Psychoactive Substances Act (with exemptions for alcohol, caffeine and tobacco) (Read 17685 times)

punaperson

Talk about hypocrisy. This law is in the U.K., but certainly the stats for the U.S. show that alcohol is by far the most damaging (to personal physical and psychological health and societal costs, etc.) drug used here, yet the draconian enforcement efforts are centered on other "illegal" drugs, including those extremely benign compared to alcohol. (And there's certainly no question at all about the harmful health effects of tobacco). It's almost as if the bureaucrat's and politician's decisions regarding policies and their implementation are governed by something other than a rational evaluation of all the best available evidence. Who'd a thunk it? There is a brief comment in the article from the recently fired "Drug Tsar" of the British government, professor David Nutt, who was fired for his career-long examination of the evidence and concluding that criminalization is an ineffective strategy in dealing with substance abuse problems.

http://www.independent.co.uk/news/uk/home-news/legal-highs-law-banned-thursday-psychoactive-substances-act-critics-professor-nutt-a7035951.html

Excerpt:

And the Government is doing something. On 26 May the Psychoactive Substances Act will come into force, introducing jail sentences of up to seven years for anyone making or supplying any substance intended for human consumption that is capable of producing a psychoactive effect (with exemptions for alcohol, caffeine and tobacco).

Not everyone is entirely convinced – although it will certainly help Government ministers look tough on drugs. [empahasis added]

“Politically, they are low-hanging fruit,” says Harry Shapiro. “The easiest thing for any Government to do is to stop people buying these things from shops next to Mothercare. But don’t imagine it’s going to solve the problem.”

Or, as James puts it: “100 per cent, people will carry on dealing and taking.”

It’s just that when it comes to the sellers, the local head shop owner might be replaced by the neighbourhood crack dealer. As experience already suggests.

passivekinetic

producing a psychoactive effect?
Like extreme left wing ideas?
"The sheep fear sheepdogs, because they fail to see the wolves."
- Anonymous

punaperson

producing a psychoactive effect?
Like extreme left wing ideas?
I also have a psychoactive effect to right wing ideas that limit personal freedom and liberty and expand government intervention into dictating and criminalizing personal choices.

Jl808

The old paradigm:
(D, Liberals) Left wing <------ Centrist -----> Right wing (R, Conservatives)

The real paradigm:
(D,R, Liberals, some Conservatives) Big government <------ Limited / small government (Libertarians, Some Conservatives) ------> No goverment (Anarchists)
« Last Edit: May 23, 2016, 10:47:02 AM by Jl808 »
I think, therefore I am armed.
NRA Life Patron member, HRA Life member, HiFiCo Life Member, HDF member

The United States Constitution © 1791. All Rights Reserved.

PeaShooter

I'm not sure what the complaint or point of this thread is. Sounds to me like the UK has simply followed suit and copied the USA on this. So, are we criticizing both the UK and the USA together?

punaperson

I'm not sure what the complaint or point of this thread is. Sounds to me like the UK has simply followed suit and copied the USA on this. So, are we criticizing both the UK and the USA together?
Any government anywhere that makes laws based upon irrational premises rather than "objective" evaluations of the best evidence available, is, well, full of shit/liars, and thus does not deserve the support of any rational human being. There is no evidence that the laws in the UK and U.S. regarding which substances are legal to consume and which are illegal consume (and thus cost people their freedom even if they harm no one by their personal use) have a rational basis (i.e. the more harmful alcohol and tobacco are legal, the less harmful cannabis and various psychoactive substances are illegal, etc.).

Similar to the claims of those passing "common sense gun safety regulations" declaring that lives will be saved by banning forward grips, bayonet lugs, and "things that go up" and magazines of greater capacity than 10 rounds (7 for NY SAFE Act, or 3 if Bloomberg had his way) on firearms. It's irrational. It's not based on any evidence that will withstand critical scrutiny, and the true goal is not the claimed "public safety" but something far more nefarious. They are lying statist tyrants masquerading as do-gooders to the masses too apathetic, too ignorant or too busy trying to survive to become informed on the issues. And innocent people pay the price.

passivekinetic

The history of HEMP is a great and even currently relevant example of this arbitrary twisting of the facts (and the mindless unquestioning sheep who follow).

It used to be illegal to NOT grow hemp, because it was so crucial to our economy.

You were fined if you did not grow it! Mandatory growing!

Then suddenly a propaganda campaign came about with that REEFER MADNESS epitomizing the whole lie, and people got put in jails for growing it.

That is now coming full circle back again! Slowly but surely. Again, completely arbitrary!

Some say reason was to give the big chemical companies business, because hemp rope and hemp fabric were much more durable and cheap than nylon, etc. and of course, various "interest groups" wanted to be sure to eliminate the competition.
"The sheep fear sheepdogs, because they fail to see the wolves."
- Anonymous

eyeeatingfish

I think it can be hard to compare alcohol to a lot of the other hard drugs. Now alcohol does indeed account for many more deaths than the hard drugs, cocaine, heroin, meth, etc and one can reason that this shows it is much more dangerous but it seems like a flawed comparison to start with.

In order to assess the danger we would need to compare them on some equal level which in reality is difficult. For starters, alcohol is cheap, abundant, socially acceptable, and is even encouraged while the illegal hard drugs aren't. To get a better assessment you would need to compare a group of alcohol users to group that used crystal meth (for example). This is not such an easy thing to study. If people used crystal meth at the same rate as people used alcohol, do you think we would still see alcohol causing so many more deaths? I would wager that you see a higher death rate among regular meth or heroin users than among regular alcohol users. This still begs the question of where to draw the line. Even if meth is more harmful than alcohol, why is meth not OK but alcohol is? Where should the line be drawn? Should there be any line at all?

Having said that I do agree that the current system of imprisonment is problematic. Not enough emphasis on substance abuse treatment leads to more recidivism. However, that does seem to be slowly changing with more programs adopting what has found to be effective. Unfortunately it is slow going.

punaperson

I think blah blah blah
I'm not even going to bother fisking that gibberish.

PeaShooter

Yeah I tend to lean towards treating all drugs the same way myself, whether alcohol/tobacco/cocaine/etc. Either a global ban or acceptance on everything. I don't feel that strongly though. The most important thing is that everyone is free to hold their own opinion, study, and debate the matter without government restriction. Unfortunately, the government does impose restrictions on debate and thought, as shown by the firing of the professor in the topic. These unconstitutional restrictions also exist in the USA.

Inspector

I know I am going to take a lot of flak for this but....

I think alcohol is just as much a drug as the other drugs mentioned here. Since alcohol is legal and the others are not, this shows the hypocrisy of the current system of government and the citizens of our country. How can one addicting drug be legal and the rest are not? My feeling is that they all should be made legal or they all should be made illegal. Including alcohol. Personally, I believe we should legalize them all. But if consistency (No hypocrisy) is important, and it is to me, then I wouldn't be adverse to making them all illegal for the sake of applying our laws consistently. JMHO
SCIENCE THAT CAN’T BE QUESTIONED IS PROPAGANDA!!!

ren



I don't know why people take all that sh!t anyways...escape from reality??!!!




I AM REALITY! :D
Deeds Not Words

Heavies

All about the $$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$

eyeeatingfish

I'm not even going to bother fisking that gibberish.

TRANSLATION:
I am not going to bother replying to people who challenge me on my position.

eyeeatingfish

I know I am going to take a lot of flak for this but....

I think alcohol is just as much a drug as the other drugs mentioned here. Since alcohol is legal and the others are not, this shows the hypocrisy of the current system of government and the citizens of our country. How can one addicting drug be legal and the rest are not? My feeling is that they all should be made legal or they all should be made illegal. Including alcohol. Personally, I believe we should legalize them all. But if consistency (No hypocrisy) is important, and it is to me, then I wouldn't be adverse to making them all illegal for the sake of applying our laws consistently. JMHO

You could absolutely make that argument for alcohol vs marijuana but with some of the hard drugs out there it ends up being apples and oranges. Some drugs do a lot more damage way faster than alcohol tends to.

As for marijuana, the facts almost dictate that if alcohol should be legal then weed should be legal. Marijuana is arguably quite a bit less worse than alcohol in so many ways. There are of course cultural and historical reasons why one is legal and the other is not but I think based on logic alone I absolutely agree, you cannot justify alcohol being legal and marijuana not.

punaperson

TRANSLATION:
I am not going to bother replying to people who challenge me on my position.
Oh, the irony. It almost hurts.

Inspector

You could absolutely make that argument for alcohol vs marijuana but with some of the hard drugs out there it ends up being apples and oranges. Some drugs do a lot more damage way faster than alcohol tends to.

As for marijuana, the facts almost dictate that if alcohol should be legal then weed should be legal. Marijuana is arguably quite a bit less worse than alcohol in so many ways. There are of course cultural and historical reasons why one is legal and the other is not but I think based on logic alone I absolutely agree, you cannot justify alcohol being legal and marijuana not.
I don't agree. Just because other drugs do "...a lot more damage way faster than alcohol tends to." It's like saying taking weaker amounts of heroin is better than taking strong amounts. So it takes longer to see the final outcome of taking heroin. It just doesn't make any sense. And it doesn't make alcohol any less bad. It is still addicting, it is still damaging, and people still do bad things while intoxicated. Bottom line is that there is no difference between the outcome of the effects of alcohol and any other the other drugs mentioned. JMHO
« Last Edit: May 25, 2016, 02:15:52 PM by Inspector »
SCIENCE THAT CAN’T BE QUESTIONED IS PROPAGANDA!!!

ren

The weak will seek out drugs to cope.
It's an easy formula.
Stay strong, stay away from drugs.
Deeds Not Words

PeaShooter

What if the government decided one day to ban orange trees but allow apple trees?

passivekinetic

What if the government decided one day to ban orange trees but allow apple trees?

Then people will be arrested for having oranges.

It sounds ridiculous but banning hemp is even more ridiculous. So, if they can ban hemp (arbitrarily) they can ban oranges.

If you told anyone in the 1940s that they would ban hemp, they would say you are nuts.

This proves that law does not have to make sense, or be good for the citizens.

http://naihc.org/hemp_information/hemp_facts.html#history

"The sheep fear sheepdogs, because they fail to see the wolves."
- Anonymous