A march on Washington with loaded rifles (Read 61908 times)

moosed

  • Trade Count: (+5)
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 867
  • Total likes: 0
  • Well, I'm all broken up over that man's rights!
  • Referrals: 2
    • View Profile
Re: A march on Washington with loaded rifles
« Reply #20 on: May 06, 2013, 12:14:19 PM »
Anyone care to weigh in on this plan and First Ammendment rights?  Should these guys have the RIGHT to do this?

I don't see any difference between a gun owner marching with loaded firearms in a peaceful protest and Martin Luther King, Jr. holding a sit-in protest where they are breaking laws by trespassing or going where Blacks were not permitted.

Civil disobedience is an American tradition.  Walking with loaded firearms where (potentially unconstitutional) laws prohibit it does not equal violence.  No difference in my mind.
When only cops have guns, it's called a "police state".

jaynick

Re: A march on Washington with loaded rifles
« Reply #21 on: May 06, 2013, 12:18:58 PM »
people are going to chicken out as the day nears
and more are going to chicken out on that day when they see how few people show up
that will leave a core group of nutjobs
who will say stupid stuff on the news
and then will resist when they are repelled or arrested
all it will take is one cop or protester losing their cool or even a backfire or firecracker and it's going to be a bloodbath

^^^ this

all it takes is one.

MDS

Re: A march on Washington with loaded rifles
« Reply #22 on: May 06, 2013, 12:56:56 PM »
According to the Constitution under the first and second amendments they already have the right to make the march. I would also agree that anyone who supposedly stands for these rights and considers the marchers effort to be foolish to be a person of (I’ll respectfully label it as) internal “incongruity”. IMO… they should have the RIGHT and already do have the RIGHT.

clshade

Re: A march on Washington with loaded rifles
« Reply #23 on: May 06, 2013, 01:38:56 PM »
According to the Constitution under the first and second amendments they already have the right to make the march. I would also agree that anyone who supposedly stands for these rights and considers the marchers effort to be foolish to be a person of (I’ll respectfully label it as) internal “incongruity”. IMO… they should have the RIGHT and already do have the RIGHT.

Well, the laws and courts of the land would disagree with you on that but you are certainly welcome to your interpretation of the Constitution.

Just for the sake of it, nowhere does the Constitution specify that the rights stipulated in the Bill of Rights are "God Given" or "Inalienable." Those words came from other documents and writings of the Founding Fathers and have no relevance to the Constitution or to its interpretation. No matter how many people think so the courts have historically and consistently disagreed. The fact that we have a host of legal gun laws that greatly "infringe" on our "right" to keep and bear arms is ample evidence of this.

Those who think the Constitution is some kind of absolute that will protect them are ignoring 200+ years of legal precedents, laws and policies that prove otherwise.

That seems (to put it mildly) internally incongruent.

Anyone who participates in that march as it is currently planned will be guilty of knowingly committing a felony according to local law and any prosecutor will have no problem proving it in court. "But the Constitution says.....!" is a legal defense that hasn't worked in all but a handful of very specific cases.

While the concept of breaking unjust laws in order to highlight how unjust they are is well known and effective, it is only effective if the vast majority of people agree that it is unjust. That is not the case in the US right now concerning the right to bear arms. The best that can happen with this march is that they are politely asked by LEO's to not cross the bridge and they call it off. The worst is... quite a bit worse.

MDS

Re: A march on Washington with loaded rifles
« Reply #24 on: May 06, 2013, 01:43:49 PM »
NM

BUD

Re: A march on Washington with loaded rifles
« Reply #25 on: May 06, 2013, 01:44:31 PM »
Well, the laws and courts of the land would disagree with you on that but you are certainly welcome to your interpretation of the Constitution.

Just for the sake of it, nowhere does the Constitution specify that the rights stipulated in the Bill of Rights are "God Given" or "Inalienable." Those words came from other documents and writings of the Founding Fathers and have no relevance to the Constitution or to its interpretation. No matter how many people think so the courts have historically and consistently disagreed. The fact that we have a host of legal gun laws that greatly "infringe" on our "right" to keep and bear arms is ample evidence of this.

Those who think the Constitution is some kind of absolute that will protect them are ignoring 200+ years of legal precedents, laws and policies that prove otherwise.

That seems (to put it mildly) internally incongruent.

Anyone who participates in that march as it is currently planned will be guilty of knowingly committing a felony according to local law and any prosecutor will have no problem proving it in court. "But the Constitution says.....!" is a legal defense that hasn't worked in all but a handful of very specific cases.

While the concept of breaking unjust laws in order to highlight how unjust they are is well known and effective, it is only effective if the vast majority of people agree that it is unjust. That is not the case in the US right now concerning the right to bear arms. The best that can happen with this march is that they are politely asked by LEO's to not cross the bridge and they call it off. The worst is... quite a bit worse.


Do you think this may have been the case at some previous point in history?  Like say around 1776 or so?
It is what it is.

moosed

  • Trade Count: (+5)
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 867
  • Total likes: 0
  • Well, I'm all broken up over that man's rights!
  • Referrals: 2
    • View Profile
Re: A march on Washington with loaded rifles
« Reply #26 on: May 06, 2013, 05:28:15 PM »
Well, the laws and courts of the land would disagree with you on that but you are certainly welcome to your interpretation of the Constitution.

Just for the sake of it, nowhere does the Constitution specify that the rights stipulated in the Bill of Rights are "God Given" or "Inalienable." Those words came from other documents and writings of the Founding Fathers and have no relevance to the Constitution or to its interpretation. No matter how many people think so the courts have historically and consistently disagreed. The fact that we have a host of legal gun laws that greatly "infringe" on our "right" to keep and bear arms is ample evidence of this.

Those who think the Constitution is some kind of absolute that will protect them are ignoring 200+ years of legal precedents, laws and policies that prove otherwise.

That seems (to put it mildly) internally incongruent.

Anyone who participates in that march as it is currently planned will be guilty of knowingly committing a felony according to local law and any prosecutor will have no problem proving it in court. "But the Constitution says.....!" is a legal defense that hasn't worked in all but a handful of very specific cases.

While the concept of breaking unjust laws in order to highlight how unjust they are is well known and effective, it is only effective if the vast majority of people agree that it is unjust. That is not the case in the US right now concerning the right to bear arms. The best that can happen with this march is that they are politely asked by LEO's to not cross the bridge and they call it off. The worst is... quite a bit worse.

Rights are, by definition, granted by nature (God, what have you), and are neither capable of being bestowed nor taken away from men and women by any government.

"Legal rights" are derived from the higher level rights bestowed by nature.  For example, the right to life gives rise to the right to keep and bear arms.  It is one's natural and unalienable right to protect one's own life, and therefore the right to use arms in the protection of one's life falls naturally under the same right.

To argue the categorization of the items listed the the Bill of Rights is counter-productive.  They are RIGHTS.  The wording in the Constitution, "the RIGHT to keep and bear arms shall not be infringed, " is indisputable.  Whether you wish to argue the right is one endowed by our creator, or a legal right which stems from such a natural right is irrelevant.

Quote
We hold these truths to be self-evident, that all men are created equal, that they are endowed by their Creator with certain unalienable Rights, that among these are Life, Liberty and the pursuit of Happiness.

The key phrase here is "among these."  The rights listed are not all inclusive.  Therefore to argue that omission from the Constitution implies a right is NOT unalienable is unsupported.
When only cops have guns, it's called a "police state".

clshade

Re: A march on Washington with loaded rifles
« Reply #27 on: May 06, 2013, 06:00:25 PM »
Tell the Japanese Americans during WWII about their  "God given rights..."

Until God comes down from the heavens and tells the Government what to do, your "rights" come from the government.

The Declaration is a legal document informing England that they would no longer be receiving taxes from us. Has ~nothing~ to do with the legal definition of rights. Applying the wording of the Declaration to the Constitution and the Bill of Rights is a classic fallacy that a lot of armchair Constitutional Scholars enjoy. Its still a fallacy.

Philosophers and historians talk about nature derived or God given rights. Meanwhile the legislature and courts deal with "legal rights" which are given and taken by the authorities.

Armed Watertown SWAT Team member: "You are being evacuated. There is a terrorist on the loose."
Resident: "Let me get my shoes..."
SWAT: "No, you are moving out now."
Resident: "But...."
SWAT: "Move! NOW!"

Notice the nuanced discussion of rights?

The 2nd amendment articulates the nature derived right to keep and bear arms. The NFA has articulated for quite some time a class of arms that you cannot keep and bear. The courts have held up time and time again that the 2nd amendment is not absolute and that regional governments have the authority to enact their own regulations. Thus... D.C's ban on open carry is both legal and Constitutional... according to today's interpretation of it.

Sure, things were quite different in 1776.

We had slaves, for example. Everything a women owned, including any money she made, was the property of her husband. Just a short while later it was legal to hunt Native Americans in California because they were animals, not people. Smokeless powder didn't exist. At that time they were still burning people alive here in Hawaii. After the revolution only land owning white males could vote in this great country. Each State printed its own currency. The Spanish Inquisition was still happening.

Laws have changed around a bit since then. Interpretations of laws that haven't changed have shifted around, too.

edit: I should say that I agree with the philosophers that "rights" are inalienable. My point is that the courts deal with laws much more than philosophy. The loaded rifle marchers are headed to jail if D.C. police chose to send them there.
« Last Edit: May 06, 2013, 06:07:07 PM by clshade »

moosed

  • Trade Count: (+5)
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 867
  • Total likes: 0
  • Well, I'm all broken up over that man's rights!
  • Referrals: 2
    • View Profile
Re: A march on Washington with loaded rifles
« Reply #28 on: May 06, 2013, 06:12:05 PM »
Tell the Japanese Americans during WWII about their  "God given rights..."

Until God comes down from the heavens and tells the Government what to do, your "rights" come from the government.

The Declaration is a legal document informing England that they would no longer be receiving taxes from us. Has ~nothing~ to do with the legal definition of rights. Applying the wording of the Declaration to the Constitution and the Bill of Rights is a classic fallacy that a lot of armchair Constitutional Scholars enjoy. Its still a fallacy.

Philosophers and historians talk about nature derived or God given rights. Meanwhile the legislature and courts deal with "legal rights" which are given and taken by the authorities.

Armed Watertown SWAT Team member: "You are being evacuated. There is a terrorist on the loose."
Resident: "Let me get my shoes..."
SWAT: "No, you are moving out now."
Resident: "But...."
SWAT: "Move! NOW!"

Notice the nuanced discussion of rights?

The 2nd amendment articulates the nature derived right to keep and bear arms. The NFA has articulated for quite some time a class of arms that you cannot keep and bear. The courts have held up time and time again that the 2nd amendment is not absolute and that regional governments have the authority to enact their own regulations. Thus... D.C's ban on open carry is both legal and Constitutional... according to today's interpretation of it.

Sure, things were quite different in 1776.

We had slaves, for example. Everything a women owned, including any money she made, was the property of her husband. Just a short while later it was legal to hunt Native Americans in California because they were animals, not people. Smokeless powder didn't exist. At that time they were still burning people alive here in Hawaii. After the revolution only land owning white males could vote in this great country. Each State printed its own currency. The Spanish Inquisition was still happening.

Laws have changed around a bit since then. Interpretations of laws that haven't changed have shifted around, too.

edit: I should say that I agree with the philosophers that "rights" are inalienable. My point is that the courts deal with laws much more than philosophy. The loaded rifle marchers are headed to jail if D.C. police chose to send them there.

Everything you are arguing is based on the norms of SOCIETY, not just the government.  Society evolves (slavery, women's rights, minority rights, civil rights in general, etc.).  As society evolves, so do the laws for that society -- for the most part.

You can cite as many examples of mistakes or societal injustices as you want.  The fact remains: the American Constitutional system of government is the worst system in the world ...except for all the others!
When only cops have guns, it's called a "police state".

clshade

Re: A march on Washington with loaded rifles
« Reply #29 on: May 06, 2013, 06:19:45 PM »
Everything you are arguing is based on the norms of SOCIETY, not just the government.  Society evolves (slavery, women's rights, minority rights, civil rights in general, etc.).  As society evolves, so do the laws for that society -- for the most part.

You do realize this is ~exactly~ the argument many leftwingers make for increased gun regulation? :-/ Its also the rationale behind the NFA and why it doesn't (legally) infringe on the 2nd amendment.

You can cite as many examples of mistakes or societal injustices as you want.  The fact remains: the American Constitutional system of government is the worst system in the world ...except for all the others!

Oh, no judgement from me on that. I didn't say it was bad, just that it was so. And the way it ~is~ differs substantially from the way many armchair Constitutional Scholars think it is.

moosed

  • Trade Count: (+5)
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 867
  • Total likes: 0
  • Well, I'm all broken up over that man's rights!
  • Referrals: 2
    • View Profile
Re: A march on Washington with loaded rifles
« Reply #30 on: May 06, 2013, 06:42:02 PM »
You do realize this is ~exactly~ the argument many leftwingers make for increased gun regulation? :-/ Its also the rationale behind the NFA and why it doesn't (legally) infringe on the 2nd amendment.

That's the beauty of a government based on human rights and the rule of law.  The fundamental basis of our system is applicable regardless of the issue or which side you are supporting.  The reasoning that "left wingers" use to support their arguments do not give them an exclusive claim to those facts and suppositions.  in fact, using the very same facts and suppositions to refute their misguided and erroneous conclusions helps bolster the pro-gun argument, in that the other side has just stipulated to the underlying principles.

More specifically, the evolution and enlightenment of a society does not support the disarming of the population.  On the contrary, use of force to protect our enlightened population from those who have not reached that same pinnacle of tolerance and acceptance is a logical conclusion.  Else, we risk having that advancement and enlightenment stripped from our society by choosing to have no means (or desire) to protect ourselves and our ideals. Hence, our advancement and enlightenment will have been wasted, and erased, because of our denial that such evolution was not universal.

I know I'm rambling, but it's been a rough month already ... and it's only the 6th!!   :wacko:
When only cops have guns, it's called a "police state".

MDS

Re: A march on Washington with loaded rifles
« Reply #31 on: May 07, 2013, 09:27:52 AM »
Rationalization through disjointed perspectives is nothing new; and yes, it’s commonly found in “law”. And yes, those are the laws they are demonstrating against. Skewed laws which are to be constitutionally congruent can be readily identified by exposing the “perspective” used to derive the “rationalization” of the “law”.  Any given perspective can derive any given evaluation. The pretense behind such skewed judiciary evaluation has become common place amongst the majority judiciary body today and it’s because of that last line of now compromised defense in which we now see our nation fallen to its knees. It’s clearly our judiciary branch, the last line that has failed – “We the people”. This has been accomplished through the internal compromise of those justices who have failed us all. My respect for law is limited to those laws that are clearly in line with common conscience and I find nothing but distain for those that are contrary to that conscience as they are a true aberration of their own undisciplined perspective. We all know what these skewed laws are like, coercion through “tax” (health care), building codes (not land use) applied to personal projects and not kept limited to the “business of”, administrative bypass of judicial due process (Fines, etc), (place your pet peeve here), etc.

So my opinion on the intent of the march on Washington remains unmoved. A nation that cannot allow such demonstration is a nation of bankrupt integrity and it’s clearly a nation that no longer represents the people. Therein lays the very intent of the March, a minority wants to peaceably assemble and demonstrate a grievance, simple as that and no diversity therein of applied perspective holds merit beyond its own devices.

moosed

  • Trade Count: (+5)
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 867
  • Total likes: 0
  • Well, I'm all broken up over that man's rights!
  • Referrals: 2
    • View Profile
Re: A march on Washington with loaded rifles
« Reply #32 on: May 07, 2013, 09:49:06 AM »
If the Executive Office of the Nation (Obama) can come out on the national media and actually SUPPORT the illegal Occupy movement's actions (no permits, trespassing on private land, destruction of private and public property,  impeding the flow of traffic, harassing pedestrians on public walkways, littering, noise, defecating and urinating in public, and so on), and applaude their spirit and determination, then Obama (and law enforcement) will be guilty of unequal application of the law should they interfere with this march. 

Picking and choosing which causes you will support by allowing one group of protestors a free pass when breaking laws and not another group just smacks of a political agenda, not law enforcement.
When only cops have guns, it's called a "police state".

BUD

Re: A march on Washington with loaded rifles
« Reply #33 on: May 07, 2013, 10:13:32 AM »
Tell the Japanese Americans during WWII about their  "God given rights..."

Until God comes down from the heavens and tells the Government what to do, your "rights" come from the government.

The Declaration is a legal document informing England that they would no longer be receiving taxes from us. Has ~nothing~ to do with the legal definition of rights. Applying the wording of the Declaration to the Constitution and the Bill of Rights is a classic fallacy that a lot of armchair Constitutional Scholars enjoy. Its still a fallacy.

Philosophers and historians talk about nature derived or God given rights. Meanwhile the legislature and courts deal with "legal rights" which are given and taken by the authorities.

Armed Watertown SWAT Team member: "You are being evacuated. There is a terrorist on the loose."
Resident: "Let me get my shoes..."
SWAT: "No, you are moving out now."
Resident: "But...."
SWAT: "Move! NOW!"

Notice the nuanced discussion of rights?

The 2nd amendment articulates the nature derived right to keep and bear arms. The NFA has articulated for quite some time a class of arms that you cannot keep and bear. The courts have held up time and time again that the 2nd amendment is not absolute and that regional governments have the authority to enact their own regulations. Thus... D.C's ban on open carry is both legal and Constitutional... according to today's interpretation of it.

Sure, things were quite different in 1776.

We had slaves, for example. Everything a women owned, including any money she made, was the property of her husband. Just a short while later it was legal to hunt Native Americans in California because they were animals, not people. Smokeless powder didn't exist. At that time they were still burning people alive here in Hawaii. After the revolution only land owning white males could vote in this great country. Each State printed its own currency. The Spanish Inquisition was still happening.

Laws have changed around a bit since then. Interpretations of laws that haven't changed have shifted around, too.

edit: I should say that I agree with the philosophers that "rights" are inalienable. My point is that the courts deal with laws much more than philosophy. The loaded rifle marchers are headed to jail if D.C. police chose to send them there.


So because laws are changed and re-interpeted over time our rights are changed?  Whether endowed or granted?  Seems like we have nothing to complain about then. 
It is what it is.

Aegis808

Re: A march on Washington with loaded rifles
« Reply #34 on: May 07, 2013, 10:18:16 AM »
This is more than appropriate, this is needed. Many of you talk big about loving your rights and being willing to defend them and now you have the opportunity to do exactly that. Shall no be infringed doesn't mean compromise, it doesn't mean talk it over and come to something the politicians can agree on. And it sure as hell doesn't mean let the government dictate how, where, and when you can use your rights. The republic is no longer in control of the people and you can't win when they don't even have to play by the rules that they create.

You'll all grumble and groan about bans for this and bans for that. Maybe you send some emails and some money to a pro-gun organization. In the end you guys will just sit back and let it happen because there's already a long history of it. Here in Hawaii it was allowed for registration to pass, "assault pistols" became a legal definition, NFA items aren't allowed, and you can't even carry your gun around at all. This passive aggressive fight being put up out here is a whole bunch of bs and  is never going to get anything fixed.

You only have rights when you are willing to defend them and the government knows this so it will ignore them first and answer for them later in their own courts. This state is right up there with NY and Cali where liberty is concerned.

BUD

Re: A march on Washington with loaded rifles
« Reply #35 on: May 07, 2013, 10:56:42 AM »
This is more than appropriate, this is needed. Many of you talk big about loving your rights and being willing to defend them and now you have the opportunity to do exactly that. Shall no be infringed doesn't mean compromise, it doesn't mean talk it over and come to something the politicians can agree on. And it sure as hell doesn't mean let the government dictate how, where, and when you can use your rights. The republic is no longer in control of the people and you can't win when they don't even have to play by the rules that they create.

You'll all grumble and groan about bans for this and bans for that. Maybe you send some emails and some money to a pro-gun organization. In the end you guys will just sit back and let it happen because there's already a long history of it. Here in Hawaii it was allowed for registration to pass, "assault pistols" became a legal definition, NFA items aren't allowed, and you can't even carry your gun around at all. This passive aggressive fight being put up out here is a whole bunch of bs and  is never going to get anything fixed.

You only have rights when you are willing to defend them and the government knows this so it will ignore them first and answer for them later in their own courts. This state is right up there with NY and Cali where liberty is concerned.

This was my point.  Without anyone ever standing up for these rights, we might not have ever gotten them. 
It is what it is.

clshade

Re: A march on Washington with loaded rifles
« Reply #36 on: May 07, 2013, 11:11:53 AM »
Needed?

As I've said before I agree with the demonstration in principle.

Doing it in D.C. is a huge mistake. Knowingly and publicly committing a felony is a huge mistake when most of us spout "law abiding gun owners" on a daily basis and that "criminals don't obey laws."

Sure, it would make a point but it is doing so in a way that is faaaaaar too easy for the opponents of the 2nd amendment to turn to their advantage. And doing so in a way that creates far more potential for damaging public moments than positive ones.

It is reactionary, incendiary hype building and not at all strategic thinking. You know why most demonstrations don't do much: utter lack of strategic thinking. Getting out there and expressing your opinion doesn't have any affect unless there is a larger movement afoot, legislation being considered, etc. That's why the Occupy "movement" hasn't accomplished much, why the hippies didn't get much actually changed in D.C. and why walking around with loaded rifles where it is a felony to do so is pointless.

When Gandhi broke the law and had lots of people making salt down by the sea and was arrested.... it was crystal clear that the British were being unreasonable in forbidding the making of salt. When (if) this march happens and some of them are thrown in jail before the rest abandon ship what crystal clear point will have been made to the larger public about gun owners and gun rights?

Sure, they are "standing up for our rights." But they are doing it in such a way that is more likely to damage those rights than to support them. That's stupid.

Jl808

Re: A march on Washington with loaded rifles
« Reply #37 on: May 07, 2013, 11:28:15 AM »
I agree that this is a bad idea. I think doing this at DC only gives the antis more ammo to fight us with.

All it takes is 1 in 1000 idiot to shoot someone and it becomes a horrible demonstration of gun rights.  An al-quaeda terrorist or an anti-gun activist can easily just plant someone in there and make the whole gathering look like a bunch of dangerous and law breaking citizens.
I think, therefore I am armed.
NRA Life Patron member, HRA Life member, HiFiCo Life Member, HDF member

The United States Constitution © 1791. All Rights Reserved.

Aegis808

Re: A march on Washington with loaded rifles
« Reply #38 on: May 07, 2013, 11:39:02 AM »
Needed?

As I've said before I agree with the demonstration in principle.

Doing it in D.C. is a huge mistake. Knowingly and publicly committing a felony is a huge mistake when most of us spout "law abiding gun owners" on a daily basis and that "criminals don't obey laws."

Sure, it would make a point but it is doing so in a way that is faaaaaar too easy for the opponents of the 2nd amendment to turn to their advantage. And doing so in a way that creates far more potential for damaging public moments than positive ones.

It is reactionary, incendiary hype building and not at all strategic thinking. You know why most demonstrations don't do much: utter lack of strategic thinking. Getting out there and expressing your opinion doesn't have any affect unless there is a larger movement afoot, legislation being considered, etc. That's why the Occupy "movement" hasn't accomplished much, why the hippies didn't get much actually changed in D.C. and why walking around with loaded rifles where it is a felony to do so is pointless.

When Gandhi broke the law and had lots of people making salt down by the sea and was arrested.... it was crystal clear that the British were being unreasonable in forbidding the making of salt. When (if) this march happens and some of them are thrown in jail before the rest abandon ship what crystal clear point will have been made to the larger public about gun owners and gun rights?

Sure, they are "standing up for our rights." But they are doing it in such a way that is more likely to damage those rights than to support them. That's stupid.

the fear of losing your rights by using them is exactly why we have been losing them. Feelings do not trump rights and by allowing them to do so you further the destruction of all rights.

BUD

Re: A march on Washington with loaded rifles
« Reply #39 on: May 07, 2013, 12:47:13 PM »
Needed?

As I've said before I agree with the demonstration in principle.

Doing it in D.C. is a huge mistake. Knowingly and publicly committing a felony is a huge mistake when most of us spout "law abiding gun owners" on a daily basis and that "criminals don't obey laws."

Sure, it would make a point but it is doing so in a way that is faaaaaar too easy for the opponents of the 2nd amendment to turn to their advantage. And doing so in a way that creates far more potential for damaging public moments than positive ones.

It is reactionary, incendiary hype building and not at all strategic thinking. You know why most demonstrations don't do much: utter lack of strategic thinking. Getting out there and expressing your opinion doesn't have any affect unless there is a larger movement afoot, legislation being considered, etc. That's why the Occupy "movement" hasn't accomplished much, why the hippies didn't get much actually changed in D.C. and why walking around with loaded rifles where it is a felony to do so is pointless.

When Gandhi broke the law and had lots of people making salt down by the sea and was arrested.... it was crystal clear that the British were being unreasonable in forbidding the making of salt. When (if) this march happens and some of them are thrown in jail before the rest abandon ship what crystal clear point will have been made to the larger public about gun owners and gun rights?

Sure, they are "standing up for our rights." But they are doing it in such a way that is more likely to damage those rights than to support them. That's stupid.

So when do we reach the tipping point on this issue?  In other words, when do we reach that point where writing to our representatives is not enough?  What makes us decide that being intellectual about it is just not enough?  I would wonder which is more dangerous, action or inaction?
It is what it is.