Inspecter,
I think our point of disagreement ends up being in how we are defining socialism.
Agreed. You should also learn how to spell correctly.
Socialism can exist in a spectrum meaning that it can exist in a form that governs every single thing or it can exist in a much more limited way.
Agreed.
It can exist in politics but can exist as a system outside of politics or the government as well.
Your wrong. The definition of Socialism
IS a form of Government (Political and economic organization). So by definition it cannot be anything but Government.
It can exist in the economy or as a social form.
Agreed. But only as part of a Socialist Government. Because you cannot take away peoples rights and control them in exchange for money/resources or whatever. Otherwise it is called something else which is nothing even close to Socialism.
Socialism is not inherently just the government stepping in and controlling everything.
Your wrong. That
IS the definition of Socialism. If they are not doing that it is NOT Socialism.
A church feeding the poor through donations is a form of socialism is it not?
No. Your Wrong. It is called charity. And the definitions of both are diametrically opposed. Socialism takes money/work involuntarily from the people who work and/or earn money and then takes complete control over that money and it is given away to whomever in exchange for control over that person in the form of welfare. The contributor has no say as to how the money is spent and to whom it is given. The other is a voluntary contribution in which the contributor is expecting the money to be used to feed the poor. They are usually members of the church so they have input as to who their money is going towards feeding.
But if we make such broad statements like socialism is evil, aren't we then in effect paint with too wide a brush? I certainly wouldn't call a church feeding the poor evil.
I don't know where you got the idea that Socialism is evil. People are evil. Socialism is a corrupt system that is used as a tool by mostly evil people to control a country and the people in it.
As for federal control of the schools, some benefits are in ensuring that as a country we maintain a certain standard instead of having some locations with lower quality than others.
Your wrong. Since the Feds have had control over our education system it has ensured that the quality of education that our students are getting is at an all time low. Yes, it may bring the lowest of the low a little higher and even things out a VERY small amount. But at what cost? The cost is that it brings down everyone else. That is also the classic definition of Socialism.
But is that really a socialist thing?
Yes.
I don't know if I would define the feds having their hand in regulations as socialism in and of itself. I think that is more akin to a gun just being a tool, capable of good or bad.
Your statement is wrong. It goes well beyond just regulations. Again, they are dictating what to teach our kids and how to teach our kids. And the parents have no input whatsoever. Based on the way it used to be I would say it is VERY much Socialism. Give money in exchange for control. It really is that simple.
I do think that when it is on the federal level, mistakes are magnified since it screws everyone, not just a state or a municipality.
Typical of Socialist Governments. Take away that control and give us back our freedom to choose and decide how and what to teach our kids then the mistakes will mostly go away. For mostly everyone. Classic Socialism is to bring down everyone who is excelling in order to try and even things out with those who cannot excel even in an opportune environment. That brings the country down as a whole. At least the way it used to be only a handful of school districts would be run poorly. Not just the whole country.
Now I will grant that I am younger (32) so I don't know the "old ways" but if we are going to go there then we must acknowledge the tendency of the older generation to resist change even when the change is for the better. (examples if needed)
As a younger person I believe that it would do you well to learn the "old ways". That way you can decide which is a better system. One where most of the countries children excel or one where the opportunities are limited in order to make things more even. To me it is a no brainer.
I find myself, as an older person, to actually not resist change when the change is for the common good. Socialism, generally speaking is not for the common good. In theory it sounds like it if you read about it and study it. But in execution it SUCKS THE BIG ONE!!!! For instance I am not a true conservative. I believe in certain regulations and social programs. I believe some of it does good. But only in controlled moderation. The problem is our creeping Socialism is running rampant and uncontrolled. It is already proven that when the feds and states interfere with education our children suffer. That is something you cannot disagree with. The facts are out there in the form of lower grades and higher drop out rates. I know it can't 100% be blamed on government interference. But before we can fix our personal social issues we need to give back control to the people where the original founders thought the power should be.
