Dammit, Bernie (liberal rant) (Read 86990 times)

Aegis808

Re: Dammit, Bernie (liberal rant)
« Reply #140 on: February 23, 2016, 03:53:44 PM »
Aegis,

i don't understand.
I don't think you thought this through.

Please see my prior post or expand on your thinking because this is interesting.

Oh I've thought it through quite a lot. Anything and everything the government does can be provided through voluntary actions and/or mutual consent.

For a more thorough explanation of the functions of such a society you can watch the following video.

aieahound

Re: Dammit, Bernie (liberal rant)
« Reply #141 on: February 23, 2016, 04:29:50 PM »
That was interesting but that guy is super naive and optimistic people do what makes sense.
And that everyone can afford it.
Sort of exactly the Karl Marx of anarchism. (Anti-socialism)

And he limits the governments role to police and judicial.
Which brings me back to...
Privatize everything ? Interesting concept.

Would there be any government regulation ?

And who would pay the freeway and common use thoroughfare repairs and maintenance ?
And do we police ourselves and put out our own fires? Or do they only service those who purchased those services from the private companies ?
Of course their would multiple fire dept's and police dept's to choose from.
Who chooses which of the various private courts to adjudicate in ?
And do you pay for the incarceration of the perp who committed the crime against you ? 
Of course no public parks either. Everything would be pay to use.
Etc.....

But would it be cheaper than taxes ? Serious question. Might be, I don't know.

And our individual national defense bills would be ginormous.
Unless I can opt out of national defense. Everyone would.
And who would collect everyone's share of all the shared expenses ?
we would have to subscribe to the road guy to use the roads. The road guy would have to hire his own cops to enforce that only paying customers use the roads.
Who would the street light guy collect from ?

 :stopjack:

 MMM,
I agree

my biggest rant with bernie: "how you gonna pay for everything you promised?"

i can bet it's coming out of my ass through a lot more in taxes.
« Last Edit: February 23, 2016, 04:42:44 PM by aieahound »

Aegis808

Re: Dammit, Bernie (liberal rant)
« Reply #142 on: February 23, 2016, 10:04:58 PM »
That was interesting but that guy is super naive and optimistic people do what makes sense.
And that everyone can afford it.
Sort of exactly the Karl Marx of anarchism. (Anti-socialism)

And he limits the governments role to police and judicial.
Which brings me back to...
And our individual national defense bills would be ginormous.
Unless I can opt out of national defense. Everyone would.
And who would collect everyone's share of all the shared expenses ?
we would have to subscribe to the road guy to use the roads. The road guy would have to hire his own cops to enforce that only paying customers use the roads.
Who would the street light guy collect from ?

 :stopjack:

 MMM,
I agree

Naive? So you're saying you can't find a way to pay for things you like without enslaving everyone else?

The naive and optimistic one here is you, you think it's completely rational that there needs to be people running around demanding everyone give them money by threat of death so there can be services that people want.

Aegis808

Re: Dammit, Bernie (liberal rant)
« Reply #143 on: February 23, 2016, 10:09:24 PM »
Don't forget, WHO WILL BUILD THE ROADS?
are you so naive to think that government should be allowed to have a monopoly over road building technology?

Aegis808

Re: Dammit, Bernie (liberal rant)
« Reply #144 on: February 23, 2016, 10:20:49 PM »
As to the issue of national defense, when was the last time the US was involved in a defensive war that wasn't from the consequences of our terrible foreign policy?


that national defense budget is working very effectively at putting cities into martial law.

aieahound

Re: Dammit, Bernie (liberal rant)
« Reply #145 on: February 23, 2016, 11:30:00 PM »
How would the fee structure be set up ? ( community used items such as roads, who selects the contractor and pays them)
Who would pay for what ? ( and who would enforce it ? And who would pay for enforcement ?)
And could everyone opt out of anything they don't want ?
And then could it be enforced that they are barred from any services they opted out of ?
subscriptions to all services you want ?
Close the armed forces ?

Like I said. Sounds like the Karl Marx of anarchism (anti-socialism)

And would it be cheaper/more cost effective per individual than government ?

I'm not trying to be argumentative, just trying to get to specifics of how it could actually work.

Too many pigs at the trough and not enough grain.
Classic quote on Bernies rant hvybarrels
« Last Edit: February 23, 2016, 11:35:39 PM by aieahound »

Aegis808

Re: Dammit, Bernie (liberal rant)
« Reply #146 on: February 24, 2016, 01:24:03 AM »
How would the fee structure be set up ? ( community used items such as roads, who selects the contractor and pays them)
Who would pay for what ? ( and who would enforce it ? And who would pay for enforcement ?)
And could everyone opt out of anything they don't want ?
And then could it be enforced that they are barred from any services they opted out of ?
subscriptions to all services you want ?
Close the armed forces ?

Like I said. Sounds like the Karl Marx of anarchism (anti-socialism)

And would it be cheaper/more cost effective per individual than government ?

I'm not trying to be argumentative, just trying to get to specifics of how it could actually work.
Classic quote on Bernies rant hvybarrels

How does a business of any sort figure out all of your questions?
If govt were in charge of building all the roofs in the US would you be asking the very same question about who would build the roofs?

eyeeatingfish

Re: Dammit, Bernie (liberal rant)
« Reply #147 on: February 24, 2016, 04:56:45 PM »
the same way any business obtains funds, by providing services at a quality and price that people will pay for.

So lets say that you want to pay for the service of the military but I do not. Will they only protect your house from foreign invasion?

There are a certain most basic level of services that the government has to provide for (in my opinion) and a pay if you want to is not realistic.

Justice for example, if you make it a pay to play system then inevitably lead to no justice for a fair portion of our population.

Many of the basic important functions of government are not things that people will voluntarily pay for, taxation is necessary at at least some level.

Do you think people should have to pay money if they want to vote? (elections cost money) Your pay for the services you want system will mean those who cannot afford to vote will get no voice. 
No ambulance ride unless you can prove you can pay for it (good luck if unconscious)
No justice unless you buy police insurance
The poor will suffer much more since they won't be able to afford the basic services
You also have to buy court insurance just in case you have to protect your rights listed in the bill of rights, so basically if you are poor, you have no freedom of speech.

What you are hinting at seems like anarchy where everything is controlled but he rich.
« Last Edit: February 24, 2016, 05:02:05 PM by eyeeatingfish »

Aegis808

Re: Dammit, Bernie (liberal rant)
« Reply #148 on: February 24, 2016, 11:59:22 PM »
So lets say that you want to pay for the service of the military but I do not. Will they only protect your house from foreign invasion?

There are a certain most basic level of services that the government has to provide for (in my opinion) and a pay if you want to is not realistic.

Justice for example, if you make it a pay to play system then inevitably lead to no justice for a fair portion of our population.

Many of the basic important functions of government are not things that people will voluntarily pay for, taxation is necessary at at least some level.

Do you think people should have to pay money if they want to vote? (elections cost money) Your pay for the services you want system will mean those who cannot afford to vote will get no voice. 
No ambulance ride unless you can prove you can pay for it (good luck if unconscious)
No justice unless you buy police insurance
The poor will suffer much more since they won't be able to afford the basic services
You also have to buy court insurance just in case you have to protect your rights listed in the bill of rights, so basically if you are poor, you have no freedom of speech.

What you are hinting at seems like anarchy where everything is controlled but he rich.

are you implying that the rich don't control everything right now?
do the courts right now give you all your rights?
the poor don't suffer right now?
people don't die if they can't buy medical care right now?
justice isn't pay to play right now?

every single obstacle you bring up is already faced by the government we have right now.

every time you say taxation is necessary you are saying that you can't imagine a way to provide for things without slavery.

eyeeatingfish

Re: Dammit, Bernie (liberal rant)
« Reply #149 on: February 25, 2016, 05:45:59 AM »
are you implying that the rich don't control everything right now?
do the courts right now give you all your rights?
the poor don't suffer right now?
people don't die if they can't buy medical care right now?
justice isn't pay to play right now?

every single obstacle you bring up is already faced by the government we have right now.

every time you say taxation is necessary you are saying that you can't imagine a way to provide for things without slavery.

You are changing the topic. Pointing to our less than perfect current system doesn't prove that your system would be better.

But to use justice as an example, yes the poor can get justice. If they call 911 the police will respond and make a case for them. They might not get all the same treatment as someone rich and famous but they will get the services as opposed to your system which guarantees they wont.

Aegis808

Re: Dammit, Bernie (liberal rant)
« Reply #150 on: February 25, 2016, 09:48:50 AM »
You are changing the topic. Pointing to our less than perfect current system doesn't prove that your system would be better.

But to use justice as an example, yes the poor can get justice. If they call 911 the police will respond and make a case for them. They might not get all the same treatment as someone rich and famous but they will get the services as opposed to your system which guarantees they wont.

Actually my topic has always been that taxation is theft. You keep bringing up different excuses that have nothing to do with this fact.

When is taxation no longer theft? Why do you think a theft based society is better?

as to your example of 911 and the police must respond to your call regardless of how much money you have. It's such a terrible claim that even the very government you're defending says it has no obligation to respond to 911 calls. During the LA riots the police were police setting up protection zones around poor neighborhoods? How many homeless in Hawaii are being saved by the police in their sit, lie, ban sweeps?

But by all means keep using broken reasoning on a system that doesn't even work the way you describe it.

Jl808

Dammit, Bernie (liberal rant)
« Reply #151 on: February 25, 2016, 01:52:48 PM »
Aegis808, that video you posted is very intriguing. I'm trying to wrap my head around the concept that everything is done through private enterprise but I wonder if this would be an unattainable concept too.

For example, when you said that roads and roofs would be done the same way, I don't think it's the same since a roof is used by a single family while a road is used by the entire public.

I like the concept but I'm having a hard time imagining how it would work universally.

Take roads for example.

I'm trying to imagine what urban planing would be like for roads if people are free to run their roads as they wish.

For example, if I built a section of a road, can I charge toll for it?  What if another person wants to build a road next it mine?  Or if the route is very popular and many people need to go through it from point A to B, what if 100 people want to build the exact same road? 1,000?

Or what about water access rights?  If I happened to own the land that the only water reserves were on, then I would be a very wealthy person charging for a very precious commodity that people cannot live without.  Or if it was a river and my property is upstream, would it be ethical for me to block the flow of the river so the folks downstream cannot use it?

Again, I like the idea but it seems like "anarchy". Maybe I need to read up some "science fiction" books.
I think, therefore I am armed.
NRA Life Patron member, HRA Life member, HiFiCo Life Member, HDF member

The United States Constitution © 1791. All Rights Reserved.

Aegis808

Re: Dammit, Bernie (liberal rant)
« Reply #152 on: February 25, 2016, 02:09:31 PM »
Aegis808, that video you posted is very intriguing. I'm trying to wrap my head around the concept that everything is done through private enterprise but I wonder if this would be an unattainable concept too.

For example, when you said that roads and roofs would be done the same way, I don't think it's the same since a roof is used by a single family while a road is used by the entire public.

I like the concept but I'm having a hard time imagining how it would work universally.

Take roads for example.

I'm trying to imagine what urban planing would be like for roads if people are free to run their roads as they wish.

For example, if I built a section of a road, can I charge toll for it?  What if another person wants to build a road next it mine?  Or if the route is very popular and many people need to go through it from point A to B, what if 100 people want to build the exact same road? 1,000?

Or what about water access rights?  If I happened to own the land that the only water reserves were on, then I would be a very wealthy person charging for a very precious commodity that people cannot live without.  Or if it was a river and my property is upstream, would it be ethical for me to block the flow of the river so the folks downstream cannot use it?

Again, I like the idea but it seems like "anarchy". Maybe I need to read up some "science fiction" books.

All regulated by the laws of supply and demand.

As to ethics for water, doesn't the government we have right now do the very same thing in Maui? Doesn't the government on the Mainland do the very same thing with the colorado river? who holds them accountable? Is there any way to opt out of the unethical actions of the government?

eyeeatingfish

Re: Dammit, Bernie (liberal rant)
« Reply #153 on: February 26, 2016, 10:10:28 AM »
All regulated by the laws of supply and demand.

As to ethics for water, doesn't the government we have right now do the very same thing in Maui? Doesn't the government on the Mainland do the very same thing with the colorado river? who holds them accountable? Is there any way to opt out of the unethical actions of the government?

I think you could find a system like that which actually exists but in micro form in the form of condominium associations. They are privately owned properties which are regulated by bylaws that require all owners to pay a certain amount which together maintains the property. The problem is that this is created through public laws. It only works because they can legally force you to cooperate.

The law of supply and demand is not fool proof. Lets say all of us live on the same road and we hire someone to pave it and make it nice. Maybe other people use it a lot and we charge a tole. But now one resident decides they aren't going to maintain the portion fronting their house, or is just crazy and blocks the road. This person who decides not to pay now drags down everyone else because either they pick up the bill for him/her or the road (service) suffers.

The government controlling the waterway is a poor analogy. The voters hold the government accountable and they are not a for profit agency that would raise the prices so much as to starve the poor if it meant a good profit. Lets say in your completely private economy system I decide to drop my drawers and poop in your water supply, what does supply and demand say about that?

Supply and demand can still end up being two wolves and a sheet deciding what is for dinner.

Aegis808

Re: Dammit, Bernie (liberal rant)
« Reply #154 on: February 26, 2016, 10:51:10 AM »
I think you could find a system like that which actually exists but in micro form in the form of condominium associations. They are privately owned properties which are regulated by bylaws that require all owners to pay a certain amount which together maintains the property. The problem is that this is created through public laws. It only works because they can legally force you to cooperate.

The law of supply and demand is not fool proof. Lets say all of us live on the same road and we hire someone to pave it and make it nice. Maybe other people use it a lot and we charge a tole. But now one resident decides they aren't going to maintain the portion fronting their house, or is just crazy and blocks the road. This person who decides not to pay now drags down everyone else because either they pick up the bill for him/her or the road (service) suffers.

The government controlling the waterway is a poor analogy. The voters hold the government accountable and they are not a for profit agency that would raise the prices so much as to starve the poor if it meant a good profit. Lets say in your completely private economy system I decide to drop my drawers and poop in your water supply, what does supply and demand say about that?

Supply and demand can still end up being two wolves and a sheet deciding what is for dinner.

How much accountability has been used for the 19 trillion dollars in national debt? How about voter accountability in Hawaii, when are the voters gonna start holding the government accountable for the stupid gun laws and rampant nepotism? Wheres the voters holding the government accountable for the poisoned water in Flint, Michigan?

How many terrible examples are you going to try to imagine will happen under a tax free world, when they have all been happening with taxation?

Still waiting for the answer of at what point is taxation is no longer theft.

aieahound

Re: Dammit, Bernie (liberal rant)
« Reply #155 on: February 26, 2016, 11:07:22 AM »
Still waiting for the answer of at what point is taxation is no longer theft.

In my opinion, taxation is theft only when the taxpayer no longer uses any public amenities, such as roads, parks, fire dept. Etc...

How much we're taxed and how it's spent....now that's a whole nother story called politics.

Still waiting for the answer as to would the privatized system be equitable and cheaper and how it would work specifically.
Answers such as would run like business are generalizations and sound like Trump when asked how he will do the things he says he'll do.

And I'm not arguing. I'm seriously interested as to how this thing could work.
« Last Edit: February 26, 2016, 11:13:44 AM by aieahound »

eyeeatingfish

Re: Dammit, Bernie (liberal rant)
« Reply #156 on: February 27, 2016, 08:54:22 AM »
How much accountability has been used for the 19 trillion dollars in national debt? How about voter accountability in Hawaii, when are the voters gonna start holding the government accountable for the stupid gun laws and rampant nepotism? Wheres the voters holding the government accountable for the poisoned water in Flint, Michigan?

How many terrible examples are you going to try to imagine will happen under a tax free world, when they have all been happening with taxation?

Still waiting for the answer of at what point is taxation is no longer theft.

You sidestepped all of my points again by trying to point out problems in the current system. These are valid criticism of the current system but you completely fail to address the more serious criticism of the system you propose.
All the terrible examples I gave you are less terrible than the problems of our current system.

Theft is the illegal taking of money by legal definition, so any legally passed tax law is technically not theft. But if we go into a moral/ethical side of it then I would say that taxation becomes theft when it is done in excess to support leaders instead of support the job of the government. Taxation for roads and police and fire department and schools is not theft.

Aegis808

Re: Dammit, Bernie (liberal rant)
« Reply #157 on: February 29, 2016, 11:48:51 PM »
You sidestepped all of my points again by trying to point out problems in the current system. These are valid criticism of the current system but you completely fail to address the more serious criticism of the system you propose.
All the terrible examples I gave you are less terrible than the problems of our current system.

Theft is the illegal taking of money by legal definition, so any legally passed tax law is technically not theft. But if we go into a moral/ethical side of it then I would say that taxation becomes theft when it is done in excess to support leaders instead of support the job of the government. Taxation for roads and police and fire department and schools is not theft.

how many people does it take to make taxation no longer theft? If the government passes a law that it okay to have sex with your wife on your wedding night against her will, is it no longer rape?

if i get a gang big enough and vote that we can take money from you is it no longer theft? If i use the money to make sure your property isn't taken by me or burned down, is it no longer theft?

what criticism can you possibly say about a society that isn't tax based can happen that doesn't already happen in a tax based society?
why is it that the problems you think will be prevented through taxes, actually happen? Taxes to protect property, even though taxation is the very theft of property?

Aegis808

Re: Dammit, Bernie (liberal rant)
« Reply #158 on: February 29, 2016, 11:50:14 PM »
In my opinion, taxation is theft only when the taxpayer no longer uses any public amenities, such as roads, parks, fire dept. Etc...

How much we're taxed and how it's spent....now that's a whole nother story called politics.

Still waiting for the answer as to would the privatized system be equitable and cheaper and how it would work specifically.
Answers such as would run like business are generalizations and sound like Trump when asked how he will do the things he says he'll do.

And I'm not arguing. I'm seriously interested as to how this thing could work.

Peacefully, through cooperation and consent, Contracts and arbitration. The very same way that you buy things everyday and people buy things from you.

eyeeatingfish

Re: Dammit, Bernie (liberal rant)
« Reply #159 on: March 01, 2016, 05:58:38 AM »
how many people does it take to make taxation no longer theft? If the government passes a law that it okay to have sex with your wife on your wedding night against her will, is it no longer rape?

if i get a gang big enough and vote that we can take money from you is it no longer theft? If i use the money to make sure your property isn't taken by me or burned down, is it no longer theft?

what criticism can you possibly say about a society that isn't tax based can happen that doesn't already happen in a tax based society?
why is it that the problems you think will be prevented through taxes, actually happen? Taxes to protect property, even though taxation is the very theft of property?

You offer a system that has more flaws to replace a system that has fewer flaws.

Taxes are necessary to run a government, there is no beating around that bush. Whether the government abuses its power or its spending of the taxes is a separate issue. At least some level of government is necessary in today's age and it has to be funded somehow.

I wouldn't consider taxes to be theft as long as the taxes are spent on services available to all. So paying for a road, for example, provides a service to everyone, it does not take from one and give to another. You are getting a service in exchange for your property.