NRA backs Red Flag law "conditionally" (Read 60250 times)

eyeeatingfish

Re: NRA backs Red Flag law "conditionally"
« Reply #100 on: May 25, 2019, 08:12:18 PM »
The problem with the example is this.  I'm using ebola because it's easy to type.  A test will confirm you either have ebola or not.  So if you have it, it's highly contagious.  Are there test for mental issues, yes there are.  But shooting people or acting violently is what the test cannot prove will happen.  There are lots of non-violent people with mental problems.

And with ebola, you will probably feel like shit and seek help.  So the carrier is willingly going there or to sick to move.

I agree most will seek help but there will always be that odd one who refuses to go voluntarily. Should that person's constitutional rights be taken away and have him forced to take a test to confirm ebola? Consider this separate from a red flag law even, it is still an interesting test on constitutional rights. Does the fact that there exists a test for ebola that can say with certainty that the person is infected or not? Does having a definitive test justify taking away the individuals rights on the suspicion they are infected?

You do bring up probably the single biggest hurdle I think the courts face though in this type of issue. They can diagnose someone with a mental illness but it is a hard line to draw of when that  diagnosis warrants take away their rights, whether it be firearms or just to walk around freely in public.

Maybe another issue that could be brought up to serve as an analysis would be pedophilia. Some feel that convicted pedophiles should never re-enter society because the risk of recidivism is too great but it is not a guarantee that they will re-offend. Then there are pedophiles who have never acted on their desires, should society set limitations on them when they haven't done anything? Honestly, if I found out my kids teacher had pedophilia I wouldn't have my kid in their class even if the teacher had never acted on it. Would you? (Yes I realize being a teacher isn't a constitutionally protected right)

Flapp_Jackson

Re: NRA backs Red Flag law "conditionally"
« Reply #101 on: May 26, 2019, 01:40:56 AM »
Maybe if you lump them together but some mental illnesses  do have higher rates of violence while others have lower rates of violence.  Of course we can't take a one size fits all approach.

I think you say my hypothetical scenario is irrelevant because you know you don't have a good answer. Even if you didn't think it was a good comparison you still couldn't answer the question.

You never even answered my earlier question about what to do with someone who shows signs of being mentally ill and violent but has committed no crime. You complain about proposed solutions but offer none of your own.

Please post statistical studies and charts that show the breakdown of violent acts committed by mentally ill patients based on the diseases they were diagnosed as having.

Identify whether "higher rates of violence" is comparing those rates among the population in general or only among the population of known, diagnosed individuals with mental illnesses.

Often, people who commit violence are abusing alcohol and/or narcotics, both illegal and prescribed. Use of drugs, and withdrawal from habitual use, increases the potential for violence exponentially in both the general population and the mentally ill. It's not unreasonable to assume the majority of violent mentally ill patients commit those acts of violence more as a side-effect of the drugs they take, Rx or self-medicating, and not the disease itself.

I don't answer irrelevant questions. it's an academic exercise with no value.
« Last Edit: May 26, 2019, 01:52:10 AM by Flapp_Jackson »
The reasonable man adapts himself to the world;
the unreasonable one persists in trying to adapt the world to himself.
Therefore, all progress depends on the unreasonable man.
-- George Bernard Shaw

eyeeatingfish

Re: NRA backs Red Flag law "conditionally"
« Reply #102 on: May 26, 2019, 07:12:04 PM »
Please post statistical studies and charts that show the breakdown of violent acts committed by mentally ill patients based on the diseases they were diagnosed as having.

Identify whether "higher rates of violence" is comparing those rates among the population in general or only among the population of known, diagnosed individuals with mental illnesses.

Often, people who commit violence are abusing alcohol and/or narcotics, both illegal and prescribed. Use of drugs, and withdrawal from habitual use, increases the potential for violence exponentially in both the general population and the mentally ill. It's not unreasonable to assume the majority of violent mentally ill patients commit those acts of violence more as a side-effect of the drugs they take, Rx or self-medicating, and not the disease itself.

I don't answer irrelevant questions. it's an academic exercise with no value.

A simple diagnosis alone is not a very reliable predictor but once someone is diagnosed. A diagnosis is just the first step towards identifying someone who may be dangerous.
"The two best predictors are actuarial strategies,15 which focus on diverse demographic and behavioural histories, and use of the HCR-20 (Historical, Clinical, Risk Management), a 20-item checklist designed to estimate the probability of future violence."
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC6019348/

I did not find a list that broke down violence rates by diagnosis. I did find some results that showed certain mental disorders have much higher rates, when combined with substance abuse, than the normal population. So one takeaway could be that if you know someone with schizophrenia who is also abusing drugs, that can serve as a more reliable predictor of violence. Again, this would need to be decided on a case by case basis and the above mentioned 20 item checklist would give us a better predictor of how violent someone will be. 

Sometimes certain symptoms present with a mental health diagnosis showed higher rates of violence. For example "Mentally ill patients with threatening, paranoid delusions are twice as likely to become aggressive compared with nonparanoid psychotic patients."
And it isn't just a biological mental illnesses either "As many as 70 percent of patients with brain injury secondary to blunt trauma exhibit irritability and aggression."
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC2686644/

Suicides correlated highly with someone who was suffering depression at the time. Usually I don't consider suicide into violence rates but since it comprises about 2/3rds of gun deaths it isn't a statistic we can ignore either.


Seeing as how you recognize  the role substances have come into play in violence, what is your suggestion in how to address those with mental health issues that are being combined with substance abuse?  You recognize a problem but are providing no alternative to red flag type laws. You admit there is a certain group of individuals that do pose an increased risk but are silent on what to do about it.

So lets modify the scenario so it is unavoidable for you. Your brother has schizophrenia and has recently taken up abusing alcohol. He has shown an increase in aggressive tendencies and now wants to buy a gun. You suggest he see a mental health professional but he refuses. What do you do absent any sort of red flag law to address this?

changemyoil66

Re: NRA backs Red Flag law "conditionally"
« Reply #103 on: May 26, 2019, 09:29:48 PM »
Since were taking away their guns because they might do something bad, we should also take away all sharp objects, cars, drivers license, household cleaning products, blunt objects such as staplers, rocks, baseballs, bottles, hammers, screw drivers , etc...if theyre big, lets say above 5'8 and 210lbs, they must remain handcuffed also.

They might use any of the above to harm someone.

Sent from my SM-G950U using Tapatalk

Flapp_Jackson

Re: NRA backs Red Flag law "conditionally"
« Reply #104 on: May 26, 2019, 10:37:06 PM »
A simple diagnosis alone is not a very reliable predictor but once someone is diagnosed. A diagnosis is just the first step towards identifying someone who may be dangerous.
"The two best predictors are actuarial strategies,15 which focus on diverse demographic and behavioural histories, and use of the HCR-20 (Historical, Clinical, Risk Management), a 20-item checklist designed to estimate the probability of future violence."
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC6019348/

I did not find a list that broke down violence rates by diagnosis. I did find some results that showed certain mental disorders have much higher rates, when combined with substance abuse, than the normal population. So one takeaway could be that if you know someone with schizophrenia who is also abusing drugs, that can serve as a more reliable predictor of violence. Again, this would need to be decided on a case by case basis and the above mentioned 20 item checklist would give us a better predictor of how violent someone will be. 

Sometimes certain symptoms present with a mental health diagnosis showed higher rates of violence. For example "Mentally ill patients with threatening, paranoid delusions are twice as likely to become aggressive compared with nonparanoid psychotic patients."
And it isn't just a biological mental illnesses either "As many as 70 percent of patients with brain injury secondary to blunt trauma exhibit irritability and aggression."
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC2686644/

Suicides correlated highly with someone who was suffering depression at the time. Usually I don't consider suicide into violence rates but since it comprises about 2/3rds of gun deaths it isn't a statistic we can ignore either.


Seeing as how you recognize  the role substances have come into play in violence, what is your suggestion in how to address those with mental health issues that are being combined with substance abuse?  You recognize a problem but are providing no alternative to red flag type laws. You admit there is a certain group of individuals that do pose an increased risk but are silent on what to do about it.

So lets modify the scenario so it is unavoidable for you. Your brother has schizophrenia and has recently taken up abusing alcohol. He has shown an increase in aggressive tendencies and now wants to buy a gun. You suggest he see a mental health professional but he refuses. What do you do absent any sort of red flag law to address this?

Abuse/habitual use of narcotics and alcohol are already disqualifying behaviors for firearm ownership.  If the person is arrested for such behavior, their right to keep guns they have as well as those they may want to purchase would be subject to confiscation/rejection.

Your entire argument, regardless of the hypotheticals you spew, boils down to one thing: how do we include people who haven't yet been entered into the system as mentally ill, violent, substance abusers, etc. if they are not causing problems or have been ignored (such as Parkland/Broward County)?  You believe we need more laws. How will that change anything?  The same people in the red flag laws can already report potentially violent people to law enforcement. The difference is red flag laws have an automatic confiscation feature, whereas today's laws require actual due process.

I don't know how many times and in how many ways that needs to be stated before you get it.
The reasonable man adapts himself to the world;
the unreasonable one persists in trying to adapt the world to himself.
Therefore, all progress depends on the unreasonable man.
-- George Bernard Shaw

punaperson

Re: NRA backs Red Flag law "conditionally"
« Reply #105 on: May 27, 2019, 06:48:29 AM »
I don't know how many times and in how many ways that needs to be stated before you get it.

ren

Re: NRA backs Red Flag law "conditionally"
« Reply #106 on: May 27, 2019, 08:21:28 AM »
We need a law that makes it illegal to even think about committing a violent act - ILLEGAL. Maybe a murder, death kill law???


It's pointless to argue with someone who would gladly take away your 2A rights. It's not about rational discussion - it's about power.
« Last Edit: May 27, 2019, 08:31:54 AM by ren »
Deeds Not Words

Mdotweber

Re: NRA backs Red Flag law "conditionally"
« Reply #107 on: May 27, 2019, 02:36:38 PM »
We need a law that makes it illegal to even think about committing a violent act - ILLEGAL. Maybe a murder, death kill law???


It's pointless to argue with someone who would gladly take away your 2A rights. It's not about rational discussion - it's about power.


Then we could all inspire joy joy feelings in everyone around us...

While we are on the subject perhaps we could just get it over with and enact pre-crime laws  Rhoads, Lee and Theilen could be our pre-cogs. Maybe Bloomberg would foot the bill.
"Dont forget, incoming fire has the right of way"-Clint Smith?

eyeeatingfish

Re: NRA backs Red Flag law "conditionally"
« Reply #108 on: May 27, 2019, 06:45:33 PM »
Since were taking away their guns because they might do something bad, we should also take away all sharp objects, cars, drivers license, household cleaning products, blunt objects such as staplers, rocks, baseballs, bottles, hammers, screw drivers , etc...if theyre big, lets say above 5'8 and 210lbs, they must remain handcuffed also.

They might use any of the above to harm someone.

Sent from my SM-G950U using Tapatalk

Fair enough but the same issue is still present. How do we restrain these people in whatever way necessary whether it be taking away firearms or taking away their freedom altogether? Should we wait until an actual crime has occurred?

eyeeatingfish

Re: NRA backs Red Flag law "conditionally"
« Reply #109 on: May 27, 2019, 06:57:33 PM »
Abuse/habitual use of narcotics and alcohol are already disqualifying behaviors for firearm ownership.  If the person is arrested for such behavior, their right to keep guns they have as well as those they may want to purchase would be subject to confiscation/rejection.

Being an alcoholic is not an arrestable offense. However your comment suggests that you support the police revoking someones firearms rights if they are found to have substance abuse issues. So get 2 DUIs and they get to take away your guns? Attend AA meetings and they get to take away your guns?

Quote
Your entire argument, regardless of the hypotheticals you spew, boils down to one thing: how do we include people who haven't yet been entered into the system as mentally ill, violent, substance abusers, etc. if they are not causing problems or have been ignored (such as Parkland/Broward County)?  You believe we need more laws. How will that change anything?  The same people in the red flag laws can already report potentially violent people to law enforcement. The difference is red flag laws have an automatic confiscation feature, whereas today's laws require actual due process.

Your understanding is flawed. So take the scenario I just mentioned and pretend there is no red flag law. You call the police and say that you believe your brother is a danger. Cops come and talk to him but he plays it cool and denies all the things you claim. Or maybe your brother just politely refuses to speak to police. The cops can call the police psychologist but if they see no warning signs they aren't going to be able to force your brother to go with them to a mental health facility. The system you point to as the solution does not adequately do what you suggest it will, there are holes in the current system, holes that red flag laws are trying to patch.

You can either suggest a workable solution or sit and complain when they come up with a bad type of red flag law that doesn't have enough protections.


Quote
I don't know how many times and in how many ways that needs to be stated before you get it.

I don't get things which are based upon flawed logic.

ren

Re: NRA backs Red Flag law "conditionally"
« Reply #110 on: May 27, 2019, 07:06:22 PM »
all this flawed logic is from a Minority Report scenario where we THINK we can predict a person's bad intentions and arrest them before the act. That's a fantasy that is not possible. We look to the law as this magical wand that will whisk things away - but let's face it we live in a world where violence happens. We can impose more laws to restrict EVERYONE"s rights but look at what we have now - unarmed LAW ABIDING citizens. We haven't tried the other way around and EMPOWER the rightful citizen. All we do is take things away. Evil, idle persons will find away while the rest of the life-pursuing law abiders will go on with the rest of productive society.
Freedom isn't perfect but it ceases to be when you start targeting the very PEOPLE THAT FOLLOW THE LAW.
You can point to the source of firearms - stolen, imported from other countries but don't criminalize the person who legally acquired the firearm.

In short the "Red Flag" law is nothing more than an avenue to disarm based on subjective opinion - a witch hunt conducted by those who are unarmed and want to assert power.

Our State has a bigger problem of DUIs and pedestrian accidents caused by vehicles. Just this morning a lady was killed down the street. We could easily translate this Red Flag law to apply to vehicles but we don't. We apply it to a statistically lesser problem of legal firearms.

Here we have a similar concept of "doing something" to save lives; along the lines of inventing technology that hasn't been invented yet.
https://www.washingtonexaminer.com/senate-democrats-propose-hot-cars-act-to-save-kids-from-heatstroke-deaths
Ac act with no definitive solution whatsoever. Just an implied mandate to car manufacturers. Instead of attacking the root nature of the problem - poor accountability; they create this BS of an act. Wishful thinking.

What a bunch of assclownery, horseshit, unicorn fuxtardiness, monkey fucking a football :grrr: from a person with no real solution. All you want is an argument with zero results. No relevance. The only valid comments are those of a Cpt Obvious nature.
« Last Edit: May 27, 2019, 07:49:53 PM by ren »
Deeds Not Words

ren

Re: NRA backs Red Flag law "conditionally"
« Reply #111 on: May 27, 2019, 07:19:27 PM »
meanwhile, we need a fucking big red flag law on knives, trucks and other "stuff" too
https://www.hawaiinewsnow.com/2019/05/28/report-japan-bus-stop-stabbing-wounds-kills-up/



Although Japan has one of the lowest crime rates in the world, it has had a series of high-profile killings, including in 2016 when a former employee at a home for the disabled allegedly killed 19 and injured more than 20 others.

In 2008, seven people were killed by a man who slammed a truck into a crowd of people in central Tokyo's Akihabara electronics district and then stabbed passers-by.

Also in 2016, a man stabbed four people at a library in northeastern Japan, allegedly over their mishandling of his questions. No one was killed.


Armchair QB all these events and all these innocent lives could have been saved by a good citizen with a gun.
Deeds Not Words

eyeeatingfish

Re: NRA backs Red Flag law "conditionally"
« Reply #112 on: May 27, 2019, 07:48:54 PM »
all this flawed logic is from a Minority Report scenario where we THINK we can predict a person's bad intentions and arrest them before the act. That's a fantasy that is not possible.

So are you of the position that no one should be confined against their will in a mental health institution until they have committed an actual crime?

Quote
In short the "Red Flag" law is nothing more than an avenue to disarm based on subjective opinion - a witch hunt conducted by those who are unarmed and want to assert power.

I think you misunderstand their intentions and goals.

Quote
Our State has a bigger problem of DUIs and pedestrian accidents caused by vehicles. Just this morning a lady was killed down the street. We could easily translate this Red Flag law to apply to vehicles but we don't. We apply it to a statistically lesser problem of legal firearms.

It might happen some day. When (if) guns are taken away and kids start using their cars to kill people at school we may see some of the same suggestions for cars.

Quote
Here we have a similar concept of "doing something" to save lives; along the lines of inventing technology that hasn't been invented yet.
https://www.washingtonexaminer.com/senate-democrats-propose-hot-cars-act-to-save-kids-from-heatstroke-deaths
Ac act with no definitive solution whatsoever. Just an implied mandate to car manufacturers. Instead of attacking the root nature of the problem - poor accountability; they create this BS of an act. Wishful thinking.

How do you attack poor accountability for kids dying from being left in hot cars in a way that makes sure no one makes that mistake anymore?

ren

Re: NRA backs Red Flag law "conditionally"
« Reply #113 on: May 27, 2019, 07:54:39 PM »
So are you of the position that no one should be confined against their will in a mental health institution until they have committed an actual crime?

I think you misunderstand their intentions and goals.

It might happen some day. When (if) guns are taken away and kids start using their cars to kill people at school we may see some of the same suggestions for cars.

There you go. Just admit what you want - disarmament. The truth set you free.


How do you attack poor accountability for kids dying from being left in hot cars in a way that makes sure no one makes that mistake anymore?

it's called accounting for your kids when you leave the car. You can count can you? Oh shit I take that back. You can't so we need some technology-that-hasn't been-invented-yet. How about some fancy sensor to remind you on your ever-so-glued-to-your-face-"smart"phone. Oh shit, let me guess you forgot your kids because you were on your phone posting a red dot selfie to your Facebook on your way into Walmart decadence because it was half the cost of an ACOG.
Yes. No one should be committed to an institution until a crime is committed. It's called innocence.

What's your solution Mr. Burgess?
« Last Edit: May 27, 2019, 08:07:46 PM by ren »
Deeds Not Words

changemyoil66

Re: NRA backs Red Flag law "conditionally"
« Reply #114 on: May 27, 2019, 08:03:04 PM »
Ever see Equilibrium? Control all emotions and anything that causes an emotion is illegal. Paintings, music, books, etc

Sent from my SM-G950U using Tapatalk

ren

Re: NRA backs Red Flag law "conditionally"
« Reply #115 on: May 27, 2019, 08:04:13 PM »
Ever see Equilibrium? Control all emotions and anything that causes an emotion is illegal. Paintings, music, books, etc

Sent from my SM-G950U using Tapatalk

you mean that was a movie? I thought it was a documentary.
Deeds Not Words

eyeeatingfish

Re: NRA backs Red Flag law "conditionally"
« Reply #116 on: May 27, 2019, 08:52:08 PM »
it's called accounting for your kids when you leave the car. You can count can you? Oh shit I take that back. You can't so we need some technology-that-hasn't been-invented-yet. How about some fancy sensor to remind you on your ever-so-glued-to-your-face-"smart"phone. Oh shit, let me guess you forgot your kids because you were on your phone posting a red dot selfie to your Facebook on your way into Walmart decadence because it was half the cost of an ACOG.
Yes. No one should be committed to an institution until a crime is committed. It's called innocence.

What's your solution Mr. Burgess?

Great, we can tell people to be good parents then throw them in jail when they fail. We hold them accountable... oh yeah, too late the kid is dead already. Heaven forbid someone comes up with a technology idea to address human forgetfulness.


Now as to your other comment, please don't use strawman arguments against me. I never said I want to disarm people of cars or guns. You said why don't they do the same thing with cars and I pointed out they may someday. Need to work on your reading comprehension if you somehow drew the conclusion I was for confiscation.

ren

Re: NRA backs Red Flag law "conditionally"
« Reply #117 on: May 27, 2019, 08:57:04 PM »
Great, we can tell people to be good parents then throw them in jail when they fail. We hold them accountable... oh yeah, too late the kid is dead already. Heaven forbid someone comes up with a technology idea to address human forgetfulness.


Now as to your other comment, please don't use strawman arguments against me. I never said I want to disarm people of cars or guns. You said why don't they do the same thing with cars and I pointed out they may someday. Need to work on your reading comprehension if you somehow drew the conclusion I was for confiscation.
You have a hard-on for confiscation. A red flag law today. Tomorrow a smell test. A whiff and boom there you are.
Once again no solution. Just worthless waha
« Last Edit: May 27, 2019, 09:04:39 PM by ren »
Deeds Not Words

eyeeatingfish

Re: NRA backs Red Flag law "conditionally"
« Reply #118 on: May 27, 2019, 09:04:09 PM »
You have a hard-on for confiscation. A red flag law today. Tomorrow a smell test. A whiff and boom there you are.

Yawn... any other false accusations you want to lump in while you are at it?

ren

Re: NRA backs Red Flag law "conditionally"
« Reply #119 on: May 27, 2019, 09:05:01 PM »
Yawn... any other false accusations you want to lump in while you are at it?

what's your solution Mr. Burgess?
I suggest a Red New Deal or something along those lines
Deeds Not Words