Dammit, Bernie (liberal rant) (Read 87027 times)

edster48

Re: Dammit, Bernie (liberal rant)
« Reply #20 on: February 02, 2016, 05:37:18 AM »
I called the type of argument you used crazy and unintelligent. I think you have enough intelligence to be above that.

You cannot just lump all types of socialism in the same boat because there are different forms with significant differences. And just because one socialist system had a murderous dictator to do horrible things does not mean all socialism will have such an outcome. The logic is just plain flawed. If we apply your logic then we must conclude that our own political system is also bad because it had slavery, discrimination, etc etc.

Hitler being a genocidal maniac is something that existed independent of him being a socialist.

Since you seem to think things are so black and white then do you favor getting rid of any and all socialist systems in this country? No more free K-12 education. Perhaps you think that the police should be a private force where they only work for people who pay for protection? No public parks of libraries. Privatize the military while we are at it? I don't want full on socialism but I cannot deny that some of what makes this country so great are socialistic programs.

Really? Just one? So Lenin, Stalin, Mao, Pol Pot, Castro, and a host of others don't count?

If socialism is so great, why do people build boats out of trash and risk their lives to escape it?

There is no such thing as "free" public education, we all pay for it via our taxes. Granted, the more government has become involved in it the less we seem to get for our money. It has progressed from local to county to state to federal control with a corresponding fall in quality. Seems more like an indictment to me.

In short, public works do not a socialist system make. The military is necessary for the defense of the nation and is provided for in the Constitution. Welfare is not.

Socialist programs have nothing to do with what made this country great. Independence, persistence and the freedom to excel, or fail, on our own merits are what made this country great. Socialism, via government interference and regulations of that freedom are what is strangling us.

Seems pretty "black and white" to me.
Always be yourself.
Unless you can be a pirate.
Then always be a pirate.

eyeeatingfish

Re: Dammit, Bernie (liberal rant)
« Reply #21 on: February 03, 2016, 02:18:46 AM »
Really? Just one? So Lenin, Stalin, Mao, Pol Pot, Castro, and a host of others don't count?

If socialism is so great, why do people build boats out of trash and risk their lives to escape it?

There is no such thing as "free" public education, we all pay for it via our taxes. Granted, the more government has become involved in it the less we seem to get for our money. It has progressed from local to county to state to federal control with a corresponding fall in quality. Seems more like an indictment to me.

In short, public works do not a socialist system make. The military is necessary for the defense of the nation and is provided for in the Constitution. Welfare is not.

Socialist programs have nothing to do with what made this country great. Independence, persistence and the freedom to excel, or fail, on our own merits are what made this country great. Socialism, via government interference and regulations of that freedom are what is strangling us.

Seems pretty "black and white" to me.

I didn't say socialism is so great but you are attributing things to socialism that are not inherent to socialism. Dictators and genocide is not something unique to socialism, nor is it something you can prove is caused by socialism. Remember that correlation is not causation. Dictators and genocide can exist outside of socialist and communist governments.

But lets use your logic of multiple socialist leaders who did horrible things. Is democracy at fault for all the bad things in our own history?

I think that socialism is an inferior system to our system but there are some elements of socialism in our government that are part of what makes out country so good.

Sure we can split hairs, yes K-12 education is not free, it is subsidized, but that is beside the point. It is a socialist system. Are you against our subsidized k-12 education? Are you against a police force paid for and run by the government with taxes? These are programs that are essentially socialist in nature. If socialism is so bad and it is so black and white then to be consistent you must then be against all public services because they are socialistic.

Consider reading this. It explains how large the spectrum of socialism is. It is not so black and white as you suggest, nor is it as narrow as you seem to define it. 
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Socialism

Inspector

Re: Dammit, Bernie (liberal rant)
« Reply #22 on: February 03, 2016, 07:06:42 AM »
Sure we can split hairs, yes K-12 education is not free, it is subsidized, but that is beside the point. It is a socialist system. Are you against our subsidized k-12 education? Are you against a police force paid for and run by the government with taxes? These are programs that are essentially socialist in nature. If socialism is so bad and it is so black and white then to be consistent you must then be against all public services because they are socialistic.
I don't want to jump in on you two guy's disagreement here. I just want to point out something regarding what EEF said that I quoted above.

K-12 education has never been free. But it was also at one time far from being Socialistic in nature. It used to be that the Federal Government did not fund local education at all. It used to be funded 100% by local property taxes only. Part of the cost of owning property and living in certain areas was that any property taxes paid went towards local education and funding local government only. This was standard operating procedure back in the those times. And it still is funded that way but no longer exclusively. It seems that those who are greedy/corrupt and/or Democrat/Socialist in nature decided to start demanding the Federal Government to throw money at local education because teachers and the teachers unions were not making enough money. When the teachers started making more then the school districts starting demanding handouts. And so the whole thing has expanded/exploded. The fact that it is subsidized is NOT beside the point. It is very much the point here in your conversation. You are making arguments like it is the ONLY way it can be. And that is just not true. One can argue against Socialist subsidized education and police forces and not be against having those things. It is the Socialist Federal Government funding of those things that one can be against.

I for one am against subsidized K-12 education because the Federal Government requires any school that takes its Socialist handouts to teach Common Core which is common crap. Don't teach common core and the Socialist gravy train goes away. There are school districts now in other parts of the country that are rejecting the Socialist handouts and have stopped teaching that common core crap. Which IMHO is good for the local families and good for the country.

I just want to put out there that this doesn't have to be this way with all these Social programs. It can go back to way it was if we would just go back to limiting our government and making government smaller. And IMHO better. Okay, back to your discussion.  :stopjack:
SCIENCE THAT CAN’T BE QUESTIONED IS PROPAGANDA!!!

hvybarrels

Re: Dammit, Bernie (liberal rant)
« Reply #23 on: February 03, 2016, 10:24:30 PM »
http://www.cnbc.com/2015/03/11/companies-cash-in-on-common-core-despite-controversy.html

I used to work for one of those textbook companies until I learned what a scam it was, then I couldn't do my job with a clear conscience.

The issue is complicated because no system lives in a vacuum, and because "human nature" isn't so far separated from the animal kingdom as we'd like to think, there are those who will never quit trying to find a way to get their fingers on someone else's goodies. Central Governments can do a lot of wonderful amazing things, but at a certain point if they get too big they start acting like ATMs that connect to our bank accounts and begin handing out vast amounts of wealth to well-connected parasites who figure out how to bribe politicians.

The "-isms" are all vulnerable to the same problem. When we create large centralized structures that should theoretically work, someone always figures out how to screw them up. A better experiment would be 50 states making more of their own decisions, and if poor decisions are made in one segment then everybody else can observe instead of being dragged down along with them.

But the way it is now, every time I hear something about another massive federal program chances are any beneficial impacts it might have had were already diluted in committee and replaced with more ATM pin numbers for the well-connected.
You don't need a parachute to go skydiving. You need a parachute to go skydiving twice.

eyeeatingfish

Re: Dammit, Bernie (liberal rant)
« Reply #24 on: February 03, 2016, 11:54:09 PM »
I don't want to jump in on you two guy's disagreement here. I just want to point out something regarding what EEF said that I quoted above.

K-12 education has never been free. But it was also at one time far from being Socialistic in nature. It used to be that the Federal Government did not fund local education at all. It used to be funded 100% by local property taxes only. Part of the cost of owning property and living in certain areas was that any property taxes paid went towards local education and funding local government only. This was standard operating procedure back in the those times. And it still is funded that way but no longer exclusively. It seems that those who are greedy/corrupt and/or Democrat/Socialist in nature decided to start demanding the Federal Government to throw money at local education because teachers and the teachers unions were not making enough money. When the teachers started making more then the school districts starting demanding handouts. And so the whole thing has expanded/exploded. The fact that it is subsidized is NOT beside the point. It is very much the point here in your conversation. You are making arguments like it is the ONLY way it can be. And that is just not true. One can argue against Socialist subsidized education and police forces and not be against having those things. It is the Socialist Federal Government funding of those things that one can be against.

I for one am against subsidized K-12 education because the Federal Government requires any school that takes its Socialist handouts to teach Common Core which is common crap. Don't teach common core and the Socialist gravy train goes away. There are school districts now in other parts of the country that are rejecting the Socialist handouts and have stopped teaching that common core crap. Which IMHO is good for the local families and good for the country.

I just want to put out there that this doesn't have to be this way with all these Social programs. It can go back to way it was if we would just go back to limiting our government and making government smaller. And IMHO better. Okay, back to your discussion.  :stopjack:

Valid concerns of course, however i would contend that whether schools are funder and controlled at a state level or a federal level, there is still the element of socialism there. It just exists at a different level. The same problems from the federal government can exist within a state government as well. A federal government can screw up our schools and a state government can screw up our schools but I wouldn't say socialism is the cause. Bad leaders making bad decisions is the problem. The details for how the subsidization should occur are of course open for discussion so as to find the best system possible but painting socialism is evil just shuts out any discussion.

There are benefits to the federal government having its hands in schools but I feel the drawbacks outweighs the benefits.

I do think that we owe subsidized the K-12 education system credit for making us such a great country and if we completely resisted all elements of socialism that would mean getting rid of public police and public schools. I think that would be a huge mistake and because of that I don't like to paint socialism with such a narrow brush. I think that socialism as a main form of government is not preferable but I recognize there are valuable aspects of socialism that we can incorporate into our government. I think the best form of government takes the positive elements of various forms of government and incorporates it to a better system. Our government incorporated many features from other governments IIRC.

I favor some social programs but I thing we have way too many and some of them are not run well. For example I have been contemplating pushing my representative to pass a law that restricts food stamps for fresh fruits, veggies, and milk only. That way they won't starve to death but we aren't buying them cheetos and candy bars. But that is another topic, sorry I am getting off track.

Inspector

Re: Dammit, Bernie (liberal rant)
« Reply #25 on: February 04, 2016, 07:33:47 AM »
Valid concerns of course, however i would contend that whether schools are funder and controlled at a state level or a federal level, there is still the element of socialism there. It just exists at a different level. The same problems from the federal government can exist within a state government as well. A federal government can screw up our schools and a state government can screw up our schools but I wouldn't say socialism is the cause. Bad leaders making bad decisions is the problem. The details for how the subsidization should occur are of course open for discussion so as to find the best system possible but painting socialism is evil just shuts out any discussion.

There are benefits to the federal government having its hands in schools but I feel the drawbacks outweighs the benefits.

I do think that we owe subsidized the K-12 education system credit for making us such a great country and if we completely resisted all elements of socialism that would mean getting rid of public police and public schools. I think that would be a huge mistake and because of that I don't like to paint socialism with such a narrow brush. I think that socialism as a main form of government is not preferable but I recognize there are valuable aspects of socialism that we can incorporate into our government. I think the best form of government takes the positive elements of various forms of government and incorporates it to a better system. Our government incorporated many features from other governments IIRC.

I favor some social programs but I thing we have way too many and some of them are not run well. For example I have been contemplating pushing my representative to pass a law that restricts food stamps for fresh fruits, veggies, and milk only. That way they won't starve to death but we aren't buying them cheetos and candy bars. But that is another topic, sorry I am getting off track.
It is obvious you did not understand what I said. So let me clear up a couple of your misunderstandings. First of all state governments are NOT local governments. I was very specific to state local governments which are County and City governments. During the period of time in which I went to school (which is the period of time I was referring in my earlier post) and before my time our schools were NOT IN ANY WAY funded by state or federal governments. They were not run by state and/or federal government. At all. All education money was derived from local property taxes only usually from the county and if any special tax money brought in through the city (sometimes through payroll taxes). But in all cases there was NEVER any funding from outside the communities. This BTW was not all that long ago.

I'll give you even a more micro example. I was born and raised in Long Beach, CA. Long Beach was one of the larger and one of the richest cities in the U.S. when I was growing up. Long Beach has its own School District LBUSD. They get property tax money from the property taxes of Long Beach residents. LBUSD is it's own entity and got no money from any outside source. They got the taxes from the properties from within Long Beach. Los Angeles County was the same way. And Los Angeles City was the same way. All education was funded by local property taxes only. We had the PTA back then which meant something. The parents of the children attending the local schools actually had a say in how their children were taught. And what they wanted their children taught. The Feds and state had nothing to do with how our education system was run at all. It is different now that we accept money in exchange for giving up control over our education system. Once you give up control Socialism has taken over. Socialism is much more than just providing funding. It is the entity that gives the money taking control away from the entity taking the money. The Federal Department of Education was not even formed until 1979. What do you think was going on before that? The federal and state governments were totally hands off until the DOE was formed. IMHO that is WHY the DOE was formed. The Federal government controls what our children learn and how they are taught if the school district decides to take money from the DOE. The program is recently been changed and it is called Common Core. The parents and the PTA's are just empty shells because the parents no longer have a say as to how and what they want their kids to learn.

Now, take what you said here: "A federal government can screw up our schools and a state government can screw up our schools but I wouldn't say socialism is the cause. Bad leaders making bad decisions is the problem." Who do you think the bad leaders are? They are the Socialists.They think they are making the correct and best decisions because of their ideology/religion. They are the ones that expanded the programs to the point where they could not be sustained financially. And when the Feds come along with money in exchange for control, the leaders take it because it is the right thing to do, then Socialism grows and expands more. In order to understand how Socialism got started in this country you have to look back at how things were BEFORE there was Socialism in every corner of our society. You are not looking at this from the perspective that you should be. You should be looking back farther in time so you will understand what it was like prior to when we had Socialism creeping into our lives. And take my word for it, we are all much worse off because of it. So to take what you said that Socialism isn't the cause, you are wrong because it was the Socialist leaders who lead us into this making the bad decisions. Believe me when I tell you my parents almost took me out of public schools and home taught me because of the creeping Socialism in our school system. And now look at it.

You also said: "There are benefits to the federal government having its hands in schools but I feel the drawbacks outweighs the benefits. " I agree about the drawbacks. But I would like you to name 3 things that our kids benefit from by having the Federal Government control what and how they learn?

The big thing we both agree upon is that there are a few social programs that I agree with. And that they are not run well and waste more tax dollars than if control were put into private hands. Like you said, another conversation for another day.  :stopjack:

Even you said a federal government and state government can screw up our schools. And they have. That is why I wanted to point out that Socialism is not beside the point. It truly is the point. You try and make out the every school district in every county and in every state in the entire country made the same bad decision. But what you don't seem to realize is that those bad decisions were made by Socialists/Progressives/Enlightened people who became the leaders who made those "BAD" decisions. And who due to their ideology/religion wanted to make things better by giving up control in exchange for money. Which is corrupt. Which is Socialism.

SCIENCE THAT CAN’T BE QUESTIONED IS PROPAGANDA!!!

edster48

Re: Dammit, Bernie (liberal rant)
« Reply #26 on: February 04, 2016, 07:43:07 PM »
I didn't say socialism is so great but you are attributing things to socialism that are not inherent to socialism. Dictators and genocide is not something unique to socialism, nor is it something you can prove is caused by socialism. Remember that correlation is not causation. Dictators and genocide can exist outside of socialist and communist governments.

But lets use your logic of multiple socialist leaders who did horrible things. Is democracy at fault for all the bad things in our own history?

I think that socialism is an inferior system to our system but there are some elements of socialism in our government that are part of what makes out country so good.

Sure we can split hairs, yes K-12 education is not free, it is subsidized, but that is beside the point. It is a socialist system. Are you against our subsidized k-12 education? Are you against a police force paid for and run by the government with taxes? These are programs that are essentially socialist in nature. If socialism is so bad and it is so black and white then to be consistent you must then be against all public services because they are socialistic.

Consider reading this. It explains how large the spectrum of socialism is. It is not so black and white as you suggest, nor is it as narrow as you seem to define it. 
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Socialism


One has to try pretty hard to ignore the fact that more genocide has been committed in the name of socialism in the last 150 years than in the entire millennium preceding it's implementation. Socialism isn't the only system to suffer under despotic genocidal leaders, but it does seem to have a higher percentage than the others. It actually seems to breed them.

Is democracy at fault for the bad things that have happened in this country? Absolutely. It behaves like a drunken uncle at a 13 year olds birthday party every time we let it into our Representative Republic.

IMO it's you that is "splitting hairs". Simply because we give our money, in the form of taxes, to our local government to fund education, a police force, or a library it doesn't mean we're participating in a socialist "system". This is a lie, perpetuated by socialists to assist in the desensitization of the general population to the idea of socialism. "See, you're a little socialist after all! What can it hurt to have just a leeetle more. For the children." Unfortunately, it's a lie too many in this country have listened to. Socialism has made great inroads into our system of government, to the detriment of our education system, police forces, and our population as a whole.

I can't blame you for the way you think on this subject. You've been steeped in it since preschool, and you don't remember what it was like before.

Forgive me for trying to show you the way back to what we used to have, an educational system that was number one in the world, the greatest economy ever seen on the planet and unparalleled freedom.
Always be yourself.
Unless you can be a pirate.
Then always be a pirate.

eyeeatingfish

Re: Dammit, Bernie (liberal rant)
« Reply #27 on: February 04, 2016, 10:26:51 PM »
Inspecter,
I think our point of disagreement ends up being in how we are defining socialism. Socialism can exist in a spectrum meaning that it can exist in a form that governs every single thing or it can exist in a much more limited way. It can exist in politics but can exist as a system outside of politics or the government as well. It can exist in the economy or as a social form. Socialism is not inherently just the government stepping in and controlling everything. A church feeding the poor through donations is a form of socialism is it not? But if we make such broad statements like socialism is evil, aren't we then in effect paint with too wide a brush? I certainly wouldn't call a church feeding the poor evil.

As for federal control of the schools, some benefits are in ensuring that as a country we maintain a certain standard instead of having some locations with lower quality than others. But is that really a socialist thing? I don't know if I would define the feds having their hand in regulations as socialism in and of itself. I think that is more akin to a gun just being a tool, capable of good or bad. I do think that when it is on the federal level, mistakes are magnified since it screws everyone, not just a state or a municipality.

Now I will grant that I am younger (32) so I don't know the "old ways" but if we are going to go there then we must acknowledge the tendency of the older generation to resist change even when the change is for the better. (examples if needed)

Edster,
I think I could agree that socialism seems to have a higher incidence of genocidal leaders but we should also consider how they are related. Is it socialism that breeds such leaders, is it socialism that allows them to rise to power, is it the genocidal leaders that put socialism into place, or is their coexistence just a correlation through some other factor and not causation?

So lets say you are talking to someone and trying to explain why socialism is bad and our system (federal republic/representative republic/democratic republic) is so much batter. You explain that socialism is bad because look at these socialist countries that had genocide and such. Ok, fair enough, but if you are going to use those incidences as an argument against socialism, then the same arguments can be made against our system which allowed genocide, slavery, discrimination, etc. This is where the hole in the argument is. If we use the same standard you are using to say socialism is evil then we must also conclude that our system is evil as well.

I think arguments against socialism should be rational and reasoned, not done through scare tactics like "hitler was a socialist" Those arguments don't result in a more educated populace.

Inspector

Re: Dammit, Bernie (liberal rant)
« Reply #28 on: February 05, 2016, 07:32:35 AM »
Inspecter,
I think our point of disagreement ends up being in how we are defining socialism.
Agreed. You should also learn how to spell correctly.

Socialism can exist in a spectrum meaning that it can exist in a form that governs every single thing or it can exist in a much more limited way.
Agreed.

It can exist in politics but can exist as a system outside of politics or the government as well.
Your wrong. The definition of Socialism IS a form of Government (Political and economic organization). So by definition it cannot be anything but Government.

It can exist in the economy or as a social form.
Agreed. But only as part of a Socialist Government. Because you cannot take away peoples rights and control them in exchange for money/resources or whatever. Otherwise it is called something else which is nothing even close to Socialism.

Socialism is not inherently just the government stepping in and controlling everything.
Your wrong. That IS the definition of Socialism. If they are not doing that it is NOT Socialism.

A church feeding the poor through donations is a form of socialism is it not?
No. Your Wrong. It is called charity. And the definitions of both are diametrically opposed. Socialism takes money/work involuntarily from the people who work and/or earn money and then takes complete control over that money and it is given away to whomever in exchange for control over that person in the form of welfare. The contributor has no say as to how the money is spent and to whom it is given. The other is a voluntary contribution in which the contributor is expecting the money to be used to feed the poor. They are usually members of the church so they have input as to who their money is going towards feeding.

But if we make such broad statements like socialism is evil, aren't we then in effect paint with too wide a brush? I certainly wouldn't call a church feeding the poor evil.
I don't know where you got the idea that Socialism is evil. People are evil. Socialism is a corrupt system that is used as a tool by mostly evil people to control a country and the people in it.

As for federal control of the schools, some benefits are in ensuring that as a country we maintain a certain standard instead of having some locations with lower quality than others.
Your wrong. Since the Feds have had control over our education system it has ensured that the quality of education that our students are getting is at an all time low. Yes, it may bring the lowest of the low a little higher and even things out a VERY small amount. But at what cost? The cost is that it brings down everyone else. That is also the classic definition of Socialism.

But is that really a socialist thing?
Yes.

I don't know if I would define the feds having their hand in regulations as socialism in and of itself. I think that is more akin to a gun just being a tool, capable of good or bad.
Your statement is wrong. It goes well beyond just regulations. Again, they are dictating what to teach our kids and how to teach our kids. And the parents have no input whatsoever. Based on the way it used to be I would say it is VERY much Socialism. Give money in exchange for control. It really is that simple.

I do think that when it is on the federal level, mistakes are magnified since it screws everyone, not just a state or a municipality.
Typical of Socialist Governments. Take away that control and give us back our freedom to choose and decide how and what to teach our kids then the mistakes will mostly go away. For mostly everyone. Classic Socialism is to bring down everyone who is excelling in order to try and even things out with those who cannot excel even in an opportune environment. That brings the country down as a whole. At least the way it used to be only a handful of school districts would be run poorly. Not just the whole country. 

Now I will grant that I am younger (32) so I don't know the "old ways" but if we are going to go there then we must acknowledge the tendency of the older generation to resist change even when the change is for the better. (examples if needed)
As a younger person I believe that it would do you well to learn the "old ways". That way you can decide which is a better system. One where most of the countries children excel or one where the opportunities are limited in order to make things more even. To me it is a no brainer.

I find myself, as an older person, to actually not resist change when the change is for the common good. Socialism, generally speaking is not for the common good. In theory it sounds like it if you read about it and study it. But in execution it SUCKS THE BIG ONE!!!! For instance I am not a true conservative. I believe in certain regulations and social programs. I believe some of it does good. But only in controlled moderation. The problem is our creeping Socialism is running rampant and uncontrolled. It is already proven that when the feds and states interfere with education our children suffer. That is something you cannot disagree with. The facts are out there in the form of lower grades and higher drop out rates. I know it can't 100% be blamed on government interference. But before we can fix our personal social issues we need to give back control to the people where the original founders thought the power should be.

 :stopjack:
« Last Edit: February 05, 2016, 11:18:51 AM by Inspector »
SCIENCE THAT CAN’T BE QUESTIONED IS PROPAGANDA!!!

Jl808

Dammit, Bernie (liberal rant)
« Reply #29 on: February 05, 2016, 07:43:25 AM »
Just want to make an observation,.. You are both coming at this from different beliefs.

EEF is coming from a belief system that people are capable of good. If the right people ("benevolent dictators") are in charge, then we would have a better government for the people.  I have met EEF and first impression is that he seems to have been brought up in a good environment and a solid family.  I can understand his world view because of this.

Edster48 is coming from a belief system that people are inherently evil.  Because people will tend to abuse power, government powers need to be limited to prevent abuse.  Just read the news, there are many many examples of this locally, nationally and internationally.

In reality, there are "good" and there are "evil" people, and government is filled with them.

I would not want to live in a world where everyone is "evil". What kind of world would it be if there were no people choosing to do good and be kind to each other?

At the same time, I would not want to be blind to the fact that there are evil people that seek power and abuse it for their own benefit.  What better way than to seek government powers by becoming the ones in charge. Also there's that saying, "power corrupts and absolute power corrupts absolutely."
« Last Edit: February 05, 2016, 08:50:29 AM by Jl808 »
I think, therefore I am armed.
NRA Life Patron member, HRA Life member, HiFiCo Life Member, HDF member

The United States Constitution © 1791. All Rights Reserved.

Jl808

Dammit, Bernie (liberal rant)
« Reply #30 on: February 05, 2016, 08:48:21 AM »
I was going to comment on EEF's comparison of taxes to charity but Inspector beat me to it.

Charity from a church feeding the poor is done with the giver's own free will.  If the giver chooses not use their money to feed the poor, then there is no consequence to the giver.

Government using taxes to feed the poor is done without the giver's consent.  If the taxpayer chooses not to pay taxes, the person goes to prison for tax evasion.

One is voluntary while the other is coerced.  Hence the saying "government is a necessary evil".
« Last Edit: February 05, 2016, 12:51:02 PM by Jl808 »
I think, therefore I am armed.
NRA Life Patron member, HRA Life member, HiFiCo Life Member, HDF member

The United States Constitution © 1791. All Rights Reserved.

Inspector

Re: Dammit, Bernie (liberal rant)
« Reply #31 on: February 05, 2016, 01:42:04 PM »
http://www.cnbc.com/2015/03/11/companies-cash-in-on-common-core-despite-controversy.html

I used to work for one of those textbook companies until I learned what a scam it was, then I couldn't do my job with a clear conscience.

The issue is complicated because no system lives in a vacuum, and because "human nature" isn't so far separated from the animal kingdom as we'd like to think, there are those who will never quit trying to find a way to get their fingers on someone else's goodies. Central Governments can do a lot of wonderful amazing things, but at a certain point if they get too big they start acting like ATMs that connect to our bank accounts and begin handing out vast amounts of wealth to well-connected parasites who figure out how to bribe politicians.

The "-isms" are all vulnerable to the same problem. When we create large centralized structures that should theoretically work, someone always figures out how to screw them up. A better experiment would be 50 states making more of their own decisions, and if poor decisions are made in one segment then everybody else can observe instead of being dragged down along with them.

But the way it is now, every time I hear something about another massive federal program chances are any beneficial impacts it might have had were already diluted in committee and replaced with more ATM pin numbers for the well-connected.
I wanted to LIKE your comments but for some reason my web browser won't do it. Maybe a sign?  :rofl:

I am curious. Did you ever read or get involved in the content of the Common Core program? I am just curious if there is something out of the ordinary that they were teaching our kids. For instance some political BS leaning in one direction? I also heard that they rewrote certain parts of our history books. Taking out certain accomplishments of white historical figures and inserted the accomplishments of black historical figures. Don't get me wrong, I am not against teaching our kids about black historical figures and their accomplishments. I would just prefer they add it to the textbooks instead of erasing certain aspects of our history. It is just that I heard that they removed certain aspects of our history like it never happened. Big events in our history just wiped away. Never to be taught to our students ever again. Again, I heard this and I have not been able to confirm it. I was just curious if you had seen any of this while you worked at the textbook company?
SCIENCE THAT CAN’T BE QUESTIONED IS PROPAGANDA!!!

ren

Deeds Not Words

edster48

Re: Dammit, Bernie (liberal rant)
« Reply #33 on: February 05, 2016, 07:03:48 PM »
Just want to make an observation,.. You are both coming at this from different beliefs.

EEF is coming from a belief system that people are capable of good. If the right people ("benevolent dictators") are in charge, then we would have a better government for the people.  I have met EEF and first impression is that he seems to have been brought up in a good environment and a solid family.  I can understand his world view because of this.

Edster48 is coming from a belief system that people are inherently evil.  Because people will tend to abuse power, government powers need to be limited to prevent abuse.  Just read the news, there are many many examples of this locally, nationally and internationally.

In reality, there are "good" and there are "evil" people, and government is filled with them.

I would not want to live in a world where everyone is "evil". What kind of world would it be if there were no people choosing to do good and be kind to each other?

At the same time, I would not want to be blind to the fact that there are evil people that seek power and abuse it for their own benefit.  What better way than to seek government powers by becoming the ones in charge. Also there's that saying, "power corrupts and absolute power corrupts absolutely."

I appreciate the effort to boil our disagreement down to the lowest common denominator, but...no. I do not believe that people are "inherently evil". If I had to say "people are inherently ______". I would say they are inherently lazy.

Human beings as a species will take the easy way over the hard or "right" way 99 times out of 100. Temptation, greed and sloth seem to be the main reasons we turn to evil, it's the easy way to attain that which we covet, without earning it.

 I recognize and accept that evil exists because I've seen and experienced it first hand. I associate socialism with evil because I know that its totalitarian nature attracts evil, like a moth to a flame. Although, the same can be said for any position of power in any political system. Good people enter politics intent on righting the wrongs only to be coerced into evil in order to attain their goals. Thus "the road to hell is paved with good intentions". Evil people look to find a place where power protects them from those they wish to take advantage of.

Evil seems to be more prevalent due mostly to a breakdown of moral barriers that once held it at bay.

This is another subject that can draw you down the "rabbit hole". Suffice it to say I know there are plenty of "good" people out there, I'll even say that I think EEF is one of them. He and I just approach certain subjects from different perspectives due to differences in upbringing, education, age and experience.
Always be yourself.
Unless you can be a pirate.
Then always be a pirate.

eyeeatingfish

Re: Dammit, Bernie (liberal rant)
« Reply #34 on: February 06, 2016, 01:51:26 AM »
According to the wikipedia article I posted, there do seem to be socialist systems that exist outside of government control. Maybe I am misunderstanding something (possible) but it didn't seem like socialism was explicitly government control of everything. Soviet socialism was of course.
For example,
"Syndicalism is a social movement that operates through industrial trade unions and rejects state socialism and the use of establishment politics to establish or promote socialism. They reject using state power to construct a socialist society, favouring strategies such as the general strike."
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Socialism#Syndicalism

Inspector, your criticisms of federal control of education are just however I believe it should be pointed out that the execution is separate from the purpose. The fact the feds have screwed up education does not mean that federal intervention is incapable to actually improving it. Federal intervention after all did ensure that schools don't discriminate against students by the color of their skin. Yes I realize it was intervention to uphold the constitution so it is not a perfect comparison but worthy of note. A failure of execution (what we currently have) is not in and of itself proof that the system itself could never succeed given good execution. I am not arguing for government control, just trying to recognize the positives among the many negatives.

I may have to concede the point about charity though. I may have been misunderstanding christian socialism.

I am not a fan of socialism, except perhaps very limited applications, but I think the biggest disservice is to oversimplify and demonize other schools of thought. There are many forms of governing and realistically non are perfect, all have flaws and most have at least a few positives. Some I think are obviously more flawed than others but I think an objective discussion of the benefits and the drawbacks is what is going to benefit us the most.

I do have a question though, in the context of control of schools and socialism, does it matter what level of government is doing the controlling? Meaning that even if you had say a Kaneohe board of education that only controlled kaneohe schools and got funds from kaneohe sources, is that not still socialism? It is still government control, just much less removed than a state or federal government. It still seems like it could be defined as socialism, just on a smaller scale. Am I missing something? Following that, if someone is completely against all forms of socialism does that dictate that they must believe each school to be completely autonomous?

Inspector

Re: Dammit, Bernie (liberal rant)
« Reply #35 on: February 06, 2016, 08:26:00 AM »
According to the wikipedia article I posted, there do seem to be socialist systems that exist outside of government control. Maybe I am misunderstanding something (possible) but it didn't seem like socialism was explicitly government control of everything. Soviet socialism was of course.
For example,
"Syndicalism is a social movement that operates through industrial trade unions and rejects state socialism and the use of establishment politics to establish or promote socialism. They reject using state power to construct a socialist society, favouring strategies such as the general strike."
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Socialism#Syndicalism
This is an interesting concept. I have to admit I had not seen this before. With that in mind then my thoughts are this. It really doesn't matter what they say they reject. The control they are trying to wrestle away from the main form of government, is still a form of government and governing their members. This form of Socialism still requires some sort of main government structure to exist. It doesn't seem to matter what type of government though. Socialist or Capitalist. The trade unions are still going to have to be a part of the main (Whole) government in order to exist and operate. They can say they operate independently and they reject they main form of government. But without cooperation and integration between the two entities then we still only have a trade union and a government. The trade unions will need the resources and tax dollars provided by the main government that the trade unions do not control. Things like tax collection, infrastructure, military, police, utilities, etc. If they wrestle away control it is highly unlikely that the main government is going to allow that because the government wants control over Union member earnings. But if it is allowed, the trade unions are going to have to cooperate and integrate their operations with the government in essesence becoming part of the government in order to have cooperation with the main government. The biggest problem I see with this form of Socialism is you need to have everyone in government and outside government as members of the trade unions. And you have to have full cooperation by everyone in order to get things done like a general strike. I have been a union member for over 30 years and having full cooperation and just getting more than 5% or 10% of workers to organize is almost impossible. I love the way Socialism is so ideological that they believe their own BS. Just say they reject something but then they don't look at the reality and consequences of doing just that.

Inspector, your criticisms of federal control of education are just however I believe it should be pointed out that the execution is separate from the purpose. The fact the feds have screwed up education does not mean that federal intervention is incapable to actually improving it.
True. The problem is is that I cannot find one example where this has occurred. The issue boils down to how much freedom the Feds are going to allow in exchange for control over education. If the Feds just throw subsidy money to education without requiring any control then the responsibility of how to spend that money goes to the agency (government or private) that receives it. The problem is that this experiment has already been tried. And it was found that the agencies that received the money did not use much of the money towards education. Hence the outcry from the people of the Feds just throwing money at problems. This is partly how the DOE came to exist. Instead of holding accountable the the local agencies the Feds just created a Socialist entity.

Federal intervention after all did ensure that schools don't discriminate against students by the color of their skin. Yes I realize it was intervention to uphold the constitution so it is not a perfect comparison but worthy of note.
Yeah, sorry but this is just not a good comparison. One involves the federal government requiring control in exchange for money and the other involves the federal government upholding the people's constitutional rights. I don't see the upholding of human rights as intervention. I guess the actual act was an intervention but the cause and effect are pretty much diametrically opposed.

A failure of execution (what we currently have) is not in and of itself proof that the system itself could never succeed given good execution. I am not arguing for government control, just trying to recognize the positives among the many negatives.
I agree that one doesn't mean the other. I get what you are saying. For me though, I am a realist. I can't find even one good example of where a social government program involving education was not screwed up by the controls that the Feds placed on our education system in exchange for money. So to argue that just because the Feds have failed at every Socialist education program they have ever tried doesn't mean that good can't come from their trying is like banging your head against the wall and expecting you don't get a headache. Considering the track record of the federal government trying to control and regulate our education system and other areas of our lives I am very surprised that there as many Democrat/Socialist/Progressive types as there are here in the U.S. Big government and big government programs do not have a very good track record in our history. To see how things have changed one must truly become a student of U.S. History at least in the short term. In this way people can decide if we are heading in the right direction or if going back to earlier ways where the problems that we have created didn't exist is the right way to go.

I may have to concede the point about charity though. I may have been misunderstanding christian socialism.

I am not a fan of socialism, except perhaps very limited applications, but I think the biggest disservice is to oversimplify and demonize other schools of thought. There are many forms of governing and realistically non are perfect, all have flaws and most have at least a few positives. Some I think are obviously more flawed than others but I think an objective discussion of the benefits and the drawbacks is what is going to benefit us the most.

I do have a question though, in the context of control of schools and socialism, does it matter what level of government is doing the controlling? Meaning that even if you had say a Kaneohe board of education that only controlled kaneohe schools and got funds from kaneohe sources, is that not still socialism? It is still government control, just much less removed than a state or federal government. It still seems like it could be defined as socialism, just on a smaller scale. Am I missing something? Following that, if someone is completely against all forms of socialism does that dictate that they must believe each school to be completely autonomous?
Your question is a good one. I apologize if my previous explanations were not clear about this. I don't consider the control of schools by government a form of Socialism in the context of the way it used to be not in the way it is now. The way it is now you are correct. But in the context of the way it used to it is not. Back when I was a child growing up city/county governments were run by non politicians. In most cases the city/county council was part time and the positions did not pay much. It was in this way that the positions mostly attracted those who would rather do good for the community than to make a living. The amount they earned was so small it was more voluntary of a position than anything else. The so called "Politicians" were really more of a conduit to the will of the people that they are now. This is significant in respect that city/county governments are much closer to the people, their constituents than a large government. And therefore the people have a much greater role to play in how the city/county governments operate. In particular the council governments were working class people like most of us here in this forum. People who are passionate and are willing to give of themselves instead of trying to make a living off of government. When the councils pay is low you don't get people spending big money to try and get into the positions. You were literally a slave to the will of the people and could not hide or have a buffer from the people like the people in big governments enjoy. You don't do what the majority wants, your out. You can get fired or voted out. The school districts were run and operated by housewives with children in the same school district. Mostly part time positions which did not pay much. Mostly those who wanted to make THEIR school district or cities/counties better worked in city/county agencies. To dig down deeper there was the PTA. This is where the parents have a monthly meeting with their children's school principal and school district reps. They told the principal how they wanted things run. And if enough parents got a petition together the principal was fired. The point of all of this is the people who count, the people who matter and the people who are mostly effected by the decisions (good or bad) by school districts, principals, city/county councils and governments had a say in how things were run. In many cases School District Agencies and city/county governments didn't make big decisions without putting the issue to vote of the people who lived in their district. That is not Socialism. This is the way American Government was supposed to work. This why people like me are all for a minimalist government. Not to the extent of say a Libertarian. But a compromise between a Libertarian and a Republican. Take away or significantly reduce the pay from all positions of all form of our government/agencies and make it mostly part time pay and voluntary again and I propose that most (not all) of the corrupt politicians and lazy government workers will disappear. And then just think about the money that is saved by doing this. Meaning taxes can be lowered and when you lower taxes people generally thrive along with the economy. JMHO
SCIENCE THAT CAN’T BE QUESTIONED IS PROPAGANDA!!!

FBI

Re: Dammit, Bernie (liberal rant)
« Reply #36 on: February 06, 2016, 12:06:36 PM »
Hi Inspector,

I graduated from Bellflower Unified School district, Bellflower Sr. High class of 73,
so we were likely neighbors.  I have followed the entire thread and really like your inputs
and agree with most of your stands.  EEF is a product
of a more recent educational system, it shows.
To keep to the 2A point on Socialism, Every socialist system has sought to disarm the general
population.  Ultimately that has been to the detriment of that population.  No one here can give an
example of a modern socialist society with a culturally diverse, completely disarmed population,
that has no significant gun crime.  Remember  "culturally diverse"  That is the operative term.
Socialism and the 2A are incompatible absolutely and completely.

Inspector

Re: Dammit, Bernie (liberal rant)
« Reply #37 on: February 06, 2016, 01:43:43 PM »
Hi Inspector,

I graduated from Bellflower Unified School district, Bellflower Sr. High class of 73,
so we were likely neighbors.  I have followed the entire thread and really like your inputs
and agree with most of your stands.  EEF is a product
of a more recent educational system, it shows.
To keep to the 2A point on Socialism, Every socialist system has sought to disarm the general
population.  Ultimately that has been to the detriment of that population.  No one here can give an
example of a modern socialist society with a culturally diverse, completely disarmed population,
that has no significant gun crime.  Remember  "culturally diverse"  That is the operative term.
Socialism and the 2A are incompatible absolutely and completely.
Hey FBI,

Yes I graduated Millikan HS in '76. My first job was working washing cars on some the small used car lots on Bellflower Blvd. Bellflower Motors was one I remember. My favorite place in the whole world before I got into shooting was a small Hobby Shop on Bellflower Blvd. that specialized in model trains. I can't for the life of me remember the name. And then there was Hobby City in Stanton with that huge slot car track. Ahhh the memories.....

Long Beach used to be one of the richest cities in the U.S. Due to the tide land money it got from the offshore oil drilling. Once it went from a part time city council to a full time politician type city government the money disappeared. Then they went on an anti big business streak. That is when McDonnell Douglas left. Then they went on an environment kick and all the new and used car lots on Long Beach Blvd. moved over to Signal Hill and most auto repair shops either were zoned out of existence or moved to another city due to the threat of being re-zoned. Then when they blew that deal to have Disney build a theme park at the port (Disney by the Sea) because they didn't want to help pay for an offramp from the LB Freeway to the theme park I knew the city had hit an all time low. Sad, LB used to be a great place to grow up as a kid as I am sure Bellflower was.

I hope that trying to explain to EEF what things were like at least before Socialism and big government creeped in to our locality that he can see that we the people have lost control of the system that was so great before it changed. It is not his fault but I just hope to enlighten him. Not trying to change his mind. The system we had was not perfect but it was not broken either. The direction we went has hurt the children. The worst part is the thought is not to go back to the way we were. But to move forward and progress. But after 50 years of this I would think it would be time to reconsider the "forward progressive" thinking.
SCIENCE THAT CAN’T BE QUESTIONED IS PROPAGANDA!!!

eyeeatingfish

Re: Dammit, Bernie (liberal rant)
« Reply #38 on: February 08, 2016, 02:37:48 AM »
This is an interesting concept. I have to admit I had not seen this before. With that in mind then my thoughts are this. It really doesn't matter what they say they reject. The control they are trying to wrestle away from the main form of government, is still a form of government and governing their members. This form of Socialism still requires some sort of main government structure to exist. It doesn't seem to matter what type of government though. Socialist or Capitalist. The trade unions are still going to have to be a part of the main (Whole) government in order to exist and operate. They can say they operate independently and they reject they main form of government. But without cooperation and integration between the two entities then we still only have a trade union and a government. The trade unions will need the resources and tax dollars provided by the main government that the trade unions do not control. Things like tax collection, infrastructure, military, police, utilities, etc. If they wrestle away control it is highly unlikely that the main government is going to allow that because the government wants control over Union member earnings. But if it is allowed, the trade unions are going to have to cooperate and integrate their operations with the government in essesence becoming part of the government in order to have cooperation with the main government. The biggest problem I see with this form of Socialism is you need to have everyone in government and outside government as members of the trade unions. And you have to have full cooperation by everyone in order to get things done like a general strike. I have been a union member for over 30 years and having full cooperation and just getting more than 5% or 10% of workers to organize is almost impossible. I love the way Socialism is so ideological that they believe their own BS. Just say they reject something but then they don't look at the reality and consequences of doing just that.

You make good points there, perhaps this does still involve government control but it is just on the less extreme end of socialism? I think people who believe in socialism just believe that once done right it will work and are just trying to attain that ideal.

Quote
True. The problem is is that I cannot find one example where this has occurred. The issue boils down to how much freedom the Feds are going to allow in exchange for control over education. If the Feds just throw subsidy money to education without requiring any control then the responsibility of how to spend that money goes to the agency (government or private) that receives it. The problem is that this experiment has already been tried. And it was found that the agencies that received the money did not use much of the money towards education. Hence the outcry from the people of the Feds just throwing money at problems. This is partly how the DOE came to exist. Instead of holding accountable the the local agencies the Feds just created a Socialist entity.

Maybe that just goes back to them thinking it will work as long as it is done right?

[/quote] Yeah, sorry but this is just not a good comparison. One involves the federal government requiring control in exchange for money and the other involves the federal government upholding the people's constitutional rights. I don't see the upholding of human rights as intervention. I guess the actual act was an intervention but the cause and effect are pretty much diametrically opposed.[/quote]

It wasn't the best example. I do think it illustrates at least a small amount of federal control, at least to the point that they can effectively monitor constitutional rights are protected perhaps.

Quote
I agree that one doesn't mean the other. I get what you are saying. For me though, I am a realist. I can't find even one good example of where a social government program involving education was not screwed up by the controls that the Feds placed on our education system in exchange for money. So to argue that just because the Feds have failed at every Socialist education program they have ever tried doesn't mean that good can't come from their trying is like banging your head against the wall and expecting you don't get a headache. Considering the track record of the federal government trying to control and regulate our education system and other areas of our lives I am very surprised that there as many Democrat/Socialist/Progressive types as there are here in the U.S. Big government and big government programs do not have a very good track record in our history. To see how things have changed one must truly become a student of U.S. History at least in the short term. In this way people can decide if we are heading in the right direction or if going back to earlier ways where the problems that we have created didn't exist is the right way to go.

I must admit I cannot think of one either but to be objective I try to at least consider there may be cases that have worked since I really haven't done any study of whether or not federal control ahs ever yielded a positive result across the board. I am sure it has yielded positive results in certain limited pictures.

Quote
Your question is a good one. I apologize if my previous explanations were not clear about this. I don't consider the control of schools by government a form of Socialism in the context of the way it used to be not in the way it is now. The way it is now you are correct. But in the context of the way it used to it is not. Back when I was a child growing up city/county governments were run by non politicians. In most cases the city/county council was part time and the positions did not pay much. It was in this way that the positions mostly attracted those who would rather do good for the community than to make a living. The amount they earned was so small it was more voluntary of a position than anything else. The so called "Politicians" were really more of a conduit to the will of the people that they are now. This is significant in respect that city/county governments are much closer to the people, their constituents than a large government. And therefore the people have a much greater role to play in how the city/county governments operate. In particular the council governments were working class people like most of us here in this forum. People who are passionate and are willing to give of themselves instead of trying to make a living off of government. When the councils pay is low you don't get people spending big money to try and get into the positions. You were literally a slave to the will of the people and could not hide or have a buffer from the people like the people in big governments enjoy. You don't do what the majority wants, your out. You can get fired or voted out. The school districts were run and operated by housewives with children in the same school district. Mostly part time positions which did not pay much. Mostly those who wanted to make THEIR school district or cities/counties better worked in city/county agencies. To dig down deeper there was the PTA. This is where the parents have a monthly meeting with their children's school principal and school district reps. They told the principal how they wanted things run. And if enough parents got a petition together the principal was fired. The point of all of this is the people who count, the people who matter and the people who are mostly effected by the decisions (good or bad) by school districts, principals, city/county councils and governments had a say in how things were run. In many cases School District Agencies and city/county governments didn't make big decisions without putting the issue to vote of the people who lived in their district. That is not Socialism. This is the way American Government was supposed to work. This why people like me are all for a minimalist government. Not to the extent of say a Libertarian. But a compromise between a Libertarian and a Republican. Take away or significantly reduce the pay from all positions of all form of our government/agencies and make it mostly part time pay and voluntary again and I propose that most (not all) of the corrupt politicians and lazy government workers will disappear. And then just think about the money that is saved by doing this. Meaning taxes can be lowered and when you lower taxes people generally thrive along with the economy. JMHO

You seem to describe small town government, but could that model work in densely populated areas? I do like that form of governing many systems though. There are certain efficiency benefits to larger systems but that also comes with drawbacks in certain other services and capabilities.

I completely get how people are worried about socialism given the context of growing up in the cold war and the soviet union. I just think that we shouldn't limit our understanding of socialism as a concept to the context of soviet socialism because then conversations between conservatives and socialists will never make any headway because they won't understand each other's positions.

Inspector

Re: Dammit, Bernie (liberal rant)
« Reply #39 on: February 08, 2016, 06:43:46 AM »
You make good points there, perhaps this does still involve government control but it is just on the less extreme end of socialism?
Nope. Not in any way, shape, form or manner. Just because a government of the people, by the people and for the people handles certain aspects of organized government the way the people have dictated them to do does not mean it is Socialism. Socialism only creeps in when government stops doing what it is supposed to do per the majority and starts doing what the individual or minority wants done.

I think people who believe in socialism just believe that once done right it will work and are just trying to attain that ideal.
Yes, the typical Liberal thoughts of the impossible Utopia.  :wacko:  It's possible that people think that. And I know many who do. Only those without common and practical sense would continue to try to selfishly do something that obviously hurts those who would normally excel under a free system in order to try and bring up those who will probably never excel under either system. After a few hundred years of trying to get it right and failing you would think the smart ones would give up and realize how flawed a system Socialism of all types is. As Einstein is quoted as defining insanity as doing the same over and over again and expecting different results.

Maybe that just goes back to them thinking it will work as long as it is done right?

See my answer above. They have had their chance to do it "right". It is time they stop this horrific social experiment called Socialism and get back to a more free and smaller system.

Yeah, sorry but this is just not a good comparison. One involves the federal government requiring control in exchange for money and the other involves the federal government upholding the people's constitutional rights. I don't see the upholding of human rights as intervention. I guess the actual act was an intervention but the cause and effect are pretty much diametrically opposed.

It wasn't the best example. I do think it illustrates at least a small amount of federal control, at least to the point that they can effectively monitor constitutional rights are protected perhaps.
Monitoring is NOT controlling. Again, not a good example.

I must admit I cannot think of one either but to be objective I try to at least consider there may be cases that have worked since I really haven't done any study of whether or not federal control ahs ever yielded a positive result across the board. I am sure it has yielded positive results in certain limited pictures.
When you find one, get back to me on that.

You seem to describe small town government, but could that model work in densely populated areas?
Have you not been comprehending what I have been writing here all along? I did give you an example of it working in a densely populated area. I grew up in Long Beach, CA. One of the largest cities in the U.S. I think it is the second or third largest in CA. It worked there and in every large city in this country. That is until someone wanted to fundamentally change how the system worked.

I do like that form of governing many systems though. There are certain efficiency benefits to larger systems but that also comes with drawbacks in certain other services and capabilities.
I would love to hear a few examples of how large government is more efficient than smaller government. I am not saying it can't be that way. What I am saying is I don't know of any examples so I expect since you made that statement you can give me some examples.

I completely get how people are worried about socialism given the context of growing up in the cold war and the soviet union.
That's nice but I did not state anything in that context. If you would like to discuss something in that context I think we should open a new thread.

I just think that we shouldn't limit our understanding of socialism as a concept to the context of soviet socialism because then conversations between conservatives and socialists will never make any headway because they won't understand each other's positions.
Not sure why you are bringing the context of socialism based on the soviet system up as I didn't. If you want to discuss that in another thread then open up a new one. Otherwise, let's stay on topic here, okay?  :stopjack:

I do want to state one more thing. I completely understand Socialism. I have studied it. I understand it. I just don't agree with it. Just because I don't agree with it doesn't mean I don't understand it. In that context I believe that Liberals/Progressives/Socialists don't understand (And usually don't want to understand) the Conservative viewpoint. I have lived in both worlds and from my experience I wouldn't want to live any where else except in a free society. Which Socialism is not. JMHO  :shaka:  :stopjack:
« Last Edit: February 08, 2016, 07:07:39 AM by Inspector »
SCIENCE THAT CAN’T BE QUESTIONED IS PROPAGANDA!!!