2aHawaii

General Topics => Legal and Activism => Topic started by: bubba808 on April 29, 2014, 06:43:56 PM

Title: Montana shooting, possibly within rights but brutal
Post by: bubba808 on April 29, 2014, 06:43:56 PM
http://missoulian.com/news/local/suspect-in-big-sky-student-s-shooting-gets-death-threats/article_fdaccb9c-d005-11e3-a429-0019bb2963f4.html (http://missoulian.com/news/local/suspect-in-big-sky-student-s-shooting-gets-death-threats/article_fdaccb9c-d005-11e3-a429-0019bb2963f4.html)
what you think, justified?
Title: Re: Montana shooting, possibly within rights but brutal
Post by: ImKu on April 29, 2014, 08:09:09 PM
I don't know the laws of that state, but to answer your question, no I do not think it is justified.  If in fact he was baiting with the intent of killing someone, that goes without saying IMO.
Title: Re: Montana shooting, possibly within rights but brutal
Post by: dogman on April 29, 2014, 08:18:38 PM
If you get repeatedly burglarized because you leave your garage door partially open, you should close your garage door.>:( :(
Title: .
Post by: Q on April 29, 2014, 08:22:43 PM
.
Title: Re: Montana shooting, possibly within rights but brutal
Post by: HiCarry on April 29, 2014, 08:57:00 PM
We don't know all the facts, so it is difficult to draw any conclusions, yet.

IF the facts show that the homeowner had legitimate concerns for his life or safety, it leans toward a justifiable shooting.

IF the facts show the homeowner "baited" the kid into committing a crime, it leans toward an unjustifiable shooting.

Remember, the media, especially in self defense shootings are notoriously biased and not beyond "doctoring" the facts to achieve their goals....NBC's altering of the 911 tape in the Travon Martin reporting is a shining example.
Title: Montana shooting, possibly within rights but brutal
Post by: Jl808 on April 29, 2014, 09:03:48 PM
Crooks should realize that playing stupid games = winning stupid prizes.
Title: Re: Montana shooting, possibly within rights but brutal
Post by: Walena on April 29, 2014, 09:22:36 PM
We all know how the media can twist around a story just to make it interesting news.

Just my initial opinion, as I don't know all the details, and how much of was reported is true, and the exact laws there. I'm not even an attorney, so I could be way off on this.

If they baited the garage to lure the thieves in and shoot them, then no.

If he armed himself and went outside to his garage to confront the person in the garage, then no.

He never I.D'd his target before he began shooting, then no.

Was there mention of any call to 911 before him going outside to the garage, because more than likely the operator would have advised him to stay inside.
Title: Re: Montana shooting, possibly within rights but brutal
Post by: dogman on April 29, 2014, 09:32:43 PM
I don't get why people say 'he should have closed the door', when it is already against the law for people to enter and individual's home or property uninvited. That is called trespassing, whether the door is open or not, so that kid had no reason to be in his garage for whatever reason.
If someone kept breaking the lock on my front door and burglarizing my home, I would get a better lock. There's nothing wrong with preventative maintenance. Unfortunately there are people who do things even though it's against the law. If the kid was stealing from the guy, maybe he got what he deserves, maybe not.
Title: .
Post by: Q on April 29, 2014, 09:40:39 PM
.
Title: Re: Montana shooting, possibly within rights but brutal
Post by: Pizzo on April 30, 2014, 06:33:38 AM
I can't speak on wether this was a "justifiable" shooting or not, there is still a lot of missing, and possibly misleading, information.

However, being born and raised in Montana (Libby, Flathead lake area and Kalispell) I can tell you that you DO NOT go onto private property or land without being invited. And you sure as hell DO NOT go into someones house, garage, barn or any other structure on said private property without being invited or without an extremely good reason!!

Doing so will, and can, result in being shot. This is just how it was and how it is up there. It's old country with unwriten rules and old laws, it's a wild place with wild people. As a child we were always taught to protect yourself and your family at any cost and to NEVER go on property we had no place being on!

With that being said Montana also has a terrible and rampid meth and prescription drug abuse problem right now and home break ins, car break ins, vandalisms and robberies are at an all time high. This has caused many of it's residents to live on edge and to expect the worse when it comes to hearing bumps in the night.

Of course none of what I wrote validates any persons actions in shooting another human being. It does however shed some light on the history and current crimes that may affect a persons (homeowners) mental state and judgements leading to a shooting.

The real question of course is WHAT THE HELL IS AN EXCHANGE STUDENT DOING IN A STRANGERS GARAGE IN THE MIDDLE OF THE NIGHT?!  :wtf:
Title: Re: Montana shooting, possibly within rights but brutal
Post by: punaperson on April 30, 2014, 06:49:21 AM
The real question of course is WHAT THE HELL IS AN EXCHANGE STUDENT DOING IN A STRANGERS GARAGE IN THE MIDDLE OF THE NIGHT?!  :wtf:
This tragedy could have been avoided were it not for the insular ignorance of Americans re the cultural practices of other nations and peoples. It is well known that outside America, and especially in Germany where this student was from, entering a stranger's property and taking things from that property in the middle of the night is an accepted activity, and even encouraged as "fun". What is wrong with Americans? Papiere bitte. [/sarcasm]
Title: Re: Montana shooting, possibly within rights but brutal
Post by: mauidog on April 30, 2014, 08:04:37 AM
It's tough to form an educated opinion when all the facts are not reported or known.  There are, however, two undeniable facts:

1.  Diren Dede will never do anything wrong ever again, and

2.  *Kaarma's a bitch!

(Note for those too lazy to read the article:  the home owner's name is Markus Kaarma.   :thumbsup:)
Title: Re: Montana shooting, possibly within rights but brutal
Post by: kumaWRX on April 30, 2014, 08:32:30 AM
I can't speak on wether this was a "justifiable" shooting or not, there is still a lot of missing, and possibly misleading, information.

However, being born and raised in Montana (Libby, Flathead lake area and Kalispell) I can tell you that you DO NOT go onto private property or land without being invited. And you sure as hell DO NOT go into someones house, garage, barn or any other structure on said private property without being invited or without an extremely good reason!!

Doing so will, and can, result in being shot. This is just how it was and how it is up there. It's old country with unwriten rules and old laws, it's a wild place with wild people. As a child we were always taught to protect yourself and your family at any cost and to NEVER go on property we had no place being on!

With that being said Montana also has a terrible and rampid meth and prescription drug abuse problem right now and home break ins, car break ins, vandalisms and robberies are at an all time high. This has caused many of it's residents to live on edge and to expect the worse when it comes to hearing bumps in the night.

Very good info  :thumbsup:   That reminds me, I recently saw a documentary on drugs in Montana and how a lot of drug dealers and runners are moving into Big Sky country.  They're coming here because drugs sell for a lot more than most other places in this country because it's distance from Mexico and South America and because there's a lot less competition to fight with.  Also, Montana has some of highest amount of addicts per capita because a lot of them are trying to escape the boredom of the vast open spaces.  I believe I saw this on Nat Geo, very interesting.
Title: Re: Montana shooting, possibly within rights but brutal
Post by: causa mortis on April 30, 2014, 01:01:43 PM
It's real simple: if you don't want to risk bodily harm, then don't sneak onto private property and into someone's garage in the middle of the night. It's obvious this German kid wasn't out making door-to-door bible sales.
Title: Re: Montana shooting, possibly within rights but brutal
Post by: aieahound on April 30, 2014, 02:14:40 PM
Based on the facts in the article ( and I'm not saying those are the real facts or complete ) Looks kinda messed up.
Legal in Texas though.  :D

Appears the homeowner went around and entered through the open garage door, effectively trapping the kid.
Then fired off four shots into the darkness, which was reportedly pitch black.

It's real simple: if you don't want to risk bodily harm, then don't sneak onto private property and into someone's garage in the middle of the night. It's obvious this German kid wasn't out making door-to-door bible sales.

+1. I agree with that.
But this seems a little Wonky.

German kid was probably talked into it by the other no-good kid that ran.
Title: Re: Montana shooting, possibly within rights but brutal
Post by: HiCarry on April 30, 2014, 09:43:37 PM
If baiting someone to commit a crime is wrong, shouldn't that make officers pretending to be prostitues wrong? What about cops baiting people to hire them when they portray themselves as hitmen? Better still, when they bail pedophiles as underage girls/boys?

This kid, for whatever reason, was illegally in his house. The shooters true motives might be revealed, but in the end it boils down to  the fact that had this kid respected this mans property and privacy, this never would have happened.

I'm pretty sure they didn't have a 'free cookies, come on in!' Sign on their garage, so it doesn't matter if the garage was partially closed or all the way open; kid shouldn't have been there, and he paid the price, whether if it was excessive or not.

Hey, for what it's worth, I agree with you. If you don't want to get shot, don't go onto others folks property or try to steal their stuff. That being said, in many places it just isn't that black or white and shooting at someone ONLY because he's in your home (i.e. without a fear for your life or safety) could well land you in deep legal doo doo....

I suspect Montana has some pretty strong Castle Doctrine laws, maybe even a presumption of deadly intent if inside a residence uninvited. 
Title: Re: Montana shooting, possibly within rights but brutal
Post by: mauidog on April 30, 2014, 09:54:41 PM
Hey, for what it's worth, I agree with you. If you don't want to get shot, don't go onto others folks property or try to steal their stuff. That being said, in many places it just isn't that black or white and shooting at someone ONLY because he's in your home (i.e. without a fear for your life or safety) could well land you in deep legal doo doo....

I suspect Montana has some pretty strong Castle Doctrine laws, maybe even a presumption of deadly intent if inside a residence uninvited.

My opinion about someone breaking into a home is basically ... if they are there when the house is empty, it's a simple breaking and entering/burglary issue.  BUT, if there is someone home, then it's a home invasion. 

If someone is brazen enough to enter a home while it's occupied, they must also be prepared to do whatever is necessary to force the residents to submit.  That makes them a serious threat which justifies use of deadly force.
Title: Re: Montana shooting, possibly within rights but brutal
Post by: HiCarry on April 30, 2014, 11:29:25 PM
My opinion about someone breaking into a home is basically ... if they are there when the house is empty, it's a simple breaking and entering/burglary issue.  BUT, if there is someone home, then it's a home invasion. 

If someone is brazen enough to enter a home while it's occupied, they must also be prepared to do whatever is necessary to force the residents to submit.  That makes them a serious threat which justifies use of deadly force.

I don't disagree with your logic but again, it depends on where you are and the laws of that state. In New Jersey you must retreat from your own home, or at least attempt to. In other states, the mere presence of someone in your house uninvited presumes they are there with deadly intent so as to justify deadly force without further articulated fear for your life or safety.

You shoot someone in your house in NJ with out additional justification, you're going to jail for a long time. Same situation in a less restrictive (or, as I prefer to call them, "more enlightened") state, and you probably won't even go "downtown" for the evening.
Title: Re: Montana shooting, possibly within rights but brutal
Post by: SOLEsource684 on May 01, 2014, 12:16:09 AM
I don't disagree with your logic but again, it depends on where you are and the laws of that state. In New Jersey you must retreat from your own home, or at least attempt to. In other states, the mere presence of someone in your house uninvited presumes they are there with deadly intent so as to justify deadly force without further articulated fear for your life or safety.

You shoot someone in your house in NJ with out additional justification, you're going to jail for a long time. Same situation in a less restrictive (or, as I prefer to call them, "more enlightened") state, and you probably won't even go "downtown" for the evening.

It still baffles me why the victim should have to retreat from their own home when some SOB criminal decides to break in. That is a total :wtf: moment.
Title: Re: Montana shooting, possibly within rights but brutal
Post by: punaperson on May 01, 2014, 06:45:43 AM
It still baffles me why the victim should have to retreat from their own home when some SOB criminal decides to break in. That is a total :wtf: moment.
Yeah, it's a mystery alright. Somewhere, in whatever reasoning there might be, is some form of an assumption about criminals not acting out of choice, but the idea that "they can't help it" because they are merely the automaton product/result of a "difficult upbringing", and therefore, like the adjudicated insane, can't really be held responsible for their actions, therefore you may not legally harm them no matter what they are doing.

1. Of course there are likely hundreds if not thousands of people who grew up in identical or nearly identical conditions that do not commit criminal acts, and
2. A lot of these criminals are recidivists with extremely lengthy histories of repeating criminal acts over and over and over again, and yet the "criminal justice system" deems them worthy of being returned to society again and again and again so they may harm innocent people.

So yeah, you gotta retreat. And if you don't retreat, you gotta be really nice to them. Because they can't help it.

Remember though, if you respond to this criminal threat in a way that harms the criminal, regardless of your upbringing and the circumstances at hand, you will (in many jurisdictions including Hawaii) be treated as a criminal who clearly acted out of choice. Go figure.
Title: Re: Montana shooting, possibly within rights but brutal
Post by: Kingkeoni on May 01, 2014, 07:48:42 AM
German kid was probably talked into it by the other no-good kid that ran.

Allow me to be the first one to call bullshit on this.

Presuming that this kid from Germany was some saint, skipping home with a picnic basket is foolish.

We don't know his true intentions right now, and the only side of the story we have is the home owners.

Germany has its own fair share of crime as well.

While gun violence is significantly less, their burglaries and robberies are up with the highest per capita in the world.

http://www.nationmaster.com/country-info/compare/Germany/United-States/Crime (http://www.nationmaster.com/country-info/compare/Germany/United-States/Crime)
Title: Re: Montana shooting, possibly within rights but brutal
Post by: aieahound on May 01, 2014, 09:24:13 AM
I'm not saying the German kid was a saint. He was certainly up to no-good.

But it's interesting that the local kid runs like a bat out of hell (presumably) when the homeowner comes out and the German kid takes 2 shotgun blasts in the back of the pitch black garage.

German exchange student could have been the mastermind. Possible but not likely.

Still sounds like the homeowner trapped him by entering the garage from outside the garage door. ( unless it's a detached garage, but then there'd be no castle doctrine ) 

Title: Re: Montana shooting, possibly within rights but brutal
Post by: Jl808 on May 01, 2014, 11:11:33 AM
German kid would still be alive if he decided not to break into someone's house.
Title: Re: Montana shooting, possibly within rights but brutal
Post by: aieahound on May 01, 2014, 02:42:16 PM
I'm not defending the kid but this was no home invasion. Wasn't even a B&E.

Homeowner sounds like a Joe Biden gone awry. If you hear a noise, just run outside and fire 4 blasts into your pitch black garage.

And I understand we don't have all the facts.

But how do we know the local kid wasn't telling the German kid, "Don't worry just run in there and grab whatever the hell he was after. We do it all the time. I'll stand watch. "
German kid. "Yeah I want to fit in. Cool."

Homeowner comes out and local kid runs like hell, leaving German kid hung out to dry. 
Never thinking that homeowner would just start blowing off multiple shotgun rounds into the garage without ID'ing anything, much less the suspect. 
Title: Re: Montana shooting, possibly within rights but brutal
Post by: mauidog on May 01, 2014, 03:03:35 PM
I'm not defending the kid but this was no home invasion. Wasn't even a B&E.

Homeowner sounds like a Joe Biden gone awry. If you hear a noise, just run outside and fire 4 blasts into your pitch black garage.

And I understand we don't have all the facts.

But how do we know the local kid wasn't telling the German kid, "Don't worry just run in there and grab whatever the hell he was after. We do it all the time. I'll stand watch. "
German kid. "Yeah I want to fit in. Cool."

Homeowner comes out and local kid runs like hell, leaving German kid hung out to dry. 
Never thinking that homeowner would just start blowing off multiple shotgun rounds into the garage without ID'ing anything, much less the suspect.

The German "kid" was 17.  Same age as Trayvon Martin.

At 17, you can legally drive, join the military with parental consent, legally watch "R" rated movies, and on and on.  This kid was old enough to know right from wrong, and unless you know something you aren't telling us, he was just as likely to be the instigator.  Not sure if you've met many foreign exchange students, but the ones I remember were more willing to break a few rules to have fun because they had the "I'm not from here" excuse to use and get away with it.

The homeowner, Kaarma (still chuckle at that name's irony!  :D ) had been burglarized several times.  For all we know, this was the same burglar coming back for more goodies thinking it'll be just as easy as last time.

How do I know all that?  The same way you know what you're posting...

IMAGINATION!!

(http://i.imgur.com/X6F9iPP.gif) (http://imgur.com/X6F9iPP)
Title: Re: Montana shooting, possibly within rights but brutal
Post by: punaperson on May 01, 2014, 03:16:14 PM
I'm not defending the kid but this was no home invasion. Wasn't even a B&E.

Homeowner sounds like a Joe Biden gone awry. If you hear a noise, just run outside and fire 4 blasts into your pitch black garage.

And I understand we don't have all the facts.

But how do we know the local kid wasn't telling the German kid, "Don't worry just run in there and grab whatever the hell he was after. We do it all the time. I'll stand watch. "
German kid. "Yeah I want to fit in. Cool."

Homeowner comes out and local kid runs like hell, leaving German kid hung out to dry. 
Never thinking that homeowner would just start blowing off multiple shotgun rounds into the garage without ID'ing anything, much less the suspect.
Whatever the facts turn out to be about who may have induced or encouraged whom to do what for whatever reasons, the fact that does apparently remain is that someone went onto and into another person's private property, likely with the intent to take something that didn't belong to them. I suppose it is possible that they were sightseeing, but the previous two similar events in the same location were thefts... could have been a coincidence, right? Theft and trespassing are clearly a choice. Yes, I said it. A person freely chose to engage in criminal activity. Unless in the extremely unusual circumstance of acting solely out of the duress of lethal threats unless he would do as ordered (aka "Patty Hearst Syndrome"), this person chose to act as he did. Whether the actions that subsequently took place were moral or legal is another question entirely, but those questions would never have arisen had not the German student chosen to do what he did, commit a crime, initiating a chain of events.

Or, more succinctly, as JI808 put it:
German kid would still be alive if he decided not to break into someone's house.
Title: Re: Montana shooting, possibly within rights but brutal
Post by: aieahound on May 01, 2014, 03:35:52 PM
I agree I'm throwing crap in there that don't exist and a 17 year old is not a kid. Probably a comment that didn't need to be made and sidetracked the thread.
 :stopjack:

This was no home invasion. Wasn't even a B&E.

Homeowner still sounds like a Joe Biden gone awry. If you hear a noise, just run outside and fire 4 blasts into your pitch black garage.

Would you run outside, enter your garage from the outside and fire 4 blasts blind on a trapped thief you think might still be there ?
( Only if you live in Texas where it's legal.  At least I think it's legal in TX. I personally thought it would be legal in Montana also.  )

What happened?
Thought the guy was rustlin' my fishin' gear again, so I shot him dead.
Did you see him?
No, I didn't see him, but I feared for my life.
Why did you fear for your life ?
Cause I ran outside and had him trapped in my garage and couldn't see him cause I had no lights or flashlight.
Why didn't you take a flashlight ?
Cause I had a shotgun.
Did you call the police ?
Who needs the police, I had a shotgun. And he's not gonna be stealing from anyone else anymore.

Meanwhile, the guy is dead. Dead.

That's a serious thing we all need to think about.
What is worth killing someone over ?
Repeatedly ripping off your crap from your open garage ?

That's a whole 'nother conversation.
( and this is NOT a thou shalt not kill rant. There are definitely situations, IMO where we would all be justified. )

German kid would still be alive if he decided not to break into someone's house.
And I agree.
Title: Re: Montana shooting, possibly within rights but brutal
Post by: Walena on May 01, 2014, 06:08:52 PM
German kid would still be alive if he decided not to break into someone's house.

The German kid AND his partner know now that it's better to be alive.   ;D
Title: Re: Montana shooting, possibly within rights but brutal
Post by: aieahound on May 01, 2014, 06:48:03 PM
The German kid AND his partner know now that it's better to be alive.   ;D

No offense to anyone, but this a little bit nuts.
And there's a few comments on this thread that mirror this sentiment.

Folks would be willing to kill a 17 year old ( or 20 year old or 22 year old or 40 year old or whatever ) to send a message to the neighborhood youth/young men/whatever you want to call them not to take your crap out of your open garage ? ( If it was legal. )

Personally, I'm not getting it.

The one kid doesn't know any better because he's dead.  Dead.

You play stupid games you get stupid prizes. I get that.
But there's a responsibility that comes with owning a firearm. ( Like not firing 4 shotgun rounds blindly into your garage. )
We have the ability to deal in Death. That's a huge responsibility which, I'm sure, most of us take seriously.

They come in my house where I'm with my wife and kids. Different story. No problem with it.
They do something life threatening outside my house to someone else and I have access to my firearm, no problem with it. ( wish we could conceal carry and our laws condoned it. Would probably (hopefully) take action regardless. )
Title: Re: Montana shooting, possibly within rights but brutal
Post by: Newb on May 01, 2014, 07:07:15 PM
I have watched this forum for quite some time as I am military and hope to eventually attain a concealed carry permit to protect myself and family. I do not post as I prefer to quietly observe and not get drawn into the internet arguments that almost always ensue.

With that being said, I honestly feel that many of the comments I read in this forum and especially in these types of threads are just giving the PD and lawmakers ammo against the cause we all stand for. Take a moment and read through some of the comments posted here. Do any of you honestly believe that based on the info presented, a person of any age should be dead? For the contents of a garage that the owner left open after being robbed twice already, he has killed another human being.

Do you really thing lawmakers and PD are in a hurry to allow that type of street justice to occur in their state? They watch these type forums and get the opinion that we are all waiting for a CCW so we can kill everyone who wrongs us in any way. And some of the comments here say just that.

I am not trying to point fingers. I am merely saying let's think about the impact of the statements we make. 
Title: Re: Montana shooting, possibly within rights but brutal
Post by: bubba808 on May 01, 2014, 07:55:29 PM
No offense to anyone, but this a little bit nuts.
And there's a few comments on this thread that mirror this sentiment.

Folks would be willing to kill a 17 year old ( or 20 year old or 22 year old or 40 year old or whatever ) to send a message to the neighborhood youth/young men/whatever you want to call them not to take your crap out of your open garage ? ( If it was legal. )

Personally, I'm not getting it.

The one kid doesn't know any better because he's dead.  Dead.

You play stupid games you get stupid prizes. I get that.
But there's a responsibility that comes with owning a firearm. ( Like not firing 4 shotgun rounds blindly into your garage. )
We have the ability to deal in Death. That's a huge responsibility which, I'm sure, most of us take seriously.

They come in my house where I'm with my wife and kids. Different story. No problem with it.
They do something life threatening outside my house to someone else and I have access to my firearm, no problem with it. ( wish we could conceal carry and our laws condoned it. Would probably (hopefully) take action regardless. )
:thumbsup:
I have watched this forum for quite some time as I am military and hope to eventually attain a concealed carry permit to protect myself and family. I do not post as I prefer to quietly observe and not get drawn into the internet arguments that almost always ensue.

With that being said, I honestly feel that many of the comments I read in this forum and especially in these types of threads are just giving the PD and lawmakers ammo against the cause we all stand for. Take a moment and read through some of the comments posted here. Do any of you honestly believe that based on the info presented, a person of any age should be dead? For the contents of a garage that the owner left open after being robbed twice already, he has killed another human being.

Do you really thing lawmakers and PD are in a hurry to allow that type of street justice to occur in their state? They watch these type forums and get the opinion that we are all waiting for a CCW so we can kill everyone who wrongs us in any way. And some of the comments here say just that.

I am not trying to point fingers. I am merely saying let's think about the impact of the statements we make. 
:thumbsup:
Title: Montana shooting, possibly within rights but brutal
Post by: Jl808 on May 02, 2014, 06:18:40 AM
Here is another one in Minnesota.

The homeowner was convicted in court of premeditated murder.

The two teens had broken into another person's home just a day prior. They have also broken into the homeowner's house before. But the judge excluded the evidence as irrelevant.

The homeowner house's had been broken into before where weapons were stolen.  A neighbor testified that the homeowner appeared frightened after the first incident.

The homeowner is a retired US State Department employee that worked on "technical security issues" for US embassies.

http://www.foxnews.com/us/2014/04/29/minn-homeowner-convicted-premeditated-murder/?intcmp=latestnews
Title: Montana shooting, possibly within rights but brutal
Post by: Jl808 on May 02, 2014, 08:17:15 AM
For the record, I do not condone vigilante justice.  But I also do not condone burglars and thieves no matter what their age.

Everyone has a right to be secure in their own person / property and protected from illegal seizure. An open garage door is not an invitation to take someone's stuff.  Back then, folks don't need to lock the front doors of their homes.  When did people forget this???

But capital punishment for theft is kinda extreme. Unless they were threatening the lives of the occupants, the burglars should have been apprehended, and tried for their actions by a just jury and the law. The same goes for the 2 homeowners involved in the shooting.

I realize that hindsight and armchair quarterbacking is 20-20, what should these homeowners have done?
Title: Re: Montana shooting, possibly within rights but brutal
Post by: kia_killer on May 02, 2014, 08:48:46 AM
I have watched this forum for quite some time as I am military and hope to eventually attain a concealed carry permit to protect myself and family. I do not post as I prefer to quietly observe and not get drawn into the internet arguments that almost always ensue.

With that being said, I honestly feel that many of the comments I read in this forum and especially in these types of threads are just giving the PD and lawmakers ammo against the cause we all stand for. Take a moment and read through some of the comments posted here. Do any of you honestly believe that based on the info presented, a person of any age should be dead? For the contents of a garage that the owner left open after being robbed twice already, he has killed another human being.

Do you really thing lawmakers and PD are in a hurry to allow that type of street justice to occur in their state? They watch these type forums and get the opinion that we are all waiting for a CCW so we can kill everyone who wrongs us in any way. And some of the comments here say just that.

I am not trying to point fingers. I am merely saying let's think about the impact of the statements we make.

I don't see any posts validating killing the guy. I may have missed it. Given the limited and probably exaggerated details from the article, I wouldn't call this justified. My stance may or may not change when more accurate and comprehensive info is available. Without identifying the intruder, he couldn't of known for sure whether it was a threat or not. IF the article turns out to be accurate, then IMO Kaarma isn't a person I would want in my neighborhood. That being said, I like many members here, have little sympathy for criminals. The fact is, had he not committed the crime this would be a non issue. I don't think anyone here would say he needed to die though.
Title: Re: Montana shooting, possibly within rights but brutal
Post by: macsak on May 02, 2014, 08:52:38 AM
For the record, I do not condone vigilante justice.  But I also do not condone burglars and thieves no matter what their age.

Everyone has a right to be secure in their own person / property and protected from illegal seizure. An open garage door is not an invitation to take someone's stuff.  Back then, folks don't need to lock the front doors of their homes.  When did people forget this???

But capital punishment for theft is kinda extreme. Unless they were threatening the lives of the occupants, the burglars should have been apprehended, and tried for their actions by a just jury and the law. The same goes for the 2 homeowners involved in the shooting.

I realize that hindsight and armchair quarterbacking is 20-20, what should these homeowners have done?

the one point that people are missing so far is that if he did indeed circle around from the outside and fire into the garage, he was firing towards the house where his partner and child were
so not only did he not identify the threat, he also ignored what was beyond his target
 :grrr:

Title: Re: Montana shooting, possibly within rights but brutal
Post by: one2boost on May 02, 2014, 09:26:34 AM
All I have to say is, bummers someone had to die, life is not like GTA or whatever video game one could respawn and start that level over when one makes a wrong choice.

Another thing, the only positive lining I see, is I bet no one will ever break into this family's home ever again.
Title: Re: Montana shooting, possibly within rights but brutal
Post by: punaperson on May 02, 2014, 09:37:14 AM
the one point that people are missing so far is that if he did indeed circle around from the outside and fire into the garage, he was firing towards the house where his partner and child were
so not only did he not identify the threat, he also ignored what was beyond his target
 :grrr:
Do you have some information that lead you to believe that that was actually the direction of fire? I didn't see anything at all about that. But if he really hadn't identified his target it could have been his neighbor trying to get back his chainsaw the guy never returned after borrowing, or something. I'm pretty sure we could speculate approximately forever until all the facts come out in court after the prosecution and defense present all their evidence.

On the other hand:

http://www.foxcarolina.com/story/25373283/spartanburg-waffle-house-shooting-video-released-sparks-new-debate (http://www.foxcarolina.com/story/25373283/spartanburg-waffle-house-shooting-video-released-sparks-new-debate)

CCW holder kills gun-toting masked robber in Waffle House. Dante (now deceased) and Jawan (now convicted of armed robbery and sentenced to 30 years) are defended by Tamika (Dante's cousin) who, of course, says he was a good kid, never did anything wrong, never got in any trouble, liked to dance, etc. etc. etc., and that people should have to have more training before getting a CCW and that he didn't have to shoot. The trainer (former county deputy) who trained the shooter for his CCW says it was all legal and clearly self-defense. It's all on surveillance video. No charges filed against shooter.
Title: Re: Montana shooting, possibly within rights but brutal
Post by: punaperson on May 02, 2014, 09:39:40 AM
All I have to say is, bummers someone had to die, life is not like GTA or whatever video game one could respawn and start that level over when one makes a wrong choice.

Another thing, the only positive lining I see, is I bet no one will ever break into this family's home ever again.
I wouldn't be surprised if Mr. Kaarma is not in jail, and/or at the very least all firearms have likely been removed from the home. Criminals aren't as afraid of baseball bats... especially if the only person in the home is female with a child.
Title: Re: Montana shooting, possibly within rights but brutal
Post by: aieahound on May 02, 2014, 09:47:58 AM
All I have to say is, bummers someone had to die, life is not like GTA or whatever video game one could respawn and start that level over when one makes a wrong choice.

Another thing, the only positive lining I see, is I bet no one will ever break into this family's home ever again.
Actually they might if the husband/partner is locked up for 20 years. ( What Puna said, he beat me to the reply )

Do you have some information that lead you to believe that that was actually the direction of fire? I didn't see anything at all about that. But if he really hadn't identified his target it could have been his neighbor trying to get back his chainsaw the guy never returned after borrowing, or something. I'm pretty sure we could speculate approximately forever until all the facts come out in court after the prosecution and defense present all their evidence.

From article ( and I'm not saying the article is accurate but it's the info we have )

"Kaarma allegedly grabbed a shotgun and exited the front door to confront the intruder. He then entered the garage through the open door and fired his shotgun four times into the darkness."

"Pflager ( Kaarma's common law wife) allegedly told police that Kaarma said “hey, hey” before he loaded a shell into the gun’s chamber. She said Dede yelled “hey” or “wait” before the shotgun fired. The boy was dead on arrival at St. Patrick Hospital.

Kaarma told police after the incident he was afraid the intruder had a knife or a tool from the garage, but couldn’t be certain because it was pitch-black inside.

“He stated he thought he was going to die and that the guy would try to get out of the garage and described thinking he could act like a caged animal,” the affidavit stated."

Footnote: http://missoulian.com/news/local/suspect-in-big-sky-student-s-shooting-gets-death-threats/article_fdaccb9c-d005-11e3-a429-0019bb2963f4.html (http://missoulian.com/news/local/suspect-in-big-sky-student-s-shooting-gets-death-threats/article_fdaccb9c-d005-11e3-a429-0019bb2963f4.html)

On the other hand:

http://www.foxcarolina.com/story/25373283/spartanburg-waffle-house-shooting-video-released-sparks-new-debate (http://www.foxcarolina.com/story/25373283/spartanburg-waffle-house-shooting-video-released-sparks-new-debate)

CCW holder kills gun-toting masked robber in Waffle House. Dante (now deceased) and Jawan (now convicted of armed robbery and sentenced to 30 years) are defended by Tamika (Dante's cousin) who, of course, says he was a good kid, never did anything wrong, never got in any trouble, liked to dance, etc. etc. etc., and that people should have to have more training before getting a CCW and that he didn't have to shoot. The trainer (former county deputy) who trained the shooter for his CCW says it was all legal and clearly self-defense. It's all on surveillance video. No charges filed against shooter.

No one here ( well maybe couple guys, or one guy ) is against CCW and the good it can do. It's this particular incident we're talking about.
Title: Re: Montana shooting, possibly within rights but brutal
Post by: punaperson on May 02, 2014, 10:28:50 AM
No one here ( well maybe couple guys, or one guy ) is against CCW and the good it can do. It's this particular incident we're talking about.
I was just pointing out that even if law enforcement, the prosecutor's office, the certified CCW trainer, etc. all agree that it was justifiable homicide, SOMEONE (in this case cousin Tamika) is going to say it was wrong and no matter what a masked gun-wielding criminal was doing that the requirements for CCW ought to be raised to a higher threshold, or a de facto impossible threshold, such as we have here in Hawaii.
Title: Re: Montana shooting, possibly within rights but brutal
Post by: aieahound on May 02, 2014, 10:32:11 AM
Roger that Puna !

I see said the blind man.  :oops:
Title: Re: Montana shooting, possibly within rights but brutal
Post by: macsak on May 02, 2014, 10:37:08 AM

From article ( and I'm not saying the article is accurate but it's the info we have )

"Kaarma allegedly grabbed a shotgun and exited the front door to confront the intruder. He then entered the garage through the open door and fired his shotgun four times into the darkness."


right
firing into the darkness towards his house and family

he did not identify his target nor did he consider the background
Title: Re: Montana shooting, possibly within rights but brutal
Post by: aieahound on May 02, 2014, 10:40:26 AM
I realize that hindsight and armchair quarterbacking is 20-20, what should these homeowners have done?

Set up bear traps and maim the F'in  thief.  ;) ( at least put him through excruciating pain )

Again, not legal here in Hawaii though as we owe trespassers the same duty of warning and reasonable care as we owe invitees. 
We would have to put a sign, Warning - Bear Traps in Garage.
Title: Re: Montana shooting, possibly within rights but brutal
Post by: punaperson on May 02, 2014, 12:47:09 PM
right
firing into the darkness towards his house and family

he did not identify his target nor did he consider the background
Given the amount of information we have from the news media, I believe Mr. Kaarma erred (morally, legally, and tactically) in discharging his shotgun, but... If the garage was attached to the house, and the house was (for example) only to the left of the garage (not behind it), if he stood at the left side of the garage opening and fired (without identifying his target) to the center/right of the garage his family would not have been endangered... now the neighbors, that might be different...?

What are the chances that various common commercial shotgun loads (slug, different sizes of shot) would penetrate typical double wall construction (one side exterior paneling) with enough velocity to injure someone at what distance?

Title: Re: Montana shooting, possibly within rights but brutal
Post by: punaperson on May 02, 2014, 01:03:50 PM
Set up bear traps and maim the F'in  thief.  ;) ( at least put him through excruciating pain )

Again, not legal here in Hawaii though as we owe trespassers the same duty of warning and reasonable care as we owe invitees. 
We would have to put a sign, Warning - Bear Traps in Garage.
Even with signs here in Hawaii (and who knows where else) I'd wager that if someone entered, even unauthorized for the purpose of stealing your property, and was injured that 1. You'd be arrested or at least taken to a law enforcement location to be formally questioned, and/or 2. prosecuted for assault of some kind, and/or 3. civilly sued by the criminal (I know that happens frequently) for damages, medical costs, PTSD, etc.. It'd be best to just choose to live somewhere where there is no crime so you wouldn't be subject to such activity. You know, like the places Michael (17 body guards) Bloomberg and Shannon (gated community with private-security-patrol) Watts live. A couple million bucks for real estate and you're all set.
Title: Re: Montana shooting, possibly within rights but brutal
Post by: aieahound on May 02, 2014, 02:00:32 PM
I was saying it tongue in cheek.
Please, don't anyone set up bear traps in your garage.

It'd be best to just choose to live somewhere where there is no crime so you wouldn't be subject to such activity. You know, like the places Michael (17 body guards) Bloomberg and Shannon (gated community with private-security-patrol) Watts live. A couple million bucks for real estate and you're all set.

So should we be able to shoot 'em ? ( Since none of us have the couple million )
Correction, Kill 'em ?
( Since  you don't shoot to wound. At least I wouldn't cause you only shoot if the situation warrants it. Hence the great responsibility )
For stealing crap out of our garages ?

Whatever happened to rock salt ? ( That's what we feared as kids running through the cow pasture )
Oh yeah, non-lethal is also illegal here in Hawaii.  >:(   :wtf:  ( Wish I knew that when I was a kid )

P.S.
Slugs will blow a clean thumb size hole in a 2x2 target frame at 50 yards. Trust me I know. I have a dedicated shotgun frame which I need to duct tape.
I don't know what shot will do.
I'm hoping it was a detached garage.
Title: Re: Montana shooting, possibly within rights but brutal
Post by: Walena on May 02, 2014, 06:55:11 PM

P.S.
Slugs will blow a clean thumb size hole in a 2x2 target frame at 50 yards. Trust me I know. I have a dedicated shotgun frame which I need to duct tape.
I don't know what shot will do.
I'm hoping it was a detached garage.


I have done some informal testing on the effects of 12 ga. on certain building materials, such as a 4X4 post, some 1/2" drywall, and some T111 plywood.

All were shot at about 25 feet with a 590 shotgun.

#9 target load on T 111 plywood (if I recall the shot size): 1 shot did not penetrate. Wad barely stuck in it. Shot penetrated after the 6th round fired.

00 Buck: 1st round didn't penetrate. Wad stuck about 1/4 in. in the ply. 2nd round went through.

Patterns were about 10 inches at that distance.


.45Acp 230gr. JHP pretty much split the 4X4 x 24 inch post in half vertically with one shot. Shot with a 1911

Drywall was mess with all ammo.

Title: Re: Montana shooting, possibly within rights but brutal
Post by: punaperson on May 02, 2014, 08:03:08 PM

I have done some informal testing on the effects of 12 ga. on certain building materials, such as a 4X4 post, some 1/2" drywall, and some T111 plywood.

All were shot at about 25 feet with a 590 shotgun.

#9 target load on T 111 plywood (if I recall the shot size): 1 shot did not penetrate. Wad barely stuck in it. Shot penetrated after the 6th round fired.

00 Buck: 1st round didn't penetrate. Wad stuck about 1/4 in. in the ply. 2nd round went through.

Patterns were about 10 inches at that distance.


.45Acp 230gr. JHP pretty much split the 4X4 x 24 inch post in half vertically with one shot. Shot with a 1911

Drywall was mess with all ammo.
Thanks for sharing that info.  :shaka:
Title: Re: Montana shooting, possibly within rights but brutal
Post by: aieahound on May 03, 2014, 09:25:31 AM
Thanks for sharing that info.  :shaka:

Yup, Thanks Walena.

Good info from a first hand test.
Makes me feel better about my shotgun in my sub-urban environment.
Title: Re: Montana shooting, possibly within rights but brutal
Post by: Walena on May 03, 2014, 04:59:10 PM
No problem, guys. I also did some tests using .38/357 & .45acp on some old cars,trucks, and an abandoned shed on my friend's ranch. But that's for another thread at another time.   :shaka:
Title: Re: Montana shooting, possibly within rights but brutal
Post by: xer 21 on May 06, 2014, 04:04:19 PM


I realize that hindsight and armchair quarterbacking is 20-20, what should these homeowners have done?

close the Goddamn door.  no one should have to fear that someone will steal their car radio if they leave the doors unlocked, but the fact of the matter is, you're a total dumbass if you get robbed because you left your car unlocked, and that's YOUR fault, even though you were wronged.

from the article, ignoring whether or not he "baited" them (which in my mind, makes it a premeditated exercise, if true) it says they got robbed only when their garage was open.  aka, the fix isnt to shoot someone, its to stop being so lazy and to just close the damn garage door when they arent in the garage.  it sucks that someone keeps robbing them, but they probably wouldnt be getting robbed if they had actually used their garage door for what its for, that is, to secure their garage.  and none of that requires anyone getting shot (or robbed, probably).

people suck.  that's a fact of life.  treat them like they suck and dont assume you can get away without locking your stuff up. 

that, and it really does sound like they were springing a trap, and that the shooter made his decision to shoot way in advance.  if the article's account is true, of course. 
Title: Re: Montana shooting, possibly within rights but brutal
Post by: mauidog on May 06, 2014, 06:18:49 PM
close the Goddamn door.  no one should have to fear that someone will steal their car radio if they leave the doors unlocked, but the fact of the matter is, you're a total dumbass if you get robbed because you left your car unlocked, and that's YOUR fault, even though you were wronged.

from the article, ignoring whether or not he "baited" them (which in my mind, makes it a premeditated exercise, if true) it says they got robbed only when their garage was open.  aka, the fix isnt to shoot someone, its to stop being so lazy and to just close the damn garage door when they arent in the garage.  it sucks that someone keeps robbing them, but they probably wouldnt be getting robbed if they had actually used their garage door for what its for, that is, to secure their garage.  and none of that requires anyone getting shot (or robbed, probably).

people suck.  that's a fact of life.  treat them like they suck and dont assume you can get away without locking your stuff up. 

that, and it really does sound like they were springing a trap, and that the shooter made his decision to shoot way in advance.  if the article's account is true, of course.

So, you basically put 100% of the blame on the VICTIM (homeowner) and 0% on the BURGLAR?  The way I read your post, we all need to live our lives in fear of "everybody else," while "everybody else" has no responsibility to follow the law.
Title: Re: Montana shooting, possibly within rights but brutal
Post by: xer 21 on May 06, 2014, 10:06:37 PM
So, you basically put 100% of the blame on the VICTIM (homeowner) and 0% on the BURGLAR?  The way I read your post, we all need to live our lives in fear of "everybody else," while "everybody else" has no responsibility to follow the law.
no, but i am saying that this didnt even need to happen if he just used some common sense.  he's like the slow kid who keeps touching the hot stove. 

if i got robbed once because i left the door open, you can be sure as hell i'd spend a little more time remembering to close the door before i planted a purse and a bunch of sensors hoping to be a tough guy and catch someone in the act.  even if its a justified shoot (its still his property and if he legitimately feared for his life, you cant tell him NOT to shoot.), that's still at the very least totally irresponsible at best if he indeed set this all up trying to catch a robber.  especially if its because he claimed it was for his kid's safety.  i dont know about you, but giving a potentially armed criminal easy access to my house doesnt exactly scream "safe" to me.

im not blaming the homeowner 100%.  but if he did set this up, i am blaming him for putting himself in a potentially dangerous situation when he could have possibly avoided it all by just closing his door.  really, just think about how stupid he is for repeatedly leaving the door open and then getting robbed, and then to immediately jump to the conclusion that instead of just closing the door, he's going to confront a potentially armed criminal?

Self defense isnt about shooting someone.  its about protecting yourself as best you can, and that doesnt always mean shooting someone.  sometimes it means closing your door. 

and for the record, all of this sounds like a total set up and doesnt sound particularly justified.  leaving belongings in an open garage with sensor's watching sounds a whole lot like setting a trap.

and these two passages from the article:

Quote
Pflager allegedly told police that Kaarma said “hey, hey” before he loaded a shell into the gun’s chamber. She said Dede yelled “hey” or “wait” before the shotgun fired. The boy was dead on arrival at St. Patrick Hospital.

and
Quote
Kaarma allegedly told his hair stylist several days before Sunday’s incident that he had been waiting up for three nights with his shotgun “to shoot some (expletive) kid.” The stylist spoke with authorities after hearing of the shooting.

dont exactly scream self defense.


im not saying that the kid wasn't in the wrong for clearly tresspassing, with who knows what intent.  but that doesnt mean that the homeowner is right.

by the way, you also might want to keep abreast of the issue, because things like these:
www.sacbee.com/2014/05/06/6383341/alleged-shooter-may-have-been.html]

make this seem even less justifiable.
[url=http://www.sacbee.com/2014/05/06/6383341/alleged-shooter-may-have-been.html]www.sacbee.com/2014/05/06/6383341/alleged-shooter-may-have-been.html (http://make this seem even less justifiable.
[url=http://www.sacbee.com/2014/05/06/6383341/alleged-shooter-may-have-been.html)[/url]
Title: Re: Montana shooting, possibly within rights but brutal
Post by: mauidog on May 06, 2014, 10:52:59 PM
no, but i am saying that this didnt even need to happen if he just used some common sense.  he's like the slow kid who keeps touching the hot stove. 

if i got robbed once because i left the door open, you can be sure as hell i'd spend a little more time remembering to close the door before i planted a purse and a bunch of sensors hoping to be a tough guy and catch someone in the act.  even if its a justified shoot (its still his property and if he legitimately feared for his life, you cant tell him NOT to shoot.), that's still at the very least totally irresponsible at best if he indeed set this all up trying to catch a robber.  especially if its because he claimed it was for his kid's safety.  i dont know about you, but giving a potentially armed criminal easy access to my house doesnt exactly scream "safe" to me.

im not blaming the homeowner 100%.  but if he did set this up, i am blaming him for putting himself in a potentially dangerous situation when he could have possibly avoided it all by just closing his door.  really, just think about how stupid he is for repeatedly leaving the door open and then getting robbed, and then to immediately jump to the conclusion that instead of just closing the door, he's going to confront a potentially armed criminal?

Self defense isnt about shooting someone.  its about protecting yourself as best you can, and that doesnt always mean shooting someone.  sometimes it means closing your door. 

and for the record, all of this sounds like a total set up and doesnt sound particularly justified.  leaving belongings in an open garage with sensor's watching sounds a whole lot like setting a trap.

and these two passages from the article:

and
dont exactly scream self defense.


im not saying that the kid wasn't in the wrong for clearly tresspassing, with who knows what intent.  but that doesnt mean that the homeowner is right.

by the way, you also might want to keep abreast of the issue, because things like these:
www.sacbee.com/2014/05/06/6383341/alleged-shooter-may-have-been.html]

make this seem even less justifiable.
[url=http://www.sacbee.com/2014/05/06/6383341/alleged-shooter-may-have-been.html]www.sacbee.com/2014/05/06/6383341/alleged-shooter-may-have-been.html (http://make this seem even less justifiable.
[url=http://www.sacbee.com/2014/05/06/6383341/alleged-shooter-may-have-been.html)[/url]

Yeah, I can see how you'd get that impression, since it's obvious the writer wants to tell a riveting story surrounding a possible murder.

There is a whole bunch of "might have beens" and "maybes" and "may have beens" and hearsay in that article.  What's missing are confessions and concrete evidence. 

May have been drunk or high on pot, might have had pot stolen before, may have been impaired by alcohol, dangerous drugs, other drugs, intoxicating substances or a combination of the above, at the time of the incident...

Lots of juicy speculation, but not much to actually prove anything one way or the other.  You could just have easily said he may NOT have been high, and he might NOT have had pot stolen before.  It's just not as interesting when you tell the story that way, is it?

Maybe it's just me, but I don't trust the media to report the facts in an unbiased manner anymore.  They all have an agenda and hope the next story they write will make their careers!
Title: Re: Montana shooting, possibly within rights but brutal
Post by: xer 21 on May 06, 2014, 11:16:03 PM
unless you believe that the writers (this is going around on many sites, it isnt just one writer reporting this)  are making stuff up completely, you cant possibly tell me that this doesnt look in any way suspicious. 

what isnt speculation though, is that the police requested to do drug testing and were granted permission to do so.  im sure they would do that if they had no reason to believe he might have been impaired, right?

by the way, there's a difference between hearsay and reporting.  hearsay is accusing someone.  those articles are just reporting new information being released.  they didnt just make those things up, those came from statements either given to them or released to them.  there's a lot the media can do to spin a story, but this isnt all spin.  all those "may have beens" you complain about are exactly how you avoid hearsay by not straight accusing someone in the article.

sure you may not have all the facts, but that doesnt mean you can just ignore everything being reported.  its one thing to be skeptical, but there's just too much here to just assume that the media is trying to spin a story for their own purposes. 
Quote
You could just have easily said he may NOT have been high, and he might NOT have had pot stolen before.  It's just not as interesting when you tell the story that way, is it?

also, that's just being dumb.  that's assuming he WAS high or drunk if you say that.  its honestly more incriminating to say it like that.  cmon.  that's a weak argument.
Title: Re: Montana shooting, possibly within rights but brutal
Post by: mauidog on May 07, 2014, 12:49:50 AM
unless you believe that the writers (this is going around on many sites, it isnt just one writer reporting this)  are making stuff up completely, you cant possibly tell me that this doesnt look in any way suspicious. 

what isnt speculation though, is that the police requested to do drug testing and were granted permission to do so.  im sure they would do that if they had no reason to believe he might have been impaired, right?

by the way, there's a difference between hearsay and reporting.  hearsay is accusing someone.  those articles are just reporting new information being released.  they didnt just make those things up, those came from statements either given to them or released to them.  there's a lot the media can do to spin a story, but this isnt all spin.  all those "may have beens" you complain about are exactly how you avoid hearsay by not straight accusing someone in the article.

sure you may not have all the facts, but that doesnt mean you can just ignore everything being reported.  its one thing to be skeptical, but there's just too much here to just assume that the media is trying to spin a story for their own purposes. 
also, that's just being dumb.  that's assuming he WAS high or drunk if you say that.  its honestly more incriminating to say it like that.  cmon.  that's a weak argument.

I think you got my point ("You could just have easily said he may NOT have been high").  Both statements are truthful, but to report something that hasn't been substantiated is prejudicial.  It might be more interesting, but insinuating there is a reason to do tests for intoxicants based on discovery of a jar with pot doesn't mean he was high that night.  Besides, according to the "legalize pot" proponents, pot makes you mellow, not violent  ;D  (which ignores the "impaired judgement" effect  :crazy: ).

To say other writers have reported the same stuff only means (1) they may have gotten the story from the AP wire, or (2) they all got their "facts" from the same source/s.  It by no means makes the story any more true to have lots of people repeat the same statements.  Look at how many media outlets reported "if you like your plan, you can keep it.  Period!"  Did that make it more true based on repetition?  Hardly!

I'm not arguing whether there is something suspicious or not about the way the shooting happened.  All I'm recommending is don't form opinions or take anything at face value.  Wait until the facts are substantiated.  Until then, it's all conjecture.  And police do things as a matter of procedure all the time.  There did not have to be any suspicion Kaarma was intoxicated to draw blood.  The police got a warrant for the blood, but how long after?  Was the jar in the garage the reason for the warrant?  If so, then his behavior after the shooting didn't indicate impairment enough to trigger the blood test on its own.  This is based solely on the report, so I have no timeline on when the warrant and blood test was done relative to the shooting.

When I said the story was full of hearsay, I wasn't referring to the reporter's words.  I meant the hairdresser who repeated what he heard Kaarma say, and the neighbor who repeated statements from the girl friend which the prosecutor relayed to the reporter.  Hearsay is when you say someone told you something.  There were no direct quotes from the hairdresser or neighbor, just the reporter's characterization based on the prosecution's information.  Had these been statements made to the reporter by Kaarma and the GF, then those would not be hearsay.

Hearsay does not have to be accusatory.  It merely has to be something being told second or third hand.

I think that's about all we can get out of the articles at the moment.  I won't be surprised if there's a trial, but a conviction will require more proof than "he left the door open", "there was pot in the garage (and maybe in his system)", and "a hairdresser said he heard Kaarma say he was going to shoot some kid." 

It's terrible a 17 year old lost his life for burglary, but it would also be terrible to send someone to jail with only a suspicion that the shooting was premeditated.  I assume the charges will include some form of homicide, which should require a finding of guilty beyond a reasonable doubt.  That's going to be very difficult without a confession.

Have a good night!   :shaka:
Title: Re: Montana shooting, possibly within rights but brutal
Post by: HiCarry on May 07, 2014, 10:29:26 PM
I was saying it tongue in cheek.
Please, don't anyone set up bear traps in your garage.

So should we be able to shoot 'em ? ( Since none of us have the couple million )
Correction, Kill 'em ?
( Since  you don't shoot to wound. At least I wouldn't cause you only shoot if the situation warrants it. Hence the great responsibility )
For stealing crap out of our garages ?

The concept of "don't shoot to wound" is not the same as "shoot to kill 'em." And one should be careful as to what one posts in regards to shooting someone to kill them. God forbid that you ever are forced into using your gun to defend yourself and do end up killing someone, your self defense claim could be in real jeopardy. Some over zealous prosecutor will comb these, and other boards, looking for just these types of statements to substantiate that you didn't really shoot to "stop the threat" but rather that you carried out your previously stated plan to kill the guy because that's what you said on some internet forum.

Whatever happened to rock salt ? ( That's what we feared as kids running through the cow pasture )
Oh yeah, non-lethal is also illegal here in Hawaii.  >:(   :wtf:  ( Wish I knew that when I was a kid )

Shoot someone with a shotgun loaded with rock salt and you will be charged with attempted murder. Raise a shotgun loaded with rock salt against someone with a gun and they can justifibly shoot you in self defense. And probably be found not guilty of a crime because he had no way to know the gun was "only" loaded rock salt.

P.S.
Slugs will blow a clean thumb size hole in a 2x2 target frame at 50 yards. Trust me I know. I have a dedicated shotgun frame which I need to duct tape.
I don't know what shot will do.
I'm hoping it was a detached garage.
Title: .
Post by: Q on May 08, 2014, 03:22:59 AM
.
Title: Re: Montana shooting, possibly within rights but brutal
Post by: bubba808 on May 08, 2014, 08:05:14 PM
So, you basically put 100% of the blame on the VICTIM (homeowner) and 0% on the BURGLAR?  The way I read your post, we all need to live our lives in fear of "everybody else," while "everybody else" has no responsibility to follow the law.
Just curious,
did the kid steal something?  How did you establish that he was a burglar?  What law are you referring to?
Title: Re: Montana shooting, possibly within rights but brutal
Post by: bubba808 on May 08, 2014, 08:17:23 PM
http://www.nydailynews.com/news/crime/drugs-factor-montana-garage-killing-cops-article-1.1782604 (http://www.nydailynews.com/news/crime/drugs-factor-montana-garage-killing-cops-article-1.1782604)
latest update
set to go to court May 12. Will be interesting to see how this develops.
Title: Re: Montana shooting, possibly within rights but brutal
Post by: mauidog on May 08, 2014, 10:00:38 PM
Just curious,
did the kid steal something?  How did you establish that he was a burglar?  What law are you referring to?

I guess you need some help, huh?

Let me Google that for you ...

http://lmgtfy.com/?q=burglary (http://lmgtfy.com/?q=burglary)
Title: .
Post by: Q on May 08, 2014, 10:41:57 PM
.
Title: Re: Montana shooting, possibly within rights but brutal
Post by: bubba808 on May 08, 2014, 10:55:49 PM
I guess you need some help, huh?

Let me Google that for you ...

http://lmgtfy.com/?q=burglary (http://lmgtfy.com/?q=burglary)

Burglary is a crime, the essence of which is illegal entry into a building for the purposes of committing an offence. Usually that offence will be theft
exactly.. now read.... he entered, but what offence did he commit? Is there any proof that he stole or entered to steal?
Title: Re: Montana shooting, possibly within rights but brutal
Post by: Kingkeoni on May 08, 2014, 11:02:50 PM
Burglary is a crime, the essence of which is illegal entry into a building for the purposes of committing an offence. Usually that offence will be theft
exactly.. now read.... he entered, but what offence did he commit? Is there any proof that he stole or entered to steal?

Simply entering illegally is an offense in and of itself.
Title: Re: Montana shooting, possibly within rights but brutal
Post by: mauidog on May 08, 2014, 11:10:18 PM
Burglary is a crime, the essence of which is illegal entry into a building for the purposes of committing an offence. Usually that offence will be theft
exactly.. now read.... he entered, but what offence did he commit? Is there any proof that he stole or entered to steal?

I'm positive he wasn't there to witness for his Lord and Savior.  At least those people have the decency to knock on the front door before walking around the house looking for you!
Title: Re: Montana shooting, possibly within rights but brutal
Post by: bubba808 on May 08, 2014, 11:31:30 PM
Simply entering illegally is an offense in and of itself.
I agree, but simply entering does NOT constitute burglary like mauidog stated.
Title: .
Post by: Q on May 08, 2014, 11:37:11 PM
.
Title: Re: Montana shooting, possibly within rights but brutal
Post by: bubba808 on May 08, 2014, 11:39:31 PM
I'm positive he wasn't there to witness for his Lord and Savior.  At least those people have the decency to knock on the front door before walking around the house looking for you!

Oh Wat, now you know the layout of the house and assume the kid walked around the house to the garage in the back?

Just relax and let the truth come out before you call da shooter a victim and start claiming the kid was burglarizing the home.  Trespassing may have been a better term.
Title: Montana shooting, possibly within rights but brutal
Post by: Jl808 on May 08, 2014, 11:42:26 PM
:rofl:  You guys all crack me up.   :shaka:  Good night!  :sleeping:
Title: Re: Montana shooting, possibly within rights but brutal
Post by: mauidog on May 08, 2014, 11:49:48 PM
Oh Wat, now you know the layout of the house and assume the kid walked around the house to the garage in the back?

Just relax and let the truth come out before you call da shooter a victim and start claiming the kid was burglarizing the home.  Trespassing may have been a better term.

Who said he went around to the back?  You really need to practice reading comprehension.  Just because you THINK you know what I was thinking doesn't mean you're right!

You really have a tough time taking in new information, don't you? 

Or is it more like you refuse to be proven wrong?
Title: Re: Montana shooting, possibly within rights but brutal
Post by: bubba808 on May 08, 2014, 11:58:28 PM
Who said he went around to the back?  You really need to practice reading comprehension.  Just because you THINK you know what I was thinking doesn't mean you're right!

You really have a tough time taking in new information, don't you? 

Or is it more like you refuse to be proven wrong?

U said it.  We are talkin about this kid in the garage that got shot.  Then u said, at least religious people knock at the front before walking around the house looking for you". 
I'm positive he wasn't there to witness for his Lord and Savior.  At least those people have the decency to knock on the front doorbefore walking around the house looking for you!
I tired talk to you, LoL SMH.
Title: Re: Montana shooting, possibly within rights but brutal
Post by: mauidog on May 09, 2014, 12:00:49 AM
U said it.  We are talkin about this kid in the garage that got shot.  Then u said, at least religious people knock at the front before walking around the house looking for you".  I tired talk to you, LoL SMH.

You like to argue.  Just admit you have no point.  You're a troll, and this is what you do!   :crazy:
Title: Re: Montana shooting, possibly within rights but brutal
Post by: HiCarry on May 09, 2014, 01:22:44 AM
Burglary is a crime, the essence of which is illegal entry into a building for the purposes of committing an offence. Usually that offence will be theft
exactly.. now read.... he entered, but what offence did he commit? Is there any proof that he stole or entered to steal?

Montana's "Castle Doctrine" appears to have a "presumption" element that allows the use of force, up to deadly force, to prevent someone from illegally entering your home. I suspect that will come into play during any proceedings.

Here's the relevant Montana statue:

45-3-103. Use of force in defense of occupied structure. (1) A person is justified in the use of force or threat to use force against another when and to the extent that the person reasonably believes that the use of force is necessary to prevent or terminate the other person's unlawful entry into or attack upon an occupied structure.

     (2) A person justified in the use of force pursuant to subsection (1) is justified in the use of force likely to cause death or serious bodily harm only if:

     (a) the entry is made or attempted and the person reasonably believes that the force is necessary to prevent an assault upon the person or another then in the occupied structure; or

     (b) the person reasonably believes that the force is necessary to prevent the commission of a forcible felony in the occupied structure.
Title: Re: Montana shooting, possibly within rights but brutal
Post by: punaperson on May 09, 2014, 06:04:28 AM
Montana's "Castle Doctrine" appears to have a "presumption" element that allows the use of force, up to deadly force, to prevent someone from illegally entering your home. I suspect that will come into play during any proceedings.

Here's the relevant Montana statue:

45-3-103. Use of force in defense of occupied structure. (1) A person is justified in the use of force or threat to use force against another when and to the extent that the person reasonably believes that the use of force is necessary to prevent or terminate the other person's unlawful entry into or attack upon an occupied structure.

     (2) A person justified in the use of force pursuant to subsection (1) is justified in the use of force likely to cause death or serious bodily harm only if:

     (a) the entry is made or attempted and the person reasonably believes that the force is necessary to prevent an assault upon the person or another then in the occupied structure; or

     (b) the person reasonably believes that the force is necessary to prevent the commission of a forcible felony in the occupied structure.
Damn, HiCarry, what is it with you and quoting facts? You are operating under the mistaken assumption that the person you are addressing 1. is capable of understanding facts, and/or 2. is not a troll. I operate under the same delusion, because i don't want to believe that anyone is really that REMAINDER OF COMMENT DELETED.

As for the law and this case, I'm guessing the lawyers will be discussing 1. whether or not the garage (attached or not attached to house?) constituted an "occupied structure" if the owners were in the house proper, and 2. what constitutes a "reasonable belief". Do I have a "reasonable belief" that the person you are addressing is not amenable to reason?
Title: Re: Montana shooting, possibly within rights but brutal
Post by: HiCarry on May 09, 2014, 02:10:13 PM
Damn, HiCarry, what is it with you and quoting facts? You are operating under the mistaken assumption that the person you are addressing 1. is capable of understanding facts, and/or 2. is not a troll. I operate under the same delusion, because i don't want to believe that anyone is really that REMAINDER OF COMMENT DELETED.

As for the law and this case, I'm guessing the lawyers will be discussing 1. whether or not the garage (attached or not attached to house?) constituted an "occupied structure" if the owners were in the house proper, and 2. what constitutes a "reasonable belief". Do I have a "reasonable belief" that the person you are addressing is not amenable to reason?
Dude, I can't help myself...it's like a disease or something....
Title: Re: Montana shooting, possibly within rights but brutal
Post by: PeaShooter on May 09, 2014, 05:20:04 PM
http://www.nytimes.com/2014/05/08/us/missoula-montana-homeowner-shoots-teenager-in-garage.html?_r=0 (http://www.nytimes.com/2014/05/08/us/missoula-montana-homeowner-shoots-teenager-in-garage.html?_r=0)

I learned of this case through that article; it paints the teenager in a slightly less favorable light than some of the other articles, saying that he was indeed there to steal and cause trouble. Anyway, here are some other ideas I had on the matter.

Suppose that the evidence eventually bears out that this teenager was the person who had been repeatedly robbing this home over the previous two weeks, would that change the minds of any of the people here advocating for the teenager?

What if we were talking about a different case in which the homeowner's garage has no door? I know plenty of people without doors on their garages. I also know the frustration of law enforcement not doing anything when your yard is repeatedly trespassed onto and robbed weekly.

Isn't it reasonable to assume malice if a forced entry occurs at night? The surveillance camera video image of the teenager looks threatening enough to me. On the other hand, if the homeowner was able to see the intruder on surveillance, it may have been wiser to call the police instead of going out to confront him. That would be a good argument for the prosecution against the homeowner.
Title: Re: Montana shooting, possibly within rights but brutal
Post by: xer 21 on May 10, 2014, 02:24:33 PM
http://www.nytimes.com/2014/05/08/us/missoula-montana-homeowner-shoots-teenager-in-garage.html?_r=0 (http://www.nytimes.com/2014/05/08/us/missoula-montana-homeowner-shoots-teenager-in-garage.html?_r=0)

I learned of this case through that article; it paints the teenager in a slightly less favorable light than some of the other articles, saying that he was indeed there to steal and cause trouble. Anyway, here are some other ideas I had on the matter.

Suppose that the evidence eventually bears out that this teenager was the person who had been repeatedly robbing this home over the previous two weeks, would that change the minds of any of the people here advocating for the teenager?

What if we were talking about a different case in which the homeowner's garage has no door? I know plenty of people without doors on their garages. I also know the frustration of law enforcement not doing anything when your yard is repeatedly trespassed onto and robbed weekly.

Isn't it reasonable to assume malice if a forced entry occurs at night? The surveillance camera video image of the teenager looks threatening enough to me. On the other hand, if the homeowner was able to see the intruder on surveillance, it may have been wiser to call the police instead of going out to confront him. That would be a good argument for the prosecution against the homeowner.
the only thing that really matters here in my mind is he did indeed plan this out as a trap.  at that point, he's already decided he's going to shoot. and that might override castle doctrine, especially since that would clearly be premeditated, and (although this probably doesnt hold in court this way), actually WANTED someone to enter his property.  especially since the better solution would have been to just prevent your shit from getting stolen by simply keeping your damn garage door closed instead of attemtping to escalate it.

if anything paints this guy in a poor light, its his hair dresser or whatever saying the guy was waiting up all night to shoot someone, if that is true information.

and i really dont care what anyone else says.  after the first couple thefts, the clear next step is to start closing your damn garage door, not wait up all night to see if someone goes into your garage again waiting to shoot him.  lethal violence is the last step, not the first.  then, this guy probably wouldnt have had any more trouble with thefts, and the kid wouldnt be dead, and he wouldnt be in court.
Title: Re: Montana shooting, possibly within rights but brutal
Post by: mauidog on May 10, 2014, 08:16:49 PM
the only thing that really matters here in my mind is he did indeed plan this out as a trap.  at that point, he's already decided he's going to shoot. and that might override castle doctrine, especially since that would clearly be premeditated, and (although this probably doesnt hold in court this way), actually WANTED someone to enter his property.  especially since the better solution would have been to just prevent your shit from getting stolen by simply keeping your damn garage door closed instead of attemtping to escalate it.

if anything paints this guy in a poor light, its his hair dresser or whatever saying the guy was waiting up all night to shoot someone, if that is true information.

and i really dont care what anyone else says.  after the first couple thefts, the clear next step is to start closing your damn garage door, not wait up all night to see if someone goes into your garage again waiting to shoot him.  lethal violence is the last step, not the first.  then, this guy probably wouldnt have had any more trouble with thefts, and the kid wouldnt be dead, and he wouldnt be in court.

Speaking for my own personal frame of mind, there is a fine line between deciding in advance you are going to shoot some unknown trespasser if you get the chance, and preparing yourself mentally to pull the trigger should you ever be in a situation that might require it.  What I've learned over time is, when facing a difficult challenge, you need to imagine yourself actually doing it.  The more you train, practice, and prepare yourself mentally, the less chance there is you'll hesitate.  It would be very easy for a prosecutor to twist preparation into premeditation. 

When it comes to reasonable doubt, however, I think it'll be difficult for the jury to split that hair without some concrete and damning evidence proving he intended to "shoot first and ask questions later."
Title: Re: Montana shooting, possibly within rights but brutal
Post by: aieahound on May 11, 2014, 11:15:57 AM

The concept of "don't shoot to wound" is not the same as "shoot to kill 'em." And one should be careful as to what one posts in regards to shooting someone to kill them. God forbid that you ever are forced into using your gun to defend yourself and do end up killing someone, your self defense claim could be in real jeopardy. Some over zealous prosecutor will comb these, and other boards, looking for just these types of statements to substantiate that you didn't really shoot to "stop the threat" but rather that you carried out your previously stated plan to kill the guy because that's what you said on some internet forum.

I value your opinions and advice HiCarry.

However, in my opinion on this one, if you're not justified in using deadly force, you better not pull out a gun.
Stop the threat. Of course we all hope the perp lives, it's a horrible thing to live with killing a person. But you're using deadly force to stop him.
And it better be justifiably deadly. Whether he dies or not.
Upon further questioning, hard to explain how you shot him center mass without acknowledging the chance of death was likely.
It's not shoot to kill, it's knowing the chance of death is likely when you fire that gun.

There's no premeditated plan in lawful self-defense shootings as far as I know. Only preparation.

 :stopjack:

I was only putting it in that context in my prior post because the young man was killed, not just shot.
Title: Re: Montana shooting, possibly within rights but brutal
Post by: mauidog on May 11, 2014, 12:27:13 PM
I value your opinions and advice HiCarry.

However, in my opinion on this one, if you're not justified in using deadly force, you better not pull out a gun.
Stop the threat. Of course we all hope the perp lives, it's a horrible thing to live with killing a person. But you're using deadly force to stop him.
And it better be justifiably deadly. Whether he dies or not.
Upon further questioning, hard to explain how you shot him center mass without acknowledging the chance of death was likely.
It's not shoot to kill, it's knowing the chance of death is likely when you fire that gun.

There's no premeditated plan in lawful self-defense shootings as far as I know. Only preparation.

 :stopjack:

I was only putting it in that context in my prior post because the young man was killed, not just shot.

It's up to everyone to know the laws and act in a way they understand is justified legally.  They must also reconcile with their own moral beliefs, which has been beaten to death on this forum a few times.

However, the law allows for the shooter the justification based on what they believed, not based on the stated or demonstrated intentions of the threat.

If a COP sees someone with a replica gun, his belief that the replica is a real gun justifies discharging his weapon. 

Reality being what it is, people like to second guess anyone's thought process when they kill another person.  The laws, however, give the benefit of the doubt to the shooter, what he believed at the time, and how high he deemed the threat being presented.

Debating whether shooting to kill is different than shooting to wound is irrelevant to what most people experience.  If you are in a situation that involves violence, and you are afraid you'll be severely injured or killed, you won't be Googling the HRS or calling an attorney to find out if pulling the trigger is justified. 

You'll do WHATEVER YOU HAVE TO DO to survive.  Either that, or you'll be unable to kill someone who intends to kill you, but at least it will be YOUR decision to make.  The gun control/anti-gun politicians and followers would rather make that decision for you in favor of the criminals.
Title: Re: Montana shooting, possibly within rights but brutal
Post by: PeaShooter on May 11, 2014, 02:38:32 PM
after the first couple thefts, the clear next step is to start closing your damn garage door, not wait up all night to see if someone goes into your garage again waiting to shoot him.

then, this guy probably wouldnt have had any more trouble with thefts, and the kid wouldnt be dead
After re-reading your posts in this thread, I think you have the facts of this case mixed up. All the linked articles say that the homeowner's home, not garage, had been broken into repeatedly in the preceding weeks. So even had the garage door been closed, this kid would probably have broken into the house next. For all we know, it's likely he was the thief who had been intruding into the house in the preceding weeks.

I also posed a common scenario in which the homeowner does not have a door on his garage, what then?
Title: .
Post by: Q on May 12, 2014, 03:04:52 AM
.
Title: Re: Montana shooting, possibly within rights but brutal
Post by: Jl808 on May 12, 2014, 04:23:20 AM
Agreed!

When I visit anyone's home, I always make it a point to stay outside the first barrier (gate, front door, fence, etc) I come across. 

Even if the first barrier only has a latch that I can open for myself, I would always wait for the person I'm visiting to acknowledge me and (1) either come out and meet me or (2) respond and ask me to come in.
Title: Re: Montana shooting, possibly within rights but brutal
Post by: xer 21 on May 12, 2014, 10:40:09 PM
After re-reading your posts in this thread, I think you have the facts of this case mixed up. All the linked articles say that the homeowner's home, not garage, had been broken into repeatedly in the preceding weeks. So even had the garage door been closed, this kid would probably have broken into the house next. For all we know, it's likely he was the thief who had been intruding into the house in the preceding weeks.

I also posed a common scenario in which the homeowner does not have a door on his garage, what then?

 the earlier articles mentioned that all previous thefts had occurred when they left their garage door open, and that he may have had pot stolen "from his garage".  i didnt get anything wrong.  if they changed their stements in more recent articles, fine.  but the articles from last week mentioned the garage, not the home.

but there's also this.  the guys who stole from him saying they stole the stuff from his garage or car.

 http://gazette.com/authorities-told-slain-student-looking-for-alcohol/article/feed/117786 (http://gazette.com/authorities-told-slain-student-looking-for-alcohol/article/feed/117786)

and the scenario without a garage door is valid.  sure.  but that isnt this scenario.  if you have a door, you can close it.  if you don't you can't, and its a different story.  but when you have it, and don't, that's just flat out irresponsible. 

sure, it would be nice if you could trust people with an open garage, but you cant.  so you close the door.  either he set them up, or he was being totally irresponsible.  again, this isnt about whether i think he was within his rights.  im just saying, he could have done a hell of a lot more to both protect his property AND his family without jumping straight to the conclusion that he needs to go confront someone with lethal force.  that middle missing step of just closing the door probably would have stopped him from getting robbed in the first place, since he has the luxury of a garage door, and probably would have stopped someone from getting killed.

and whether or not he really did fear for his life (which im not buying yet, but if he did, its within his rights to shoot), you have to admit its not exactly fair for the kid to get shot and killed because some dude had his weed stolen.  yes, he made a really dumb choice and paid for it, but you cannot tell me he deserved to die over this. 

i've said it before and i'll say it again.  self defense with lethal force is supposed to be the last option.  you're not supposed to be actively looking to kill someone.  this guy clearly skipped over a totally valid option and went straight to lethal force, and could very well have been looking forward to it too.  im not saying this applies to anyone here, or to any more than a very few people out there, but just as there's idiots everywhere who make large groups look bad, there are gun owners who tarnish OUR reputation and fantasize about vigilante justice or who hope that they'll one day get to defend themselves (which in itself isnt really true, because they're not really looking to defend themselves, but to kill).  all im saying is that this reminds me a bit of that Minnesota case where they guy was waiting for someone to break in.    and that this guy just might be one of those guys.

and if you want to hate on me cause "i'm siding with anti gun people" (which is the vibe im already getting here), well, no.  cmon guys, this isnt even a large national story.  there's barely a side worth picking if that debate were in play because the only stories that matter in that debate are the ones large enough to make a national impact.  you only found it because you care about gun owners and the legal issues surrounding them as it pertains to us.  i get it.  its cases like these which can make or break gun rights for us sometimes.  if this guy got convicted, it would be a small (very small, considering where he lives, but still) black eye on those who wish to defend themselves, and those things still count.  but i just think some people are a little too quick to side with the shooter.  the shooter isnt always right.  i mean, cmon guys, we had people here supporting the minnesota shooting. 
Title: Re: Montana shooting, possibly within rights but brutal
Post by: xer 21 on May 12, 2014, 10:43:23 PM
Speaking for my own personal frame of mind, there is a fine line between deciding in advance you are going to shoot some unknown trespasser if you get the chance, and preparing yourself mentally to pull the trigger should you ever be in a situation that might require it.  What I've learned over time is, when facing a difficult challenge, you need to imagine yourself actually doing it.  The more you train, practice, and prepare yourself mentally, the less chance there is you'll hesitate.  It would be very easy for a prosecutor to twist preparation into premeditation. 

When it comes to reasonable doubt, however, I think it'll be difficult for the jury to split that hair without some concrete and damning evidence proving he intended to "shoot first and ask questions later."
of course it's a fine line, and that's the issue here.

but if he really told his hairdresser he was going to shoot some kids, i have a feeling that that's going to come back to haunt him.

just remember folks, the charges didnt come out of nowhere.  they are pretty unique charges; the cops already have SOME suspicion.  im not saying they can prove anything, but they probably feel like they have SOMETHING.
Title: Re: Montana shooting, possibly within rights but brutal
Post by: PeaShooter on May 13, 2014, 01:29:33 PM
That new article has a lot of newer information than the old ones. Not surprisingly, both sides of the case are saying things that they think will help them in court. So as always it will be up to a jury in the end to decide whom to believe and what they think the facts are.

I don't really think it matters whether or not I think the teenager "deserved" to die, but for what it's worth, I do not think he deserved to die. Unless this teenager or his friends had also broken into this individual's house in the preceding weeks, in which case maybe he did deserve what he got.

We can also read between the lines of the latest article somewhat. How the heck did police suddenly find these two additional teens who claim to have burglarized the open garage and car in the preceding weeks? I'm just speculating, but probably they are the friends of the teenager who was shot. If so, that makes the claims of all the teenagers less credible in my eyes. As much as we find the behavior and claims of the homeowner to be odd in this case, the behavior and claims of the 4+ teenagers now involved in this case are odd as well.

Even if this guy did bait the teenagers in a minor sense, I can't say that I am completely against what he did. If I were robbed repeatedly and the police did not do anything about it, I might want to do the same. In an extreme case of baiting I would be worried, though. Like what if some maniac decided he wanted to kill people for fun in a legal manner by tricking innocent people onto his property, that would be scary.

Title: Montana shooting, possibly within rights but brutal
Post by: Newb on May 14, 2014, 05:01:18 AM
Sorry but if I am so worried about people stealing from my garage, I would start by closing the door. Then security systems, cameras or whatever else he had. And then, maybe, deadly force. And that's a big maybe.

And if I'm not mistaken, since the door was open, and he technically hasn't stolen anything yet as he is still on the property, isn't he only trespassing at that point?
Title: Re: Montana shooting, possibly within rights but brutal
Post by: mauidog on May 14, 2014, 07:34:24 AM
Sorry but if I am so worried about people stealing from my garage, I would start by closing the door. Then security systems, cameras or whatever else he had. And then, maybe, deadly force. And that's a big maybe.

And if I'm not mistaken, since the door was open, and he technically hasn't stolen anything yet as he is still on the property, isn't he only trespassing at that point?

See previous posts on definition of Burglary:

Burglary is a crime, the essence of which is illegal entry into a building for the purposes of committing an offense.

The burglar doesn't have to run outside holding a pillowcase with stolen property to prove intent.  The teen had no legitimate reason to be on that property, in that garage   He probably didn't even know the residents.

Based on that, his intent can be inferred to have been theft or some other crime.

Simply entering illegally is a burglary offense in and of itself.
Title: Re: Montana shooting, possibly within rights but brutal
Post by: HiCarry on May 14, 2014, 02:15:58 PM
Mens rea - As an element of criminal responsibility, a guilty mind; a guilty or wrongful purpose; a criminal intent. Guilty knowledge and wilfulness.

http://legal-dictionary.thefreedictionary.com/mens+rea (http://legal-dictionary.thefreedictionary.com/mens+rea)
Title: Re: Montana shooting, possibly within rights but brutal
Post by: xer 21 on May 14, 2014, 02:53:37 PM


Even if this guy did bait the teenagers in a minor sense, I can't say that I am completely against what he did. If I were robbed repeatedly and the police did not do anything about it, I might want to do the same. In an extreme case of baiting I would be worried, though. Like what if some maniac decided he wanted to kill people for fun in a legal manner by tricking innocent people onto his property, that would be scary.
im pretty sure most people, including you, would just not leave their doors open.
Title: Re: Montana shooting, possibly within rights but brutal
Post by: mauidog on May 14, 2014, 03:16:41 PM
im pretty sure most people, including you, would just not leave their doors open.

You really need to find another point to discuss.

Not everyone REMEMBERS to close and lock all the doors.  I know I've left my garage door open more than once after working outside, only to discover it open just before bedtime.  Also, my daughter has left the house on at least two occasions thinking I was home and left the front door wide open.  That in no way invites anyone to come in for any reason.

People make mistakes and leave keys in door knobs, keys in ignitions, car doors unlocked, back doors open, windows open ... none of this is relevant.

 :wacko:
Title: Re: Montana shooting, possibly within rights but brutal
Post by: xer 21 on May 14, 2014, 04:38:06 PM
You really need to find another point to discuss.

Not everyone REMEMBERS to close and lock all the doors.  I know I've left my garage door open more than once after working outside, only to discover it open just before bedtime.  Also, my daughter has left the house on at least two occasions thinking I was home and left the front door wide open.  That in no way invites anyone to come in for any reason.

People make mistakes and leave keys in door knobs, keys in ignitions, car doors unlocked, back doors open, windows open ... none of this is relevant.

 :wacko:
its absolutely relevant.
Title: Re: Montana shooting, possibly within rights but brutal
Post by: mauidog on May 14, 2014, 05:04:12 PM
its absolutely relevant.

Is not!
Title: Re: Montana shooting, possibly within rights but brutal
Post by: macsak on May 14, 2014, 05:15:58 PM
Is not!

duck season!
Title: Re: Montana shooting, possibly within rights but brutal
Post by: mauidog on May 14, 2014, 05:22:55 PM
duck season!

(http://i.imgur.com/PvEMCGE.jpg) (http://imgur.com/PvEMCGE)

 :popcorn:
Title: Re: Montana shooting, possibly within rights but brutal
Post by: PeaShooter on December 18, 2014, 02:32:34 PM
http://news.yahoo.com/deliberations-resume-exchange-student-killing-062400337.html (http://news.yahoo.com/deliberations-resume-exchange-student-killing-062400337.html)

So it appears the guy has been convicted. I don't really like the decision but oh well. I don't know all the facts, but as I said earlier I would personally be fine with someone who had baited the kid in, as long as it was not an extreme case (the killing of an innocent). If the kid had been repeatedly burglarizing properties prior to his death, then that would justify the end result in my mind, but other people probably don't see it that way.
Title: Re: Montana shooting, possibly within rights but brutal
Post by: eyeeatingfish on December 21, 2014, 09:13:38 AM
Crooks should realize that playing stupid games = winning stupid prizes.

I nominate this for comment of the year!
Title: Re: Montana shooting, possibly within rights but brutal
Post by: eyeeatingfish on December 21, 2014, 09:29:51 AM
My assessment:
-The garage door being open is a non issue. Sure he could have closed it but he still has an expectation that no one would come inside. What if the man only had a carport and not a garage door, would this man be not allowed to defend his property? Or what if he left the door open so the thief would return and then he tackled the thief and detained him till police arrived? That would be a legal action as well.
-The comments he allegedly made about waiting to shoot someone doesn't prove ill intent but certainly doesn't help. Obviously he had reason to be concerned for the safety of his property but his comments could be used to suggest that he didn't give the intruder a chance to surrender.

-The thing that I think hurts him the most is that he testified that he couldn't see because it was pitch black.  This man has to be able to justify why he pulled the trigger with only the information available to him up until that point. From what I can gather from this article alone he knew someone (or something) was in the garage but he couldn't see who and he couldn't tell if the person had a weapon. That alone does not justify lethal force.

What if the individual was a police officer checking for a suspect? '
What if the individual was a neighbor looking for a dog?
What if the individual was an elderly person with dimentia?
What if the individual was a 6 year old kid who ran away from home?
This man had good reason to be concerned but I do not think he had good reason to shoot. It does not appear that he can articulate a real threat by the person, he can only articulate that he knew a person was there. Based on just this article I think a manslaughter cahrge would be most appropriate.

After further reading it appears he was convicted and I would have to say from what I do know this appears appropriate.