2aHawaii
General Topics => Political Discussion => Topic started by: ren on September 18, 2020, 02:06:01 PM
-
RIP :(
-
Not unexpected, but still somber news.
Can't say I'm sad, though. Makes this November's election even more important.
-
Trump should make the nomination before the election choosing someone the Left would have no problem with.
That would diffuse the Democrats, because if they oppose his pick, it eliminates the possibility that the Dems will also support that nominee if Trump loses.
Trump: "I nominate this LIBERAL to the Supreme Court." (Liberal, but not Extreme Left)
Democrats: "Orange Man BAD! We'll never accept that nominee!"
Biden: "I won, and I will support Former President Trump's Supreme Court Liberal nominee."
Democrats: "Yay!!"
-
Trump should make the nomination before the election choosing someone the Left would have no problem with.
That would diffuse the Democrats, because if they oppose his pick, it eliminates the option of the Dems also picking that nominee if Trump loses.
Trump: "I nominate this LIBERAL to the Supreme Court." (Liberal, but not Extreme Left)
Democrats: "Orange Man BAD! We'll never accept that nominee!"
Biden: "I won, and I will support Former President Trump's Supreme Court Liberal nominee."
Democrats: "Yay!!"
Is there enough time for trump to pick another justice?
-
Conservative Twitter : (some form of) RIP, our prayers and condolences to the family
Leftist Twitter :
-
Is there enough time for trump to pick another justice?
Only if the Senate can push the confirmation vote through.
Trump could name his nominee today if he wanted. It's up to McConnell to call for a confirmation hearing.
Maybe now, with the lockdowns and other pandemic crap going on, the Dems will be too distracted to put up as much of a fight as they did against Kavanaugh.
-
Conservative Twitter : (some form of) RIP, our prayers and condolences to the family
Leftist Twitter :
Wow there are some unstable people on Twitter. Sounds familiar actually.
Still sad news overall. That said, think things are crazy now? Hold on to your butts.
-
Conservative Twitter : (some form of) RIP, our prayers and condolences to the family
Leftist Twitter :
Stages of grief:
1. Denial; "No! No" Nooooooooooo!!!!"
2. Anger; "F**k!! Sh!#!! G@dd@mmit!! Motherf**ker!! Burn it all down!!"
3. Bargaining; "Trump NEEDS to nominate a far left judge, just to be FAIR! If Trump does that, we won't BURN IT ALL DOWN!!"
4. Depression; "We're all SCREWED!! This is the end of Democracy! The Fascists have won!!"
5. Acceptance. <== Not going to happen.
-
HolyShite! This is the battle lines drawn.
The election of which President will rest on this as much as anything with anyone who knows anything.
Debates should be entertaining.
Congress will clusterfuck as usual, only this time on purpose.
Still sad news overall. That said, think things are crazy now? Hold on to your butts.
Well said.
-
Stages of grief:
1. Denial; "No! No" Nooooooooooo!!!!"
2. Anger; "F**k!! Sh!#!! G@dd@mmit!! Motherf**ker!! Burn it all down!!"
3. Bargaining; "Trump NEEDS to nominate a far left judge, just to be FAIR! If Trump does that, we won't BURN IT ALL DOWN!!"
4. Depression; "We're all SCREWED!! This is the end of Democracy! The Fascists have won!!"
5. Acceptance. <== Not going to happen.
Those who’ve accepted can’t be leftists because leftists can’t accept reality....
-
She was an incredible lady with a historic and outstanding career. I did not agree with all her decisions but she always presented her case with decorum. The unhinged left could learn a lot from her example, but they are too busy playing winner take all.
-
Word is nominee will be announced within a few days and McConnell says Trump's nominee will get a vote from the full Senate. So there!
-
Do the Democrat Party thing,
Ram it through before it can be stopped.
I'd normally say RIP.
But in her case it's more like I need to Pee
on the enemy.
"Who's next" My favorite
album cover..
-
https://youtu.be/mIDK9cYIoHs
-
Top prediction at this point for Trump's pick:
Amy Coney Barrett
United States Circuit Judge of the
United States Court of Appeals for the
Seventh Circuit
https://youtu.be/Lx5yRYbRoIg
-
Trump’s Supreme Court list: President reveals
names of 20 more people he’d consider nominating
White House Press Secretary Kayleigh McEnany said in a statement, “President Trump’s list of potential
Supreme Court nominees demonstrates his commitment to appointing originalists, who will abide by the
Constitution, and textualists, who will implement the plain meaning of statutes. They will uphold the rule
of law and ensure that America continues to shine as a beacon of freedom and justice around the world.”
https://www.foxnews.com/politics/trump-announces-judicial-appointment-list-20-names
-
To be honest I think it’d be cool if trump waited until after the election. Just to get people motivated to go out and vote for him.
Kind of like if you believe your gonna win then “put your justice nominee where your mouth is” :rofl:
Edit: might also go over really well with independents and undecided voters.
-
To be honest I think it’d be cool if trump waited until after the election. Just to get people motivated to go out and vote for him.
Kind of like if you believe your gonna win then “put your justice nominee where your mouth is” :rofl:
Edit: might also go over really well with independents and undecided voters.
The court begins hearing cases in two weeks. Why do you want to have a 4/4 split until next March (the session ends in June)? That time frame likely would mean that the new justice would be excluded from virtually all the cases for the whole court calendar year, and wouldn't likely be actually involved in litigation until the October 2021 session begins. No way. DO IT NOW!
-
Trump should make the nomination before the election choosing someone the Left would have no problem with.
Any they would have no problem with would be the end of the 2A, of course.
Civil war, here we come.
-
To be honest I think it’d be cool if trump waited until after the election. Just to get people motivated to go out and vote for him.
Kind of like if you believe your gonna win then “put your justice nominee where your mouth is” :rofl:
Edit: might also go over really well with independents and undecided voters.
That's one strategy.
Even if Trump makes his pick now, the Senate still has to confirm. Look at how long the Dems drug out the Kavanaugh hearings, trying to delay it until after the midterms. Had the Dems won the Senate, they could have blocked Kavanaugh's confirmation. That cluster was the worst circus in the history of Congress.
If that crap happens again, Trump can use the circus/hearings to fire up his voting base. He won't have to delay his nomination until after the election, because the Dems will try to do that for him.
I'm not sure what the rules are, but once a nomination is before the Senate, I would think the Senate has to vote for confirmation at some point. Could a President Biden ( :shake:) withdraw a SC nomination once it's presented to the Senate for confirmation? Would be interesting to see him try.
I think Trump should go ahead with the nomination. If confirmation happens, that's a very good thing whether Trump wins reelection or not. Plus, I don't believe Biden is going to win. Even if he survives the debates, I think any enthusiasm for him will fade once his lack of faculties is demonstrated for all to see.
If Trump wins, there's the probability the Dems/Leftist groups will contest the election results again, riot and drag the final electoral vote out as long as possible, which could delay the SC nomination.
Better to get this SC pick in the "win" column as soon as possible, while the Dems are more focused on stealing the election.
I heard Adam Schiff has another whistleblower report and is opening another investigation into Trump. That man has no credibility, but it isn't stopping him. I guess he figures his image can't get any worse! :crazy: That could easily be the Dem's "October Surprise" for 2020.
All that on top of what punaperson said re: a missing jurist on the court for that long.
The sooner, the better.
-
https://youtu.be/mIDK9cYIoHs
what a racist, misogynist thing to say!
he's SO unpresidential!
-
what a racist, misogynist thing to say!
he's SO unpresidential!
Yeah. If she had been a Conservative Male Justice, Trump would have been briefed on the passing long before the press had to inform him.
So out of touch! :wtf:
-
Trump should make the nomination before the election choosing someone the Left would have no problem with.
I thought republicans said nominations shouldn't be made so close to a presidential election.
-
I thought republicans said nominations shouldn't be made so close to a presidential election.
They did.
-
I thought republicans said nominations shouldn't be made so close to a presidential election.
There are 2 types of PRESIDENTIAL elections: 1st term and 2nd term. Obama named a nominee in his second term (lame duck) which is why the Senate did not want to have confirmation hearings. They didn't think it was fair TO THE NOMINEE to have hearings in such a major political season as it would only politicize the confirmation proceedings.
Not all "Presidential elections" are equal. The Dems even tried to use the midterm election to block Kavanaugh's nomination "prior to an election" -- not even a Presidential election year. You Liberals will twist any and everything to spin a narrative in your favor or against the other side.
Trump is not only running for reelection (not a lame duck), but he's got a better than even chance or winning. So, there's no justification for delaying the process. The nominee will get a fairer hearing out from under the distraction of a new administration immediately replacing the outgoing administration.
-
Nobody said that -- except for Democrats when Trump was nominating Kavanaugh.
The issue with Obama was he was a Lame Duck and on his way out of office. And it wasn't "Republicans", it was the Senate majority. Small subset of "Republicans."
Trump is not only running for reelection (not a lame duck), but he's got a better than even chance or reelection. So, there's no justification for delaying the process.
Ok, yes, it was some republicans. And Kavanaugh wasn't nominated while Trump was running for president.
You said that though. Here is a quote from you in a 2018 post
"In the middle of a PRESIDENTIAL GENERAL ELECTION (not a midterm) is the wrong environment to be going through a justice confirmation."
The republicans in charge of holding hearings on a nominee for SCOTUS make this argument then Garland was selected. You can sure as hell bet that democrats are going to play the exact same card and it is going to make republicans look like weasels. Not a look I like to wear but they made it back then and they better stick to it.
-
https://youtu.be/suiVdH9CVH8
-
If you believe in the Second Amendment, it's critical that Trump gets reelected.
https://youtu.be/epFdlWi8W7w
-
Ok, yes, it was some republicans. And Kavanaugh wasn't nominated while Trump was running for president.
You said that though. Here is a quote from you in a 2018 post
"In the middle of a PRESIDENTIAL GENERAL ELECTION (not a midterm) is the wrong environment to be going through a justice confirmation."
The republicans in charge of holding hearings on a nominee for SCOTUS make this argument then Garland was selected. You can sure as hell bet that democrats are going to play the exact same card and it is going to make republicans look like weasels. Not a look I like to wear but they made it back then and they better stick to it.
And I stand by that statement.
RGB should have had better timing. She had plenty of opportunities to kick off before this year, but she refused to at the very least retire, just to thwart Trump.
Who battles cancer 4 times plus a host of other ailments and refuses to retire before 88 years old? That's just pure stubbornness. :wtf:
And if you don't think that's true, you need to read the news today:
Ruth Bader Ginsburg’s dying wish was not to be ‘replaced’ until there’s a new president
https://www.cnbc.com/2020/09/18/justice-ruth-bader-ginsburg-wished-that-i-will-not-be-replaced-until-a-new-president-is-installed-report-says.html
Nothing Anti-Trump about Ruthie, rest her soul. :geekdanc:
-
After taking in some of the opinions of others online, here's what I see in a nutshell:
Delaying the replacement of RBG until after the election MAY help energize the right to vote for Trump, BUT
delaying will ABSOLUTELY become THE ISSUE for the Democrats to energize voters for Biden.
Right now, there's really no issue that Biden can press to get out the vote other than "I'm not Trump." Leaving the SC nomination on the table in November hands them a YUUUUGE carrot to get Democrats to vote.
I think the best thing Trump and the Senate can do now is press for the nomination before November, which totally diffuses the issue. And hopefully the Dems spent a big chunk of their campaign using that as an issue, reducing the resources spent on others.
It'll be interesting to see what Trump's administration decides to do. No matter which way it goes, the media is going to pounce and relentlessly try to bash Trump over it. So, there's really no difference from that perspective no matter which way he decides.
-
Ok, yes, it was some republicans. And Kavanaugh wasn't nominated while Trump was running for president.
You said that though. Here is a quote from you in a 2018 post
"In the middle of a PRESIDENTIAL GENERAL ELECTION (not a midterm) is the wrong environment to be going through a justice confirmation."
The republicans in charge of holding hearings on a nominee for SCOTUS make this argument then Garland was selected. You can sure as hell bet that democrats are going to play the exact same card and it is going to make republicans look like weasels. Not a look I like to wear but they made it back then and they better stick to it.
But it was during a midterm where dems were hoping to gain the senate majority and deny Trump any chance of picking a justice.
Honestly I’d like to see the repubs play dirty for once. They are usually such spineless pussies id rather watch them grow a sack and be on the offensive rather then always playing defense. For some reason the left gets to play little games and pull ridiculous shit all the time.
Like I said in another post, it’d be cool to see trump wait till after the election. It would prove that the right is actually looking at a red wave this November.
-
Only if the Senate can push the confirmation vote through.
Trump could name his nominee today if he wanted. It's up to McConnell to call for a confirmation hearing.
Maybe now, with the lockdowns and other pandemic crap going on, the Dems will be too distracted to put up as much of a fight as they did against Kavanaugh.
Doubtful.
Just think somewhere out there there's a rapist, raging homophob, sexist, demon judge in our court system.
Too bad that judge won't know how evil he/she is until Trump nominates him/her.
-
But it was during a midterm where dems were hoping to gain the senate majority and deny Trump any chance of picking a justice.
Honestly I’d like to see the repubs play dirty for once. They are usually such spineless pussies id rather watch them grow a sack and be on the offensive rather then always playing defense. For some reason the left gets to play little games and pull ridiculous shit all the time.
Like I said in another post, it’d be cool to see trump wait till after the election. It would prove that the right is actually looking at a red wave this November.
The republicans played dirty when they denied giving Garland even a nomination hearing. Not an actual vote, just a hearing.
They should have just had the hearing and voted him down instead of looking corrupt by making up some non existent standard about election times. That is what bothers me, that isn't conservativism in action, it is big government bureaucracy in action, something we expect from democrats, not republicans.
Personally I do want Trump to nominate someone as soon as possible but if congress holds hearings on it then they have just shot themselves in the foot from their imaginary rule from 4 years ago. RBG was a classy lady, had a long great career, and now that she has passed we need a new judge asap because the government still has a job to do.
-
The republicans played dirty when they denied giving Garland even a nomination hearing. Not an actual vote, just a hearing.
They should have just had the hearing and voted him down instead of looking corrupt by making up some non existent standard about election times. That is what bothers me, that isn't conservativism in action, it is big government bureaucracy in action, something we expect from democrats, not republicans.
Personally I do want Trump to nominate someone as soon as possible but if congress holds hearings on it then they have just shot themselves in the foot from their imaginary rule from 4 years ago. RBG was a classy lady, had a long great career, and now that she has passed we need a new judge asap because the government still has a job to do.
I still say there is ample justification for what McConnell did. He had the opportunity to affect the make-up of the Supreme Court, but it was a SLIM CHANCE.
If you remember, Hillary was supposed to win handily by a large landslide. Trump wasn't even on the Electoral College radar. There's nothing to support the notion that McConnell knew a Republican would win. Therefore, delaying the hearings until after November was probably going to give Hildabeast the option to keep Garland as the nominee. So, McConnell was more than justified in delaying in order to keep the hearings from becoming political.
In the case of RGB's vacancy, the hearings are going to be political no matter when they occur. Now, after the election, or when Pence is elected -- as long as a Republican is making the nomination, it's going to be politicized.
-
After the impeachment any chance of bipartisan cooperation is dead. This will be a brutal fight as the CIA and other corrupt intelligence agencies make a desperate scramble to regain lost ground, because it is clear that Ginsberg was part of their Color Revolution plan to overthrow the election results. The divisions in the country will deepen, and it was not even 24 hourse before AOC started calling out her followers to "radicalize". Unfortunately this means we can most likely expect more street violence and possibly domestic terrorism, compounding the already disastrous economic situation. On the other hand it is rather entertaining watching the Democratic leadership beg for parlay now that they have wandered so far up Schitt Creek without a paddle.
-
The republicans played dirty when they denied giving Garland even a nomination hearing. Not an actual vote, just a hearing.
They should have just had the hearing and voted him down instead of looking corrupt by making up some non existent standard about election times. That is what bothers me, that isn't conservativism in action, it is big government bureaucracy in action, something we expect from democrats, not republicans.
Personally I do want Trump to nominate someone as soon as possible but if congress holds hearings on it then they have just shot themselves in the foot from their imaginary rule from 4 years ago. RBG was a classy lady, had a long great career, and now that she has passed we need a new judge asap because the government still has a job to do.
Why hold a vote to only down vote the nominee? What a waste of tax dollars that would be. No opposing party has ever voted for an opposing presidents nominee since 1880. There’s nothing dirty about that nor is it hypocrisy on any party it’s just politics. Like Obama so smugly said “elections have consequences.”
-
Another reason McConnell gave for holding up the hearing on Garland was related to the election. He said that by leaving the nomination on the table in Nov, it offered voters a chance to weigh in on which party they wanted to choose who sits on the highest court in the land.
In other words, It was Hillary, coupled with Trump voters, who took the nomination away from Garland, not McConnell. Had she not lost, that seat would have been hers to fill.
Makes perfect sense to me -- let the voters decide when it's a lame duck appointment, because it's unfair to the nominee to turn their confirmation into a political football.
The political football thing is a given no matter when Trump makes his pick. It's like when a judge denies change of venue in a criminal trial based on his reasoning that no other jury will be any more partial than a local one. Nothing to gain by making a different choice.
-
If Trump drops a nomination before November, it will definitely impact those who would be part of the vetting and confirmation process. Kamala Harris comes to mind. Not sure who in the House that would be involved that are up for re-election, but that's another angle I was thinking about. Distraction.
Then there are other ways to distract the public. . . :shake:
-
If Trump drops a nomination before November, it will definitely impact those who would be part of the vetting and confirmation process. Kamala Harris comes to mind. Not sure who in the House that would be involved that are up for re-election, but that's another angle I was thinking about. Distraction.
Then there are other ways to distract the public. . . :shake:
Absolutely. If Harris is dragged off the campaign trail for a few weeks when there are only 44 days remaining before election day, Biden's campaign will suffer.
Trump has 3-4 family members plus VP Pence criss-crossing the US campaigning. Biden has Harris .... and himself.
Another strategic reason to nominate a replacement now. :thumbsup: :geekdanc:
-
Unfortunately this means we can most likely expect more street violence and possibly domestic terrorism
The bastards are already threatening this:
"“If they ever TRY toreplace RBG we burn the entire f---ing thing down,” threatened former CNN staffer and part-time cannibal Reza Aslan."
" “Mitch McConnell is an evil b@stard. Burn the whole party to the ground. The GOP is done.”"
Keep your powder dry.
-
The bastards are already threatening this:
"“If they ever TRY toreplace RBG we burn the entire f---ing thing down,” threatened former CNN staffer and part-time cannibal Reza Aslan."
" “Mitch McConnell is an evil b@stard. Burn the whole party to the ground. The GOP is done.”"
Keep your powder dry.
Are these the same people who claim Trump is destroying "democracy?"
I don't think they know the meaning of the word.
-
If you believe in the Second Amendment, it's critical that Trump gets reelected.
https://youtu.be/epFdlWi8W7w
So he wants Trump to nominate someone who supports late term/live birth abortions, supports open borders and consequent free government-funded medical care and food and housing for illegal aliens, supports blocking mining and fossil fuel development, etc., etc., etc., but will be a strong proponent of Second Amendment rights to the extent of getting rid of requirements for suppressors and full auto, etc.? Haha. What a fucking idiot.
-
So he wants Trump to nominate someone who supports late term/live birth abortions, supports open borders and consequent free government-funded medical care and food and housing for illegal aliens, supports blocking mining and fossil fuel development, etc., etc., etc., but will be a strong proponent of Second Amendment rights to the extent of getting rid of requirements for suppressors and full auto, etc.? Haha. What a fucking idiot.
You must have watched a different video than I did. :wacko:
-
https://youtu.be/suiVdH9CVH8
My data limit gets reset at midmight tonight so I watched the video.
It was pretty good except the mention of three Pubby's that
may stray. I don't think Mitch McConnell was one of them
more likely Mitt Romney.
It will be interesting to see how this plays out.
Just got #5 of Orville Redenbocker popcorn on sale.
-
My data limit gets reset at midmight tonight so I watched the video.
It was pretty good except the mention of three Pubby's that
may stray. I don't think Mitch McConnell was one of them
more likely Mitt Romney.
It will be interesting to see how this plays out.
Just got #5 of Orville Redenbocker popcorn on sale.
I think the two others being discussed are Susan Collins and Lisa Murkowski. If memory serves, weren't they the ones on the fence regarding Trump's impeachment? They, along with Mitt Romney, made statements to the effect of, "I think I should see all the evidence before making up my mind." That included ALL THE DOCUMENTS AND DEPOSITIONS the Democrats in the House tried to coerce from the administration without taking their subpoenas through the courts to have enforced or quashed.
Never-Trumpers (aka Swamp Critters) exist in both parties, because they have a certain way of doing things in DC, and Trump just isn't playing by their rules. When the President isn't interested in seeking office for power and wealth, it threatens those who are.
-
Tbh they should not confirm anyone. All it will do is piss off the left. Motivate them to vote. Even if they get someone in they going to pack the courts so instead of 6-3 it will be 6-9. And with current political trends they will be able to pull it off
-
Tbh they should not confirm anyone. All it will do is piss off the left. Motivate them to vote. Even if they get someone in they going to pack the courts so instead of 6-3 it will be 6-9. And with current political trends they will be able to pull it off
Mitch made the comment during the Obama nomination of Garland that the main reason he delayed was because the Republicans became the majority during Obama's administration. That, to him, was a mandate by voters that they wanted Obama's policies and decisions to be more constrained than the Dems were doing.
By delaying, he gave the voters another chance to voice their preference for a new justice through the general election. Had Hildabeast won, the Dems would have had no issue with the delay.
However, the Senate is still a GOP majority. Until that changes, the President's party is secondary as it relates to McConnell's comments.
The President can only nominate. The Senate has the power to confirm or reject the nominee. That, to me, says more about how voters want decisions made than who becomes President.
Congress represents the voters. The President represents everyone. At least, that's how the system was designed.
-
Here's a scenario for you:
- Trump and/or the Senate are unable/unwilling to confirm a new justice by November.
- The Presidential race is so close in a couple of battleground states, and there are so many "irregularities" with mail-in votes, it takes 2 months to go through all the recounts, re-recounts and legal challenges.
- If the final determination of who won the election comes down to a Supreme Court decision:
(1) What if the Supreme Court is tied (4-4) on whether the race is over regardless of who is in the lead, or the recounts continue allowing whoever is behind to catch up after they "find" enough votes to gain the lead?
(2) What if the now-mostly-conservative Supreme Court rules Trump is the winner, and Liberals are unable to accept the decision as legitimate and nonpartisan?
If you lived through the Gore vs Bush 2000 election, you might remember how the Democrats chose specific counties to START a Florida recount, then tried to get the recount stopped as soon as the vote totals favored Gore. The lawyers from both camps will be trying to game the laws and election procedures for their party before anyone is at work on Wednesday.
You might also remember how the lawyers managed to get the rules changed to allow the recounts to "interpret the intentions" of those who cast ballots with problems like incompletely punched "chads". The rules had always been that an incomplete or incorrectly marked ballot was deemed a "spoiled ballot" and not to be counted. I imagine they've learned from that experience and the shenanigans in 2020 will be significantly more "creative".
This is another reason to appoint the justice and confirm them before Nov. A decision that gives Trump the win will be bad, but a Supreme Court deadlocked over what the Constitution and election laws mean could be a lot worse.
-
Here's a scenario for you:
- Trump and/or the Senate are unable/unwilling to confirm a new justice by November.
- The Presidential race is so close in a couple of battleground states, and there are so many "irregularities" with mail-in votes, it takes 2 months to go through all the recounts, re-recounts and legal challenges.
- If the final determination of who won the election comes down to a Supreme Court decision:
(1) What if the Supreme Court is tied (4-4) on whether the race is over regardless of who is in the lead, or the recounts continue allowing whoever is behind to catch up after they "find" enough votes to gain the lead?
(2) What if the now-mostly-conservative Supreme Court rules Trump is the winner, and Liberals are unable to accept the decision as legitimate and nonpartisan?
If you lived through the Gore vs Bush 2000 election, you might remember how the Democrats chose specific counties to START a Florida recount, then tried to get the recount stopped as soon as the vote totals favored Gore. The lawyers from both camps will be trying to game the laws and election procedures for their party before anyone is at work on Wednesday.
You might also remember how the lawyers managed to get the rules changed to allow the recounts to "interpret the intentions" of those who cast ballots with problems like incompletely punched "chads". The rules had always been that an incomplete or incorrectly marked ballot was deemed a "spoiled ballot" and not to be counted. I imagine they've learned from that experience and the shenanigans in 2020 will be significantly more "creative".
This is another reason to appoint the justice and confirm them before Nov. A decision that gives Trump the win will be bad, but a Supreme Court deadlocked over what the Constitution and election laws mean could be a lot worse.
To quote someone who is arguably the world's best example of the essence of the Democrat party,
"I consider it completely unimportant who in the party will vote, or how; but what is extraordinarily important is this — who will count the votes, and how.”
J. Stalin
Source;
The Memoirs of Stalin’s Former Secretary by Boris Bazhanov, published in 2002. Translated from the Russian, the version which, according to
Bazhanov, was uttered in 1923 by Stalin in reference to a vote in the Central Committee of the Communist Party of the Soviet Union.
-
🤔
https://babylonbee.com/news/trump-nominates-himself-to-the-supreme-court?fbclid=IwAR1EzGj6bGhMCEKXRrENhXX-MlnHdhGOsLtgPbdQv-5PjcBzGcShilB_azg
-
Remember last year when it was reported that Ginsberg was deceased, erroneously, but then we didn't see or hear from her till now?
Funny how this comes out to make things even more unstable. 🤔
:tinfoil:
-
🤔
https://babylonbee.com/news/trump-nominates-himself-to-the-supreme-court?fbclid=IwAR1EzGj6bGhMCEKXRrENhXX-MlnHdhGOsLtgPbdQv-5PjcBzGcShilB_azg
Bold move cotton
-
Remember last year when it was reported that Ginsburg was deceased, erroneously, but then we didn't see or hear from her till now?
Funny how this comes out to make things even more unstable. 🤔
:tinfoil:
She was doing chemo for stage 4 metastatic pancreatic cancer -- just one in a long line of cancer diagnoses and pneumonia. I'll give her a pass for not being well enough to be visible the last few months, but not for hanging onto her seat.
I believed she was unfit to be on the bench with the time she required for treatments and, honestly, her age. The only reason I see she has given for not retiring when she could was that she hated Trump.
NPR reports that Ginsburg's granddaughter told them Ginsburg's most fervent final request is that ANOTHER PRESIDENT fill her vacated seat on the Supreme Court.
No more evidence is needed to see she was a TDS-sufferer, too, on top of all her other health issues.
Also, I highly doubt the nation will wait 4 more years for "another president" to be sworn in before filling her seat. The Constitution requires it be filled as soon as circumstances allow.
Ginsburg herself was nominated by Slick Willy and Confirmed by a Democrat majority in the Senate in 1993 in less than the amount of time we have now before the general election. So, it's not unprecedented that a President and Senate majority from the same party can confirm a Supreme Court Justice that quickly.
I wonder if the White House lawyers are researching all the close votes against Trump before the Supreme Court so they can appeal the rulings based on Ginsburg's animosity toward Trump? If not, maybe they should. She should have kept that "dying wish" to herself, because another president in 2020 is not a given (or in my mind a real possibility), and especially because she is supposed to be nonpartisan and unbiased as a Supreme Court judge.
https://youtu.be/htAeK6_Ij0M
-
I have nothing good to say about her and did not like her. Hope she fares better in paradise with the big “judge”. Good riddance.... :wave:
-
Collins and murkowski Will not support a nominee apparently.
-
Remember last year when it was reported that Ginsberg was deceased, erroneously, but then we didn't see or hear from her till now?
But, there had been a few sightings, I thought?
(https://i.pinimg.com/originals/06/b4/87/06b487db753899d97c19e5c6cc5b5ac6.jpg)
-
Collins and murkowski Will not support a nominee apparently.
If my math is right, that still leaves 51 GOP Senators. As long as they get a simple majority, they can call a confirmation vote.
I'm worried others are going to follow suit, like Romney.
There are 45 Dems and 3 Indies.
-
If my math is right, that still leaves 51 GOP Senators. As long as they get a simple majority, they can call a confirmation vote.
I'm worried others are going to follow suit, like Romney.
There are 45 Dems and 3 Indies.
I would be fucken floored if Romney voted for trumps nominee
-
I would be fucken floored if Romney voted for trumps nominee
Kavanaugh was confirmed with a vote of 50 - 48. Steve Daines of Montana was absent, and Lisa Murkowski voted "Present". She didn't vote against Kavanaugh, but she did voice her opposition to the nomination.
One Dem broke ranks and voted with the Republicans: Joe Manchin. Everyone else voted straight down party lines.
I can see Romney trying to extort McConnell or Trump. In exchange for his confirmation vote, he may want a committee position/chairmanship or other ransom to better his chances of reelection in 2 years. He just entered office in 2019 after the midterms, so there's no track record of him voting with or against the GOP on critical issues.
Correct me if I'm wrong, but I think I remember learning that, in case of a tie in the Senate, the VP, Pence, get's to cast the tie breaking vote as President of the Senate.
So, if the total looks something like 49-49, with 2 members not voting or voting "Present", Pence will be able to get the confirmation passed.
I believe the cloture rules require a simple majority, meaning the nominee needs to get 50 votes in the sSenate, no matter who those Senators are. 49 with a tie or 50 should be the target number of votes to get a confirmation.
-
Kavanaugh was confirmed with a vote of 50 - 48. Steve Daines of Montana was absent, and Lisa Murkowski voted "Present". She didn't vote against Kavanaugh, but she did voice her opposition to the nomination.
One Dem broke ranks and voted with the Republicans: Joe Manchin. Everyone else voted straight down party lines.
I can see Romney trying to extort McConnell or Trump. In exchange for his confirmation vote, he may want a committee position/chairmanship or other ransom to better his chances of reelection in 2 years. He just entered office in 2019 after the midterms, so there's no track record of him voting with or against the GOP on critical issues.
Correct me if I'm wrong, but I think I remember learning that, in case of a tie in the Senate, the VP, Pence, get's to cast the tie breaking vote as President of the Senate.
So, if the total looks something like 49-49, with 2 members not voting or voting "Present", Pence will be able to get the confirmation passed.
you are correct, sir
-
I thought republicans said nominations shouldn't be made so close to a presidential election.
The People rejected the Democrats in 2014, when the
Democrats lost the Senate Majority. Remember "Elections have consequences" Obama said that. The consequence of losing the Senate is that you lose the opportunity to confirm SCOTUS nominations. These rules were designed to put a check on power. If Democrats had both the Senate and the Executive branch trust and believe they would have confirmed and Left Wing nut to the Supreme Court.
Obviously politicians can't outright say that because it's off-putting but that's politics.
-
I wonder what the democrats reaction would be if Trump nominates a liberal to the seat.
:worship: Uncle Trump
-
I wonder what the democrats reaction would be if Trump nominates a liberal to the seat.
:worship: Uncle Trump
I have a little scenario playing on my evil mind .....
1. Trump nominates a super-Leftist Liberal (AOC? Omar?).
2. That totally diffuses the issue of SCOTUS nominations in an election year. No calls of hypocrisy, etc.
3. McConnell doesn't call a vote in Oct, but promises he will the day after the election.
4. McConnell drops the other shoe by calling a vote as promised which fails to pass (GOP in the Senate down votes the Liberal nominee).
5. Trump wins and nominates his preferred candidate.
Total misdirection.
The downside is Trump will have to rely on the 8 justices to come to proper decisions if/when the election results make their way to SCOTUS. That's the wildcard.
-
I believe Cruz does a very good job of explaining the situation, the past history of such circumstances, and why it's important to FILL THE SEAT.
Also, I had forgotten how much I despise that little worm Stephanopolous.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=B3FB5bjFRuQ (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=B3FB5bjFRuQ)
-
I believe Cruz does a very good job of explaining the situation, the past history of such circumstances, and why it's important to FILL THE SEAT.
Also, I had forgotten how much I despise that little worm Stephanopolous.
Why do you have to insult actual worms? :geekdanc:
-
Why do you have to insult actual worms? :geekdanc:
My belated and sincere apologies to nematodes and annelids everywhere.
-
:grrr:
I believe Cruz does a very good job of explaining the situation, the past history of such circumstances, and why it's important to FILL THE SEAT.
Also, I had forgotten how much I despise that little worm Stephanopolous.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=B3FB5bjFRuQ (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=B3FB5bjFRuQ)
Meh, I like Cruz but he didn’t really answer the question. It’s obvious that Cruz (not all republicans) backed himself into a corner by making those statements and the only reason his stance changed is because the republicans hold the votes.
It also pains me to say it but shitnopolous does make a good point that now all of a sudden an even court could be a constitutional crisis but it wasn’t back in 2016.
-
:grrr:
Meh, I like Cruz but he didn’t really answer the question. It’s obvious that Cruz (not all republicans) backed himself into a corner by making those statements and the only reason his stance changed is because the republicans hold the votes.
It also pains me to say it but shitnopolous does make a good point that now all of a sudden an even court could be a constitutional crisis but it wasn’t back in 2016.
The Constitutional Crisis now lies in the possibility that the election process and results have a good chance of going before the Supreme Court several times to ensure the rules are being followed.
In 2016, nobody really thought Trump had a good chance of beating Hildabeast -- including the GOP majority in the US Senate.
The Dems are engaging in all manner of rules changes and tactics to ensure they have an opportunity to manipulate the vote count. They want 100% mail-in voting using stale, unkept voter roles to send out millions of ballots. They changed the Pennsylvania rules to allow ballots that arrive 3 days late with no postmark to be included. They now accept ballots with mismatched signatures and with no effort to contact the voter to verify the ballot reflects their votes.
Add to that the "ballot harvesting" in which political activists drive around collecting ballots from homes. There is a NY Post article in which a self-professed fraud used ballot harvesting to collect ballots, steam open the signed exterior envelopes, and insert completed ballots of their own before resealing and dropping them off to be counted.
Ballot harvesting inserts unknown, unvetted and unsupervised people into the vote retrieval process. They are not postal service employees, poll workers or even political campaign employees. They are from groups like Media Matters (formerly ACORN) and other activist groups who will do anything to ensure the other party loses.
All that in addition to the request for recounts and injunctions to stop those recounts being fought in the courts.
Of all the election seasons in which the results will be influenced by decisions from the Supreme Court, this year has the best odds of it happening. We need a full bench of 9 judges to make sure their rulings are not compromised by a 4-4 split decision..
According to the Left, Trump has represented a Constitutional Crisis since he won the Presidency. They've played that card so often, a REAL Constitutional Crisis is not going to get as much attention as it should (Please review The Boy Who Cried 'Wolf!' ).
-
And so it begins ....
An awful lot of ballots can be ""discovered" and "corrected" in 6 days....
https://youtu.be/R1ZaoDIAJhE
-
The debate/discussion in the thread on whether or not the WH should nominate ahead of the election is good, but think it misses a big point. Which is the initiative. Whether or not the WH does nominate or not, I think is a big deal. However, I think the bigger deal is that those opposed to the WH (TDSers, Never Trumpers, etc) have ABSOFRICKLOUTELY no choice. Zero, nada, ziltch on what comes next. I think that in itself is quite powerful. I also think that Trump is mostly (loose on the mostly) approaching with a level of strategic "smartness".
The word is out that apparently the WH will name the replacement end of the week, after the funeral services for RBG. That's almost a whole week of a whole lot of folks strategizing about something in a reactionary way. Is Trump smart? Maybe, maybe not. But I do think the WH in general is playing this well.
-
I don't think the "constitutional crisis" folks we be able to wait until
Christmas, uh, winter solstice to get this gift for the young person in their life. They'll need immediate training time since the adults will be carrying out such activities if 1. Trump nominates someone this year, 2. the senate judiciary committee holds hearings this year, 3. the senate votes on the nominee this year and 4. the senate consents to the nominee.
Fisher-Price Releases 'My First Peaceful Protest' Playset With House You Can Actually Burn Down
September 21st, 2020
(https://i.imgur.com/U8Og0UJ.jpg)
EAST AURORA, NY—The toy geniuses at Fisher-Price have announced a brand new toy made just for leftist parents and their kids: the My First Peaceful Protest playset. The kid-size clubhouse will come with several varieties of spray paint so kids can tag the tiny building with their own empowering slogans. It will also be made out of cardboard, allowing the cute little tikes to burn the whole thing down if their demands are not met.
"Here at Fisher-Price, we are steadfastly committed to social justice," said toy designer Camden Flufferton. "We need to teach our kids what democracy looks like, and there's no better example of democracy in action than violent vandalism and arson. We hope this new playset will serve as an inspiration for parents wanting to teach their kids how to threaten citizens with violence whenever their demands are not met."
The set will also come with toy televisions, cell phones, jewelry, and clothing, allowing kids to simulate looting before they torch the entire set. The set will be available in stores for $399 because of capitalism.
Experts are questioning the wisdom of this move by Fisher-Price, mainly because people in the target market don't typically have any kids. "We know we'll probably only sell, like, 3 of these," said Flufferton, "but selling them isn't the point. We just need you to know we're on the right side of history."
-
The People rejected the Democrats in 2014, when the
Democrats lost the Senate Majority. Remember "Elections have consequences" Obama said that. The consequence of losing the Senate is that you lose the opportunity to confirm SCOTUS nominations. These rules were designed to put a check on power. If Democrats had both the Senate and the Executive branch trust and believe they would have confirmed and Left Wing nut to the Supreme Court.
Obviously politicians can't outright say that because it's off-putting but that's politics.
Merick Garland wasn't a left wing nut, he was rather a centrist/moderate. He just wasn't very pro-gun.
When Obama picked a nominee congress had a job to do. They should have held their hearings and voted him down if they really didn't want him. But no, they made up a BS argument to justify stalling. That's the type of big government bureaucracy and abuse I dislike no matter which side does it. They are elected to do a job and they refused to. This is the same type of abuse when out local legislature is hearing a gun law and blocks in person testimony. Can they do it? Yes. Is it legal? Yes, but it is officials delinquent in their jobs.
-
Why hold a vote to only down vote the nominee? What a waste of tax dollars that would be. No opposing party has ever voted for an opposing presidents nominee since 1880. There’s nothing dirty about that nor is it hypocrisy on any party it’s just politics. Like Obama so smugly said “elections have consequences.”
Why let us submit testimony on new firearms laws if they are just going to block in person testimony and vote without regard to what the written testimony was? Are we wrong to complain when our legislature does that to us?
Why do it though? Because it is their job and because instead of just being honest about it they made us a BS argument that is now coming back to haunt them. If they were not going to hold any hearings then simply say they want to postpone the hearing until after the election in case a republican gets elected.
-
Why let us submit testimony on new firearms laws if they are just going to block in person testimony and vote without regard to what the written testimony was? Are we wrong to complain when our legislature does that to us?
Why do it though? Because it is their job and because instead of just being honest about it they made us a BS argument that is now coming back to haunt them. If they were not going to hold any hearings then simply say they want to postpone the hearing until after the election in case a republican gets elected.
Your analogy is an apples to orange comparison. However I do agree that they should’ve just said they were stalling.
Conservative America should not be beholden to Mitch’s games. Like you said the republican senate had a job to do in 2016, and they have a job to do now.
-
Merick Garland wasn't a left wing nut, he was rather a centrist/moderate. He just wasn't very pro-gun.
When Obama picked a nominee congress had a job to do. They should have held their hearings and voted him down if they really didn't want him. But no, they made up a BS argument to justify stalling. That's the type of big government bureaucracy and abuse I dislike no matter which side does it. They are elected to do a job and they refused to. This is the same type of abuse when out local legislature is hearing a gun law and blocks in person testimony. Can they do it? Yes. Is it legal? Yes, but it is officials delinquent in their jobs.
Bullshit.
Congress (or more accurately, the Senate) did their job. The Senate's job is to act as a check on the actions of the Executive branch and the house. The GOP gained a majority in the Senate 2 years after Obama was elected and immediately after the ACA was CRAMED DOWN THE NATION'S THROAT without a single Republican voting "yes".
The Senate has INCREASED that majority every 2 years since.
Since the Senate is a stop-gap between the desires of the President and the desires of the people, it's logical to assume that if the Senate was wrong by not confirming Garland, and again wrong for confirming Kavanaugh in a midterm election year, the Senate would have a Democrat majority by now.
People put too much stock in who sits in the Oval Office and forgets that the Senate exists to keep the President from taking us down a radical road with the brakes off.
So, long story short, who runs the Senate says much more about how the majority of voters want the government to be run than the man (and party) elected President.
I guarantee you the Democrats would have no qualms about nominating an RBG replacement tomorrow if Hidabeast was in office.
"Elections have consequences." -- Pres. Obama
The arguments from the Democrats are purely procedural. The justifications of the Republicans are idealogical. The decisions made the next few months will guide the nation's actions for decades. That's what the Democrats are terrified of, not "precedent", "rules" or "accusations of hypocrisy."
The Democrats are all hypocrites, especially Biden.
Joe Biden is accused of hypocrisy after a 2016 op-ed emerged in which he slammed Republicans for holding up a
Supreme Court appointment, stating that it is the 'constitutional duty' of a president to nominate if a vacancy becomes
available.
He made the comments in a March 2016 op-ed with the New York Times, in which he added that he was 'surprised
and saddened' to hear Republican senators say they would not longer accept a nomination because it was an election
year.
His words resurfaced this week after he blasted President Donald Trump for moving to nominate a candidate to fill the
vacancy left by the death of Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg on Friday.
Biden claimed that the nomination should wait until after the election in 44 days.
https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-8752197/Joe-Biden-said-2016-presidents-constitutional-duty-SCOTUS-seat.html
Dems -- always wanting to change the rules because they lost. Biden said in 2016 FILL THAT SCOTUS SEAT NOW -- IT'S YoUR CONSTITUTIONAL DUTY!! This week he's saying DON'T EVEN THINK ABOUT DOING THAT BEFORE THE ELECTION!!
These are the same people wanting to tear down the Electoral College because they lost in 2016, and will probably lose again in 2020.
If the Senate fails to take advantage of the vacancy now, Republican voters will absolutely punish them. I think they know that.
-
Your analogy is an apples to orange comparison. However I do agree that they should’ve just said they were stalling.
Conservative America should not be beholden to Mitch’s games. Like you said the republican senate had a job to do in 2016, and they have a job to do now.
The same people crying that Garland deserved a confirmation hearing and vote are now OUTRAGED that we are going to try and hold a confirmation hearing and vote.
No principles involved in their screeches. Just sour grapes.
Remember when Harry Reid changed Senate rules on cloture to get 3 (that's THREE) of Obama's nominees confirmed to appellate courts? McConnell warned him that setting such a precedent was a bad idea, and that the Democrats would one day wish they'd never gone down that road.
They are now having to sleep in the bed they made for themselves.
I have no sympathy for them. These crumbs tried to impeach a President IN AN ELECTION YEAR and WITH NO ACTUAL CRIMES ALLEGED.
So far, everything the Dems have done the last 12 years have backfired on them.
Breaks my heart..... :rofl: :rofl: :rofl: :rofl: :rofl: :rofl: :rofl: :rofl: :rofl: :rofl: :rofl:
-
I read this morning that McConnell is saying he has the votes to pass a nominee. I say FILL THE SEAT!!!
The two women that Trump says he is considering look to be good candidates. I just despise identity politics and watching Trump pick from only 2 women smacks of this.
RBG was a SCOTUS justice. She was supposed to be devoid of political views and actions. Even tho the left would constantly hold her up as a political tool. She did nothing to stop this. I read (I cannot verify the validity of the following) that she had not been performing her justice duties since May. And that she had known all along that she was dying. So the fact that she did not resign in May and allow the process to take its course just shows she had such hatred towards Trump that she couldn’t allow herself to do the right thing. This is backed up by the statement her daughter made as RGB’s dying wish. If that isn’t being a political hack I don’t know what is.
-
Mitt Romney declared he will support a vote before the election. That gave Mitch the votes he needed.
-
Mitt Romney declared he will support a vote before the election. That gave Mitch the votes he needed.
Good. I hope they go about and get it done.
I'm not the sharpest knife in the cupboard but what happened in 2016 is not the same as to what is happening now. Even I can understand that.
The Democrats would be doing the exact same thing if they held the senate majority and the president was a democrat.
Get it done and God Bless America.
-
So the fact that she did not resign in May and allow the process to take its course just shows she had such hatred towards Trump that she couldn’t allow herself to do the right thing. This is backed up by the statement her daughter made as RGB’s dying wish. If that isn’t being a political hack I don’t know what is.
The shocking displays of hatred toward her by liberals for not retiring during the Øbowel regime and then dying during Trump were testament that she was just a political tool.
Copied from some Twit post I believe:
"fµck you Ruth Bader Ginsburg"
fµck you for not retiring under Obama
fµck you for dying under Trump
fµck you
fµck you
fµck you"
Such empathy, that they always claim conservatives are devoid of.
-
Good. I hope they go about and get it done.
I'm not the sharpest knife in the cupboard but what happened in 2016 is not the same as to what is happening now. Even I can understand that.
The Democrats would be doing the exact same thing if they held the senate majority and the president was a democrat.
Get it done and God Bless America.
You seem pretty rational and logical, as apparent by your rational and logical thought process.
Liberals are generally motivated by emotion, which often forsakes logic. Not that there's anything wrong with basing one's opinion from an emotional perspective. Just that most of the perspectives based primarily on emotion tend to be hypocritical and irrational. Notice folks like that here?
-
Flapp_Jackson
You are absolutely correct.
I would argue that the Senate wouldn't be doing the job they were elected to do: if they DIDN'T block Obamas nomination.
As for voting on a nomination, you needed a 60% majority to even call a vote. Harry Reid and the Democrat Majority in 2013 effectively nullified the 60% majority rule with their Nuclear Option. They know they fxcked up and set a bad presidence. now they need to fix their mistake by granting Puerto Rico statehood.
-
You seem pretty rational and logical, as apparent by your rational and logical thought process.
Liberals are generally motivated by emotion, which often forsakes logic. Not that there's anything wrong with basing one's opinion from an emotional perspective. Just that most of the perspectives based primarily on emotion tend to be hypocritical and irrational. Notice folks like that here?
I think the Democrat Politicians are motivated by power, greed and a "win at all costs" mindset. They know their positions do not stand up to public scrutiny, so they (and their complicit Media organizations) gin up an emotional argument they feed to the masses -- that includes everyone, not just Liberals. The people who don't bother to understand the issues are convinced of the Dems' positions based on the information they are given alone. The facts that destroy the politicians' positions are not offered as frequently nor as powerfully
Humans often make decisions based on emotion over logic. What car to buy, which house to buy/rent, what guns to own, ... Corporations and charities market to those emotions, because that will motivate people to action long before a rational appeal will.
-
Bullshit.
Congress (or more accurately, the Senate) did their job. The Senate's job is to act as a check on the actions of the Executive branch and the house. The GOP gained a majority in the Senate 2 years after Obama was elected and immediately after the ACA was CRAMED DOWN THE NATION'S THROAT without a single Republican voting "yes".
The Senate has INCREASED that majority every 2 years since.
Since the Senate is a stop-gap between the desires of the President and the desires of the people, it's logical to assume that if the Senate was wrong by not confirming Garland, and again wrong for confirming Kavanaugh in a midterm election year, the Senate would have a Democrat majority by now.
People put too much stock in who sits in the Oval Office and forgets that the Senate exists to keep the President from taking us down a radical road with the brakes off.
So, long story short, who runs the Senate says much more about how the majority of voters want the government to be run than the man (and party) elected President.
I guarantee you the Democrats would have no qualms about nominating an RBG replacement tomorrow if Hidabeast was in office.
"Elections have consequences." -- Pres. Obama
The arguments from the Democrats are purely procedural. The justifications of the Republicans are idealogical. The decisions made the next few months will guide the nation's actions for decades. That's what the Democrats are terrified of, not "precedent", "rules" or "accusations of hypocrisy."
The Democrats are all hypocrites, especially Biden.
https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-8752197/Joe-Biden-said-2016-presidents-constitutional-duty-SCOTUS-seat.html
Dems -- always wanting to change the rules because they lost. Biden said in 2016 FILL THAT SCOTUS SEAT NOW -- IT'S YoUR CONSTITUTIONAL DUTY!! This week he's saying DON'T EVEN THINK ABOUT DOING THAT BEFORE THE ELECTION!!
These are the same people wanting to tear down the Electoral College because they lost in 2016, and will probably lose again in 2020.
If the Senate fails to take advantage of the vacancy now, Republican voters will absolutely punish them. I think they know that.
Congress' job was to hold a nomination hearing, they didn't and McConnell gave a BS excuse for not doing it which made republicans look bad and are just fueling democrat objections now. That is the bottom line and that is why I am criticizing the actions of McConnell and his republican friends for their actions in 2016.
Pretending that which party wins and loses seats in congress is a referendum on whether they should hold nomination hearings for SCOTUS justice nominees is just a fancy dressed up empty argument. Again it all boils down to the basic argument of "we are in power so we get to decide". Anything beyond that is just lipstick on a pig.
I just wish the republicans had the integrity to do their job, be honest about it, and make statements they can be consistent on instead of flip flopping worse than John Kerry.
-
Your analogy is an apples to orange comparison. However I do agree that they should’ve just said they were stalling.
Conservative America should not be beholden to Mitch’s games. Like you said the republican senate had a job to do in 2016, and they have a job to do now.
Agreed. I don't actually like that one person can have so much power in congress either. It's like here when we want some bill introduced but a committee can simply refuse to hold a hearing on it and the bill dies.
-
Congress' job was to hold a nomination hearing, they didn't and McConnell gave a BS excuse for not doing it which made republicans look bad and are just fueling democrat objections now. That is the bottom line and that is why I am criticizing the actions of McConnell and his republican friends for their actions in 2016.
Pretending that which party wins and loses seats in congress is a referendum on whether they should hold nomination hearings for SCOTUS justice nominees is just a fancy dressed up empty argument. Again it all boils down to the basic argument of "we are in power so we get to decide". Anything beyond that is just lipstick on a pig.
I just wish the republicans had the integrity to do their job, be honest about it, and make statements they can be consistent on instead of flip flopping worse than John Kerry.
Show me in the Constitution where it says the Senate must hold hearings and schedule votes when it flies in the face of precedent? Your opinion of what the Senate's job is needs supporting material. The Constitution contradicts you.
There have been 29 times that a SCOTUS vacancy occurred in a presidential election year. That counts vacancies created by new seats on the Court, but not vacancies for which there was a nomination already pending when the year began, such as happened in 1835–36 and 1987–88.
The President made a nomination in all 29 cases! That's 22 presidents out of 44 (obviously some made multiple nominations in election years -- Washington made 3). Therefore, Trump would be breaking with precedent if he decided to not name a nominee.
That pretty much nails down the President's case -- he has a duty to name his choice based on the Constitution and historical precedent going back to President Washington.
Next, the Senate. The Constitution gives that majority the power to seat any nominee they want, and to BLOCK any nominee they want. Up until Harry Reid changed the rules, the Senate needed a super majority (60) to approve cloture, which allowed a confirmation vote to be taken. Basically a vote to hold the real vote. If the Dems had left that rule in place, they could have blocked the vote via a filibuster. Too bad for them, the rule change allows a cloture vote with a simple majority. Sucks to be so bent on immediate wins that you lose sight of the damage it can cause down the road when the power changes parties. :rofl:
There have been 10 times that there was a SCOTUS vacancy, and the President and Senate Majority were from opposite parties. In 6 of the 10 cases, the President made the nomination before election day. Only one of those was confirmed before the election. That's 1 out of 6 confirmed when they had SAME SITUATION THAT WE HAD WITH GARLAND. The other 4 nominations were made after the election in a lame duck session. The Senate left 3 of those open for the winner of the General Election to decide.
The norm in these cases strongly favored holding the seat open for the conflict between the two branches to be resolved by the presidential election. That is what Republicans did in 2016.
Finally, in the case where the President and Senate Majority are unified, election-year nominees get confirmed. That is the norm that applies this year. 19 times between 1796 and 1968, presidents have sought to fill a Supreme Court vacancy in a presidential-election year while their party controlled the Senate. 10 of those nominations came before the election; and 9 of the 10 were successful.
Vacancies during midterms election years, like the Kavanaugh nomination, follow another norm. Those seats are nominated and confirmed no matter who controls the Senate.
So, your opinion of what the Senate's job is falls apart in the face of actual historical facts -- as usual..
-
Show me in the Constitution where it says the Senate must hold hearings and schedule votes when it flies in the face of precedent? Your opinion of what the Senate's job is needs supporting material. The Constitution contradicts you.
There have been 29 times that a SCOTUS vacancy occurred in a presidential election year. That counts vacancies created by new seats on the Court, but not vacancies for which there was a nomination already pending when the year began, such as happened in 1835–36 and 1987–88.
The President made a nomination in all 29 cases! That's 22 presidents out of 44 (obviously some made multiple nominations in election years -- Washington made 3). Therefore, Trump would be breaking with precedent if he decided to not name a nominee.
That pretty much nails down the President's case -- he has a duty to name his choice based on the Constitution and historical precedent going back to President Washington.
Next, the Senate. The Constitution gives that majority the power to seat any nominee they want, and to BLOCK any nominee they want. Up until Harry Reid changed the rules, the Senate needed a super majority (60) to approve cloture, which allowed a confirmation vote to be taken. Basically a vote to hold the real vote. If the Dems had left that rule in place, they could have blocked the vote via a filibuster. Too bad for them, the rule change allows a cloture vote with a simple majority. Sucks to be so bent on immediate wins that you lose sight of the damage it can cause down the road when the power changes parties. :rofl:
There have been 10 times that there was a SCOTUS vacancy, and the President and Senate Majority were from opposite parties. In 6 of the 10 cases, the President made the nomination before election day. Only one of those was confirmed before the election. That's 1 out of 6 confirmed when they had SAME SITUATION THAT WE HAD WITH GARLAND. The other 4 nominations were made after the election in a lame duck session. The Senate left 3 of those open for the winner of the General Election to decide.
The norm in these cases strongly favored holding the seat open for the conflict between the two branches to be resolved by the presidential election. That is what Republicans did in 2016.
Finally, in the case where the President and Senate Majority are unified, election-year nominees get confirmed. That is the norm that applies this year. 19 times between 1796 and 1968, presidents have sought to fill a Supreme Court vacancy in a presidential-election year while their party controlled the Senate. 10 of those nominations came before the election; and 9 of the 10 were successful.
Vacancies during midterms election years, like the Kavanaugh nomination, follow another norm. Those seats are nominated and confirmed no matter who controls the Senate.
So, your opinion of what the Senate's job is falls apart in the face of actual historical facts -- as usual..
Flapp,
You are absolutely right and that idiot is absolutely wrong. I guess he has never the constitution. Whichever party is in power in the senate sets the procedure for presidential nominees. And if the senate is controlled by the other party from the president, they determine how they want to handle nominees. Just like the president does not have to explain why he nominates someone to SCOTUS, neither does the Senate have to have to have a hearing and they can reject a nominee for any reason. And they don’t have to supply a reason either. McConnell had every right and was within his power to reject Garland and not provide a reason. Period. He only made the Republicans look bad in the mind of that idiot you are showing up. It is the narcissism and prejudice that this idiot has that will keep him trying to defend himself when he has NO DEFENSE WHATSOEVER. Waiting for his narcissism and prejudice to kick in in 3 2 1.....
-
https://youtu.be/B_Dh5QxGkrg
-
Video snipped
"...and a huge fight over the court's future."
Um .... nope. It's not much of a fight when the Democrats have no leverage.
They proved they have no interest in honor, decorum or fairness in the Kavanaugh hearings, and even less interest in historical precedence. They trot out ONE instance of the GOP Senate holding onto a nomination in an election year (2016) while also failing to tell the WHOLE story (Dem president vs. GOP Senate). As I posted, the history of nominations is based on one factor: whether or not the president and the Senate majority are of the same party. The pattern proves that Trump and/or the Senate would be going against the norm if they delay filling this vacancy.
Pelosi said she has "many arrows in her quiver" when George "Hillary is my president" Snuffleupagus asked her about using impeachment to delay the confirmation.
Really? She's evil enough to even consider impeachment before the election? If she does, the House needs to remove her from Congress for abuse of power. Impeachment is not to be used as a political tool to achieve some procedural goal. It's the most extreme measure used to charge a top government official of high crimes and misdemeanors. They had no actual crimes with which to charge Trump the first time around. Right now they certainly have nothing more to offer. Trump's following the Constitution. Only in the twisted mind of Democrats could they ever equate that with "abuse of power" or any other charge.
Not a fight. More like swatting mosquitos.
-
Let me get this straight. Everyone here is angry at eye for saying that it's beyond hypocritical to be fine when the Republicans blocked the Supreme Court hearing but to do the 99% the same thing themselves to get their pick in is correct thing to do.
-
Let me get this straight. Everyone here is angry at eye for saying that it's beyond hypocritical to be fine when the Republicans blocked the Supreme Court hearing but to do the 99% the same thing themselves to get their pick in is correct thing to do.
No. You don't have anything straight at all.
In 2016, the Dems were irate that Obama's pick was held up until after the election. Now, in 2020, they are irate that Trump and the Senate are not holding up the nomination until after the election. It has nothing to do with GOP hypocrisy. It's about Democrats wanting it one way when it's their president's nominee, and use a 180-degree opposite argument when its Trump's turn.
Even though the GOP has had the Senate majority (and the power) to confirm or block a nomination, it doesn't change the fact that the Democrats have changed their tune.
The fact is that history (the "norm", or precedent -- not "president") agrees with the Senate's stance BOTH TIMES. Who controls the Senate matters. It always has. Almost every time the Senate was considering a nominee which the other party's president nominated (for example, Obama), the Senate has waited until after the election to see who still sits as president and the Senate majority. If, however, the President and Senate majority are of the same party, the norm is for the Senate to hold confirmation hearings before the election.
Just because the press and democrats in DC choose to only give the public half the equation doesn't make it add up -- no matter how much EEF wants it to.
-
Let me get this straight. Everyone here is angry at eye for saying that it's beyond hypocritical to be fine when the Republicans blocked the Supreme Court hearing but to do the 99% the same thing themselves to get their pick in is correct thing to do.
And if history, precedent, norms and facts don't convince you, then consider this: when I think about the absolutely filthy and disgusting lies the Democrats in the Senate used to smear Kavanaugh as a sexual predator at 17 years old, as someone who exposed himself in college at parties, and as a gang bang rapist, all based on completely unsupportable, unbelievable accusations, the Democrats don't deserve a shred of consideration. If it's legal, Trump and the Senate should ram this nomination through at light speed!!
The Dems have proven they want power and will stop at nothing, including smearing a judge's reputation in front of his wife, his children and the entire world. McConnell should be tired of the Dems' pretense of valuing honor. Their actions embarrassed the Senate, the Federal government, and the nation.
They are now stupidly threatening to stack the court when (if) they control the Executive and Senate. It would just require passing a piece of legislation through both the U.S. House of Representatives and Senate, which the president would then sign. From a mathematical standpoint, Democrats would only need simple majorities in the House and Senate — and a Democratic president — in order to adjust the number of justices.
However, the current number of 9 seats was established 150 years ago. FDR tried to do this, and failed miserably. If the Dems try it, they may suffer an even worse backlash. Just because you lose the game one year doesn't mean you need to change the rules. If you can't establish a better strategy to win the next time around, then too bad.
The things the Dems want to do should be done in the Legislature, not the SCOTUS. If the laws exist and can stand up to Constitutional scrutiny, then the make-up of the court is 100% moot. What we see is that even when Obama's party controlled the House, Senate and Executive, the only thing they did of any consequence was pass ACA. There were MANY bills they could have pushed through while the country waiting for the next midterm elections, but that was the only thing they wanted -- that and a lot more debt to bail out Obama's campaign contributors via stimulus money. Once the ACA shocked voters into seeing through "The Messiah", the voters gave control of the House to the GOP. Two years later, they won the Senate majority. After that, the Oval Office.
In those 2 years, they could have tried to pack the court, but they didn't, because their party had all the power. Now that they are the minority in the Senate, they want to stack the court? Ain't happening!!
(https://i.imgur.com/dysYCrR.jpg)
-
Let me get this straight. Everyone here is angry at eye for saying that it's beyond hypocritical to be fine when the Republicans blocked the Supreme Court hearing but to do the 99% the same thing themselves to get their pick in is correct thing to do.
Besides your wanting to ignore the facts/truth that Flapp laid out for you, the issue is that EEF (and you) are ignoring your own hypocrisy. You are blasting the Republicans for being hypocrites but you become a hypocrite yourself for not blasting the Democrats for the exact same thing. Either be consistent and blast both Democrats and Republicans for their hypocrisy or get blasted for only calling out one side.
-
Besides your wanting to ignore the facts/truth that Flapp laid out for you, the issue is that EEF (and you) are ignoring your own hypocrisy. You are blasting the Republicans for being hypocrites but you become a hypocrite yourself for not blasting the Democrats for the exact same thing. Either be consistent and blast both Democrats and Republicans for their hypocrisy or get blasted for only calling out one side.
I do. Only difference is that they were stopped and Republicans appear not to be. When it happened I was cheering the Republicans on. But the fact that Republicans have made a big stink about it then proceeded to do the and thing so blatant is what I'm trying to get at.
-
I do. Only difference is that they were stopped and Republicans appear not to be. When it happened I was cheering the Republicans on. But the fact that Republicans have made a big stink about it then proceeded to do the and thing so blatant is what I'm trying to get at.
You have not. Please post the link where you have called out the Democrats for their hypocrisy on this subject previously on this (or any) forum and I’ll believe you called out the Democrats and are not a hypocrite on this subject.
So you are saying you can only be a hypocrite if you are successful (Republican)? And you can’t be a hypocrite if you are not successful (Democrat)? :rofl: The reason why the Republicans “Appear” not to be stopped is because they control the Senate. It is their rules and they don’t have to explain their rules or actions to anyone. It’s politics. EVERY politician lies and is a hypocrite. It comes with the territory. Why are you only calling out the Republicans for something that is truly a nothing burger? If you read what Flapp wrote you will see you are calling foul on nothing.
-
You have not. Please post the link where you have called out the Democrats for their hypocrisy on this subject previously on this (or any) forum and I’ll believe you called out the Democrats and are not a hypocrite on this subject.
So you are saying you can only be a hypocrite if you are successful (Republican)? And you can’t be a hypocrite if you are not successful (Democrat)? :rofl: The reason why the Republicans “Appear” not to be stopped is because they control the Senate. It is their rules and they don’t have to explain their rules or actions to anyone. It’s politics. EVERY politician lies and is a hypocrite. It comes with the territory. Why are you only calling out the Republicans for something that is truly a nothing burger? If you read what Flapp wrote you will see you are calling foul on nothing.
No I'm saying both democrats and republicans are stupid and should of never tried to push a justice through in the election year. Its just I am calling out the republicans because they are doing it RIGHT NOW. Would be weird if I was calling out the democrats for something that happened 5 years ago....
Personally I think this close to election I don't give a danm who controls the senate or president just leave it off till after election.
-
No I'm saying both democrats and republicans are stupid and should of never tried to push a justice through in the election year. Its just I am calling out the republicans because they are doing it RIGHT NOW. Would be weird if I was calling out the democrats for something that happened 5 years ago....
Personally I think this close to election I don't give a danm who controls the senate or president just leave it off till after election.
In 2016, did the Senate proceed according to rules/procedures?
Now, IF Senate proceeds and confirms a nominee, would it be according to rules/procedures?
Now it’s obvious that you have your own ideas of what should be an get all salty when the pesky rules don’t bend around your ideals. Like your twisted versions of what I means to be alive. I mean you are entitled to your opinion. But that’s the issue here. You feel like your entitlement is above rules and laws of Society. Sound familiar to the many “movements” going on today? Sounds like the whining of a teenager who doesn’t get their way.
-
No I'm saying both democrats and republicans are stupid and should of never tried to push a justice through in the election year. Its just I am calling out the republicans because they are doing it RIGHT NOW. Would be weird if I was calling out the democrats for something that happened 5 years ago....
Personally I think this close to election I don't give a danm who controls the senate or president just leave it off till after election.
Except historical context doesn’t support your opinion that they should “just leave it off until the election”. Refer to flapps post on why your wrong.
Now given the historical context I’m not sure why Cruz, Graham, Mitch and others had to make some bogus excuse to not hold the vote. The people elected a republican senate and they would’ve been destroyed had they allowed Obama to push through his nomination.
-
No I'm saying both democrats and republicans are stupid and should of never tried to push a justice through in the election year. Its just I am calling out the republicans because they are doing it RIGHT NOW. Would be weird if I was calling out the democrats for something that happened 5 years ago....
Personally I think this close to election I don't give a danm who controls the senate or president just leave it off till after election.
So, you are saying that President Trump should not do the job he was elected to do by nominating a SCOTUS candidate? President Obama did it in 2016. But you didn’t provide a link to any post any where showing where you called him and the Democrats out in 2016 for doing exactly what you say President Trump should not do now. HYPOCRITE OFTEN?
You cannot say that both parties are stupid but the president shouldn’t do his job that he was elected to do without being a hypocrite. That is exactly what you are saying.
-
No I'm saying both democrats and republicans are stupid and should of never tried to push a justice through in the election year. Its just I am calling out the republicans because they are doing it RIGHT NOW. Would be weird if I was calling out the democrats for something that happened 5 years ago....
Personally I think this close to election I don't give a danm who controls the senate or president just leave it off till after election.
"should of"
"Its just"
"till after"
[drops mic]
-
So, you are saying that President Trump should not do the job he was elected to do by nominating a SCOTUS candidate? President Obama did it in 2016. But you didn’t provide a link to any post any where showing where you called him and the Democrats out in 2016 for doing exactly what you say President Trump should not do now. HYPOCRITE OFTEN?
You cannot say that both parties are stupid but the president shouldn’t do his job that he was elected to do without being a hypocrite. That is exactly what you are saying.
Yes, most nominations take deliberation don't recall a nomination ever happening a week after a death.... at this point they just trying to rush someone through because they fear the election. Idc how you try to justify this one you can only put so much lipstick on the pig.
I do agree with your points but this is political all this is going to do is polarize everyone and potentially open up the excuse for democrats to pack the court next year. If they just hold off the democrats have no excuse or reason to do that.
-
Yes, most nominations take deliberation don't recall a nomination ever happening a week after a death.... at this point they just trying to rush someone through because they fear the election. Idc how you try to justify this one you can only put so much lipstick on the pig.
I do agree with your points but this is political all this is going to do is polarize everyone and potentially open up the excuse for democrats to pack the court next year. If they just hold off the democrats have no excuse or reason to do that.
We didn't start the fire. . .
-
Yes, most nominations take deliberation don't recall a nomination ever happening a week after a death.... at this point they just trying to rush someone through because they fear the election. Idc how you try to justify this one you can only put so much lipstick on the pig.
I do agree with your points but this is political all this is going to do is polarize everyone and potentially open up the excuse for democrats to pack the court next year. If they just hold off the democrats have no excuse or reason to do that.
Sorry but I don’t think you really understand what is going on. And until you open your mind to what is really happening in this world, no amount of telling you the facts and the truth is going to make you understand reality.
-
We didn't start the fire. . .
Doesn't mean you're burn everything down. Sounds like all the rioters right now....
-
Sorry but I don’t think you really understand what is going on. And until you open your mind to what is really happening in this world, no amount of telling you the facts and the truth is going to make you understand reality.
I'm honestly trying to see both sides and pick a middle route of cooperation. We won't get anything done otherwise. Being "right" doesn't mean shit if the other side can do whatever they want with public support because they play emotion better. It just like natto, you might sing the songs of praise that it tastes good. But popular opinion is much harder to convince the masses.
If you need to be so specific in your reasoning, I'll admit in this exact specific case you have sound logic. I'm convinced to a point. But if you can't comvince everyone its meaningless it LOOKS bad, smells bad, but might not technically be bad. The idea is not to piss off masses and democrats.
Deep down I hope even you realize Republicans wanted to block a liberal justice in 2016 and democrats want to block a conservative one now. The election is in like 2 months. You are just giving free ammo to the democrats to pack the court because Republicans feel they will lose 2020 elections.
-
Doesn't mean you're burn everything down. Sounds like all the rioters right now....
Uhh, you totally missed my point. . .
-
You are just giving free ammo to the democrats to pack the court because Republicans feel they will lose 2020 elections.
You said that a couple of times already, but uh, what?
Ammo? Like democrats "need" any reason to push their agenda.
And how could democrats pack the court?
-
You said that a couple of times already, but uh, what?
Ammo? Like democrats "need" any reason to push their agenda.
And how could democrats pack the court?
The Democrats have been threatening to pack the courts ever since the Kavanaugh hearings. That requires the House, Senate and President to agree to do it.
That's the reason GINSBURG herself said in an interview that the number 9 (which the Supreme Court has had for over 150 years now) is working fine. She believed packing the court is a really bad idea.
Judges were added early in US history as states were added. The number has been working fine up until now that a LIBERAL LEANING COURT the past 40 years is starting to lean right. Sounds like a balance to me. Nothing wrong with that.
https://youtu.be/6pkwfITbEuM
-
The Democrats have been threatening to pack the courts ever since the Kavanaugh hearings. That requires the House, Senate and President to agree to do it.
That's the reason GINSBURG herself said in an interview that the number 9 (which the Supreme Court has had for over 150 years now) is working fine. She believed packing the court is a really bad idea.
Judges were added early in US history as states were added. The number has been working fine up until now that a LIBERAL LEANING COURT the past 40 years is starting to lean right. Sounds like a balance to me. Nothing wrong with that.
Copy all and I get all of that. Was just trying to make the connection to "because Republicans feel they will lose 2020 elections". How does that factor in if "That requires the House, Senate and President to agree to do it" like you said?
The needing House, Senate, and President to do it was my point. Based on established rules, policy, "president", etc. But some "feel" that's not the way things should be done.
-
Uhh, you totally missed my point. . .
I think I picked up on it. :geekdanc: :thumbsup:
The Democrats smeared Kavanaugh to stop Trump from getting a confirmation until after the midterms. Taking over the Senate majority in the midterm election a couple of months later was their only hope for stopping Kavanaugh's confirmation.
The Democrats have enjoyed a Liberal-leaning court for 2-3 generations. Now that the court is shifting right, they want to do whatever it takes to stop that shift.
The Democrats changed the rules of the Senate to merely require a simple majority vote to stop filibusters in judicial appointments. McConnell told Harry Reid the Dems would be sorry they did that someday.
The Democrats have had bad timing when it comes to SCOTUS vacancies. Ginsburg could have retired toward the end of Obama's 2nd term to be treated for her pancreatic cancer. She believed the polls and thought Hildabeast would be the President. She held onto dear life for years hoping Trump would be taken out of office so she could have another president fill her seat. If she'd been more conservative in her decision (pun intended), she would have not taken the chance and retired before 2016. This appointment now means Trump will have appointed 3 Supreme Court Justices in just one term. If one believed in fate, or God or luck, one might have the opinion that such a run on nominations was pre-ordained.
The Democrats have been blocking Trump nominees for many more positions than a couple of Supreme Court nominees. They blocked (and are still blocking) Ambassador appointments and executive cabinet appointments.
That tactic also came back to bite the Dems. Since the start of his presidency, President Donald Trump has appointed at least 216 new federal judges to U.S. federal courts, and it could reach 230 by election day. Trump has appointed far more federal judges than his predecessors. Data from Heritage.org shows Barack Obama appointed 158 federal judges among 188 nominees, while George W. Bush and Bill Clinton both appointed 203 judges. When taking office in 2017, the president inherited 108 federal judicial vacancies -- the most of any incoming president since Clinton in 1992. Given there are 870 seats, Trump will have filled one-fourth of them in less than 4 years. McConnell used Harry Reid's nuclear option to bypass Democrat obstruction in the Senate, and they have been filling judicial vacancies faster than Hillary Clinton goes through a box a chardonnay! :thumbsup: :geekdanc:
-
(https://i.imgur.com/Y369I42.jpg)
-
https://youtu.be/A2lNHj6KvfE
-
Disqualifying Barrett from being on the Supreme Court because of her Catholic beliefs is 100% Unconstitutional.
You think people like Feinstein give a flying flip about the Constitution? The LIBERAL dogma lives loudly in her. She should resign for failing to live up to her oath of office. :wacko:
https://youtu.be/vTi1xoXJvD8
-
I'm honestly trying to see both sides and pick a middle route of cooperation. We won't get anything done otherwise. Being "right" doesn't mean shit if the other side can do whatever they want with public support because they play emotion better. It just like natto, you might sing the songs of praise that it tastes good. But popular opinion is much harder to convince the masses.
If you need to be so specific in your reasoning, I'll admit in this exact specific case you have sound logic. I'm convinced to a point. But if you can't comvince everyone its meaningless it LOOKS bad, smells bad, but might not technically be bad. The idea is not to piss off masses and democrats.
Deep down I hope even you realize Republicans wanted to block a liberal justice in 2016 and democrats want to block a conservative one now. The election is in like 2 months. You are just giving free ammo to the democrats to pack the court because Republicans feel they will lose 2020 elections.
-
I think I picked up on it. :geekdanc: :thumbsup:
SNIP
There's what you said, but I wasn't expecting OG to pick up on that.
I was thinking he "may" be aware of the Great Divider in Chief.
He's probably too young for Billy Joel. . . :rofl:
-
There's what you said, but I wasn't expecting OG to pick up on that.
I was thinking he "may" be aware of the Great Divider in Chief.
He's probably too young for Billy Joel. . . :rofl:
That was when Billy Joel made good songs -- actually very close to the end of that period.
Can't blame him if he doesn't listen to oldies. :thumbsup: :geekdanc: :shaka:
-
...
Deep down I hope even you realize Republicans wanted to block a liberal justice in 2016 and democrats want to block a conservative one now. The election is in like 2 months. You are just giving free ammo to the democrats to pack the court because Republicans feel they will lose 2020 elections.
Historically, Republicans have seen their greatest successes at the ballot box when they don't try to placate the Leftist/Liberal/Democrat/Socialist side of the aisle. if we wanted those people's policies and programs, we would have elected them instead.
When the GOP sticks to their principles and act according to what the majority of conservatives support, they tend to enjoy better election results than when they capitulate in the name of cooperation.
We have several branches to create balance in government. When that balance is upset, the voters tend to correct it. Same for party control within the branches. When one party is in power for too long, they get stupid. Taking their toys away is the best way to fix that.
I wish the politicians could remember how that works long after inauguration.
Based on your comments and arguments, I suspect you have no clue how "Republicans" feel. The Dems are throwing unprecedented amounts of money at contested districts to try and win both chambers of Congress. Hillary outspent Trump 2:1 to the tune of $1.5 Billion. Money for ads doesn't help if the message is nothing better than "Orange Man Bad!"
Ever notice how you rarely hear any platform details from Democrats seeking power? They hope to tear down the GOP candidates with character flaws and by blaming everything (including the Lindburgh kidnapping, the destruction of the Hindenburg, and JFK's assassination) on them. The best they have to offer are ambiguous, flowery descriptions of how this effort will fix a problem and that program will increase jobs, income and free shit. Blah, blah, blah. They never can offer up details on how it works. They are only focused on winning -- the details will be worked out after they gain political power. Most times, the promises never happen.
When one Dem finally does offer up a plan, it's a farfetched concoction of massive spending, massive taxation, and no idea how to execute the plan. The math never adds up. Look at ACA. It was a sick joke when Obama and the Dems in Congress launched it. But, people who believe the marketing hype refuse to think about the facts. They simply believe it must be because the Republicans somehow caused it to fail. That's the Socialist mindset. Socialism (Communism) can only succeed if there is no opposition to it. Since there is always opposition (no matter how many times they convene firing squads), they have a built-in excuse as to why their plans continuously fail.
Republicans in some districts might be nervous, but they all understand that an opportunity to appoint a Supreme Court Justice doesn't come along every year. This appointment will help shape the path of the country for generations. Plus, if they want to win their races, they need RNC support (aka MONEY). Too much to lose if they don't support the President's nominee and confirm before the election.
-
That was when Billy Joel made good songs -- actually very close to the end of that period.
Can't blame him if he doesn't listen to oldies. :thumbsup: :geekdanc: :shaka:
I didn't care for that album
or the ones before that
he started sucking when he dated/married Christie Brinkley
a good way to go down, but his music suffered
too happy and less drugs...
-
I didn't care for that album
or the ones before that
he started sucking when he dated/married Christie Brinkley
a good way to go down, but his music suffered
too happy and less drugs...
We Didn't Start the Fire is one of those songs I label as "Would have been less liked if not for the music video."
https://youtu.be/eFTLKWw542g
-
More Fake News about Amy Coney Barrett. The hit pieces against her are just starting.
https://www.newsweek.com/amy-coney-barrett-people-praise-group-inspired-handmaids-tale-1533293
Before reading the entire article, I suggest reading the last paragraph:
Correction: This article's headline originally stated that People of Praise inspired 'The Handmaid's Tale'.
The book's author, Margaret Atwood, has never specifically mentioned the group as being the inspiration
for her work. A New Yorker profile of the author from 2017 mentions a newspaper clipping as part of her
research for the book of a different charismatic Catholic group, People of Hope. Newsweek regrets the
error.
:wtf: :wtf: :wtf:
The entirety of the article is captured in the title:
How Charismatic Catholic Groups Like Amy Coney Barrett's
People of Praise Inspired 'The Handmaid's Tale'
They watered it down with "like" after saying it had been the group that inspired the author of the book.
First paragraph:
Amy Coney Barrett, a favorite to be President Donald Trump's Supreme Court nominee to replace Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg,
is affiliated with a type of Christian religious group that served as inspiration for Margaret Atwood's dystopian novel,
The Handmaid's Tale.
This is why Trump calls the media out as the enemy of the people. instead of taking the article down, they added a blurb completely contradicting the theme of the article. They left it up because they know it'll get clicks and help to smear Trump's nominee -- assuming she's even the one picked.
These kinds of people ARE enemies to the people. Propaganda without any basis in fact is dangerous to our nation's survival.
-
Trump’s selection for appointment to the Supreme Court and the success or failure of it getting through will be a turning point in this election.
I think more and more people are starting to realize it.
Line drawn in the sand.
-
https://babylonbee.com/news/genius-trump-nominates-joe-biden-to-supreme-court?fbclid=IwAR2YC8t5Gj93FqGoOnv3byzQkB7zOZfmaL_N8GyV975XI1ypxu2yrekjvk4 (https://babylonbee.com/news/genius-trump-nominates-joe-biden-to-supreme-court?fbclid=IwAR2YC8t5Gj93FqGoOnv3byzQkB7zOZfmaL_N8GyV975XI1ypxu2yrekjvk4)
-
(http://www.usrifleteams.com/forums/uploads/monthly_2020_09/Ruth.jpg.76c6e2197e16bd5bde2a6d87244ed09c.jpg)
-
(http://www.usrifleteams.com/forums/uploads/monthly_2020_09/Ruth.jpg.76c6e2197e16bd5bde2a6d87244ed09c.jpg)
https://2ahawaii.com/index.php?topic=38106.msg339574#msg339574
-
https://babylonbee.com/news/genius-trump-nominates-joe-biden-to-supreme-court?fbclid=IwAR2YC8t5Gj93FqGoOnv3byzQkB7zOZfmaL_N8GyV975XI1ypxu2yrekjvk4 (https://babylonbee.com/news/genius-trump-nominates-joe-biden-to-supreme-court?fbclid=IwAR2YC8t5Gj93FqGoOnv3byzQkB7zOZfmaL_N8GyV975XI1ypxu2yrekjvk4)
Genius Trump Nominates Joe Biden To Supreme Court
Forcing Dems To Accuse Him Of Sexual Assault
:rofl: :rofl: :rofl: :thumbsup: :thumbsup: :thumbsup:
The flaw in that plan is that Liberal Politicians are judged by a different set of standards and rules as everyone else. The GOP would accuse Sleezy Joe of assault, but the Dems would defend him.
Another flaw: Joe filling a lifetime appointment on the bench might create yet another vacancy for Trump to fill in a year or two! :shake:
-
ABC 6PM News said Barrett is the nominee and the official announcement will be made tomorrow.
-
:D
-
Show me in the Constitution where it says the Senate must hold hearings and schedule votes when it flies in the face of precedent? Your opinion of what the Senate's job is needs supporting material. The Constitution contradicts you.
That is a pretty empty argument. The constitution says very little about the government having to do anything. The constitution grants and assigns certain powers to certain branches of government. Sure, congress could refuse to confirm justices every again and the supreme court would cease to exist in a few decades, because nothing says they have to. I don't know how you can't see how silly of an argument you are making. Nothing says cops have to give you CPR if they find you having a heart attack, by your logic I guess you would be fine with them standing over you saying they don't have to help you.
There have been 29 times that a SCOTUS vacancy occurred in a presidential election year. That counts vacancies created by new seats on the Court, but not vacancies for which there was a nomination already pending when the year began, such as happened in 1835–36 and 1987–88.
The President made a nomination in all 29 cases! That's 22 presidents out of 44 (obviously some made multiple nominations in election years -- Washington made 3). Therefore, Trump would be breaking with precedent if he decided to not name a nominee.
As I have stated already, I have no problem with Trump nominating someone, it is his job to nominate people. He also wasn't the one that made the stupid argument in 2016. Besides that, I am glad you are suddenly so interested in Trump maintaining tradition.
Next, the Senate. The Constitution gives that majority the power to seat any nominee they want, and to BLOCK any nominee they want. Up until Harry Reid changed the rules, the Senate needed a super majority (60) to approve cloture, which allowed a confirmation vote to be taken. Basically a vote to hold the real vote. If the Dems had left that rule in place, they could have blocked the vote via a filibuster. Too bad for them, the rule change allows a cloture vote with a simple majority. Sucks to be so bent on immediate wins that you lose sight of the damage it can cause down the road when the power changes parties. :rofl:
Yup, they shot themselves in the foot there.
The norm in these cases strongly favored holding the seat open for the conflict between the two branches to be resolved by the presidential election. That is what Republicans did in 2016. [/u]
That is really just an empty excuse devised to hide the real position they are taking: "We are doing it because we have control and we can."
Presidential elections aren't supposed to resolve SCOTUS justice picks, that is just made up. Elected people are elected for a term, none of this BS about not doing their job because voters should get to choose. Voters chose when they elected the people for their term.
Finally, in the case where the President and Senate Majority are unified, election-year nominees get confirmed. That is the norm that applies this year. 19 times between 1796 and 1968, presidents have sought to fill a Supreme Court vacancy in a presidential-election year while their party controlled the Senate. 10 of those nominations came before the election; and 9 of the 10 were successful.
Of course you can make the case that it is "the norm" but there is absolutely no argument to be made that it should be the norm. Lots of things are normal that shouldn't be normal. Again, you really gotta come up with better arguments here.
-
Let me get this straight. Everyone here is angry at eye for saying that it's beyond hypocritical to be fine when the Republicans blocked the Supreme Court hearing but to do the 99% the same thing themselves to get their pick in is correct thing to do.
That is Flapp's basic MO. We can sit around all day pointing out democrat hypocrisy and be happy but the minute someone criticizes a republican for the same thing he (and certain others) flip out. Hypocrisy is hypocrisy but they only care about it when it doesn't favor them, and you better not point it out when it does favor them.
Notice his reply after, he tries to change it about how I am not criticizing democrats when they do such things. Democrat actions weren't the subject here but they try to make it as if I, and now you, are ignoring hypocrisy by democrats. They can't defend the actions of the republicans to they bring up some empty red herring type argument. I am sure if someone were actually defending democrats here then both you and I would call them out on it. But do they ask our opinions when democrats pull this type of thing? Nope, they just assume our positions (falsely) and then attack us for it.
That is how you can tell that people like Flapp are mindless political drones, which is sad because on other occasions Flapp has shown himself to be fairly wise. Yet here either his blindness or the desire to cause strife blocks that wisdom.
-
y'all are dumb
-
y'all are dumb
I wish it was truly that simple. :wacko:
-
Bottom line is RBG should have retired before 2016 to let Obama pick her successor if she was so concerned about not letting Trump make the call. But like all the other Democrats, she thought that no way Trump would be elected. Well, she bet wrong and I for one, am glad to see ACB replace her.
-
Bottom line is RBG should have retired before 2016 to let Obama pick her successor if she was so concerned about not letting Trump make the call. But like all the other Democrats, she thought that no way Trump would be elected. Well, she bet wrong and I for one, am glad to see ACB replace her.
I believe that's "The Notorious ACB".
-
Bottom line is RBG should have retired before 2016 to let Obama pick her successor if she was so concerned about not letting Trump make the call. But like all the other Democrats, she thought that no way Trump would be elected. Well, she bet wrong and I for one, am glad to see ACB replace her.
For us to even CONSIDER respecting RBG's wish, we'd first have to wait until after the election. That gives the Dem voters a much bigger incentive to turn out. Her request INTERFERES with the election.
Now, let's say the Senate waits for the next president to enter office. If Trump wins, that means we have to deal with an 8-judge panel for 4 more years?
Lastly, if (when) the results of the election are challenged and wind up before the Supreme Court, having an even number of judges risks a tie decision. Talk about a Constitutional Crisis!!
In 29 cases where a SCOTUS vacancy comes up in an election year, all 29 times the President made a nomination. So, Trump holding up the nomination would be wrong. Period.
The Senate then has the responsibility to evaluate and vote on the nominee. To fail to fill the vacancy with a likely contentious and litigious election in Nov would be irresponsible.
Sitting back and twiddling our thumbs is not an answer given the state of this election. Mail-in ballots, changes to states' rules for such ballots, stories of mass fraud, ... SCOTUS needs to be ready rule.
-
All day Friday, CNN was announcing Barrett as Trump’s pick. They cited a “Trump insider” as their source. Fox News then picked it up citing CNN as their source. I think it would be funny if the “insider” gave CNN fake news so they spent the day attacking Barrett. Head fake then announce Lagoa as the nominee. :rofl:
-
Fake news media say ACB was the only one DJT interviewed and did so twice. Barbara Lagoa would be a smart move to get the Latino and Florida vote. Democrats tearing her apart would anger Latinos and Floridans.
-
Fake news media say ACB was the only one DJT interviewed and did so twice. Barbara Lagoa would be a smart move to get the Latino and Florida vote. Democrats tearing her apart would anger Latinos and Floridans.
exactly my opinion
trump can nominate acb next time if he wins
then he will have nominated 50% of the female Supremes
worst sexist ever!
-
That was when Billy Joel made good songs -- actually very close to the end of that period.
Can't blame him if he doesn't listen to oldies. :thumbsup: :geekdanc: :shaka:
That era was a little before my time, but I did enjoy a number of his songs.
I didn't care for that album
or the ones before that
he started sucking when he dated/married Christie Brinkley
a good way to go down, but his music suffered
too happy and less drugs...
#maybeyoushouldhavebeenamusician
#stillnotadoctor
:rofl:
-
All day Friday, CNN was announcing Barrett as Trump’s pick. They cited a “Trump insider” as their source. Fox News then picked it up citing CNN as their source. I think it would be funny if the “insider” gave CNN fake news so they spent the day attacking Barrett. Head fake then announce Lagoa as the nominee. :rofl:
:hmm:
Initiative. . . keep 'em guessing. Spun up preparing to counter ACB, then bam. . .
But, alas. . .
https://www.sun-sentinel.com/news/politics/fl-ne-barbara-lagoa-supreme-court-announcement-20200926-dowzhhn4rrdj7mheisfm2di7qa-story.html
-
I am happy with ACB as the nominee.
-
The Democrats know they don't have the votes to stop her confirmation. Will they use procedural attempts to slow down the process and/or attempt to smear her in some way during the hearings?
I'd think they'd know that smearing her will activate more Trump supporters and maybe some undecideds, but being rational isn't necessarily a strong point with liberals. Can't wait for October 12, or whenever.
-
Joe Pags nice parody
https://youtu.be/iTqnLlWTHZ4
-
The Democrats know they don't have the votes to stop her confirmation. Will they use procedural attempts to slow down the process and/or attempt to smear her in some way during the hearings?
I'd think they'd know that smearing her will activate more Trump supporters and maybe some undecideds, but being rational isn't necessarily a strong point with liberals. Can't wait for October 12, or whenever.
There's a rumor that the Dems are going to boycott the confirmation hearings, since they know, shy of some disqualifying bombshell, Barrett will be confirmed before the election.
I don't know if that includes the members of the Senate Judiciary Committee running the hearings or simply the rest of the Dem Senators and House members. I really HOPE they boycott it, because (1) it makes them look even more childish, and (2) it reduces the chance the hearings will devolve into another Kavanaugh debacle.
On the other hand, Dems who want to be in the 2024 Primaries will take this chance to get national exposure for themselves.
Interested to see how much of a tantrum the Dems will throw the next few weeks.
-
There's a rumor that the Dems are going to boycott the confirmation hearings, since they know, shy of some disqualifying bombshell, Barrett will be confirmed before the election.
I don't know if that includes the members of the Senate Judiciary Committee running the hearings or simply the rest of the Dem Senators and House members. I really HOPE they boycott it, because (1) it makes them look even more childish, and (2) it reduces the chance the hearings will devolve into another Kavanaugh debacle.
On the other hand, Dems who want to be in the 2024 Primaries will take this chance to get national exposure for themselves.
Interested to see how much of a tantrum the Dems will throw the next few weeks.
Well, I see some of them saying they will focus the attack on health care (Obamacare case early November at SCOTUS) claiming that 7 trillion people will be left to die in the streets if Barrett is confirmed.
I'd really love it if they boycotted, then the Judiciary Committee hearing would go something like this:
Chairman Lindsey Graham: "The Committee will come to order. No Democrats? Okay. Clerk, call the roll. All in favor of confirming Ms. Coney Barrett please say aye. Unanimous. Okay. That was easy. Committee adjourned."
-
Well, I see some of them saying they will focus the attack on health care (Obamacare case early November at SCOTUS) claiming that 7 trillion people will be left to die in the streets if Barrett is confirmed.
I'd really love it if they boycotted, then the Judiciary Committee hearing would go something like this:
Chairman Lindsey Graham: "The Committee will come to order. No Democrats? Okay. Clerk, call the roll. All in favor of confirming Ms. Coney Barrett please say aye. Unanimous. Okay. That was easy. Committee adjourned."
I marvel at how there's a 99.99% chance of Barrett being confirmed, yet the Dems continue to attack her. As if that will somehow play in their favor if/when an issue they care about is before her.
Justice Barrett: "Senator Feinstein, I rule in favor of your opponent. You may now present your opening statement if you think it'll do any good .... " :rofl: :rofl: :rofl:
-
Hirono is such an embarrassment ...
Democratic senator warns that Barrett will strike down Obamacare amid pandemic
Democratic Sen. Mazie Hirono, a member of the Senate Judiciary Committee, said that Supreme Court nominee
Amy Coney Barrett will strike down the Affordable Care Act if she is confirmed.
“Judiciary Republicans are prepared to vote for whoever the nominee is, but they want to push this person through
to steal yet another Supreme Court seat, to vote down the Affordable Care
Act,” Hirono said.
The Supreme Court will hear oral arguments on the future of the ACA on Nov. 10.
“She is going to strike down the Affordable Care Act in the midst of a pandemic, leaving millions and millions of people
without health care,” Hirono said.
The senator from Hawaii told CNN’s Wolf Blitzer she will not be meeting with Barrett ahead of confirmation hearings.
“I will not be meeting with her. I will take the opportunity to question her when she is under oath,” Hirono said.
White House Chief of Staff Mark Meadows said he hopes the nominee will be confirmed by Nov. 1.
“We may not be able to stop it; we can slow it down. But the American people need to know
what's at stake,” Hirono said. “... And what’s at stake is their very health care.”
https://www.cnn.com/politics/live-news/us-election-news-09-26-20/index.html
What did we learn from this article, boys and girls?
1. Trump is stealing Supreme Court seats by exercising his powers and duties as specified in the US Constitution.
2. This one new Justice will be the reason the ACA gets repealed if it ever does. Not that the law, Constitution or arguments against keeping it are valid, but that a single judge will swing the court over to Trump's side.
3. The Congress (House and Senate) have had 10 years -- since the ACA was passed in 2010 -- to fix any deficiencies that make the act vulnerable to repeal. So far, they've done little to nothing in that regard.
4. The Act (more aptly named the Unaffordable Careless Act) should have been repealed in 2010 based solely on the bill being passed (a) without a single Republican vote, and (b) the bait & switch the Dems pulled by passing the bill without a tax (but with a FINE or PENALTY), then changing it to a TAX so the SCOTUS would not say the bill was unconstitutional. I believe this is a perfect example of taxation without representation. Our representatives did not pass a TAX bill.
5. The mandate has since been ruled unconstitutional. Without that provision, the act cannot survive financially. That's the main argument being presented in Nov to the SCOTUS.
6. Lazy Mazie said they can't stop the confirmation, but they can try to slow it down. Any motion she, or any other Democrat, makes in the hearing must have that motion considered in the context of this statement. There can not be an assumption that any Democrat will be suggesting (demanding) anything which causes a delay as having been made in "good faith" . Hirono tried to delay Kavanaugh's vote by demanding a month long FBI background investigation -- one which was done in a few days. When they can't find a single person who can corroborate the accuser's story, there's really not much to do. :rofl: :thumbsup: :geekdanc:
-
In case someone was wondering why the Senate should not delay this appointment, beyond what's already been posted, there's one aspect I don't think has gotten attention.
Let's say the Senate delays until after the election for any reason -- "muh decorum", Dem threats to retaliate, etc. Then, after the election as long as the GOP still has a Senate majority, they will still confirm Trump's nominee in a lame duck session. They have until January to do whatever they want before the new Congress/President are inaugurated.
This is the same tactic the Dems tried with Kavanaugh. They knew they could not prevent confirmation with a Senate minority, so they were doing a "Hail, Mary," praying they became the Senate majority.
It didn't work 2 years ago, and it won't work this time. The Senate has the power and the duty to consider Trump's nominee without unnecessary delay. And the #1 issue that the Supreme Court will need to be ready to decide after Nov 1 will be a contested election. They need all 9 seats filled to ensure they can decide the cases that may arise.
The irony is, the Dems are creating the #1 reason to not delay by increasing the probability there will be a contested election through their own actions: changing state election rules (not counting any mail-in votes before election day, not allowing ballots with obviously mismatched signatures to be tossed, paying Democrat-leaning felons in FL so they can vote, etc.), and allowing ballot harvesting (private activist groups collecting ballots to turn them in). Their attempts to cheat require that we anticipate legal challenges. Good job, Dems! :rofl:
-
For everything everyone is saying about her being non bias because of her religious beliefs on abortion no one was willing to put money up for a bet....hmmmm I guess in the end we know what people truly believe.
-
For everything everyone is saying about her being non bias because of her religious beliefs on abortion no one was willing to put money up for a bet....hmmmm I guess in the end we know what people truly believe.
I believe Flapp asked you what the time limit was. It cannot be open ended.
-
I believe Flapp asked you what the time limit was. It cannot be open ended.
True I would like to say it depends on who elected president. Republican or Democrat to be fair i would say 8 years that gives ample opportunity to both sides. Unless you have a better idea. Rules will be simple. If in those 8 years an abortion case gets heard by the Supreme Court if Amy votes to limit or eliminate abortion rights i win. If she votes to keep the status quo or expand rights you win. If no case is accepted by the court then the bet is void.
-
In case someone was wondering why the Senate should not delay this appointment, beyond what's already been posted, there's one aspect I don't think has gotten attention.
Let's say the Senate delays until after the election for any reason -- "muh decorum", Dem threats to retaliate, etc. Then, after the election as long as the GOP still has a Senate majority, they will still confirm Trump's nominee in a lame duck session. They have until January to do whatever they want before the new Congress/President are inaugurated.
This is the same tactic the Dems tried with Kavanaugh. They knew they could not prevent confirmation with a Senate minority, so they were doing a "Hail, Mary," praying they became the Senate majority.
It didn't work 2 years ago, and it won't work this time. The Senate has the power and the duty to consider Trump's nominee without unnecessary delay. And the #1 issue that the Supreme Court will need to be ready to decide after Nov 1 will be a contested election. They need all 9 seats filled to ensure they can decide the cases that may arise.
The irony is, the Dems are creating the #1 reason to not delay by increasing the probability there will be a contested election through their own actions: changing state election rules (not counting any mail-in votes before election day, not allowing ballots with obviously mismatched signatures to be tossed, paying Democrat-leaning felons in FL so they can vote, etc.), and allowing ballot harvesting (private activist groups collecting ballots to turn them in). Their attempts to cheat require that we anticipate legal challenges. Good job, Dems! :rofl:
I read somewhere this morning that Trump has hired or activated dozens of lawyers in anticipation of a contested election. But now I can’t find it. I believe it will be a huge fight.
-
For everything everyone is saying about her being non bias because of her religious beliefs on abortion no one was willing to put money up for a bet....hmmmm I guess in the end we know what people truly believe.
still waiting for your answer to my question...
-
but how will we know whether her religious beliefs led her to vote against the case rather than say, the law and the Constitution?
you know, what she is sworn to do, disregarding her personal biases?
-
but how will we know whether her religious beliefs led her to vote against the case rather than say, the law and the Constitution?
you know, what she is sworn to do, disregarding her personal biases?
That's impossible to prove question. All we know is based on the past she is anti abortion. She's a devout catholic which believes abortion is evil and wrong. And she is quoted saying religion affects her life and how she lives it. That's what the bet is about.
-
That's impossible to prove question. All we know is based on the past she is anti abortion. She's a devout catholic which believes abortion is evil and wrong. And she is quoted saying religion affects her life and how she lives it. That's what the bet is about.
so then your bet is impossible...
-
The Democrats know they don't have the votes to stop her confirmation. Will they use procedural attempts to slow down the process and/or attempt to smear her in some way during the hearings?
I'd think they'd know that smearing her will activate more Trump supporters and maybe some undecideds, but being rational isn't necessarily a strong point with liberals. Can't wait for October 12, or whenever.
You’re gonna hurt their feewings.
This is an example of an uber Liberal (former co-worker’s wife). She’s a total TDS’er, rants about how Trump has divided this country, but posts stuff like this. Again blaming this on Trump.
Funny is she’s all girl power and stuff. Interesting how she’ll try to trash ACB.
-
For everything everyone is saying about her being non bias because of her religious beliefs on abortion no one was willing to put money up for a bet....hmmmm I guess in the end we know what people truly believe.
It's an open-ended bet. Nobody is going to bet you something that can't be claimed for a number of years. The longer you stretch out the deadline, the better the odds are in your favor.
Barrett herself said it's highly unlikely R v. W will be overturned in the near future. It's a non-issue for the majority of people.
p.s. You do know that betting is illegal in Hawaii, right? Maybe you should reconsider taking bets on a public forum, genius! :crazy:
-
That's impossible to prove question. All we know is based on the past she is anti abortion. She's a devout catholic which believes abortion is evil and wrong. And she is quoted saying religion affects her life and how she lives it. That's what the bet is about.
There are 4 other Catholics on the Supreme Court. She will make 5.
It's unconstitutional to consider a person's religion to be used for qualification or disqualification for public office. I thought you worshipped the Constitution. Maybe you should go back and read it.
Biden is a practicing Catholic.
Pelosi is a practicing Catholic.
I guess the only religious people you want to trust are the hypocrites who pretend to be Catholics and live their lives any damn way they feel like?
37% of the House of Representatives are Roman Catholic. These are the people who actually draft, amend, pass, reject and repeal the laws the Supreme Court interprets.
Is it your opinion that the Supreme Court has more power than the 435 members of the US House of Representatives, the 100 members of the US Senate, and the President of the United States combined?
Your civics teachers failed you.
https://www.rollcall.com/2020/02/26/house-lawmakers-make-a-dash-for-ash/
-
so then your bet is impossible...
It's an open-ended bet. Nobody is going to bet you something that can't be claimed for a number of years. The longer you stretch out the deadline, the better the odds are in your favor.
Barrett herself said it's highly unlikely R v. W will be overturned in the near future. It's a non-issue for the majority of people.
p.s. You do know that betting is illegal in Hawaii, right? Maybe you should reconsider taking bets on a public forum, genius! :crazy:
Not really if nothing is heard then no one wins... it's void. So the length of time has no effect. I'm not even saying it's going to pass im just saying she will vote to limit abortion. Her religion or anything about her isn't part of this bet. It's literally only one thing. How she votes, which side she votes on a case.
To be legal I've never said it had to happen in Hawaii. We can payout in a legal state. In just mostly trying to make a point.
-
Not really if nothing is heard then no one wins... it's void. So the length of time has no effect. I'm not even saying it's going to pass im just saying she will vote to limit abortion. Her religion or anything about her isn't part of this bet. It's literally only one thing. How she votes, which side she votes on a case.
To be legal I've never said it had to happen in Hawaii. We can payout in a legal state. In just mostly trying to make a point.
The only point you've made is that you don't like her because she is not afraid of commitment.
She's committed to her family, her faith, her occupation, and her oath of office.
What you'd PREFER is someone who shares your ideologies and will follow those ideals above her obligation to follow the Constitution and the laws passed by Congress.
Ideologues like yourself are afraid of people who act according to principles, because you don't want to be held to the same standards as everybody else. You want to have an advantage.
As such, you ASSUME that everyone else thinks like you do. What Liberals expect is for "Liberal" judges to follow their ideological beliefs, as opposed to Conservatives who want the have judges be consistent and constitutionally faithful.
p.s. The payout location is irrelevant. The Hawaii laws concerning gambling say wherever the bet is places, either the bettor's end or the bet takers location, makes it illegal if either is in Hawaii. Look up Internet Gaming laws as they exist for Hawaii.
If the gaming server is in Barbados, and you are in Hawaii playing Texas Hold'em for money, you are breaking the law -- even if the money is changing hands via non-US-based banks.
if you are going to try to dodge laws, you should do more research, genius.
-
The only point you've made is that you don't like her because she is not afraid of commitment.
She's committed to her family, her faith, her occupation, and her oath of office.
What you'd PREFER is someone who shares your ideologies and will follow those ideals above her obligation to follow the Constitution and the laws passed by Congress.
Ideologues like yourself are afraid of people who act according to principles, because you don't want to be held to the same standards as everybody else. You want to have an advantage.
As such, you ASSUME that everyone else thinks like you do. What Liberals expect is for "Liberal" judges to follow their ideological beliefs, as opposed to Conservatives who want the have judges be consistent and constitutionally faithful.
p.s. The payout location is irrelevant. The Hawaii laws concerning gambling say wherever the bet is places, either the bettor's end or the bet takers location, makes it illegal if either is in Hawaii. Look up Internet Gaming laws as they exist for Hawaii.
If the gaming server is in Barbados, and you are in Hawaii playing Texas Hold'em for money, you are breaking the law -- even if the money is changing hands via non-US-based banks.
if you are going to try to dodge laws, you should do more research, genius.
You got me i don't want someone with ideology I don't agree with to be put in. Someone who doesn't have the same ideology as the Constitution with clearly says separation of church and state.
-
There are 4 other Catholics on the Supreme Court. She will make 5. ...
37% of the House of Representatives are Roman Catholic. These are the people who actually draft, amend, pass, reject and repeal the laws the Supreme Court interprets.
Only approximately 22% of the U.S. population is Catholic.
That would be 56% of the Supreme Court and 37% of the House for Reps.
Would it be different if it were Muslims ?
P.S. I don’t know anything about her, am not for or against her, I need to read on stances and legal decisions.
Just these ridiculous arguments make me laugh.
-
The hypocrisy is the same people who are arguing for separation of Church and State are making an issue of a person's PERSONAL beliefs. So should justices have no faith / religion? They should be looking at their professional background not their personal.
-
The hypocrisy is the same people who are arguing for separation of Church and State are making an issue of a person's PERSONAL beliefs. So should justices have no faith / religion? They should be looking at their professional background not their personal.
I'm just saying if because of your religion you openly believe something it might not be best if you work in a mandatory non biased job.
If you have religion all you have to do is have it not influence your opinions on how to do your job.
That Twitter kingdom of God quote clearly shows she does not have that. That's all in saying.
-
The hypocrisy is the same people who are arguing for separation of Church and State are making an issue of a person's PERSONAL beliefs. So should justices have no faith / religion? They should be looking at their professional background not their personal.
Exactly. The Senate's job is to decide whether or not the nominee is QUALIFIED for the position based solely on knowledge, experience, character and demonstrated ability. Anything not related to the job's requirements should be left alone.
Her qualifications would be extremely difficult to match. Even Democrat Harvard lawyers have nothing but glowing praise for her abilities as a judge.
That means the only thing they can throw at her will be personal attacks. So far, her faith and her adopted kids have been targeted on Twitter, and as soon as that happens, people come out of the wings telling them to stop. It only makes the Left look childish and desperate.
My opinion: The ACA and Roe v Wade are going to be the top two (only?) issues being used to try and scare people against her. Everything else will be seen as just more of the "Kavanaugh Effect".
For the Dems to fight this nomination with no chance of blocking her gains them absolutely nothing. Unless they can delay the vote and use the SCOTUS issue to win the Presidency and the Senate majority, they agains win nothing.
Therefore, they will be trying to delay the confirmation vote at all cost. It's their only play.
-
I'm just saying if because of your religion you openly believe something it might not be best if you work in a mandatory non biased job.
If you have religion all you have to do is have it not influence your opinions on how to do your job.
That Twitter kingdom of God quote clearly shows she does not have that. That's all in saying.
The person who cuts my hair is a lesbian. She cuts my hair the way I like it and does a very good job. I don't care who she married - she cuts hair really well so she gets my business.
-
I'm just saying if because of your religion you openly believe something it might not be best if you work in a mandatory non biased job.
If you have religion all you have to do is have it not influence your opinions on how to do your job.
That Twitter kingdom of God quote clearly shows she does not have that. That's all in saying.
Are you saying that nobody can do a job without being a slave to their perceptions, beliefs and experiences?
We seat thousands of jurors every day who have something in their background that MAY influence their ability to reach an objective decision based on the law and the evidence presented.
Jurists include both Judges and members of juries. Both have the same responsibilities. We trust judges to recuse themselves if a conflict actually comes up. Jurors, also, get excused if they have conflicts. Otherwise, we trust that a person's OATH to do their job fairly and as expected will be how things will be done.
That's the system. You don't have to agree with it, but we trust it every single day. Your fear of a religious woman becoming a judge after she's been doing that job for 3 years just one level lower in the federal judicial system is irrational.
-
The person who cuts my hair is a lesbian. She cuts my hair the way I like it and does a very good job. I don't care who she married - she cuts hair really well so she gets my business.
That's exactly what I am saying. Thats what should be happening. Now what if because she was a lesbian she only gave certain haircuts that her culture approves? And showed a bias unbecoming of her job?
This exactly like those "pharmacists" or something a little while back that refused to do their job because of their religious beliefs. Do your job and keep your beliefs out of it. Whether you cut hair, dispense medicine or judge law, if you can't you are not qualified for the job.
In 1998, soon after finishing law school, Barrett co-authored an article titled “Catholic Judges in Capital Cases,” which ultimately concluded, “that Catholic judges (if they are faithful to the teaching of their church) are morally precluded from enforcing the death penalty.” <--- this is what i am worried about
-
That's exactly what I am saying. Thats what should be happening. Now what if because she was a lesbian she only gave certain haircuts that her culture approves? And showed a bias unbecoming of her job?
This exactly like those "pharmacists" or something a little while back that refused to do their job because of their religious beliefs. Do your job and keep your beliefs out of it. Whether you cut hair, dispense medicine or judge law, if you can't you are not qualified for the job.
In 1998, soon after finishing law school, Barrett co-authored an article titled “Catholic Judges in Capital Cases,” which ultimately concluded, “that Catholic judges (if they are faithful to the teaching of their church) are morally precluded from enforcing the death penalty.” <--- this is what i am worried about
Got any actual cases to support your FEAR!!??
Fear is an emotion. Without a rational basis for a fear, we call it a phobia.
I'm sure in the time she's been on the appellate court and as a law professor, there must be one time she's been in trouble for applying her religious beliefs where they were inappropriate.
Take your time. Just one instance is all you need.
Ginsburg made no attempt to hide her disdain for the 2nd Amendment, yet she never recused herself from gun-related cases.
Obviously, it's not a stretch to trust our judges will make fair decisions without being controlled by their beliefs.
-
Ginsburg on the 2nd Amendment.....
"In the wake of the fierce, nationwide debate over gun rights and gun control, Justice Ginsburg also
explained the historical basis for her view on the Second Amendment.
"The Second Amendment has a preamble about the need for a militia ... Historically, the new government
had no money to pay for an army, so they relied on the state militias," she said. "The states required men
to have certain weapons and they specified in the law what weapons these people had to keep in their
home so that when they were called to do service as militiamen, they would have them. That was the entire
purpose of the Second Amendment."
Ginsburg said the disappearance of that purpose eliminates the function of the Second Amednment. [sic]
"It's function is to enable the young nation to have people who will fight for it to have weapons that those
soldiers will own," she said. "I view the Second Amendment as rooted in the time totally allied to the need
to support a militia. So ... the Second Amendment is outdated in the sense that its function has become
obsolete."
https://armsandthelaw.com/archives/2013/10/justice_ginsber.php
So wrong.
The idea was to rely for our defense primarily through an armed citizenry that can be called up as a militia. If the people themselves are the military power of the state, then that power cannot be used against the people. That’s what they meant when they called this system “necessary to the security of a free state.”
The purpose was not only to protect the state from foreign powers. It was to protect "the people" from tyranny -- both foreign and domestic.
Maybe Ruthie should have printed a copy of her oath of office to remind herself now and again what she was appointed to do:
SCOTUS Justices take 2 oaths of office.
THE CONSTITUTIONAL OATH:
“I, _________, do solemnly swear (or affirm) that I will support and defend the Constitution of the United States against all enemies, foreign and domestic;
that I will bear true faith and allegiance to the same;
that I take this obligation freely, without any mental reservation or purpose of evasion;
and that I will well and faithfully discharge the duties of the office on which I am about to enter.
So help me God.”
THE JUDICIAL OATH:
“I, _________, do solemnly swear (or affirm) that I will administer justice without respect to persons,
and do equal right to the poor and to the rich,
and that I will faithfully and impartially discharge and perform all the duties incumbent upon me as _________
under the Constitution and laws of the United States. So help me God.”
Time for a new judge to correct that opinion from the bench.
-
You got me i don't want someone with ideology I don't agree with to be put in. Someone who doesn't have the same ideology as the Constitution with clearly says separation of church and state.
Where in the FUCK does it say “Separation of Church and State” in the constitution? Let me tell you, it does not say that at all. You sir are not telling the truth. And you are showing your ignorance of this subject if you really think that the constitution says that. You have some very weird misconceptions of reality.
You have absolutely no proof that ACB doesn’t have the ability to rule per the constitution no matter her feelings about abortion. None. Zero. Zilch. And if she decides something PER THE CONSTITUTION, it does not prove she is deciding a case per her feelings. You are projecting your feelings onto her and that is not reality. And it certainly not fair to her. You are making that up just like you made up that “the separation of church and state” is stated in the constitution. You continue to make shit up.
But let’s discuss this in technical terms if you are capable of critical thinking. Rowe vs Wade was a decision determining legality of state laws as decided by SCOTUS per the constitution. It is not a right, it is not in the constitution and technically speaking, SCOTUS is not supposed to make any laws by deciding what each law the states are supposed to make. THIS IS A STATE ISSUE, NOT A FEDERAL/CONSTITUTIONAL ISSUE. That is what SCOTUS will decide IF (and that is a big IF) SCOTUS decides to hear whether Rowe vs Wade should be overturned. But there is no evidence (unless you can predict the future) that ACB will not vote to NOT rehear it. There are probably enough constitutionalist (and religious and conservative) SCOTUS justices (that would probably vote to overturn Rowe vs Wade) that will vote to NOT rehear Rowe vs Wade. Justice Kavanaugh has already stated he would vote to not rehear any cases like this. And he is one that would probably vote to overturn Rowe. If SCOTUS did vote to rehear it, and if ACB finds that it is illegal, which it is, and it is overturned, then what happens? Women DO NOT LOSE their right to get an abortion. How can they lose a right that they never had in the first place? What happens is that state law goes back into effect if Rowe vs Wade is overturned. Which is the way it was BEFORE Rowe vs Wade. And women were getting abortions long before that. So tell us all, what would actually change if Rowe vs Wade would be overturned?
You really should understand what you are talking about before you open your mouth. Otherwise you look foolish.
-
Where in the FUCK does it say “Separation of Church and State” in the constitution? Let me tell you, it does not say that at all. You sir are not telling the truth. And you are showing your ignorance of this subject if you really think that the constitution says that. You have some very weird misconceptions of reality.
You have absolutely no proof that ACB doesn’t have the ability to rule per the constitution no matter her feelings about abortion. None. Zero. Zilch. And if she decides something PER THE CONSTITUTION, it does not prove she is deciding a case per her feelings. You are projecting your feelings onto her and that is not reality. And it certainly not fair to her. You are making that up just like you made up that “the separation of church and state” is stated in the constitution. You continue to make shit up.
But let’s discuss this in technical terms if you are capable of critical thinking. Rowe vs Wade was a decision determining legality of state laws as decided by SCOTUS per the constitution. It is not a right, it is not in the constitution and technically speaking, SCOTUS is not supposed to make any laws by deciding what each law the states are supposed to make. THIS IS A STATE ISSUE, NOT A FEDERAL/CONSTITUTIONAL ISSUE. That is what SCOTUS will decide IF (and that is a big IF) SCOTUS decides to hear whether Rowe vs Wade should be overturned. But there is no evidence (unless you can predict the future) that ACB will not vote to NOT rehear it. There are probably enough constitutionalist (and religious and conservative) SCOTUS justices (that would probably vote to overturn Rowe vs Wade) that will vote to NOT rehear Rowe vs Wade. Justice Kavanaugh has already stated he would vote to not rehear any cases like this. And he is one that would probably vote to overturn Rowe. If SCOTUS did vote to rehear it, and if ACB finds that it is illegal, which it is, and it is overturned, then what happens? Women DO NOT LOSE their right to get an abortion. How can they lose a right that they never had in the first place? What happens is that state law goes back into effect if Rowe vs Wade is overturned. Which is the way it was BEFORE Rowe vs Wade. And women were getting abortions long before that. So tell us all, what would actually change if Rowe vs Wade would be overturned?
You really should understand what you are talking about before you open your mouth. Otherwise you look foolish.
To augment, the 1st Amendment prevents the government from making laws which establish religion (like England did when they required top political officials belong to the official religion), nor can gov't prohibit the free exercise thereof.
People love to say this means anything that is part of religious doctrine can be prohibited in the context of government -- for example: no 10 Commandments plaques in courthouses, no Christmas displays, no Bibles used for taking oaths, etc. That's not how it was supposed to be.
Let's say the Bible states that we are required to pay our taxes to the state (Render unto Caesar that which is Caesar's"). Using the separation concept, anyone who believes the Christian teachings is prohibited from paying taxes to any government under the jurisdiction of the Constitution. Separation means just that. The two may never cross each other's doctrine.
People love to pick and choose what parts of the Bible are forbidden to be incorporated in laws, but they always skip over the parts they agree with. Since when does acceptance of a principal that's taught from religious text required to nullify it from the "separation" requirement?
The entire "separation belief system" crumbles when you realize the entire government was founded on Judeo-Christian ideas, and that the ideas are baked into the Constitution itself. Trying to separate religion from government is not only what the 1st Amendment is NOT supposed to do, but it's impossible to even try.
It would be like trying to separate conjoined twins that share all of their vital organs. Religion and government can only be separated if you are trying to kill both religion and the Constitution in the process.
if you ask most people, we could do with a little more adherence to the ethical teachings of religion. There's a lot of stealing, killing, and lying going around -- especially in an election season like now.
-
To augment, the 1st Amendment prevents the government from making laws which establish religion (like England did when they required top political officials belong to the official religion), nor can gov't prohibit the free exercise thereof.
People love to say this means anything that is part of religious doctrine can be prohibited in the context of government -- for example: no 10 Commandments plaques in courthouses, no Christmas displays, no Bibles used for taking oaths, etc. That's not how it was supposed to be.
Let's say the Bible states that we are required to pay our taxes to the state (Render unto Caesar that which is Caesar's"). Using the separation concept, anyone who believes the Christian teachings is prohibited from paying taxes to any government under the jurisdiction of the Constitution. Separation means just that. The two may never cross each other's doctrine.
People love to pick and choose what parts of the Bible are forbidden to be incorporated in laws, but they always skip over the parts they agree with. Since when does acceptance of a principal that's taught from religious text required to nullify it from the "separation" requirement?
The entire "separation belief system" crumbles when you realize the entire government was founded on Judeo-Christian ideas, and that the ideas are baked into the Constitution itself. Trying to separate religion from government is not only what the 1st Amendment is NOT supposed to do, but it's impossible to even try.
It would be like trying to separate conjoined twins that share all of their vital organs. Religion and government can only be separated if you are trying to kill both religion and the Constitution in the process.
if you ask most people, we could do with a little more adherence to the ethical teachings of religion. There's a lot of stealing, killing, and lying going around -- especially in an election season like now.
Well said, Flapp. I am one of the non religious types, I not only agree with this, but I think religion is a necessary part of our culture and who we are as a country. It is the religious people in this country that do the most good for our country and for their fellow Americans. Generally speaking of course. To be non religious and to not accept religion at its face value is not reality.
-
Just for fun, for any fans of the egomaniac the notorious-indeed RBG:
Ginsburg’s stance on abortion seemed to edge toward eugenics during a New York Times Magazine interview in 2009 while opining about the Hyde Amendment, which prohibits federally funded abortions. Ginsburg said, “Frankly, I had thought that at the time Roe was decided there was concern about population growth and particularly growth in populations that we don’t want to have too many of.”
“...populations that we don’t want to have too many of.”? Gee, I wonder what population she was referring to? smh.
-
You really should understand what you are talking about before you open your mouth. Otherwise you look foolish.
Arguing with children/millennials having a smartphone and google may be humorous, but a bit ridiculous.
I suspect they view it like their precious video games, just a game to be "won".
-
Where in the FUCK does it say “Separation of Church and State” in the constitution? Let me tell you, it does not say that at all. You sir are not telling the truth. And you are showing your ignorance of this subject if you really think that the constitution says that. You have some very weird misconceptions of reality.
Yup, the goal of Leftism is complete reliance on the State and so they have waged a hundred year war against the Judeo-Christian religious history and principles that this country was founded on.
-
Yup, the goal of Leftism is complete reliance on the State and so they have waged a hundred year war against the Judeo-Christian religious history and principles that this country was founded on.
The thing is I feel sorry for this Omnigun kid as he has been brainwashed by the media. His thinking that the constitution even says anything remotely close is the brainwashing by the media. But you can’t tell him that. It probably will hurt his feelings. His whole argument is feeling and emotion based and he doesn’t seem to care what the facts and truth is. Sad to see it in our own 2A community.
-
Well said, Flapp. I am one of the non religious types, I not only agree with this, but I think religion is a necessary part of our culture and who we are as a country. It is the religious people in this country that do the most good for our country and for their fellow Americans. Generally speaking of course. To be non religious and to not accept religion at its face value is not reality.
This country was given a set of rules( Constitution) that presumed that ethical men would follow those rules.
Ethics are dictated to us by God eg. the Ten commandments. Ethics are what you practice
when nobody is watching you. The founders knew the country would fail if un-ethical men got into
positions of power. They had faith that, that would not happen, but built in safeguards for such an
occurrence. Those safeguards have been ignored for too long.
Professional ethics are man made rules. Professional ethics are ignored whenever
you can get away with it and it suits your purpose.
America is now run by people ruled by professional ethics,
Democrats, that ignore the Constitutional safeguards.
Ye reap, what ye sow.
.
-
This country was given a set of rules( Constitution) that presumed that ethical men would follow those rules.
Ethics are dictated to us by God eg. the Ten commandments. Ethics are what you practice
when nobody is watching you. The founders knew the country would fail if un-ethical men got into
positions of power. They had faith that, that would not happen, but built in safeguards for such an
occurrence. Those safeguards have been ignored for too long.
Professional ethics are man made rules. Professional ethics are ignored whenever
you can get away with it and it suits your purpose.
America is now run by people ruled by professional ethics,
Democrats, that ignore the Constitutional safeguards.
Ye reap, what ye sow.
.
One example of where the expectation of ethical behavior has been destroyed is Congress. They have immunity for anything they say while acting in their official capacity. That's why people like Reid, Schiff, Pelosi and Schumer have been able to lie with impunity.
In an interview with former Dem Senate Majority Leader Harry Reid, he was asked if he regretted lying on the floor of the Senate when he said Gov. Romney had paid no income taxes -- a lie disproven when Romney made his returns public. Reid grinned his little Grinch grin and said, "We won, didn't we?"
This is why nobody should believe a single thing the Dems in Congress say. Ethics flow down from the top of an organization. Look at the sham impeachment of Trump, the Russia-Collusion attempted coup, and all the lies told about Kavanaugh without a shred of evidence.
Hillary was not a member of Congress when she was using her illegal server to bypass the FOIA requirements of the Secretary of State position. Her lies were not covered by the immunity she enjoyed as a former member of the Senate. However, the corrupt FBI and DOJ refused to hold her accountable for violating federal laws.
This is one result of not believing in a higher power. When you aren't concerned about the laws of your god, savior, or other deity, you start believing your personal situation takes precedence over any other concern.
-
@inspector and @flapp and @grovler
I swear don't blame everything on millennials.
https://www.mtsu.edu/first-amendment/article/885/establishment-clause-separation-of-church-and-state#:~:text=The%20most%20famous%20use%20of,between%20the%20church%20and%20state.”
Contrary to popular belief not all media is fake news.
I don't take any offense and hopefully no one here does of what I say. I'm just an independent voter leaning libertarian in the sea of Republicans. I'm not even atheist.
-
Yup, the goal of Leftism is complete reliance on the State and so they have waged a hundred year war against the Judeo-Christian religious history and principles that this country was founded on.
No idea how war on religion is related to reliance on state. If anything it's the opposite. If government is church and you rely on church to decide how you morally live life isn't that the definition of reliance on the state.
At that point we are no different than isis.
-
@inspector and @flapp and @grovler
I swear don't blame everything on millennials.
https://www.mtsu.edu/first-amendment/article/885/establishment-clause-separation-of-church-and-state#:~:text=The%20most%20famous%20use%20of,between%20the%20church%20and%20state.”
Contrary to popular belief not all media is fake news.
I don't take any offense and hopefully no one here does of what I say. I'm just an independent voter leaning libertarian in the sea of Republicans. I'm not even atheist.
Did you read your linked article? ALL of it?
Show me where it says religion is to be forbidden in government leaders' beliefs.
Hint: It doesn't.
The article spells out that GOVERNMENT is not to pass laws with respect to RELIGION (i.e. the Constitution protects religion from government action). Nothing in it about laws being void of religion or religious doctrine.
You can't wipe the memories of elected officials who pass and adjudicate laws. As such, you also can't discriminate on the basis of religion ("prohibiting the free exercise thereof"). So, to claim someone with ANY stated religious belief is automatically forbidden from serving on the Supreme Court violates the text and meaning of the Constitution itself.
-
EEOC laws are also clear.
Religious Discrimination
Religious discrimination involves treating a person (an applicant or employee) unfavorably because of his or her religious beliefs. The law protects not only people who belong to traditional, organized religions, such as Buddhism, Christianity, Hinduism, Islam, and Judaism, but also others who have sincerely held religious, ethical or moral beliefs.
Religious discrimination can also involve treating someone differently because that person is married to (or associated with) an individual of a particular religion.
Religious Discrimination & Work Situations
The law forbids discrimination when it comes to any aspect of employment, including hiring, firing, pay, job assignments, promotions, layoff, training, fringe benefits, and any other term or condition of employment.
Religious Discrimination & Harassment
It is illegal to harass a person because of his or her religion.
Harassment can include, for example, offensive remarks about a person's religious beliefs or practices. Although the law doesn't prohibit simple teasing, offhand comments, or isolated incidents that aren't very serious, harassment is illegal when it is so frequent or severe that it creates a hostile or offensive work environment or when it results in an adverse employment decision (such as the victim being fired or demoted).
The harasser can be the victim's supervisor, a supervisor in another area, a co-worker, or someone who is not an employee of the employer, such as a client or customer.
Religious Discrimination and Segregation
Title VII also prohibits workplace or job segregation based on religion (including religious garb and grooming practices), such as assigning an employee to a non-customer contact position because of actual or feared customer preference.
Religious Discrimination & Reasonable Accommodation
The law requires an employer or other covered entity to reasonably accommodate an employee's religious beliefs or practices, unless doing so would cause more than a minimal burden on the operations of the employer's business. This means an employer may be required to make reasonable adjustments to the work environment that will allow an employee to practice his or her religion.
Examples of some common religious accommodations include flexible scheduling, voluntary shift substitutions or swaps, job reassignments, and modifications to workplace policies or practices.
Religious Accommodation/Dress & Grooming Policies
Unless it would be an undue hardship on the employer's operation of its business, an employer must reasonably accommodate an employee's religious beliefs or practices. This applies not only to schedule changes or leave for religious observances, but also to such things as dress or grooming practices that an employee has for religious reasons. These might include, for example, wearing particular head coverings or other religious dress (such as a Jewish yarmulke or a Muslim headscarf), or wearing certain hairstyles or facial hair (such as Rastafarian dreadlocks or Sikh uncut hair and beard). It also includes an employee's observance of a religious prohibition against wearing certain garments (such as pants or miniskirts).
When an employee or applicant needs a dress or grooming accommodation for religious reasons, he should notify the employer that he needs such an accommodation for religious reasons. If the employer reasonably needs more information, the employer and the employee should engage in an interactive process to discuss the request. If it would not pose an undue hardship, the employer must grant the accommodation.
Religious Discrimination & Reasonable Accommodation & Undue Hardship
An employer does not have to accommodate an employee's religious beliefs or practices if doing so would cause undue hardship to the employer. An accommodation may cause undue hardship if it is costly, compromises workplace safety, decreases workplace efficiency, infringes on the rights of other employees, or requires other employees to do more than their share of potentially hazardous or burdensome work.
Religious Discrimination And Employment Policies/Practices
An employee cannot be forced to participate (or not participate) in a religious activity as a condition of employment.
https://www.eeoc.gov/religious-discrimination
-
@omnigun
I don't know where you attended school, nor how many grades you were able to get passing grades in, but you've absorbed some pretty messed up, and not uncommon, beliefs and misinformation.
It's not so much that you don't know. It's that much of what you know just isn't so.
-
@omnigun
I don't know where you attended school, nor how many grades you were able to get passing grades in, but you've absorbed some pretty messed up, and not uncommon, beliefs and misinformation.
It's not so much that you don't know. It's that much of what you know just isn't so.
Reputable private school and I got high 3's GPA.
Did you read your linked article? ALL of it?
Show me where it says religion is to be forbidden in government leaders' beliefs.
Hint: It doesn't.
The article spells out that GOVERNMENT is not to pass laws with respect to RELIGION (i.e. the Constitution protects religion from government action). Nothing in it about laws being void of religion or religious doctrine.
You can't wipe the memories of elected officials who pass and adjudicate laws. As such, you also can't discriminate on the basis of religion ("prohibiting the free exercise thereof"). So, to claim someone with ANY stated religious belief is automatically forbidden from serving on the Supreme Court violates the text and meaning of the Constitution itself.
What?? I haven't said leaders or anyone shouldn't be religious now you making shit up. I said a judge who has pre-existing bias because of her religion who has spoken of said bias should not be in a position where she decides the laws of the whole nation. There are different levels of bias and how much people have. No one is perfect, but I expect if your a judge you should be more un-bias than most. How you got everyone must be ashiest is a ridiculous.
-
Reputable private school and I got high 3's GPA.
What?? I haven't said leaders or anyone shouldn't be religious now you making shit up. I said a judge who has pre-existing bias because of her religion who has spoken of said bias should not be in a position where she decides the laws of the whole nation. There are different levels of bias and how much people have. No one is perfect, but I expect if your a judge you should be more un-bias than most. How you got everyone must be ashiest is a ridiculous.
Now YOU'RE making shit up.
Where did Barrett say she "has pre-existing bias because of her religion who has spoken of said bias?"
You're reading into her statements what you want to see/hear. She never said she would decide cases based on her religion -- in fact, she said just the opposite.
Barrett is a Textualist / Constitutionalist who believes we should apply the Constitution AS WRITTEN AT THE TIME. She disagrees that new, more modern times changes the meaning of the Constitution. If the times require a different reading, then it may require an amendment, but twisting it to apply to cases that they were never intended to address is incorrect.
If you can't see that she's not a religious nut, nobody can help you.
-
Now YOU'RE making shit up.
Where did Barrett say she "has pre-existing bias because of her religion who has spoken of said bias?"
You're reading into her statements what you want to see/hear. She never said she would decide cases based on her religion -- in fact, she said just the opposite.
Barrett is a Textualist / Constitutionalist who believes we should apply the Constitution AS WRITTEN AT THE TIME. She disagrees that new, more modern times changes the meaning of the Constitution. If the times require a different reading, then it may require an amendment, but twisting it to apply to cases that they were never intended to address is incorrect.
If you can't see that she's not a religious nut, nobody can help you.
I literally linked one where she said no Catholics (herself) can rule on death penalty.
The one where she quoted about the kingdom of god....do you need me to research more for you?
-
Fake news media say ACB was the only one DJT interviewed and did so twice. Barbara Lagoa would be a smart move to get the Latino and Florida vote. Democrats tearing her apart would anger Latinos and Floridans.
Are their no female asian conservative judges? Why Asians always gotta be underrepresented?
-
I literally linked one where she said no Catholics (herself) can rule on death penalty.
The one where she quoted about the kingdom of god....do you need me to research more for you?
Nope. She actually said the opposite regarding recusal for death penalty cases based on being Catholic alone.
Your reading comprehension needs work.
Read the last line and tell me again that "she said no Catholics (herself) can rule on death penalty."
You may not understand, but death penalty cases have many phases, and not all of them involve sentencing, enforcing jury recommendations, and affirming.
The Catholic Church's opposition to the death penalty places Catholic judges in a moral and legal bind.
While these judges are obliged by oath, professional commitment, and the demands of citizenship to
enforce the death penalty, they are also obliged to adhere to their church's teaching on moral matters.
Although the legal system has a solution for this dilemma by allowing the recusal of judges whose
convictions keep them from doing their job, Catholic judges will want to sit whenever possible without
acting immorally. However, litigants and the general public are entitled to impartial justice, which may
be something a judge who is heedful of ecclesiastical pronouncements cannot dispense. Therefore, the
authors argue, we need to know whether judges are legally disqualified from hearing cases that their
consciences would let them decide. While mere identification of a judge as Catholic is not sufficient reason
for recusal under federal law, the authors suggest that the moral impossibility of enforcing capital
punishment in such cases as sentencing, enforcing jury recommendations, and affirming are in fact
reasons for not participating.
https://scholarship.law.nd.edu/law_faculty_scholarship/527/
As for the Kingdom of God quote, what about it concerns you?
You should read this whole article:
https://pjmedia.com/news-and-politics/tyler-o-neil/2020/09/21/has-the-smear-campaign-against-amy-coney-barrett-already-begun-n948943
If nothing else, read this part of the articel:
Yet many conservatives — and even some pro-Biden political observers — rightly castigated Charles and others for attacking
Barrett’s faith. Barrett, who taught at Notre Dame Law School for 15 years and who is a practicing Roman Catholic, was merely
using a common term in Jewish and Christian circles, meant to reference doing justice and following God’s will in her work.
“I hate to break it to you, Ron, but all believing Jews and Christians think that our purpose is to build the kingdom of God,” Yoram
Hazony, an Orthodox Jew and president of the Herzl Institute in Jerusalem, tweeted in response to Charles.
Patrick Brennan, a former writer for National Review, noted that “All Christians devote their lives to building the Kingdom of God.”
“This kind of cheap, ignorant misinterpretation of Barrett saying she believes what Catholics believe — here, just that we must effect
justice and peace in this world — is a preview of things to come,” Brennan warned. [referring to the confirmation hearing and main stream
media attacks]
Andrew Figgy, a law school student who describes himself as a “left-conservative for Biden,” condemned the attacks on Barrett as
“ignorant and malicious.”
“We’re all called to build towards the Kingdom of God and that has nothing to do with ‘theocracy’. See: Romans 14:17, Matthew 6:33,
John 18:36,” Figgy tweeted.
The Kingdom of God is a central concept in Judaism and Christianity. Judaism established the idea that the awful power that created
the entire universe was also the giver of the moral law, the one who speaks through conscience. God chose Israel as His chosen people.
When the people of Israel asked for a king, God described Himself as offended — God Himself was their king, speaking through the
judges and the prophets.
The prophet Daniel envisioned a future in which the God of Heaven would establish a kingdom that would forever abide (Daniel 2:44).
The prophet Zechariah predicted that “the LORD will be king over all the earth. On that day the LORD will be one and his name one”
(Zechariah 14:9). The prophet Habakkuk, writing amid the oppression of the Babylonian Empire, predicted that empire’s fall, saying,
“for the earth will be filled with the knowledge of the glory of the LORD, as the waters cover the sea” (Habakkuk 2:14).
These Kingdom of God prophecies looked forward to a time when true justice would become the order of the day — when the God who
cares for the widow and the orphan would stand up for the weakest members of society and establish justice.
Have you ever been to Sunday School or studied the Bible in an academic classroom? If you had, you would not be making the comments you made. They appear to be from complete ignorance since you are taking her comments out of the context of religion vs. a theocracy.
-
Are their no female asian conservative judges? Why Asians always gotta be underrepresented?
Agreed, well in general, not just for judges. Hate crimes on Asians increased due to the Chyna Virus, but little media attention. Black dude who's acting a fool gets shot by a white guy and it's all over the news for weeks. But same could be said about black on black shootings.
-
Reputable private school and I got high 3's GPA.
. I'm an honor grad, but had easy ass classes. Band, weight training, art, and just enough math (no calculus) to get into UH.
-
. I'm an honor grad, but had easy ass classes. Band, weight training, art, and just enough math (no calculus) to get into UH.
Honors for Participation :rofl:
-
. I'm an honor grad, but had easy ass classes. Band, weight training, art, and just enough math (no calculus) to get into UH.
I cannot believe that you and omni both passed spelling in high school...
-
I cannot believe that you and omni both passed spelling in high school...
is this CMO in high school?
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=17BbnmG4CWg
-
Agreed, well in general, not just for judges. Hate crimes on Asians increased due to the Chyna Virus, but little media attention. Black dude who's acting a fool gets shot by a white guy and it's all over the news for weeks. But same could be said about black on black shootings.
The Reverend Martin Luther King, Jr. was unavailable for comment.
However, he has been quoted as saying:
"I have a dream that my four little children will one day live in a nation where they will not be judged by the color of their skin but by the content of their character."
-
Democrat Senators, who have a responsibility to the public to vet Supreme Court nominees, are refusing to meet with Amy Coney Barrett ahead of the confirmation hearings.
They don't care if she's qualified for the job of Supreme Court Justice or not. They only care about her political beliefs.
The Dems can't win elections every time, so they rely on "Liberal activists in robes" to make law when the House and Senate refuse to pass their SJW/Socialist/Leftist agenda..
https://youtu.be/4AQ60mMzD9Y
-
I'll just leave this here....inb4 fake news
https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2020/oct/01/amy-coney-barrett-supreme-court-roe-v-wade
-
I'll just leave this here....inb4 fake news
https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2020/oct/01/amy-coney-barrett-supreme-court-roe-v-wade
In a statement to the Guardian, the White House said: “As Judge Barrett said on the day she was nominated, ‘A judge must apply the law as written. Judges are not policymakers, and they must be resolute in setting aside any policy views they might hold.’”
The statement appears to reflect an acknowledgment that Barrett’s personal views on abortion could hurt her chances at confirmation.
First part is a statement. Assuming captured properly, is FACT.
Second part is an opinion. That latter part is what I hate about biased media these days, that weak minded folks will tend to remember and connect both as facts, when not true. At least not necessarily.
Yeah, I get that unbiased news is rare these days, but there are so many Americans that will just take what a "trusted source" reports as the truth. It's no different than the propaganda machines of countries that many Americans think we're above.
-
First part is a statement. Assuming captured properly, is FACT.
Second part is an opinion. That latter part is what I hate about biased media these days, that weak minded folks will tend to remember and connect both as facts, when not true. At least not necessarily.
Yeah, I get that unbiased news is rare these days, but there are so many Americans that will just take what a "trusted source" reports as the truth. It's no different than the propaganda machines of countries that many Americans think we're above.
True, I think the most important part of this article is the fact she signed off. All judgements should be based on that fact not the authors opinion.
-
Second part is an opinion. That latter part is what I hate about biased media these days, that weak minded folks will tend to remember and connect both as facts, when not true.
And there we have the description of the low information voter, or low-info types as i call them.
-
First part is a statement. Assuming captured properly, is FACT.
Second part is an opinion. That latter part is what I hate about biased media these days, that weak minded folks will tend to remember and connect both as facts, when not true. At least not necessarily.
Yeah, I get that unbiased news is rare these days, but there are so many Americans that will just take what a "trusted source" reports as the truth. It's no different than the propaganda machines of countries that many Americans think we're above.
The Second part is not just an opinion, it's a perfect example of SPIN.
The statement appears to reflect an acknowledgment that Barrett’s personal views on abortion could hurt her chances at confirmation.
"appears to reflect" tells you they are interpreting what she said. Their interpretation is wrong.
She was not acknowledging that her personal views on abortion could hurt her chances. That would mean she believes those views should / will be considered in her nomination process. Nothing in her statement comes close to saying this.
A judge must apply the law as written. Judges are not policymakers, and they must be resolute in setting aside any policy views they might hold.
To me, that looks like plain English. She's stating that ANY judge's personal views should not lead them to make policy. A judge should apply the law as written. Period.
In other words, she believes in leaving one's views on abortion at the door, and in deciding cases on the merits of the case, the Constitution, and the existing precedences.
Don't trust what she said. Listen to what I'm telling you she said. :wacko:
-
The Second part is not just an opinion, it's a perfect example of SPIN.
"appears to reflect" tells you they are interpreting what she said. Their interpretation is wrong.
She was not acknowledging that her personal views on abortion could hurt her chances. That would mean she believes those views should / will be considered in her nomination process. Nothing in her statement comes close to saying this.
To me, that looks like plain English. She's stating that ANY judge's personal views should not lead them to make policy. A judge should apply the law as written. Period.
In other words, she believes in leaving one's views on abortion at the door, and in deciding cases on the merits of the case, the Constitution, and the existing precedences.
Don't trust what she said. Listen to what I'm telling you she said. :wacko:
omni's reply will be:
"but, muh feelings..."
-
omni's reply will be:
"but, muh feelings..."
As he frantically pokes at his iFag for more arguerment talking points.
-
To me, that looks like plain English.
Of course, feelings and emotion are what matters to liberals, not clear speech or facts.
-
True, I think the most important part of this article is the fact she signed off. All judgements should be based on that fact not the authors opinion.
Tell that to RBG's supporters as it applies to her gun control agenda. She believed the 2nd Amendment was 100% relegated to the militia, and that the people, apart from serving in a militia, had no right to keep or bear arms. She said that the Heller decision was WRONG.
Never mind that pesky clause that says, "being necessary to the security of a free State." That's the part that says we need to be able to protect ourselves from tyranny, both foreign AND DOMESTIC. Logically, if only the state (militia) has the means to apply force, then the people are no longer free. "the right of the people to keep and bear Arms, shall not be infringed". The people, not the militia nor the state, has the RIGHT to keep and bear arms.
Yet, she applied her personal opinion on the 2nd Amendment to cases every chance she had.
I don't see Barrett coming close to this "shining example".
-
I love that everyone here conveniently ignores the one thing I pointed out and bandwagons the one thing I said was wrong...don't read the article for the author but just read it for the ONE FACT that she signed off on an anti abortion groups ad. Fuck the liberal author spin etc, I didn't link it because of the bias of all authors left or right. Facts dont lie. Please don't ignore them folks. Don't be a sheep.
-
Tell that to RBG's supporters as it applies to her gun control agenda. She believed the 2nd Amendment was 100% relegated to the militia, and that the people, apart from serving in a militia, had no right to keep or bear arms. She said that the Heller decision was WRONG.
Never mind that pesky clause that says, "being necessary to the security of a free State." That's the part that says we need to be able to protect ourselves from tyranny, both foreign AND DOMESTIC. Logically, if only the state (militia) has the means to apply force, then the people are no longer free. "the right of the people to keep and bear Arms, shall not be infringed". The people, not the militia nor the state, has the RIGHT to keep and bear arms.
Yet, she applied her personal opinion on the 2nd Amendment to cases every chance she had.
I don't see Barrett coming close to this "shining example".
Ummm are you assuming I support RBG? I don't and FYI I never did...not sure why you are trying to explain why she is bad on 2a. I already know that. I am focusing on the present, RBG is dead, end of story.
As he frantically pokes at his iFag for more arguerment talking points.
Also FYI rob, I use an android device. Might be a lil hard to keep up with the times. They are devices that came up after your flip phone.
-
I love that everyone here conveniently ignores the one thing I pointed out and bandwagons the one thing I said was wrong...don't read the article for the author but just read it for the ONE FACT that she signed off on an anti abortion groups ad. Fuck the liberal author spin etc, I didn't link it because of the bias of all authors left or right. Facts dont lie. Please don't ignore them folks. Don't be a sheep.
facts don't lie
"A judge must apply the law as written. Judges are not policymakers, and they must be resolute in setting aside any policy views they might hold."
-
facts don't lie
"A judge must apply the law as written. Judges are not policymakers, and they must be resolute in setting aside any policy views they might hold."
That's true, you seem to have a lot of faith in her ability to do this. I should expect she recuses herself from all abortion rights cases then? If she said that in public I would more than be ready to support her. She hasn't yet and that is my only worry.
-
That's true, you seem to have a lot of faith in her ability to do this. I should expect she recuses herself from all abortion rights cases then? If she said that in public I would more than be ready to support her. She hasn't yet and that is my only worry.
so how come you have no issue with jews and other catholics and other religions being on the supreme court and "possibly" having an issue with removing their personal beliefs from their rulings?
-
Ummm are you assuming I support RBG? I don't and FYI I never did...not sure why you are trying to explain why she is bad on 2a. I already know that. I am focusing on the present, RBG is dead, end of story.
That's your problem. I say one thing, and you try to read between the lines. Just like when we correct your mistakes, you interpret the comments to fit your response rather than address the points directly.
Did I ever, even once, say you supported RBG? Ever? No, I did not. I used her obvious bias and how her rulings in those related cases obviously indicated bias. She never met a gun control law she didn't like. When she sat down on that bench with the fervent understanding that Heller was decided wrongly, and that the 2nd Amendment does not protect an individual right, then her rulings can be criticized as being tainted by her personal beliefs.
Amy Coney Barrett, while also being allowed to have her personal beliefs, has given no one cause to think her beliefs have influenced any of her decisions.
That's the difference. You take what I said about RBG personally, even though I was using her history as a parallel to Barrett's.
Stop reading into these posts what you want to see. If you aren't sure, ask. It's called "communication".
-
That's true, you seem to have a lot of faith in her ability to do this. I should expect she recuses herself from all abortion rights cases then? If she said that in public I would more than be ready to support her. She hasn't yet and that is my only worry.
this doesn't mean she has to recuse herself
she has stated that she will only rule on the law
-
facts don't lie
"A judge must apply the law as written. Judges are not policymakers, and they must be resolute in setting aside any policy views they might hold."
so how come you have no issue with jews and other catholics and other religions being on the supreme court and "possibly" having an issue with removing their personal beliefs from their rulings?
And round, and round he goes. . .
Again, totally missing the point
-
this doesn't mean she has to recuse herself
she has stated that she will only rule on the law
So if someone is biased you think they can magically remove all bias and rule with no bias? Then why would anyone ever recuse themselves?
-
Judges are not policymakers,
Seem to be an awful lot of activist "judges" that disagree with you.
Liberals have made judge-shopping into an art to force their agenda on us.
-
so how come you have no issue with jews and other catholics and other religions being on the supreme court and "possibly" having an issue with removing their personal beliefs from their rulings?
Unfortunately I have had no opportunity to have a say in who got picked, this is the first justice I have extensively looked at because her opinions can change a major law and swing the court. I don't believe any religion should be grounds of judgement, unless it induces marketable bias. We can prove to some degree of factual bias on certain views because of her religion. If she can prove they will not affect her decisions by recusing herself then she won't have bias. So far she has not.
-
Seem to be an awful lot of activist "judges" that disagree with you.
Liberals have made judge-shopping into an art to force their agenda on us.
Yeah all those activists trying to force their ideals of abortion and death penalty on people...I wonder who.
Swings both ways. I think liberal activism is just as bad, but I refuse to turn a blind eye to the right. You must judge both sides. Else you are just a blind opposite liberal. You are what you hate.
-
That's your problem. I say one thing, and you try to read between the lines. Just like when we correct your mistakes, you interpret the comments to fit your response rather than address the points directly.
Did I ever, even once, say you supported RBG? Ever? No, I did not. I used her obvious bias and how her rulings in those related cases obviously indicated bias. She never met a gun control law she didn't like. When she sat down on that bench with the fervent understanding that Heller was decided wrongly, and that the 2nd Amendment does not protect an individual right, then her rulings can be criticized as being tainted by her personal beliefs.
Amy Coney Barrett, while also being allowed to have her personal beliefs, has given no one cause to think her beliefs have influenced any of her decisions.
That's the difference. You take what I said about RBG personally, even though I was using her history as a parallel to Barrett's.
Stop reading into these posts what you want to see. If you aren't sure, ask. It's called "communication".
You are trying to connect dots that don't exist. Her belief on the second amendment has nothing to do with religion...All judges have personal opinions on laws. That's literally every single judge. But i feel those that have certain views because of a religion and can be influenced by a 3rd party (pope pastor etc) should be judged more thoroughly to be absolutely sure it does not affect their rulings on laws.
Interesting thing that I found when looking things up:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Treaty_of_Tripoli#Article_11
-
Aicarumba
-
So if someone is biased you think they can magically remove all bias and rule with no bias? Then why would anyone ever recuse themselves?
What justice on SCOTUS isn't "biased"? That have all made public and published statements demonstrating preferred views on a whole variety of subject matters. If having a pre-existing value or preference is disqualifying, all the justices would have to recuse themselves from almost all cases before the court.
You're argument that "religious" values somehow deserve more scrutiny than "secular" values is vacuous.
-
You are trying to connect dots that don't exist. Her belief on the second amendment has nothing to do with religion...All judges have personal opinions on laws. That's literally every single judge. But i feel those that have certain views because of a religion and can be influenced by a 3rd party (pope pastor etc) should be judged more thoroughly to be absolutely sure it does not affect their rulings on laws.
Interesting thing that I found when looking things up:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Treaty_of_Tripoli#Article_11
bingo!
https://2ahawaii.com/index.php?topic=38106.msg340169#msg340169
-
Unfortunately I have had no opportunity to have a say in who got picked, this is the first justice I have extensively looked at because her opinions can change a major law and swing the court. I don't believe any religion should be grounds of judgement, unless it induces marketable bias. We can prove to some degree of factual bias on certain views because of her religion. If she can prove they will not affect her decisions by recusing herself then she won't have bias. So far she has not.
How did you come to the conclusion that you will have any say in whether or not THIS judge "gets picked"?
This is not American Idol. You don't get to vote for your favorite nominees.
We have a Hawaii delegation in the Senate who will be voting "No" for confirmation. If all you want is your "say", then wish granted!! Without any particular reason (other than ORANGE MAN BAD and NOT MUH LIBTARD ACTIVIST PICK), our elected Senators will be fighting to prevent confirmation REGARDLESS of any religion, perception of bias, or fitness to serve on the court.
Nothing you say or do will change the predicted outcome. She will get confirmed, and you will get your vote against her via our partisan Senators.
Enjoy! :geekdanc: :popcorn:
-
Technically, any decision that has a dissenting opinion is biased. Both in decision and dissent.
That’s why there are nine Justices.
-
Technically, any decision that has a dissenting opinion is biased. Both in decision and dissent.
That’s why there are nine Justices.
Why is a dissent technically biased? If one is ruling based on the law, why is it necessarily biased?
For me, there’s business/work and personal. Sure what’s personal can shape how I do business/work, but I often have to put my personal biases aside and do what is best for the work/business context. Am I fair? I’d like to think so, that I can do my job without personal bias.
-
Never mind that pesky clause that says, "being necessary to the security of a free State." That's the part that says we need to be able to protect ourselves from tyranny, both foreign AND DOMESTIC.
Is that what it says?
Seems like your inflecting your opinion on it.
Seems like in the time it was written it could be that we would not be ruled by a King, particularly of any foreign country.
Aren’t term limits against a free state ? Why can’t we vote for whoever for forever if we wan’t?
“ A well regulated Militia, being necessary to the security of a free State, the right of the people to keep and bear Arms, shall not be infringed.”
The Supreme Court did choose the version with the commas though in Heller v.
Thank goodness.
-
Why is a dissent technically biased? If one is ruling based on the law, why is it necessarily biased?
For me, there’s business/work and personal. Sure what’s personal can shape how I do business/work, but I often have to put my personal biases aside and do what is best for the work/business context. Am I fair? I’d like to think so, that I can do my job without personal bias.
2 sides read the same law and intent and precedence totally differently.
That’s dissent. (Hence dissenting opinion. )
What lenses are they looking through ? Bias ?
If it was totally unbiased, and fair, why would we care who the next Justice is or who selects them ?
But we do.
-
2 sides read the same law and intent and precedence totally differently.
That’s dissent. (Hence dissenting opinion. )
What lenses are they looking through ? Bias ?
Different interpretation of the law. I often have to discuss code with other engineers and we often read the same words differently. Why does that have to be bias? Just different ways of reading, understanding, etc the same words.
One would hope a lens of logic and common sense. Not after a few "teas". . .
-
2 sides read the same law and intent and precedence totally differently.
That’s dissent. (Hence dissenting opinion. )
What lenses are they looking through ? Bias ?
If it was totally unbiased, and fair, why would we care who the next Justice is or who selects them ?
But we do.
Yeah, got it. I'm not saying bias CAN'T influence the decision. The whole point of the convo we've been having is that it doesn't HAVE to. That IF there is someone of principle, they could rule without letting their personal bias impact their professional. At least that's my point.
-
Is that what it says?
Seems like your inflecting your opinion on it.
Seems like in the time it was written it could be that we would not be ruled by a King, particularly of any foreign country.
Aren’t term limits against a free state ? Why can’t we vote for whoever for forever if we wan’t?
“ A well regulated Militia, being necessary to the security of a free State, the right of the people to keep and bear Arms, shall not be infringed.”
The Supreme Court did choose the version with the commas though in Heller v.
Thank goodness.
Do you disagree with "my opinion?" If so, you should just say so instead of trolling my post.
"INFLECTING YOUR OWN OPINION?"
LOL! I was typing in monotone. No inflection at all. :rofl: :rofl: :rofl:
This is "my opinion:"
Let a regular army, fully equal to the resources of the country, be formed; and let it be entirely at the devotion of the federal government;
still it would not be going too far to say, that the state governments, with the people on their side, would be able to repel the danger. The
highest number to which, according to the best computation, a standing army can be carried in any country, does not exceed one hundredth
part of the whole number of souls; or one twenty-fifth part of the number able to bear arms. This proportion would not yield, in the
United States, an army of more than twenty-five or thirty thousand men. To these would be opposed a militia amounting to near half a million
of citizens with arms in their hands, officered by men chosen from among themselves, fighting for their common liberties, and united and
conducted by governments possessing their affections and confidence. It may well be doubted, whether a militia thus circumstanced could
ever be conquered by such a proportion of regular troops. Those who are best acquainted with the last successful resistance of this country
against the British arms, will be most inclined to deny the possibility of it. Besides the advantage of being armed, which the Americans possess
over the people of almost every other nation, the existence of subordinate governments, to which the people are attached, and by which the
militia officers are appointed, forms a barrier against the enterprises of ambition, more insurmountable than any which a simple government
of any form can admit of. Notwithstanding the military establishments in the several kingdoms of Europe, which are carried as far as the public
resources will bear, the governments are afraid to trust the people with arms. And it is not certain, that with this aid alone they would not be able to
shake off their yokes. But were the people to possess the additional advantages of local governments chosen by themselves, who could collect the
national will and direct the national force, and of officers appointed out of the militia, by these governments, and attached both to them and to the militia,
it may be affirmed with the greatest assurance, that the throne of every tyranny in Europe would be speedily overturned in spite of the legions which
surround it.
-- James Madison
The Federalist, No. 46
January 29, 1788
https://avalon.law.yale.edu/18th_century/fed46.asp
In short, this is not MY opinion. I simply agree with the person who wrote this. Coincidentally, he was also one of the framers of the Constitution and the Bill of Rights.
-
So what makes the court Conservative or Liberal?
How people read the same words differently?
Why one way or the other?
What leans them?
What leans engineers to it is It to code or not?
Legal or we can get away with it and have a plausible argument?
(Code is pretty specific but hard to decipher)
One would hope a lens of logic and common sense. Not after a few "teas". . .
Unfortunately that’s not the case here on either side. Even without “tea”.
I hope I’ve applied both.
Is she 2A or not 2A, that is the question.
-
against the British arms, will be most inclined to deny the possibility of it. Besides the advantage of being armed, which the Americans possess
over the people of almost every other nation, the existence of subordinate governments, to which the people are attached, and by which the
militia officers are appointed, forms a barrier against the enterprises of ambition, more insurmountable than any which a simple government
of any form can admit of. Notwithstanding the military establishments in the several kingdoms of Europe, which are carried as far as the public
resources will bear, the governments are afraid to trust the people with arms. And it is not certain, that with this aid alone they would not be able to
shake off their yokes. But were the people to possess the additional advantages of local governments chosen by themselves, who could collect the
national will and direct the national force, and of officers appointed out of the militia, by these governments, and attached both to them and to the militia,
it may be affirmed with the greatest assurance, that the throne of every tyranny in Europe would be speedily overturned in spite of the legions which
surround it.
-- James Madison
The Federalist, No. 46
January 29, 1788
That’s funny.
Federalist Papers and just proved my point.
Thank you. :geekdanc:
America already took away our right bear arms in that context when we couldn’t acquire Apache helicopters, tanks, killer drones, automatic weapons, RPGs .........
-
So what makes the court Conservative or Liberal?
1) How people read the same words differently?
Why one way or the other?
What leans them?
2) What leans engineers to it is It to code or not?
Legal or we can get away with it and have a plausible argument?
(Code is pretty specific but hard to decipher)
Unfortunately that’s not the case here on either side. Even without “tea”.
I hope I’ve applied both.
3) Is she 2A or not 2A, that is the question.
1) How do people read the same words differently? I mean they read the same words, but the meaning they take away from the same words can be very different. I can tell you 100% in my heart that religion does NOT lean my professional decisions. Can others? I would think so. I just am not so quick to judge and dismiss based on my feewings. . .
2) The code I am referring to often times is legal language. Some codes become legal requirements, some remain recommendations. Not sure what you are getting at WRT plausible argument. My point was that engineers often apply judgement to words in code and how to interpret. It's not an issue if it's to code or not. The issue usually is how a designer goes about trying to meet the code. See, stuff like building code and such intentionally leaves certain areas up to interpretation and the expectation is that licensed engineers have the discipline to apply proper judgement. While not lofty status, I don't consider SCOTUS that different.
3) Now that, is important. :thumbsup:
-
So what makes the court Conservative or Liberal?
How people read the same words differently?
Why one way or the other?
What leans them?
What leans engineers to it is It to code or not?
Legal or we can get away with it and have a plausible argument?
(Code is pretty specific but hard to decipher)
Unfortunately that’s not the case here on either side. Even without “tea”.
I hope I’ve applied both.
Is she 2A or not 2A, that is the question.
If you have to ask, you're already part of the Liberal low-information sheep-force.
The Legislature creates laws. The Constitution is where the laws derive their validity.
The court is to decide cases in which laws are made in opposition of the Constitution, where a question of Constitutionality in enforcement needs settling, and where appeals from lower court rulings need a hearing.
You are calling the judges/the court "Liberal" or "Conservative." That's inaccurate.
The court is not a person, and therefore is not partisan. The individual justices who seek to interpret laws in order to push an activist agenda, especially in areas where the Congress has failed to pass laws regarding these very issues, are the issue.
To that point, it's more often the case that the Liberals are unable to get their Social Justice, Progressive, Socialist agenda passed in Congress. They therefore turned to the SCOTUS to rule in ways that give them what they wanted. There's a reason there was no federal law making abortion legal in all states ahead of Roe v Wade. The Congress members knew that was an issue the individual states must decide for themselves because there's no legal basis for putting the issue in federal jurisdiction.
The Liberal Activist Judges then hammered the issue of abortion into the Constitution using very flimsy and loose interpretations of what "privacy" meant according the the Bill of Rights.
Non-Activist judges, Conservative or Liberal, would have maintained the issue as a state's right to regulate.
-
That’s funny.
Federalist Papers and just proved my point.
Thank you. :geekdanc:
America already took away our right bear arms in that context when we couldn’t acquire Apache helicopters, tanks, killer drones, automatic weapons, RPGs .........
Explain that conclusion ....
If you can.
Who said civilians can't own those weapons systems?
https://youtu.be/jVs5kgvA_Ow
-
If you have to ask, you're already part of the Liberal low-information sheep-force.
You are calling the judges/the court "Liberal" or "Conservative." That's inaccurate.
The court is not a person, and therefore is not partisan.
The Liberal Activist Judges then hammered the issue of abortion into the Constitution using very flimsy and loose interpretations of what "privacy" meant according the the Bill of Rights.
Non-Activist judges, Conservative or Liberal, would have maintained the issue as a state's right to regulate.
OK Biden.
The Green energy bill will fund fund itself but I am not for it.
The court is not partisan but activist judges are, so not activist judges then ...but ......But the Supreme Court passed it....but they are not partisan.....
How many sides of your mouth can you talk out of ?
Explain that conclusion ....
If you can.
Who said civilians can't own those weapons systems?
Full auto. Can if you can cash in a free state.
Does Arnold’s shoot live rounds? (I don’t know)
What about all the other weapons systems you neglect to mention along with fighter jets and ordnance.
-
OK Biden.
The Green energy bill will fund fund itself but I am not for it.
The court is not partisan but activist judges are, so not activist judges then ...but ......But the Supreme Court passed it....but they are not partisan.....
How many sides of your mouth can you talk out of ?
Did you not notice the difference between "partisan" and "Liberal Activist Judges?"
I can't teach you English and reading comprehension, but I can call you out when you fail. Maybe you'll start trying harder.
-
Explain that conclusion ....
If you can.
Who said civilians can't own those weapons systems?
Ah, the hoary old "tanks and bazookas" routine, right out of the decades ole Handgun Control "how to debate gun nuts" handbook.
I hope no one has any lingering illusions what the several liberal trolls are about. It is not a common commitment to defending the 2A and rejecting government overreach.
-
Ah, the hoary old "tanks and bazookas" routine, right out of the decades ole Handgun Control "how to debate gun nuts" handbook.
I hope no one has any lingering illusions what the several liberal trolls are about. It is not a common commitment to defending the 2A and rejecting government overreach.
I think it's pure ignorance. He likes guns for himself, but he never bothered to learn why the right is important, nor what the right actually protects.
He's been in Hawaii too long, believing whatever the state and Democrats told him. Hopefully we're getting through to him. The 2A is about tyranny. It's not about hunting or target practice, or even concealed carry. Every gun control law that requires a citizen or legal resident to ask permission to exercise their rights gives the government more power and control should a need to fight tyranny at home ever manifest itself.
-
Did you not notice the difference between "partisan" and "Liberal Activist Judges?"
I can't teach you English and reading comprehension, but I can call you out when you fail. Maybe you'll start trying harder.
So how did Roe v.Wade get passed ?
Liberal Activist Judges on the Supreme Court? ( Totally different from Partisan.)
You still on technical discombobulation do distract people ?
You must have been an English major ( if you went to college) as you’re always on this grammar and comprehension crap.
-
I think it's pure ignorance. He likes guns for himself, but he never bothered to learn why the right is important, nor what the right actually protects.
He's been in Hawaii too long, believing whatever the state and Democrats told him. Hopefully we're getting through to him. The 2A is about tyranny. It's not about hunting or target practice, or even concealed carry. Every gun control law that requires a citizen or legal resident to ask permission to exercise their rights gives the government more power and control should a need to fight tyranny at home ever manifest itself.
I totally get what the 2A is about.
And my posts support that.
As have my actions. (More than I can say for you Flapp.)
But you keep posting stuff that pokes holes In it.
I’m just reluctantly pointing that out.
You say stupid stuff and have no reply’s to rebuttals and that’s dangerous for our 2A community
P.S. RobDmc unfortunately can’t see this because he censored me. :wave:
-
So how did Roe v.Wade get passed ?
Liberal Activist Judges on the Supreme Court? ( Totally different from Partisan.)
You still on technical discombobulation do distract people ?
You must have been an English major ( if you went to college) as you’re always on this grammar and comprehension crap.
You must have been at the beach during 12 years of English class. So far, you've provided little evidence to the contrary. :wacko:
I'm not about to waste hours posting links to the massive volume of scholarly writings and legal opinions re: Roe v Wade.
Even the woman who was "Roe" said she wished the Supreme Court had never ruled in her favor.
Norma McCorvey, the plaintiff in the case that legalized abortion for women, has confessed in innumerable interviews and
speaking events that she never had an abortion and that her pregnancy was not a product of rape as she had claimed in the
case. The then mother of two gave her third child the gift of adoption.
“McCorvey had made one trip to an illegal abortion clinic in Dallas that had been shut down. But now, McCorvey says she
wouldn’t have had an abortion, anyway, because she was too far along in her pregnancy. “I can honestly say no, I wouldn’t
have,” she said.
Norma McCorvey wrote in her first book, I Am Roe, that she in fact was not pregnant by rape like she had first said. That was a
lie. She said she had invented the rape story in an attempt to make a stronger case for an abortion.
In 1995, Norma McCorvey declared herself pro-life.
Norma McCorvey publicly committed her life to ‘serving the Lord and helping women save babies.’ She accepted a new job at
Operation Rescue as a computer operator and was welcomed into the pro-life community. Since that time, McCorvey published
“Won By Love” in January of 2003, sharing her true story and accounts of changing her position from pro-choice to pro-life.
In short, Lawyers who lied and activist judges who wanted to legislate from the bench as the House and Senate had been Constitutionally constrained is how the law passed.
https://www.liveaction.org/news/7-things-didnt-know-jane-roe-roe-v-wade/
https://nypost.com/2018/07/06/why-roe-v-wade-is-a-travesty-of-constitutional-law/
-
1) How do people read the same words differently? I mean they read the same words, but the meaning they take away from the same words can be very different. I can tell you 100% in my heart that religion does NOT lean my professional decisions. Can others? I would think so. I just am not so quick to judge and dismiss based on my feewings. . .
2) The code I am referring to often times is legal language. Some codes become legal requirements, some remain recommendations. Not sure what you are getting at WRT plausible argument. My point was that engineers often apply judgement to words in code and how to interpret. It's not an issue if it's to code or not. The issue usually is how a designer goes about trying to meet the code. See, stuff like building code and such intentionally leaves certain areas up to interpretation and the expectation is that licensed engineers have the discipline to apply proper judgement. While not lofty status, I don't consider SCOTUS that different.
3) Now that, is important. :thumbsup:
Your Boss/job instructs you to engineer a better abortion machine would you? So that women can more easily access their right to abort. Nothing legally is stopping you fyi. With your religious conviction (I assume its against abortion) would you do your job?
-
Explain that conclusion ....
If you can.
Who said civilians can't own those weapons systems?
https://youtu.be/jVs5kgvA_Ow
Can we buy nerve gas or nukes?
-
I totally get what the 2A is about.
And my posts support that.
As have my actions. (More than I can say for you Flapp.)
But you keep posting stuff that pokes holes In it.
I’m just reluctantly pointing that out.
You say stupid stuff and have no reply’s to rebuttals and that’s dangerous for our 2A community
P.S. RobDmc unfortunately can’t see this because he censored me. :wave:
Flapp is just used to being a trump, screaming at someone else on why hes always right and everything is how he thinks it is. Then gas lighting anyone who disagrees.
-
Can we buy nerve gas or nukes?
Look up the definition of arms as they relate to the 2nd amendment.
Nerve gas is illegal internationally. It is a weapon that falls under the category of Chemical Weapons.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chemical_Weapons_Convention
The Chemical Weapons Convention (CWC) is an arms control treaty that outlaws the production, stockpiling, and use of chemical weapons and their precursors. The full name of the treaty is the Convention on the Prohibition of the Development, Production, Stockpiling and Use of Chemical Weapons and on their Destruction and it is administered by the Organisation for the Prohibition of Chemical Weapons (OPCW), an intergovernmental organization based in The Hague, The Netherlands. The treaty entered into force on 29 April 1997. The Chemical Weapons Convention prohibits the large-scale use, development, production, stockpiling and transfer of chemical weapons. Very limited production for research, medical, pharmaceutical or protective purposes is still permitted. The main obligation of member states under the convention is to effect this prohibition, as well as the destruction of all current chemical weapons. All destruction activities must take place under OPCW verification.
As of May 2018, 193 states have become parties to the CWC and accept its obligations. Israel has signed but not ratified the agreement, while three other UN member states (Egypt, North Korea and South Sudan) have neither signed nor acceded to the treaty.[1][5] Most recently, the State of Palestine deposited its instrument of accession to the CWC on 17 May 2018. In September 2013 Syria acceded to the convention as part of an agreement for the destruction of Syria's chemical weapons.[6][7]
As of November 2018, 96.62% of the world's declared chemical weapons stockpiles had been destroyed.[8] The convention has provisions for systematic evaluation of chemical production facilities, as well as for investigations of allegations of use and production of chemical weapons based on intelligence of other state parties.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chemical_Weapons_Convention
Nuclear, chemical and biological weapons are classes of WEAPONS OF MASS DESTRUCTION. They have no legitimate tactical purpose other than to wipe out everyone in an area indiscriminately -- combatants and noncombatants alike.
Arms, according to recent court rulings include that which a modern military infantryman might carry into battle.
In the 1939 case U.S. v. Miller, the Supreme Court held that the Second Amendment protected those arms that would be useful to a citizen’s militia in a military engagement. The court held that the Second Amendment did not protect short-barrelled shotguns, but the decision seems to imply that machineguns, rocket launchers and antitank rifles would be protected.
U.S. v. Heller redefined the meaning of “arms” in the Second Amendment. The decision held that the Second Amendment protected all firearms “commonly is use,” but not those that were “dangerous or unusual” without defining those terms.
In U.S. v. McDonald, the Supreme Court subsequently held that the Second Amendment was a Fundamental Right and was incorporated onto the states by the 14th Amendment.
https://www.quora.com/Is-the-word-arms-in-the-Second-Amendment-defined-somewhere?share=1
You would not carry ("keep and bear") WMDs. They normally require a delivery and dispersal system, meaning the target is far enough away from you, you have options available with which you can defend and protect yourself.
-
Flapp is just used to being a trump, screaming at someone else on why hes always right and everything is how he thinks it is. Then gas lighting anyone who disagrees.
And you have no idea what you're talking about.
Ever.
-
If you had to engineer a better abortion machine would you? Nothing legally is stopping you fyi.
Are you attempting to make a connection to support your argument on ACB? Not even close to being analogy worthy btw.
To answer your question, no I would not. First, no such thing. Second, there are other things to guide one’s actions than the legality of something. Third, my religious beliefs would have zero impact on my decision.
Nice try WLB...
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
-
Are you attempting to make a connection to support your argument on ACB? Not even close to being analogy worthy btw.
To answer your question, no I would not. First, no such thing. Second, there are other things to guide one’s actions than the legality of something. Third, my religious beliefs would have zero impact on my decision.
Nice try WLB...
:rofl: :rofl: :rofl:
I wonder if Google will offer him a clue on that one? :popcorn:
-
Your Boss/job instructs you to engineer a better abortion machine would you? So that women can more easily access their right to abort. Nothing legally is stopping you fyi. With your religious conviction (I assume its against abortion) would you do your job?
You assume? Bwahahahaha
:facepalm:
I am against people who approach life like they know it all from a position of ignorance.
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
-
Flapp is just used to being a trump, screaming at someone else on why hes always right and everything is how he thinks it is. Then gas lighting anyone who disagrees.
It's not that I'm always right.
It's just that you and AssHole are always WRONG!
This is not about opinions, and how you have some right to your own -- no matter how stupid and illogical it is.
It's about you being able to make your case without resorting to whining, insults and statements totally void of substance.
You have beliefs, pure and simple. Without facts and supportive information, you're no better than a blind follower of a cult religion.
'Nother glass o' KoolAid, Brother?
(https://i.imgur.com/T3xLksL.jpg?2)
-
It's just that you and AssHole are always WRONG!
Yeah, about time to add to my ignore list.
You have beliefs, pure and simple. Without facts and supportive information, you're no better than a blind follower of a cult religion.
I'm sure all his facef*ck and twit groups, or whatever it is they do all day on their iFags, are fully supportive and give helpful suggestions how to fight those evil conservatives.
-
You assume? Bwahahahaha
:facepalm:
I am against people who approach life like they know it all from a position of ignorance.
Are you attempting to make a connection to support your argument on ACB? Not even close to being analogy worthy btw.
To answer your question, no I would not. First, no such thing. Second, there are other things to guide one’s actions than the legality of something. Third, my religious beliefs would have zero impact on my decision.
Nice try WLB...
Wait....why does it not apply? I work with computers if my boss wanted me to program a machine that does [insert] with abortion, because I have no religious commandments stopping me I don't see why I would not listen and do that program. You literally spelt out religious bias. Just does it magically not apply for judges?
I don't pretend to know everything but I also don't shove my head into a hole like ostrich and blindly follow. I try think objectively from both sides. Even if that side is one I don't agree with. I am only human in the end though, I make mistakes.
-
Wait....why does it not apply? I work with computers if my boss wanted me to program a machine that does [insert] with abortion, because I have no religious commandments stopping me I don't see why I would not listen and do that program. You literally spelt out religious bias. Just does it magically not apply for judges?
I don't pretend to know everything but I also don't shove my head into a hole like ostrich and blindly follow. I try think objectively from both sides. Even if that side is one I don't agree with. I am only human in the end though, I make mistakes.
The difference, since you need to have it pointed out, is that you have a choice. You can ask the boss to assign that project to someone else, You can look for other employment. Or you can do as instructed.
Free will.
There's nothing magic about someone taking a commitment (Oath of Office, wedding vows, and so on) seriously. As a judge, her oath comes before her personal beliefs. I'm sure most times there is no conflict. Only in cases where she might have to consider murdering a human being would it likely ever be an issue.
To believe that she is incapable of executing the duties of her office without conflict tells me that you've never made a commitment to anyone or anything that you value above your own hedonistic desires and beliefs.
Not everyone is like you. Liberals always tend to think we are all the same.
"We need to ban all guns. I know I can't be trusted with one, especially knowing how uncontrollably pissed I get from road rage. Also, I really don't like guns enough to take the time I'd need to become a safe gun owner.
if I can't be trusted, then it's logical that everyone else can't be trusted, either.."
I believe the clinical term is "projection."
p.s. You literally "spelt" "spelled" wrong. "Spelt" is a type of wheat.
-
Wait....why does it not apply? I work with computers if my boss wanted me to program a machine that does [insert] with abortion, because I have no religious commandments stopping me I don't see why I would not listen and do that program. You literally spelt out religious bias. Just does it magically not apply for judges?
I don't pretend to know everything but I also don't shove my head into a hole like ostrich and blindly follow. I try think objectively from both sides. Even if that side is one I don't agree with. I am only human in the end though, I make mistakes.
Did
I
Say
It
Does
Not
Apply?
Damn...
-
Are you attempting to make a connection to support your argument on ACB? Not even close to being analogy worthy btw.
To answer your question, no I would not. First, no such thing. Second, there are other things to guide one’s actions than the legality of something. Third, my religious beliefs would have zero impact on my decision.
Nice try WLB...
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
Did
I
Say
It
Does
Not
Apply?
Damn...
-
WTF
Are
You
Effing
Serious
Your
Effing
Emotional
Biased
Is effed
-
Can someone talk some sense into this millennial emeffer?
-
I
Still
Did
Not
Say
That
It
Allied?
You
ASSUMED
it
Applied
There’s
A
Difference
-
Can someone talk some sense into this millennial emeffer?
"Never argue with an idiot. He'll drag you down to his level and then beat you with experience."
I've hit that point of diminishing returns in which the challenge and fun of an academic exchange starts to suck the life out of you as the effort turns one-sided.
At this stage, the only solution I can recommend is a reading list from sources that don't teach Activist Journalism, Social Justice Warrior or "Peaceful Protestor" as career choices.
-
I apologize that's its come to this. I guess in the end i am pro abortion and you are all anti. We will never come to see eye to eye. This judge threatens my values and views on freedom so I can't fully support her. She supports your values so you can. Everyone keeps blaming emotion, but we are all human and powered by them. I sincerely hope you are all correct and she will faithfully do her job with no bias. I have no power to change her not getting in the job. All I have is a way to vent my concerns to you all. Sorry it's gotten to this level. I just really value freedom. Thanks for listening and I hope everyone the best.
-
I apologize that's its come to this. I guess in the end i am pro abortion and you are all anti. We will never come to see eye to eye. This judge threatens my values and views on freedom so I can't fully support her. She supports your values so you can. Everyone keeps blaming emotion, but we are all human and powered by them. I sincerely hope you are all correct and she will faithfully do her job with no bias. I have no power to change her not getting in the job. All I have is a way to vent my concerns to you all. Sorry it's gotten to this level. I just really value freedom. Thanks for listening and I hope everyone the best.
You just pinpointed one of the reasons you are unable to have a productive discussion on this topic.
Your label of "Pro-Abortion" tells me you think that is an acceptable form of birth control, and it should be not just available and legal, but PROVIDED ON DEMAND WITHOUT ANY CONDITIONS AND AT INSURANCE OR TAX PAYER EXPENSE.
The more PC position for your belief is called Pro-Choice". But most on that side, just like you, don't discuss any other choices. You think abortion is the best, often the only, answer.
Likewise, your label of "Anti-Abortion" is not accurate for the opposing side. It's called "Pro-Life".
I think every decision related to an unwanted pregnancy is difficult, but if you think life has value and meaning, then you'll consider options (CHOICES) which preserve life -- that of the child and that of the mother.
In rare, extreme circumstances (rape, incest, actual threat to the mother's life), abortion is not only a valid choice, but it may be the best choice. That's far from "Anti-Abortion." But what's happening now is nowhere near "safe, legal and rare," as the Left once chanted when marching for Roe v Wade.
PP doesn't provide "Planning" services for "Parents." Their organization's name is a true oxymoron. Planning implies "before action is taken."
PP, in that same context, does not believe in CHOICE. They don't have a 100,000 person staff of lawyers and legal secretaries assisting patients with adoptions. Instead, they use the vast majority of their revenue to perform thousands upon thousands of abortions. If they offered adoption services, post-birth motherhood classes and family support services, maybe you could call them Pro-Choice." In reality, Planned Parenthood is exactly like you: "Pro-Abortion."
-
You just pinpointed one of the reasons you are unable to have a productive discussion on this topic.
Your label of "Pro-Abortion" tells me you think that is an acceptable form of birth control, and it should be not just available and legal, but PROVIDED ON DEMAND WITHOUT ANY CONDITIONS AND AT INSURANCE OR TAX PAYER EXPENSE.
Yes it should be available and legal, without conditions. Only thing I wont say is tax payer expense.
The more PC position for your belief is called Pro-Choice". But most on that side, just like you, don't discuss any other choices. You think abortion is the best, often the only, answer.
It is up to the PERSON to decide what they want to do. Your or myself should have NO say in what they decide.
Likewise, your label of "Anti-Abortion" is not accurate for the opposing side. It's called "Pro-Life".
If you want I can call it pro-life its the same thing
I think every decision related to an unwanted pregnancy is difficult, but if you think life has value and meaning, then you'll consider options (CHOICES) which preserve life -- that of the child and that of the mother.
You or me should have NO say to judge someone's choices. It is up to them to choose if they want to "preserve life" or not. It is their freedom
In rare, extreme circumstances (rape, incest, actual threat to the mother's life), abortion is not only a valid choice, but it may be the best choice. That's far from "Anti-Abortion." But what's happening now is nowhere near "safe, legal and rare," as the Left once chanted when marching for Roe v Wade.
Like I keep saying we have no right to dictate someone elses decisions on whats best for them its their freedom to decide on their own. IDK what you are talking about. Abortion now is incredibly safe, I know people who have had them.
PP doesn't provide "Planning" services for "Parents." Their organization's name is a true oxymoron. Planning implies "before action is taken."
What? Planning for parenthood includes not deciding to be a parent...
PP, in that same context, does not believe in CHOICE. They don't have a 100,000 person staff of lawyers and legal secretaries assisting patients with adoptions. Instead, they use the vast majority of their revenue to perform thousands upon thousands of abortions. If they offered adoption services, post-birth motherhood classes and family support services, maybe you could call them Pro-Choice." In reality, Planned Parenthood is exactly like you: "Pro-Abortion."
I see absolutely nothing wrong with that. Even if you think PP is an abortion machine if you don't believe in them DONT FUCKING GO. No one is forcing you to use their services. If they are pro abortion I could give any shits less. Don't fund them with taxes so people like you can stop hating on them. Even if you don't believe anything I said like how I used their services for STD testing etc and I didn't get an abortion. Sexual health is important but I guess if more people are like you they wouldn't have to worry about that :rofl: If you want less abortions you should support PP, I've had ex's get birth control through them that prevented pregnancies. STD testing to prevent spreading diseases. But according to you that's probably all fake news all they do is abortions, probably invented some sort of male abortion.
-
What? Planning for parenthood includes not deciding to be a parent...
Thanks for illustrating in bright, shiny letters what an "oxymoron" is.
You can't plan for parenthood when you decided to not be a parent. Parenthood doesn't exist without a parent.
Definition of parenthood
: the state of being a parent
specifically : the position, function, or standing of a parent
You know how to use Google. Now look up the definition of "parent."
Oh, hell...... might as well lead you to yet another lake ....
Definition of parent (Entry 1 of 2)
1a: one that begets or brings forth offspring
just became parents of twins
b: a person who brings up and cares for another
foster parents
2a: an animal or plant that is regarded in relation to its offspring
The parent brings food to the chicks.
According to YOU, anyone contemplating abortion is a parent. By definition, they have children/offspring. That means abortion is killing that child/offspring, otherwise the term "parent" can't apply.
No definiton of "parent" I can find includes "clump of cells". :geekdanc:
-
Unplanned Parenthood?
Planned Unparenthood?
-
Thanks for illustrating in bright, shiny letters what an "oxymoron" is.
You can't plan for parenthood when you decided to not be a parent. Parenthood doesn't exist without a parent.
You know how to use Google. Now look up the definition of "parent."
Oh, hell...... might as well lead you to yet another lake ....
According to YOU, anyone contemplating abortion is a parent. By definition, they have children/offspring. That means abortion is killing that child/offspring, otherwise the term "parent" can't apply.
No definiton of "parent" I can find includes "clump of cells". :geekdanc:
Other than the fact you ignored everything else and picked the one thing that is based on semantics ok...ummm For parenthood, you have to plan when you are ready for children. Bringing a child into the world when you are unable to fulfill your role is cruel. If you dont want to join the parenthood realm abortion is a viable option.
-
Other than the fact you ignored everything else and picked the one thing that is based on semantics ok...ummm For parenthood, you have to plan when you are ready for children. Bringing a child into the world when you are unable to fulfill your role is cruel. If you dont want to join the parenthood realm abortion is a viable option.
That's called Parenthood Prevention.
Abortion usually results from lack of planning.
Just stop.
-
That's called Parenthood Prevention.
Abortion usually results from lack of planning.
Just stop.
You know you can plan for your future after you make a mistake? How to resolve errors. You dont have to just accept fate T_T
Oops we accidently made a pregnancy we are unable to financially or mentally complete. Lets PLAN to end it and continue our lives....so one day we can join parenthood when we are ready. You know planning for your future parenthood even if that isnt today T_T
-
You know you can plan for your future after you make a mistake? How to resolve errors. You dont have to just accept fate T_T
Oops we accidently made a pregnancy we are unable to financially or mentally complete. Lets PLAN to end it and continue our lives....so one day we can join parenthood when we are ready. You know planning for your future parenthood even if that isnt today T_T
You're ignoring the CONSEQUENCES of CHOICE MADE in the ABSENCE of ACTUAL PLANNING.
Consequences actually exist. You're advocating for mass murder in order to avoid those consequences.
We all know how babies are made. You want to enjoy the process without the consequences of carelessness.
PP doesn't call themselves "New Beginnings."
That's already taken, BTW.
https://nbminnesota.com/
-
The only PLAN in Planned Parenthood was Sanger's plan to commit genocide based on race.
You're really in good company with all your contortionist attempts at redefining the truth.
-
The only PLAN in Planned Parenthood was Sanger's plan to commit genocide based on race.
You're really in good company with all your contortionist attempts at redefining the truth.
So Roe v. Wade was a result of Sanger’s plan, through the use of “activist” judges and lying lawyers, to accomplish eugenics?
I enjoy my “tea” but I want to try some of whatever your taking. (Oh shit, I didn’t put an apostrophe and re at the end of my your....something else you can comment on. :shake:)
Ah shit, if you Guys want to argue the point argue the point.
Is Trump’s pick to replace RBG for SCOTUS a good and qualified one ?
Will she get through confirmation?
Is she Pro-2A ?
That’s the way I see it.
Abortion is settled law.
But don’t worry, anti-abortion States are working every loophole in the settled law to make it as difficult as possible.
Same as Hawaii is doing to our 2A Rights.
-
Your Boss/job instructs you to engineer a better abortion machine would you? So that women can more easily access their right to abort. Nothing legally is stopping you fyi. With your religious conviction (I assume its against abortion) would you do your job?
I’ll give you a personal experience from my brother. He broke down and cried like a baby almost every night after work. He did his job in spite of his strict religious convictions as a strict Mormon.
My brother was an OB/GYN and had his own practice for over 20 years in LA County. Then one patient sued him for the max of his insurance which was $1M. I won’t get into the details of the suit. They also filed a complaint with the AMA. In the meantime the AMA suspended his license to practice while they performed an investigation into the complaint brought by the patient. It took several years for them to clear my brother of any wrongdoing. But the insurance still paid out and he could no longer get insurance to practice medicine.
In the years that the AMA suspended his license do you know what he did? He took a job working at the LA County Public Health Facility providing prenatal care and counseling. Despite his religious beliefs he performed abortions because that is what his job required him to do. It literally brought him to his knees every night when he came home.
Despite your obvious bias towards people who are religious, 10’s of 1,000’s of people perform their jobs every day against their religious beliefs. If my brother can do it, ACB can certainly and easily do her job and rule per the law/constitution in spite of any religious beliefs she might have. You make it sound like religious people are a bunch of nuts. Your words, not mine. But in fact they are hard working Americans who put aside their religious beliefs every fucking day to do a fucking job they are asked and committed to do. Why do you have such a religious bias and hard on for ACB? Everybody else here sees it, maybe its time you do too.
-
You're ignoring the CONSEQUENCES of CHOICE MADE in the ABSENCE of ACTUAL PLANNING.
Consequences actually exist. You're advocating for mass murder in order to avoid those consequences.
We all know how babies are made. You want to enjoy the process without the consequences of carelessness.
PP doesn't call themselves "New Beginnings."
That's already taken, BTW.
https://nbminnesota.com/
Dang I've seen some crazy stuff but this takes the cake. First of it has to be alive to call it murder but that's another fight. People like sex. People don't always want babies. Mistakes happens. Stopping the mistakes before they are born and even a bigger mistake is perfectly fine. Just like jacking off is perfectly fine you are killing all those millions of potential lives :crazy:
-
So Roe v. Wade was a result of Sanger’s plan, through the use of “activist” judges and lying lawyers, to accomplish eugenics?
I enjoy my “tea” but I want to try some of whatever your taking. (Oh shit, I didn’t put an apostrophe and re at the end of my your....something else you can comment on. :shake:)
Ah shit, if you Guys want to argue the point argue the point.
Is Trump’s pick to replace RBG for SCOTUS a good and qualified one ?
Will she get through confirmation?
Is she Pro-2A ?
That’s the way I see it.
Abortion is settled law.
But don’t worry, anti-abortion States are working every loophole in the settled law to make it as difficult as possible.
Same as Hawaii is doing to our 2A Rights.
Who needs Marijuana reform when we can get what he's on
-
The only PLAN in Planned Parenthood was Sanger's plan to commit genocide based on race.
You're really in good company with all your contortionist attempts at redefining the truth.
Race? Do only jewish babies get aborted or something?
Curious on a side note cause you got some wack out views. If you did a test and the baby was deformed/missing chromosomes. Would you abort? Or is that mass genetic murder?
-
I’ll give you a personal experience from my brother. He broke down and cried like a baby almost every night after work. He did his job in spite of his strict religious convictions as a strict Mormon.
My brother was an OB/GYN and had his own practice for over 20 years in LA County. Then one patient sued him for the max of his insurance which was $1M. I won’t get into the details of the suit. They also filed a complaint with the AMA. In the meantime the AMA suspended his license to practice while they performed an investigation into the complaint brought by the patient. It took several years for them to clear my brother of any wrongdoing. But the insurance still paid out and he could no longer get insurance to practice medicine.
In the years that the AMA suspended his license do you know what he did? He took a job working at the LA County Public Health Facility providing prenatal care and counseling. Despite his religious beliefs he performed abortions because that is what his job required him to do. It literally brought him to his knees every night when he came home.
Despite your obvious bias towards people who are religious, 10’s of 1,000’s of people perform their jobs every day against their religious beliefs. If my brother can do it, ACB can certainly and easily do her job and rule per the law/constitution in spite of any religious beliefs she might have. You make it sound like religious people are a bunch of nuts. Your words, not mine. But in fact they are hard working Americans who put aside their religious beliefs every fucking day to do a fucking job they are asked and committed to do. Why do you have such a religious bias and hard on for ACB? Everybody else here sees it, maybe its time you do too.
I applaud your brother. I truly hope she is as strong as your brother. I have grown up skeptical of people, especially ones who have strong religious views. With that is at stake I would rather not risk it. Literally freedom and the future of America is at risk. Its a slippery slope as we all know with the 2nd amendment. First they outlaw abortion, next comes speech, then comes the thought police and you cant say anything negative about the government/religion. Next thing we know we are Iran. I know many who tried to convert or force their beliefs on me so I am only human and go by experiences of the past. I mean no offense to you or others but I feel its my duty as an American to protect freedom, freedom for all.
-
So Roe v. Wade was a result of Sanger’s plan, through the use of “activist” judges and lying lawyers, to accomplish eugenics?
I enjoy my “tea” but I want to try some of whatever your taking. (Oh shit, I didn’t put an apostrophe and re at the end of my your....something else you can comment on. :shake:)
Ah shit, if you Guys want to argue the point argue the point.
Is Trump’s pick to replace RBG for SCOTUS a good and qualified one ?
Will she get through confirmation?
Is she Pro-2A ?
That’s the way I see it.
Abortion is settled law.
But don’t worry, anti-abortion States are working every loophole in the settled law to make it as difficult as possible.
Same as Hawaii is doing to our 2A Rights.
The right to buy, sell and own slaves was settled law.
Women barred from voting was settled law.
Prohibition was settled law, which was an actual Constitutional Amendment.
Legally owning fully automatic firearms was settled law.
In Texas, killing a person was justified if 3 people of good moral character testified the deceased "needed killing." Settled law!
Your "settled law" argument is stupid. The only laws written in stone, AFAIK, are enumerated 1 through 10.
Even Supreme Court rulings have been reversed. Here's a list of 10 such cases ...
10 Overturned Supreme Court Cases
The U.S. Supreme Court is the highest court in the nation. Its decisions set precedents that all other
courts then follow, and no lower court can ever supersede a Supreme Court decision. In fact, not even Congress
or the president can change, reject or ignore a Supreme Court decision.
American law operates under the doctrine of stare decisis, which means that prior decisions should be
maintained -- even if the current court would otherwise rule differently -- and that lower courts must abide
by the prior decisions of higher courts. The idea is based on a belief that government needs to be relatively
stable and predictable.
This means that overturning a Supreme Court decision is very difficult. There are two ways it can happen:
** States can amend the Constitution itself. This requires approval by three-quarters of the state legislatures --
no easy feat. However, it has happened several times.
** The Supreme Court can overrule itself. This happens when a different case involving the same constitutional
issues as an earlier case is reviewed by the court and seen in a new light, typically because of changing social and
political situations.
It isn't easy to do, but we've compiled a list of 10 Supreme Court cases that were later overturned. Many of them
left a permanent mark on American history.
Lochner v. New York (1905) and Adkins v. Children's Hospital (1923)
Chisholm v. Georgia (1793)
Adler v. Board of Education (1952)
Bowers v. Hardwick (1986)
Pace v. Alabama (1883)
Austin v. Michigan State Chamber of Commerce (1990)
Oregon v. Mitchell (1970)
Wolf v. Colorado (1949)
Dred Scott v. Sandford (1857)
Plessy v. Ferguson (1896)
https://money.howstuffworks.com/10-overturned-supreme-court-cases.htm
-
Dang I've seen some crazy stuff but this takes the cake. First of it has to be alive to call it murder but that's another fight. People like sex. People don't always want babies. Mistakes happens. Stopping the mistakes before they are born and even a bigger mistake is perfectly fine. Just like jacking off is perfectly fine you are killing all those millions of potential lives :crazy:
People like a lot of things, but they choose not to do them if the risk of consequences is more than they are willing to accept.
People like sex because we are animals. The drive to perpetuate the species is strong. It's part of why we reproduce. The urges are natural, but they also have a purpose: making babies.
To blindly ignore the risk of pregnancy for your own pleasure, then expect there to be no consequences is immature and selfish. With the choices in contraceptions today, it's ridiculous that such a large number of people require abortions every year.
Having sex and making an unwanted baby is not a "mistake". Wearing mismatched socks to work or leaving the front door open when leaving the house are "mistakes".
Having sex is a choice. The baby is the unintended consequence of your irresponsible choice to have sex. We all know the effectiveness rates of birth control methods. Few are 100%.
If you CHOOSE to engage in sexual intercourse, and that results in a fertilized egg, it was not a mistake. It was a result of your choice.
-
The right to buy, sell and own slaves was settled law.
Women barred from voting was settled law.
Prohibition was settled law, which was an actual Constitutional Amendment.
Legally owning fully automatic firearms was settled law.
In Texas, killing a person was justified if 3 people of good moral character testified the deceased "needed killing." Settled law!
Your "settled law" argument is stupid. The only laws written in stone, AFAIK, are enumerated 1 through 10.
Even Supreme Court rulings have been reversed. Here's a list of 10 such cases ...
10 Overturned Supreme Court Cases
https://money.howstuffworks.com/10-overturned-supreme-court-cases.htm
This exactly why I'm so worried just takes one judge to over turn it and ruin freedom.
-
This exactly why I'm so worried just takes one judge to over turn it and ruin freedom.
How many abortions do you plan to have the next 5-10 years? Sounds like you're overly optimistic with your "social agenda." :geekdanc:
-
I applaud your brother. I truly hope she is as strong as your brother. I have grown up skeptical of people, especially ones who have strong religious views. With that is at stake I would rather not risk it. Literally freedom and the future of America is at risk. Its a slippery slope as we all know with the 2nd amendment. First they outlaw abortion, next comes speech, then comes the thought police and you cant say anything negative about the government/religion. Next thing we know we are Iran. I know many who tried to convert or force their beliefs on me so I am only human and go by experiences of the past. I mean no offense to you or others but I feel its my duty as an American to protect freedom, freedom for all.
First of all, you really don’t seem to know what the fuck you are talking about. “Outlaw abortion”? Where in the world did you come up with that moronic idea? Anybody with half a brain knows 2 facts are in play here. First one is that the chance of SCOTUS ever voting just to rehear Rowe vs Wade is almost nil since most of the justices have already stated they won’t vote to rehear existing SCOTUS decisions. Chances are this will never come to SCOTUS to rehear. But the second fact is that even if SCOTUS rehears it and overturns it, WHAT THE FUCK DO YOU THINK IS GOING TO HAPPEN? I asked you that in an earlier post but you conveniently decided to NOT answer me. ANSWER THE QUESTION! Do you really think if it is overturned that abortion will be outlawed? :rofl:
-
First of all, you really don’t seem to know what the fuck you are talking about. “Outlaw abortion”? Where in the world did you come up with that moronic idea? Anybody with half a brain knows 2 facts are in play here. First one is that the chance of SCOTUS ever voting just to rehear Rowe vs Wade is almost nil since most of the justices have already stated they won’t vote to rehear existing SCOTUS decisions. Chances are this will never come to SCOTUS to rehear. But the second fact is that even if SCOTUS rehears it and overturns it, WHAT THE FUCK DO YOU THINK IS GOING TO HAPPEN? I asked you that in an earlier post but you conveniently decided to NOT answer me. ANSWER THE QUESTION! Do you really think if it is overturned that abortion will be outlawed? :rofl:
If they do rehear then 100% they can overturn. Once had happens abortion restriction laws come into affect for half the nation. Are your saying that won't happen? Its documented. Half of the usa will lose access to abortion. Not sure what you are getting at.
-
How many abortions do you plan to have the next 5-10 years? Sounds like you're overly optimistic with your "social agenda." :geekdanc:
None but how many mag bans do you see coming. What if they start doing 8 round then 5 then no semi auto. Cause muskets lol. It's a slippery slope. I will defend freedoms of others which I don't use. Because I am American that's my duty as a Patriot. If you pick and choose what freedom to protect or have you dont have freedom.
-
None but how many mag bans do you see coming. What if they start doing 8 round then 5 then no semi auto. Cause muskets lol. It's a slippery slope. I will defend freedoms of others which I don't use. Because I am American that's my duty as a Patriot. If you pick and choose what freedom to protect or have you dont have freedom.
Since firearms are a protected Constitutional right, and abortions are not -- Supreme Court mistakes notwithstanding -- your parallel is not logical.
Rights are not granted by the Court. They are protected by the Constitution. Science has progressed greatly since the 1970s. To argue a growing child is not a human being ignores what we know today.
-
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Kyp1qCwq2Rc
-
The right to buy, sell and own slaves was settled law.
Women barred from voting was settled law.
Prohibition was settled law, which was an actual Constitutional Amendment.
Legally owning fully automatic firearms was settled law.
In Texas, killing a person was justified if 3 people of good moral character testified the deceased "needed killing." Settled law!
Your "settled law" argument is stupid. The only laws written in stone, AFAIK, are enumerated 1 through 10.
Even Supreme Court rulings have been reversed. Here's a list of 10 such cases ...
10 Overturned Supreme Court Cases
https://money.howstuffworks.com/10-overturned-supreme-court-cases.htm
First of all, you really don’t seem to know what the fuck you are talking about. “Outlaw abortion”? Where in the world did you come up with that moronic idea? Anybody with half a brain knows 2 facts are in play here. First one is that the chance of SCOTUS ever voting just to rehear Rowe vs Wade is almost nil since most of the justices have already stated they won’t vote to rehear existing SCOTUS decisions. Chances are this will never come to SCOTUS to rehear. But the second fact is that even if SCOTUS rehears it and overturns it, WHAT THE FUCK DO YOU THINK IS GOING TO HAPPEN? I asked you that in an earlier post but you conveniently decided to NOT answer me. ANSWER THE QUESTION! Do you really think if it is overturned that abortion will be outlawed? :rofl:
Inspector, I don’t to mean to get you into this, but that’s the perfect reply to Flapp’s comment.
Hound :shaka:
-
... I will defend freedoms of others which I don't use. Because I am American that's my duty as a Patriot. If you pick and choose what freedom to protect or have you dont have freedom.
Whose FREEDOM are you "protecting"? Where does the freedom you refer to come from?
-
If they do rehear then 100% they can overturn. Once had happens abortion restriction laws come into affect for half the nation. Are your saying that won't happen? Its documented. Half of the usa will lose access to abortion. Not sure what you are getting at.
Good, I at least have your attention. You still don’t understand the entirety of the laws and restrictions and constitutional rights. First, abortion is not a right. It has never been and never will be. In order to make it a right it has to be added to the constitution. And we all know the chances of that happening are nil. The idea behind our constitution is for any law or restriction not stated in our constitution is to be settled by the states, counties and cities. And it is perfectly correct for each state to have varying levels of freedoms and restrictions. There is one unwritten freedom that Americans have. And that is freedom of movement. And combined with freedom of choice gives Americans a very unique and powerful situation that a lot of people in this world don’t have and will never experience. Keep in mind all of the above while I continue.
You said “Half of the usa will lose access to abortion.” It’s just not a true statement. You are not stating the truth in its entirety. The truth is that they may or may not lose their access to abortion to varying degrees in the state they happen to be in at that exact moment only. So please do not continue with with your train of thought that anyone will lose access to abortion because it is just not true. There is not one state that outright outlaws abortion. Just because there is a restriction on abortion in a state also does not mean they still cannot get an abortion. The point I made in my post to you a few days ago is that not one woman in the US has ever been denied an abortion. Period.
BEFORE Rowe vs Wade women were never denied the ability to get an abortion. Ever. How do you think all these women were getting abortions before Rowe vs Wade? They did it just like they do now. They got in their car and drove to the nearest abortion clinic, paid their $50 and had the brains of their babies sucked out. An American citizen only needs to get in their car and go to a state that has laws that allow abortions to the extent she wants. All Rowe vs Wade does is make it more of a convenience and makes it possible for congress to force taxpayers to pay for abortions. Nothing more, nothing less. For me it is disgusting to have to pay for a woman to have an abortion just because she took a calculated risk and lost. Having sex and getting pregnant is not making a mistake if she didn’t want to get pregnant. It is a calculated risk only.
I was alive during the Rowe vs Wade debate. And the left and media constantly lied and said women couldn’t get abortions. It was and never will be true. You have been brainwashed into thinking what you do. While access to abortion might have been restricted to one degree or another only in the general area they live in, women have been getting abortions without restrictions long before Rowe vs Wade was ever considered. The fact is Rowe vs Wade will never be overturned because it will never be reheard. But even if it is reheard, and overturned, women will still never lose the ability to get an abortion. They may have to drive an additional hour or two in order to get one. But they will always have access to abortion.
-
Good, I at least have your attention. You still don’t understand the entirety of the laws and restrictions and constitutional rights. First, abortion is not a right. It has never been and never will be. In order to make it a right it has to be added to the constitution. And we all know the chances of that happening are nil. The idea behind our constitution is for any law or restriction not stated in our constitution is to be settled by the states, counties and cities. And it is perfectly correct for each state to have varying levels of freedoms and restrictions. There is one unwritten freedom that Americans have. And that is freedom of movement. And combined with freedom of choice gives Americans a very unique and powerful situation that a lot of people in this world don’t have and will never experience. Keep in mind all of the above while I continue.
You said “Half of the usa will lose access to abortion.” It’s just not a true statement. You are not stating the truth in its entirety. The truth is that they may or may not lose their access to abortion to varying degrees in the state they happen to be in at that exact moment only. So please do not continue with with your train of thought that anyone will lose access to abortion because it is just not true. There is not one state that outright outlaws abortion. Just because there is a restriction on abortion in a state also does not mean they still cannot get an abortion. The point I made in my post to you a few days ago is that not one woman in the US has ever been denied an abortion. Period.
BEFORE Rowe vs Wade women were never denied the ability to get an abortion. Ever. How do you think all these women were getting abortions before Rowe vs Wade? They did it just like they do now. They got in their car and drove to the nearest abortion clinic, paid their $50 and had the brains of their babies sucked out. An American citizen only needs to get in their car and go to a state that has laws that allow abortions to the extent she wants. All Rowe vs Wade does is make it more of a convenience and makes it possible for congress to force taxpayers to pay for abortions. Nothing more, nothing less. For me it is disgusting to have to pay for a woman to have an abortion just because she took a calculated risk and lost. Having sex and getting pregnant is not making a mistake if she didn’t want to get pregnant. It is a calculated risk only.
I was alive during the Rowe vs Wade debate. And the left and media constantly lied and said women couldn’t get abortions. It was and never will be true. You have been brainwashed into thinking what you do. While access to abortion might have been restricted to one degree or another only in the general area they live in, women have been getting abortions without restrictions long before Rowe vs Wade was ever considered. The fact is Rowe vs Wade will never be overturned because it will never be reheard. But even if it is reheard, and overturned, women will still never lose the ability to get an abortion. They may have to drive an additional hour or two in order to get one. But they will always have access to abortion.
Georgia passed the "heartbeat law" -- if a heartbeat is recorded, the abortion is only allowed in very rare, narrow and specific circumstances. Hollywood threatened to "boycott the state." Haven't heard a word about any boycott since. :rofl:
Since 1973, there have been many new scientific tests and facts discovered. To think that in 1973 pro-abortion doctors knew enough to guess-timate when life begins, when the fetus feels pain or has sensory perception and when it is considered viable, and that nothing has changed in nearly HALF A CENTURY of medical and technological breakthroughs is naive at best -- more like intellectually and ethically dishonest.
Since R v W is "the law", every new test or analysis that could shed new light on when life begins has been ignored. Nothing doctors provide now matters, because it changes nothing about the law. However, if the feds stop protecting abortionists, then we can have an honest and scientific discussion on the practice. Until then, it's unlikely anything will change -- even if it should.
-
Georgia passed the "heartbeat law" -- if a heartbeat is recorded, the abortion is only allowed in very rare, narrow and specific circumstances. Hollywood threatened to "boycott the state." Haven't heard a word about any boycott since. :rofl:
Since 1973, there have been many new scientific tests and facts discovered. To think that in 1973 pro-abortion doctors knew enough to guess-timate when life begins, when the fetus feels pain or has sensory perception and when it is considered viable, and that nothing has changed in nearly HALF A CENTURY of medical and technological breakthroughs is naive at best -- more like intellectually and ethically dishonest.
Since R v W is "the law", every new test or analysis that could shed new light on when life begins has been ignored. Nothing doctors provide now matters, because it changes nothing about the law. However, if the feds stop protecting abortionists, then we can have an honest and scientific discussion on the practice. Until then, it's unlikely anything will change -- even if it should.
I have personally changed some of my opinions on abortion since it became a national topic in the 70’s. I have gone from agreeing with Omnigun to a much more restricted view of abortions. But I am not completely against them. And medical science has a lot to do with my changing opinion. My brother had a lot to do with my changing opinion as well.
But I have not changed my opinion about this being a state issue and not a constitutional issue. The states have the right to restrict and limit abortions as they see fit. And we all have the choice to travel/move to a state with less restrictions. It seems the younger generation doesn’t appreciate the freedoms we older folk understand and hold dear.
-
Good, I at least have your attention. You still don’t understand the entirety of the laws and restrictions and constitutional rights. First, abortion is not a right. It has never been and never will be. In order to make it a right it has to be added to the constitution. And we all know the chances of that happening are nil. The idea behind our constitution is for any law or restriction not stated in our constitution is to be settled by the states, counties and cities. And it is perfectly correct for each state to have varying levels of freedoms and restrictions. There is one unwritten freedom that Americans have. And that is freedom of movement. And combined with freedom of choice gives Americans a very unique and powerful situation that a lot of people in this world don’t have and will never experience. Keep in mind all of the above while I continue.
You said “Half of the usa will lose access to abortion.” It’s just not a true statement. You are not stating the truth in its entirety. The truth is that they may or may not lose their access to abortion to varying degrees in the state they happen to be in at that exact moment only. So please do not continue with with your train of thought that anyone will lose access to abortion because it is just not true. There is not one state that outright outlaws abortion. Just because there is a restriction on abortion in a state also does not mean they still cannot get an abortion. The point I made in my post to you a few days ago is that not one woman in the US has ever been denied an abortion. Period.
BEFORE Rowe vs Wade women were never denied the ability to get an abortion. Ever. How do you think all these women were getting abortions before Rowe vs Wade? They did it just like they do now. They got in their car and drove to the nearest abortion clinic, paid their $50 and had the brains of their babies sucked out. An American citizen only needs to get in their car and go to a state that has laws that allow abortions to the extent she wants. All Rowe vs Wade does is make it more of a convenience and makes it possible for congress to force taxpayers to pay for abortions. Nothing more, nothing less. For me it is disgusting to have to pay for a woman to have an abortion just because she took a calculated risk and lost. Having sex and getting pregnant is not making a mistake if she didn’t want to get pregnant. It is a calculated risk only.
I was alive during the Rowe vs Wade debate. And the left and media constantly lied and said women couldn’t get abortions. It was and never will be true. You have been brainwashed into thinking what you do. While access to abortion might have been restricted to one degree or another only in the general area they live in, women have been getting abortions without restrictions long before Rowe vs Wade was ever considered. The fact is Rowe vs Wade will never be overturned because it will never be reheard. But even if it is reheard, and overturned, women will still never lose the ability to get an abortion. They may have to drive an additional hour or two in order to get one. But they will always have access to abortion.
I do agree that technically you are correct in some ways. It's not outlawed across the nation. But flapp was right to aka heartbeat law where it is outlawed 100% in a state. Yes you can travel but that is a burden. People who want abortions tend to be poor and not have the resources to have a baby. That means many don't have the resources to pay to travel and take off work etc to get it done. This a undue burden that should not be the case. Much like how our current state has a soft ban on guns right now. It's impossible to get an appointment so basically many people including myself can't purchase guns and exercise our rights. Sure we can technically go to another state and purchase them. Is that fair? Same argument can be held if you don't like Hawaii gun laws, move. Is that fair? Personally I say no.
You shouldn't limit freedom and someone's choice even if you don't agree with it. It's important to protect all freedoms or you have none. In many of those states that are restricted they will just get more and more till its basically banned. I personally think abortion is a constitutional right via privacy like how it was argued. There was no way for the founder's to know abortion because of the technological times but I believe if they did it would be included spelled out.
-
I have personally changed some of my opinions on abortion since it became a national topic in the 70’s. I have gone from agreeing with Omnigun to a much more restricted view of abortions. But I am not completely against them. And medical science has a lot to do with my changing opinion. My brother had a lot to do with my changing opinion as well.
But I have not changed my opinion about this being a state issue and not a constitutional issue. The states have the right to restrict and limit abortions as they see fit. And we all have the choice to travel/move to a state with less restrictions. It seems the younger generation doesn’t appreciate the freedoms we older folk understand and hold dear.
I do appreciate somethings but it's completely wrong to assume just because you are old you know what's right. Back in the day old people thought slaves were ok. Argued for a while till they were replaced. Same goes for women's rights. List can go on for people who were wrong about something.
-
Whose FREEDOM are you "protecting"? Where does the freedom you refer to come from?
The freedom of all Americans. It might not be spelt out word for word in the Constitution but it is everywhere. Privacy or how it came by shouldn't matter. There's no way the Constitution can predict everything. It's not perfect. But as an American you should always strive for more freedom not less. Even if you oppose the view. That's what America culture is about. Personal choice. Even if 99% of the people are pro life, we shouldn't exclude the 1%. Much like religion all religion is acceptable even Muslims.
Also youor anyone haven't answered my question. If you did a test and your future child had either genetic or physical issues. Would you support aborting?
-
First of all, you really don’t seem to know what the fuck you are talking about. “Outlaw abortion”? Where in the world did you come up with that moronic idea? Anybody with half a brain knows 2 facts are in play here. First one is that the chance of SCOTUS ever voting just to rehear Rowe vs Wade is almost nil since most of the justices have already stated they won’t vote to rehear existing SCOTUS decisions. Chances are this will never come to SCOTUS to rehear. But the second fact is that even if SCOTUS rehears it and overturns it, WHAT THE FUCK DO YOU THINK IS GOING TO HAPPEN? I asked you that in an earlier post but you conveniently decided to NOT answer me. ANSWER THE QUESTION! Do you really think if it is overturned that abortion will be outlawed? :rofl:
Inspector is right. The supreme court can't just magically overturn Roe v. Wade because they composition of the justices is different. A case in controversy needs to work its way up to the Supreme Court, and the Supreme Court would have to overrule their own precedent established in Roe v. Wade. Both of these are extremely unlikely, if not impossible due to the existence of the other. The Supreme Court can't have a case in controversy over a subject that's already been decided, and they can't decide on something (again) without a case in controversy. At best, someone could bring a case along the peripherals like Planned Parenthood v. Casey. In Casey, the state didn't outright ban abortions, but instead created obstacles like waiting periods and requiring parental consent and this was ruled constitutional. So there are ways to attack abortion along the borders, but there are balances to keep these in check. Also with the way the Supreme Court works, this would be years and years away.
Additionally, even though abortion was not protected by the Constitution outright in specific language, it can still fall under the penumbra of constitutional protections (Griswold v. Connecticut). In the same way the constitution did not specifically say speech over the internet is protected under the first amendment, or semi-automatic firearms are protected under the second amendment, there can be a logical inference that they fall within the constitutional shadow and are thus protected.
Also, of interesting relevance to us here in the firearms community, abortion and gun control are basically the same argument from polar opposite sides:
Primary argument: "We need to ban (guns/abortions) for the sake of the children"
Courts rule: "no you can't ban (guns/abortions) outright, but states can make their own policies."
Individual states: "Well we don't like (guns/abortions) so we're gonna throw up obstacles like waiting periods, and mandatory classes, and proof of competency, and make it really hard to have (guns/abortions) in our state."
Believing the federal government or states should have the right to restrict one and not the other is quite hypocritical.
-
First of all, you really don’t seem to know what the fuck you are talking about. “Outlaw abortion”? Where in the world did you come up with that moronic idea? Anybody with half a brain knows 2 facts are in play here. First one is that the chance of SCOTUS ever voting just to rehear Rowe vs Wade is almost nil since most of the justices have already stated they won’t vote to rehear existing SCOTUS decisions. Chances are this will never come to SCOTUS to rehear. But the second fact is that even if SCOTUS rehears it and overturns it, WHAT THE FUCK DO YOU THINK IS GOING TO HAPPEN? I asked you that in an earlier post but you conveniently decided to NOT answer me. ANSWER THE QUESTION! Do you really think if it is overturned that abortion will be outlawed? :rofl:
Thank you Inspector for this information.
The left makes it seem like as soon as a new justice is appointed, all prior cases are re opened for review.
Thank you for sharing what actually occurs, since I was genuinely interested.
-
I do agree that technically you are correct in some ways. It's not outlawed across the nation. But flapp was right to aka heartbeat law where it is outlawed 100% in a state. Yes you can travel but that is a burden. People who want abortions tend to be poor and not have the resources to have a baby. That means many don't have the resources to pay to travel and take off work etc to get it done. This a undue burden that should not be the case. Much like how our current state has a soft ban on guns right now. It's impossible to get an appointment so basically many people including myself can't purchase guns and exercise our rights. Sure we can technically go to another state and purchase them. Is that fair? Same argument can be held if you don't like Hawaii gun laws, move. Is that fair? Personally I say no.
You shouldn't limit freedom and someone's choice even if you don't agree with it. It's important to protect all freedoms or you have none. In many of those states that are restricted they will just get more and more till its basically banned. I personally think abortion is a constitutional right via privacy like how it was argued. There was no way for the founder's to know abortion because of the technological times but I believe if they did it would be included spelled out.
Are you for real? Seriously. What universe do you live in where people don’t have to take responsibility for their own actions? If people want to fuck their brains out they need to take responsibility for their own actions if the woman gets pregnant. Who fucking cares if it is a burden? Oh, that’s right, you do! :rofl: The facts and the truth don’t care about your feeling snowflake. Sorry. If people are so poor they don’t have the resources to have a baby that they can’t afford, they shouldn’t be taking a calculated risk and fucking their brains out. If they do that without considering the consequences then they are morons and live in an unreal universe like you do. They also need to suffer the consequences of their actions. Otherwise people are going to continue to make bad decisions. That’s how people learn, moron. But if you take away their responsibility and the consequences of their actions they will just keep on doing what feels good to them. Where do you come up with this shit? Really. Where? Why should us tax payers pay for the stupidity of others? Only morons want to pay for the stupidity of other morons. But I guess you feel so bad for those morons that you want to pay for their stupidity? Boo hoo, sorry your feelings are getting in the way of your critical thinking.
Where do come off making this shit up? :rofl: Seriously, how do get through life thinking it’s okay for people to act irresponsibly and that the government should encourage it? Life isn’t fair. You need to grow up and learn some life lessons, dude. You really have no conception of the real world.
-
.
Where do come off making this shit up? :rofl: Seriously, how do get through life thinking it’s okay for people to act irresponsibly and that the government should encourage it? Life isn’t fair. You need to grow up and learn some life lessons, dude. You really have no conception of the real world.
Exactly (well mostly) what I’ve been trying to get through to him. He’s still stuck on his feelings and refusing to accept reality. He thinks what he wants will change the world. I mean I get people are energized by certain issues, but he seems to twist or ignore facts for what he believes is “right” in his mind.
-
I do appreciate somethings but it's completely wrong to assume just because you are old you know what's right. Back in the day old people thought slaves were ok. Argued for a while till they were replaced. Same goes for women's rights. List can go on for people who were wrong about something.
Wow, dude. You just make up shit as you go along. Wow. And I’ll bet you are fine with making stuff up. You accuse me assuming something just because I am old? I never said that. But did it ever dawn on you that I could be right? So far you offer no proof of my being wrong. :rofl:
I never said just because I am old I know what’s right. All I said was I changed my OPINION over the years, gave examples of why I changed my opinion and said the younger generation doesn’t appreciate the freedoms someone my age does. I don’t know where you get off saying I’m right just because I’m old. I don’t appreciate your making that up and your accusation.
Where do you get off accusing me of saying something I didn’t? But I suspect I hit a nerve with you. Why else would you react like that! Personally, I think that deep down inside you know I am right. It’s just that your feelings won’t allow you be objective and view the truth. :rofl:
Dude, I’m done talking to you. I don’t appreciate your making shit up about me and accusing me of saying something I didn’t. Good luck living in your alternate universe. By not accepting reality you are just making your life harder for yourself by not dealing with the real world. And you certainly don’t make any sense to those of us who understand reality.
-
Inspector is right. The supreme court can't just magically overturn Roe v. Wade because they composition of the justices is different. A case in controversy needs to work its way up to the Supreme Court, and the Supreme Court would have to overrule their own precedent established in Roe v. Wade. Both of these are extremely unlikely, if not impossible due to the existence of the other. The Supreme Court can't have a case in controversy over a subject that's already been decided, and they can't decide on something (again) without a case in controversy. At best, someone could bring a case along the peripherals like Planned Parenthood v. Casey. In Casey, the state didn't outright ban abortions, but instead created obstacles like waiting periods and requiring parental consent and this was ruled constitutional. So there are ways to attack abortion along the borders, but there are balances to keep these in check. Also with the way the Supreme Court works, this would be years and years away.
Additionally, even though abortion was not protected by the Constitution outright in specific language, it can still fall under the penumbra of constitutional protections (Griswold v. Connecticut). In the same way the constitution did not specifically say speech over the internet is protected under the first amendment, or semi-automatic firearms are protected under the second amendment, there can be a logical inference that they fall within the constitutional shadow and are thus protected.
Also, of interesting relevance to us here in the firearms community, abortion and gun control are basically the same argument from polar opposite sides:
Primary argument: "We need to ban (guns/abortions) for the sake of the children"
Courts rule: "no you can't ban (guns/abortions) outright, but states can make their own policies."
Individual states: "Well we don't like (guns/abortions) so we're gonna throw up obstacles like waiting periods, and mandatory classes, and proof of competency, and make it really hard to have (guns/abortions) in our state."
Believing the federal government or states should have the right to restrict one and not the other is quite hypocritical.
Well said and researched. I learned something new from your post. Thanks!
-
Thank you Inspector for this information.
The left makes it seem like as soon as a new justice is appointed, all prior cases are re opened for review.
Thank you for sharing what actually occurs, since I was genuinely interested.
Long time no see! How have you guys been? I hope you two are doing well.
You are absolutely right about this. And because the left makes this into something emotional, those who are prone to allowing their feelings to override simple logic means they are always overreacting to things that are mostly uncertain. Those of us who use our heads understand the lies that the left puts out. Even if ACB were the type of judge that allows her religion to override her decisions against the law and constitution (which she is not), it is a totally moot point as she will never get the chance to vote whether to rehear Rowe vs Wade or not. So it makes no difference in the real world. So why play on peoples emotions? The left does this to influence the low information voter. Those that think with their hearts instead of their minds. You sir understand this situation very well and better than most.
See
Inspector is right. The supreme court can't just magically overturn Roe v. Wade because they composition of the justices is different. A case in controversy needs to work its way up to the Supreme Court, and the Supreme Court would have to overrule their own precedent established in Roe v. Wade. Both of these are extremely unlikely, if not impossible due to the existence of the other. The Supreme Court can't have a case in controversy over a subject that's already been decided, and they can't decide on something (again) without a case in controversy. At best, someone could bring a case along the peripherals like Planned Parenthood v. Casey. In Casey, the state didn't outright ban abortions, but instead created obstacles like waiting periods and requiring parental consent and this was ruled constitutional. So there are ways to attack abortion along the borders, but there are balances to keep these in check. Also with the way the Supreme Court works, this would be years and years away.
Additionally, even though abortion was not protected by the Constitution outright in specific language, it can still fall under the penumbra of constitutional protections (Griswold v. Connecticut). In the same way the constitution did not specifically say speech over the internet is protected under the first amendment, or semi-automatic firearms are protected under the second amendment, there can be a logical inference that they fall within the constitutional shadow and are thus protected.
Also, of interesting relevance to us here in the firearms community, abortion and gun control are basically the same argument from polar opposite sides:
Primary argument: "We need to ban (guns/abortions) for the sake of the children"
Courts rule: "no you can't ban (guns/abortions) outright, but states can make their own policies."
Individual states: "Well we don't like (guns/abortions) so we're gonna throw up obstacles like waiting periods, and mandatory classes, and proof of competency, and make it really hard to have (guns/abortions) in our state."
Believing the federal government or states should have the right to restrict one and not the other is quite hypocritical.
This was my bad, I had it poorly worded. Antithesis is spot on. You cant re-rule but you can bring a case that brings up similar if the same circumstances and can get ruled on.
Inspector please dont make it seem like its so impossible. IT really isnt.
-
Thank you Inspector for this information.
The left makes it seem like as soon as a new justice is appointed, all prior cases are re opened for review.
Thank you for sharing what actually occurs, since I was genuinely interested.
Long time no see! How have you guys been? I hope you two are doing well.
You are absolutely right about this. And because the left makes this into something emotional, those who are prone to allowing their feelings to override simple logic means they are always overreacting to things that are mostly uncertain. Those of us who use our heads understand the lies that the left puts out. Even if ACB were the type of judge that allows her religion to override her decisions against the law and constitution (which she is not), it is a totally moot point as she will never get the chance to vote whether to rehear Rowe vs Wade or not. So it makes no difference in the real world. So why play on peoples emotions? The left does this to influence the low information voter. Those that think with their hearts instead of their minds. You sir understand this situation very well and better than most.
-
Inspector is right. The supreme court can't just magically overturn Roe v. Wade because they composition of the justices is different. A case in controversy needs to work its way up to the Supreme Court, and the Supreme Court would have to overrule their own precedent established in Roe v. Wade. Both of these are extremely unlikely, if not impossible due to the existence of the other. The Supreme Court can't have a case in controversy over a subject that's already been decided, and they can't decide on something (again) without a case in controversy. At best, someone could bring a case along the peripherals like Planned Parenthood v. Casey. In Casey, the state didn't outright ban abortions, but instead created obstacles like waiting periods and requiring parental consent and this was ruled constitutional. So there are ways to attack abortion along the borders, but there are balances to keep these in check. Also with the way the Supreme Court works, this would be years and years away.
Additionally, even though abortion was not protected by the Constitution outright in specific language, it can still fall under the penumbra of constitutional protections (Griswold v. Connecticut). In the same way the constitution did not specifically say speech over the internet is protected under the first amendment, or semi-automatic firearms are protected under the second amendment, there can be a logical inference that they fall within the constitutional shadow and are thus protected.
Also, of interesting relevance to us here in the firearms community, abortion and gun control are basically the same argument from polar opposite sides:
Primary argument: "We need to ban (guns/abortions) for the sake of the children"
Courts rule: "no you can't ban (guns/abortions) outright, but states can make their own policies."
Individual states: "Well we don't like (guns/abortions) so we're gonna throw up obstacles like waiting periods, and mandatory classes, and proof of competency, and make it really hard to have (guns/abortions) in our state."
Believing the federal government or states should have the right to restrict one and not the other is quite hypocritical.
I am going to condense some of my posts into this one. Antisepsis is absolutely right here. Well worded.
This brings up an important question. Inspector/Flapp, if you believe that abortions should be state rights, do you also believe firearm control should be too? You cant have only one side. In this case just like a state like Georgia can place major restrictions on abortion making it a defacto ban. Hawaii can do the exact same with guns.
I believe both should be protected federally for everyone. If only I worded it as such we probably could of avoided much of the heartache of this thread. I think no matter if you are against abortion for religious or scientific views. You should support the ability for all individuals in any state to make up their decision on what they believe if its prochoice or prolife on their own. Same with free speech, gun rights etc. It should be protected choice of freedom nationwide.
This applies to the press and everything. The left super liberals news have as much right to run as the right conservative news. You may hate on the other but you should protect their right to exist. Same with guns and everything. You can't pick and choose freedom.
-
Exactly (well mostly) what I’ve been trying to get through to him. He’s still stuck on his feelings and refusing to accept reality. He thinks what he wants will change the world. I mean I get people are energized by certain issues, but he seems to twist or ignore facts for what he believes is “right” in his mind.
Yeah, I tire easily of his emotional feelings about things with no basis in reality. I also got tired of his accusations and making stuff up. I stopped short of calling him a liar as I really think he believes his emotions are right in his mind. I just feel sorry for the guy. I can’t imagine what life would be like looking at it from an emotional state.
-
Wait....why does it not apply? I work with computers if my boss wanted me to program a machine that does [insert] with abortion, because I have no religious commandments stopping me I don't see why I would not listen and do that program. You literally spelt out religious bias. Just does it magically not apply for judges?
I don't pretend to know everything but I also don't shove my head into a hole like ostrich and blindly follow. I try think objectively from both sides. Even if that side is one I don't agree with. I am only human in the end though, I make mistakes.
I apologize that's its come to this. I guess in the end i am pro abortion and you are all anti. We will never come to see eye to eye. This judge threatens my values and views on freedom so I can't fully support her. She supports your values so you can. Everyone keeps blaming emotion, but we are all human and powered by them. I sincerely hope you are all correct and she will faithfully do her job with no bias. I have no power to change her not getting in the job. All I have is a way to vent my concerns to you all. Sorry it's gotten to this level. I just really value freedom. Thanks for listening and I hope everyone the best.
First, I apologize for some of those posts. I has some drinks (no excuse) and got heated. My bad on that.
Second, you tend to ASSUME a lot about folks. Hence my comments about your ignorance. You also seem to twist what people say either to try to "win" the argument through your views as well as insert your OPINIONS and/or perceptions of people and the world. I mean you're certainly free to make up your own mind, but you need to stop twisting what people say.
Third, I am not pro abortion. I am not anti abortion. In general, I am for the individual's right to decide what is best for them. Of course circumstances dependent. I am that way for 2a as well. My belief is that it's up the individual to decide what is best for them and hate when the "I know what is best for everyone" folks impose their values on everyone. You're doing the same thing even though you say you're "fighting for freedom".
Overall, on rights, IMO personal responsibility is huge. So when people demonstrate that they are incapable of responsible behavior, then I am for limiting or even taking away of privileges of those freedoms, but have to be very careful on that. I actually haven't read that deeply into ACB's background, but my point in this thread was IF ACB said she is capable of setting aside her religious beliefs and do her JOB, why are you so irrationally against her? And again, what do you have to substantiate your accusation that ACB will NOT be capable of performing her duties as Supreme Court Justice without religious bias?
Last, you appear to have ASSUMED that "literally spelt out religious bias", I can tell you beyond a shadow of a doubt that religion does not sway my professional decisions. I am not a particularly religious person. I am a person of principle shaped by life experiences. You seem to lump me into religious, which is simply not the case. You just assumed. . . again, ignorance. Personally, there was a time when I detested religion as IMO it forced itself upon people. I've come to appreciate certain aspects of religion, all religions. That you seem to be so irrationally stuck on religion, again, you're totally missing key points. That's your right to live life ignorant, just don't expect society to just accept that. You may view that as people being mean or toxic, but have you every considered your personal responsibilities?
You accuse me of shoving my head in the sand and blindly follow. Uh huh. I think I am pretty open minded and can appreciate other points of views. That said, trust but verify. Actually, my views on abortion aren't that different from yours. I was just pointing out HOW you seem to go about presenting your side seems hugely ignorant.
-
Why is there is a Left and Right court?
Shouldn’t the Court be impartial ?
How do do we get 5-4 votes from some of the sharpest minds in the judiciary ?
-
Wow, dude. You just make up shit as you go along. Wow. And I’ll bet you are fine with making stuff up. You accuse me assuming something just because I am old? I never said that. But did it ever dawn on you that I could be right? So far you offer no proof of my being wrong. :rofl:
I never said just because I am old I know what’s right. All I said was I changed my OPINION over the years, gave examples of why I changed my opinion and said the younger generation doesn’t appreciate the freedoms someone my age does. I don’t know where you get off saying I’m right just because I’m old. I don’t appreciate your making that up and your accusation.
Where do you get off accusing me of saying something I didn’t? But I suspect I hit a nerve with you. Why else would you react like that! Personally, I think that deep down inside you know I am right. It’s just that your feelings won’t allow you be objective and view the truth. :rofl:
Dude, I’m done talking to you. I don’t appreciate your making shit up about me and accusing me of saying something I didn’t. Good luck living in your alternate universe. By not accepting reality you are just making your life harder for yourself by not dealing with the real world. And you certainly don’t make any sense to those of us who understand reality.
My apologies I didn't mean that. I was just tired of people discounting young people simply because they are young. I have different experiences from you doesn't mean they are wrong. Deep down I do not think you are correct. Some things you say are but the bottom line I believe I and many others that have similar views to me are correct. FYI more than 50% of America supports pro-choice. Are they all wrong, ignorant masses?
-
Yeah, I tire easily of his emotional feelings about things with no basis in reality. I also got tired of his accusations and making stuff up. I stopped short of calling him a liar as I really think he believes his emotions are right in his mind. I just feel sorry for the guy. I can’t imagine what life would be like looking at it from an emotional state.
Copy. He assumes much, and he assumed much of me. He's probably so sure he's right, but gets easily frustrated when people just don't see his point. Well, maybe they have no merit, or he should look to substantiate them. Everyone is entitled to their opinions, including those based on emotion, but that's not a good foundation to present your views in hopes of swaying people to see your side. At least not for rational folks.
-
First, I apologize for some of those posts. I has some drinks (no excuse) and got heated. My bad on that.
Second, you tend to ASSUME a lot about folks. Hence my comments about your ignorance. You also seem to twist what people say either to try to "win" the argument through your views as well as insert your OPINIONS and/or perceptions of people and the world. I mean you're certainly free to make up your own mind, but you need to stop twisting what people say.
Third, I am not pro abortion. I am not anti abortion. In general, I am for the individual's right to decide what is best for them. Of course circumstances dependent. I am that way for 2a as well. My belief is that it's up the individual to decide what is best for them and hate when the "I know what is best for everyone" folks impose their values on everyone. You're doing the same thing even though you say you're "fighting for freedom".
Overall, on rights, IMO personal responsibility is huge. So when people demonstrate that they are incapable of responsible behavior, then I am for limiting or even taking away of privileges of those freedoms, but have to be very careful on that. I actually haven't read that deeply into ACB's background, but my point in this thread was IF ACB said she is capable of setting aside her religious beliefs and do her JOB, why are you so irrationally against her? And again, what do you have to substantiate your accusation that ACB will NOT be capable of performing her duties as Supreme Court Justice without religious bias?
Last, you appear to have ASSUMED that "literally spelt out religious bias", I can tell you beyond a shadow of a doubt that religion does not sway my professional decisions. I am not a particularly religious person. I am a person of principle shaped by life experiences. You seem to lump me into religious, which is simply not the case. You just assumed. . . again, ignorance. Personally, there was a time when I detested religion as IMO it forced itself upon people. I've come to appreciate certain aspects of religion, all religions. That you seem to be so irrationally stuck on religion, again, you're totally missing key points. That's your right to live life ignorant, just don't expect society to just accept that. You may view that as people being mean or toxic, but have you every considered your personal responsibilities?
You accuse me of shoving my head in the sand and blindly follow. Uh huh. I think I am pretty open minded and can appreciate other points of views. That said, trust but verify. Actually, my views on abortion aren't that different from yours. I was just pointing out HOW you seem to go about presenting your side seems hugely ignorant.
I realize you are correct I have grouped a lot of you into one group to make for simplicity in arguments. That's my bad. As for assumptions, I don't know or cant track everyone's individual opinions and feelings on everything. There has to be some level of assuming.
Thanks to your post I realize I might have come one of my more hated tendencies. I personally think grouping people together for semi similar beliefs is wrong and is what is destroying America. I am guilty of this too. I will do my best to separate out everyone's differencing beliefs. Thanks to this retrospect I actually realize now how America has been so divided. Its always us for them. Though my opinions on this forum appear to be different than most which enables you all to disagree as one unison voice. I shouldn't defend based on that. I take pride in being independent and realize that I has not been upholding my standards.
Copy. He assumes much, and he assumed much of me. He's probably so sure he's right, but gets easily frustrated when people just don't see his point. Well, maybe they have no merit, or he should look to substantiate them. Everyone is entitled to their opinions, including those based on emotion, but that's not a good foundation to present your views in hopes of swaying people to see your side. At least not for rational folks.
I think returning to post #300 will be a good way to reset this topic to less emotional state He has worded it far better than I have. I was trying to get that point across.
-
Why is there is a Left and Right court?
Shouldn’t the Court be impartial ?
How do do we get 5-4 votes from some of the sharpest minds in the judiciary ?
I agree with this 100%
-
Why is there is a Left and Right court?
Shouldn’t the Court be impartial ?
How do do we get 5-4 votes from some of the sharpest minds in the judiciary ?
noun
noun: judgement
1.
the ability to make considered decisions or come to sensible conclusions.
"an error of judgment"
Sensible is the key, IMO.
Have you ever taken courses on management? I've discussed this in other threads and with many friends. Ever taken the Meyers Brigg personality test? It's about 40 questions and pretty interesting when you see the results of self evaluation and well as others. There are folks that I work with that are super nice, but when we discuss work, it seems like they are on a totally different planet. It's usually in the last two aspects of the profile (there are four "ratings") that where if you're different, you can see problems from VASTLY different perspectives and hence, approach them differently.
Do some Justices have their opinions swayed by personal biases? I think so. But CAN they set aside their biases and do their job? I think many can. But the issue with ACB is can she? WRT to 2a, it appears that ACB would lean toward maintaining, even broadening 2a rights, as an "originalist".
Described by the National Review as a “champion of originalism,” Barrett was the lone dissenter in a case last year that upheld a U.S. District Court ruling that barred a Wisconsin man from owning a firearm because he was convicted of felony mail fraud. Barret wrote that the Second Amendment “confers an individual right, intimately connected with the natural right of self-defense and not limited to civic participation,” an opinion several legal experts told Guns and America, places her outside the mainstream of judges. In a May 2019 interview, Barrett focused on the importance of founding-era history to her Second Amendment analysis and described herself as an originalist.
https://wamu.org/story/20/09/29/amy-coney-barrett-could-reshape-interpretation-of-the-second-amendment/ (https://wamu.org/story/20/09/29/amy-coney-barrett-could-reshape-interpretation-of-the-second-amendment/)
-
noun
noun: judgement
1.
the ability to make considered decisions or come to sensible conclusions.
"an error of judgment"
Sensible is the key, IMO.
Have you ever taken courses on management? I've discussed this in other threads and with many friends. Ever taken the Meyers Brigg personality test? It's about 40 questions and pretty interesting when you see the results of self evaluation and well as others. There are folks that I work with that are super nice, but when we discuss work, it seems like they are on a totally different planet. It's usually in the last two aspects of the profile (there are four "ratings") that where if you're different, you can see problems from VASTLY different perspectives and hence, approach them differently.
Do some Justices have their opinions swayed by personal biases? I think so. But CAN they set aside their biases and do their job? I think many can. But the issue with ACB is can she? WRT to 2a, it appears that ACB would lean toward maintaining, even broadening 2a rights, as an "originalist".
https://wamu.org/story/20/09/29/amy-coney-barrett-could-reshape-interpretation-of-the-second-amendment/ (https://wamu.org/story/20/09/29/amy-coney-barrett-could-reshape-interpretation-of-the-second-amendment/)
Curious you mention that. I am intj. What is everyone else?
https://www.16personalities.com/intj-personality
-
I am going to condense some of my posts into this one. Antisepsis is absolutely right here. Well worded.
This brings up an important question. Inspector/Flapp, if you believe that abortions should be state rights, do you also believe firearm control should be too? You cant have only one side. In this case just like a state like Georgia can place major restrictions on abortion making it a defacto ban. Hawaii can do the exact same with guns.
I believe both should be protected federally for everyone. If only I worded it as such we probably could of avoided much of the heartache of this thread. I think no matter if you are against abortion for religious or scientific views. You should support the ability for all individuals in any state to make up their decision on what they believe if its prochoice or prolife on their own. Same with free speech, gun rights etc. It should be protected choice of freedom nationwide.
This applies to the press and everything. The left super liberals news have as much right to run as the right conservative news. You may hate on the other but you should protect their right to exist. Same with guns and everything. You can't pick and choose freedom.
I know what you are trying to say, but need to be very careful with the last.
-
I know what you are trying to say, but need to be very careful with the last.
What do you mean. Do you think you can pick and choose freedom? I don't understand what you are alluding to.
-
Curious you mention that. I am intj. What is everyone else?
https://www.16personalities.com/intj-personality
I am ENTJ. I think I am close to middle-ground on the N/S and I think I've has ESTJ before. I've found if folks are different in the last two, that tends to lead to a "WTF are they thinking" initial reaction. BUT, after some explanation, I usually see the merits. However, if folks are also far extreme on the middle two N/S and F/T, that can lead to a "WTF are they thinking" reaction as well.
-
Curious you mention that. I am intj. What is everyone else?
https://www.16personalities.com/intj-personality
istj-a
-
What do you mean. Do you think you can pick and choose freedom? I don't understand what you are alluding to.
How do you define freedom? Freedom to "do what you want"?
Freedom as laid out by the Constitution?
You seem to be the freedom to do what one wants type. Then again, freedom comes with personal responsibilities. At least IMO. It's when people have demonstrated that they are incapable of that is when many problems arise.
-
istj-a
Bwahahahaha. "asshole" subtype. . . ;D
:rofl:
-
I am ENTJ. I think I am close to middle-ground on the N/S and I think I've has ESTJ before. I've found if folks are different in the last two, that tends to lead to a "WTF are they thinking" initial reaction. BUT, after some explanation, I usually see the merits. However, if folks are also far extreme on the middle two N/S and F/T, that can lead to a "WTF are they thinking" reaction as well.
I am close to ENTJ a previous test had me get that result. I understand, sometimes I have a hard time to tell how others think. Doesn't help i don't have all that much empathy.
-
How do you define freedom? Freedom to "do what you want"?
Freedom as laid out by the Constitution?
You seem to be the freedom to do what one wants type. Then again, freedom comes with personal responsibilities. At least IMO. It's when people have demonstrated that they are incapable of that is when many problems arise.
I personally believe in freedom to do what one wants. BUT a HUGE caveat is that it must not affect the freedoms of another person.
AKA own all the guns you want yourself. But if you use them to deprive someone else of their freedom (rob, murder, etc) is very bad.
So i see nothing wrong with abortion for any reason including your own mistakes. As your abortion has zero impact on my life or anyone elses.
-
Inspector is right. The supreme court can't just magically overturn Roe v. Wade because they composition of the justices is different. A case in controversy needs to work its way up to the Supreme Court, and the Supreme Court would have to overrule their own precedent established in Roe v. Wade. Both of these are extremely unlikely, if not impossible due to the existence of the other. The Supreme Court can't have a case in controversy over a subject that's already been decided, and they can't decide on something (again) without a case in controversy. At best, someone could bring a case along the peripherals like Planned Parenthood v. Casey. In Casey, the state didn't outright ban abortions, but instead created obstacles like waiting periods and requiring parental consent and this was ruled constitutional. So there are ways to attack abortion along the borders, but there are balances to keep these in check. Also with the way the Supreme Court works, this would be years and years away.
Additionally, even though abortion was not protected by the Constitution outright in specific language, it can still fall under the penumbra of constitutional protections (Griswold v. Connecticut). In the same way the constitution did not specifically say speech over the internet is protected under the first amendment, or semi-automatic firearms are protected under the second amendment, there can be a logical inference that they fall within the constitutional shadow and are thus protected.
Also, of interesting relevance to us here in the firearms community, abortion and gun control are basically the same argument from polar opposite sides:
Primary argument: "We need to ban (guns/abortions) for the sake of the children"
Courts rule: "no you can't ban (guns/abortions) outright, but states can make their own policies."
Individual states: "Well we don't like (guns/abortions) so we're gonna throw up obstacles like waiting periods, and mandatory classes, and proof of competency, and make it really hard to have (guns/abortions) in our state."
Believing the federal government or states should have the right to restrict one and not the other is quite hypocritical.
I am going to condense some of my posts into this one. (edited and reposted with a more detailed post) Antisepsis is absolutely right here. Well worded.
This brings up an important question. Inspector/Flapp/Everyone, if you believe that abortions should be state rights, do you also believe firearm control should be too? What about free speech can some states have varying laws on the definition of free speech? You cant have only one side. In this case just like a state like Georgia can place major restrictions on abortion making it a defacto ban. Hawaii can do the exact same with guns.
I believe both should be protected federally for everyone. If only I worded it as such we probably could of avoided much of the heartache of this thread. I think no matter if you are against abortion for religious or scientific views. You should support the ability for all individuals in any state to make up their decision on what they believe if its prochoice or prolife on their own. Who gets to draw the line? I have asked before but no one answered, if you did a test on your partner and the baby had genetic or physical deformities will it be okay to have an abortion then? I know people mentioned rape or incest. But why is that so special? If you truly believe all fetuses are 100% alive and human isn't that still murder? Who gets to draw the line? Who gets decide what they can pick and choose what people can do? You can't only have the things you want. Same with free speech, gun rights etc. It should be protected choice of freedom nationwide. Only you should decide what you morally believe in. Don't force your beliefs on anyone else, whether you believe it religious or scientific.
It is your right to decide for yourself. This applies to the press and everything. The left super liberals news have as much right to run as the right conservative news. You may hate on the other but you should protect their right to exist. Same with guns and everything. You can't pick and choose freedom. In the sense that you can't get some things while depriving others of other things.
AKA you cant limit someone from saying something if you don't agree with them. I would dare to go to the extremes of hate speech is free speech. I may personally think you are an utter dumbass. But you have the right to say all the stupid incorrect shit you want.
drck1000 asked what freedom I believe in, I personally believe in freedom to do what one wants. BUT a HUGE caveat is that it must not affect the freedoms of another person.
AKA own all the guns you want yourself. But if you use them to deprive someone else of their freedom (rob, murder, etc) is very bad.
So i see nothing wrong with abortion for any reason including your own mistakes. As your abortion has zero impact on my life or anyone else's. It is your decision and yours alone. If you make a decision you must find people to support that. AKA if you want an abortion find a doctor freely willing to give you one. Don't force all doctors to do it or force tax payers to pay for the abortions themselves.
Even if you believe in personal responsibility for your actions, people have the right to be irresponsible. As long as that doesn't have an impact on your rights/freedom. I am not arguing about responsibility or lack of, is relevant to this topic. I personally believe in safe sex and being responsible in that sense and have practiced it and had no issues. But that's my personal choice, I cant force that upon others. IF they decide to have unsafe sex then they run the risks of pregnancy or STI's. Then its their own responsibility to fix those issues. Hopefully they will learn but you can't force them. These rights should transcends states. Just like how (Assuming) everyone here believes that gun rights are protected everywhere. Hawaii cant ban guns and another state cant just allow it. Antithesis again perfectly illustrated it, though I am leaning more toward protected federally and less on the states choosing for various reasons that I mentioned. I personally don't agree that either issue (guns or abortion) is a states issue. But I digress.
I know some may bring up the fact that its not expressively protected under the constitution but like Antithesis pointed out internet speech wasn't either. The constitution is a perfect foundation for a great nation. But our forefathers could not predict the future much less 200 years later. What technology and advances have come.
I know FLAPP has gone to the farm to relax, so I summarized most of my opinions in this one post if he or others dare to respond. I apologize for the long rough journey here. I mean no ill will to anyone here.
-
Curious you mention that. I am intj. What is everyone else?
https://www.16personalities.com/intj-personality
I'm INFJ-A
introverted, intuitive, feeling, and judging
Funny that I suceeded in the engineering professions
software and electronics. I must have mellowed with age.
The test suggested I become a doctor with my personality,
I thought about becoming a doctor when I was younger,
but decided I really didn't
like people all THAT much.
I wanted to fix/make things that didn't talk back or complain.
I don't think the test means much.
Just for grins I went back and took test giving the answers
I would have given at age 17
I came back as ISTJ-A
Mac and I have something in common.
-
Bwahahahaha. "asshole" subtype. . . ;D
:rofl:
most people are shocked that i am an introvert
not very many are shocked that i am an asshole...
-
most people are shocked that i am an introvert
not very many are shocked that i am an asshole...
ISTP-A Decided to recheck my @sshole quotient.
Still good I suppose, hope my anti-social score is still up there.
-
Yeah, I tire easily of his emotional feelings about things with no basis in reality.
Fairly well sums up most rabid liberals and too many democrats.
Often wonder what Harry Truman would think of the current democrats.
-
I'm INFJ-A
introverted, intuitive, feeling, and judging
Funny that I suceeded in the engineering professions
software and electronics. I must have mellowed with age.
The test suggested I become a doctor with my personality,
I thought about becoming a doctor when I was younger,
but decided I really didn't
like people all THAT much.
I wanted to fix/make things that didn't talk back or complain.
I don't think the test means much.
Just for grins I went back and took test giving the answers
I would have given at age 17
I came back as ISTJ-A
Mac and I have something in common.
That’s the “F” side coming out. You sound very much like a female marine biologist I used to work with.
It’s not about the meaning of the test. Well, at least not for determining career path. The point I was making it is CAN shed light on different perspectives of people. In the work context, as well as life. Not end all be all of meaning.
Interestingly my profile changed from when I first took the test maybe 10+ years ago to recently. Then also it changes if I respond from a work context to personal.
-
most people are shocked that i am an introvert
not very many are shocked that i am an asshole...
not shocked that you’re an introvert. Totally shocked that you’re not a -sa
“Super” ;D
-
That’s the “F” side coming out. You sound very much like a female marine biologist I used to work with.
It’s not about the meaning of the test. Well, at least not for determining career path. The point I was making it is CAN shed light on different perspectives of people. In the work context, as well as life. Not end all be all of meaning.
Interestingly my profile changed from when I first took the test maybe 10+ years ago to recently. Then also it changes if I respond from a work context to personal.
"it changes if I respond from a work context to personal"
That is exactly what I did with the test.
First score was from my work perspective.
Second was from my personal perspective.
Good observations on your part.
I want to be an asshole, but rarely do you get
ahead in the world if you go through
life acting that way.
-
It’s rare that it happens but people change.
Life experiences such as parenthood is a life changing experience. Omnigun, you won’t know parenthood from that perspective until you one day have to care for and be responsible for someone who is completely dependent on you for their survival such as a tiny baby which you call a parasite. Some people count this experience as growing up. You won’t really know this strong bond of parenthood until you have one of your own. Some people become parents but never develop this strong bond, but others do.
What goes around comes around. Helpless children eventually grow up and some take care of their parents. It’s important to instill strong family values as it is what makes the world go around.
Omnigun, don’t be so fast to to discount people’s religious beliefs just because it is not yours. Religion is not an “opiate for the masses” just as babies are not “parasites”. A belief in the almighty is a great source of strength and hope for people, just as a baby brought up well can be an asset instead of a liability to you and your life.
This greatly depends on your attitude, perspective as to how you see your reality and the world you live in.
Consider a story from the Bible of Saul of Tarsus who was one of the greatest and fanatical prosecutor of the “radical followers of Jesus”. He pursued the early Christians until he ran head on into Jesus, became blind and was restored. He did a complete 180 degree and became one of Christianity’s strongest advocates writing a lot of the epistles in the New Testament. An encounter with the divine is a life changing experience and your life changes when you have one of those.
-
"it changes if I respond from a work context to personal"
That is exactly what I did with the test.
First score was from my work perspective.
Second was from my personal perspective.
Good observations on your part.
I want to be an asshole, but rarely do you get
ahead in the world if you go through
life acting that way.
I never put much stock in these standardized personality tests
Personality and other traits are usually situational. Solutions can be technical, creative, objective, subjective, logical, emotional, etc, etc.
Context is king. I find others, as well as myself, will adapt to the situation in order to better understand the problem and assess a proper set of potential solutions.
If someone is failing at work, it might be fixed with training. Or they may be having personal problems affecting performance, which may require professional counseling or simply taking time to talk to them. They might even be unhappy with you or the other employees. If they can't communicate with you what the actual problem is, maybe a move to another office, or even leaving, is the best solution (doesn't solve the underlying problem, but sometimes you have to sever the limb to stop the infection).
Working in an office takes a different set of skills than being on the road all the time. So does working alone versus supervising a large team. Too many scenarios to list.
It all comes down to your ability to adapt to a given situation and apply what you already know. Just because you tested in a mostly technical, logical, analytical quadrant does not mean you lack the emotional, feeling, empathetic characteristics. A good leader and manager is well-rounded, having a broad range of knowledge.
Jack of all trades, master of few.
These tests are mostly for managers. These are blunt tools that let managers pigeonhole employees so they might better understand what is needed to motivate their workers and whether a person is more suited a given task over others.
You manage things. You lead people.
-
It’s rare that it happens but people change.
Life experiences such as parenthood is a life changing experience. Omnigun, you won’t know parenthood from that perspective until you one day have to care for and be responsible for someone who is completely dependent on you for their survival such as a tiny baby which you call a parasite. Some people count this experience as growing up. You won’t really know this strong bond of parenthood until you have one of your own. Some people become parents but never develop this strong bond, but others do.
What goes around comes around. Helpless children eventually grow up and some take care of their parents. It’s important to instill strong family values as it is what makes the world go around.
Omnigun, don’t be so fast to to discount people’s religious beliefs just because it is not yours. Religion is not an “opiate for the masses” just as babies are not “parasites”. A belief in the almighty is a great source of strength and hope for people, just as a baby brought up well can be an asset instead of a liability to you and your life.
This greatly depends on your attitude, perspective as to how you see your reality and the world you live in.
Consider a story from the Bible of Saul of Tarsus who was one of the greatest and fanatical prosecutor of the “radical followers of Jesus”. He pursued the early Christians until he ran head on into Jesus, became blind and was restored. He did a complete 180 degree and became one of Christianity’s strongest advocates writing a lot of the epistles in the New Testament. An encounter with the divine is a life changing experience and your life changes when you have one of those.
As with my recent summarization. https://2ahawaii.com/index.php?topic=38106.msg340489#msg340489 I most mostly fighting for the "rights" of others/everyone. I've never had to use abortion services and I never plan to. Parasite language was a bit harsh i was heated. I will see if being a parent which I hopefully will be with my GF one day will change me but even if does. I don't believe I will ever change fighting for someone else's right to get an abortion. Even if I personally one day find god, discover some science or get a change of heart. Its more of a freedom principle thing. Much like free speech and the right to own firearms. If I do change on that view I just become another hypocrite. You cant be pro gun and anti abortion.
On a side not even if I have kids I have no expectations for them to be forced to take care of me. I am happy to go to a care home. Family values don't have to be religion based. I plan to raise my children agnostic but if they find religion as long as its not a cult that's their own freewill.
While religion can be a force for good, it can also be a force for evil just as easily. I remain neutral, others can practice it and I will find out the truth if I die.
-
Not if but when.
Death is the only certain thing. And taxes. :Shaka:
-
Not if but when.
Death is the only certain thing. And taxes. :Shaka:
:rofl: Lowkey I hope technology advances to a point I am no longer mortal. Via robotics or uploading my consciousness. Its not out of realm to solve death in my timeframe.
-
You cant be pro gun federally and anti abortion state supporter.
I would re-think this assumption as there are a lot of people who are strongly pro-gun who are also pro-life (anti-abortion).
-
I would re-think this assumption as there are a lot of people who are strongly pro-gun who are also pro-life (anti-abortion).
https://2ahawaii.com/index.php?topic=38106.msg340489#msg340489
TLDR you cant be pro states rights for abortion but anti states rights for gun control. Its a bit hypocritical to be both.
If you believe the state should have the undeniable rights to regulate abortion, theoretically you should support its rights to gun control.
If you want to guarantee the rights of all to firearms, you should guarantee the rights to pro-choice for all.
-
You cant be pro gun and anti abortion.
I'm pro-gun because I believe in protecting life.
I'm pro-life for the same reason.
You need to stop trying to speak in absolutes. You're not very good at it.
Gun rights are natural, god-given rights protected under the Constitution. Therefore, a federal issue.
Abortion is not a natural, god-given right, nor is it protected under the Constitution. Therefore, a state issue.
As Ginsburg said, the Roe decision affirmed the right of DOCTORS to perform abortions. It in no way affirmed a woman's right to have an abortion. Maybe a distinction without a difference to you, but it demonstrates the Liberal pro-abortion framing of the issue, and how the "Constitutional" right to privacy BS was just that.
-
Raising a child is not just about having a nanny to take care of you in old age. I know of many good parents who take good care of their children and pay for their own care home in their old age.
There are many rich experiences you get to have with your children as you grow up together, them as a child and you as an adult. Responsibility for them and concern for their future is a very humbling experience and you realize how short of a life we have and how little we have control of anything.
There’s another Greek proverb that come to mind.
“A society grows great when old men plant trees whose shade they know they shall never sit in.”
-
I'm pro-gun because I believe in protecting life.
I'm pro-life for the same reason.
You need to stop trying to speak in absolutes. You're not very good at it.
Gun rights are natural, god-given rights protected under the Constitution. Therefore, a federal issue.
Abortion is not a natural, god-given right, nor is it protected under the Constitution. Therefore, a state issue.
As Ginsburg said, the Roe decision affirmed the right of DOCTORS to perform abortions. It in no way affirmed a woman's right to have an abortion. Maybe a distinction without a difference to you, but it demonstrates the Liberal pro-abortion framing of the issue, and how the "Constitutional" right to privacy BS was just that.
Just like I said previously and the other user pointed out the constitution isn't infallible and couldn't predict everything in the future. Just like free speech the internet it can be interpreted for modern times.
This right of privacy, whether it be founded in the Fourteenth Amendment's concept of personal liberty and restrictions upon state action, as we feel it is, or ... in the Ninth Amendment's reservation of rights to the people, is broad enough to encompass a woman's decision whether or not to terminate her pregnancy.
— Roe, 410 U.S. at 153.
A State may properly assert important interests in safeguarding health, maintaining medical standards, and in protecting potential life. At some point in pregnancy, these respective interests become sufficiently compelling to sustain regulation of the factors that govern the abortion decision. ... We, therefore, conclude that the right of personal privacy includes the abortion decision, but that this right is not unqualified and must be considered against important state interests in regulation.
— Roe, 410 U.S. at 154.
We need not resolve the difficult question of when life begins. When those trained in the respective disciplines of medicine, philosophy, and theology are unable to arrive at any consensus, the judiciary, in this point in the development of man's knowledge, is not in a position to speculate as to the answer.
— Roe, 410 U.S. at 159.[54]
A state criminal abortion statute of the current Texas type, that excepts from criminality only a life-saving procedure on behalf of the mother, without regard to pregnancy stage and without recognition of the other interests involved, is violative of the Due Process Clause of the Fourteenth Amendment.
— Roe, 410 U.S. at 164.
You keep saying doctor, doctor, doctor. I don't see this. Its a personal privacy right protected under the 14th amendment. Just like how internet speech is covered under the 1st.
TLDR both are Federally protected.
-
Raising a child is not just about having a nanny to take care of you in old age. I know of many good parents who take good care of their children and pay for their own care home in their old age.
There are many rich experiences you get to have with your children as you grow up together, them as a child and you as an adult. Responsibility for them and concern for their future is a very humbling experience and you realize how short of a life we have and how little we have control of anything.
There’s another Greek proverb that come to mind.
“A society grows great when old men plant trees whose shade they know they shall never sit in.”
I am not arguing against this. I completely agree. Kids can be very rewarding. I wish to leave the world a better place then when I got here and for my kids to have a better future than myself. Its partly why I desire to have kids.
But one major thing is I want my kids to have more freedom than myself. I feel we have lost a bit in my generation. I want to regain that for them and for the next generation.
-
Just like I said previously and the other user pointed out the constitution isn't infallible and couldn't predict everything in the future. Just like free speech the internet it can be interpreted for modern times.
This right of privacy, whether it be founded in the Fourteenth Amendment's concept of personal liberty and restrictions upon state action, as we feel it is, or ... in the Ninth Amendment's reservation of rights to the people, is broad enough to encompass a woman's decision whether or not to terminate her pregnancy.
— Roe, 410 U.S. at 153.
A State may properly assert important interests in safeguarding health, maintaining medical standards, and in protecting potential life. At some point in pregnancy, these respective interests become sufficiently compelling to sustain regulation of the factors that govern the abortion decision. ... We, therefore, conclude that the right of personal privacy includes the abortion decision, but that this right is not unqualified and must be considered against important state interests in regulation.
— Roe, 410 U.S. at 154.
We need not resolve the difficult question of when life begins. When those trained in the respective disciplines of medicine, philosophy, and theology are unable to arrive at any consensus, the judiciary, in this point in the development of man's knowledge, is not in a position to speculate as to the answer.
— Roe, 410 U.S. at 159.[54]
You keep saying doctor, doctor, doctor. I don't see this. Its a personal privacy right protected under the 14th amendment. Just like how internet speech is covered under the 1st.
You're wrong. The majority of legal scholars agree with me -- as did RBG. The issue gave doctors the right to perform abortions. By extension, it legalized the procedure for BOTH patients and providers. How difficult is it for you to wrap your head around that FACT!!??
As for your CONTINUED harping on Internet free speech, it's the court's realm to rule on that. It's a particular medium of communication at issue, not whether the right to free speech exists.
You have one thing you said half right: the framers of the Constitution knew the document would not cover every possible question. They therefore, in their humility and wisdom, left us an "escape clause: The Constitution can be CHANGED. They made the process difficult, so that it isn't changed by a tiny majority, but by the overwhelming majority of states. If abortion is truly a right based on a woman's autonomous control over her own body AND NOTHING ELSE, then there should be an amendment put forth and debated. I don't see that happening. What I see is a bunch of activists screaming to hang on to the existing victory handed to them by the court with zero interest in addressing the underlying questions in open and honest debate. They, like you, will always retreat to the same talking points, including "The Supreme Court said so!!" :wacko:
-
You're wrong. The majority of legal scholars agree with me -- as did RBG. The issue gave doctors the right to perform abortions. By extension, it legalized the procedure for BOTH patients and providers. How difficult is it for you to wrap your head around that FACT!!??
As for your CONTINUED harping on Internet free speech, it's the court's realm to rule on that. It's a particular medium of communication at issue, not whether the right to free speech exists.
You have one thing you said half right: the framers of the Constitution knew the document would not cover every possible question. They therefore, in their humility and wisdom, left us an "escape clause: The Constitution can be CHANGED. They made the process difficult, so that it isn't changed by a tiny majority, but by the overwhelming majority of states. If abortion is truly a right based on a woman's autonomous control over her own body AND NOTHING ELSE, then there should be an amendment put forth and debated. I don't see that happening. What I see is a bunch of activists screaming to hang on to the existing victory handed to them by the court with zero interest in addressing the underlying questions in open and honest debate. They, like you, will always retreat to the same talking points, including "The Supreme Court said so!!" :wacko:
I will agree with both, its a privacy right of the patient and the doctor. What's wrong with that? The government has no right to snoop into my computer much less the right to snoop into my medical files or procedures. It extends to both patients and doctors as intended. And i think it perfectly fits in the 14th amendment.
I am completely open to changing the constitution to update to our times. I think that would be a wonderful thing. We can add to the second to clariy without a doubt all arms. We can expand free speech. We can guarantee the right to our own bodies. We can cancel the patriot act and permanently restore more rights to Americans.
But for now, like the 1st and 2nd. The 14th and all the prochoice it brings should be federally protected. Until it comes to a time where we change the constitution to fit. I hope we lean to a more freedom based changes but the prolife side like yourself might change it in that direction.
-
You're wrong. The majority of legal scholars agree with me -- as did RBG. The issue gave doctors the right to perform abortions. By extension, it legalized the procedure for BOTH patients and providers. How difficult is it for you to wrap your head around that FACT!!??
As for your CONTINUED harping on Internet free speech, it's the court's realm to rule on that. It's a particular medium of communication at issue, not whether the right to free speech exists.
You have one thing you said half right: the framers of the Constitution knew the document would not cover every possible question. They therefore, in their humility and wisdom, left us an "escape clause: The Constitution can be CHANGED. They made the process difficult, so that it isn't changed by a tiny majority, but by the overwhelming majority of states. If abortion is truly a right based on a woman's autonomous control over her own body AND NOTHING ELSE, then there should be an amendment put forth and debated. I don't see that happening. What I see is a bunch of activists screaming to hang on to the existing victory handed to them by the court with zero interest in addressing the underlying questions in open and honest debate. They, like you, will always retreat to the same talking points, including "The Supreme Court said so!!" :wacko:
Seems like you had a 12-24 hr bug. . .
:rofl:
-
Ruth Bader Ginsburg wasn’t really fond of Roe v. Wade, the landmark Supreme Court decision that in 1973
established a constitutional right to abortion. She didn’t like how it was structured.
The ruling, she noted in a lecture at New York University in 1992, tried to do too much, too fast — it essentially
made every abortion restriction in the country at the time illegal in one fell swoop — leaving it open to fierce attacks.
https://www.nytimes.com/2020/09/21/us/ruth-bader-ginsburg-roe-v-wade.html
-
Seems like you had a 12-24 hr bug. . .
:rofl:
Just poking the bear (teddy bear). :popcorn: :popcorn: :popcorn:
-
The issue about abortion has nothing to do with gun rights.
The pro-choice / pro-life issue is about whose right supersedes the other (the mother’s or the baby’s)?
An abortion choice is a death sentence for the child who will have no future after that. A life choice is not necessarily a life ending experience for the mom, it may be harder and a long inconvenience but not necessarily a fatal result for the mom.
A rhetorical question... Whose right is more important - your daughter’s right to abort your grandchild or your grandchild’s right to live?
I do not want to belabor this and do not expect an answer from you but I just want you to think about it.
-
@omnigun
Answer this question.
Q: Should the state or federal government arrest and punish someone who tortures their own cat or dog to death?
Based on your "values", the individual's freedom to do what they want should reign supreme as long as he's not violating the rights of another human being.
What's your answer?
-
I will agree with both, its a privacy right of the patient and the doctor. What's wrong with that? The government has no right to snoop into my computer much less the right to snoop into my medical files or procedures. It extends to both patients and doctors as intended. And i think it perfectly fits in the 14th amendment.
I am completely open to changing the constitution to update to our times. I think that would be a wonderful thing. We can add to the second to clariy without a doubt all arms. We can expand free speech. We can guarantee the right to our own bodies. We can cancel the patriot act and permanently restore more rights to Americans.
But for now, like the 1st and 2nd. The 14th and all the prochoice it brings should be federally protected. Until it comes to a time where we change the constitution to fit. I hope we lean to a more freedom based changes but the prolife side like yourself might change it in that direction.
DOCTORS are not covered by privacy laws (doctor-patient privilege). The privilege applies only to the patient. If a patient waives their right, the doctor has no choice but to provide the information being sought by the government.
^^^^
In short, THIS is what's wrong with THAT.
-
It seems to me we've raised generations of children who are well aware of their rights and freedoms (many of which don't actually exist, like the right to free healthcare and college),
but they skipped the day their teachers taught responsibility.
When I grew up, I had the freedom to use my mom's car whenever I needed as long as I came home in time for her to leave for work, and it had the same amount of gasoline, or more, as when I took it.
If either rule was broken, I lost driving privileges for a length of time.
These are the lessons that create mature, responsible and dependable individuals. Failure invites consequences. Responsible behavior is rewarded with continued liberties.
So simple, yet here we are with Mister "MUH FREEDOMS!!" teaching us how nothing else matters.
:sleeping:
-
Damn missed 2 days and over 100 post.
Sent from my SM-G950U using Tapatalk
-
Gun rights are natural, god-given rights protected under the Constitution. Therefore, a federal issue.
Abortion is not a natural, god-given right, nor is it protected under the Constitution. Therefore, a state issue.
Gun rights are natural, God-given ? God handed handed Adam a 12 gauge and said go forth and kill that rabbit? Adam picked that 12 gauge off a tree.
:wtf: Are you talking about?
It is a Constitutional Right.
Supreme Court decided abortion was a Constitutional Right.
DOCTORS are not covered by privacy laws (doctor-patient privilege). The privilege applies only to the patient. If a patient waives their right, the doctor has no choice but to provide the information being sought by the government.
^^^^
In short, THIS is what's wrong with THAT.
If a patient doesn’t waive it, then it is doctor-patient privilege. The Doctor has the privilege not to release any info based on patient privilege.
-
Gun rights are natural, God-given ? God handed handed Adam a 12 gauge and said go forth and kill that rabbit? Adam picked that 12 gauge off a tree.
SNIP
No, duh. Such blasphemy is mind boggling.
It was a Glock 😝
Nah, maybe a Colt SAA
-
Damn missed 2 days and over 100 post.
Lots of them are blocked now, much better after getting rid of the tiresome airhead millennial crap.
-
No, duh. Such blasphemy is mind boggling.
It was a Glock 😝
Nah, maybe a Colt SAA
:rofl: :thumbsup:
-
many of which don't actually exist, like the right to free healthcare and college
The result of the degradation of education by leftist teachers unions.
But, look at all that self esteem, all those participation ribbons, and media affirmation for being a well indoctrinated airhead.
-
Gun rights are natural, God-given ? God handed handed Adam a 12 gauge and said go forth and kill that rabbit? Adam picked that 12 gauge off a tree.
:wtf: Are you talking about?
It is a Constitutional Right.
Supreme Court decided abortion was a Constitutional Right.
If a patient doesn’t waive it, then it is doctor-patient privilege. The Doctor has the privilege not to release any info based on patient privilege.
The Supreme Court made a decision based on lies and a flimsy Constitutional redefining of privacy rights. Doesn't make it a perfect, or even a good, decision.
he Doctor has the privilege not to release any info based on patient privilege.
Are you really this ignorant?
Oh, yeah ...... you are.
The doctor has no "privilege", whether or not the patient waives privacy rights. The doctor has a DUTY to follow the law and protect the PATIENT'S right to privacy.
But, don't just take my word for it:
Physician–patient privilege is a legal concept, related to medical confidentiality, that protects communications
between a patient and their doctor from being used against the patient in court.
In the United States, the Federal Rules of Evidence do not recognize doctor–patient privilege.
At the state level, the extent of the privilege varies depending on the law of the applicable jurisdiction. For example, in
Texas there is only a limited physician–patient privilege in criminal proceedings, and the privilege is limited in civil cases
as well.[4]
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Physician%E2%80%93patient_privilege
Just because a doctor may use the physician-patient rules of evidence to conceal unethical or criminal behavior doesn't make the privilege his.
If the patient waives their privilege, then the doctor has no protection. Hence, the doctor had no such privilege at all -- ever.
-
Gun rights are natural, God-given ? God handed handed Adam a 12 gauge and said go forth and kill that rabbit? Adam picked that 12 gauge off a tree.
:wtf: Are you talking about?
It is a Constitutional Right.
Supreme Court decided abortion was a Constitutional Right.
If a patient doesn’t waive it, then it is doctor-patient privilege. The Doctor has the privilege not to release any info based on patient privilege.
Shh don't tell flap. He disagrees with that is a supreme court judge dont you know?
-
The Supreme Court made a decision based on lies and a flimsy Constitutional redefining of privacy rights. Doesn't make it a perfect, or even a good, decision.
Are you really this ignorant?
Oh, yeah ...... you are.
The doctor has no "privilege", whether or not the patient waives privacy rights. The doctor has a DUTY to follow the law and protect the PATIENT'S right to privacy.
But, don't just take my word for it:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Physician%E2%80%93patient_privilege
Just because a doctor may use the physician-patient rules of evidence to conceal unethical or criminal behavior doesn't make the privilege his.
If the patient waives their privilege, then the doctor has no protection. Hence, the doctor had no such privilege at all -- ever.
So you are flat out saying you want to put a judge in to overturn that "wrong" dicision you disagree with. You are as bias as you claim I am. But the difference is you have many people who agree with your views on abortion.
-
@omnigun
Answer this question.
Q: Should the state or federal government arrest and punish someone who tortures their own cat or dog to death?
Based on your "values", the individual's freedom to do what they want should reign supreme as long as he's not violating the rights of another human being.
What's your answer?
Hmmm, animals deserve a level of freedom higher than random cells but lower than humans. I would support minimal government intrusion. A crime is committed but not as serious as a if it were human.
-
Shh don't tell flap. He disagrees with that is a supreme court judge dont you know?
If you're trolling, you suck at it.
If you're just being a dick, we already have that part figured out. No need to oversell it! :popcorn:
-
The issue about abortion has nothing to do with gun rights.
The pro-choice / pro-life issue is about whose right supersedes the other (the mother’s or the baby’s)?
An abortion choice is a death sentence for the child who will have no future after that. A life choice is not necessarily a life ending experience for the mom, it may be harder and a long inconvenience but not necessarily a fatal result for the mom.
A rhetorical question... Whose right is more important - your daughter’s right to abort your grandchild or your grandchild’s right to live?
I do not want to belabor this and do not expect an answer from you but I just want you to think about it.
I am not arguing when people believe life begins because its impossible to win. Everyone has their own opinions. What I am arguing is for self determination with adherence to the 14th amendment. And other American amendments. Its not your right or anyone else right to tell someone what to do.
Tell me this, with your religious views. Is abortion ok in the circumstances of incest, rape? What about if its physically or genetically deformed? So far no one has answered me because they know they are all hypocrites. If its truly alive as you all say, then any abortion for any reason is murder.
As to answer that, my daughters right is far more important, I don't view the grandchild to exist until a period of time near birth.
-
So you are flat out saying you want to put a judge in to overturn that "wrong" dicision you disagree with. You are as bias as you claim I am. But the difference is you have many people who agree with your views on abortion.
WTF does this comment even mean? Is there a point?
-
DOCTORS are not covered by privacy laws (doctor-patient privilege). The privilege applies only to the patient. If a patient waives their right, the doctor has no choice but to provide the information being sought by the government.
^^^^
In short, THIS is what's wrong with THAT.
So if a patient demands to remain private isn't that literally perfectly fine? And can be used for abortion. I don't understand an issue here. Most patients want to remain private. We already confirmed the patient has the right to remain private.
-
Hmmm, animals deserve a level of freedom higher than random cells but lower than humans. I would support minimal government intrusion. A crime is committed but not as serious as a if it were human.
Animals are considered by the courts (especially pets) as "property." Animals are not protected under the Constitution. They therefore have no "freedoms" as protected by government.
On what do you base your opinion that laws should protect animals. Since the Constitution doesn't apply, from where does the power come to pass laws making it a crime to torture your pet?
-
Tell me this, with your religious views. Is abortion ok in the circumstances of incest, rape? What about if its physically or genetically deformed? So far no one has answered me because they know they are all hypocrites.
Each person will have to live with the choice they make. Others choose to give up unplanned pregnancies for adoption to families that cannot have their own and want to raise a child.
There are families that choose to have their genetically deformed or down syndrome children anyway and love them as their own. I have 2 sets of neighbors that have down syndrome children and I greatly respect them for raising and loving their children the way they do. It doesn’t seem right to generalize all people and it would be unfair to call everyone hypocrites.
If its truly alive as you all say, then any abortion for any reason is murder.
I would have to agree with you on this.
The one exception i can think of is when there is a medical situation where one is either going to have to choose to save the mother or child.
-
Animals are considered by the courts (especially pets) as "property." Animals are not protected under the Constitution. They therefore have no "freedoms" as protected by government.
On what do you base your opinion that laws should protect animals. Since the Constitution doesn't apply, from where does the power come to pass laws making it a crime to torture your pet?
States still have rights not all laws are the constitution. Just happens that abortion and the right to privacy is. And like you said torturing pets isn't in there either. So that means its states rights.
-
Each person will have to live with the choice they make. Others choose to give up unplanned pregnancies for adoption to families that cannot have their own and want to raise a child.
There are families that choose to have their genetically deformed or down syndrome children anyway and love them as their own. I have 2 sets of neighbors that have down syndrome children and I greatly respect them for raising and loving their children the way they do. It doesn’t seem right to generalize all people and it would be unfair to call everyone hypocrites.
I would have to agree with you on this.
The one exception i can think of is when there is a medical situation where one is either going to have to choose to save the mother or child.
While I don't agree with your views. I respect that you are constant. I am only calling those hypocrites when they say abortion is murder yet there are circumstances (commonly used, incest and rape) that magically don't make it. It very much is true whatever choice they make they have to live with. That's literally all I am supporting. Peoples right to choose.
I see your edit, I have a question on that. How do you weigh whos life is more "important" to save?
-
That question is a tough one... mother or child. That choice belongs to the mother and if she happened to be my wife, I would support whatever choice she makes, whether to save her life or save the child.
If my wife was incapacitated and the choice was mine to make, I would always choose to save my wife.
-
The Supreme Court made a decision based on lies and a flimsy Constitutional redefining of privacy rights. Doesn't make it a perfect, or even a good, decision.
Are you really this ignorant?
Oh, yeah ...... you are.
The doctor has no "privilege", whether or not the patient waives privacy rights. The doctor has a DUTY to follow the law and protect the PATIENT'S right to privacy.
But, don't just take my word for it:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Physician%E2%80%93patient_privilege
Just because a doctor may use the physician-patient rules of evidence to conceal unethical or criminal behavior doesn't make the privilege his.
If the patient waives their privilege, then the doctor has no protection. Hence, the doctor had no such privilege at all -- ever.
OK English Major.
Are semantics all you can really ever argue about and not substance ?
What if the patient doesn’t waive privilege does the doctor then have “duty” not “privilege “.
Talk about ignorant .... ( take Away your google......) do you form original thoughts ..?
Shh don't tell flap. He disagrees with that is a supreme court judge dont you know?
I think it was 5 Judges at least.
P.S.
Props to JL conversation as that’s kind of my thinking.
-
States still have rights not all laws are the constitution. Just happens that abortion and the right to privacy is. And like you said torturing pets isn't in there either. So that means its states rights.
You did NOT answer the question.
You just reiterated what I said, and then implied what you THINK i was looking for.
We now agree that the Constitution does not apply to animals -- only to human beings.
Whether the Feds or the States make laws against torturing animals is irrelevant.
What I asked is:
On what do you base your opinion that laws should protect animals?
Those laws can be at any level of government.
Answer the question I asked, not the one you think I'm going to ask next.
-
OK English Major.
Are semantics all you can really ever argue about and not substance ?
What if the patient doesn’t waive privilege does the doctor then have “duty” not “privilege “.
Talk about ignorant .... ( take Away your google......) do you form original thoughts ..?
I think it was 5 Judges at least.
P.S.
Props to JL conversation as that’s kind of my thinking.
Not semantics. Just plain English.
The facts are the facts. You stated them wrong -- doctors do not enjoy a physician-patient privilege. Just like lawyers. They, too, are bound by their DUTY under the law and professional ethics to keep client communications private. The attorney-client PRIVILEGE belongs to the client.
If you refuse to accept that you were wrong, then at least you're consistent on both points: being wrong and denying it.
Can you even use Google? Read? Understand English?
Look up the definitions yourself. If your parents and teachers didn't see fit to educate you, I'm sure as hell not about to try.
-
I am only calling those hypocrites when they say abortion is murder yet there are circumstances (commonly used, incest and rape) that magically don't make it.
Have you ever studied morality and ethics? If not, it explains why you'd have a problem understanding them.
People who have seemingly conflicting views morally are usually following their ethics.
Morals dictate what you see as right or wrong. Ethics is how you apply those morals in specific situations. Using the example of murder, I believe it is morally wrong to take a life, but I never said it was ethically wrong under all circumstances. If someone is threatening my life or the life of others, then I believe it's ethical to kill that person to prevent murder.
Same applies to abortion. While killing a fetus for most reasons is immoral, the exceptions you listed make the decision ethical.
Nothing hypocritical about that at all. Ignoring ethics while trying to trip someone up using moral arguments alone is a favorite tactic of many since too few seem to have an understanding of morals, ethics and their difference.
-
Have you ever studied morality and ethics? If not, it explains why you'd have a problem understanding them.
People who have seemingly conflicting views morally are usually following their ethics.
Morals dictate what you see as right or wrong. Ethics is how you apply those morals in specific situations. Using the example of murder, I believe it is morally wrong to take a life, but I never said it was ethically wrong under all circumstances. If someone is threatening my life or the life of others, then I believe it's ethical to kill that person to prevent murder.
Same applies to abortion. While killing a fetus for most reasons is immoral, the exceptions you listed make the decision ethical.
Nothing hypocritical about that at all. Ignoring ethics while trying to trip someone up using moral arguments alone is a favorite tactic of many since too few seem to have an understanding of morals, ethics and their difference.
It’s also easier to think one has the moral high ground and be uncompromising on those views when one hasn’t really lived life enough for experience to show otherwise. Especially true for those who have been living life fed by a golden spoon.
I dunno OG personally but he reminds me a lot of my buddies 18 yo son. So confident in himself because my buddies’ ex-wife’s family spoils him rotten and essentially having his way with everything. Life came so easy for him that he wasn’t able to see life through a different lens.
-
It’s also easier to think one has the moral high ground and be uncompromising on those views when one hasn’t really lived life enough for experience to show otherwise. Especially true for those who have been living life fed by a golden spoon.
I dunno OG personally but he reminds me a lot of my buddies 18 yo son. So confident in himself because my buddies’ ex-wife’s family spoils him rotten and essentially having his way with everything. Life came so easy for him that he wasn’t able to see life through a different lens.
I remember a million years ago when I was a young apprentice. It was pau hana time and back then the general contractor would allow the construction trades to drink and eat pupu and just shoot the shit after work.
The subject on hand was about people who grew up with "silver spoons in their mouth". Me in my young naive manner was being very vocal about my disdain for these type of people.
The superintendent lectured me cautioning me to not just pass these people off as snub nosed, entitled jerks because many times these people do not really know any better. It took the sup a very long time to make me understand how a person cannot correct themselves if they don't think they are doing or behaving badly.
Since then I try to be more understanding but once in a while you meet some who are just......... :grrr:
-
I remember a million years ago when I was a young apprentice. It was pau hana time and back then the general contractor would allow the construction trades to drink and eat pupu and just shoot the shit after work.
The subject on hand was about people who grew up with "silver spoons in their mouth". Me in my young naive manner was being very vocal about my disdain for these type of people.
The superintendent lectured me cautioning me to not just pass these people off as snub nosed, entitled jerks because many times these people do not really know any better. It took the sup a very long time to make me understand how a person cannot correct themselves if they don't think they are doing or behaving badly.
Since then I try to be more understanding but once in a while you meet some who are just......... :grrr:
No different than going to a friend's house for dinner, and the host's kids displaying table manners that would never be tolerated at your table.
The kids only knew what they had been taught. if their table behavior was incorrect according to "official" etiquette rules, it's not their fault as much as it is their parents'.
However, once the kid is old enough to go to dinners alone, observe others as they follow the rules and can find where they, too, can learn the rules, it's up to the kid to make the effort to learn on their own. There's nothing wrong with being ignorant. There is something wrong with never being taught that it's their responsibility to continue learning over the course of their lives.
Graduating High School or College is not an indication that you've learned everything you'll ever need to know.
(https://i.imgur.com/oPRxlv3.jpg)
-
I remember a million years ago when I was a young apprentice. It was pau hana time and back then the general contractor would allow the construction trades to drink and eat pupu and just shoot the shit after work.
The subject on hand was about people who grew up with "silver spoons in their mouth". Me in my young naive manner was being very vocal about my disdain for these type of people.
The superintendent lectured me cautioning me to not just pass these people off as snub nosed, entitled jerks because many times these people do not really know any better. It took the sup a very long time to make me understand how a person cannot correct themselves if they don't think they are doing or behaving badly.
Since then I try to be more understanding but once in a while you meet some who are just......... :grrr:
I said golden spoon because looking back, I grew up quite comfortable. I mean worked since I was 13 in a family business, but I pretty much had most things I wanted. I had to work for most of it, but I also had plenty of nice things. That said, I had plenty of “correction” from my parents and esp uncles growing up to put me in my place. I know they prob said similar things if me when I was growing up. While I don’t necessarily fault those who don’t know any better, I also don’t just tolerate it.
Same with my buddy’s son. When he was younger and would hang out with us, he would often get called out on the naive stuff he says. We mostly would just laugh it off as “one day he’ll learn”. Now that he’s older, there has been more than a few instances where he learned the hard way. His mother and her bf’s just want to be his friends and enable his entitled world views. Not necessarily a bad thing, but he also has burned bridges with his actions and attitude. He has since realized that and has started to try to mend things.
-
I said golden spoon because looking back, I grew up quite comfortable. I mean worked since I was 13 in a family business, but I pretty much had most things I wanted. I had to work for most of it, but I also had plenty of nice things. That said, I had plenty of “correction” from my parents and esp uncles growing up to put me in my place. I know they prob said similar things if me when I was growing up. While I don’t necessarily fault those who don’t know any better, I also don’t just tolerate it.
Same with my buddy’s son. When he was younger and would hang out with us, he would often get called out on the naive stuff he says. We mostly would just laugh it off as “one day he’ll learn”. Now that he’s older, there has been more than a few instances where he learned the hard way. His mother and her bf’s just want to be his friends and enable his entitled world views. Not necessarily a bad thing, but he also has burned bridges with his actions and attitude. He has since realized that and has started to try to mend things.
Military service is one of the best ways for young men and women to mature while having a safety net: food, clothing, lodging, medical, dental, ..... and skills training.
It wasn't that long ago high school grads couldn't wait to move out of their parents' home and be independent. Seems that norm has changed. Even the gov't wants kids on their parents' healthcare insurance until age 26 if they are in school. Eight years after HS, and still in school as a "child?" :wtf:
When I was 26, I was a college graduate serving in the USAF as a 1st LT and OIC (Officer in Charge) of our deployed unit in Saudi Arabia. That was 1987.
-
Ask this spoon talk making me hungry even though I got food poisoning or something right now. Jk
Why does everyone think I had an ez life? I'm a product of divorce and worked since 16....
-
Ask this spoon talk making me hungry even though I got food poisoning or something right now. Jk
Why does everyone think I had an ez life? I'm a product of divorce and worked since 16....
I'm a "product" of divorce and worked since I was 8.
How does either indicate an easy vs. hard life?
-
Graduating High School or College is not an indication that you've learned everything you'll ever need to know.
Yabbut, an iFag and google can provide that.
-
Ask this spoon talk making me hungry even though I got food poisoning or something right now. Jk
Why does everyone think I had an ez life? I'm a product of divorce and worked since 16....
“Had” and ez life? You old eh? Haha
“Product” of divorce? That’s an interesting one. 😳🤣
-
“Had” and ez life? You old eh? Haha
“Product” of divorce? That’s an interesting one. 😳🤣
He's still just a clump of cells....
-
Have you ever studied morality and ethics? If not, it explains why you'd have a problem understanding them.
People who have seemingly conflicting views morally are usually following their ethics.
Morals dictate what you see as right or wrong. Ethics is how you apply those morals in specific situations. Using the example of murder, I believe it is morally wrong to take a life, but I never said it was ethically wrong under all circumstances. If someone is threatening my life or the life of others, then I believe it's ethical to kill that person to prevent murder.
Same applies to abortion. While killing a fetus for most reasons is immoral, the exceptions you listed make the decision ethical.
Nothing hypocritical about that at all. Ignoring ethics while trying to trip someone up using moral arguments alone is a favorite tactic of many since too few seem to have an understanding of morals, ethics and their difference.
Did not study that. Only had comp sci courses mostly. Maybe my morals are lacking...then again I still don't view that clump of cells as alive. So to me its not immoral. To me even if you have a heartbeat unless you have consciousness you are not a formed human.
-
You did NOT answer the question.
You just reiterated what I said, and then implied what you THINK i was looking for.
We now agree that the Constitution does not apply to animals -- only to human beings.
Whether the Feds or the States make laws against torturing animals is irrelevant.
What I asked is:
On what do you base your opinion that laws should protect animals?
Those laws can be at any level of government.
Answer the question I asked, not the one you think I'm going to ask next.
Not sure what you are getting at....is it some ethical or moral thing? Laws don't have to based on anything.
-
So if someone’s loses consciousness? Are they then by OG’s definition no longer a formed human?
Laws don’t have to be based on anything? Even OG’s feelings?
???
-
...I still don't view that clump of cells as alive. So to me its not immoral. To me even if you have a heartbeat unless you have consciousness you are not a formed human.
So if someone’s loses consciousness? Are they then by OG’s definition no longer a formed human?
Yep. Every night when he(?) goes to sleep (i.e. losing consciousness) he reverts to an unformed clump of cells.
I think a case could be argued that even when consciousness returns upon awakening in the morning there is still nothing there but an uninformed unformed clump of cells.
-
Yep. Every night when he(?) goes to sleep (i.e. losing consciousness) he reverts to an unformed clump of cells.
I think a case could be argued that even when consciousness returns upon awakening in the morning there is still nothing there but an uninformed unformed clump of cells.
it's a slippery slope to start letting the state/lawmakers decide what constitutes a human being with the right to live.
https://www.dailymotion.com/video/x6ywhne
Also on Netflix:
https://tinyurl.com/yylslf8a
-
No once you gain consciousness you gain humanity then you can't lose that till you PERMENTLY LOSE it. AKA death.
-
No once you gain consciousness you gain humanity then you can't lose that till you PERMENTLY LOSE it. AKA death.
There are people deemed incompetent to decide whether or not to continue providing life support even though they are very much conscious.
Victims of stroke, traumatic head injury, dementia, etc.
Those people are conscious, but others make the decision to end their lives or withhold medical treatment so they may pass.
So much for the "must permanently lose consciousness (aka death)" argument.
-
Not sure what you are getting at....is it some ethical or moral thing? Laws don't have to based on anything.
Laws are based on documents (such as the Constitution), morals, ethics, and so on.
Where does the state or federal government derive its power to even make laws? The Constitution. The federal gov't makes laws within their jurisdiction. All other laws are relegated to the states.
States have their own Constitutions.
Do any of these Constitutions include animal rights? Is the state required to protect the animals from torture or abuse based on the protections listed in the Constitution such as our Bill of Rights?
if not, then criminal laws must (1) not violate the applicable Constitutions, and (2) address a behavior or act that society deems criminal.
So, on what basis is animal torture considered criminal? Is it a moral basis? What makes humans, any human, believe the practice of torturing ones own pet is wrong?
Does religion grant the animals these rights? Common sense? Empathy?
Where does the desire/duty to protect these animals come from?
-
Laws are based on documents (such as the Constitution), morals, ethics, and so on.
Where does the state or federal government derive its power to even make laws? The Constitution. The federal gov't makes laws within their jurisdiction. All other laws are relegated to the states.
States have their own Constitutions.
Do any of these Constitutions include animal rights? Is the state required to protect the animals from torture or abuse based on the protections listed in the Constitution such as our Bill of Rights?
if not, then criminal laws must (1) not violate the applicable Constitutions, and (2) address a behavior or act that society deems criminal.
So, on what basis is animal torture considered criminal? Is it a moral basis? What makes humans, any human, believe the practice of torturing ones own pet is wrong?
Does religion grant the animals these rights? Common sense? Empathy?
Where does the desire/duty to protect these animals come from?
You do know there are countries like England that don't have Constitutions. Im pretty sure they have laws. Including ones that deal with animal cruelty.
-
There are people deemed incompetent to decide whether or not to continue providing life support even though they are very much conscious.
Victims of stroke, traumatic head injury, dementia, etc.
Those people are conscious, but others make the decision to end their lives or withhold medical treatment so they may pass.
So much for the "must permanently lose consciousness (aka death)" argument.
If you are brain dead you are dead. If you get into an accident and there's no oxygen to your brain for like 10min no matter the state of your body you are dead. Others aka doctors can decide on your state.
-
I used to be super pro abortion when I was younger and fucking around a lot. Had a few pregers scares from chicks. So abortion was a no brainer and they were down with it too. IIRC, at that time they allowed abortions up until 3 months. And the really down chicks even said "well if I am preggers, at least you can shoot inside until 3 months".
Then I got older and realized it's way more complicated, for all the reasons you guys are mentioning.
-
My grandfather had a stroke and was brain dead. The only thing keeping him alive were the machines. To test if he was brain dead, the docs turned the machines off. If he gasp for air or had any other type of reaction, then his brain was not dead. They did this multiple times and had zero response from his body. So they pounced him brain dead and turned the machines off.
-
You do know there are countries like England that don't have Constitutions. Im pretty sure they have laws. Including ones that deal with animal cruelty.
So, where does England base its laws? They have a Parliament, similar to our Congress. They have to derive their authority to make laws from somewhere.
Thee Monarchy? Magna Carta?
If we assume all of the documents only apply to humans, then the source of their authority to create laws is established.
The real question remains: Where does the desire/duty to protect these animals come from?
i.e. what makes animal torture wrong? You think it'd derived from feelings?
-
If you are brain dead you are dead. If you get into an accident and there's no oxygen to your brain for like 10min no matter the state of your body you are dead. Others aka doctors can decide on your state.
Did I EVER use the words "Brain Dead?" Ever?
I said "incompetent" -- legally non compos mentis ...
non compos mentis nŏn kŏm″pəs mĕn′tĭs►
adj. Not of sound mind and hence not legally competent.
n. One who is not legally competent.
n. Not capable, mentally, of managing one's own affairs; not of sound mind; not having the normal use of reason. Often abbreviated non compos and non comp. See insane.
Incompetent -- as in "unable to follow along with an intellectual conversation :sleeping: ".
-
The real question remains: Where does the desire/duty to protect these animals come from?
i.e. what makes animal torture wrong? You think it'd derived from feelings?
You sound like a guy arguing about slavery 400 years ago.
“Where does the desire to protect these animals come from ?
What makes animal torture wrong?
These are my personal property to do with as I see fit.”
Times change and wrongs are righted.
I think there would be a Constitutional Amendment if every State didn’t adopt a cruelty to animals law.
(Unless one State allows torturing animals which I’m not aware of.)
And isn’t the Constitution the Law of the Land.
So your saying laws are based on laws. No shit Sherlock.
-
You sound like a guy arguing about slavery 400 years ago.
“Where does the desire to protect these animals come from ?
What makes animal torture wrong?
These are my personal property to do with as I see fit.”
Times change and wrongs are righted.
I think there would be a Constitutional Amendment if every State didn’t adopt a cruelty to animals law.
(Unless one State allows torturing animals which I’m not aware of.)
And isn’t the Constitution the Law of the Land.
So your saying laws are based on laws. No shit Sherlock.
You sound like a troll.
Bye.
-
Incompetent -- as in "unable to follow along with an intellectual conversation :sleeping: ".
That’s trolling.
(But appropriate for this situation and to respond to your post. :geekdanc:)
-
You sound like a troll.
Bye.
The amount of hate these three blocked liberals have is amazing.
They certainly have no common ground with most of the forum, just show up to argue and spew.
-
The amount of hate these three blocked liberals have is amazing.
They certainly have no common ground with most of the forum, just show up to argue and spew.
AssHole slings insults even when he can't honestly find anything to pick apart in my post.
He can't help it.
"The Troll Dogma Lives Loudly in Him."
-
The amount of hate these three blocked liberals have is amazing.
They certainly have no common ground with most of the forum, just show up to argue and spew.
Who are theses three blocked liberals? I have at least four on your radar by my count and that’s if you're including me. I’m technically an Independent.
I’ve met a ton of the forum members and broke bread with them.
(And drank “tea”)
How would you even know RobDmc when you block us?
You can’t even read what we post, much less form an opinion on it.
https://youtu.be/8scSwaKbE64
-
Where were my insults?
Edit: I did say no shit Sherlock.
What ..... in YOUR post I reposted ?
You pick apart grammar and English! :wtf: who does that ?!
Old Padawan. Learn to answer direct questions and not deflect and insult, then productive discussions you may have.
-
AssHole slings insults even when he can't honestly find anything to pick apart in my post.
Cannot see it, but I will not give a liberal the time of day IRL, certainly no time for them online.
Kuleana is strange, but seems not in it just to push liberal talking points like these other three.
-
'She said it is “never appropriate for a judge to impose that judge’s personal convictions, whether they derive from faith or anywhere else on the law.”'
https://www.msn.com/en-us/news/politics/no-dogma-democrats-walk-tightrope-on-barrett-s-faith/ar-BB19TGfc?ocid=msedgdhp
but hey, feelings trump (lol) what someone actually says on the matter...
-
'She said it is “never appropriate for a judge to impose that judge’s personal convictions, whether they derive from faith or anywhere else on the law.”'
https://www.msn.com/en-us/news/politics/no-dogma-democrats-walk-tightrope-on-barrett-s-faith/ar-BB19TGfc?ocid=msedgdhp
but hey, feelings trump (lol) what someone actually says on the matter...
Feelings > Facts
It is spoken