keep the registry open. Data from other states mirrors those findings and currently, across the nation, those that hold CCWs are less likely than the population in general to commit ANY crime, let alone a firearms related one. And it is interesting that many of the folks who were initially opposed to CCW based on the same fears and concerns you raise, such as LE, have subsequently come out and said they were wrong and that all the bad things they tthought would happen never did. And finally, I think it says a lot that not one state that has made it easier to get a CCW has repealed its law, or subsequently made it more difficult to get one. 
very interesting these are the statistics that I had asked for in the first place.  Where are these metrics published (I.e. are they verifiable?)

And while you are entitled to your opinions, you are not entitled to your own facts. As stated above, your concern that WHEN we get CCW folks will be shooting each other over parking stalls and other perceived slights, just isn't going to happen. It hasn't happened anywhere else in the US that has liberal CCW laws, why do you suspect it will happen here? its just a concern I have, what credible sources provide info that you are talking about, so I can read and investigate further.  Are the people of Hawaii dumber than their counterparts on the mainland? as in every state, some are dumber than others, if we use test scores as an indicator, what do you think the answer is?Are they in general, more prone to unprovoked outbursts than those on the mainland? I think yes, thats why Q thinks if ccw is granted, people will start becoming more polite.What personality flaws make you think individuals in Hawaii aren't going to be as safe, responsible, and restrained as those on the mainland? personality wise, as evidenced by this very forum, in my experience ppl in Hi are more emotional, more passionate than ppl on the mainland.  Try go to one local party, vs a mainland party, seem more subduedYou do realize that most of the shooting we have had here have been with illegal, non-registered guns, right?nope I didnt, please sight your source. With the exception of Uyesugi and Deedy, the notable firearms related shootings have all been with non-registered guns. So, don't be too concerned about those legal, law abiding citizens with guns, be concerned with the criminals that will carry and use firearms regardless of what any law says. 
interesting, definately makes me think more about ccw

And I would bet that all those news stories, or at least the vast majority, were about people using illegal guns, not lawful concealed carriersit is possible, but no way to confirm as it wasnt stated in the news. I also hate to break it to you, but a lot of the crimes, including violent and firearms related, are not reported in the news. If you personally know any cops, ask them haw frequently these crimes are actually committed versus reported. You will be surprised. I have discussed this with cop friends and relatives, what you speak of was never said
And God did not say you not kill, he said you should not murder. Killing in defense of yourself, your family, or the church was never thought to be a sin. 
my friend, you do not get to interpret GODs word for me, you are way out of bounds.  You are correct, murder, and the bible defines a murderer as anyone who strikes another down and causes death.  If you need other bible verses to support the fact to support, lmk.


Please see my other response about a right versus a privilege. Was it a right to own a handgun in Washington DC before the Heller decision? Of course it was, that's why it went to court. Just because you can't exercise a right doesn't make it not a right and suggesting otherwise again shows a certain amount of ignorance about the topic one would otherwise think one would have at this point in time. And, just to be clear, I use ignorance/ignorant not as a pejorative, but rather to convey that you just don't know...as I have said, owning a handgun is vastly different than ccw said gun.  If you have the right to ccw, do it.  Let me see you do it.  If you get arrested, your defense can be, "you are within your rights". Let me see you exercise your right lawfully....just saying.



Title: Re: yet another reason to not escalate straight to deadly force if ccw were allowed
Post by: bubba808 on February 28, 2014, 06:20:55 PM
THIS is why I state that you do not understand the requirements that must be met prior to using Deadly Force, as YOU are the one asking the questions here in bold.  Here's one.  Never point you weapon at someone unless you intend to shoot.  BASIC firearms safety.  Maybe I was taught differently, but safe firearms handling and the rules and regulations of Deadly Force and when it is justified to use is ingrained from training.  You stay you understand the requirements, then you should be able to answer your questions yourself then.
so my response denying that theres a correlation between property crime and use of deadly force, because you cannot use deadly force for property crime  confuses you.  I know the answer to the question, I am posing the question to the individual who posted it so the realize the answer.

OMG man, you keep missing my point.  You are basically stating that because you worry about "sensitive" people with the ability of obtaining CCW will go and shoot people for no reason, that CCW is not a good idea for Hawaii.  Am I right?  PLEASE explain how that is any different than someone that is worried that an "assault weapon" (as the liberal media would say) in the hands of a crazy person is the reason they should be banned.   :popcorn: 
I see your point, youre missing mine.  Where can you bring an assult weapon lawfully right now? Its very restrictive.  And thats good, it keeps guns at home or at the range or on hunting grounds.  CCW will now mean firearms could be everywhere around us at any time.  Get it?

I was not bashing (don't know how many different ways I can put that), but it was supposed to be informative for you to see another perspective of what others may gather from your posts.  If you still do not see the correlation then I have nothing more to add (and will stop trying).  Well seemed like a cheap shot, and it was insulting to me. LoL.. its like say "no get insulted but youre ugly, and I only wanted to tell you that ppl might think youre ugly cuz your face.  Ah kaman. 

For the military, I will speak for myself.  Part of our basic job entails LEO type of duty (armed sentries).  So, I guess your talking specifically base police (to make the group smaller). Do those LEO type duties extend beyond the jurisdiction of the thing or place youre guarding?  I dont mind military leo types but only within their jurisdiction, which is usually on base.

As far as the race thing, that is a different tangent that you decided to go off on your own.  Not me.  YOU are the one that quoted me and then stated "this is Hawaii".  Hence my response.  STOP trying to insinuate that I am saying anything if I didn't state it myself.  To answer your question, no I am not stating that because I am Hawaiian that only my views represent "local style".  Your assumptions have been way off the mark man, so if you need clarification it's better you ask than assume.  You da one said "im kanaka maoli" you brought up race....the fact of the matter is this Hawaii,  a region made up of many races and cultures.

nuff for today, my beer getting cold.... enjoy your weekend
Title: Re: yet another reason to not escalate straight to deadly force if ccw were allowed
Post by: bubba808 on February 28, 2014, 06:25:04 PM

ok give me time to read and rebutt if necessary... this shit giving me a headache... I no believe I get homework. 
Title: Re: yet another reason to not escalate straight to deadly force if ccw were allowed
Post by: ImKu on February 28, 2014, 06:25:41 PM



I also see your point.  Aloha :shaka:
Title: Re: yet another reason to not escalate straight to deadly force if ccw were allowed
Post by: HiCarry on February 28, 2014, 06:57:36 PM
Bubba:
First, I CITED all the statistics I provided. It is in the format of most scholarly articles in that the title of the piece along with the source and date of said source follows. I have done far more work in researching these statistics than you appear to be willing to do. I suggest that you actually review those, and others, before asking me to do more.

I provided you the "credible sources" you want in regards to CCW and the rate of crime perpetrated by permit holders. There are others and all substantiate the same conclusion: Those law abiding concealed carry permittees are more law abiding than the general public and less likely to commit any violent crime.

Regarding the source of info on the Hawaii shootings: that is from following those stories through the years. If you doubt my statement, please feel free to research it to your heart's content.

As to the police and the number of violent crimes and the under reporting of those crimes: I work with the police on a regular basis and therefore talk frequently with many different officers. This is what I am told. In addition, in 20+ years at a local trauma center, I can tell you that only a fraction of the violent crimes make it to the news. I recall nights where we were inundated with victims of violent crimes and thought I'd surely see some news coverage of those incidents, but rarely did.

As for the whole "If you have a right to ccw do it..." attitude is a clear indication that you are willfully ignorant at to what rights are. You need to educate yourself and be willing to accept that what you thought, and beliefs you held may be wrong. It is interesting to me that instead of answering the two questions I posed to you about this issue, you instead choose to reiterate your previous remarks. This too, IMHO, shows a clear unwillingness to actually process new information and learn. You profess to come here to do just that, learn. But your attitude in one of closed mindedness.

As for "interpreting GODs [sic] word for [you]..." Well, bubba, this just illustrates even more how indoctrinated you are to your own beliefs and how unwilling you are to learn. Here are a few links, readily available in less than a few seconds via Google that easily refutes your biblical "definition" of murder:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Thou_shalt_not_kill (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Thou_shalt_not_kill)

http://biblehub.com/exodus/20-13.htm (http://biblehub.com/exodus/20-13.htm)

http://www.godandscience.org/apologetics/notkill.html (http://www.godandscience.org/apologetics/notkill.html)

http://carm.org/questions/you-shall-not-kill-yet-god-kills (http://carm.org/questions/you-shall-not-kill-yet-god-kills)

http://www.rumormillnews.com/cgi-bin/archive.cgi?read=31043 (http://www.rumormillnews.com/cgi-bin/archive.cgi?read=31043)

http://people.ucalgary.ca/~elsegal/Shokel/001102_ThouShaltNotMurder.html (http://people.ucalgary.ca/~elsegal/Shokel/001102_ThouShaltNotMurder.html)

http://winteryknight.wordpress.com/2010/03/25/does-the-bible-say-thou-shalt-not-kill-or-thou-shalt-not-murder/ (http://winteryknight.wordpress.com/2010/03/25/does-the-bible-say-thou-shalt-not-kill-or-thou-shalt-not-murder/)

If you recall your Sunday School studies, you should also remember that it was Jesus that said if you don't have a sword, sell your cloak to buy one....what use is a sword if not for killing?


Title: Re: yet another reason to not escalate straight to deadly force if ccw were allowed
Post by: new guy on February 28, 2014, 07:44:42 PM
too... many... words...

 ;D

I respectfully submit that agreeing to disagree and moving onto greener pastures might be in order, at this point.
Title: Re: yet another reason to not escalate straight to deadly force if ccw were allowed
Post by: kia_killer on February 28, 2014, 10:35:23 PM
Me too, I let statistic weigh in on my decisions also.  When I asked for statistics, none were provided.  Are you seriously questioning if my feelings are justified? My uncomfortable feeling is a result of my own perceptions, how can you tell if my feeling are justified, as they are my feelings.  Just like the feelings of being threatened are based on the individuals perceptions may or may not be justified to you, but to me they are justified. Imam agreeing with you about the problem with extreme scenarios, but that goes for both sides of the issue, which is what I was trying to illustrate.   
My question WRT CCW, is not wether crime is low, was crime high before and now that ccw was is allowed, did it go down?  I.e. did ccw actually ear decrease crime?   I understand what youre saying about criminals, however criminals are the extreme, if you read my posts, I have stated that my concern would be more about the increased number of firearms in public and the careless use of these firearms.  I think I mentioned that the shooting were reported to be due to apparent road rage and altercation in a parking lot etc.  These were non accidental from citizens, not LEO, if citizen was a criminal it was not or could not be determined via news report.
WRT gang related crime, youre saying gangs cause higher crime rates and other states have a bigger problem with gang crime than Hawaii, so arent you providing statistics that say Hawaii has less crime? So do we then need ccw to reduce crime when we already have less crime?

 The discussion has never been about reducing crime, at least from my perspective. Reduction in crime is a documented side effect of ccw which is a plus, but this discussion has been about the right and ability to defend yourself effectively against possibly armed assailants intent on doing harm to you or your family.  Even though Hawaii has relatively low crime rates, if ccw could drop that more, would that be a bad thing??? "Imam agreeing with you about the problem with extreme scenarios, but that goes for both sides of the issue, which is what I was trying to illustrate" I here what you're saying, but the issue isn't that I'm not seeing the other side of hypotheticals. The difference between the two sides is this. Your hypotheticals are extreme and don't have any real evidence that they will be common scenarios if ccw is allowed. The other sides hypotheticals involving physical limitations are far more substantial and realistic. I know several people with heart conditions and/or back problems. Take into account all the possible injuries people could have that would put them at a physical disadvantage against an attacker and you see how these hypotheticals aren't nearly as far fetched as you might think. Also for the record, no one here has said or implied that use of force is the first option in any scenario. Deescalation or walking away should always be the first option, but there are possible situations where that may not be feasible. I could lay out a hypothetical, but we both know how well that would be received. Let's just say that if I am ever faced with any type of said hypothetical, I would like to be able to effectively defend myself. Without ccw I am unable to even be prepared for such a situation if it ever comes around. As for the remainder of your post I'll direct you to HiCarry's post and the link I provided earlier.
Title: Re: yet another reason to not escalate straight to deadly force if ccw were allowed
Post by: HiCarry on March 01, 2014, 04:30:21 PM
I don't think the discussion started out about reducing crime, but tangentially wandered into areas other than the OP probably intended. My desire in participating in this type of discussion stems from the hope that all of "us" will be able to participate in discussions here, so we can all hone our ability to counter the anti-gun message where ever that might be needed. It could be talking to your family or friends, or your legislators. We all need to be informed and be able to argue with facts and not rely on the "emotional" arguments of "I feel" or "I think" like the anti's tend to.

Prior "discussions" in other threads lead me to believe there was a need for this type of exchange. We all need to know what our rights are, how to exercise them effectively, and how to fight to get them back. I don't believe for a moment that just because your rights are being suppressed, that you should lay down and accept that they're gone forever. And that goes for all rights, not just our Second Amendment rights. Our right to "..be secure in their persons, houses, papers, and effects..." has slowly been eroded, the right against self-incrimination has been weakened, and people continue to suggest that we need to give up just a little bit more in the name of safety and security.

If these things bother you, if you complain about the overly strict firearms laws, about First Amendment exclusion zones, about arbitrary and unwarranted stops at so called remote border sites, you will need to get involved. And if you get involved, you'll need to know the facts, and be able to articulate those facts in a calm, reasonable, and courteous manner (at least most of the time...) in order to be effective.

Back to the question of reducing crime: It is a frequent ploy of the anti-gunners to suggest that if we have all these wanna-be cowboys out in public , that it is inevitable that shootings, even over trivial disagreements, will happen. That's what they say every chance they get and it makes for a great sound bite, so it sells to the mass market that has for years been force fed this and similar pablum. They'll claim it's just common sense, more guns equal more shootings....and crimes. And any attempts to get them "off message" with facts and real world experiences, will be met with great gnashing of teeth and wailing. "Think about the children" they'll cry, using statistics that include 15-20 year olds, you know, "gang aged" kids, to raise the number of  "kids" killed from firearms. So you must be able to counter this. And the stats they'll use about suicides, or that the Heller decision was a "sea change" interpretation by an "activist" Supreme Court. Do you know the history to refute those claims? Or the theory of substitution when it comes to suicide rates? 

So these discussions are useful, but only if we don't get sidetracked and get into snarky asides and vague claims of superior, super secrete training that makes someone the expert who's opinion should just be accepted. We're better than that and we have the ability to drive this effort. I think it's OK to disagree here, especially in terms of the technical aspects of firearms. What the best holster is, the best gun, the best caliber, the best room clearing method. But what we should not compromise on, what we should all agree upon, is that this is an "us" against "them" and we need to stay on message as well as they do. We need to resist to effort to stoop to their level and stick to facts. And we need to be willing to invest time and effort to bring the "newbies" into the fold. And be cognizant of the fact that the new folks will probably come in with some misconceptions and misinformation. So we have to take care of them, help them out, show them the truth (I sound like I should be asking you for a hallelujah next...) and be able to argue with the anti's. It's a tall order, but one we need to make happen if we wish to continue making the type of progress we've enjoyed the last few years.

So, discuss away. Opine to your hearts content. But let's stick to the facts, help each other out and remember that the anonymous person behind the screen name may be on the range next to you someday....

I'm climbing off my soapbox now.....
Title: Re: yet another reason to not escalate straight to deadly force if ccw were allowed
Post by: bubba808 on April 21, 2014, 12:09:31 PM

Bubba:

….As for "interpreting GODs [sic] word for [you]..." Well, bubba, this just illustrates even more how indoctrinated you are to your own beliefs and how unwilling you are to learn. Here are a few links, readily available in less than a few seconds via Google that easily refutes your biblical "definition" of murder:

 

  (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Thou_shalt_not_kill)

 

http  (http://biblehub.com/exodus/20-13.htm)

 

 (http://www.godandscience.org/apologetics/notkill.html)

 

http  (http://carm.org/questions/you-shall-not-kill-yet-god-kills)

 

  (http://www.rumormillnews.com/cgi-bin/archive.cgi?read=31043)

 

  (http://people.ucalgary.ca/~elsegal/Shokel/001102_ThouShaltNotMurder.html)

 

 (http://winteryknight.wordpress.com/2010/03/25/does-the-bible-say-thou-shalt-not-kill-or-thou-shalt-not-murder/)

 

If you recall your Sunday School studies, you should also remember that it was Jesus that said if you don't have a sword, sell your cloak to buy one....what use is a sword if not for killing?


 

 

As my responses are lengthy I will respond to HiCarry in 3 separate posts. 

1-         Regarding the need for CCW in Hawaii.

2-         Regarding the right to keep and bear arms (CCW specific).

3-         Regarding what the bible states about killing.

 

I will start with #3-

In our previous (unanswered) discussion I had explained that the bible did not allow killing per the sixth commandment, HiCarry had challenged my interpretation as he believes he is withing the biblical definition.  After reading through HiCarrys links, they only reinforced my beliefs and is evidence that he did not read or understand them before posting. I sincerely hope that his apparent ignorance (and when I say ignorant I mean the prejorative also as a (lack of understanding) and the subsequent advice he gave on GODs word does not lead any astray.

(Romans 16:17)

17 Now I urge you, brethren, keep your eye on those who cause dissentions and hindrances contrary to the teaching which you learned, and turn away from them.

18 For such men are slaves, not of our Lord Christ but of their own appetites; and by their smooth and flattering speech they deceive the hearts of the unsuspecting

 

Although I had prepared a rebuttal awhile ago, I was reluctant to post my response as the accurate interpretation of the word of GOD captured in the bible is a touchy subject to say the least.  I would not want to unintentionally lead anyone astray through misinterpreting GODs words.

(Jeremiah 23:2)

….Because you have scattered my flock and driven them away and have not bestowed care on them, I will bestow punishment on you for the evil you have done,

 

After recent Passover and Easter messages regarding life and that no matter how cold and lifeless others can be, the promise and the possibility of rebirth and renewal is always present.  And considering the consequence of not trying to help HiCarry, I have chosen to warn him one final time.

(Ezekiel 3:19)

Yet if thou warn the wicked (the unbeliever), and he turn not from his wickedness, nor from his wicked way (his way of salvation), he shall die in his iniquity; but thou hast delivered thy soul.

 

I would like to point out that the following is MY opinion regarding what the bible says about killing.  I feel that understanding the bible (the laws of GOD) is more important than understanding any man-made law like HRS in regards to use of deadly force even if you feel threatened.

 

To address the differeing opinion on killing, Let me start with a little about the origins of the bible.  The bible was originally captured in the Hebrew language.  The bible has been translated many, many, times before reaching its current iterations (i.e. current popular translation) (e.g New King James etc) and the translations can cloud the original word or intended meaning.  Therefore, I caution you in putting too much “weight” in certain translations as their meanings have been “diluted” over time, and certain versus and words meaning has been “lost in the translations”. 

 

I encourage you to research for yourself and consider many translations and if needed consider the original Hebrew words that were written in an attempt to understand what the word meant at the time it was written.

 

Now I feel that especially with a subject as important as “killing or murder” due to the consequences of acting with a poor understand.  I must point out the Hebrew words, originally written and their meaning, in order to understand the what GOD has intended.  Also understanding each verse in the context it was written.

 

The Israelites did not have a Hebrew term that precisely fits our present-day definition of murder. 

The intent of the sixth commandment was to protect individuals from danger.

The term for Murder in the context used in the Sixth Commandment (Exodus 20:13 & Deut 5:17) and other quoted verses can be easily misunderstood due to the ambiguity in terminology. The meaning of “Rasah” (Hebrew word for killing) had a specialized meaning in connection with “guilt” which was determined either by:

1)         the intention of the killer (whether premeditated or accidental) (Num 36:12-14, & Joshua 20:9)

or

2)         By the “type of object” used in the apparent manslaughter (Num 35:16-21); iron, stone, or wooden objects were considered likely to cause death.

In addition there are many other verses discussing this topic as follows:

 

(Exodus 23:7)

Have nothing to do with a false charge and do not put an innocent or honest person to death, for I will not acquit the guilty.

 

(Deuteronomy 5:17)

"You shall not murder.

 

(Numbers 35:12)

They will be places of refuge from the avenger, so that anyone accused of murder may not die before they stand trial before the assembly.

 

(Numbers 35:16-21)

16But if he struck him down with an iron object, so that he died, he is a murderer; the murderer shall surely be put to death. 17If he struck him down with a stone in the hand, by which he will die, and as a result he died, he is a murderer; the murderer shall surely be put to death. 18Or if he struck him with a wooden object in the hand, by which he might die, and as a result he died, he is a murderer; the murderer shall surely be put to death. 19'The blood avenger himself shall put the murderer to death; he shall put him to death when he meets him. 20If he pushed him of hatred, or threw something at him lying in wait and as a result he died, 21or if he struck him down with his hand in enmity, and as a result he died, the one who struck him shall surely be put to death, he is a murderer; the blood avenger shall put the murderer to death when he meets him.

 

(Numbers 36:12-14)

12'The cities shall be to you as a refuge from the avenger, so that the manslayer will not die until he stands before the congregation for trial. 13'The cities which you are to give shall be your six cities of refuge. 14'You shall give three cities across the Jordan and three cities in the land of Canaan; they are to be cities of refuge.…

 

(Joshua 20:9)

Any of the Israelites or any foreigner residing among them who killed someone accidentally could flee to these designated cities and not be killed by the avenger of blood prior to standing trial before the assembly.

 

 

Only GOD has the right to terminate life; killing can be allowed if it is carrying out of GODs will.   The only way you can kill someone IAW GODs will would be Killing in a Holy war(blessed by GOD), or executing capital punishment for someone was found guilty of murder (blood avenger), other than doing GODs will, Man does not have the expressed “Right” to kill. Murder deprives God of his property (human life), and a murderer has taken the property of GOD.(Leviticus 17:11-14, Leviticus 24:174:11).

 

(Genesis 9:5)

And for your lifeblood I will surely demand an accounting. I will demand an accounting from every animal. And from each human being, too, I will demand an accounting for the life of another human being.

 

(Genesis 9:6)

"Whoever sheds human blood, by humans shall their blood be shed; for in the image of God has God made mankind.

 

(Exodus 21:12)

"Anyone who strikes a person with a fatal blow is to be put to death.

 

(Leviticus 17:11)

11'For the life of the flesh is in the blood, and I have given it to you on the altar to make atonement for your souls; for it is the blood by reason of the life that makes atonement.'

 

(Leviticus 24:17)

"'Anyone who takes the life of a human being is to be put to death.

 

(2 Samuel 4:11)

11“How much more, when wicked men have killed a righteous man … shall I not now require his blood from your hand and destroy you from the earth?”

 

“Rasah” did not cover the subject of killing in war or capital punishment, which were done only at the command of God; thus, they were not in the same category as murder.

 

(Numbers 31:1)

The Lord spoke to Moses, saying, “Avenge the people of Israel on the Midianites. Afterward you shall be gathered to your people.” So Moses spoke to the people, saying, “Arm men from among you for the war, that they may go against Midian to execute the Lord's vengeance on Midian. You shall send a thousand from each of the tribes ofIsrael to the war.”

 

(Romans 13:1-14)

… there is no authority except from God, and those that exist have been instituted by God. ….if you do wrong, be afraid, for he does not bear the sword in vain. For he is the servant of God, an avenger who carries out God's wrath on the wrongdoer. Therefore one must be in subjection, not only to avoid God's wrath but also for the sake of conscience.

 

(Ephesians 6:10-20)

Finally, be strong in the Lord and in the strength of his might. Put on the whole armor of God, that you may be able to stand against the schemes of the devil. For we do not wrestle against flesh and blood, but against the rulers, against the authorities, against the cosmic powers over this present darkness, against the spiritual forces of evil in the heavenly places. Therefore take up the whole armor of God, that you may be able to withstand in the evil day, and having done all, to stand firm. Stand therefore, having fastened on the belt of truth, and having put on the breastplate of righteousness…

 

 

In biblical times, there were consequenses for killing.  The death penalty was imposed for persons who killed with premeditation (as described in the deadly force discussions we had on the other thread where you feel threatened), but not for persons who committed accidental manslaughter ( Exod 21:12-13 ; Lev 24:17 ; Deut 27:24).

If you were guilty of premeditated murder, you did not even require a trial( Exod 21:14 ; Num 35:19 ; Deut 19:11-13 ).

BUT the caveat for the avenger was that in order to kill someone in this situation a

1-         a premeditated murder had to be committed first

2-         and two witnesses were required to convict the premeditated murderer.   

Conviction of a murderer required two witnesses ( Num 35:30 ; Deut 17:6 ; 19:15 ; 1 Sam 21:4 ).

Continued.......
Title: Re: yet another reason to not escalate straight to deadly force if ccw were allowed
Post by: bubba808 on April 21, 2014, 12:12:41 PM
The blood avenger (Executioner), was not allowed to pity a murderer or else the land would be defiled ( Num 35:34 ; David put himself in the hands of God because of this (2 Sam 12:13 ). No money could be exchanged to “buy back your life” was allowed since this would have signified consent with the crime, undermining the value of human life and breaking the covenant with God.

 

(Exodus 21:12, 14) 

      12“He who strikes a man so that he dies shall surely be put to death. 13“But if he did not lie in wait for him, but God let him fall into his hand, then I will appoint you a place to which he may flee. 14“If, however, a man acts presumptuously toward his neighbor, so as to kill him craftily, you are to take him even from My altar, that he may die.

 

(Leviticus 24:17)

      17‘If a man takes the life of any human being, he shall surely be put to death. 18‘The one who takes the life of an animal shall make it good, life for life. 19‘If a man injures his neighbor, just as he has done, so it shall be done to him: 20fracture for fracture, eye for eye, tooth for tooth; just as he has injured a man, so it shall be inflicted on him. 21‘Thus the one who kills an animal shall make it good, but the one who kills a man shall be put to death. 22‘There shall be one standard for you; it shall be for the stranger as well as the native, for I am the LORD your God.’” 23Then Moses spoke to the sons of Israel, and they brought the one who had cursed outside the camp and stoned him with stones. Thus the sons of Israel did, just as the LORD had commanded Moses.

 

The two types of Killing in the bible discussed above are defined in a few places.

1-         Premeditated murder

and

2-         accidental manslaughter

 These are the only two choices discussed in the bible.  To quickly determine which category shooting an individual with a gun falls into, please understand that pulling a trigger intentionally does not fall under accidental manslaughter. 

 

It is important to note that the Old Testament saw a fundamental difference between the two types of homicide ( Deut 19:1-13 ; Joshua 20:1-7 ), providing two levels of meaning for “Rasah”.

 

(Deuteronomy 19:4-7)

 4“Now this is the case of the manslayer who may flee there and live: when he kills his friend unintentionally, not hating him previously— 5 as when a man goes into the forest with his friend to cut wood, and his hand swings the axe to cut down the tree, and the iron head slips off the handle and strikes his friend so that he dies—he may flee to one of these cities and live; 6 otherwise the avenger of blood might pursue the manslayer in the heat of his anger, and overtake him, because the way is long, and take his life, though he was not deserving of death, since he had not hated him previously. 7“Therefore, I command you, saying, ‘You shall set aside three cities for yourself.’

 

However, the same term could also apply to intentional manslaughter IAW GODs will ( Deut 4:41 ; 19:3-6 ; Joshua 20:3 ), blood vengeance ( Numbers 35:27 Numbers 35:30 ), the legal execution of a criminal (after a conviction of at least ) ( Num 35:30 ).

 

The Old Testament. Vs The New Testament. Although the New Testament writers lived in a different time and environment, they were consistant in their view of murder with their Old Testament counterparts.

 

JESUS’ interpretation of the sixth commandment differed from the contemporary Jewish scholars (who had a narrowly literal view), and agreed with the “spirit of the Old Testament law on homicide” ( Matt 5:21-22 ). He pointed out a spiritual cause for murder; its root was internal anger.

One was not righteous by simply refraining from homicide; an angry person was also subject to judgment. He thus contended that hating one's brother was in the sphere of the command against murder, as it was part of a process leading to a potential murderous act (Lev 19:17-18 ). JESUS' words were in effect a full summary of the murder law (Exod 21:12 ; Deut 17:8 ).

 

The intent as well as the act came under God's judgment.  He condemned the evil disposition of the heart that lay at the root of the transgression. The beginning of the outward act of murder was sinful anger or hatred, an attitude that was a sin against the sixth commandment. and added that the cause of murder was a consequence of frustrated desire ( James 4:2 ; 1 Kings 21 ).

 

It is important to understand the individuals who were given the right to exact the death penalty for murder ( John 19:10-11 ; Rom 13:1-4 ).

A whole nation could be guilty of murder ( Matt 27:25 ; Acts 2:23 Acts 2:36 ; 3:15 ; 5:28 ; 7:52 ).

Satan was considered the original murderer ( John 8:44 ).

Murderers had no place in God's kingdom ( Gal 5:20 ; Rev 21:8 ).

 

The death of Christ was the supreme example of murder in the Scriptures His violent death was recounted ( Acts 5:30, Acts 26:21 ; Eph 2:16 ) Christ was murdered in hostility. Christ was symbolized as the slaughtered Lamb, signifying his humble obedience and innocence ( Rev 5:6-12 ; 13:8 ). Slain martyrs were likewise labeled ( Rev6:9 ).

 

Another common Hebrew word for killing “Harag” could also be used for indirect (accidental or as a result of)… murder. Meaning you can be held responsible for causing a death even though you did not physically kill someone.  In fact, striking with the intent to murder , and suicide (killing self) fell into this category as well.   

 

Pharaoh viewed Moses' killing of an Egyptian as a crime ( Exod 2:14-15 ). Joab's spilling of the blood of Abner was condemned ( 2 Sam 3:30 ; 1 Kings 2:5 ). David was responsible for the death of Uriah, although he did not physically kill him ( 2 Sam 12:9 ). Judicial murder was also condemned ( Exod 23:7 ; Psalm 10:8 ; 94:6 ). Harag was also the term used for Cain's crime against Abel ( Gen 4:8 ), and for the murderers of Ishbosheth ( 2 Sam 4:11-12 ).

Striking a parent (possibly with the intent to murder Exod 21:15 ), inducing death by miscarriage ( Exod 21:22-23 ), and sacrificing children to a foreign god ( Lev 20:2-3 ) were apparently considered murder and were capital crimes.

 

If a man beat a slave to death, he was probably punished (or better avenged) by being put to death by the covenant community ( Exod 21:20 ). There was no legislation outlawing suicide, as it must have been very rare. Those who committed suicide in Scripture had been placed in a situation of certain death ( Judges 9:54 ; 16:30 ; 1 Sam 31:4 ; 2 Sam 17:23 ; 1 Kings 16:18 ).

 

The bible also discusses unsolved Murders. A strange ceremony was performed when the murderer (or manslayer) was not known ( Deut 21:1-9 ). Since the religious implications (murder was a crime against GOD), the matter could not be left alone; the guilt had to be atoned for. The elders of the closest city were obliged to take responsibility for the act and instigated a procedure to remove the guilt. They took a heifer and broke its neck. They then washed their hands over the dead creature, symbolizing their accepting the burden for it, but not the guilt. They then declared that they were not eyewitnesses, and prayed for the innocence of the entire community. There was no compensation for the family of the victim.

 

HiCarry also brought up: “If you recall your Sunday School studies, you should also remember that it was Jesus that said if you don't have a sword, sell your cloak to buy one....what use is a sword if not for killing?”   I believe the above demonstrates some of the uses of the sword.  The bible shows when the passage is taken in context (Luke 22:36-38), Jesus is aware of fulfilling a prophecy that involves two swords, and is understood to mean Jesus has had “enough” of the topic and further rebukes the use by saying “those that live by the sword shall die by the sword.” 

(Matthew 26:52) "Put up again thy sword into his place: for all they that take the sword shall perish with the sword."

 

All of the above can be found by reading a bible or “doing a quick google search”, but you must actually READ and understand the results.

 

My only source is the bible itself. 

 

There are  numerous variations of faith, therefore without judging you and without knowing your specific denomination of faith, I would suggest, if you are truly interested in the subject, you put as much effort into research and understanding how GOD expects you to live your life.   The reason it is important for Christians  to understand ( if you are a Christian),  I think you are gambling with your own everlasting life by ignoring GODs word.  If you need more on this subject I suggest you pray and go to church.  I will say that you should be weary and not accept at face value anything that any “man” tells you, but put your trust in GOD and pray that you will be blessed with a better understanding of what is truly important in our short lives.
Title: Re: yet another reason to not escalate straight to deadly force if ccw were allowed
Post by: Q on April 21, 2014, 12:24:10 PM
The blood avenger (Executioner), was not allowed to pity a murderer or else the land would be defiled ( Num 35:34 ; David put himself in the hands of God because of this (2 Sam 12:13 ). No money could be exchanged to “buy back your life” was allowed since this would have signified consent with the crime, undermining the value of human life and breaking the covenant with God.

 

(Exodus 21:12, 14)

      12“He who strikes a man so that he dies shall surely be put to death. 13“But if he did not lie in wait for him, but God let him fall into his hand, then I will appoint you a place to which he may flee. 14“If, however, a man acts presumptuously toward his neighbor, so as to kill him craftily, you are to take him even from My altar, that he may die.

 

(Leviticus 24:17)

      17‘If a man takes the life of any human being, he shall surely be put to death. 18‘The one who takes the life of an animal shall make it good, life for life. 19‘If a man injures his neighbor, just as he has done, so it shall be done to him: 20fracture for fracture, eye for eye, tooth for tooth; just as he has injured a man, so it shall be inflicted on him. 21‘Thus the one who kills an animal shall make it good, but the one who kills a man shall be put to death. 22‘There shall be one standard for you; it shall be for the stranger as well as the native, for I am the LORD your God.’” 23Then Moses spoke to the sons of Israel, and they brought the one who had cursed outside the camp and stoned him with stones. Thus the sons of Israel did, just as the LORD had commanded Moses.

 

The two types of Killing in the bible discussed above are defined in a few places.

1-         Premeditated murder

and

2-         accidental manslaughter

 These are the only two choices discussed in the bible.  To quickly determine which category shooting an individual with a gun falls into, please understand that pulling a trigger intentionally does not fall under accidental manslaughter.

 

It is important to note that the Old Testament saw a fundamental difference between the two types of homicide ( Deut 19:1-13 ; Joshua 20:1-7 ), providing two levels of meaning for “Rasah”.

 

(Deuteronomy 19:4-7)

 4“Now this is the case of the manslayer who may flee there and live: when he kills his friend unintentionally, not hating him previously— 5 as when a man goes into the forest with his friend to cut wood, and his hand swings the axe to cut down the tree, and the iron head slips off the handle and strikes his friend so that he dies—he may flee to one of these cities and live; 6 otherwise the avenger of blood might pursue the manslayer in the heat of his anger, and overtake him, because the way is long, and take his life, though he was not deserving of death, since he had not hated him previously. 7“Therefore, I command you, saying, ‘You shall set aside three cities for yourself.’

 

However, the same term could also apply to intentional manslaughter IAW GODs will ( Deut 4:41 ; 19:3-6 ; Joshua 20:3 ), blood vengeance ( Numbers 35:27 Numbers 35:30 ), the legal execution of a criminal (after a conviction of at least ) ( Num 35:30 ).

 

The Old Testament. Vs The New Testament. Although the New Testament writers lived in a different time and environment, they were consistant in their view of murder with their Old Testament counterparts.

 

JESUS’ interpretation of the sixth commandment differed from the contemporary Jewish scholars (who had a narrowly literal view), and agreed with the “spirit of the Old Testament law on homicide” ( Matt 5:21-22 ). He pointed out a spiritual cause for murder; its root was internal anger.

One was not righteous by simply refraining from homicide; an angry person was also subject to judgment. He thus contended that hating one's brother was in the sphere of the command against murder, as it was part of a process leading to a potential murderous act (Lev 19:17-18 ). JESUS' words were in effect a full summary of the murder law (Exod 21:12 ; Deut 17:8 ).

 

The intent as well as the act came under God's judgment.  He condemned the evil disposition of the heart that lay at the root of the transgression. The beginning of the outward act of murder was sinful anger or hatred, an attitude that was a sin against the sixth commandment. and added that the cause of murder was a consequence of frustrated desire ( James 4:2 ; 1 Kings 21 ).

 

It is important to understand the individuals who were given the right to exact the death penalty for murder ( John 19:10-11 ; Rom 13:1-4 ).

A whole nation could be guilty of murder ( Matt 27:25 ; Acts 2:23 Acts 2:36 ; 3:15 ; 5:28 ; 7:52 ).

Satan was considered the original murderer ( John 8:44 ).

Murderers had no place in God's kingdom ( Gal 5:20 ; Rev 21:8 ).

 

The death of Christ was the supreme example of murder in the Scriptures His violent death was recounted ( Acts 5:30, Acts 26:21 ; Eph 2:16 ) Christ was murdered in hostility. Christ was symbolized as the slaughtered Lamb, signifying his humble obedience and innocence ( Rev 5:6-12 ; 13:8 ). Slain martyrs were likewise labeled ( Rev6:9 ).

 

Another common Hebrew word for killing “Harag” could also be used for indirect (accidental or as a result of)… murder. Meaning you can be held responsible for causing a death even though you did not physically kill someone.  In fact, striking with the intent to murder , and suicide (killing self) fell into this category as well.   

 

Pharaoh viewed Moses' killing of an Egyptian as a crime ( Exod 2:14-15 ). Joab's spilling of the blood of Abner was condemned ( 2 Sam 3:30 ; 1 Kings 2:5 ). David was responsible for the death of Uriah, although he did not physically kill him ( 2 Sam 12:9 ). Judicial murder was also condemned ( Exod 23:7 ; Psalm 10:8 ; 94:6 ). Harag was also the term used for Cain's crime against Abel ( Gen 4:8 ), and for the murderers of Ishbosheth ( 2 Sam 4:11-12 ).

Striking a parent (possibly with the intent to murder Exod 21:15 ), inducing death by miscarriage ( Exod 21:22-23 ), and sacrificing children to a foreign god ( Lev 20:2-3 ) were apparently considered murder and were capital crimes.

 

If a man beat a slave to death, he was probably punished (or better avenged) by being put to death by the covenant community ( Exod 21:20 ). There was no legislation outlawing suicide, as it must have been very rare. Those who committed suicide in Scripture had been placed in a situation of certain death ( Judges 9:54 ; 16:30 ; 1 Sam 31:4 ; 2 Sam 17:23 ; 1 Kings 16:18 ).

 

The bible also discusses unsolved Murders. A strange ceremony was performed when the murderer (or manslayer) was not known ( Deut 21:1-9 ). Since the religious implications (murder was a crime against GOD), the matter could not be left alone; the guilt had to be atoned for. The elders of the closest city were obliged to take responsibility for the act and instigated a procedure to remove the guilt. They took a heifer and broke its neck. They then washed their hands over the dead creature, symbolizing their accepting the burden for it, but not the guilt. They then declared that they were not eyewitnesses, and prayed for the innocence of the entire community. There was no compensation for the family of the victim.

 

HiCarry also brought up: “If you recall your Sunday School studies, you should also remember that it was Jesus that said if you don't have a sword, sell your cloak to buy one....what use is a sword if not for killing?”   I believe the above demonstrates some of the uses of the sword.  The bible shows when the passage is taken in context (Luke 22:36-38), Jesus is aware of fulfilling a prophecy that involves two swords, and is understood to mean Jesus has had “enough” of the topic and further rebukes the use by saying “those that live by the sword shall die by the sword.”

(Matthew 26:52) "Put up again thy sword into his place: for all they that take the sword shall perish with the sword."

 

All of the above can be found by reading a bible or “doing a quick google search”, but you must actually READ and understand the results.

 

My only source is the bible itself.

 

There are  numerous variations of faith, therefore without judging you and without knowing your specific denomination of faith, I would suggest, if you are truly interested in the subject, you put as much effort into research and understanding how GOD expects you to live your life.   The reason it is important for Christians  to understand ( if you are a Christian),  I think you are gambling with your own everlasting life by ignoring GODs word.  If you need more on this subject I suggest you pray and go to church.  I will say that you should be weary and not accept at face value anything that any “man” tells you, but put your trust in GOD and pray that you will be blessed with a better understanding of what is truly important in our short lives.

So what if we aren't Christian?
Title: Re: yet another reason to not escalate straight to deadly force if ccw were allowed
Post by: mauidog on April 21, 2014, 01:33:16 PM
So what if we aren't Christian?

Whachu mean "we"?

(http://i.imgur.com/ygk10z0.jpg) (http://imgur.com/ygk10z0)
Title: Re: yet another reason to not escalate straight to deadly force if ccw were allowed
Post by: bubba808 on April 21, 2014, 02:19:53 PM
So what if we aren't Christian?

then it does not apply.  Religion is a personal choice, it is how ive chosen to live my life. I am not pushing my religion on anyone.  Merely clarifying, where I was questioned. 
Again, these are my personal choices, yours may be different.
Title: Re: yet another reason to not escalate straight to deadly force if ccw were allowed
Post by: HiCarry on April 21, 2014, 03:27:35 PM
Bubba,

Once again, I see that you typed a lot, but didn't really say anything. The fact is that "kill" in the 6th commandment is a misinterpretation of "murder" which, as we know from both the historical perspective and the current legal definition, is not the same. If you choose to interpret it as to mean you cannot kill any person, at any time, for any reason, than go ahead. Just don't expect many other religious scholars to agree with you.

The bottom line is that CCW does not induce good, law abiding citizens to shoot others without good, justifiable cause. You have been provided all sorts of information that backs this general premise. If after researching it you still hold your same beliefs, so be it. Again, just don't be too surprised when the vast majority of folks (especially here) disagree with you.

Aloha
Title: Re: yet another reason to not escalate straight to deadly force if ccw were allowed
Post by: bubba808 on April 21, 2014, 04:22:49 PM
Bubba,

Once again, I see that you typed a lot, but didn't really say anything. The fact is that "kill" in the 6th commandment is a misinterpretation of "murder" which, as we know from both the historical perspective and the current legal definition, is not the same. If you choose to interpret it as to mean you cannot kill any person, at any time, for any reason, than go ahead. Just don't expect many other religious scholars to agree with you.

The bottom line is that CCW does not induce good, law abiding citizens to shoot others without good, justifiable cause. You have been provided all sorts of information that backs this general premise. If after researching it you still hold your same beliefs, so be it. Again, just don't be too surprised when the vast majority of folks (especially here) disagree with you.

Aloha

HiCarry-
Once again i see you have not read or understood.  I am ok with that.
What i am saying that the bible does ALLOW KILLING, in certain situations, However, none of these situations where you are allowed to kill involve you, one person, on their own, with a CCW, feeling scared, to murder someone. 

please offer up your religious scholars and the actual scripture that they are sighting as i have. 

again youre either missing the point or intentionally skirting the issue.  I am not saying that CCW incites people to shoot others, i am saying that per the bible you do not have justification to shoot and kill someone unless you and another person witnessed a murder and agreed you were to act as the blood avenger and dispatch the murderer.  None of which you discussed, in fact what what was discussed was how you would make the decision (alone) and never shoot to wound (i.e. murder). 

let anyone here who disagrees,  post something worth reading that might change my belief.
 
the words directly from the links you provide:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Thou_shalt_not_kill (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Thou_shalt_not_kill)
“Justified killing: due consequence for crime[edit]
The Torah and Hebrew Bible made clear distinctions between the shedding of innocent blood and killing as the due consequence of a crime. A number of sins were considered to be worthy of the death penalty including murder,[20] incest,[21] bearing false witness on a capital charge,[22] adultery,[23] idolatry,[24]having sexual relations with a member of the same sex, etc.[15]
For example, the Exodus narrative describes the people as having turned to idolatry with the golden calf while Moses was on the mountain receiving the law from God. When Moses came down, he commanded the Levites to take up the sword against their brothers and companions and neighbors. The Levites obeyed and killed about three thousand men who had sinned in worship of the golden calf. As a result, Moses said that the Levites had received a blessing that day at the cost of son and brother.[25] On a separate occasion, a blasphemer was stoned to death because he blasphemed the name of the LORD with a curse.[26]
The Hebrew Bible has many other examples of sinners being put to death as due consequence for crimes. “
Please show me where you are justified with CCW to make the determination to and use deadly force?????
http://biblehub.com/exodus/20-13.htm (http://biblehub.com/exodus/20-13.htm)
“"You have heard that it was said to the people long ago, 'You shall not murder, and anyone who murders will be subject to judgment.'”

http://www.godandscience.org/apologetics/notkill.html (http://www.godandscience.org/apologetics/notkill.html)
link does not exist

http://carm.org/questions/you-shall-not-kill-yet-god-kills (http://carm.org/questions/you-shall-not-kill-yet-god-kills)
“"slayer 16, murderer 14, kill 5, murder 3, slain 3, manslayer 2, killing 1, slayer + 310 1, slayeth 1, death 1." 1
Murder is the unlawful taking of life.  Killing is the lawful taking of life.  God has said, "You shall not murder," not "You shall not kill."  If mere killing of any kind was the issue, then why would God saying killing in self defense is permissible?  He wouldn't.  This is another reason that modern translations say, "You shall not murder."

http://www.rumormillnews.com/cgi-bin/archive.cgi?read=31043 (http://www.rumormillnews.com/cgi-bin/archive.cgi?read=31043)
“Most Christians have been led to believe that Scripture forbids the Taking of a life; that is to kill. That it forbids the taking of a life under any circumstance; even in Self Defense. If this is so, why would GOD tell Israel “Thou Shalt Not Kill”, yet then turn around and tell then to kill their enemies? This would seem to be a Glaring Contradiction, would it not? UNLESS, GOD Never said “Thou Shalt Not Kill” to begin with! Even though the Bible may actually say the word “Kill” in several places, is this what the Original Hebrew and Greek Texts actually say?”

http://people.ucalgary.ca/~elsegal/Shokel/001102_ThouShaltNotMurder.html (http://people.ucalgary.ca/~elsegal/Shokel/001102_ThouShaltNotMurder.html)
“For me, one of the most irksome cases has always been the rendering of the sixth commandment as "Thou shalt not kill." In this form, the quote has been conscripted into the service of diverse causes, including those of pacifism, animal rights, the opposition to capital punishment, and the anti-abortion movement.

Indeed, "kill" in English is an all-encompassing verb that covers the taking of life in all forms and for all classes of victims. That kind of generalization is expressed in Hebrew through the verb "harag." However, the verb that appears in the Torah's prohibition is a completely different one, " ratsah" which, it would seem, should be rendered "murder." This root refers only to criminal acts of killing.”

http://winteryknight.wordpress.com/2010/03/25/does-the-bible-say-thou-shalt-not-kill-or-thou-shalt-not-murder/ (http://winteryknight.wordpress.com/2010/03/25/does-the-bible-say-thou-shalt-not-kill-or-thou-shalt-not-murder/)
“For me, one of the most irksome cases has always been the rendering of the sixth commandment as "Thou shalt not kill." In this form, the quote has been conscripted into the service of diverse causes, including those of pacifism, animal rights, the opposition to capital punishment, and the anti-abortion movement.

Indeed, "kill" in English is an all-encompassing verb that covers the taking of life in all forms and for all classes of victims. That kind of generalization is expressed in Hebrew through the verb "harag." However, the verb that appears in the Torah's prohibition is a completely different one, " ratsah" which, it would seem, should be rendered "murder." This root refers only to criminal acts of killing.”

Title: Re: yet another reason to not escalate straight to deadly force if ccw were allowed
Post by: bubba808 on April 21, 2014, 05:33:45 PM
Bubba:
As for the whole "If you have a right to ccw …

To my 2nd point- Regarding the right to keep and bear arms (CCW specific).
I will say that due to my previous lack of understanding, I was wrong and I was surprised by what I found out. 
If I am solely going with the word of the founding fathers and their intent, then I agree with HiCarry and Funtimes that indeed it is the right of the people to keep and bear arms, as a well organized militia to regulate the government, and includes the right to carry (open/concealed).
I do have a better understanding of Funtimes reasoning now that I have done some extensive reading including the Peruta case.  I can understand better why you believe you have are being denied this right. 

as I had asked HiCarry for statistics regarding how CCW has proven to reducing crime and increasing safety, and I have not seen any conclusive statistics to support what HiCarry has stated, I did my own research using credible sources.  I simply compared each states level of GUN CONTROL laws, against the states POPULATION, times the AMOUNT of GUN RELATED CRIME (reported). 
The ONLY thing that is clear is that there is NO CLEAR EVIDENCE.  CCW does not make the state safer.   To be fair, I would like to add that there is NO CLEAR EVIDENCE that not carrying firearms and relying on law enforcement makes it safer either.  The data is kind of all over the place and IMHO inconclusive on either side. 

My credible sources are as follows if anyone would like to check/verify:
http://www.guncite.com/journals/dkjgc.html (http://www.guncite.com/journals/dkjgc.html)
http://www.newyorker.com/reporting/2012/04/23/120423fa_fact_lepore?currentPage=all (http://www.newyorker.com/reporting/2012/04/23/120423fa_fact_lepore?currentPage=all)
http://www.deathpenaltyinfo.org/murder-rates-nationally-and-state (http://www.deathpenaltyinfo.org/murder-rates-nationally-and-state)
http://www.fbi.gov/about-us/cjis/ucr/crime-in-the-u.s/2011/crime-in-the-u.s.-2011/tables/table-1 (http://www.fbi.gov/about-us/cjis/ucr/crime-in-the-u.s/2011/crime-in-the-u.s.-2011/tables/table-1)
http://www.politifact.com/virginia/statements/2012/jan/27/jim-moran/rep-jim-moran-says-us-gun-homicide-rate-20-times-h/ (http://www.politifact.com/virginia/statements/2012/jan/27/jim-moran/rep-jim-moran-says-us-gun-homicide-rate-20-times-h/)
http://www.cdc.gov/nchs/data/nvsr/nvsr59/nvsr59_04.pdf (http://www.cdc.gov/nchs/data/nvsr/nvsr59/nvsr59_04.pdf)
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gun_violence_in_the_United_States_by_state (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gun_violence_in_the_United_States_by_state)
"Table 20: Murder by State, Types of Weapons, 2010". Uniform Crime Reports 2010. FBI.
"Gun Owners as a Percentage of Each State's Population, 2007".
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gun_violence_in_the_United_States_by_state (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gun_violence_in_the_United_States_by_state)
Title: Re: yet another reason to not escalate straight to deadly force if ccw were allowed
Post by: mauidog on April 21, 2014, 10:53:33 PM
http://www.press.uchicago.edu/Misc/Chicago/493636.html (http://www.press.uchicago.edu/Misc/Chicago/493636.html)

Quote
States with the largest increases in gun ownership also have the largest drops in violent crimes.
Thirty-one states now have such laws—called “shall-issue” laws. These laws allow adults the right to
carry concealed handguns if they do not have a criminal record or a history of significant mental illness.
Title: Re: yet another reason to not escalate straight to deadly force if ccw were allowed
Post by: HiCarry on April 22, 2014, 11:22:42 AM
Bubba,

You crack me up. First you say that you don't think folks should have CCW and bolster that claim with vague references to "God's law" about not killing. When presented with factual info about the general misinterpretation of the 6th commandment (in part due to literal misinterpretation of the Hebrew text) you say:

Quote
I am not saying that CCW incites people to shoot others, i am saying that per the bible you do not have justification to shoot and kill someone unless you and another person witnessed a murder and agreed you were to act as the blood avenger and dispatch the murderer.  None of which you discussed, in fact what what was discussed was how you would make the decision (alone) and never shoot to wound (i.e. murder).

The links I provided and that you subsequently included in your reply clearly show that the bible was OK with killing in self defense and that there was a clear difference between killing and murder. To suggest that the only (biblically speaking) "justified" killing was to be some kind of "blood avenger" acting as judge, jury and executioner is laughable on it's face. As I said, you can interpret scripture as you choose, but as the links I provided clearly show, many biblical scholars and learned individuals disagree.

As for the history of the right to carry firearms, as Funtimes suggested, you should read the Peruta decision and for info CCW and crime rates, you should read More Guns, Less Crime, or anything my Lott, or Mustard.

http://www.justfacts.com/guncontrol.asp (http://www.justfacts.com/guncontrol.asp)

http://www.cato.org/publications/policy-analysis/fighting-back-crime-selfdefense-right-carry-handgun (http://www.cato.org/publications/policy-analysis/fighting-back-crime-selfdefense-right-carry-handgun)

Aloha

Title: Re: yet another reason to not escalate straight to deadly force if ccw were allowed
Post by: Q on April 22, 2014, 11:31:31 AM
Its simple: if you don't want to CCW, then don't CCW.

90% of the people on 2a want to CCW, and 99% of those people would be willing to use deadly force if necessary, because we are all law abiding citizens who would exercise our right to self-protection, in those certain situations, within the full confines of the law.

As I told you before, from a psychological perspective what you are doing is called projection. You are reflecting upon what YOU would do in these situations, and consciously/subconsciously projecting this course of action to everyone else. Just because you might kill someone unnecessarily while carrying doesn't mean everyone else will.
Title: Re: yet another reason to not escalate straight to deadly force if ccw were allowed
Post by: HiCarry on April 22, 2014, 11:47:59 AM
A good article by Lott. Note that he lists all the scientific studies on guns and crime rates. 19 of those studies show CCW reduces crime, 10 show no change, and 1 shows an increase.....

http://digitalcommons.law.umaryland.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=3522&context=mlr (http://digitalcommons.law.umaryland.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=3522&context=mlr)

It's also a good primer on why the Second Amendment should be evaluated with Strict scrutiny, just as other core, fundamental rights should be, rather than some lesser, ill-defined intermediate scrutiny.....
Title: Re: yet another reason to not escalate straight to deadly force if ccw were allowed
Post by: bubba808 on April 24, 2014, 07:29:12 PM
Its simple: if you don't want to CCW, then don't CCW.

90% of the people on 2a want to CCW, and 99% of those people would be willing to use deadly force if necessary, because we are all law abiding citizens who would exercise our right to self-protection, in those certain situations, within the full confines of the law.

As I told you before, from a psychological perspective what you are doing is called projection. You are reflecting upon what YOU would do in these situations, and consciously/subconsciously projecting this course of action to everyone else. Just because you might kill someone unnecessarily while carrying doesn't mean everyone else will.
How you know what 90% on 2a want and what 99% are willing to do? What you are is doing is called bullshitting.  Please share your source for fact.
Title: Re: yet another reason to not escalate straight to deadly force if ccw were allowed
Post by: bubba808 on April 24, 2014, 07:33:08 PM
http://www.press.uchicago.edu/Misc/Chicago/493636.html (http://www.press.uchicago.edu/Misc/Chicago/493636.html)

look at the references I provided, info is up to date... lott uses old data from1977 thru 1994.  Its 20 year old data.
Title: Re: yet another reason to not escalate straight to deadly force if ccw were allowed
Post by: bubba808 on April 24, 2014, 07:56:25 PM
HiCarry,

dont twist what I said.  Go back n read. If you still dont get it, re-read.  You havent shown me anything substantial or specific to support you argument, and frankly i dont care as i dont think you are genuine in anything you post about the bible.    Im fine leaving things alone as is. 
People who are interested, can read both our arguments for themselves and make their own decision.   im not trying to convince you or anyone.  just inform you of a what i think the bible says so I can smile and wash my hands.   

With that said, I can think of many other ways to personally enjoy my time and firearms, then going round and around with you. Im content to again, agree to disagree and end this thread.

Aloha
Title: Re: yet another reason to not escalate straight to deadly force if ccw were allowed
Post by: Q on April 24, 2014, 08:13:48 PM
How you know what 90% on 2a want and what 99% are willing to do? What you are is doing is called bullshitting.  Please share your source for fact.

Probably because I actually meet the guys on 2a, instead of sitting behind a keyboard, punching a way on google, trying to justify a dumbass point of view that isn't supported by anyone else on this thread but you.

So have a coke, a smile and shut your pie hole, troll  :geekdanc:
Title: Re: yet another reason to not escalate straight to deadly force if ccw were allowed
Post by: bubba808 on April 24, 2014, 08:28:40 PM
http://www.hawaiireporter.com/hawaii-firearms-registrations-reach-record-high-after-70-percent-jump/123 (http://www.hawaiireporter.com/hawaii-firearms-registrations-reach-record-high-after-70-percent-jump/123)

http://www.hawaiireporter.com/hawaii-firearm-permits-at-record-high-level-in-2013/123 (http://www.hawaiireporter.com/hawaii-firearm-permits-at-record-high-level-in-2013/123)


Consider the following two reports that show firearm registrations going through the roof and gun crimes and crime in general DECREASING, ALL WITHOUT CCW.  And as for 90 percent you refer to, how did only 4 people put in applications  for CCW in 2012 and 5 in 2013 if theres so much interest.  And there are so few shooting here, that I dont see 99 percent either. Clown.

I dont see alot of people staging rallys and sign waving for CCW. SMH GTFOH LOL
Just saying.


Its simple: if you don't want to CCW, then don't CCW.

90% of the people on 2a want to CCW, and 99% of those people would be willing to use deadly force if necessary, because we are all law abiding citizens who would exercise our right to self-protection, in those certain situations, within the full confines of the law.

As I told you before, from a psychological perspective what you are doing is called projection. You are reflecting upon what YOU would do in these situations, and consciously/subconsciously projecting this course of action to everyone else. Just because you might kill someone unnecessarily while carrying doesn't mean everyone else will.

Probably because I actually meet the guys on 2a, instead of sitting behind a keyboard, punching a way on google, trying to justify a dumbass point of view that isn't supported by anyone else on this thread but you.

So have a coke, a smile and shut your pie hole, troll  :geekdanc:
You must be mad cuz I discredit your wild factless claims and throw it in your face.
Funny how I came to the last 3 gtg and didnt see any Qs chirpin in the crowd.  Listen cupcake, keep it up with the names, maybe one of your shitty mosins end up somewhere special.
 And if youre the poster child for CCW, youre doing a great job not provoking others with your comments and proving you deserve CCW.  U wanna chirp on here, chirp, seems like youre the troll behind the keyboard.
Title: Re: yet another reason to not escalate straight to deadly force if ccw were allowed
Post by: bubba808 on April 24, 2014, 08:36:38 PM
http://www.guns.com/2014/04/04/hawaii-firearms-permits-record-levels-2013-500-percent-since-2000/ (http://www.guns.com/2014/04/04/hawaii-firearms-permits-record-levels-2013-500-percent-since-2000/)

Another great article from 2014 hawaii. Showing gun statistics without CCW. 

Title: Re: yet another reason to not escalate straight to deadly force if ccw were allowed
Post by: bubba808 on April 24, 2014, 09:13:16 PM
The links I provided and that you subsequently included in your reply clearly show that the bible was OK with killing in self defense and that there was a clear difference between killing and murder. To suggest that the only (biblically speaking) "justified" killing was to be some kind of "blood avenger" acting as judge, jury and executioner is laughable on it's face.
If you read what i said, you cant act as the jury, and judge. 

If you do want to continue your argument, please sight the scripture that states you can use deadly force cuz you felt threatened.
Title: Re: yet another reason to not escalate straight to deadly force if ccw were allowed
Post by: Q on April 24, 2014, 09:36:32 PM
http://www.hawaiireporter.com/hawaii-firearms-registrations-reach-record-high-after-70-percent-jump/123 (http://www.hawaiireporter.com/hawaii-firearms-registrations-reach-record-high-after-70-percent-jump/123)

http://www.hawaiireporter.com/hawaii-firearm-permits-at-record-high-level-in-2013/123 (http://www.hawaiireporter.com/hawaii-firearm-permits-at-record-high-level-in-2013/123)


Consider the following two reports that show firearm registrations going through the roof and gun crimes and crime in general DECREASING, ALL WITHOUT CCW.  And as for 90 percent you refer to, how did only 4 people put in applications  for CCW in 2012 and 5 in 2013 if theres so much interest.  And there are so few shooting here, that I dont see 99 percent either. Clown.

I dont see alot of people staging rallys and sign waving for CCW. SMH GTFOH LOL
Just saying.

You must be mad cuz I discredit your wild factless claims and throw it in your face.
Funny how I came to the last 3 gtg and didnt see any Qs chirpin in the crowd.  Listen cupcake, keep it up with the names, maybe one of your shitty mosins end up somewhere special.
 And if youre the poster child for CCW, youre doing a great job not provoking others with your comments and proving you deserve CCW.  U wanna chirp on here, chirp, seems like youre the troll behind the keyboard.

See...the problem is that even though I don't go to GTGs anymore because I'm tired of having to socialize with idiots like yourself, individuals like myself and HiCarry still hold more credibility, respect and influence on this forum or on the range than you do, so no matter how many spastic google searches you do to try and validate your point, no one gives a shit.

Get over it; no one likes what you have to say, because most of us want CCW, which is why the 2a admin isn't jumping in to try and stop us from calling out your stupid ass points.

And special place for my mosins? Don't tempt me with a good time!  :geekdanc: :geekdanc: :geekdanc: Feel free to catch a ride with your neighbor the next time that person goes to the range so you can show me  :thumbsup:
Title: Re: yet another reason to not escalate straight to deadly force if ccw were allowed
Post by: bubba808 on April 24, 2014, 10:28:36 PM
See...the problem is that even though I don't go to GTGs anymore because I'm tired of having to socialize with idiots like yourself, individuals like myself and HiCarry still hold more credibility, respect and influence on this forum or on the range than you do, so no matter how many spastic google searches you do to try and validate your point, no one gives a shit.

Get over it; no one likes what you have to say, because most of us want CCW, which is why the 2a admin isn't jumping in to try and stop us from calling out your stupid ass points.

And special place for my mosins? Don't tempt me with a good time!  :geekdanc: :geekdanc: :geekdanc: Feel free to catch a ride with your neighbor the next time that person goes to the range so you can show me  :thumbsup:
Hmmm, is that frustration due to your lack of a rubuttal to facts?
Listen maggot, ill humor you for a bit.  see your problem is you act like a scared little 14 year old girl, and in actuality youre a chubby 40 year old hermit, your appearance is dirty and unkept,  you live with worms that are as worthless as the rusty broken mosins you try to hock on here.  You are poor and probably on welfare, thats why you always try to sell rubbish in the classified and  beg for buckshot sales in OGC. You have, what i like to call lil dick syndrome, where you always try to project some impressive persona, cuz youre insecure, your dicks tiny, and you aint shit.  You cant get a local girl, so you claim you like hairy ukrainian women, but Even they wont take you up on mail order bride offers, cuz you suck.  You will never and can never amount to shit in the real world, cuz your piss poor attitude.  If you were in the military (which i doubt), youre a disgrace and most surely got discharged cuz you cant stfu and control your mouth.  You and your few butt buddies can stroke each other and believe each others bullshit all you want, im the one who doesnt give a shit.   You cant back up your claims, or counter any of mine cuz youre useless.    I wonder why so many others on this forum get into arguments with you? See any common denominators?  Youre the one that nobody gives a shit about.  Its statements like above that leaves you, and those who support you with less and less credibility.      lol
Title: Re: yet another reason to not escalate straight to deadly force if ccw were allowed
Post by: Q on April 24, 2014, 10:32:00 PM
Hmmm, is that frustration due to your lack of a rubuttal to facts?
Listen maggot, ill humor you for a bit.  see your problem is you act like a scared little 14 year old girl, and in actuality youre a chubby 40 year old hermit, your appearance is dirty and unkept,  you live with worms that are as worthless as the rusty broken mosins you try to hock on here.  You are poor and probably on welfare, thats why you always try to sell rubbish in the classified and  beg for buckshot sales in OGC. You have, what i like to call lil dick syndrome, where you always try to project some impressive persona, cuz youre insecure, your dicks tiny, and you aint shit.  You cant get a local girl, so you claim you like hairy ukrainian women, but Even they wont take you up on mail order bride offers, cuz you suck.  You will never and can never amount to shit in the real world, cuz your piss poor attitude.  If you were in the military (which i doubt), youre a disgrace and most surely got discharged cuz you cant stfu and control your mouth.  You and your few butt buddies can stroke each other and believe each others bullshit all you want, im the one who doesnt give a shit.   You cant back up your claims, or counter any of mine cuz youre useless.    I wonder why so many others on this forum get into arguments with you? See any common denominators?  Youre the one that nobody gives a shit about.  Its statements like above that leaves you, and those who support you with less and less credibility.      lol

 :rofl: :rofl: :rofl: :rofl:

That was actually pretty good comedy!

P.S. in case you didn't know, someone put up a poll as to who would carry a weapon if given the chance; looks like you better go vote no, because that 99% I talked about? yeah, actually at 100% right now.  :geekdanc: :geekdanc: :geekdanc:
Title: Re: yet another reason to not escalate straight to deadly force if ccw were allowed
Post by: bubba808 on April 24, 2014, 10:42:21 PM
:rofl: :rofl: :rofl: :rofl:

That was actually pretty good comedy!

P.S. in case you didn't know, someone put up a poll as to who would carry a weapon if given the chance; looks like you better go vote no, because that 99% I talked about? yeah, actually at 100% right now.  :geekdanc: :geekdanc: :geekdanc:
Its was fun writing, truth makes the best comedy. Hey stupid, your statement was that 90% on this forum want CCW, a few out of thousands of members doesnt equal 90%.  Actually currently 3/2403=0.12%  not even close.  Dont tell me i need to school you on how statistics work too? Ohp, just did.  Your quote was also that 99% of people would use deadly force, not CCW.... keep going .... like your credibilty....
Title: Re: yet another reason to not escalate straight to deadly force if ccw were allowed
Post by: Jl808 on April 24, 2014, 11:07:40 PM
(http://1-media-cdn.foolz.us/ffuuka/board/tg/image/1344/16/1344168277708.gif)
Title: Re: yet another reason to not escalate straight to deadly force if ccw were allowed
Post by: dustoff003 on April 24, 2014, 11:13:19 PM
Bench 80
Title: Re: yet another reason to not escalate straight to deadly force if ccw were allowed
Post by: Q on April 24, 2014, 11:31:04 PM
Its was fun writing, truth makes the best comedy. Hey stupid, your statement was that 90% on this forum want CCW, a few out of thousands of members doesnt equal 90%.  Dont tell me i need to school you on how statistics work too? Your quote was also that 99% of people would use deadly force, not CCW.... keep going .... like your credibilty....

Actually, you are right; I said 90%.

Meh...90%, 99%....point is, no one cares about what you think.

2a Administrators told us to let up on you in the beginning so you could share your point of view. Frankly, the lack of defense on your behalf by any of the members on this forum, or the fact that the poll is at a 100% rating as to who would carry a concealed weapon, demonstrates that my outlook is shared by far more individuals on this forum and abroad. All you have accomplished is producing a failed attempt to convince people that CCW doesn't make people safe and may result in misapplication of deadly force, and an even more pathetic attempt to try and use the bible to justify that 'killin is bad...real bad!', simply because you have a subconscious desire to kill people and/or a deep fear that you might in fact kill someone if given a concealed weapon, based upon your consistent psychological projections throughout this discussion, implying that others might act out your own personal fantasies.



But no problem. In honor of your valiant attempt to disprove what the majority of people believe in and support on this forum, I have created this masterpiece in your memory:
Title: Re: yet another reason to not escalate straight to deadly force if ccw were allowed
Post by: bubba808 on April 24, 2014, 11:41:49 PM
Actually, you are right; I said 90%.

Meh...90%, 99%....point is, no one cares about what you think.

2a Administrators told us to let up on you in the beginning so you could share your point of view. Frankly, the lack of defense on your behalf by any of the members on this forum, or the fact that the poll is at a 100% rating as to who would carry a concealed weapon, demonstrates that my outlook is shared by far more individuals on this forum and abroad. All you have accomplished is producing a failed attempt to convince people that CCW doesn't make people safe and may result in misapplication of deadly force, and an even more pathetic attempt to try and use the bible to justify that 'killin is bad...real bad!', simply because you have a subconscious desire to kill people and/or a deep fear that you might in fact kill someone if given a concealed weapon, based upon your consistent psychological projections throughout this discussion, implying that others might act out your own personal fantasies.



But no problem. In honor of your valiant attempt to disprove what the majority of people believe in and support on this forum, I have created this masterpiece in your memory:

youre pathetic.  You'd make a great target holder.   LoL
Title: Re: yet another reason to not escalate straight to deadly force if ccw were allowed
Post by: dustoff003 on April 24, 2014, 11:58:02 PM

youre pathetic.  You'd make a great target holder.   LoL

Hey bubba I am gonna ask the same question I asked the guy dblnaknak in the other thread where him and Q were going at it, there Q posted all of his experience, training and qualifications. Would you care to share your experience, training and qualifications with us?
Title: Re: yet another reason to not escalate straight to deadly force if ccw were allowed
Post by: bubba808 on April 25, 2014, 06:19:00 AM
Hey bubba I am gonna ask the same question I asked the guy dblnaknak in the other thread where him and Q were going at it, there Q posted all of his experience, training and qualifications. Would you care to share your experience, training and qualifications with us?
sure, with respect to this thread, I have lived in Hawaii all my life, I have used firearms for over 25 years here to hunt, and target practice.  I am a college graduate(including statistics lol), homeowner and a father.  I have been reading the bible for over 30 years.  I am not claiming that im am expert in guns or even the bible.  I do have an understanding of the bible which forms my beliefs, I have also analyzed the topic of killing at church.  As for firearms, its more of a hobby, when I have time, and extra cash.  On 2ahawaii, I just sharing my opinion and beliefs about firearms.  Im pretty straight forward, stand up for what I believe and call bullshit when I see it.  im also willing to learn, understand, and accept new things if they are agreeable to me.

Q can have every experience and qual but he is quick to judge, likes to name call, and is quick to discredit others when he doesnt agree with their personal beliefs if they dont align with his.

Now that I have shared a bit about myself, please share your experience, training and qualifications also?
Title: Re: yet another reason to not escalate straight to deadly force if ccw were allowed
Post by: 2aHawaii on April 25, 2014, 07:07:53 AM
Q, cut it with the ad hominem attacks. Thanks.
Title: Re: yet another reason to not escalate straight to deadly force if ccw were allowed
Post by: bubba808 on April 25, 2014, 07:10:20 AM
1 is there a need for CCW in Hawaiii?
 Is CCW a need or a want?

I'm not here to convince or persuade anyone.  Let's just present facts, discuss and let people make their own decisions free from criticism. 
 if there is a need (necessary) are there statistics to warrant the need?  Crime in Hawaii has generally been on the decline without CCW.  gun ownership is up.  So do we need CCW?
  I am trying to be objective.  I have asked the so called experts or proponents of CCW and have not seen anything substantial other than its what they want cuz they feel it's their right.   And that's ok too.     I actually agree, it's their right.  I was just curious as to why they felt the need, or if there was a need.
2 does the Bible say we can kill others if we feel threatened?  I haven't seen it.
Title: Re: yet another reason to not escalate straight to deadly force if ccw were allowed
Post by: mauidog on April 25, 2014, 08:22:41 AM
1 is there a need for CCW in Hawaiii?
 Is CCW a need or a want?

I'm not here to convince or persuade anyone.  Let's just present facts, discuss and let people make their own decisions free from criticism. 
 if there is a need (necessary) are there statistics to warrant the need?  Crime in Hawaii has generally been on the decline without CCW.  gun ownership is up.  So do we need CCW?
  I am trying to be objective.  I have asked the so called experts or proponents of CCW and have not seen anything substantial other than its what they want cuz they feel it's their right.   And that's ok too.     I actually agree, it's their right.  I was just curious as to why they felt the need, or if there was a need.
2 does the Bible say we can kill others if we feel threatened?  I haven't seen it.

Do you NEED a fire extinguisher?  How many times have you been at home and the room caught fire?
Do you NEED an airbag in your car?  How many times have your cars been in collisions and the airbag deployed?
Do you NEED a police force?  How many times have you needed to call the police to protect you from an immediate threat?
Do you NEED life insurance?  After all, life insurance does YOU no good.  It only helps the beneficiaries of the policy.
Do you NEED a first aid kit at home, at work and in the car?  How many times have you used one to save a life?
Do you NEED to learn CPR?  How many heart attacks have you saved anyone from?
Do you NEED to learn how to swim?  How many times have you needed to jump into the water and save a drowning kid?
Do you NEED to finish high school?  Look at all the successful dropouts in the country.
Do you NEED to go to the dentist twice a year?  You can always buy dentures when the time comes.

Do you NEED to carry a gun?  The majority of the people will never have to use their concealed firearm.  Would you rather have it and never NEED it, or NEED it and not have one?

Dr. Suzanna Hupp Testimony (Better Quality) to Congress on the Second Amendment (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FvTO-y-B2YM#)
Title: Re: yet another reason to not escalate straight to deadly force if ccw were allowed
Post by: 2aHawaii on April 25, 2014, 08:35:59 AM
I would say that the need for CCW in Hawaii stems from it being a right. Since I may not need to use the "right" right now, doesn't mean it should be taken away.
Title: Re: yet another reason to not escalate straight to deadly force if ccw were allowed
Post by: punaperson on April 25, 2014, 09:02:09 AM
1 is there a need for CCW in Hawaiii?

Define"need". Clearly explain how your definition of need has any causal connection or relationship, or even correlation, with CCW and self-defense.

 Is CCW a need or a want?

Define your terms. Clearly explain what the definitions you offer have to do with CCW and self-defense.

I'm not here to convince or persuade anyone. 

How would you characterize what you are doing here? It seems you're making judgments and evaluations based upon the fact that people disagree with you on factual data and don't subscribe to your belief system.

Let's just present facts, discuss and let people make their own decisions free from criticism.

If you choose to quote the "bible" you ipso facto have chosen to ignore the very concept of "facts".
 
 if there is a need (necessary) are there statistics to warrant the need? 

What statistic(s) would satisfy your criteria for their being a "sufficient" "need (necessary)" [sic]?

Crime in Hawaii has generally been on the decline without CCW.  gun ownership is up.  So do we need CCW?

Please clearly explain how the declining crime rate has any bearing on the issue of individuals being legally allowed to carry a weapon outside their property for the purpose of self-defense. Please refrain from quoting your "bible".

  I am trying to be objective. 

Really? That's laughable. Anyone who quotes the "bible" as authority for anything hasn't the foggiest notion of what "objectivity" is. You may be "trying", but you are failing miserably.

I have asked the so called experts or proponents of CCW and have not seen anything substantial other than its what they want cuz they feel it's their right.   

You have "not seen anything substantial" in all the DGU data and other information presented because your a priori assumptions and beliefs and biases are so strong that you are incapable of reasoning. This lack of critical thinking skills, including the ability to evaluate evidence, is further borne out by your unwarranted belief that your "bible" is somehow authoritative in spite of all the evidence clearly showing that it is nothing but a collection of fables and myths mostly from a pre-literate culture that has since been added to, deleted from, edited, and changed in many ways, both in content and language meanings whenever it suited the power-controlling needs of the clerical bureaucrats who could intimidate and scare the ignorant masses by threats of "hell" and various kinds of torture (e.g. burning at the stake) if a person questioned the bureaucrats "authority" in any way (e.g. the earth revolves around the sun). Someone could just as meaningfully quote the Spiderman or Star Trek archives, but anyone who took their blabber of "authoritative" quotes seriously is equally deluded and incapable of critical thinking or evidence evaluation.

And that's ok too.     I actually agree, it's their right.  I was just curious as to why they felt the need, or if there was a need.

Again, your back to the "need" issue. Define it. And explain what kind of "need", and how any kind of "need" would meet your criteria for sufficiency for CCW.


2 does the Bible say we can kill others if we feel threatened?  I haven't seen it.

As we all know, anyone can "see" anything they want in the "bible". Anyone can justify anything they want using that mythological collection of fairy tales as an "authority". Whatever you see or don't see there has no bearing on the issue of CCW to anyone other than yourself or other deluded believers in such nonsense.
Title: Re: yet another reason to not escalate straight to deadly force if ccw were allowed
Post by: kia_killer on April 25, 2014, 09:10:06 AM
Spot on.  :thumbsup:


Do you NEED a fire extinguisher?  How many times have you been at home and the room caught fire?
Do you NEED an airbag in your car?  How many times have your cars been in collisions and the airbag deployed?
Do you NEED a police force?  How many times have you needed to call the police to protect you from an immediate threat?
Do you NEED life insurance?  After all, life insurance does YOU no good.  It only helps the beneficiaries of the policy.
Do you NEED a first aid kit at home, at work and in the car?  How many times have you used one to save a life?
Do you NEED to learn CPR?  How many heart attacks have you saved anyone from?
Do you NEED to learn how to swim?  How many times have you needed to jump into the water and save a drowning kid?
Do you NEED to finish high school?  Look at all the successful dropouts in the country.
Do you NEED to go to the dentist twice a year?  You can always buy dentures when the time comes.

Do you NEED to carry a gun?  The majority of the people will never have to use their concealed firearm.  Would you rather have it and never NEED it, or NEED it and not have one?

Dr. Suzanna Hupp Testimony (Better Quality) to Congress on the Second Amendment (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FvTO-y-B2YM#)
Title: Re: yet another reason to not escalate straight to deadly force if ccw were allowed
Post by: punaperson on April 25, 2014, 09:10:51 AM
Do you NEED a fire extinguisher?  How many times have you been at home and the room caught fire?
Do you NEED an airbag in your car?  How many times have your cars been in collisions and the airbag deployed?
Do you NEED a police force?  How many times have you needed to call the police to protect you from an immediate threat?
Do you NEED life insurance?  After all, life insurance does YOU no good.  It only helps the beneficiaries of the policy.
Do you NEED a first aid kit at home, at work and in the car?  How many times have you used one to save a life?
Do you NEED to learn CPR?  How many heart attacks have you saved anyone from?
Do you NEED to learn how to swim?  How many times have you needed to jump into the water and save a drowning kid?
Do you NEED to finish high school?  Look at all the successful dropouts in the country.
Do you NEED to go to the dentist twice a year?  You can always buy dentures when the time comes.

Do you NEED to carry a gun?  The majority of the people will never have to use their concealed firearm.  Would you rather have it and never NEED it, or NEED it and not have one?

Dr. Suzanna Hupp Testimony (Better Quality) to Congress on the Second Amendment (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FvTO-y-B2YM#)
+1000  :thumbsup:
Title: yet another reason to not escalate straight to deadly force if ccw were allowed
Post by: dustoff003 on April 25, 2014, 09:28:08 AM
Snipped:


sure, with respect to this thread

Now that I have shared a bit about myself, please share your experience, training and qualifications also?

Thanks bubba.

I am really nobody special. I am a transplant I grew up in NY & FL then the Army brought me here in 97, I have been here ever since. I am an Aircraft Mechanic, Citizen Soldier, Gentleman Farmer and Model Rocket Scientist. I bought my first firearm in the late 90's and have been a collector and recreational shooter time and money permitting. I am not all high speed nor do I claim to be. I have no other training in firearms besides what I have learned in the military and the NRA pistol course the missus and I took to get our affidavits. I have received the Army Marksmanship Unit rifle training similar to the slides and vids others have posted here recently. I am a PMI (Preliminary Marksmanship Instruction) instructor at my unit I can do M16/4 rifle but I will usually do the class for the M9 pistol. I have some college but no degree, I am a married homeowner we are childless at this time. I am not much on the bible I have tried to read it a few times but couldn't make it out of Genesis. I am a heavily lapsed Catholic, my wife is a Theravada Buddhist, I consider myself to be an Agnostic Theist at present.

Aloha see you around

p.s. I like rusty M-N's....(http://img.tapatalk.com/d/14/04/26/unytetem.jpg)
Title: Re: yet another reason to not escalate straight to deadly force if ccw were allowed
Post by: macsak on April 25, 2014, 09:49:39 AM
Do you NEED a fire extinguisher?  How many times have you been at home and the room caught fire?
Do you NEED an airbag in your car?  How many times have your cars been in collisions and the airbag deployed?
Do you NEED a police force?  How many times have you needed to call the police to protect you from an immediate threat?
Do you NEED life insurance?  After all, life insurance does YOU no good.  It only helps the beneficiaries of the policy.
Do you NEED a first aid kit at home, at work and in the car?  How many times have you used one to save a life?
Do you NEED to learn CPR?  How many heart attacks have you saved anyone from?
Do you NEED to learn how to swim?  How many times have you needed to jump into the water and save a drowning kid?
Do you NEED to finish high school?  Look at all the successful dropouts in the country.
Do you NEED to go to the dentist twice a year?  You can always buy dentures when the time comes.

Do you NEED to carry a gun?  The majority of the people will never have to use their concealed firearm.  Would you rather have it and never NEED it, or NEED it and not have one?

Dr. Suzanna Hupp Testimony (Better Quality) to Congress on the Second Amendment (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FvTO-y-B2YM#)

yes, you NEED to go to the dentist twice a year
you also NEED to brush at least 3 times a day and floss at least once a day
Title: Re: yet another reason to not escalate straight to deadly force if ccw were allowed
Post by: punaperson on April 25, 2014, 09:58:37 AM
yes, you NEED to go to the dentist twice a year
you also NEED to brush at least 3 times a day and floss at least once a day
Yep. I'm pretty sure that is in the "bible". The "bible" of the American Dental Association. You know, the people who advocate for "Crest". Completely objective.
Title: Re: yet another reason to not escalate straight to deadly force if ccw were allowed
Post by: BUD on April 25, 2014, 10:12:30 AM
yes, you NEED to go to the dentist twice a year
you also NEED to brush at least 3 times a day and floss at least once a day

You really need to define need.......like do you really need a root canal?
Title: Re: yet another reason to not escalate straight to deadly force if ccw were allowed
Post by: macsak on April 25, 2014, 10:33:15 AM
Yep. I'm pretty sure that is in the "bible". The "bible" of the American Dental Association. You know, the people who advocate for "Crest". Completely objective.

i skipped the smiley face because i thought it would be understood that i was saying it tongue-in-cheek
i guess i assumed incorrectly
Title: Re: yet another reason to not escalate straight to deadly force if ccw were allowed
Post by: punaperson on April 25, 2014, 10:45:44 AM
i skipped the smiley face because i thought it would be understood that i was saying it tongue-in-cheek
i guess i assumed incorrectly
I skipped the smiley face because i thought it would be understood that i was saying it sarcastically.
I guess i assumed incorrectly.  ;) :geekdanc: :shaka: :shake:
Title: Re: yet another reason to not escalate straight to deadly force if ccw were allowed
Post by: macsak on April 25, 2014, 10:57:01 AM
I skipped the smiley face because i thought it would be understood that i was saying it sarcastically.
I guess i assumed incorrectly.  ;) :geekdanc: :shaka: :shake:

damnit, you got me

thanks for making me smile
Title: Re: yet another reason to not escalate straight to deadly force if ccw were allowed
Post by: bubba808 on April 25, 2014, 02:18:21 PM
Mauidog,
Your follow on questions were irrelevant so i deleted them. 
Do you NEED a fire extinguisher?  No, but even if I did, you wont see me carrying one around just incase there were fires.  Now if I came across fires everyday, then I would carry it everyday.
Do you NEED an airbag in your car?  According to the government I do, they are in my newer cars n trucks no matter what.
Do you NEED a police force?  Me personally, No, but its not my choice.
Do you NEED life insurance?  No, but if were going to die soon, I'd wish I bought some so my family would be set.
Do you NEED a first aid kit at home, at work and in the car?  Yes, yes, no.  But you wont see me carrying one around cuz I dont need bandaids that often.
Do you NEED to learn CPR?  No,  but if I was interested in saving lives, or had friends/family with heart conditions, I would learn.
Do you NEED to learn how to swim? No, but I grew up here so I did learn. 
Do you NEED to finish high school?  No, but its not a good idea not to.
Do you NEED to go to the dentist twice a year? No but I do, but you wont see me carrying macsack around just in case I get a cavity.
Do you NEED to carry a gun?  The majority of the people will never have to use their concealed firearm. So based on your statement, then, no, I dont need to carry one.



Title: Re: yet another reason to not escalate straight to deadly force if ccw were allowed
Post by: bubba808 on April 25, 2014, 02:31:47 PM
I would say that the need for CCW in Hawaii stems from it being a right. Since I may not need to use the "right" right now, doesn't mean it should be taken away.
Your need is based on  your want to exercise your right, but are there any other reasons?  Like if you were getting robbed or raped, I would say there may be a need.   For example, now, our chief of police SHOULD make a determination based on REASON of applicants who FEAR injury of person or property.  Any reasons?
Title: Re: yet another reason to not escalate straight to deadly force if ccw were allowed
Post by: new guy on April 25, 2014, 02:48:43 PM
In my opinion, we may have reached (passed?) that point in time for participants to say, "you aren't going to convince me, and I'm not going to convince you... so, let's just agree to disagree on this issue and move on."
Title: Re: yet another reason to not escalate straight to deadly force if ccw were allowed
Post by: 2aHawaii on April 25, 2014, 02:52:34 PM
Your need is based on  your want to exercise your right, but are there any other reasons?  Like if you were getting robbed or raped, I would say there may be a need.   For example, now, our chief of police SHOULD make a determination based on REASON of applicants who FEAR injury of person or property.  Any reasons?

You jumped from my need for it to be allowed to whether it should be limited in some fashion or not. I answered the first question as to need and why it should be allowed.

If you want to say that I only need to be carrying WHILE I am being robbed or raped, well it's kinda to late. Really think about that one. Really.

The fact is, this is an abuse of power and severely limits the right. In the past it has been used for nepotism, a complete ban, and everything in between. In California, it depends on what county you live in as to whether it is even possible to get a carry permit. In Hawaii it was a de-facto ban on carrying firearms up until this past year in Kauai(?) and in Honolulu County, it still is a de-facto ban. This is the reason it needs to be "shall issue." To fight this kind of abuse in the courts just takes way too long and the type of abuse can just change with the governing powers.
Title: Re: yet another reason to not escalate straight to deadly force if ccw were allowed
Post by: punaperson on April 25, 2014, 03:11:45 PM
In my opinion, we may have reached (passed?) that point in time for participants to say, "you aren't going to convince me, and I'm not going to convince you... so, let's just agree to disagree on this issue and move on."
I don't think it's very likely that any "convincing" is going to happen on this forum. Most people posting here seem to be either fairly familiar with the issues and have investigated and thought through their positions, or a small minority are laboring under misconceptions and/or preconceptions or under the sway of superstitions to support their conclusions. Either way, it's still "interesting" (to me) to see the various levels of logic or lack thereof and how people try to justify their conclusions. I didn't participate until after 100 comments, but it has gone on a long time.
Title: Re: yet another reason to not escalate straight to deadly force if ccw were allowed
Post by: bubba808 on April 25, 2014, 03:22:13 PM
Define"need". Clearly explain how your definition of need has any causal connection or relationship, or even correlation, with CCW and self-defense.
please see any dictionary? really any othese can do, but #4 fits the best.  is there any necessity arising from any circumstance of a situation or case that justifies CCW in Hawaii
need  -noun 
1. a requirement, necessary duty, or obligation: There is no need for you to go there. 
2. a lack of something wanted or deemed necessary: to fulfill the needs of the assignment. 
3. urgent want, as of something requisite: He has no need of your charity. 
4. necessity arising from the circumstances of a situation or case: There is no need to worry. 
5. a situation or time of difficulty; exigency: to help a friend in need; to be a friend in need.   


Define your terms. Clearly explain what the definitions you offer have to do with CCW and self-defense.
for example, are there statistics that depict a large enough problem in Hawaii [that a gun can solve] to warrant every citizen being allowed to carry a concealed firearm?

How would you characterize what you are doing here? It seems you're making judgments and evaluations based upon the fact that people disagree with you on factual data and don't subscribe to your belief system.
expressing my opinion, and trying to understand if there are reasons to support CCW in Hawaii.  my opinions is not based on the fact that people disagree with me or my beliefs..     

If you choose to quote the "bible" you ipso facto have chosen to ignore the very concept of "facts".
  I believe in GOD and the bible contains fact.  my choice.  you can do whatever you want.       

What statistic(s) would satisfy your criteria for their being a "sufficient" "need (necessary)" [sic]?
see above   

Please clearly explain how the declining crime rate has any bearing on the issue of individuals being legally allowed to carry a weapon outside their property for the purpose of self-defense. Please refrain from quoting your "bible".
have you read any of the other posts?  Its others opinion that CCW reduces crime rates.  Im saying crime rates are reduced anyway, independent of CCW.     

Really? That's laughable. Anyone who quotes the "bible" as authority for anything hasn't the foggiest notion of what "objectivity" is. You may be "trying", but you are failing miserably.
yes, youre laughable.  what do you believe in?  I think youre failing at this post.   

You have "not seen anything substantial" in all the DGU data and other information presented because your a priori assumptions and beliefs and biases are so strong that you are incapable of reasoning. This lack of critical thinking skills, including the ability to evaluate evidence, is further borne out by your unwarranted belief that your "bible" is somehow authoritative in spite of all the evidence clearly showing that it is nothing but a collection of fables and myths mostly from a pre-literate culture that has since been added to, deleted from, edited, and changed in many ways, both in content and language meanings whenever it suited the power-controlling needs of the clerical bureaucrats who could intimidate and scare the ignorant masses by threats of "hell" and various kinds of torture (e.g. burning at the stake) if a person questioned the bureaucrats "authority" in any way (e.g. the earth revolves around the sun). Someone could just as meaningfully quote the Spiderman or Star Trek archives, but anyone who took their blabber of "authoritative" quotes seriously is equally deluded and incapable of critical thinking or evidence evaluation.
sorry, I haven't, care to site specifically which data I am supposed to be convinced by?  I thought you were confused about even basic definitions of terminology?  how did you come up with this gem?  you can think of the bible that way,and if you read my posts, I explain that.   lol smh.    star trek n spiderman- well u seem spacey to me     

Again, your back to the "need" issue. Define it. And explain what kind of "need", and how any kind of "need" would meet your criteria for sufficiency for CCW.
please read above, I don't like repeating

As we all know, anyone can "see" anything they want in the "bible". Anyone can justify anything they want using that mythological collection of fairy tales as an "authority". Whatever you see or don't see there has no bearing on the issue of CCW to anyone other than yourself or other deluded believers in such nonsense.
we all?  I dont agree.  the question was simply "does the bible say we can kill others when we feel threatened?"   
Title: Re: yet another reason to not escalate straight to deadly force if ccw were allowed
Post by: punaperson on April 25, 2014, 03:35:58 PM
Your need is based on  your want to exercise your right, but are there any other reasons?  Like if you were getting robbed or raped, I would say there may be a need.   For example, now, our chief of police SHOULD make a determination based on REASON of applicants who FEAR injury of person or property.  Any reasons?
You sound as if you'd like New Jersey's "justifiable need" requirement for CCW which means you must provide documented and verified evidence of prior physical injury or threat of serious bodily injury and there must be no other option open to avoid future injury other than issuing a CCW license. In other words, virtually no one gets one there. I think the current official number is 200. Of course that's 200 more than the official number of active licenses for Hawaii, which is, do the math, zero.

A reason? How about this: Crime statistics show that in Hawaii there are crimes. Some of these crimes result in serious bodily injury or property injury. It is highly likely, given history, that such crimes will occur again in the future. There is no known way to determine prior to such an event whether a particular individual will be the victim of such a crime. Therefore, anyone who lives in the state of Hawaii, where such crimes are documented to have occurred, and by all reasonable assessment are likely to occur again in the future, may at some future point in time be the victim of such a crime of injury to person or property. Therefore ANY PERSON present in the state of Hawaii has sufficient and justifiable REASON to believe that they may be the victim of a criminal attempt to inflict serious bodily injury or property damage. Is that spelled out clearly enough?

Why would the law demand that a person FEAR such an event to be eligible for consideration to exercise their right to self-defense using whatever arm they choose? Why that particular emotion? Why not "aware" or "prudent" given the fact that such crimes occur? What about "sad"? Why the need to have any emotion at all? Why not just a neutral awareness of the facts of criminal activity?

Of course this entire argument takes place in the context of a totally unconstitutional infringement of a natural, civil, fundamental, individual, inalienable Constitutionally-protected right of self-defense wherein the government has absolutely even being involved in any way at all much less setting standards or criteria that they then cynically deny that anyone in the entire state (except for one court-ordered CCW that was valid for six months that has expired) has met in the last 15 years. Absurd.
Title: Re: yet another reason to not escalate straight to deadly force if ccw were allowed
Post by: BUD on April 25, 2014, 03:37:25 PM


So when do you "need" to believe in God?  Some of the time or all of the time?  I mean if you aren't in immediate fear of death or immediate need of salvation, then you only believe in God when you need him?  I didn't think so.  You "carry" God with you all the time, just in case right? 
Title: Re: yet another reason to not escalate straight to deadly force if ccw were allowed
Post by: bubba808 on April 25, 2014, 03:47:09 PM
You jumped from my need for it to be allowed to whether it should be limited in some fashion or not. I answered the first question as to need and why it should be allowed.
need is defined as follows:
1. a requirement, necessary duty, or obligation: There is no need for you to go there. 
2. a lack of something wanted or deemed necessary: to fulfill the needs of the assignment. 
3. urgent want, as of something requisite: He has no need of your charity. 
4. necessity arising from the circumstances of a situation or case: There is no need to worry. 
5. a situation or time of difficulty; exigency: to help a friend in need; to be a friend in need.   
so how did you address need?

If you want to say that I only need to be carrying WHILE I am being robbed or raped, well it's kinda to late. Really think about that one. Really.
the same argument applies to these statements.  yes its too late for all of these but, do you carry around extinguishers, and first aid kits, etc?  really think about that one.
Do you NEED a fire extinguisher?  No, but even if I did, you wont see me carrying one around just incase there were fires.  Now if I came across fires everyday, then I would carry it everyday.
Do you NEED an airbag in your car?  According to the government I do, they are in my newer cars n trucks no matter what.
Do you NEED a police force?  Me personally, No, but its not my choice.
Do you NEED life insurance?  No, but if were going to die soon, I'd wish I bought some so my family would be set.
Do you NEED a first aid kit at home, at work and in the car?  Yes, yes, no.  But you wont see me carrying one around cuz I dont need bandaids that often.
Do you NEED to learn CPR?  No,  but if I was interested in saving lives, or had friends/family with heart conditions, I would learn.
Do you NEED to learn how to swim? No, but I grew up here so I did learn. 
Do you NEED to finish high school?  No, but its not a good idea not to.
Do you NEED to go to the dentist twice a year? No but I do, but you wont see me carrying macsack around just in case I get a cavity.
Do you NEED to carry a gun?  The majority of the people will never have to use their concealed firearm. So based on your statement, then, no, I dont need to carry one.


The fact is, this is an abuse of power and severely limits the right. In the past it has been used for nepotism, a complete ban, and everything in between. In California, it depends on what county you live in as to whether it is even possible to get a carry permit. In Hawaii it was a de-facto ban on carrying firearms up until this past year in Kauai(?) and in Honolulu County, it still is a de-facto ban. This is the reason it needs to be "shall issue." To fight this kind of abuse in the courts just takes way too long and the type of abuse can just change with the governing powers.
I agree with you,  the right that the founding fathers had intended is to keep and bear and includes the right to carry, and by not granting, is an abuse of power.  its not the question I am asking.  im interested in good reasons to carry in Hawaii.   Do we have a big murder problem, or big rape problem, or big robbery problem in Hawaii that carrying guns would solve
Title: Re: yet another reason to not escalate straight to deadly force if ccw were allowed
Post by: bubba808 on April 25, 2014, 03:54:01 PM
So when do you "need" to believe in God?  Some of the time or all of the time?  I mean if you aren't in immediate fear of death or immediate need of salvation, then you only believe in God when you need him?  I didn't think so.  You "carry" God with you all the time, just in case right?
well bud, actually, it doent quite work that way.  because I believe,  I need to live as GOD has commanded and do my best to stay on the straight and narrow path.  my everlasting life, after this physical body rots away, is based on my ability to live as prescribed as much as possible.  so to answer your question, every moment that I don't live IAW GODs laws, I jeapordize my chance at salvation, and will be put to death.  I carry GOD with me all the time because I have to, NOT JUST IN CASE!
Title: Re: yet another reason to not escalate straight to deadly force if ccw were allowed
Post by: new guy on April 25, 2014, 04:06:48 PM
Aloha bubba808,

In your own words, I think we can all agree that, "the right that the founding fathers had intended is to keep and bear arms and includes the right to carry, and by not granting, is an abuse of power."

Can we also agree that we each have different opinions, different tolerances, different physical statures, and are shaped by different past experiences?

Based upon one's own opinions/tolerances/physical statures/past experiences/etc., can we agree that where one individual may be/feel safe, another individual may be/feel threatened, insecure, and/or unsafe?

By not taking these things into consideration, an individual can be marginalized and his/her safety can be compromised.

In my mind it boils down to this:

An individual should have the option to exercise the ability to CCW, if that individual so chooses.

If one individual personally feels uncomfortable with exercising the ability to CCW, then that individual may certainly opt not to CCW.

However, just because one individual personally feels uncomfortable with the idea of CCW, themselves, that individual should not project his/her misgivings onto others, and preclude another individual from exercising the ability to CCW, if the other individual so chooses to CCW, and as long as the other individual can do so responsibly.

Or, perhaps I may have oversimplified the issue?

Respectfully,
new guy
Title: Re: yet another reason to not escalate straight to deadly force if ccw were allowed
Post by: HiCarry on April 25, 2014, 04:24:35 PM
It is impossible, IMHO, to "justify" CCW by stating the statistical odds of any one individual person needing a gun to defend themselves. Even if there was only 1 rape, 1 violent assault, and 1 murder per year, I would hold that there is still a need for CCW.

It is not the odds of anything bad happening that drives the desire to CCW, although in high crime areas one can certainly see more easily why one would choose to carry. Rather, I tend to think of it as what happens to "me" or "mine." In that regard it doesn't matter if the murder rate is very low if that murder is me or one of my loved ones.
Title: Re: yet another reason to not escalate straight to deadly force if ccw were allowed
Post by: BUD on April 25, 2014, 04:26:41 PM
well bud, actually, it doent quite work that way.  because I believe,  I need to live as GOD has commanded and do my best to stay on the straight and narrow path.  my everlasting life, after this physical body rots away, is based on my ability to live as prescribed as much as possible.  so to answer your question, every moment that I don't live IAW GODs laws, I jeapordize my chance at salvation, and will be put to death.  I carry GOD with me all the time because I have to, NOT JUST IN CASE!

Actually, it does work that way. You see, while you believe that you need to live as GOD commanded ALL OF THE TIME, there are many christians who believe they can do it some of the time.  Open your bible and tell me how many times it says you are forgiven if you ask.  How many times it says Jesus paid for ALL of your sins (not some, but ALL).  You see, not everyone conducts themselves as you do.  But the commonality in it all is that you are all guaranteed the choice to a) believe and b) how you conduct yourself.  Truth is there is no one size fits all answer to any of this.  Just as you percieve that you must live every moment in your life according to GOD's commandments, there are other belivers who see it differently.  Just as there are people here who see the need to carry a concealed weapon as a true need in response to some perceived dangers, there are others who see it as a right to have protection against unforeseen dangers.  Same as you, you percieve dangers in not conducting yourself as GOD commanded and others see that they can do it some or all of the time, just in case. I do not pass judgement on you or anyone else, just pointing out that whether the issue is GOD or CCW there is no one right answer as everyone sees it differently.
Title: Re: yet another reason to not escalate straight to deadly force if ccw were allowed
Post by: punaperson on April 25, 2014, 04:37:08 PM
Define"need". Clearly explain how your definition of need has any causal connection or relationship, or even correlation, with CCW and self-defense.
please see any dictionary? really any othese can do, but #4 fits the best.  is there any necessity arising from any circumstance of a situation or case that justifies CCW in Hawaii
need  -noun 
1. a requirement, necessary duty, or obligation: There is no need for you to go there. 
2. a lack of something wanted or deemed necessary: to fulfill the needs of the assignment. 
3. urgent want, as of something requisite: He has no need of your charity. 
4. necessity arising from the circumstances of a situation or case: There is no need to worry. 
5. a situation or time of difficulty; exigency: to help a friend in need; to be a friend in need. 

Necessity? Why must there be a "necessity"? If there is a "possibility" of a person enduring serious bodily injury at the hands of a criminal then that is all that ought to be required. See my post above. What I asked was how do you determine if anything is or is not a "necessity". You don't want to answer that question. Why? 

Define your terms. Clearly explain what the definitions you offer have to do with CCW and self-defense.
for example, are there statistics that depict a large enough problem in Hawaii [that a gun can solve] to warrant every citizen being allowed to carry a concealed firearm?

Again you avoid answering the question asked of you? Do you ever actually answer a question, or always deflect? What "statistic" would "depict a large enough problem in Hawaii" that would create your condition of "necessity"? If one person who could possibly have defended themselves had they been armed suffers serious bodily injury, that is "necessity" enough (given that all the statistics show that CCW has not in other jurisdictions increased crime). And clearly there is more than one person so injured in Hawaii, and likely more than one that could better defend themselves were they armed.

You wrote: "...to warrant every citizen being allowed to carry a concealed firearm". Ever heard of a "straw man argument"? You're full of them. No one that I am aware of has ever suggested that every citizen should be allowed to carry a concealed firearm. Why did you make that up? Why can't you just deal with the actual facts and claims without making things up that are no more than misleading and false red herrings? Name one person on this forum, or even anywhere else, that has suggested all convicted violent felons, adjudicated mentally ill, children, etc. carry concealed. Go ahead, support your claim. Let's see it.


How would you characterize what you are doing here? It seems you're making judgments and evaluations based upon the fact that people disagree with you on factual data and don't subscribe to your belief system.
expressing my opinion, and trying to understand if there are reasons to support CCW in Hawaii.  my opinions is not based on the fact that people disagree with me or my beliefs.. 

You make judgments and evaluations of people, including name calling, based upon people disagreeing with you. Clearly those are merely your opinions, I'm not disputing that. Your claim that you are only dealing with facts and/or reasons and not your opinions is absurd.  

If you choose to quote the "bible" you ipso facto have chosen to ignore the very concept of "facts".
  I believe in GOD and the bible contains fact.  my choice.  you can do whatever you want.   

Gee thanks. Sorry, but you don't get to choose what is and what is not "fact". I know you want to, because there is no actual evidence that would substantiate the vast majority of the superstitious mythology that is your "bible". When you use that document to attempt to justify secular laws you lose all credibility. Unless you want to say that all other religions and their "sacred scriptures" from their "gods" are equally valid with yours. Is that what you believe? And it's just a geographical happenstance of your birth location that you are a christian rather than a muslim or zoroastrian?    

What statistic(s) would satisfy your criteria for their being a "sufficient" "need (necessary)" [sic]?
see above   

Yeah, no answer is your answer. Good job.

Please clearly explain how the declining crime rate has any bearing on the issue of individuals being legally allowed to carry a weapon outside their property for the purpose of self-defense. Please refrain from quoting your "bible".
have you read any of the other posts?  Its others opinion that CCW reduces crime rates.  Im saying crime rates are reduced anyway, independent of CCW.   

Uh. Aren't you the person who claimed to have taken a statistics class?  Where's your multivariate time-regression analysis? Do I really have to explain this to you? Crime rates are going down. What does that have to do with how much they would have gone down had there been CCW in Hawaii? How do you know what it would have done had CCW been in place? Perhaps it would have gone down much more had CCW been in effect in Hawaii (as the majority of studies show is the case). You have nothing but pure speculation. Useless. Or are you are arguing that since crime has gone down, no one needs to do anything more to attempt to lower the crime rate even more because it is now so low that no one should care about the few remaining victims?

Really? That's laughable. Anyone who quotes the "bible" as authority for anything hasn't the foggiest notion of what "objectivity" is. You may be "trying", but you are failing miserably.
yes, youre laughable.  what do you believe in?  I think youre failing at this post. 

None of your business what I do or don't "believe in". I tend to choose verifiable facts that will withstand critical scrutiny as determined by the preponderance of replicable data. I'll give you a hint: It doesn't include any superstitious fairy tales full of "miracles". See David Hume.

You have "not seen anything substantial" in all the DGU data and other information presented because your a priori assumptions and beliefs and biases are so strong that you are incapable of reasoning. This lack of critical thinking skills, including the ability to evaluate evidence, is further borne out by your unwarranted belief that your "bible" is somehow authoritative in spite of all the evidence clearly showing that it is nothing but a collection of fables and myths mostly from a pre-literate culture that has since been added to, deleted from, edited, and changed in many ways, both in content and language meanings whenever it suited the power-controlling needs of the clerical bureaucrats who could intimidate and scare the ignorant masses by threats of "hell" and various kinds of torture (e.g. burning at the stake) if a person questioned the bureaucrats "authority" in any way (e.g. the earth revolves around the sun). Someone could just as meaningfully quote the Spiderman or Star Trek archives, but anyone who took their blabber of "authoritative" quotes seriously is equally deluded and incapable of critical thinking or evidence evaluation.
sorry, I haven't, care to site specifically which data I am supposed to be convinced by?  I thought you were confused about even basic definitions of terminology?  how did you come up with this gem?  you can think of the bible that way,and if you read my posts, I explain that.   lol smh.    star trek n spiderman- well u seem spacey to me

You make my point. If you examine all the evidence and conclude that the "bible" contains mostly factual accounts of events, then I'm not surprised in the least that you read all the studies regarding CCW and write the kinds of things you do about that subject.   

Again, your back to the "need" issue. Define it. And explain what kind of "need", and how any kind of "need" would meet your criteria for sufficiency for CCW.
please read above, I don't like repeating

You don't like actually answering questions is what you don't like. I'll give you another chance: What specific "necessity" would warrant, in your opinion, granting a person in Hawaii a CCW license, given that crime is going down anyway?

As we all know, anyone can "see" anything they want in the "bible". Anyone can justify anything they want using that mythological collection of fairy tales as an "authority". Whatever you see or don't see there has no bearing on the issue of CCW to anyone other than yourself or other deluded believers in such nonsense.
we all?  I dont agree.  the question was simply "does the bible say we can kill others when we feel threatened?"

Sorry, my mistake. I meant "all rational people with critical thinking skills willing to look at all the evidence and evaluate the quality of that evidence". Why do you seem to believe that it would matter to anyone other than yourself (and your fellow believers in superstition) what your "bible" says about such matters? Do you really believe that your particular document has any special authority compared to anything else ever written by other people throughout the history of mankind? I'll go with Kant's Prolegomena to Any Future Metaphysics.
Title: Re: yet another reason to not escalate straight to deadly force if ccw were allowed
Post by: bubba808 on April 25, 2014, 04:42:55 PM
Aloha bubba808,

In your own words, I think we can all agree that, "the right that the founding fathers had intended is to keep and bear arms and includes the right to carry, and by not granting, is an abuse of power."

Can we also agree that we each have different opinions, different tolerances, different physical statures, and are shaped by different past experiences?

Based upon one's own opinions/tolerances/physical statures/past experiences/etc., can we agree that where one individual may be/feel safe, another individual may be/feel threatened, insecure, and/or unsafe?

By not taking these things into consideration, an individual can be marginalized and his/her safety can be compromised.

In my mind it boils down to this:

An individual should have the option to exercise the ability to CCW, if that individual so chooses.

If one individual personally feels uncomfortable with exercising the ability to CCW, then that individual may certainly opt not to CCW.

However, just because one individual personally feels uncomfortable with the idea of CCW, themselves, that individual should not project his/her misgivings onto others, and preclude another individual from exercising the ability to CCW, if the other individual so chooses to CCW, and as long as the other individual can do so responsibly.

Or, perhaps I may have oversimplified the issue?

Respectfully,
new guy
Sup new guy, I can agree with mostly everything you stated, heres my 2 cents.
by leaving the "choice" to exercise CCW up to an individual,  while that person may now be safer , can the safety of other citizens can be compromised???  to what extent? if the amount of crimes that CCW prevents, is equal or less than the amount of problems it creates, why would it be a good idea?  for a selfish individual, its a great idea, for a family, or community, maybe not such a good idea?  im not sure
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gun_violence_in_the_United_States (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gun_violence_in_the_United_States) 
Title: Re: yet another reason to not escalate straight to deadly force if ccw were allowed
Post by: bubba808 on April 25, 2014, 04:47:47 PM
It is impossible, IMHO, to "justify" CCW by stating the statistical odds of any one individual person needing a gun to defend themselves. Even if there was only 1 rape, 1 violent assault, and 1 murder per year, I would hold that there is still a need for CCW.

It is not the odds of anything bad happening that drives the desire to CCW, although in high crime areas one can certainly see more easily why one would choose to carry. Rather, I tend to think of it as what happens to "me" or "mine." In that regard it doesn't matter if the murder rate is very low if that murder is me or one of my loved ones.

this is the most meaningful response in this whole thread. I can accept this answer, and fully understand it.  it isn't pretty, but its the truth.  thanks HiCarry
Title: Re: yet another reason to not escalate straight to deadly force if ccw were allowed
Post by: BUD on April 25, 2014, 05:00:58 PM
this is the most meaningful response in this whole thread. I can accept this answer, and fully understand it.  it isn't pretty, but its the truth.  thanks HiCarry

Yes, you see everyone should be able to proceed based on their own perceptions and not all people perceive danger or threats the same. 
Title: Re: yet another reason to not escalate straight to deadly force if ccw were allowed
Post by: macsak on April 25, 2014, 05:18:30 PM
It is not the odds of anything bad happening that drives the desire to CCW, although in high crime areas one can certainly see more easily why one would choose to carry. Rather, I tend to think of it as what happens to "me" or "mine." In that regard it doesn't matter if the murder rate is very low if that murder is me or one of my loved ones.

well said, HiC
Title: Re: yet another reason to not escalate straight to deadly force if ccw were allowed
Post by: bubba808 on April 25, 2014, 05:38:10 PM
[quote author=BUD link=topic=13650.msg138618#msg138618 date=1398479201]Actually, it does work that way. You see, while you believe that you need to live as GOD commanded ALL OF THE TIME, there are many christians who believe they can do it some of the time.  Open your bible and tell me how many times it says you are forgiven if you ask.  How many times it says Jesus paid for ALL of your sins (not some, but ALL).  You see, not everyone conducts themselves as you do.  But the commonality in it all is that you are all guaranteed the choice to a) believe and b) how you conduct yourself.  Truth is there is no one size fits all answer to any of this.  Just as you percieve that you must live every moment in your life according to GOD's commandments, there are other belivers who see it differently.  Just as there are people here who see the need to carry a concealed weapon as a true need in response to some perceived dangers, there are others who see it as a right to have protection against unforeseen dangers.  Same as you, you percieve dangers in not conducting yourself as GOD commanded and others see that they can do it some or all of the time, just in case. I do not pass judgement on you or anyone else, just pointing out that whether the issue is GOD or CCW there is no one right answer as everyone sees it differently.[/quote]I appreciate this perspective.  granted there are Christians that don't follow as expected, that's why we all don't get saved.  this isn't burger king where we can have it our way, It isn't easy.   I am not claiming to be righteous, im just trying not to break the big ten, and do my best with the rest.  I have tons of flaws.    to my knowledge, he bible really only allows one "reset" and certain sins cannot be forgiven.  the reset is during your baptism, as Christ was baptized.  from that point you have no excuses, and can attempt to repent but true repentence means not doing it again, and it doesn't mean its forgiven.    I think there is a right answer, but like you said.. YMMV.
Title: Re: yet another reason to not escalate straight to deadly force if ccw were allowed
Post by: mauidog on April 25, 2014, 06:35:00 PM
Mauidog,
Your follow on questions were irrelevant so i deleted them. 
Do you NEED a fire extinguisher?  No, but even if I did, you wont see me carrying one around just incase there were fires.  Now if I came across fires everyday, then I would carry it everyday.
Do you NEED an airbag in your car?  According to the government I do, they are in my newer cars n trucks no matter what.
Do you NEED a police force?  Me personally, No, but its not my choice.
Do you NEED life insurance?  No, but if were going to die soon, I'd wish I bought some so my family would be set.
Do you NEED a first aid kit at home, at work and in the car?  Yes, yes, no.  But you wont see me carrying one around cuz I dont need bandaids that often.
Do you NEED to learn CPR?  No,  but if I was interested in saving lives, or had friends/family with heart conditions, I would learn.
Do you NEED to learn how to swim? No, but I grew up here so I did learn. 
Do you NEED to finish high school?  No, but its not a good idea not to.
Do you NEED to go to the dentist twice a year? No but I do, but you wont see me carrying macsack around just in case I get a cavity.
Do you NEED to carry a gun?  The majority of the people will never have to use their concealed firearm. So based on your statement, then, no, I dont need to carry one.

There is ONE word you used in your responses to my post that makes any sense at all, bubba.  That word is in red.... CHOICE.

If you choose to not prepare for an emergency, then you are responsible for the consequences.  My decision is my responsibility.  It's a very, very simple concept called individual responsibility. 

You live your life as you see fit, and I live mine as I choose.  As long as neither of us cause problems for the other or cause harm to our families, then what I do is none of your business.  Live and let live. 

Freedom ... liberty ... individual responsibility ... choice.   
Title: Re: yet another reason to not escalate straight to deadly force if ccw were allowed
Post by: bubba808 on April 25, 2014, 07:05:16 PM
Snipped:

Thanks bubba.

I am really nobody special. I am a transplant I grew up in NY & FL then the Army brought me here in 97, I have been here ever since. I am an Aircraft Mechanic, Citizen Soldier, Gentleman Farmer and Model Rocket Scientist. I bought my first firearm in the late 90's and have been a collector and recreational shooter time and money permitting. I am not all high speed nor do I claim to be. I have no other training in firearms besides what I have learned in the military and the NRA pistol course the missus and I took to get our affidavits. I have received the Army Marksmanship Unit rifle training similar to the slides and vids others have posted here recently. I am a PMI (Preliminary Marksmanship Instruction) instructor at my unit I can do M16/4 rifle but I will usually do the class for the M9 pistol. I have some college but no degree, I am a married homeowner we are childless at this time. I am not much on the bible I have tried to read it a few times but couldn't make it out of Genesis. I am a heavily lapsed Catholic, my wife is a Theravada Buddhist, I consider myself to be an Agnostic Theist at present.

Aloha see you around

p.s. I like rusty M-N's....(http://img.tapatalk.com/d/14/04/26/unytetem.jpg)
nice, hope to see you around also.
Title: Re: yet another reason to not escalate straight to deadly force if ccw were allowed
Post by: Jl808 on April 25, 2014, 07:10:07 PM
Speaking of God and the right to bear arms.....  A pastor (or priest if you're Catholic) was delivering a sermon entitled "Stand Still and Let the Good Lord Fight Your Battles", on the topic of not fighting but letting God vanquish evil himself.   As he was delivering the sermon, a gust of wind lifted his garment and the congregation noticed he was carrying a gun.

After the service a congregant asked him, "I understood your sermon, but aren't you contradicting yourself by carrying a gun? You did say you are supposed to let the Lord fight your battles for you?"

"I do", said the pastor / priest "the gun is just to hold them off until the Lord gets here".

---------------------

Peace be with you all, my 2a brothers and sisters!  Have a happy Friday!
Title: Re: yet another reason to not escalate straight to deadly force if ccw were allowed
Post by: bubba808 on April 25, 2014, 07:11:56 PM
There is ONE word you used in your responses to my post that makes any sense at all, bubba.  That word is in red.... CHOICE.

If you choose to not prepare for an emergency, then you are responsible for the consequences.  My decision is my responsibility.  It's a very, very simple concept called individual responsibility. 

You live your life as you see fit, and I live mine as I choose.  As long as neither of us cause problems for the other or cause harm to our families, then what I do is none of your business.  Live and let live. 

Freedom ... liberty ... individual responsibility ... choice.

understood, just dont want stray bullets headed my way when im out in public.  Individual responsibility is great, until it does affect or cause harm to our families.  Thanks
Title: Re: yet another reason to not escalate straight to deadly force if ccw were allowed
Post by: bubba808 on April 25, 2014, 07:13:51 PM
Speaking of God and the right to bear arms.....  A pastor (or priest if you're Catholic) was delivering a sermon entitled "Stand Still and Let the Good Lord Fight Your Battles", on the topic of not fighting but letting God vanquish evil himself.   As he was delivering the sermon, a gust of wind lifted his garment and the congregation noticed he was carrying a gun.

After the service a congregant asked him, "I understood your sermon, but aren't you contradicting yourself by carrying a gun? You did say you are supposed to let the Lord fight your battles for you?"

"I do", said the pastor / priest "the gun is just to hold them off until the Lord gets here".
lol, luckily im not catholic.  I can agree with the priest, as hold em off doesnt mean kill. 
Title: Re: yet another reason to not escalate straight to deadly force if ccw were allowed
Post by: Bunker on April 25, 2014, 08:51:43 PM
Just an observation but this thread appears to be approaching the realm of diminished returns....O0
Title: Re: yet another reason to not escalate straight to deadly force if ccw were allowed
Post by: mauidog on April 25, 2014, 08:55:21 PM
understood, just dont want stray bullets headed my way when im out in public.  Individual responsibility is great, until it does affect or cause harm to our families.  Thanks

Okay, Mister "the odds are..".  What are the odds of  "stray bullets headed my way when im out in public" being caused by legal concealed carry permit holders?  Name as many incidents as you can, in the last 30 years, in which an innocent bystander in public was shot and killed by a stray bullet fired from a private citizen legally carrying a concealed weapon.

Now, for extra credit, list how many times an innocent person was shot and injured or killed by POLICE trying to stop a suspect.

Once you compile those "lengthy" lists, calculate the odds of which is more likely.  Based on that calculation, state your conclusion based purely on the facts and evidence your research includes.

Be sure to EXCLUDE any reports of "nearly killed", "almost shot" and other yellow journalist attempts to paint CCW permit holders in a bad light.

Again, LEGALLY CARRIED firearms only.

I assume you already have an idea of these numbers and details of the shootings that form the basis of your fear that stray bullets are a given where CCW is legal.
Title: Re: yet another reason to not escalate straight to deadly force if ccw were allowed
Post by: mauidog on April 25, 2014, 09:04:53 PM
Okay, Mister "the odds are..".  What are the odds of  "stray bullets headed my way when im out in public" being caused by legal concealed carry permit holders?  Name as many incidents as you can, in the last 30 years, in which an innocent bystander in public was shot and killed by a stray bullet fired from a private citizen legally carrying a concealed weapon.

Now, for extra credit, list how many times an innocent person was shot and injured or killed by POLICE trying to stop a suspect.

Once you compile those "lengthy" lists, calculate the odds of which is more likely.  Based on that calculation, state your conclusion based purely on the facts and evidence your research includes.

Be sure to EXCLUDE any reports of "nearly killed", "almost shot" and other yellow journalist attempts to paint CCW permit holders in a bad light.

Again, LEGALLY CARRIED firearms only.

I assume you already have an idea of these numbers and details of the shootings that form the basis of your fear that stray bullets are a given where CCW is legal.

Follow-up:  which is the greater danger? 

1)  an active shooter allowed to continue his killing with no resistance by armed CCW civilians, or

2)  an innocent bystander being killed by that CCW holder trying to stop the active shooter?

In other words, do you think you're safer in an active shooter scenario if nobody stops the shooter before the police are called and can arrive?
Title: Re: yet another reason to not escalate straight to deadly force if ccw were allowed
Post by: bubba808 on April 25, 2014, 09:21:14 PM
Okay, Mister "the odds are..".  What are the odds of  "stray bullets headed my way when im out in public" being caused by legal concealed carry permit holders?  Name as many incidents as you can, in the last 30 years, in which an innocent bystander in public was shot and killed by a stray bullet fired from a private citizen legally carrying a concealed weapon.

Now, for extra credit, list how many times an innocent person was shot and injured or killed by POLICE trying to stop a suspect.

Once you compile those "lengthy" lists, calculate the odds of which is more likely.  Based on that calculation, state your conclusion based purely on the facts and evidence your research includes.

Be sure to EXCLUDE any reports of "nearly killed", "almost shot" and other yellow journalist attempts to paint CCW permit holders in a bad light.

Again, LEGALLY CARRIED firearms only.

I assume you already have an idea of these numbers and details of the shootings that form the basis of your fear that stray bullets are a given where CCW is legal.

look, I have searched, but havent found it exactly
http://smartgunlaws.org/gun-deaths-and-injuries-statistics/ (http://smartgunlaws.org/gun-deaths-and-injuries-statistics/)
 but this shows how many gun deaths occured in 2010 (11078), and excludes injuries, suicides etc.   Gun deaths were the 3rd highest cause of deaths in the us.  Now I dont know what percent was caused by legal firearms but the report went on to state that..
In 2010, unintentional firearm injuries caused the deaths of 606 people.
From 2005-2010, almost 3,800 people in the U.S. died from unintentional shootings.

Over 1,300 victims of unintentional shootings for the period 2005–2010 were under 25 years of age.

People of all age groups are significantly more likely to die from unintentional firearm injuries when they live in states with more guns, relative to states with fewer guns. On average, states with the highest gun levels had nine times the rate of unintentional firearms deaths compared to states with the lowest gun levels.

Now, I think it would be reasonable to say that at least one of these deaths were caused by legal firearm, so just as the argument for CCW is based off of just in case a serious threat or property damage may happen, Im saying a stray bullet may happen too. 



Title: Re: yet another reason to not escalate straight to deadly force if ccw were allowed
Post by: new guy on April 25, 2014, 09:27:29 PM
Sup new guy, I can agree with mostly everything you stated, heres my 2 cents.
by leaving the "choice" to exercise CCW up to an individual,  while that person may now be safer , can the safety of other citizens can be compromised???  to what extent? if the amount of crimes that CCW prevents, is equal or less than the amount of problems it creates, why would it be a good idea?  for a selfish individual, its a great idea, for a family, or community, maybe not such a good idea?  im not sure
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gun_violence_in_the_United_States (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gun_violence_in_the_United_States) 


Aloha bubba808,

Like Hicarry astutely stated, there is no way that I can provide you with an "absolute" justification that is sure to resonate with you, so to try to do so would be foolhardy (and a waste of time) on my part.

I am content to simply say that it sounds like your mind is made up on this matter, and while I may not personally agree with everything you have said about this matter, I do share some of your concerns amd respect your point of view.   :shaka:

Mahalo and Out,
new guy
Title: Re: yet another reason to not escalate straight to deadly force if ccw were allowed
Post by: bubba808 on April 25, 2014, 09:28:50 PM
Follow-up:  which is the greater danger? 

1)  an active shooter allowed to continue his killing with no resistance by armed CCW civilians, or

2)  an innocent bystander being killed by that CCW holder trying to stop the active shooter?

In other words, do you think you're safer in an active shooter scenario if nobody stops the shooter before the police are called and can arrive?
how many active shooter scenarios have we had in hawaii? What Uesugi? you mean the active shooter with legal firearms that took out his co workers? Or you must mean Deedy? Where the shooter was a possibly drunk off duty out of state LEO who violated his duty by drinking and then shooting with a legal CCW? In both instances It was legal firearms and I think I It would be worse if others CCW would have intervened and exchanged more shots.
Title: yet another reason to not escalate straight to deadly force if ccw were allowed
Post by: Dblnaknak on April 25, 2014, 09:31:00 PM
Hey bubba I am gonna ask the same question I asked the guy dblnaknak in the other thread where him and Q were going at it, there Q posted all of his experience, training and qualifications. Would you care to share your experience, training and qualifications with us?

I didn't reply because Q is full of shit. It wasn't worth my time because he tries to cyber bully his way in the forum.

I gave up when the admins edited my responses in favor of Q.

In the end everyone has their own point of view. Q's logic is one of a glorified security guard that turned in his gun at the end of his shift. Now he's stuck walking around his house is his tighty whites with his holdter clipped to the elastic waist band. Troll that.
Title: Re: yet another reason to not escalate straight to deadly force if ccw were allowed
Post by: yurcarmeean on April 25, 2014, 09:33:39 PM
sweet vid!
bout that old school sh*t! 
confidence is knowing you can kick ass, wisdom is knowing when an ass-kicking is justified
Title: Re: yet another reason to not escalate straight to deadly force if ccw were allowed
Post by: bubba808 on April 25, 2014, 09:37:01 PM
Aloha bubba808,

Like Hicarry astutely stated, there is no way that I can provide you with an "absolute" justification that is sure to resonate with you, so to try to do so would be foolhardy (and a waste of time) on my part.

I am content to simply say that it sounds like your mind is made up on this matter, and while I may not personally agree with everything you have said about this matter, I do share some of your concerns amd respect your point of view.   :shaka:

Mahalo and Out,
new guy
thanks bro.
Title: Re: yet another reason to not escalate straight to deadly force if ccw were allowed
Post by: kia_killer on April 25, 2014, 10:54:33 PM
how many active shooter scenarios have we had in hawaii? What Uesugi? you mean the active shooter with legal firearms that took out his co workers? Or you must mean Deedy? Where the shooter was a possibly drunk off duty out of state LEO who violated his duty by drinking and then shooting with a legal CCW? In both instances It was legal firearms and I think I It would be worse if others CCW would have intervened and exchanged more shots.
What does the legality of the weapon used in an active shooter scenario have to do with anything? This is about ccw and the ability to protect yourself or others from imminent danger. I don't care if a gun is legal or not, if I'm in an active shooter scenario, I don't want to have to rely on "just rush em' ".  It's very evident that you are set in your ways, and when challenged you just dig deeper looking for ANY excuse, valid or not to justify yourself. The simple question is, would you let yourself or loved one become a victim because of your unsubstantiated fear of ccw holders? Secondly, if YOU are willing to be a victim, what makes you think everyone else should have to be too?
Title: Re: yet another reason to not escalate straight to deadly force if ccw were allowed
Post by: Q on April 25, 2014, 11:22:35 PM
I didn't reply because Q is full of shit. It wasn't worth my time because he tries to cyber bully his way in the forum.

I gave up when the admins edited my responses in favor of Q.

In the end everyone has their own point of view. Q's logic is one of a glorified security guard that turned in his gun at the end of his shift. Now he's stuck walking around his house is his tighty whites with his holdter clipped to the elastic waist band. Troll that.

 :sleeping: :sleeping: :sleeping: :sleeping: :sleeping:

Still waiting on those Hot-A's, cook.

While you are making my eggs, you can continue to elaborate about your top secret police agency that you work for, and how you know so much more about law enforcement or CCW even though you refuse to validate what agency that really is.
Title: Re: yet another reason to not escalate straight to deadly force if ccw were allowed
Post by: HiCarry on April 25, 2014, 11:56:56 PM
this is the most meaningful response in this whole thread. I can accept this answer, and fully understand it.  it isn't pretty, but its the truth.  thanks HiCarry

The need to protect yourself and your loved ones isn't pretty, but it is, again IMHO, a necessity.  As I have said at every single class I teach, "If your knowledge of guns and self defense comes from movies or television, you're wrong." Too many people who don't know the truth glamorize and/or romanticize these types of events, fueling fantasies of being the hero and such. But reality dictates that you look pragmatically at a potential threat and devise a workable solution. For some, the solution is to carry a gun. If you choose this path, you must be willing to take a life. Not in the sterile movie manner where a single, well placed shot to the knee incapacitates the bad guys, who conveniently drops their gun rather than attempting to shoot back at you. Nor the action/adventure model where a shotgun blasts the bad guy off his feet and 10 feet backwards while somehow magically not splattering his thoracic contents about the room. Taking a life, even justifiably, will be difficult (and in case where a gun was used, probably messy). It will cause psychological problems and most likely fuel endless debates with yourself about whether you did the right thing. Watching someone die, knowing you were the cause, will indelibly ink the event in your mind forever, and it won't be a pretty scene. But what's the alternative? Standing by, helplessly watching someone injure, rape, or kill your loved one(s)?

And, in the same vein, too many people who don't know, demonize and vilify anyone who chooses to prepare for the unthinkable.  They fail to consider the truly evil and depraved mind of someone willing to injure, rape, or kill to achieve their goals. They insulate themselves from the stark reality that there really are very bad guys (and girls) out there that don't function on the same moral and ethical playing field "we" do. There are criminals that will kill kids for their new sneakers, men that will abduct and rape women and children solely for their own twisted pleasures, and some that would think nothing of killing you for the ATM withdrawal you just made. If you want to believe that the pistol under your robe is there to hold off, yet not kill, your attacker until the good lord arrives, go ahead. It just shows again how little you are willing to open your mind and stray from your preconceived notions.

If you accept that you may need to use your gun for self defense, believing you can do so without the possibility of killing someone, you're using, at best, misguided misinformation, and at worse, magical thinking.

You continue to believe that Hawaii doesn't need CCW because it isn't a particularly violent or crime ridden place. You try to claim that armed citizens mean innocent bystanders will get shoot with an alarming frequency, but in no other state has this occurred. You fear that the otherwise good people of Hawaii will, once legally armed, be unable to control themselves and initiate gunfights over trivial matters, but again experience in other states just doesn't substantiate these fears. You bring up these canards again and again, but they are baseless and just don't happen in other states so your concerns, based on all empirical evidence are unfounded.

Again, it is not the odds of something happening to me or my loved ones that matters, it is the significance if it does....

Title: Re: yet another reason to not escalate straight to deadly force if ccw were allowed
Post by: HiCarry on April 26, 2014, 12:04:30 AM
how many active shooter scenarios have we had in hawaii? What Uesugi? you mean the active shooter with legal firearms that took out his co workers? Or you must mean Deedy? Where the shooter was a possibly drunk off duty out of state LEO who violated his duty by drinking and then shooting with a legal CCW? In both instances It was legal firearms and I think I It would be worse if others CCW would have intervened and exchanged more shots.
Research has shown that a large number of active shooter events are stopped by citizens, and a significant number of those were armed citizens. I won't search for all the relevant info for you, but I'll start it for you...

http://backwoodshome.com/blogs/MassadAyoob/2009/04/24/among-the-cops-and-their-instructors/ (http://backwoodshome.com/blogs/MassadAyoob/2009/04/24/among-the-cops-and-their-instructors/)

Title: Re: yet another reason to not escalate straight to deadly force if ccw were allowed
Post by: mauidog on April 26, 2014, 01:39:51 AM
how many active shooter scenarios have we had in hawaii? What Uesugi? you mean the active shooter with legal firearms that took out his co workers? Or you must mean Deedy? Where the shooter was a possibly drunk off duty out of state LEO who violated his duty by drinking and then shooting with a legal CCW? In both instances It was legal firearms and I think I It would be worse if others CCW would have intervened and exchanged more shots.

See, you keep saying "How many of [whatever]" has happened?  it's not enough to justify being prepared."

How many home invasions have to happen before it's enough to make you think about self defense?  About alarms in your home?  About buying a big dog?  What's that magic number of events that convinces you that maybe there is a reason to take a proactive approach and be responsible for your own protection?

How many times do people in Hawaii have to be stabbed before you think self protection is needed?

How many muggings in Waikiki (which are way under-reported to the public) are sufficient to justify being able to defend yourself?


When it happens to YOU, it only takes one!!
Title: Re: yet another reason to not escalate straight to deadly force if ccw were allowed
Post by: punaperson on April 26, 2014, 06:42:19 AM
What does the legality of the weapon used in an active shooter scenario have to do with anything? This is about ccw and the ability to protect yourself or others from imminent danger. I don't care if a gun is legal or not, if I'm in an active shooter scenario, I don't want to have to rely on "just rush em' ".  It's very evident that you are set in your ways, and when challenged you just dig deeper looking for ANY excuse, valid or not to justify yourself. The simple question is, would you let yourself or loved one become a victim because of your unsubstantiated fear of ccw holders? Secondly, if YOU are willing to be a victim, what makes you think everyone else should have to be too?
Excellent rejoinder to "bubba's" irrelevant issue. I see you making the same error I did in addressing "bubba"... asking "bubba" to be logically consistent and evaluate evidence using critical thinking skills. "bubba" presents an unending series of strawmen and red herrings and logical fallacies and outright avoidance of actually addressing the logical and factual errors "bubba" writes to the point one might be inclined to suspect "troll". If not a "troll", then just plain "sad".
Title: Re: yet another reason to not escalate straight to deadly force if ccw were allowed
Post by: 2aHawaii on April 26, 2014, 07:57:41 AM
Excellent rejoinder to "bubba's" irrelevant issue. I see you making the same error I did in addressing "bubba"... asking "bubba" to be logically consistent and evaluate evidence using critical thinking skills. "bubba" presents an unending series of strawmen and red herrings and logical fallacies and outright avoidance of actually addressing the logical and factual errors "bubba" writes to the point one might be inclined to suspect "troll". If not a "troll", then just plain "sad".

I agree and this thread has gone about as far as it's gonna go. For bubba it seems how much can we allow a right while constitutionally, it's how much should we limit a right.