Dammit, Bernie (liberal rant) (Read 86995 times)

Inspector

Re: Dammit, Bernie (liberal rant)
« Reply #100 on: February 17, 2016, 04:55:10 AM »
....I remain perplexed at why it is so difficult for some to hold discussions independent of their biases.
This coming from someone who refuses to acknowledge there is no difference between distribution (democracy) and redistribution (socialism). This is one of the biases you have and made me decide to stop trying to discuss socialism with you. Your hypocrisy is not going unnoticed here.

http://the-difference-between.com/redistribution/distribution

Get over your bias about this and offer up some content instead of debate and you can have a discussion with everyone!

I discuss things with people in order to learn and expand my knowledge. But when you don't offer anything interesting to talk about, and all you want to do is debate based on your own biases then there is no discussion. Yet once again I feel like I am talking to a wall.



SCIENCE THAT CAN’T BE QUESTIONED IS PROPAGANDA!!!

eyeeatingfish

Re: Dammit, Bernie (liberal rant)
« Reply #101 on: February 17, 2016, 06:27:21 AM »
This coming from someone who refuses to acknowledge there is no difference between distribution (democracy) and redistribution (socialism). This is one of the biases you have and made me decide to stop trying to discuss socialism with you. Your hypocrisy is not going unnoticed here.

http://the-difference-between.com/redistribution/distribution

Get over your bias about this and offer up some content instead of debate and you can have a discussion with everyone!

I discuss things with people in order to learn and expand my knowledge. But when you don't offer anything interesting to talk about, and all you want to do is debate based on your own biases then there is no discussion. Yet once again I feel like I am talking to a wall.

From the link you provided:
"redistribution is the act of changing the distribution of resources. "

That is what public schools do, even if at a local level. Taxes are paid by everyone in the community and then spent on resources only for those who attend school. The distribution of resources are still changed.

I am not making up definitions here I am trying to stick to the technical defnition

Jl808

Dammit, Bernie (liberal rant)
« Reply #102 on: February 17, 2016, 07:17:10 AM »
Heavies, than you for that great video.

I think what EEF (especially) and aieahound are being adamant about and trying to point out is that elements of socialism exists in America.

When the government interfered with the free market by bailing out the banks and the auto industry, aieahound called it "elite socialism". (I called it "crony capitalism".)  To ask like Hillary, "what difference does it make?"

The salient detail that I see is whether we are a capitalist society that is acting a bit socialist or are we a socialist society that is acting a bit capitalist.

I would say America is the former and a country like China would be more of the latter.  America is a free society (thanks to the founding fathers and to the Constitution) that allowed elements of socialism to exist ("socialistic capitalism"). Communist China is a socialist country that allowed elements of capitalism to exist ("capitalistic socialism").

More government control represent more socialism, while more individual control represent more capitalism. To which side does the balance of power currently tip?

Has America been transformed to a point where it is now a socialist country acting capitalistic?  I certainly hope not.

My questions to hvybarrels, EEF and aieahound:

1) What do you think about "socialistic capitalism" or about "capitalistic socialism"?  Do you see any relevant difference between them?

2) Are European countries or Canada more "socialistic capitalism" or are they more "capitalistic socialism"?  What about America?

3) Which one do you think is better?  Is one more immoral than the other?

« Last Edit: February 17, 2016, 07:44:28 AM by Jl808 »
I think, therefore I am armed.
NRA Life Patron member, HRA Life member, HiFiCo Life Member, HDF member

The United States Constitution © 1791. All Rights Reserved.

survivorman

Re: Dammit, Bernie (liberal rant)
« Reply #103 on: February 17, 2016, 07:22:17 AM »
THERE!!!
Now while you're trying to unsee that, can we please change the subject.

new guy

Re: Dammit, Bernie (liberal rant)
« Reply #104 on: February 17, 2016, 07:38:45 AM »
.
« Last Edit: August 11, 2016, 12:16:12 AM by new guy »
Your mindset is your primary weapon. - Jeff Cooper

Aegis808

Re: Dammit, Bernie (liberal rant)
« Reply #105 on: February 17, 2016, 01:06:24 PM »
You didn't answer the question.

why answer a loaded question?

Kuleana

Re: Dammit, Bernie (liberal rant)
« Reply #106 on: February 17, 2016, 05:28:18 PM »
Aloha JI808,

Excellent thoughtful posting.


I think what EEF (especially) and aieahound are being adamant about and trying to point out is that elements of socialism exists in America.

America does have elements of socialism.


When the government interfered with the free market by bailing out the banks and the auto industry, aieahound called it "elite socialism". (I called it "crony capitalism".)  To ask like Hillary, "what difference does it make?"

I agree with you that crony capitalism seems more appropriate.


The salient detail that I see is whether we are a capitalist society that is acting a bit socialist or are we a socialist society that is acting a bit capitalist.

I would say America is the former and a country like China would be more of the latter.  America is a free society (thanks to the founding fathers and to the Constitution) that allowed elements of socialism to exist ("socialistic capitalism"). Communist China is a socialist country that allowed elements of capitalism to exist ("capitalistic socialism").

Great analogy.


More government control represent more socialism, while more individual control represent more capitalism. To which side does the balance of power currently tip?

Has America been transformed to a point where it is now a socialist country acting capitalistic?  I certainly hope not.

My questions to hvybarrels, EEF and aieahound:

1) What do you think about "socialistic capitalism" or about "capitalistic socialism"?  Do you see any relevant difference between them?

As you articulated earlier, the differences between both of them lie in the amount of government control over the economic system currently in-place in the country in-question.


2) Are European countries or Canada more "socialistic capitalism" or are they more "capitalistic socialism"?  What about America?

European countries are theoretically more socialistic capitalism, but in practice is another story.


3) Which one do you think is better?  Is one more immoral than the other?

The question is not which is better, but rather which system is more appropriate given the cultural, socio-economic, religious, demographic, etc. factors present in the country in-question.


As to the question to which is more immoral, that question is too subjective to answer. The thing we need to remember when discussing capitalism and socialism is that capitalism is more of a market-based economic ideology with the individual at the center, while socialism, as an economic paradigm, can have both market and non-market forms with society at the center.


Kuleana

MMM

Re: Dammit, Bernie (liberal rant)
« Reply #107 on: February 17, 2016, 06:35:34 PM »
FROM:Molon Labe Industries
February 15 at 6:30am · Belleair Beach, FL ·
How many of you know people who think that socialism is just about being nice...?

In the 20th century there have been numerous political systems, but in the latter half of the century there were only two survivors, Socialism and Capitalism. So we have at this time in the Western world, which for all practical purposes controls the world, two opposing political systems. (I have already previously stated that there is no basic difference between socialists and communists. There are, however, some very important factors relating to socialism of which you should be aware. Socialism will not work in a free market economy and, as a consequence it invariably deteriorates into a totalitarian state. Anyone wishing to argue that point is asked to point to one single instance where this was not the result).

It therefore behooves us to remember who the worst despotic governments of this century were: Nazis in Germany, Fascists in Italy, Communists in the USSR, [Romania, East Germany, Bulgaria, Hungary, Yugoslavia, Czechoslovakia, Poland, Cuba, North Korea, Cambodia, Vietnam, etc.] and China - each and every one of them a paragon of socialist endeavor. Their leaders; Hitler, Mussolini, Stalin [Ceausescu, Tito, Pol Pot, etc.] and Mao Tse Tung. The outstanding legacy of these individuals is that they each tried to out-do the others in the total number of their own citizens which they murdered. It is a fact that each of these men killed more of their own civilian citizens than they lost in military conflict.

The reason for this is inherent to socialism. It promises things that it cannot possibly deliver. When socialist politicians in power come to the realization that it is impossible to deliver on their promises and political unrest develops, they have two options if they plan to stay in power. First, they must locate a scapegoat on whom they can blame their inability to deliver. Any Jew can tell you who that was for the Germans and the Russians. The second is to develop, and rapidly so, a state security apparatus to keep them in office - the SS, the KGB, [Securitate, Stasi] etc.

The basic tenets of socialism are:
1. Seduce the populace into accepting the government as the arbitrator of all problems; government from cradle-to-grave
2. Begin delivering on those services to make the citizens dependent
3. Take away the citizens' guns
4. Increase taxes on all services while destroying any free market alternative services
5. Blame the chosen scapegoat for the inability to meet demand for services
6. Have the centralized national police force round up any dissidents

Socialism cannot work because the cost of services must be collected in the form of taxes, and this is not a sustainable possibility. The reason is that since government pays for all services, neither the producer nor the consumer cares about the cost, and hence there is an uncontrolled spiral of inflation (today's medical costs are a case in point and healthcare is not yet totally socialized). Furthermore, the government has no funds or assets. It only has the funds it confiscated from its citizens. The total inefficiency of a centralized bureaucracy does not help either.
Once citizens are weaned on this cradle-to-grave concept and are no longer self-reliant, they become wards of the state and will not accept any reduction of services. The government subsequently has no option but to reduce services, and as popular resistance develops State repression begins. This is the socialist cycle. It has been found to occur in every socialist state in existence to date.

The current most outrageous examples of this are North Korea and Cuba. These two societies share much in common - both are socialist, both are totalitarian, both have more political prisoners then any nation close to their size, both have non-working universal health care, in both the citizens suffer malnutrition, and both have food and fuel rationing. Their leaders and party members, in the meantime, eat caviar and drink champagne.

Socialism can never work in any environment. It violates human nature and logic.

The capitalist economic system differs greatly from its socialist adversary in numerous ways. While the socialist system is a top down centralized arrangement, the capitalist system, which can only exist in a free market economy that recognizes the right of private property, is totally controlled by the market itself. Interestingly, personal freedom, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness can also only thrive in free market economies. Capitalism is a sort of volatile and confusing situation where the capital markets dictate demand, price, and methods of distribution. The reason that the left is so very successful in criticizing capitalism is because it is not regulated and therefore difficult to explain. The reason capitalism works so well is that demand dictates production as well as price, thus avoiding market inequities and shortages.

Socialism's principal theorem is centralization of markets under government control. This has never worked and there is not one single instance in world history where centralized governmental market manipulation has been successful. This, however, does not deter the Robert Reichs (America's socialist Secretary of Labor who said, "Greedy corporations are screwing their employees, squeezing down wages while increasing profits." This statement, from an economic illiterate who has never in his entire life worked for, or in, a business that made a profit. He appears to me to be a little man with a Napoleon complex, who, while having no clue about anything to do with economics, presents himself as a great expert. Corporate downsizing, mergers, and staff reductions has a great deal to do with international trade policies, NAFTA, EC, WTO, etc. and very little to do with greed.) of this world, who continuously make every effort to centralize economic as well as social and political power for themselves and their Satori masters (the ruling elite).

George Washington said it best: "Government, like fire, is a good servant, but a fearful master." All capitalist functions are directed at free market concepts. A free market is one that serves society with little government interference. This concept is unpopular with the Satori because in order to attain more and more power they require centralization of all economic, social, and political functions. Because of their poor performance in the political frame they have altered their modus operandi and are now implementing their schemes through judicial activism. These judicial incursions, which by the way, in the United States are in violation of constitutional law, have been sold to the public based on the false misnomer that greedy capitalists don't care about the people, their welfare, safety, or health, but that politicians do.

This, without doubt, is a ludicrous statement. The capitalist must perform to market standards. Competition will put him out of business if he provides an inferior product or service. He is furthermore constrained by his customers, stockholders, board of directors, lending institutions, as well as numerous laws, and, if all else fails, product liability statutes. In addition there is a veritable alphabet soup of governmental agencies which oversee his product, conduct with employees, public safety, product safety, environmental compliance, and financial performance.

In fact capitalists are over-regulated, which causes a considerable burden to be put on the public in the form of increased prices. A noteworthy fact is: the most egregious acts against the consumer, the environment, and the public in general, have all been made by socialist states.

Kuleana

Re: Dammit, Bernie (liberal rant)
« Reply #108 on: February 17, 2016, 07:51:15 PM »
Aloha MMM,

My comments in bold.


FROM:Molon Labe Industries
February 15 at 6:30am · Belleair Beach, FL ·
How many of you know people who think that socialism is just about being nice...?

In the 20th century there have been numerous political systems, but in the latter half of the century there were only two survivors, Socialism and Capitalism. So we have at this time in the Western world, which for all practical purposes controls the world, two opposing political systems. (I have already previously stated that there is no basic difference between socialists and communists. There are, however, some very important factors relating to socialism of which you should be aware. Socialism will not work in a free market economy and, as a consequence it invariably deteriorates into a totalitarian state. Anyone wishing to argue that point is asked to point to one single instance where this was not the result).

The author's statement that socialism and communism has no differences is his opinion to which I disagree.  The are a number of theoretical differences between the two and examples in history to show this.  In the Wiemar Republic, you had the socialist-democrats, national socialists, fascists, and communists.


It therefore behooves us to remember who the worst despotic governments of this century were: Nazis in Germany, Fascists in Italy, Communists in the USSR, [Romania, East Germany, Bulgaria, Hungary, Yugoslavia, Czechoslovakia, Poland, Cuba, North Korea, Cambodia, Vietnam, etc.] and China - each and every one of them a paragon of socialist endeavor. Their leaders; Hitler, Mussolini, Stalin [Ceausescu, Tito, Pol Pot, etc.] and Mao Tse Tung. The outstanding legacy of these individuals is that they each tried to out-do the others in the total number of their own citizens which they murdered. It is a fact that each of these men killed more of their own civilian citizens than they lost in military conflict.

The author tries to lump all the dictators together forgetting that each had their own unique take on socialism that was different to each other.


The reason for this is inherent to socialism. It promises things that it cannot possibly deliver. When socialist politicians in power come to the realization that it is impossible to deliver on their promises and political unrest develops, they have two options if they plan to stay in power. First, they must locate a scapegoat on whom they can blame their inability to deliver. Any Jew can tell you who that was for the Germans and the Russians. The second is to develop, and rapidly so, a state security apparatus to keep them in office - the SS, the KGB, [Securitate, Stasi] etc.

The basic tenets of socialism are:
1. Seduce the populace into accepting the government as the arbitrator of all problems; government from cradle-to-grave
2. Begin delivering on those services to make the citizens dependent
3. Take away the citizens' guns
4. Increase taxes on all services while destroying any free market alternative services
5. Blame the chosen scapegoat for the inability to meet demand for services
6. Have the centralized national police force round up any dissidents

Socialism cannot work because the cost of services must be collected in the form of taxes, and this is not a sustainable possibility. The reason is that since government pays for all services, neither the producer nor the consumer cares about the cost, and hence there is an uncontrolled spiral of inflation (today's medical costs are a case in point and healthcare is not yet totally socialized).

The out-of-control health care costs in the US is not because of a movement towards socialized medicine, but by the collusion by the capitalist insurance companies and their allies in Congress setting the laws in their favor.


Furthermore, the government has no funds or assets. It only has the funds it confiscated from its citizens. The total inefficiency of a centralized bureaucracy does not help either.
Once citizens are weaned on this cradle-to-grave concept and are no longer self-reliant, they become wards of the state and will not accept any reduction of services. The government subsequently has no option but to reduce services, and as popular resistance develops State repression begins. This is the socialist cycle. It has been found to occur in every socialist state in existence to date.

The current most outrageous examples of this are North Korea and Cuba. These two societies share much in common - both are socialist, both are totalitarian, both have more political prisoners then any nation close to their size, both have non-working universal health care, in both the citizens suffer malnutrition, and both have food and fuel rationing. Their leaders and party members, in the meantime, eat caviar and drink champagne.

The author proudly mentions North Korea and Cuba as the poster children of the failures of socialist states.  He cleverly leaves out China which is the most current example of a relatively successful socialist state as they are posed to lead the World in GDP in the next 10 years.


Socialism can never work in any environment. It violates human nature and logic.

The author really needs to address China if he really wants to prove the failure of socialism.


The capitalist economic system differs greatly from its socialist adversary in numerous ways. While the socialist system is a top down centralized arrangement, the capitalist system, which can only exist in a free market economy that recognizes the right of private property, is totally controlled by the market itself. Interestingly, personal freedom, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness can also only thrive in free market economies. Capitalism is a sort of volatile and confusing situation where the capital markets dictate demand, price, and methods of distribution. The reason that the left is so very successful in criticizing capitalism is because it is not regulated and therefore difficult to explain. The reason capitalism works so well is that demand dictates production as well as price, thus avoiding market inequities and shortages.

The author clearly is delusional in his explanation of capitalism. All what he writes is the theoretical outcomes of what should happen in the perfect case of capitalism.  He leaves out the empirical realities of small amounts of rich and large amounts of poor that [b]ALWAYS[/u] results in capitalism in the long-run.  Furthermore, he forgets the rise of OLIGOPOLIES and MONOPOLIES that also results in capitalism when there is no government control in the free-market.[/b]


Socialism's principal theorem is centralization of markets under government control. This has never worked and there is not one single instance in world history where centralized governmental market manipulation has been successful. This, however, does not deter the Robert Reichs (America's socialist Secretary of Labor who said, "Greedy corporations are screwing their employees, squeezing down wages while increasing profits." This statement, from an economic illiterate who has never in his entire life worked for, or in, a business that made a profit. He appears to me to be a little man with a Napoleon complex, who, while having no clue about anything to do with economics, presents himself as a great expert. Corporate downsizing, mergers, and staff reductions has a great deal to do with international trade policies, NAFTA, EC, WTO, etc. and very little to do with greed.) of this world, who continuously make every effort to centralize economic as well as social and political power for themselves and their Satori masters (the ruling elite).

Once again, completely delusional. Are we to believe that international trade policies are the main reason US corporations are flocking to cheap labor sweat shops in China and Mexico?  BS! Moreover, when a company decides to downside, it is almost always to protect its self-interest, profit margins, at the expense of workers. Is this bad? NO!  But does workers get screwed over because of this?  YES!


George Washington said it best: "Government, like fire, is a good servant, but a fearful master." All capitalist functions are directed at free market concepts. A free market is one that serves society with little government interference. This concept is unpopular with the Satori because in order to attain more and more power they require centralization of all economic, social, and political functions. Because of their poor performance in the political frame they have altered their modus operandi and are now implementing their schemes through judicial activism. These judicial incursions, which by the way, in the United States are in violation of constitutional law, have been sold to the public based on the false misnomer that greedy capitalists don't care about the people, their welfare, safety, or health, but that politicians do.

Sure, I'm sure the fracking oil companies had the people safety in-mind when evidence began surfacing that their activities are causing earthquakes in the vicinity of their operations.


This, without doubt, is a ludicrous statement. The capitalist must perform to market standards. Competition will put him out of business if he provides an inferior product or service. He is furthermore constrained by his customers, stockholders, board of directors, lending institutions, as well as numerous laws, and, if all else fails, product liability statutes. In addition there is a veritable alphabet soup of governmental agencies which oversee his product, conduct with employees, public safety, product safety, environmental compliance, and financial performance.

In fact capitalists are over-regulated, which causes a considerable burden to be put on the public in the form of increased prices. A noteworthy fact is: the most egregious acts against the consumer, the environment, and the public in general, have all been made by socialist states.

The truth is those markets that need more government regulation are not receiving it (i.e., Wall Street) and those that would prosper well with less regulation are receiving more (i.e., firearm industry).


Kuleana

eyeeatingfish

Re: Dammit, Bernie (liberal rant)
« Reply #109 on: February 17, 2016, 08:12:27 PM »
why answer a loaded question?

It isn't loaded, it is a consequence of the premise, it would be a consequence of a insurance system for police services.

eyeeatingfish

Re: Dammit, Bernie (liberal rant)
« Reply #110 on: February 17, 2016, 08:13:53 PM »
It doesn't matter what anyone else said, and whether you are white or not makes absolutely no difference to me, but based on the fact that you raised this statement on your own accord, are YOU then saying that you are NOT white?

I pose that question to anyone who assumes an individuals race based on their political standing.

MMM

Re: Dammit, Bernie (liberal rant)
« Reply #111 on: February 17, 2016, 08:50:16 PM »
aloha kuleana,

my comments below in blue.


Aloha MMM,

My comments in bold.


FROM:Molon Labe Industries
February 15 at 6:30am · Belleair Beach, FL ·
How many of you know people who think that socialism is just about being nice...?

In the 20th century there have been numerous political systems, but in the latter half of the century there were only two survivors, Socialism and Capitalism. So we have at this time in the Western world, which for all practical purposes controls the world, two opposing political systems. (I have already previously stated that there is no basic difference between socialists and communists. There are, however, some very important factors relating to socialism of which you should be aware. Socialism will not work in a free market economy and, as a consequence it invariably deteriorates into a totalitarian state. Anyone wishing to argue that point is asked to point to one single instance where this was not the result).

The author's statement that socialism and communism has no differences is his opinion to which I disagree.  The are a number of theoretical differences between the two and examples in history to show this.  In the Wiemar Republic, you had the socialist-democrats, national socialists, fascists, and communists.


It therefore behooves us to remember who the worst despotic governments of this century were: Nazis in Germany, Fascists in Italy, Communists in the USSR, [Romania, East Germany, Bulgaria, Hungary, Yugoslavia, Czechoslovakia, Poland, Cuba, North Korea, Cambodia, Vietnam, etc.] and China - each and every one of them a paragon of socialist endeavor. Their leaders; Hitler, Mussolini, Stalin [Ceausescu, Tito, Pol Pot, etc.] and Mao Tse Tung. The outstanding legacy of these individuals is that they each tried to out-do the others in the total number of their own citizens which they murdered. It is a fact that each of these men killed more of their own civilian citizens than they lost in military conflict.

The author tries to lump all the dictators together forgetting that each had their own unique take on socialism that was different to each other.


The reason for this is inherent to socialism. It promises things that it cannot possibly deliver. When socialist politicians in power come to the realization that it is impossible to deliver on their promises and political unrest develops, they have two options if they plan to stay in power. First, they must locate a scapegoat on whom they can blame their inability to deliver. Any Jew can tell you who that was for the Germans and the Russians. The second is to develop, and rapidly so, a state security apparatus to keep them in office - the SS, the KGB, [Securitate, Stasi] etc.

The basic tenets of socialism are:
1. Seduce the populace into accepting the government as the arbitrator of all problems; government from cradle-to-grave
2. Begin delivering on those services to make the citizens dependent
3. Take away the citizens' guns
4. Increase taxes on all services while destroying any free market alternative services
5. Blame the chosen scapegoat for the inability to meet demand for services
6. Have the centralized national police force round up any dissidents

Socialism cannot work because the cost of services must be collected in the form of taxes, and this is not a sustainable possibility. The reason is that since government pays for all services, neither the producer nor the consumer cares about the cost, and hence there is an uncontrolled spiral of inflation (today's medical costs are a case in point and healthcare is not yet totally socialized).

The out-of-control health care costs in the US is not because of a movement towards socialized medicine, but by the collusion by the capitalist insurance companies and their allies in Congress setting the laws in their favor.


Furthermore, the government has no funds or assets. It only has the funds it confiscated from its citizens. The total inefficiency of a centralized bureaucracy does not help either.
Once citizens are weaned on this cradle-to-grave concept and are no longer self-reliant, they become wards of the state and will not accept any reduction of services. The government subsequently has no option but to reduce services, and as popular resistance develops State repression begins. This is the socialist cycle. It has been found to occur in every socialist state in existence to date.

The current most outrageous examples of this are North Korea and Cuba. These two societies share much in common - both are socialist, both are totalitarian, both have more political prisoners then any nation close to their size, both have non-working universal health care, in both the citizens suffer malnutrition, and both have food and fuel rationing. Their leaders and party members, in the meantime, eat caviar and drink champagne.

The author proudly mentions North Korea and Cuba as the poster children of the failures of socialist states.  He cleverly leaves out China which is the most current example of a relatively successful socialist state as they are posed to lead the World in GDP in the next 10 years.


Socialism can never work in any environment. It violates human nature and logic.

The author really needs to address China if he really wants to prove the failure of socialism.


The capitalist economic system differs greatly from its socialist adversary in numerous ways. While the socialist system is a top down centralized arrangement, the capitalist system, which can only exist in a free market economy that recognizes the right of private property, is totally controlled by the market itself. Interestingly, personal freedom, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness can also only thrive in free market economies. Capitalism is a sort of volatile and confusing situation where the capital markets dictate demand, price, and methods of distribution. The reason that the left is so very successful in criticizing capitalism is because it is not regulated and therefore difficult to explain. The reason capitalism works so well is that demand dictates production as well as price, thus avoiding market inequities and shortages.

The author clearly is delusional in his explanation of capitalism. All what he writes is the theoretical outcomes of what should happen in the perfect case of capitalism.  He leaves out the empirical realities of small amounts of rich and large amounts of poor that [b]ALWAYS[/u] results in capitalism in the long-run.  Furthermore, he forgets the rise of OLIGOPOLIES and MONOPOLIES that also results in capitalism when there is no government control in the free-market.[/b]


Socialism's principal theorem is centralization of markets under government control. This has never worked and there is not one single instance in world history where centralized governmental market manipulation has been successful. This, however, does not deter the Robert Reichs (America's socialist Secretary of Labor who said, "Greedy corporations are screwing their employees, squeezing down wages while increasing profits." This statement, from an economic illiterate who has never in his entire life worked for, or in, a business that made a profit. He appears to me to be a little man with a Napoleon complex, who, while having no clue about anything to do with economics, presents himself as a great expert. Corporate downsizing, mergers, and staff reductions has a great deal to do with international trade policies, NAFTA, EC, WTO, etc. and very little to do with greed.) of this world, who continuously make every effort to centralize economic as well as social and political power for themselves and their Satori masters (the ruling elite).

Once again, completely delusional. Are we to believe that international trade policies are the main reason US corporations are flocking to cheap labor sweat shops in China and Mexico?  BS! Moreover, when a company decides to downside, it is almost always to protect its self-interest, profit margins, at the expense of workers. Is this bad? NO!  But does workers get screwed over because of this?  YES!


George Washington said it best: "Government, like fire, is a good servant, but a fearful master." All capitalist functions are directed at free market concepts. A free market is one that serves society with little government interference. This concept is unpopular with the Satori because in order to attain more and more power they require centralization of all economic, social, and political functions. Because of their poor performance in the political frame they have altered their modus operandi and are now implementing their schemes through judicial activism. These judicial incursions, which by the way, in the United States are in violation of constitutional law, have been sold to the public based on the false misnomer that greedy capitalists don't care about the people, their welfare, safety, or health, but that politicians do.

Sure, I'm sure the fracking oil companies had the people safety in-mind when evidence began surfacing that their activities are causing earthquakes in the vicinity of their operations.


This, without doubt, is a ludicrous statement. The capitalist must perform to market standards. Competition will put him out of business if he provides an inferior product or service. He is furthermore constrained by his customers, stockholders, board of directors, lending institutions, as well as numerous laws, and, if all else fails, product liability statutes. In addition there is a veritable alphabet soup of governmental agencies which oversee his product, conduct with employees, public safety, product safety, environmental compliance, and financial performance.

In fact capitalists are over-regulated, which causes a considerable burden to be put on the public in the form of increased prices. A noteworthy fact is: the most egregious acts against the consumer, the environment, and the public in general, have all been made by socialist states.

The truth is those markets that need more government regulation are not receiving it (i.e., Wall Street) and those that would prosper well with less regulation are receiving more (i.e., firearm industry).


Kuleana

so..........you're a socialist, bernie sanders lover?!    :rofl: :rofl:

new guy

Re: Dammit, Bernie (liberal rant)
« Reply #112 on: February 17, 2016, 08:50:52 PM »
.
« Last Edit: August 11, 2016, 12:15:40 AM by new guy »
Your mindset is your primary weapon. - Jeff Cooper

Kuleana

Re: Dammit, Bernie (liberal rant)
« Reply #113 on: February 17, 2016, 09:07:50 PM »
Aloha MMM,

"so..........you're a socialist, bernie sanders lover?!    :rofl: :rofl:"

No, I am not!

I am a political and economic ideological pragmatist, who believes the best political and economic system is the one most convenient given the current socio-economic situation present in society.



Kuleana

aieahound

Re: Dammit, Bernie (liberal rant)
« Reply #114 on: February 17, 2016, 09:12:24 PM »
3 words...

Made in China.

The most common words on our capitalist goods...made in a Socialist country.

Why is that and what's wrong with that ?
(And there's definitely something wrong with that.)
« Last Edit: February 17, 2016, 09:24:02 PM by aieahound »

hvybarrels

Re: Dammit, Bernie (liberal rant)
« Reply #115 on: February 17, 2016, 09:32:32 PM »
You don't need a parachute to go skydiving. You need a parachute to go skydiving twice.

eyeeatingfish

Re: Dammit, Bernie (liberal rant)
« Reply #116 on: February 18, 2016, 02:41:01 AM »
My question has nothing to do with political standing.

My question has everything to do with the veracity and truthfulness (or lack thereof) in your posts.

You claim to be objective and open-minded, so to quote you:

I rarely ever lie as a matter of principle and personal aversion, and my activity on 2A is no exception.

But to your specific question of whether I am saying I am not white, No I am not saying I am not white. But my question was to Ren since he asked.

eyeeatingfish

Re: Dammit, Bernie (liberal rant)
« Reply #117 on: February 18, 2016, 06:00:38 AM »
Heavies, than you for that great video.

I think what EEF (especially) and aieahound are being adamant about and trying to point out is that elements of socialism exists in America.

When the government interfered with the free market by bailing out the banks and the auto industry, aieahound called it "elite socialism". (I called it "crony capitalism".)  To ask like Hillary, "what difference does it make?"

The salient detail that I see is whether we are a capitalist society that is acting a bit socialist or are we a socialist society that is acting a bit capitalist.

I would say America is the former and a country like China would be more of the latter.  America is a free society (thanks to the founding fathers and to the Constitution) that allowed elements of socialism to exist ("socialistic capitalism"). Communist China is a socialist country that allowed elements of capitalism to exist ("capitalistic socialism").

More government control represent more socialism, while more individual control represent more capitalism. To which side does the balance of power currently tip?

Has America been transformed to a point where it is now a socialist country acting capitalistic?  I certainly hope not.

My questions to hvybarrels, EEF and aieahound:

1) What do you think about "socialistic capitalism" or about "capitalistic socialism"?  Do you see any relevant difference between them?

2) Are European countries or Canada more "socialistic capitalism" or are they more "capitalistic socialism"?  What about America?

3) Which one do you think is better?  Is one more immoral than the other?

I will give my opinion here,

1) I agree with your assessment but the labeling can be a little confusing. In the USA I think the socialistic elements do not all have to do with the economy, rather they exist mostly in terms of government service. Under the one definition of socialism that has the government owning private industries this does not exactly qualify us as socialistic though. To be a little picky, you might need to lengthen the label for America. Perhaps a socialistic democratic capitalism. If we wanted to get really technical I am sure you could add a few more terms onto that label. The USA government regulates the market but it does not own it, (not socialism as I understand it.) We can talk about socialism in America in separate areas I believe. Socialism in government services and socialism in government ownership of the economy.

2) I think Europe, to overgeneralize, is more socialistic in terms of government as well as economy but certainly significantly less than China. I am not that well studied about Canada's economy or the various European economies though so I think my opinion here is fairly weak and just stems from a loose understanding.

3) I think morality is irrelevant. It is like asking if a gun is evil. It is neither, just a tool that can be used for good or evil.

I prefer free market capitalism to a socialism government controlled market because I believe the free market is much more adaptive, robust, and efficient. Having said that, we don't have a truly free market either. We have a regulated hence somewhat free market, and rightly so. A truly free market would allow for the existence of slavery if it were profitable for example. (It actually does, just not legally) I think any pure form of government can be used to abuse people.

So while I reject socialism in our economy, I do believe in government funded social programs in very limited situations such as free (subsidized) k-12 education and a few others.  I maintain that public education is a form of socialism as it does consist of taxes taken from all being used for the benefit of a select group. I prefer the school be locally controlled as opposed to being federally controlled but the level of government that controls the school is irrelevant to whether a public subsidized school is a form of socialism. I support this limited application of socialism because of the many benefits it provides all of the people in the community. I can elaborate if needed.

I do wish to retract on earlier statement when I suggested that a government funded police/fire department was socialism because I now realize that there is no disparity in terms of payment and eligibility for service. All pay taxes to support a police department and all are eligible to receive services. This is in contrast to a school which only offers services to those with children.

Bottom line as well is that the government is only going to be as effective as the people who elect it. That's why when we try to set up a tested form of government in other countries following war, it doesn't always work.

dustoff003

Re: Dammit, Bernie (liberal rant)
« Reply #118 on: February 18, 2016, 06:10:44 AM »
^^^^^ I think we're done here folks^^^^ yeah!!!!! and I gave MD grief... Sorry

Inspector

Re: Dammit, Bernie (liberal rant)
« Reply #119 on: February 18, 2016, 06:57:11 AM »
^^^^^ I think we're done here folks^^^^ yeah!!!!! and I gave MD grief... Sorry
MD is no longer with us.  :'( :'( :'(

Rest in peace my friend.  :o :o :o
SCIENCE THAT CAN’T BE QUESTIONED IS PROPAGANDA!!!