Montana shooting, possibly within rights but brutal (Read 49445 times)

aieahound

Re: Montana shooting, possibly within rights but brutal
« Reply #40 on: May 02, 2014, 10:32:11 AM »
Roger that Puna !

I see said the blind man.  :oops:

macsak

Re: Montana shooting, possibly within rights but brutal
« Reply #41 on: May 02, 2014, 10:37:08 AM »

From article ( and I'm not saying the article is accurate but it's the info we have )

"Kaarma allegedly grabbed a shotgun and exited the front door to confront the intruder. He then entered the garage through the open door and fired his shotgun four times into the darkness."


right
firing into the darkness towards his house and family

he did not identify his target nor did he consider the background

aieahound

Re: Montana shooting, possibly within rights but brutal
« Reply #42 on: May 02, 2014, 10:40:26 AM »
I realize that hindsight and armchair quarterbacking is 20-20, what should these homeowners have done?

Set up bear traps and maim the F'in  thief.  ;) ( at least put him through excruciating pain )

Again, not legal here in Hawaii though as we owe trespassers the same duty of warning and reasonable care as we owe invitees. 
We would have to put a sign, Warning - Bear Traps in Garage.

punaperson

Re: Montana shooting, possibly within rights but brutal
« Reply #43 on: May 02, 2014, 12:47:09 PM »
right
firing into the darkness towards his house and family

he did not identify his target nor did he consider the background
Given the amount of information we have from the news media, I believe Mr. Kaarma erred (morally, legally, and tactically) in discharging his shotgun, but... If the garage was attached to the house, and the house was (for example) only to the left of the garage (not behind it), if he stood at the left side of the garage opening and fired (without identifying his target) to the center/right of the garage his family would not have been endangered... now the neighbors, that might be different...?

What are the chances that various common commercial shotgun loads (slug, different sizes of shot) would penetrate typical double wall construction (one side exterior paneling) with enough velocity to injure someone at what distance?

punaperson

Re: Montana shooting, possibly within rights but brutal
« Reply #44 on: May 02, 2014, 01:03:50 PM »
Set up bear traps and maim the F'in  thief.  ;) ( at least put him through excruciating pain )

Again, not legal here in Hawaii though as we owe trespassers the same duty of warning and reasonable care as we owe invitees. 
We would have to put a sign, Warning - Bear Traps in Garage.
Even with signs here in Hawaii (and who knows where else) I'd wager that if someone entered, even unauthorized for the purpose of stealing your property, and was injured that 1. You'd be arrested or at least taken to a law enforcement location to be formally questioned, and/or 2. prosecuted for assault of some kind, and/or 3. civilly sued by the criminal (I know that happens frequently) for damages, medical costs, PTSD, etc.. It'd be best to just choose to live somewhere where there is no crime so you wouldn't be subject to such activity. You know, like the places Michael (17 body guards) Bloomberg and Shannon (gated community with private-security-patrol) Watts live. A couple million bucks for real estate and you're all set.

aieahound

Re: Montana shooting, possibly within rights but brutal
« Reply #45 on: May 02, 2014, 02:00:32 PM »
I was saying it tongue in cheek.
Please, don't anyone set up bear traps in your garage.

It'd be best to just choose to live somewhere where there is no crime so you wouldn't be subject to such activity. You know, like the places Michael (17 body guards) Bloomberg and Shannon (gated community with private-security-patrol) Watts live. A couple million bucks for real estate and you're all set.

So should we be able to shoot 'em ? ( Since none of us have the couple million )
Correction, Kill 'em ?
( Since  you don't shoot to wound. At least I wouldn't cause you only shoot if the situation warrants it. Hence the great responsibility )
For stealing crap out of our garages ?

Whatever happened to rock salt ? ( That's what we feared as kids running through the cow pasture )
Oh yeah, non-lethal is also illegal here in Hawaii.  >:(   :wtf:  ( Wish I knew that when I was a kid )

P.S.
Slugs will blow a clean thumb size hole in a 2x2 target frame at 50 yards. Trust me I know. I have a dedicated shotgun frame which I need to duct tape.
I don't know what shot will do.
I'm hoping it was a detached garage.
« Last Edit: May 02, 2014, 02:25:25 PM by aieahound »

Walena

Re: Montana shooting, possibly within rights but brutal
« Reply #46 on: May 02, 2014, 06:55:11 PM »

P.S.
Slugs will blow a clean thumb size hole in a 2x2 target frame at 50 yards. Trust me I know. I have a dedicated shotgun frame which I need to duct tape.
I don't know what shot will do.
I'm hoping it was a detached garage.


I have done some informal testing on the effects of 12 ga. on certain building materials, such as a 4X4 post, some 1/2" drywall, and some T111 plywood.

All were shot at about 25 feet with a 590 shotgun.

#9 target load on T 111 plywood (if I recall the shot size): 1 shot did not penetrate. Wad barely stuck in it. Shot penetrated after the 6th round fired.

00 Buck: 1st round didn't penetrate. Wad stuck about 1/4 in. in the ply. 2nd round went through.

Patterns were about 10 inches at that distance.


.45Acp 230gr. JHP pretty much split the 4X4 x 24 inch post in half vertically with one shot. Shot with a 1911

Drywall was mess with all ammo.

punaperson

Re: Montana shooting, possibly within rights but brutal
« Reply #47 on: May 02, 2014, 08:03:08 PM »

I have done some informal testing on the effects of 12 ga. on certain building materials, such as a 4X4 post, some 1/2" drywall, and some T111 plywood.

All were shot at about 25 feet with a 590 shotgun.

#9 target load on T 111 plywood (if I recall the shot size): 1 shot did not penetrate. Wad barely stuck in it. Shot penetrated after the 6th round fired.

00 Buck: 1st round didn't penetrate. Wad stuck about 1/4 in. in the ply. 2nd round went through.

Patterns were about 10 inches at that distance.


.45Acp 230gr. JHP pretty much split the 4X4 x 24 inch post in half vertically with one shot. Shot with a 1911

Drywall was mess with all ammo.
Thanks for sharing that info.  :shaka:

aieahound

Re: Montana shooting, possibly within rights but brutal
« Reply #48 on: May 03, 2014, 09:25:31 AM »
Thanks for sharing that info.  :shaka:

Yup, Thanks Walena.

Good info from a first hand test.
Makes me feel better about my shotgun in my sub-urban environment.

Walena

Re: Montana shooting, possibly within rights but brutal
« Reply #49 on: May 03, 2014, 04:59:10 PM »
No problem, guys. I also did some tests using .38/357 & .45acp on some old cars,trucks, and an abandoned shed on my friend's ranch. But that's for another thread at another time.   :shaka:

xer 21

Re: Montana shooting, possibly within rights but brutal
« Reply #50 on: May 06, 2014, 04:04:19 PM »


I realize that hindsight and armchair quarterbacking is 20-20, what should these homeowners have done?

close the Goddamn door.  no one should have to fear that someone will steal their car radio if they leave the doors unlocked, but the fact of the matter is, you're a total dumbass if you get robbed because you left your car unlocked, and that's YOUR fault, even though you were wronged.

from the article, ignoring whether or not he "baited" them (which in my mind, makes it a premeditated exercise, if true) it says they got robbed only when their garage was open.  aka, the fix isnt to shoot someone, its to stop being so lazy and to just close the damn garage door when they arent in the garage.  it sucks that someone keeps robbing them, but they probably wouldnt be getting robbed if they had actually used their garage door for what its for, that is, to secure their garage.  and none of that requires anyone getting shot (or robbed, probably).

people suck.  that's a fact of life.  treat them like they suck and dont assume you can get away without locking your stuff up. 

that, and it really does sound like they were springing a trap, and that the shooter made his decision to shoot way in advance.  if the article's account is true, of course. 

mauidog

Re: Montana shooting, possibly within rights but brutal
« Reply #51 on: May 06, 2014, 06:18:49 PM »
close the Goddamn door.  no one should have to fear that someone will steal their car radio if they leave the doors unlocked, but the fact of the matter is, you're a total dumbass if you get robbed because you left your car unlocked, and that's YOUR fault, even though you were wronged.

from the article, ignoring whether or not he "baited" them (which in my mind, makes it a premeditated exercise, if true) it says they got robbed only when their garage was open.  aka, the fix isnt to shoot someone, its to stop being so lazy and to just close the damn garage door when they arent in the garage.  it sucks that someone keeps robbing them, but they probably wouldnt be getting robbed if they had actually used their garage door for what its for, that is, to secure their garage.  and none of that requires anyone getting shot (or robbed, probably).

people suck.  that's a fact of life.  treat them like they suck and dont assume you can get away without locking your stuff up. 

that, and it really does sound like they were springing a trap, and that the shooter made his decision to shoot way in advance.  if the article's account is true, of course.

So, you basically put 100% of the blame on the VICTIM (homeowner) and 0% on the BURGLAR?  The way I read your post, we all need to live our lives in fear of "everybody else," while "everybody else" has no responsibility to follow the law.
An unarmed man can only flee from evil, and evil is not overcome by fleeing from it.   -- Jeff Cooper

xer 21

Re: Montana shooting, possibly within rights but brutal
« Reply #52 on: May 06, 2014, 10:06:37 PM »
So, you basically put 100% of the blame on the VICTIM (homeowner) and 0% on the BURGLAR?  The way I read your post, we all need to live our lives in fear of "everybody else," while "everybody else" has no responsibility to follow the law.
no, but i am saying that this didnt even need to happen if he just used some common sense.  he's like the slow kid who keeps touching the hot stove. 

if i got robbed once because i left the door open, you can be sure as hell i'd spend a little more time remembering to close the door before i planted a purse and a bunch of sensors hoping to be a tough guy and catch someone in the act.  even if its a justified shoot (its still his property and if he legitimately feared for his life, you cant tell him NOT to shoot.), that's still at the very least totally irresponsible at best if he indeed set this all up trying to catch a robber.  especially if its because he claimed it was for his kid's safety.  i dont know about you, but giving a potentially armed criminal easy access to my house doesnt exactly scream "safe" to me.

im not blaming the homeowner 100%.  but if he did set this up, i am blaming him for putting himself in a potentially dangerous situation when he could have possibly avoided it all by just closing his door.  really, just think about how stupid he is for repeatedly leaving the door open and then getting robbed, and then to immediately jump to the conclusion that instead of just closing the door, he's going to confront a potentially armed criminal?

Self defense isnt about shooting someone.  its about protecting yourself as best you can, and that doesnt always mean shooting someone.  sometimes it means closing your door. 

and for the record, all of this sounds like a total set up and doesnt sound particularly justified.  leaving belongings in an open garage with sensor's watching sounds a whole lot like setting a trap.

and these two passages from the article:

Quote
Pflager allegedly told police that Kaarma said “hey, hey” before he loaded a shell into the gun’s chamber. She said Dede yelled “hey” or “wait” before the shotgun fired. The boy was dead on arrival at St. Patrick Hospital.

and
Quote
Kaarma allegedly told his hair stylist several days before Sunday’s incident that he had been waiting up for three nights with his shotgun “to shoot some (expletive) kid.” The stylist spoke with authorities after hearing of the shooting.

dont exactly scream self defense.


im not saying that the kid wasn't in the wrong for clearly tresspassing, with who knows what intent.  but that doesnt mean that the homeowner is right.

by the way, you also might want to keep abreast of the issue, because things like these:
www.sacbee.com/2014/05/06/6383341/alleged-shooter-may-have-been.html]

make this seem even less justifiable.
[url=http://www.sacbee.com/2014/05/06/6383341/alleged-shooter-may-have-been.html]www.sacbee.com/2014/05/06/6383341/alleged-shooter-may-have-been.html
[/url]

mauidog

Re: Montana shooting, possibly within rights but brutal
« Reply #53 on: May 06, 2014, 10:52:59 PM »
no, but i am saying that this didnt even need to happen if he just used some common sense.  he's like the slow kid who keeps touching the hot stove. 

if i got robbed once because i left the door open, you can be sure as hell i'd spend a little more time remembering to close the door before i planted a purse and a bunch of sensors hoping to be a tough guy and catch someone in the act.  even if its a justified shoot (its still his property and if he legitimately feared for his life, you cant tell him NOT to shoot.), that's still at the very least totally irresponsible at best if he indeed set this all up trying to catch a robber.  especially if its because he claimed it was for his kid's safety.  i dont know about you, but giving a potentially armed criminal easy access to my house doesnt exactly scream "safe" to me.

im not blaming the homeowner 100%.  but if he did set this up, i am blaming him for putting himself in a potentially dangerous situation when he could have possibly avoided it all by just closing his door.  really, just think about how stupid he is for repeatedly leaving the door open and then getting robbed, and then to immediately jump to the conclusion that instead of just closing the door, he's going to confront a potentially armed criminal?

Self defense isnt about shooting someone.  its about protecting yourself as best you can, and that doesnt always mean shooting someone.  sometimes it means closing your door. 

and for the record, all of this sounds like a total set up and doesnt sound particularly justified.  leaving belongings in an open garage with sensor's watching sounds a whole lot like setting a trap.

and these two passages from the article:

and
dont exactly scream self defense.


im not saying that the kid wasn't in the wrong for clearly tresspassing, with who knows what intent.  but that doesnt mean that the homeowner is right.

by the way, you also might want to keep abreast of the issue, because things like these:
www.sacbee.com/2014/05/06/6383341/alleged-shooter-may-have-been.html]

make this seem even less justifiable.
[url=http://www.sacbee.com/2014/05/06/6383341/alleged-shooter-may-have-been.html]www.sacbee.com/2014/05/06/6383341/alleged-shooter-may-have-been.html
[/url]

Yeah, I can see how you'd get that impression, since it's obvious the writer wants to tell a riveting story surrounding a possible murder.

There is a whole bunch of "might have beens" and "maybes" and "may have beens" and hearsay in that article.  What's missing are confessions and concrete evidence. 

May have been drunk or high on pot, might have had pot stolen before, may have been impaired by alcohol, dangerous drugs, other drugs, intoxicating substances or a combination of the above, at the time of the incident...

Lots of juicy speculation, but not much to actually prove anything one way or the other.  You could just have easily said he may NOT have been high, and he might NOT have had pot stolen before.  It's just not as interesting when you tell the story that way, is it?

Maybe it's just me, but I don't trust the media to report the facts in an unbiased manner anymore.  They all have an agenda and hope the next story they write will make their careers!
An unarmed man can only flee from evil, and evil is not overcome by fleeing from it.   -- Jeff Cooper

xer 21

Re: Montana shooting, possibly within rights but brutal
« Reply #54 on: May 06, 2014, 11:16:03 PM »
unless you believe that the writers (this is going around on many sites, it isnt just one writer reporting this)  are making stuff up completely, you cant possibly tell me that this doesnt look in any way suspicious. 

what isnt speculation though, is that the police requested to do drug testing and were granted permission to do so.  im sure they would do that if they had no reason to believe he might have been impaired, right?

by the way, there's a difference between hearsay and reporting.  hearsay is accusing someone.  those articles are just reporting new information being released.  they didnt just make those things up, those came from statements either given to them or released to them.  there's a lot the media can do to spin a story, but this isnt all spin.  all those "may have beens" you complain about are exactly how you avoid hearsay by not straight accusing someone in the article.

sure you may not have all the facts, but that doesnt mean you can just ignore everything being reported.  its one thing to be skeptical, but there's just too much here to just assume that the media is trying to spin a story for their own purposes. 
Quote
You could just have easily said he may NOT have been high, and he might NOT have had pot stolen before.  It's just not as interesting when you tell the story that way, is it?

also, that's just being dumb.  that's assuming he WAS high or drunk if you say that.  its honestly more incriminating to say it like that.  cmon.  that's a weak argument.

mauidog

Re: Montana shooting, possibly within rights but brutal
« Reply #55 on: May 07, 2014, 12:49:50 AM »
unless you believe that the writers (this is going around on many sites, it isnt just one writer reporting this)  are making stuff up completely, you cant possibly tell me that this doesnt look in any way suspicious. 

what isnt speculation though, is that the police requested to do drug testing and were granted permission to do so.  im sure they would do that if they had no reason to believe he might have been impaired, right?

by the way, there's a difference between hearsay and reporting.  hearsay is accusing someone.  those articles are just reporting new information being released.  they didnt just make those things up, those came from statements either given to them or released to them.  there's a lot the media can do to spin a story, but this isnt all spin.  all those "may have beens" you complain about are exactly how you avoid hearsay by not straight accusing someone in the article.

sure you may not have all the facts, but that doesnt mean you can just ignore everything being reported.  its one thing to be skeptical, but there's just too much here to just assume that the media is trying to spin a story for their own purposes. 
also, that's just being dumb.  that's assuming he WAS high or drunk if you say that.  its honestly more incriminating to say it like that.  cmon.  that's a weak argument.

I think you got my point ("You could just have easily said he may NOT have been high").  Both statements are truthful, but to report something that hasn't been substantiated is prejudicial.  It might be more interesting, but insinuating there is a reason to do tests for intoxicants based on discovery of a jar with pot doesn't mean he was high that night.  Besides, according to the "legalize pot" proponents, pot makes you mellow, not violent  ;D  (which ignores the "impaired judgement" effect  :crazy: ).

To say other writers have reported the same stuff only means (1) they may have gotten the story from the AP wire, or (2) they all got their "facts" from the same source/s.  It by no means makes the story any more true to have lots of people repeat the same statements.  Look at how many media outlets reported "if you like your plan, you can keep it.  Period!"  Did that make it more true based on repetition?  Hardly!

I'm not arguing whether there is something suspicious or not about the way the shooting happened.  All I'm recommending is don't form opinions or take anything at face value.  Wait until the facts are substantiated.  Until then, it's all conjecture.  And police do things as a matter of procedure all the time.  There did not have to be any suspicion Kaarma was intoxicated to draw blood.  The police got a warrant for the blood, but how long after?  Was the jar in the garage the reason for the warrant?  If so, then his behavior after the shooting didn't indicate impairment enough to trigger the blood test on its own.  This is based solely on the report, so I have no timeline on when the warrant and blood test was done relative to the shooting.

When I said the story was full of hearsay, I wasn't referring to the reporter's words.  I meant the hairdresser who repeated what he heard Kaarma say, and the neighbor who repeated statements from the girl friend which the prosecutor relayed to the reporter.  Hearsay is when you say someone told you something.  There were no direct quotes from the hairdresser or neighbor, just the reporter's characterization based on the prosecution's information.  Had these been statements made to the reporter by Kaarma and the GF, then those would not be hearsay.

Hearsay does not have to be accusatory.  It merely has to be something being told second or third hand.

I think that's about all we can get out of the articles at the moment.  I won't be surprised if there's a trial, but a conviction will require more proof than "he left the door open", "there was pot in the garage (and maybe in his system)", and "a hairdresser said he heard Kaarma say he was going to shoot some kid." 

It's terrible a 17 year old lost his life for burglary, but it would also be terrible to send someone to jail with only a suspicion that the shooting was premeditated.  I assume the charges will include some form of homicide, which should require a finding of guilty beyond a reasonable doubt.  That's going to be very difficult without a confession.

Have a good night!   :shaka:
An unarmed man can only flee from evil, and evil is not overcome by fleeing from it.   -- Jeff Cooper

HiCarry

Re: Montana shooting, possibly within rights but brutal
« Reply #56 on: May 07, 2014, 10:29:26 PM »
I was saying it tongue in cheek.
Please, don't anyone set up bear traps in your garage.

So should we be able to shoot 'em ? ( Since none of us have the couple million )
Correction, Kill 'em ?
( Since  you don't shoot to wound. At least I wouldn't cause you only shoot if the situation warrants it. Hence the great responsibility )
For stealing crap out of our garages ?

The concept of "don't shoot to wound" is not the same as "shoot to kill 'em." And one should be careful as to what one posts in regards to shooting someone to kill them. God forbid that you ever are forced into using your gun to defend yourself and do end up killing someone, your self defense claim could be in real jeopardy. Some over zealous prosecutor will comb these, and other boards, looking for just these types of statements to substantiate that you didn't really shoot to "stop the threat" but rather that you carried out your previously stated plan to kill the guy because that's what you said on some internet forum.

Whatever happened to rock salt ? ( That's what we feared as kids running through the cow pasture )
Oh yeah, non-lethal is also illegal here in Hawaii.  >:(   :wtf:  ( Wish I knew that when I was a kid )

Shoot someone with a shotgun loaded with rock salt and you will be charged with attempted murder. Raise a shotgun loaded with rock salt against someone with a gun and they can justifibly shoot you in self defense. And probably be found not guilty of a crime because he had no way to know the gun was "only" loaded rock salt.

P.S.
Slugs will blow a clean thumb size hole in a 2x2 target frame at 50 yards. Trust me I know. I have a dedicated shotgun frame which I need to duct tape.
I don't know what shot will do.
I'm hoping it was a detached garage.

Q

.
« Reply #57 on: May 08, 2014, 03:22:59 AM »
.
« Last Edit: December 14, 2016, 03:33:58 PM by Q »

bubba808

Re: Montana shooting, possibly within rights but brutal
« Reply #58 on: May 08, 2014, 08:05:14 PM »
So, you basically put 100% of the blame on the VICTIM (homeowner) and 0% on the BURGLAR?  The way I read your post, we all need to live our lives in fear of "everybody else," while "everybody else" has no responsibility to follow the law.
Just curious,
did the kid steal something?  How did you establish that he was a burglar?  What law are you referring to?

bubba808

Re: Montana shooting, possibly within rights but brutal
« Reply #59 on: May 08, 2014, 08:17:23 PM »
http://www.nydailynews.com/news/crime/drugs-factor-montana-garage-killing-cops-article-1.1782604
latest update
set to go to court May 12. Will be interesting to see how this develops.